Press conference by the President of the Government and the President of the French Republic

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

29 August 2012 · Joint press conference with the President of the French Republic following a working lunch

Context
Rajoy addressed a joint press conference with French President Hollande following a bilateral working lunch in Spain on 29 August 2012.
Main themes
EU economic integration, Eurozone crisis, Spain-France bilateral relations, fiscal consolidation and structural reforms, Greece debt crisis, European Growth Pact, banking union, Syria conflict, Mali and Sahel security, ECOWAS initiatives, United Nations Security Council
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,505
93rd percentile
Sentences
205
89th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
13.1
58th percentile
Syntax
3.16
67th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 48%45%
  • Geopolitical 27%26%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Social 3%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

205 sentences in 70 paragraphs

President of the Government . A very good afternoon to you all and welcome once again. It gives me great pleasure to appear here before you following the working lunch held with the President of the French Republic, François Hollande, to briefly set out the results of our meeting.

Firstly, allow me to take advantage of this occasion to thank President Hollande for his visit which, as you are aware, is the second formal meeting held, following my trip to Paris on 23 May last, since his election as President of the Republic.

As we announced in Paris in May, the next bilateral summit will be held later this year in France, specifically on 10 October. We will thus return to our previous custom of holding summits between the two countries, which has been on hold since 2009. Two key partners such as France and Spain should ensure that we maintain ongoing and in-depth dialogue, which can be best realised through the bilateral summit.

As is natural, during our meeting today we dedicated the majority of our time to analysing the situation of the European Union and the Eurozone, as well as the situation in Spain and the measures we are implementing in accordance with our commitments as upstanding European partners.

Spain has shown its determination and its European responsibility through a strategy of profound fiscal consolidation and an audacious raft of structural reforms, unparalleled in the European Union. In this respect, as I did in May in Paris, I conveyed to President Hollande our firm determination to continue with this reformist agenda.

As regards Europe, we exchanged impressions on the current situation, in particular on the Eurozone and the actions that the European Union as a whole should take. We agree on the importance of two decisions taken during the latest European Council: firstly, the agreement on the Growth Pact, which was an initiative with very decisive participation from the French President, as you are aware, and which Spain supported, and which will mobilise resources to help our countries exit the crisis, and secondly, we decided, at this Council, to embark on a process of greater economic and fiscal integration of the European Union.

As regards this latter issue, Spain, as one of the stalwarts behind embarking on this process, has already made its proposals, as you are aware, for greater integration, which have been well received by the European institutions, regarding which I have had the pleasure of exchanging opinions today with President Hollande. In this respect, together with our European partners, we must take some important decisions in the month of December.

These ambitious proposals defend greater economic, fiscal, banking and institutional integration. We aim to extend solidarity between the State and our citizens and ensure that Member States and institutions, each within the framework of its responsibilities and the spirit of unity and solidarity, act swiftly and decisively. We want the European Union to take steps forward and I will be very clear in this respect: no backward steps will be taken by the Euro, the single market or the Union.

In relation to Greece, which we also tackled during our meeting, allow me to convey to you my conviction that Greece is going to meet its commitments and that Spain and its partners in the Eurozone seek to support this country in its important effort to ensure, on the one hand, the integrity and stability of the Eurozone and the return of Greece to economic stability and sustainable growth, on the other.

Finally, we exchanged points of view on two very important international matters. Firstly, we analysed the situation in Syria, where the French Government and its President are particularly active, as you are aware. We share a profound concern at the very high cost of human life both within and beyond its borders.

Consequently, we will continue working closely with the rest of our European partners in seeking a negotiated solution under the framework of the United Nations Security Council that is currently chaired, as you know, by France. We are, likewise, in agreement that the solution to the crisis lies in Assad leaving power. It is also important to look at the situation following his departure, and hence we believe that the opposition should achieve a form of unity that enables it to become a clear alternative to the regime.

