Press Conference by the Italian Prime Minister and the President of the Government
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed a joint press conference with Italian Prime Minister Monti in Rome on 22 February 2012, discussing bilateral, European, and international issues.
- Main themes
- Bilateral Spain-Italy relations, economic reforms, labour market reform, banking system reform, European Union fiscal compact, Single European Market integration, growth and job creation, services sector deregulation, international security, Syria and Iran, UNIFIL and Afghanistan missions, European Council March 2012
- Duration
- ~46 min
- Words
- 5,548
- Sentences
- 215
- Readability
- 53
- Grade
- 12.0
- Syntax
- 3.06
- Vocabulary
- 2.03
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
215 sentences in 82 paragraphs
However, today was an important occasion that enabled us to examine in greater detail both the bilateral problems and, in particular, problems of a European and international nature. We spoke, above all, about our respective experiences in the field of reforms to enable our economies to become more dynamic again and to increase their growth potential and job creation.
I told Mariano Rajoy, and I am also delighted to do this publicly, that I am very impressed by his reform of the banking system and the labour market. These are crucial measures which, in our opinion, are heading in the right direction. In this respect, I suggested to the President that we should activate direct contact at a level of the technical ministries in order to exchange ideas on the labour market. I believe that we have much to learn from one another, because the challenges and the rules of the labour market, for example, are not exactly the same in the two countries.
Of course we have also spoken about the European Union, a matter on which there is much common ground between our two countries. We have found ourselves side by side supporting the decision to grant the new tranche of aid to Greece, in negotiations on the "fiscal compact" and also in our strategies for growth and job creation.
As regards this last matter, the President of the Government and I have jointly promoted an initiative in the form of a joint letter that has been signed together with another ten Heads of Government and sent to President Van Rompuy and President Durao Barroso, in light of the upcoming European Council on 1 and 2 March, which will constitute a working basis for coordinating our actions and we hope that increasingly the actions of the Commission and the Council as well in the direction of growth, development and employment, above all for young people.
Completing and extending the integration of the Single European Market to have only one that is truly single would allow us, and we both agree on this, to obtain very, very significant benefits for the European economy and for each one of our countries. In particular, in the area of services, which represent more than three quarters of the economy, the introduction of a healthy dose of competition, which this sector currently lacks, would help create more companies and jobs, above all for our young people, and would also help to reduce processes. We have already done this in the aviation and telecommunications sectors at a European level, with the very positive results that we are all aware of.
Europe can also attain significant results in other fields, such as energy or by creating a digital single market through efficient and reliable payment systems and copyrights.
In many of these fields, particularly services, it escapes no-one that there is a strong correlation between action taken at a European level to really open up and integrate the services markets and what many of us do in our respective Member States as regards market deregulation. If you look at the raft of deregulations carried out by the Italian Government at the end of January, and whose passage through Parliament is now at a very advanced stage, many of these deregulations precisely affect the services sector. And hence, this is the domestic face on the concerted action that we carry out together with other countries at a European level in matters of services.
We have also spoken with Mariano Rajoy about international matters, and have seen that our points of view are very similar. Our respective troops are carrying out the UNIFIL mission in Lebanon and also in Afghanistan. We are both following with grave concern the development of the situation in Syria and we are seeing with growing apprehension the events unfolding in Iran, waiting for Tehran to finally accept the invitation to return to real negotiations. We will obviously remain in close cooperation on these international matters, both at the Summit in Chicago and at the ministerial Conference in Tokyo.
As regards European matters, our collaboration is very close at all our meetings, starting, as I said earlier, at the European Council on 1 March.
Hence, Mr. President, welcome once again and thank you very much for your visit. The floor is yours.
Mr. Rajoy . A very good afternoon to you Ladies and Gentlemen. I would like to start this speech by thanking Prime Minister Monti for his words of welcome and the way we have all been treated. As he said, it is not the first time we have spoken; we have spoken by phone on various occasions during recent times and also, as he indicated, at the last European Council. This has been a longer meeting, where we have tackled specific matters and for me it is a pleasure and an honour to be here today, and I am very grateful for the way I have been received.
