Press conference by President of the Government and President of the European Council
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed a press conference in Spain on August 27, 2012, following a working lunch with European Council President Herman Van Rompuy to discuss EU and Eurozone stability.
- Main themes
- European economic integration, Eurozone stability, banking union, fiscal union, Spain's economic reforms, public deficit reduction, euro risk premiums, economic and monetary union, European Council roadmap, job creation and growth, market confidence
- Duration
- ~42 min
- Words
- 5,090
- Sentences
- 172
- Readability
- 46
- Grade
- 14.0
- Syntax
- 3.30
- Vocabulary
- 2.08
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
172 sentences in 70 paragraphs
President of the Government .- Ladies and gentlemen, a very good afternoon to you. Welcome back after the holidays, for those of you who have been fortunate enough to have had them.
I appear here today before all of you following the lunch I have held with the President of the European Council, Herman Van Rompuy, to briefly set out the results of this meeting, although I hope you will first allow me to take advantage of the occasion to thank Mr Van Rompuy for choosing Spain to spend his holidays, and also thank those many millions of European citizens who have also spent this summer in our country. I hope and desire that they choose the same destination next year.
The working lunch we have held was mainly devoted to analysing the situation of the European Union and the Eurozone, as well as the situation of Spain and the measures being implemented pursuant to our commitments as leading European partners.
I have assured President Van Rompuy that Spain will continue making the necessary reforms to exit the crisis and return to generate confidence, to return to a path of growth and job creation.
As you are aware, during the course of these last few months, Spanish society has made a great effort and the government has had to make complicated, tough and difficult decisions, which are what the situation dictates. We must reduce our public deficit and we cannot spend more than we collect in revenue, especially in a situation such as the one we are going through where it is so difficult to find financing. We need to make reforms to generate growth and create jobs, and we are working hard on that, in such a difficult environment, as you are all aware. And we will continue working along these lines in the future, meeting our commitments as a European Union partner.
I reiterated to the President of the European Council the need for us all to make this effort, all of the Member States, Spain and the rest, as well as all of the European institutions, each one meeting its responsibilities to ensure, firstly, the stability of the markets and the euro, and secondly, to clearly map out the course that the European Union must follow to face up to the challenges of the future. At least in my opinion, this course inevitably includes greater integration of our economies and leads to achieving economic and monetary union.
As you are aware, the latest European Council, which took place at the end of June - a European Council which, in my opinion, was extremely important - was one of the European Councils with the greatest content held in the last few years, and at which the foundations were laid, in my opinion, for what should be the Europe of the future. The President of the Council was commissioned with drawing up an in-depth, clearly-defined 'road map' to achieve true economic and monetary union.
The European Council and its President have a lot or work to do during September prior to the European Council in October, and has already started their round of meetings to this end, which we hope will reap rewards in the month of December.
I would like to take advantage of this opportunity to wish Mr Van Rompuy the greatest success in this mission. Spain will help him in this task; Spain has already made a proposal, one more - anyone can make one - on banking union and fiscal union for the future. Of course, in this proposal we said that the European Council in June was a Council of great importance and that now we must continue to take steps forward and the near future firm up many of the issues that were agreed therein.
It is very important that we achieve banking union by the month of December, a sole supervisory authority and a deposit guarantee fund, and it is also important that we can proceed to the direct recapitalisation of the banks by the European institutions.
It is also very important that we resolve as soon as possible the problems of the Eurozone, fundamentally those that affect doubts surrounding the euro. We have heard - in my case with great satisfaction - both the President of the European Central Bank and international bodies such as the International Monetary Fund, say that in Europe there are risk premiums and differentials between premiums that do not correspond to the true basics of the economy. It is important that we are aware of this and that this is acted on in the future, and above all it is very important that steps are taken for the creation of a banking union and a fiscal union.
We have spoken about all these issues. I repeat, Spain remains committed to European integration, Spain wants these problems to be resolved in the short term, as soon as possible, because when that happens we will return to economic growth and job creation, and we will continue working to that end, but we also want the matters of banking union and fiscal union to be tackled in the short- to medium-term future.
Finally, I wanted to tell you that we have spoken about Greece and I have given Mr Van Rompuy my opinion on the matter. Were Greece to pull out of the Eurozone, as some have said, or indeed were any country to pull out of the Eurozone, it would be a collective disaster for Europe. It would not only be a problem for Greece, but a collective disaster for the whole of Europe, one which we cannot allow under any circumstances.