Secondly, we have spoken about the situation in the Sahel region, and in particular, in Mali. This country needs to overcome the humanitarian crisis in which it is submerged, and to do that, it is essential for democratic normality to return to the country following the coup d'état in March. It is also necessary to urgently deal with the Salafist terrorists groups which, led by Al Qaeda, have taken control part of the north of the country. In this respect, we agreed to support the initiatives to resolve the crisis being headed up by the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS), under the auspices of the African Union and the United States Security Council.

In short, our working meeting has been very fruitful and we have been able to tackle the most important questions on the international, bilateral and, of course, European agenda. I can say, in this respect, that France and Spain are working in close collaboration and we share the same vision regarding the irreversibility of the Euro and the integration and solidarity of Europe.

I would like to once again thank President Hollande for this, his first visit, as President of the French Republic, to Spain. You will always be welcome here and I would also like to thank you for your support for certain initiatives that Spain has proposed at the last European Council. Thank you very much, I will now hand you over to him.

Mr. Hollande . Ladies and gentlemen, I would also like to thank President of the Government Rajoy for his invitation here. This is the first time that I have been here in Spain since I was elected as President of the Republic. President of the Government Rajoy and I enjoy a good personal relationship and our countries enjoy a good bond of friendship.

As regards the bilateral summit, this will be held on 10 October in Paris. The last meeting of this type was held three years ago, and using this format the two governments will have the occasion to tackle common issues such as transport, the economy, culture and security.

We also have good relations, beyond what we have to do in matters related to our two countries, regarding Europe and the decisions expected of it. Both he and I, together with others, took a good position at the European Council on 29 June on growth - the agreement that was adopted on that occasion - and on stability, because we created a device that allows the European Mechanism and the Central Bank to intervene; and we also took a position to strengthen economic and monetary union, which will be adopted at the European Council at the end of the year.

But before the end of the year there is another important meeting, which we agreed among all the European countries, above all the members of the Eurozone, and that is the Council on 19 October. I feel that on this date and within this framework, following meetings of the Eurogroup, we will take decisions that will affect the Eurozone and, moreover, that they will be lasting decisions. We have been delaying decisions for too long and that has been one of the root causes of the doubts that have arisen.

It is true that there are reasons for that. In order to implement it, there are various events that need to take place: firstly, to see whether the Court in Karlsruhe will authorise the European Stability Mechanism, which is the issue being raised in Germany. There are upcoming elections in the Netherlands, there are also meetings regarding the soundness of the banking system and there is work being carried out which will be completed in the month of September. The 'troika' must submit its report at the end of September or the beginning of October at the latest. At the same time, Greece, which I will comment on later, must take certain parliamentary decisions at the start of October.

In other words, there are various events prior to these decisions but, once their results are known, the decisions should be adopted. President of the Government Rajoy and I are committed to the irreversibility of the Euro. I believe that this is the message that we should send out when the leaders of the Eurozone meet, because it is our responsibility to do so. It is very important that the people, and also the markets, because they watch us, are convinced of this irreversibility, of this commitment to a project that goes beyond the single market, because that is what will allow us to build a more complete union.

So, what does this mean? Firstly, for Greece. I met with Prime Minister Samaras, who was also on a trip. I reminded him in Paris of my conviction that the Greeks are committed to a process and that they want to show their credibility. We will need to look closely at the report issues by the 'troika'; but I believe that, if the Greeks show this credibility, by the time of the European Council in June, we will have to allow them to continue applying the programme.

Let's not have any doubts about their continuity.

As regards the other countries, I am in Spain and I will speak about Spain. President of the Government Rajoy sought to explain to me the situation here; significant efforts and sacrifices have undoubtedly been made. I am not here to judge these efforts, but I can already see that they are bearing fruit. However, the interest rates remain too high and that is why we have come up with this mechanism - the European Financial Stability Fund, until such time as the European Stability Mechanism is validated. These formulas, these funds, must contribute support to the banks when the latter need them or when States request resources to find solutions. It is each State's individual responsibility as to what it does. Spain is sovereign to decide whether to request it or not and when.

