Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

14 February 2012 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions from Rosa Díez of Unión Progreso y Democracia during a government control session in the Spanish Cortes on 14 February 2012.
Main themes
Democratic regeneration, transparency and anti-corruption measures, citizen disaffection from politics, austerity and fiscal responsibility, judicial independence, electoral reform, institutional trust, political party reform, Transparency Law, quality of democracy
Duration
~22 min
71st percentile
Words
2,680
71st percentile
Sentences
88
57th percentile
Readability
42
41st percentile
Grade
14.8
74th percentile
Syntax
3.14
66th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
30th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 42%41%
  • Institutional 41%40%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

88 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Rosa Díez, of the Parliamentary Group of Unión Progreso y Democracia

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ms. Díez.- When citizens disengage from politics, political institutions tend to disengage from citizens, and that, as Your Lordship must understand, is very bad for democracy. I ask you, Mr. President of the Government, what initiatives your Government plans to take precisely to combat this scourge and what initiatives your Government plans to take to improve the quality of our democracy.

President.- Ms. Díez, first of all, I want to tell you that I do not share the view that citizens disengage from politics. They are interested in politics in the same way they have been interested over the years. There may be politicians who disengage from citizens, but there are also many politicians who are attentive to the problems of citizens.

That said, which I believe was important to state, I will tell you that we are taking, and will take, austerity measures whose basic objective is to spend taxpayers' money wisely, which we believe is an obligation of any Government; we will take measures in terms of transparency and will soon present here, in the Cortes, a Transparency Law; in terms of democratic regeneration, we will soon present a Law for the Reform of Regulatory Bodies, as well as an Organic Law to Reform the Organic Law of the Constitutional Court; we will also propose that twelve of the twenty members of the Judicial Power Council be elected by judges and a series of regulations that, in more detail, I can provide you either in the second part of my speech or at any time in the Cortes.

In any case, it is important to point out that one of the things this Government will do is to tell the truth and not engage in demagoguery.

Ms. Díez.- It is evident, Mr. President, that there is enormous disaffection between citizens and politics, and that it is not a Spanish problem; it is a problem of all democracies in the world. Not recognizing this reality makes it impossible to combat it. It is a problem we have, for which I do not blame anyone, but it is important that we at least share the diagnosis in order to successfully confront it.

The latest report from Transparency International recommends that Spain take 44 specific measures to improve the quality of our democracy. Among the recommended measures are a national pact against corruption; regulations to improve the quality of democracy in political parties; the need to modify the electoral system; the need to promote internal democracy in parties; the need to depoliticize the organs of Justice and the Constitutional Court, and also the need to urgently approve a Law on Access to Information. I add another consideration: the need to depoliticize the financial system and to hold accountable those individuals who have led many of our institutions to bankruptcy.

You will agree with me, President, that there is institutional distrust in Spain and low civic engagement that must be corrected with self-criticism and concrete measures. It is not just me saying this; it is what citizens say every time they are asked: correct it with self-criticism and concrete measures. Some of the measures you have announced seem to me to be what needs to be done.

How can we look the other way when in the 2011 report on the corruption index Spain is ranked 32nd, one position and one-tenth above Botswana? Is that something we should be proud of or should we say that nothing is happening here? Not to mention poverty or exclusion data that place millions of Spanish citizens outside, on the margins. We must also resolve these problems because we cannot demand that citizens continue to trust us, the politicians, if we do not contribute to solving their problems.

I encourage you, President, to take bold initiatives. It is not just about the economy; we must resolve the political and institutional crisis.

President.- One thing is what the reports say, which are very respectable; but I tell you what the Government I lead is planning to do and what it is already doing.

