Press conference by the President of the Government after the European Council meeting
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed a press conference on 13 December 2012 following the final European Council meeting of the year, summarizing progress on EU integration and banking supervision.
- Main themes
- European integration, banking union and supervision, Economic and Monetary Union, eurozone crisis management, fiscal consolidation and growth, Spain's role in EU decisions, Greece stabilization, European Stability Mechanism, sovereign debt crisis, single supervisory authority, ECB debt markets intervention, Treaty on Stability Coordination and Governance
- Duration
- ~45 min
- Words
- 5,374
- Sentences
- 213
- Readability
- 55
- Grade
- 11.8
- Syntax
- 3.16
- Vocabulary
- 1.81
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other213 sentences in 68 paragraphs
President of the Government. Ladies and gentlemen, a very good afternoon and thank you very much for coming here to this conference following on from the last European Council meeting of this year.
The most important thing I have to tell you - and I'll tell you right from the start - is that this European Council meeting of yesterday and today, 14 December, closes a year in which Europe has made firm progress towards greater integration; and that is - in my opinion, but I think I can talk in the name of many Spanish people - good news.
This year, against a background of economic crisis, the debate in the European Union has come to focus steadily on the most important subjects, and decisions and steps have been taken that seemed impossible at the start of the year. And I would like to tell you that Spain has also been a very active party in the decisions that have been adopted.
The European Council meetings of January and March recognised the need to double the efforts being made to pull Europe out of the crisis; but the measures agreed still did not form a coherent whole. Even so, decisive steps were taken, such as the preparation and the signing of the Treaty on Stability, Coordination and Governance and the European Stability Mechanism.
I would like to recall the importance of the initiative that twelve Member States, among them Spain, adopted in February, with the letter we sent to President Barroso stressing the need to present specific initiatives to stimulate growth in Europe, as a necessary complement to fiscal consolidation. Many of these measures were already included in the March meeting of the European Council, but it has been at the Council meetings of June, October and the latest in December when very specific and decisive steps have been taken in the right direction. The decisions of the European Council have also been strengthened by agreements adopted on the resolution of the crisis in Greece and the decisions of the European Central Bank.
The European Council meeting in June was a key Council meeting, as I have already said on some occasions. It approved the Compact for Growth and Jobs; but also - and what's more for the first time - there was clear talk at a Council meeting of the need to improve our Economic and Monetary Union. To make progress in this direction, President Van Rompuy, together with the President of the Commission, the President of the Eurogroup and the President of the European Central Bank were commissioned to prepare a roadmap with a strict schedule for achieving real Economic and Monetary Union. In addition, the Euro Summit asked the Council for an urgent proposal to create a single mechanism for banking supervision that could open the way for a direct recapitalisation of the financial institutions and break the vicious circle of banking debt and sovereign debt.
The Euro Summit in June, as you will remember, also opened the way for the Central European Bank to intervene in the debt markets to stabilise the Eurozone. That is why in September it formalised the debt buying programme, the OMT, which has had a very obvious calming effect on the markets.
The Council meeting in October made progress on the June agreements by including the countries that are not part of the Euro. Some points of the supervision mechanism were clarified, and the commitment to reach an agreement before the end of the year was reaffirmed. Above all, there was discussion for the first time of a complete report on the steps needed for creating a real economic policy, a real Economic and Monetary Union.
I would like to say that Spain, as I mentioned at the start, has made an forceful contribution, because we have done so forcefully, to this debate with the joint vision contained in the letter I sent to the four Presidents and my European colleagues on 6 June, and with proposals related to banking and fiscal union that were included in separate texts I sent to the same recipients at the start of August. Their content has been reflected in the basic documents.
In addition to the above, throughout the year very significant steps have been taken to stabilise the situation in Greece. These reveal the firm will of the European Union to support Greece and thus the irreversible commitment to the existence of the single currency.
So it was that we came to this Council meeting in December, where there was agreement on a single supervisory authority. This is something, as you all know, that was unthinkable at the start of this year 2012. This Summit had two goals, basically: first, to achieve a tangible result that could be applied with respect to supervision; and second, to continue to make progress in defining future issues: banking union, fiscal union, economic union and political union.