In terms of the Central Bank, I respect its independence, but I have heard what its president said, on behalf of the institution he heads up, and he has taken a position that he will need to expand on in the coming days. That will allow us to take the pressure off the burden of servicing debt and the cost of borrowing in countries that are making a great effort and which are so important for the Eurozone.

I believe that if we base ourselves on responsibility, on being serious, on credibility and also on verifying how an economy in growth operates, an economy that allows our people to acquire confidence and the markets to find the occasion to place money without risk, the image of the European Union will be considerably strengthened.

I will conclude with the issues of international politics that President of the Government Rajoy mentioned that we tackled at lunch and on which we have identical points of view.

As regards Syria, we are both convinced, and we are not the only ones, fortunately, that Bashar al-Assad must leave power in order to find a political solution in Syria and hence the formation of an alternative government, a provisional government; that is a condition, but not the only one. It is our duty to convince the two countries that are not yet convinced of this - I speak about Russia and China - that the exit from power of Bashar al-Assad will not bring chaos, but rather just the opposite; it will bring an ordered solution and allow all minorities to be represented. We must continue applying pressure and even today at the Security Council, Laurent Fabius has called a meeting that allows all solutions to be discussed, above all in terms of humanitarian aid, that will allow the matter of refugees to be resolved, and through the refugees, continue applying pressure on Syria and, at any event, on the regime of Bashar al-Assad, and bring the country to this transition.

As regards the Sahel region, a matter on which I have spoken regularly since my election, it is an extremely serious matter. That on this continent that is so close, with which we have so many ties, a part of the territory is occupied by Al Qaeda in the Maghreb or by similar groups; that we have seen the recruitment of child soldiers or, at any event, of men serving a terrorist cause, that in this territory there is a surge in drug trafficking, people trafficking and hostage-taking, with the consequences that this may have for the whole of Western Africa, and perhaps, one day, for our own continent, justifies the position of the international community. But we first need to help the Government of Mali to re-establish its authority and that it is the African people themselves, through ECOWAS and the African Union, who decide to intervene under the mandate, of course, of the United Nations.

In conclusion, President of the Government Rajoy and I do not form part of the same political formation, that is no great surprise to anyone; but we share a vision over the question of the future of Europe. That is fundamental, because our countries are united and because we have a sense of responsibility. We don't want there to be situational responses to one or other difficulty from a Member State of the European Union, we want structural responses now that allow us to do away with the uncertainties and concerns. It is undoubtedly important because the lack of growth is causing a lack of confidence. When the austerity plans help others, when there are doubts surrounding investors, what is going to suffer, above all, is economic activity and employment. It is a vicious circle and we are thus bound, of course, to put the public expenses of each country in order, which is our responsibility, but also set a course and take the decisions at the most suitable time, and this time has come - the European Council of 19 October.

Thank you once again, President of the Government Rajoy, for your welcome.

Q . Mr President, you just said that growth is suffering a loss of confidence. This matter of confidence is being raised by both countries - France and Spain - public opinion has raised it to differing degrees in this return to activity and the popularity of both governments is low. Will you assume this loss of popularity on a lasting basis? Can you govern without the support of the majority of the population?

Mr. Hollande . I don't know whether the situations are comparable and I am not going to go into detail, but what is certain is that, when you don't have growth, when an excessive effort is made, when there are doubts or when prices are uncontrolled, there will always be doubts in public opinion.

I will only talk about France. We need to speak sincerely about the situation, about the crisis. The recession in Spain, in Italy, in the majority of European countries, zero growth in France, lower economic activity in Germany… That is the reality of the situation: a higher deficit, a decline in competitiveness. I tell the French people the truth. We will implement a policy which allows us, above all, to improve the situation of the public finances, which will be the first thing we propose to do; there will then be a debate, already committed to, on improving competitiveness, and finally, we must resolve the problem of the Eurozone.