Mario Monti has explained what we spoke about here today wonderfully well; and hence I don't think it makes much sense for me to repeat what is a true reflection of the reality of what took place. But I would rather make a few points about the current European situation.
I have proposed to Prime Minister Monti something on which we both agree: that at these times in Europe we need to commit to fiscal consolidation together with policies for growth and policies that help to create jobs.
That is why we have signed, together with other Heads of Government of the European Union, a letter addressed to Mr. Durao Barroso and to Mr. Van Rompuy to talk about subjects that may help to result in economic growth and job creation in Europe as swiftly as possible - following the forecasts that have been made by the European Commission today.
I think that significant progress can be made on all the matters dealt with in this letter; on matters of the deregulation of services; on matters of the single market; on energy matters - interconnections are particularly important for Spain - on matters affecting the labour market; on matters of SMEs; on innovation and on opening up new markets. We live in an open, global and competitive world and hence it is absolutely essential to carry out reforms in order not to lag behind other places in the world.
I said it in London two days ago and I will say it again now; when Europe was created, many years ago now, back in 1957 in Rome, there was talk of the free movement of people, goods, capital and services. 54 years later this has still not taken place definitively and that is the commitment that we need to make in the future: more Europe.
We have heard about and we have exchanged impressions and information about the reforms being carried out in the two countries. This is a difficult moment and I believe that both the people here in Italy and back home in Spain understand the decisions that we are taking, which we are obliged to take. I believe that much hard work is being done in Italy, I believe that it is taking the measures that it has to take and I am absolutely convinced that we will all continue doing this.
In Spain, and I have explained this to Mario Monti, we have also taken some important decisions and will continue taking others.
This is going to be a very reformist legislature. In addition to the decisions that we have taken on reducing the public deficit by 1.5% of the GDP, there will be - when the Budget is presented - further reductions of the public deficit; we have also approved the labour reform via a Royal Decree Law, which is now in force, although it still needs to be debated in Parliament; we have implemented the restructuring of the new financial system; we have also incorporated the "golden rule" into our Constitution which was recently approved in Brussels, and this Friday we will present, after completing the necessary procedures, the Budgetary Stability Act, which will oblige all public authorities (Central Government, the autonomous regions and the local authorities) to meet the public deficit objectives, which Spain commits to before its European partners.
Hence, I am very pleased with the meeting. I believe that we are going through times in which Europe needs reforms, it needs courage to tackle the crisis and it needs to explain to our citizens, each of us to our own citizens and to Europe as a whole, that there are things that need to be done.
There are hard times ahead; this is going to be a tough year, a complicated year. We will have to keep making reforms and these reforms are not going to show results in the short term, and hence, this makes them tougher still and even harder to understand, but I would like to state here, in the same way as I have said in Spain, that we are laying the foundations for the future and that serious governments cannot govern by only thinking about the short term or about the next twenty-four hours. We need to think about the medium and the long term because, by acting in this way, we will manage to create jobs, we will achieve economic growth and we will manage to maintain and improve the welfare state, which is our objective, at least of the two people here and assuredly of the vast majority of European leaders.
Thank you very much Prime Minister. It is of course a real pleasure to be here with all of you.
Q . For both prime ministers. We have just been informed of the growth figures published by the European Union for Spain and for Italy, both of which are negative. Will you ask for the deficit objectives to be revised for Spain and for Italy?
And a second question. Spain and Italy have spent two years making very tough cuts and the two countries, according to these economic figures, these figures from Brussels, are going to fall into recession. Do you think that the time has come to propose other measures aside from cuts?
Mr. Rajoy . Those are two questions. To the first one I will respond regarding what the government I lead will do, as you would expect. Prime Minister Monti will do what he thinks is best for the general interests of his country, as you would also expect.