I am absolutely convinced that the Greek government is meeting its obligations. The Greek government has assumed its commitments, and in the same way as other European governments, I am convinced that it will meet its commitments.
But, I repeat, any other decision will undoubtedly be a collective disaster for such an important and decisive project for the lives of so many people as is this European project, which has been underway for so many years. Hence, I also gave him my opinion on this matter.
Aside from that, I would like to once again thank Mr Van Rompuy for having been so gracious to join me here, for the second time this year, and thank him again for having spent his holidays here in Spain, which shouldn't have been any great effort at all, as Spain is such a great location, and I will now leave you all in his hands.
Mr. Van Rompuy .- The President of the Government and I have just held a very constructive working lunch at which we have exchanged opinions, which have also been very constructive, on the current situation in Spain and in Europe.
It has been a pleasure for me to spend my holidays here in Spain with my children, who are now grown up, and with my grand-children, and to break off from my holidays for this working lunch.
As regards Spain, we have made the same general assessment of the situation. Spain has been hit by an economic and financial crisis, basically created by the indebtedness of the private sector caused by an unsustainable property boom. This imbalance has had consequences for the general competitiveness of the Spanish economy. This was created within Spain, but was also made possible by certain deficiencies in the architecture of the Eurozone. Hence, we have a shared responsibility for resolving this together and that is what we are now doing.
As regards Spain, the Government of Mr Rajoy has embarked on a slew of courageous and ambitious adjustments, and its Eurozone partners have committed 100 billion euros to a European assistance package aimed at restructuring the financial sector in Spain. Within this context, 30 billion euros of aid have been approved and we are prepared to quickly move to safeguard financial stability. I trust that this reconstruction will be carried out successfully and swiftly in order to clarify the situation of the financial system, restore confidence, stimulate the Spanish economy and, with time, reduce the risks and the pressure on the Spanish taxpayer.
All the European partners have realised the magnitude of the structural and fiscal reforms undertaken, as well as those to be taken. These reforms need to be applied fully. They may be costly, they may be harsh in the short term, but they will contribute towards growth and job creation in the medium term. These adjustments are difficult at any time but, if the challenges of the financial markets persist, the European leaders, at the Council in June, have already shown their desire to help Spain. In this respect, the European Central Bank presented on 2 August a framework of possible interventions, which it stood fully behind.
As regards the Eurozone as a whole, we have started a joint process of underpinning the structure of the Eurozone so that this type of crisis will never be repeated. The current situation has forced us to recognise some of the defects in the original design of the Eurozone and the extent to which this has created and indeed sustained this crisis. This is a long but necessary process, and I will report on this at the European Councils in October and December.
The Spanish authorities and the Spanish government are contributing to this joint effort to a tremendous extent and I know that they will continue working on the four pillars that they presented to the European Council at the June meeting in the report entitled "Towards a genuine economic and monetary union". I mentioned this in this report, which includes an integrated financial framework - what we call banking union - to underpin financial stability and avoid financial risks becoming risks for taxpayers.
Secondly, a type of fiscal union that recognises our deep interdependence and need to act jointly.
Thirdly, an economic union that supports the competitiveness of the Eurozone as a whole, but which also corrects the prejudicial macro-economic divergences within the Eurozone.
And finally, a political union that sustains a more integrated economic union through the appropriate mechanisms for accountability.
As has been underlined by the crisis in Spain, it is particularly urgent to make progress on banking union. It is key within this context to establish a sole banking supervisory authority that covers all banks in the Eurozone, and to that end, the European Commission will make certain specific legislative proposals in September.
Let there be no doubts. There is no going back on the euro, and allow me to insist once again that the future of Greece lies in the Eurozone, but only through the combination of strong and decisive actions in each Member State and with decisive joint action will we be able to put this crisis behind us. This means tackling the short-term effects of the crisis, such as access to the sovereign debt markets or the uncertainties surrounding the Eurozone; but also tackling the most fundamental long-term challenges being faced by the Eurozone.
That is exactly what European leaders are doing and I would thank the President of the Government and his colleagues for their significant contribution to this new economic architecture of the Eurozone.