I am looking at these three objectives: budgetary seriousness, job creation and competitiveness, as well as clarity in the decisions in the Eurozone so that we can have perspective and hope in the coming months. The role of politicians is to tell the truth, on the one hand, and to have perspective and inspire hope.

President of the Government . I will answer this question in relation to Spain and I will not say anything very different to what I have had the occasion to say to the Spanish people over the course of these last few months. Spain is going through a very difficult period, it has an unemployment problem, negative growth, a very serious public deficit and problems of competitiveness, and I believe that the first duty of a governor, as Mr Hollande mentioned, is to be sincere with the people and take those decisions that are useful for resolving the problems of the country. Spain has, like everyone else, an objective, which is economic growth and job creation. This is synonymous with well-being, with wealth, with revenue for the public administration services and the best public services.

Hence, that is our objective: economic growth and job creation, and that requires three things: firstly, controlling the public deficit. Last year Spain had a public deficit of 8.9%, which we need to reduce this year to 6.3%. It is difficult, because it means reducing the public deficit by 2.6% and, moreover, doing so in a time of recession; furthermore, with significant financing problems, as you are aware. But we will do this.

Secondly, we must make structural reforms. We have been making and continue to make them over these last eight months since we took the responsibility of governing. And all these decisions are tough, they are complicated and are unpopular. On occasions I have been obliged to take certain tough decisions, which I wouldn't have taken under normal circumstances. I have had to raise stakes that I would never have raised normally, but I have done so because the obligation of those in power is always to attend to the general interests of the country.

Hence, correcting the deficit and making reforms is essential if we want to grow and create jobs.

Thirdly and finally, it is fundamental to have clarity regarding the Euro. I agree with what the President of the French Republic said, but I believe that we must be aware of the consequences of our actions. We all want the European Union, we all want the Euro to be maintained and we have all asserted the irreversibility of the Euro; but it is very important that we do away with the situation whereby in certain countries the Euro is financed at zero percent while in other countries this percentage is very high. One European Union country has today issued 10-year bonds and had to pay 5.82% while in July it had to pay 5.96%, and yet there are other countries that can finance them at much lower rates. With this market fragmentation and these prices it is very difficult for the monetary union to operate as such.

This is the main issue, we have had our first battle on this matter and progress was made and very important decisions were reached at the European Council in June, but we must continue working on this between now and the end of the year.

Q . A question for both of you. Yesterday, Mr Draghi said that there are times when exceptional decisions need to be taken. I wanted to ask you whether you believe that the time has come to take this type of measure.

A question for President Hollande, I wanted to know whether you believe that Spain should ask for a bailout now, and whether you have spoken about this issue this morning and whether the European Central Bank should buy up unlimited debt.

And on the same matter, I wanted President of the Government Rajoy to respond to the accusations and insinuations that the government is going to delay the bailout until after the elections in Galicia and the Basque Country on 21 October. And following the idea of what you said about telling the truth to the people, and on the eve of the entry into force of the new VAT rise and other cuts, can you guarantee the Spanish people that in the Budget for 2013 there will not be any further cuts or tax rises?

President of the Government . As regards the first question on the assertions made by Mr Draghi, you are referring to an article that was published today in a German daily which states that "the European Central Bank should take exceptional measures in exceptional circumstances". I am not going to make any comments about what Mr Draghi has said. I respect the independence of the European Central Bank. What I can say, because I have already said it on various occasions, is that not long ago Mr Draghi made a statement which is a simple truth, and that is that the differentials that currently exist in Europe and which make certain countries seek financing at very high prices do not respond to economic fundamentals, but rather to the doubts surrounding the Euro.

This statement is very important and was made by the President of the European Central Bank and I am in full agreement with this statement. Aside from that, this is a matter that sets one against the other and each must act in his own area of responsibility while always respecting the independence of the other.