To date, we have seen three growth forecasts for Spain: the Bank of Spain - 1.5% negative growth, the International Monetary Fund - 1.7% negative growth, and now, the European Commission tells us that there will be 1% negative growth in Spain. I would also like to remind you that not long ago the European Commission itself said that Spain would grow by 0.7%, specifically last November.
And the Government of Spain last year, in 2011, said that in 2012 Spain would enjoy growth of 2.3%; just imagine, 2.3%.
I would like to say that I expected this forecast made by the European Commission. I was fully aware that the growth forecast, and I was waiting to see it, was going to be about this, or even worse. That is why I have to say - I said it before and I will say it again - that this will be a tough year for Spain. This will be a tough year for Spain and it is good that we are all aware of this because, logically, by acknowledging the situation and knowing the lie of the land and where we are at means that we can build on it and so do things to construct a better future.
This situation obliges us to the following: firstly, it obliges us to be realistic. The worst thing that can be done in any walk of life is not to face reality. And hence, I guarantee that the Government of Spain will be realistic.
We will shortly present, in the month of March, in the first fortnight of March, our macro-economic table, with a negative forecast for growth, along the lines marked by these three bodies: the European Commission, the Bank of Spain and the International Monetary Fund. We will set our forecast for growth along these lines, which will not be the most optimistic of the three, just to be clear, minus 1%. But there or thereabouts.
Following that, we will set our ceiling on State spending and also the budgetary stability objective, the deficit for the public authorities as a whole. I would like to say that the ceiling on spending will be prudent. We will base ourselves on a prudent forecast for revenue. We are not going to say how much we will collect or how much we think we will collect. There are certain outlooks that are not good for this year and we will set them out in the forecast for revenue.
We will inform the autonomous regions and the local authorities that, after this forecast for growth, they have to adopt the corresponding corrective measures, because the Budget has been drawn up on the basis of a growth forecast which, as some of us suggested, was never going to be certain.
So, we will present our Budget on this basis on the date that I have been saying we will make the announcement since I became President of the Government, I am complying with the schedule we established. We will present our Budget, in principle, on Friday 30 March.
I would like to say the following about the Budget: firstly, as I indicated, it will be realistic; secondly, the forecast for revenue will be sensible and reasonable, in other words, we are not going to say that we will collect what we will not in fact collect; thirdly, the objective is to comply therewith, we are not going to draw up a Budget to then not comply with it; we are going to draw up a Budget and that is why it needs to be sensible, to comply with it; in fourth place, I should say that a good part of today's problems stem from having made a Budget which then couldn't be complied with and which was far indeed from the reality. I will not do that. I would prefer to say "things are how they are" but I am not going to say it in eight months, I would prefer to say it now.
Hence the objective will remain the reduction of the public deficit. That is what I have to say. As of now, we will talk with the Commission. We had a growth forecast of 2.3% but now the same forecast is of negative growth; we had a deficit that was going to be 6% but which is now going to exceed 8%. Consequently, the only thing I can say is that we will speak with the Commission but that, at any event, Spain will comply with the objectives of the public deficit.
And it will comply - and that is my reply to your second question - because I do believe that it is necessary to reduce the public deficit. You ask whether now is the right time to reduce the public deficit. The problem is that we spent 90 billion euros in Spain that we didn't have to spend; and we now have to ask for those 90 billion euros from someone; and so, this someone can give it to us or not, and if they don't give it to us, we can have whatever public deficit we may have but there is a problem without a solution.
And hence, the Government's position is a commitment to fiscal consolidation, but also a commitment, with measures in place, to economic growth and job creation. That is why, I repeat, we sent that letter that Mario Monti referred to in his speech, as have I.