Q .- Firstly, a question for the two of you. Do you consider that the situation of short- and medium-term Spanish debt is sustainable without a bailout such as that, for example, proposed by the European Central Bank and to which the President of the Council just referred to? Would this bailout involve some type of macro-economic conditions?
On another note, a question for President Van Rompuy. Do you feel, as is the case with Spain, France and Italy, that it would be appropriate for the European Central Bank on 6 September to come up with a resounding and immediate plan to deal with the European debt crisis?
President of the Government .- The question for me, if I understand correctly, is basically whether the government intends to use the instruments the Central Bank has said should be used if someone wants the Central Bank to act. I cannot add much more to this issue than what I said in this same room on 3 August. We will do whatever is in the general interest of the Spanish people, and hence, that will be the criterion on which we base all our decisions, even those which we haven't yet taken. Hence, I cannot announce anything new about something on which no decision has yet been taken.
However, I would like to say something that I feel is extremely important and that is to reiterate the words spoken by Mr Draghi that I mentioned earlier. Mr Draghi, in his appearance before the media, said that it was unacceptable that as a result of the doubts surrounding the euro, financing differentials should exist between different European Union countries and that countries should encounter difficulties when seeking financing, which is the problem being faced by Spain at this time. We have held an auction today, as you are aware, a short-term placement of Treasury bills at three and six months. Things went better than last time, considerably better, but at any event, the risk premium remains unacceptable and does not respond to the basics of the Spanish economy.
It was very important that the European Council in June - I always recognise the importance of the European Council of June, because I believe it was a truly decisive Council - reflected the will of all the countries to resolve this problem. The Central Bank made an announcement, took a step forward, and it is now the turn of the individual Member States that may be interested to take a decision one way or another. The conditionality is what, in my opinion, marks the difference of this European Council, in the event that a country requests an intervention. The European Council speaks about complying with what we are already doing, in other words the recommendations of the European semester and the procedure on excessive deficit.
Hence, the situation is like this: the risk premium remains too high; I believe very important steps have been taken regarding the irreversibility of the euro and I believe that at this time European leaders, and individual heads of state are saying to all those who want to hear it that the euro is here to stay, that it is a serious currency and that the process of European integration cannot be stopped and that it is striving onwards. Today we have heard the President of the European Council speak about banking union and fiscal union.
Hence, that is my opinion on the question asked of me.
Mr. Van Rompuy .- Firstly, as regards a request for financial support beyond that set out in the programme for the financial sector, that totally depends on the Spanish government to take a decision. Spain is an important country with a strong government, and it is its responsibility to take a decision in this respect.
But I would like to remind you that Spain already has a broad programme to restructure its financial sector, which tackles the most urgent economic challenges being faced by Spain. Spain has taken on certain courageous commitments in this respect through its multi-annual Stability and Convergence Programme and yet, if the challenges of the markets continue and if the Spanish authorities see them as useful, then the European institutions, as we said at the European Council in June, and was even said by the European Central Bank, may take the appropriate actions. But it is the sole responsibility of the Spanish government to take the decision and I believe that the Spanish government is sufficiently strong to make its own assessment and judgment-call.
As regards the meeting of the European Central Bank on 6 September, it shouldn't even be necessary to say that the European Central Bank is an independent institution, it does what it feels is best to comply with its mandate and it has a very good track-record in this respect.
President Draghi and President of the Government Rajoy have said that they have identified a perception of risk which, if the convertibility risk is exceeded, according to what was stated on 2 August, interventions would be made on the secondary market to show that the integrity of the Eurozone is irrevocable. But the former also very clearly stated that this could not be done alone and that this would require action, firstly from governments of Member States, and secondly, from individual central banks should this not be sufficient. In my opinion, the framework proposed by the European Central Bank is very clear and I believe that, were it to be used, it would be very effective.
Q .- Mr President of the Government, I would like to address this question to President Van Rompuy as well. It is not very clear to me at this time at what stage negotiations are at on the conditions for a potential European intervention. Would Spain be asked for an additional adjustment, in addition to what was stated up to 2014?
Would there be oversight visits from the 'troika' in exchange for this aid?
President of the Government .- As regards the negotiations you refer to, you are asking at what stage we are at at this time. At no stage whatsoever. There is quite simply no negotiation going on regarding this matter because the government has not made any request in this respect. Hence there are no negotiations about anything.
Mr. Van Rompuy .- I am wholly in agreement with what the President of the Government has stated.