As regards the accusations and insinuations surrounding Galicia and the Basque Country, I have not heard any accusations, which doesn't mean that there haven't been any - I don't hear everything, as you can imagine - nor have I heard any insinuations, but at any event, this could only come from an evil mind and, since I don't believe in evil minds, I shall have to consider that there have not been any accusations or insinuations. You must appreciate that at this time in my life the only thing I will respond to and the only thing that concerns me are the general interests of my country.

In the same way as when we asked for help for the financial sector we did so because we believed that it was good for Spain in order to recover credit and to help with economic growth and job creation, I, when I am fully apprised of exactly what is on offer, will take a decision. But I can assure you, I would ask that you believe me, that it has absolutely nothing to do with these insinuations or accusations, if indeed there have been any.

As regards the VAT rise, I have already stated that I was not in favour of raising VAT, nor raising Personal Income Tax. I was not in favour of that. I have had to do things that were not in my election manifesto and I don't like doing that, but the reality is the reality and, if I want to contribute and help this country grow economically and create jobs, I have to take those measures that can help to achieve that. Our reference remains growth and job creation, and as far as I can, I will help this situation return to where it was at the start, but at this time not trying to achieve that would be a grave error on my part that all Spaniards would end up paying for.

I am aware that I have taken some harsh decisions which I didn't like taking and which weren't on my agenda. I understand that people are unhappy with this and I understand that many people who supported us are unhappy with this, but Spain needs to do these things at this time, because Spain cannot, as occurred in the past, spend 90 billion euros more than it collects in revenue, quite simply because it does not have it and it is difficult to find.

What will we do in the next Budget? In the next Budget I can tell you know that we will not raise Personal Income Tax, or Value Added Tax. We will try to draft a Budget that allows us to meet our deficit commitment with the European Commission, which stands at 4.5% for 2013. And I hope that we do not need to take such difficult decisions as those we have taken during the course of these first few months of this legislature.

But, I repeat, in the situation in which we find ourselves today, and if we want to be serious and overcome this situation, we must do many things at the same time: firstly, reduce the deficit, and that is complicated, and that harms many people and initially may even make us fall into recession, but we have no other choice, and secondly, make structural reforms in order to be competitive. I would like to say to you that I am very pleased with where Spanish exports are going; this is a very important fact. Spain currently has, for the first time ever, a positive goods trade surplus with Germany.

We export more than we import. That is a very positive fact, that our companies go overseas and sell. We have gone from a foreign trade deficit of as much as 11% to zero this year.

This is something very important, but we still have a long way to go; we have to deal with our foreign debt and our public deficit, and we need to be working in this direction.

Finally, it is important to resolve the problems of the irreversibility of the Euro. Something is wrong in the monetary union that we form part of, which should be good for all of us, when some countries are financed at zero percent and other at six percent.

Mr. Hollande . Don't look to me to make Mr Draghi's job even more complicated than it already is. Any statement that any of us makes does not necessarily help his responsibility.

I would only ask for the application of the decisions that we took at the European Council on 29 June; decisions which precisely allow for intervention in exceptional circumstances. Subsequently, it is down to the European Central Bank to translate this message taking into account its own objectives.

Remember that among the missions of the European Central Bank is price stability, as well as monetary policy. When we see that there are such major differences in the interest rates without any economic justification, this may be justification in itself for intervention, precisely in the name of the objectives of monetary policy. I will say no more. The application of the decisions of the European Council and acting in such a way that Mr Draghi continues with what he announced and that he gives more specific details on 6 September. And those that are most in favour of the independence of the European Central Bank should respect the same principles, which are those that we currently apply.