I insist on what I have said: these are hard times, but they are times when we need to govern, thinking about the medium and the long term, and not putting anything else in the limelight that does not involve the general interests of Spain. I have taken decisions that affect many people: some affect the financial system, others affect the electricity companies, other affect trade unions and business leaders; I have increased personal income tax for high earners; I have increased property tax and I have made already cuts to the Budget; but believe me that if we are doing this it is because we believe that it is what is required in the general interest of the Spanish people which is, of course, at this late time in the day, the only thing that matters.
Mr. Monti . As regards how this affects the Italian Government, I will give a brief reply.
The revision that the European Commission has published today comes as no surprise. We can ask ourselves two questions: Is it necessary to carry out new manoeuvres in Italy to ensure the objective, that we can confirm, of balancing the accounts for 2013?
Do we need new manoeuvres of these forecasts on the Gross Domestic Product? No. Why not? Because in the raft of measures adopted in December - known as "Save Italy" - we took into account a very prudent forecast as regards the evolution of the Gross Domestic Product and because, in a very prudent manner, we suggested a hypothesis whereby the interest rates would remain at last November's levels, while they have dropped considerably, and finally, because, although we have introduced strong instruments, which are producing results, in order for the effectiveness of the fight against tax evasion to increase, we had not reflected a single euro under this heading in the accounts.
Hence we have created prudent margins which allow me to say that we will continue with the objective of balanced accounts in 2013 which, as I will remind you, is an objective that was already assumed by the previous Italian Government, and it is not necessary to take any further measures.
The second question in relation to the forecast made by the Commission, which has come as no surprise, is, in light of this figure published by the Commission, will the Italian Government change its own growth policy? The answer in this case is also "no".
Why? Because the line that the Italian Government is already taking to generate growth is a line of structural interventions.
In the decree in December, as regards the structural element, in addition to the very incisive pension reform, we shifted part of the tax burden on production factors, in other words, on employment and businesses, towards equity. Hence we have fiscally safeguarded, above all, the need for competitiveness, and hence, for growth. We have also done much to free up the growth potential of the Italian economy through deregulation, so that there is greater competition.
And hence, we don't see any reason to have to introduce, let's say, to inject, ulterior elements to foster growth, but rather that we are convinced that those measures we have started to introduce in the Italian economic fabric are the right ones and will produce results. Naturally, the fact that interest rates have dropped, although not as quickly as we might have hoped, has created greater 'space' in the State accounts and also in company accounts.
On another note, a figure published today I think - at least I saw it this morning - made me think, and think positively. I am talking about the indicator of the situation of consumer confidence in February, which has risen. That really is surprising to me and a very pleasant surprise, although these figures should never be over-interpreted taken individually. But the consumers confidence index has risen significantly more than the small technical increase that the majority of the forecasts suggested.
I believe that both Spain and Italy greatly trust in fuelling their own growth and that recovery will come through the very delicate work we already have underway, and also in the improvement in European control to provide a better base for growth. I believe that this is what we intend to do, together with others, through our actions in Brussels.
Q . The President of the Government, Mariano Rajoy, has already spoken about the needs of the objectives that a government should propose in such a complicated situation. Prime Minister Monti said this morning that my government is an interim government that proposes to be a long-lasting government. Regarding this long-term objective, do you also envisage the possibility of improving the position of Italy; in other words, that Italy can become one of the countries most contributing to help strengthen Europe?
Mr. Monti . On the one hand, I thank you, and on the other hand, dear journalists, I beg that you don't do this. You analyse each adjective and each noun I use too much. But, it is true, we are an interim government working on long-term objectives. That is why we need to think about the future. In the past, and I refer to the distant past, we had many long-lasting governments that worked on the basis of short-term governments and now is the time to compensate that.
Perhaps that answer is sufficient, or do you want me to go into further detail?
Above all, let's not forget that here we need to reassess our previous governments because the contribution from Italy to the construction of Europe has been absolutely decisive at various times. I only need remind you that under the Italian Presidency, the decision was adopted on direct universal suffrage for the European Parliament, under the Italian Presidency, also in Milan in 1985, it was decided to move in the direction of the Single European Act, and thus the Single Market; and also under the Italian Presidency, in Rome in 1990, the definitive steps were taken to shore up the Treaty of Maastricht. On these last two occasions I think that we can still remember Prime Minister Thatcher, because she saw a Europe, fostered by Italy, moving off on its own path, although we have a great interest in fully bringing the United Kingdom back into the fold, which can also be seen through our letters.