Q .- This question is for Mr Rajoy. You stated that the conditions for the assistance that Spain is receiving are those which are already set. Today Catalonia has asked for a bailout from the Spanish State; it has asked for 6 billion euros, and it has stated that it will not accept any further conditions than those already contained in the adjustment plan. I would like to know whether central government is willing to accept that or whether it will try to impose further conditions.
Taking advantage of this moment, I would like to know if you believe that, following the letter that we were made aware of yesterday asking for aid so that Europe can help us to meet our challenges, the proposal for a fiscal compact will not help in this European context.
And I wanted to ask Mr Van Rompuy if he believes that the economic situation of the autonomous regions creates mistrust towards Spain?
President of the Government .- The Regional Government of Catalonia has perceived - we all knew this, the Government of Catalonia knew this and we all knew this - that it has a liquidity problem and that it cannot deal with certain debt maturities. That is the major problem being faced by our country at this time and that is the main issue we have been talking about over the course of these last few months. It is not a question of Catalonia increasing its debt; it is a question of Catalonia having to pay, but not being able to pay, its debt maturities, and hence it has asked the State for aid.
This is something that has been going on during the course of these last few months, not only in Catalonia, but also in other autonomous regions. We have been dealing with this matter since January of this year since which time we have been saying that the autonomous regions are also a part of Spain, and hence the Spanish Government will not wash its hands of the situation of the autonomous regions. We have, initially, advanced funds from the treasury to the autonomous regions; we have given them a deadline for repaying their outstanding debts to the State, a deadline that is double that given by the previous government; we have implemented the Supplier Payment Plan so that the autonomous regions can pay their outstanding debts to their suppliers, and we have helped them, not for the first time, to refinance their own debts. In other words, this is not a new situation, nor has it only taken place in Catalonia; this also occurred in Andalusia not long ago, in the Region of Valencia and also in other autonomous regions.
Hence, as I have already said on various occasions, we are not going to wash our hands of the problems and difficulties being faced by the autonomous regions, at this or at any other time. We will help Catalonia, in the same way as we help the rest of the autonomous regions, and what is important is that everyone, starting with the Government of Spain, followed by the autonomous regions and the local authorities, meet their commitments regarding the public deficit and public debt, because what has brought us to this situation is principally our colossal public deficit. I have said on countless occasions that we cannot spend what we don't have, and yet last year we spent 90 billion euros more than we collected in revenue; we must do away with this situation and we must start to reduce our deficit, among other things, because we are running the risk of not being able to receive financing.
Hence, the Government of Spain will help the Regional Government of Catalonia, as we have done on many other occasions, and we will speak with them about everything we need to speak about. It is not a question of looking for controversy but rather of resolving problems. My desire is to resolve problems, and furthermore, it is my duty.
As regards the letter seeking aid, I was not sent a letter exactly seeking aid, what I was sent was a letter to discuss the fiscal compact. I told Mr. Mas that I will receive him, as I have done on other occasions when he has asked to be received, I will listen to him very closely and I will give him my opinion. Whether this is prejudicial or not, I believe that what the Spanish people need to do at this time is focus on the fundamentals, and what is fundamental is reducing the public deficit - I repeat, we cannot spend what we don't have - continue making the structural reforms we are working on, because they are fundamental for growth and job creation, and thirdly, continue restructuring the Spanish financial system.
We are at a phase, as you are aware, of evaluating the real needs of the Spanish financial system. We are subjecting our financial entities to the most strenuous examination that any financial entity of any country has ever undergone so that the security of Spanish banks, when this examination is concluded and European aid is firmed up, will be total and absolute, which is comforting to know.
And we hope that as of then, credit will begin to circulate again and the economy will hence return to growth with the resulting creation of jobs.
These are the three main objectives, these are the three main priorities and the most important element for resolving our current problems is to grow the economy. What has happened to the autonomous regions and to central government? In two years - 2009 and 2010, revenue fell by 70 billion euros in Spain. So, with 70 billion euros less in revenue but no reduction in expenses, it is clear that this is not a sustainable model, and this affected the autonomous regions, this affected central government and this also affected our local authorities, because there was less revenue from Personal Income Tax, from Value Added Tax and from Special Taxes. And all this happened because of the decline in economic activity.