The first goal has been achieved. The agreement on banking supervision is very good news for various reasons: first, because of its content and the progress this represents in the process of European integration; second, for the security it provides to the citizens, which is the most important, and to investors in our financial system; and third, because it demonstrates that Europeans meet the commitments we set ourselves. I believe that by now you know the key elements of the agreement, but if you are interested I will be very happy to give them to you; but I don't want to lengthen my statement here unduly. So, the first goal has been achieved.
With respect to the second goal, the definition of these future subjects - banking, fiscal, economic and political union - the conclusions are making progress with respect to what we had done so far. A new goal has been included in European policy that is very important for Spain; and that is the special attention paid by economic policy to youth unemployment.
Making progress in these four areas to which I have referred requires a new institutional framework such as that presented in the documents of the four Presidents, the Commission and the Parliament. They are very ambitious documents. The Spanish Government agrees with their proposals and, in fact, the Spanish proposals to which I referred before and which we made in the summer, have been substantially included in these documents.
The content of the report by the four Presidents includes very new elements that are key for the future of the European Union. Not all the Member States are prepared to make such profound progress at such a fast pace on integration, but others are, and you already know what the position of the Spanish government is. But what there is consensus on - and this is very important - is on completing the institutional architecture, where the key documents are the documents I have mentioned, those of the four Presidents. These proposals are being incorporated, Council meeting by Council meeting, into their Conclusions, as has been the case so far.
I would also like to say that Spain had a very special interest in establishing time-frames and this has now taken place. Today we have a roadmap.
I would only like to say that before entering the final and shortest part of my statement, that over the upcoming days the Spanish Government, as it has done with banking union and fiscal union, and as I mentioned before, is going to send to the four Presidents and my European colleagues a document with specific proposals to provide more content for the part in which we have made least progress, which is political union.
On another tack, the European Council has also for the first time since 2008 occupied itself with issues of security and defence. We have agreed the working programme for the European Council meeting of December 2013, which will deal with these subjects in detail. We have decided to strengthen the Common Security and Defence Policy instruments, which were already included in the Lisbon Treaty, and so to improve our capacity for managing crises in the light of the accumulated experience of recent years. We believe that Europe is destined to play an increasingly important role on the international scene, and should be properly prepared to do so. At the same time, I would like to stress that the pooling and sharing of security and defence capabilities could help boost some sectors of our economies and create jobs.
In short, I have tried to sum up as far as possible in a statement of these characteristics what has happened this year in the European Union and the progress that has been made. I am satisfied about how the process has advanced this year. When I arrived here, I only heard talk about fiscal discipline and austerity; today, less than a year on, there is already talk of growth and talk of a banking union; there is talk of economic union and already talk of fiscal union. And that is important.
I believe that the institutional architecture of the European Union and the Economic and Monetary Union - and many others also believe this - is still not complete. I am absolutely aware, as is everyone, that this process cannot be completed in twenty-four hours. Just consider that the Treaty of Rome dates from 1957 and there had already been an opening phase to this Treaty of Rome. But I believe that there is the goodwill to complete this institutional architecture; and that for those of us who believe in the European Union and in a space for democracy, freedom, coexistence - and also today, progress and welfare - this is something that brings us great comfort.
I am available for any questions you may have.
Q. I would like to ask you, Mr Rajoy, whether after this year you consider that the European Union has been through the worst; whether it has now passed the danger zone.
And with respect to what is happening in Spain, I would like to know about this basis for agreement between CiU and Esquerra, who are talking about progress towards their own State. How does your Government think it can stop it, that is if it wants to stop it?
President of the Government. With respect to the situation of the European Union, the worst that we can do and the worst that leaders can do is deceive themselves. There is only one thing worse, and that is trying to convince others of it.
The economic situation of the European Union today is not good. This year we are going to be in recession, and for next year 2013 there are forecasts that do not rule out that the European Union could fall back into recession, which would be a second recession. That is a piece of information that is out there and that has to be taken into account. In addition, it has to be taken into account that this is the only region in the world that is in this economic situation. So this situation is serious, and there are major countries with negative economic growth, and that affects - a great deal, as you know very well and as we all know in Spain - the way of life and welfare of very many people. So it is a very worrying issue.
Now, having said that, it is true that there are things that have improved and I have tried to sum them up in my initial presentation. I believe that simply talking about growth and jobs now is very important. Talking about European integration, banking union, fiscal union and economic union reveals, among other things, a clear commitment by the European Union to the Euro, and it is precisely the doubts about the Euro that have been behind many of the things happening in the markets over recent months and have caused so much damage to many economies in the Eurozone.