In terms of austerity, which I place great importance on because it is about respecting the resources and money of the taxpayer, we have made and will continue to make reductions in administrative structures; we will resize the public business and foundation sector; we have reduced subsidies to political parties and I am willing to continue discussing this matter and to listen to your proposals, as well as those of the unions and business organizations; we will implement a broad plan to reduce current spending and optimize resources in the Administration; we will bring a Transparency Law in this session; we will create a Transparency Portal; we will elevate a series of ethical principles and conduct that should govern the actions of members of the Government and senior officials to the rank of law; clear regulations to provide complete information on budgets and the asset situation of political parties, business organizations, unions, foundations, and NGOs; publicity of indicators that allow for the evaluation of public policies; publicity of subsidies and their beneficiaries; more transparency in administrative contracting; we will standardize the setting of remuneration for local elected officials and we will establish a reference framework for the salaries of senior officials across the Administration.

On this, I am willing to talk with you and with all the Groups…

Response of the President of the Government to Mr. Josu Iñaki Erkoreka, of the Basque Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, since the middle of last year, as you surely are aware, the Spanish shipbuilding sector is in critical condition. It was already greatly weakened due to Asian competition; in fact, over the last twenty-five years, Europe has gone from representing 25% of the global market share to just 5%, and within that 5% European share, Spanish shipyards hold only 11%; 11% of the 5% global. The weakening is evident.

But in mid-last year, the final blow came. A formal investigation initiated by the European Commission revealed that what is known as the Spanish tax leasing system could be incompatible with European competition law, and therefore, it agreed to its immediate suspension. Since then, there have been no orders in the shipyards and their employees have no work. The situation is frankly dramatic and could still worsen if immediate measures are not taken.

Just in the Basque Country, look at how dramatic the situation is: the sector provides direct employment to seven thousand people and indirect employment to approximately ten thousand. That is why it is essential for the Government to take measures. It is necessary to pull the shipbuilding sector out of the critical condition it is in now, and for that, it is urgent and important that the Government negotiates with the European Union for a Commission authorization for a new tax leasing system to replace the currently existing one, so that the shipyards can recover their activity immediately. That is why I pose the question that appears on the agenda: What measures is the Government adopting for the immediate implementation of a financial leasing system for ships that allows for the salvation of the shipbuilding sector?

President.- You are right, and I share your concern. I believe I know the subject well, because not long ago I met in Vigo with the President of the Xunta de Galicia and representatives of various trade unions, who conveyed the problem to me. It undoubtedly affects the shipbuilding sector in Spain, particularly important in the Basque Country and Galicia, and also in some other territories of our country.

What you have said is true. In June of last year, the European Commission initiated proceedings against Spain for a possible qualification as state aid of the regulations on Corporate Tax, which were incompatible with Community Law, and since we came to Government, we have already been trying to work, make decisions, and raise, as you have pointed out, this issue with the European Commission. The Ministers of Industry, Energy and Tourism, and Finance and Public Administration are having various meetings with different members of the European Commission, both at a technical and political level.

For my part, what I want to tell you is that I give, and the Government I lead gives, absolute priority to the implementation of this financing system for ships for the shipbuilding sector, for the reasons you have mentioned and because it is so, without a doubt; that we have been working intensively with the technical services of the European Commission in defining the instruments that make up the new system, which is what you are asking for; that the Minister of Finance and Public Administration, through the General Directorate of Taxes, presented the draft to the European Commission on February 3 to obtain its formal approval; that negotiations are developing in a reasonable manner; that there are some countries with a special regime, as you surely know, specifically France, and therefore, we believe that the Commission must grant us a similar regime, and I hope that within not too long we will have a reasonable solution and a solution that is satisfactory for the Commission and, above all, what matters most to us, for the shipbuilding sector.

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, allow me to insist on two ideas that are fundamental to pull the sector out of the quagmire: first, the new system that is instituted must guarantee the competitiveness of the sector, which has already lost many points in global market share; and second, it is urgent. The new system that is to be proposed must be in force during the first quarter of 2012; otherwise, the sector will die, Mr. President, and I do not think you want to live with the honor of being the President of the Government at the moment when a sector with such tradition and that has provided so many jobs for so many years disappears definitively. That is all.