Hence, the challenge is to generate economic activity, to grow, to create jobs and then things will start to get better. That is the challenge, that is the priority and that, as I have said on numerous occasions and I will continue saying, is the main priority of this government during this legislature, and I believe that this is in line with the general interests of the Spanish people as a whole. Is this difficult? Of course it is difficult. Can this be achieved? Yes, it can.
Is it complicated and tough? Yes, it is. Will we need to take decisions that are unpopular with many people? Yes, and I am well aware of that, but I believe that our duty is to do things right, because that way we will win our future, both in the medium and in the long term.
The worst thing in a situation like this is to continue on a road to nowhere. I am not prepared to do that, but rather what I want… I have an objective for Spain and an objective for Europe as well, and that is why both the Government of Spain and I are making contributions towards greater European integration because we believe that it is good for Europe and good for Spain.
Mr. Van Rompuy .- I will be a little less passionate than the President of the Government. In the first place, as regards the autonomous regions, I come from a federal state, and during my long professional career I have been involved in the process of converting a unitary state into a federal state. It gives me great satisfaction to have contributed to this historic process, and hence.
I am especially sensitive to federalism and the problems surrounding a federal state such as Spain. But, from a European point of view, we propose goals, fiscal targets, economic targets and objectives for a country as a whole. How do you achieve these objectives for a country as a whole? It is Spain's responsibility to organise itself so as to meet these objectives.
I know that the government has taken significant measures so that the autonomous regions are also in line with the general objectives and for that reason I will not comment on the matter, but from a European point of view, the results of the country as a whole are what are most important. For everything else it is down to Spain to organise its own internal affairs.
Q .- President of the Government, you yourself say that you have various fronts open at this time, to which you could perhaps add the economy, which in recent days has shown itself to be more fragile than expected. I had a specific question. The ratings agency Moody's plan to conclude in mid-September its new revision of the rating for Spain, and with the situation that you have described and with the things still to be done, do you fear a new downgrade in the rating of the Spanish debt before concluding, for example, the agreements, the conditions and the details of the purchase of bonds by the ECB?
President of the Government .- I am unaware of what the agency you have mentioned is going to do, and of whether it has seen in a favourable light the public statements made by the other two main ratings agencies. I find this comforting, but I repeat that I believe that the main problem in the short term - I refer to the short term in relation to certain economies in the Eurozone - is that countries are being financed at a price that has nothing to do with the basics of their economies.
I believe that everything related to resolving doubts surrounding the euro, such as asserting, as has been done today by the President of the European Council, that there is no going back on the euro, and everything related to making progress on the decisions taken at the very important - I repeat - European Council in the month of June, are steps in the right direction which help calm the markets and help inspire something that is fundamental for me, which is that the euro is here to stay.
Hence, aside from that, we all have to continue with our policies. We are aware that we have made a commitment to reducing the public deficit, and we are working on that, and we are aware than we need to restructure our financial system, and we are working on that. I believe that we will become aware this month of the needs of this financial system, which will be less than the 100 billion euros to be loaned to our banks by the European Union. We will also continue with our process of structural reforms and I believe that next year the situation of growth will be much better than that of this year.
I would remind you of one thing: when we presented the General State Budget for 2012, we said, because we should tell the truth to the Spanish people and to the whole world, that this was not going to be a good year. In our draft General Budget for this year, we said that the Spanish economy would shrink by 1.7% this year and we repeated this in the definitive Budget, when the European Commission spoke about shrinkage of 1.1%. We said that it would be 1.7% and we will see at the end of the year what the final shrinkage is. We knew that this year would be difficult, but we also knew that we would need to lay the foundations during this year in order to make economic recovery a reality.
Let me tell you something: our public deficit figures are very high and our public debt is increasing, but this is something temporary. Just a few years ago Spain had a surplus in its public accounts; in other words, the public deficit is clearly something temporary.
Spain is a country that signed up in Maastricht to join the euro, meeting its requirements, and which then had a surplus in its public accounts, and Spain even managed to reach a level of public debt of 40% of its GDP.
Hence, what has occurred over the last few years is something temporary. However, it is true that we need to make an effort to overcome this; we are currently making this effort and you can be totally and utterly sure that we will achieve this together - the Spanish people - although we need to make a great effort and although our governments need to take difficult decisions. But this is a temporary situation that this country will overcome and soon.
Thank you very much.