The fact that a satisfactory response has been given to the situation that Greece is suffering is very comforting. We have always supported Greece, my Government has done so and the Government of the previous President of the Government did so for reasons of solidarity. We believe that the Greeks, just like us, have to fulfil their commitments, but we believe that the European Union is based on certain principles, and one of them is solidarity.
Well, the message that has been transmitted is that the European Union supports Greece, that Greece has to do its homework, just as all the rest of us have to, but that the Euro is there and so is the European Union and the countries that make up the Union. That is a good message, because it projects security and it projects certainty.
Another good message is the decision adopted this summer by the President of the European Central Bank. The President of the European Central Bank says that if there are difficulties and he is asked, he will intervene, and this will benefit the countries and benefit all our citizens.
And then the dynamic of the European Council meetings this year has been good. I told you before, when I came here the first time as President of the Government of Spain, the great debate - and some of you undoubtedly remember it - was about the level of public deficit that Spain had to have in 2012 and 2013. That was what was being talked about. Now we also talk about this because, obviously, we cannot spend much more than we collect and that is why the Spanish people are making major efforts, but there is also talk about other things that, in my opinion, are equally or more important for the future.
On the subject of Catalonia, as far as I know, no agreement has been signed yet. What I have read worries me and, as you can understand perfectly, I can't agree with the things that are being said in this document that a national newspaper has published today, because it is far from what I think and what I believe that the immense majority of citizens think. But as I don't know if it has been concluded, if there is going to be an agreement or we are simply faced with talks that appear to end or not, I don't know. I don't want to position myself on this.
What I do want to say is that there is a priority at this time in Catalonia and in Spain as a whole, and that priority is to fight against the crisis; the priority is to grow and create jobs, so that people can work, so that government revenues increase, because people who work pay their taxes, so we can improve public services and take care of people who are going through a difficult time. That is the priority and that is what in my opinion all the governments - regional, local and central - should be dedicated to.
Of course, political stability is very important for achieving good results when it comes to fighting the crisis. I don't believe that introducing factors that generate political instability helps at all. That is my opinion and that is how I see it.
Q. Mr President of the Government, I would like to continue with the subject of Catalonia and I would like to know if you could be a little more specific on what it is that worries you in this agreement which Esquerra and CiU have reached, and we have been able to read. Is it the tax increase, or is it only the consultation…. ? What is it exactly that worries you?
With respect to the reform being undertaken by Minister Gallardón in the justice system, for the first time all the groups (judges, prosecutors and lawyers) have joined forces against this reform and have asked for your direct intervention. I would like you to give your opinion about this conflict.
President of the Government. With respect to the first subject, I have nothing to add to what I have already said. I believe, for my part, that it would not make much sense to talk about an agreement that I don't know has been concluded, nor what its specific content is. I know what I have read. Based on that, I don't know if these aspects that I have seen are or will end up becoming specific or not in an agreement, or even if such an agreement will be concluded. What I do know is the same as you; what I know, at any rate.
With respect to the second part, we are in a very difficult situation. There are many protests in Spain. We have taken decisions that affect practically all the Spanish people, practically all of them. We have been forced to raise taxes, which affects everyone, and affects you, both direct taxes and indirect taxes; we have taken measures in the area of health; we have taken measures in the area of education; we have taken measures that affect electricity companies; we have taken measures that affect the salaries of the directors of financial institutions; we have taken measures that affect the public authorities; measures that affect us, the politicians, and we have taken decisions that also affect civil servants. We have taken many decisions and some of these decisions I believe had to be taken, because reforms have to be made in the Spanish economy; others, I would not have taken if we were not in such a difficult situation.
In the case of fees, to give you just one figure, with the new fees we are going to pay 10% of the cost of the justice system, and the rest, 90% we are also all going to pay as taxpayers. In other words, 10% is going to be paid by the users and 90% by the taxpayers, whether or not they are users of the justice system. To give you just one example, in Germany people pay 43% and in the countries that form part of the European Council the average is 29%. In other words, the countries that form part of the European Council pay 29% of the justice system through fees, and we are going to pay 10%.
There are many people who are excluded from the fees: in the criminal justice system, for the first hearings at employment tribunals... there are very many. Over 70% of the matters that are in the courts are excluded from the fees.