Hence, given that the contribution from Italy to building Europe has always been important and that, in financial terms, Italy has now become a net contributor, we are now dedicated to the voice that we heard moving in the right direction for economic policy and for European policy in general, and that it arrives from Italy with as much force as possible. As you are aware, we have greatly activated this and we have devoted a lot of time to this in recent sessions of the Italian Parliament.
Q . President of the Government, Mariano Rajoy, you have said, as regards the deficit objective, that you were going to speak with the European Commission. Logically the parameters in which our country moves are different. But I would like to insist, will Spain ask for a reduction in this deficit objective? What will you ask for?
You have talked about the Budget, you spoke about revenue and also about cuts. Against this backdrop of recession, do you think it is right that Spain continues to make cuts? I think we are talking about a figure of some 40 billion euros.
As regards the growth policies that the two of you have talked about, you have asked Europe for long-term growth policies. What growth policies could Europe adopt in the short term to help countries in the Eurozone?
Mr. Rajoy . Those are three issues. Firstly, the public deficit, secondly whether the policy to reduce spending is right or not, and thirdly, what can be done on matters of growth policies.
Reducing spending only has one objective: to reduce the public deficit. Reducing the public deficit, as I said before, is fundamental, because it is a commitment that we have assumed, firstly, when we joined the Euro, and secondly, the when the Government of Spain, last year, presented its Stability and Growth Plan, it said that it would be 4.4% this year.
It is a question of complying with certain commitments that nobody imposed on us, but rather which we voluntarily assumed and which we assumed because we believed - and I, of course, continue believing - that the policy of not spending what we don't have was a good policy. We cannot spend all our lives spending more than we have because you reach a point when you cannot pay it back or no-one will lend you anymore.
Hence, we have to move towards policies with a reasonable public deficit, and that can be achieved in two ways: by increasing revenue or by reducing costs; or by doing both things at once - increasing revenue and reducing costs - which is what we did in the decision taken on 30 December.
Apart from that, what are we going to do? Firstly, continue reducing the public deficit. What we are going to do now is draw up a Budget which is more austere than last year's, which will be what we approve; but, after that we have to implement growth policies because I have no intention of raising taxes again.
Reforms, which is the last question you had for me. What do we need to do to stimulate economic growth? Well, that depends on many things. It depends on us having a good financing system for our economy, but, above all, it depends on making structural reforms. I, for example, believe that the labour reform that we have presented is designed with this objective. We have carried out this labour reform to create jobs, that is our main reason, and so that no more jobs are shed; in order not to make a lot of adjustments as has happened in Spain over the course of the last few years, based on people not losing their jobs, so that SMEs can recruit and give opportunities and possibilities to young people. That is a reform to generate growth.
The reform of the financial system is another reform looking to generate economic growth and create employment. There is no credit available in Spain now; well there is no credit because of the situation that our financial entities are going through. It is a question of being obliged or of obliging them, which is what we have done, to undertake a reorganisation process so that there are no doubts surrounding the system, so that there are loans between entities and to generate credit in the future. This is another structural reform that helps growth.
And the Budgetary Stability Act is nine tenths of the same. And everything else we will propose in the coming weeks and months is to the same end. We are now proposing, through the ICO (Official Credit Institute), to pay suppliers, to pay many people who have not been paid, as everyone knows, for years now. Two things will be done: firstly, settle payment, which is an elementary obligation to those who provide a service, and secondly, inject money into the economy, which should also be good for consumption and investment, and hence, for growth.