Secondly, you ask when Spain should finally request aid from the Stability Mechanism. That responsibility lies solely with Spain. I can appreciate that Spain might, at any event, wait for certain clarifications that are essential. You already know the events that I reminded you of that need to take place: when is the European Stability Mechanism indeed going to kick in, what exactly will the Court in Karlsruhe decide, what is the position of the European Central Bank, what will be the conclusions of the working groups on banking… Once all this information becomes know, Spain, like other countries, will say what it is going to do.

I would like to conclude by saying that there are some very tough policies being implemented in Europe. I heard the President of the Spanish Government talk about a three percent rise in VAT - three percent - and about certain decisions regarding the civil service and State benefits. That is tough for the people and also has consequences for other countries. Although it may improve the competitiveness of the Spanish economy, there will be fewer imports, and hence, for the French economy there will be fewer exports and France is the leading economic and trading partner of Spain.

Hence, we are bound and that is why I want decisions to be taken within the shortest deadlines so that we can apply, in accordance with the decisions in June, in addition to the budgetary adjustment measures, which are variable according to the country… We are not all in the same situation and I would remind you that France asks for loans at a much lower interest rate than Spain, but we need growth and we need economic activity, and we need to coordinate our economic policies. I believe that today we have been in agreement.

Q . There has been much talk today about confidence, President Hollande, and I trust in the State to ensure the security of the French people, and I would like to ask you a question as the Head of the Armed Forces, will you send the military to Marseille, as has been suggested by a socialist senator?

Mr. Hollande . The Minister for Home Affairs has already spoken about this matter. The military does not concern itself with occupying the streets of the Republic, that is the job of the gendarmes. That is the work of the police, which will be reinforced in Marseille, who will act to eradicate this violence, this criminality and trafficking. Hence let's leave those forces who are tasked with this mission to get on with their work, and let's strengthen their capacity. In this respect, the priority security area is one of the main solutions - there will be others - that Marseille needs.

Q. President of the Government Rajoy, Catalonia has requested 5.9 billion euros from the Autonomous Liquidity Fund, Valencia has announced it needs 4.5 million and other regional governments have already announced that they will also be asking for financing. If this fund managed by your government runs out, will you be prepared to increase its funding? Do you not feel that this route of requesting auxiliary financing from central government might generate the mistrust of the markets regarding the Spanish regional model?

President of the Governm ent. What you say is true but, in the same way as I say this, I would also say to you that this is nothing new. We have been doing this since we came to government. There are other regional governments with liquidity problems, with difficulties in refinancing their debts and the State is helping them because I believe that we ought to.

I would also like to say that I know what the regional governments are going to request during the course of the year, because what we will be dealing with are the foreign maturities and their public deficit. We already knew this, and hence, it came as no surprise what was requested by Catalonia the other day or by the Region of Valencia. Hence, there is no problem of running out of funds in this respect.

I would also like to say that this does not mean rising debt, this means that the regional governments are refinancing their debt, that the State is helping them, but the debt remains the same and it belongs to the autonomous regions.

Hence, this does not surprise me, because I know about it, we knew it was going to happen, we have dealt with it and we will continue dealing with it until the financing and liquidity problems we are speaking about here are resolved. I repeat, it is very important that we are aware of this because sometimes headlines are published, and news items appear or it seems that something newsworthy has emerged and that is not the case. The government is fully aware that there is a group of autonomous regions with liquidity problems and the government is dealing with them, but I was already aware that Catalonia and Valencia were going to announce something like this, in the same way as I am aware that other regional governments will ask for the same.

This was on the cards, this does not mean additional debt, but is rather simply a case of dealing with liquidity and financing problems which, unfortunately, exist here today and which are greatly complicating things. Here we do not only need to reduce our public deficit, we do not only need to make structural reforms, but we also need for the matter of the euro not to generate more doubts in Europe than it has already created, because that also makes the financing of our public administration services, our financial entities and our companies more difficult.

Hence, a part of the responsibility lies solely with us, while there is another part which we must try to resolve with our Eurozone partners, who are aware of what is taking place.

It has been a pleasure ladies and gentlemen. Thank you very much.