President.- I agree: it must guarantee competitiveness and it is urgent. We are doing everything in our power to resolve it. I would add one more thing: it should not produce retroactive effects because, without a doubt, it would generate many problems and difficulties for people who used this system based on the existing legislation at that time.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. President of the Government, do you consider that the measures your Government is taking are what this country needs?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba. I believe so. Logically, if I did not believe it, I would not take them or we would take different ones. I also believe that more needs to be taken, and we are working on that. And all these measures—I take this opportunity to tell you—will not produce effects in the short term due to the economic situation that is occurring in our country and the international environment, especially the European environment. But I believe we are laying the foundations for sustained and stable growth in the future, and therefore, to generate employment, which is the main objective of the Government I lead.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- On Friday, you approved the labor reform. You spent the campaign saying that you would not make dismissal cheaper, and you have done just the opposite: where there were 45 days, you have put 20; where there were 33, 20. You have made dismissal cheaper and, what is worse, Mr. Rajoy, making dismissal cheaper, when a reflection is approaching, is the best way to increase unemployment.

You said you would simplify the number of contracts. You have not done so; you have created one more, a new contract. I will tell you in advance that the idea of lowering social contributions to promote employment is a good idea; the problem is that you have turned it into a monument to precariousness: you have created a contract with a one-year trial period or, in other words, a year of free and easy dismissal. You call it an indefinite contract, but it is not so. It is a very defined contract: a maximum of 364 days.

And finally, you said you would make a balanced reform and you have done the opposite: you have broken all the balances that have been built over many years in our labor relations system by giving all powers to the employer; omnipotent powers to reduce everything from hours to wages.

In Europe, many labor reforms have been made, Mr. Rajoy, and all of them aimed to give flexibility to companies and security to workers; they call it flexi-security. You have created a new concept that is flexi-insecurity. Let me tell you: insecurity for those who have a contract, because they do not know what their working conditions will be; insecurity for those who have one of these new contracts that you create because they do not know how long the trial period will last, and insecurity, above all, for young people who have never had any type of contract because, with no unemployment to contribute to the new contracts, there is nothing for them. And insecurity, Mr. Rajoy, at this moment is the worst thing for our economy, for job creation, and for economic growth.

I will tell you one last thing: you have, in reality, presented a total amendment to our system of labor relations, a total amendment to what we have created in democracy. I will simplify it for you. It could be said that your labor reform is something like this: either you accept the wage cuts or here is your bill. And, Mr. Rajoy, that cannot be the formula for creating jobs in Spain.

President.- You have focused almost the entirety of your speech on a specific point of the reforms we have proposed; specifically, the labor reform. I want to say that this Government is making decisions, has an economic policy program, and is acting in all areas in which it must act.

We have reduced the public deficit by 1.5 percent of Gross Domestic Product; we have approved a Budget Stability Law, whose fundamental objective is that no Administration squanders public resources and spends more than it has; we have approved a regulation on the restructuring of our financial system to bring back credit; some other measures, and perhaps the most important is the labor reform.

I fully understand that you do not like the labor reform proposed by the Government, but the previous situation was leading us nowhere because, as you very well know, Spain has, unfortunately, the record for unemployment in the European Union. More than five million Spaniards want to work and cannot. We have more unemployment than double the average of the European Union.

You talk about young people, but the problem is that between 45 and 50 percent of young people cannot work, and in a situation like this we can do three things: either do nothing, or labor reforms, like the one you made with all due respect, which served absolutely no purpose, or make a labor reform in line with what is being proposed in Europe.

There is a 20-day contract, which already existed, but did not work because it was poorly drafted; there is a 33-day contract that now becomes, which has existed since 1977, but now both will really work; there are rules to guarantee flexibility and mobility within the company; a contract is indeed created to hire young people, because the aim is to facilitate the hiring of young people, and a change is given to training.

And it is true that here many possibilities or much power, if you will, will be lost by both business organizations and unions; but we have to govern for the people, for the workers, so that jobs are created…