All the reforms included in the letter signed by Prime Minister Monti and by myself are based along these lines. Electricity interconnections, all the issues of the single market, the deregulation of services…, that is what needs to be done for us to enjoy economic growth in the future. That is why you will always hear me say: we need to do two things at the same time: firstly, not spend what we don't have, control the public deficit - that cannot be done by an autonomous region or a local council, nor should it be done by a family, or a company - and secondly, carry out reforms that result in growth and jobs.
Let me tell you something to end up on, there is no precedent in the history of Spain in which our country had had economic growth and created jobs at a time of high public deficit and high public debt. Whenever there is a high public deficit and public debt rises, jobs are shed and there is negative economic growth. There is no precedent in this country, as I said.
Q . I had a question for President of the Government, Mariano Rajoy and another for Prime Minister Monti.
Mr. Monti . So two then.
Q . I will join them into one. As regards the reform measures outlined by Mariano Rajoy, I would like to ask, particularly of the President of the Government, if he doesn't fear a social reaction and if he doesn't fear a social reaction from the lobbies, as happened in Italy.
And the same question for Prime Minister Monti. Regarding those reforms, for example, that are being passed through Parliament now and are experiencing modifications, how would you assess these modifications? Does the Government think it should accept them or intervene in some way?
Mr. Rajoy . The first question, the one addressed to me, is about whether or not I fear a social reaction. We have taken decisions, as I said before, that affect many people: the financial system, the electricity companies, business organisations, trade unions, public servants, etc.
The only thing I can say is that Spain, in my opinion, and the rest of Europe needs moderation at this time, it needs common sense, it needs balance and it needs a government to take decisions thinking about the medium and the long term and in the general interest of the country. And governments should also explain why we are taking decisions.
But I believe that if the measures we take are perceived by the people to be just and equal, that measures are not taken that prejudice one group or another… The only item we have raised in the Budget is pensions, the only one, because we believe that pensioners are in a bad situation with no way out. That is the only item we have raised. All others we have decreased, or can be decreased.
So, if we are just and if we are fair, I am convinced that there will not be social tension. It is true that last Sunday there were demonstrations against the labour reform organised by trade unions. I have to say that I respect them but that, in all sincerity, this labour reform is what Spain needs. In other words, neither the Government I lead nor the one led by Mario Monti takes decisions to annoy anyone. We don't do that. Decisions are taken to try to improve things and, above all, to pave the way for a better future.
And hence I am not afraid, although some things have already taken place, that there may be an out-of-the ordinary situation, because I believe in maturity, in balance and in the common sense of the Spanish people.
Mr. Monti . I would also sign up to this last phrase by the President of the Government, Mariano Rajoy. Our people, our public opinion, even with profoundly different forms between the two countries at this time, our political systems are showing evidence of great maturity, aware of the fact that what is in play is the collective well-being and that the policies to make a country more modern or more competitive are in the interest of each and every one of us.
So, the interests of the sectors are legitimate interests most of the time and it is understandable that they try to translate to modifications to the proposals made by the government, for example, on matters of deregulation. And it is also absolutely normal and right that the government is open to dialogue with a body that has the final word on the matter, such as Parliament.
This work is underway as regards deregulation; but the government is very interested in the matter and is disposed to employ all the credit that it can make available for the result - let me express myself in political terms and concisely - to be like this.
We have asked, if we take account of the two issue open today - work and deregulation - for sacrifices for the sake of modernisation, and hence, for willingness to change acquired habits both from one side and from the other.
We have two objectives that guide our actions: that there is equilibrium in the sacrifices made by the various social and economic players, and that the level of progress towards modernisation, and hence, towards a more competitive Italy, be a high level of progress. An equilibrium could also be obtained by doing nothing or by making tiny steps forward, trying to reach an equilibrium in the participation in the sacrifice but at a level that really makes the country more competitive.
This responsibility is ours towards society, towards public opinion. There will be changes that we adopt, because not all change means a step backwards, some mean an improvement, and other modifications that we cannot and will not accept.
Thank you very much.