I understand that there are people who don't like this and I can understand that it may be damaging to them. I believe that the Minister has made an effort to talk. He has the unquestionable support of the Government and his President of the Government, but I insist, in a situation such as the one we are living in Spain now I believe that we have to make an effort and I believe that it must be an effort by all of us. I understand that people may feel annoyed and that they don't like some things. We don't do them, many of them, because we like to, but I believe that it is a sound and balanced decision.
Q. I would like to know whether the Government has already rejected this European fund that aimed, among other things, to help pay the cost of unemployment for the countries with problems.
And second, Europe has already said on a number of occasions that it is ready to help Spain in case it needs it, referring to the bailout. Can Spain now bear these levels of debt? Have you taken into account the effect that the possible return of Berlusconi could have on our interest payments?
President of the Government. With respect to the question of the bailout, my position is the one you already know. It is an instrument that the European Central Bank, Mr Draghi and the people who form the decision-making bodies in the Central Bank have made available for countries; and as this provision is there, the Spanish Government is of course not going to reject it or say that it will not use it at any time. In other words, just as at a certain time we asked for help for the financial institutions with the aim of recovering credit, restoring their health and to ensure there was no doubt left on this issue, if we consider it is necessary, convenient and in the interests of all the Spanish people to ask for it, we will do so. Until now, we have not considered it necessary and so we won't do so.
With respect to the second question, frankly we have to worry about what we have to do. It's true there are things that can influence us from outside, but what we should be concerned about, and what the Government of Spain aims to do, is to reduce the public deficit. So I'm telling you, we can't spend what we don't have, because then you have to borrow it and it's difficult to get. You already know that there are many local and regional governments in Spain that can't access the markets, and so they can't finance themselves. That is why the central government has had to support many regional governments that are in this situation.
We have to make structural reforms and we have to create a more competitive economy. That is what we have to be concerned about. There are things that are improving: the export sector is improving a great deal. Next year our foreign balance is going to be in surplus, and that is fantastic, because that has never happened. And today we have a trade balance that is already positive with the Eurozone; in other words, we sell them more than they sell us.
These are positive facts, which show that there are things that are being done well; that we are gaining in competiveness and that we have companies that are sustaining an economy which, without a doubt, will emerge from and overcome this situation.
So that is what is important to me. And then the European process is also important for me for two reasons: first, because I firmly believe in Europe, on principle; but also because I believe that some of the things that are happening with the risk premium are due to doubts, which are increasingly being dispelled and which, in my opinion, are already mostly dissipated as a result of some of the decisions that I have mentioned, which have to do with the irreversibility of the Euro itself.
Q. Mr President of the Government, you have twice mentioned compliance with the deficit target. It is a priority of the Government, but I would like to know if we are still going to comply with the targets set or are we going to try to negotiate in this respect.
And on the domestic front, you have asked with respect to Catalonia that they should focus on priorities and on what is important. Is Mr Artur Mas focusing on priorities and what is important, or is he in your opinion making a mistaken reading of what the ballot results told him?
President of the Government. With respect to the second question, I don't want to be rude, but I have already said everything I had to say.
With respect to the first, it is an obligation to correct the deficit, because we are members of a club in which the rules have to be followed. But as well as being an obligation, it is essential for Spain today if we want to grow and if we want to generate employment. In addition, not doing so could lead us to a situation into which some other public administrations have fallen, as I said before in one of my answers.
Everyone knows that. It is true that it is difficult to reach an agreement on whether I reduce this, or reduce that, whether I raise this tax or not... There are all kinds of opinions on that. There are those who say that we should have reduced the deficit with more spending and not have raised taxes, and there are those who say that we should have raised taxes more, and reduced spending less. There are opinions for everyone on this.
What I say is that the Government has taken balanced and fair decisions, because it has dealt with spending, it has dealt with revenues, and it has also affected many people; in other words, both people in a difficult situation and people in a better situation. But with all the decisions we have taken, in the end we have always aimed to take care of the people who are in the most difficult situation. For example, pensions. We raised pensions 2% for those who earn less than a thousand euros and for those who earn more than a thousand euros we raised them 1%. Income tax? We raised it by seven points for those who earn most; for those who earn very little, the rise was zero; starting from there, zero, half and one point. In other words, we have tried to be fair when it comes to sharing the efforts and sacrifices that, I repeat have to be made. Given this starting point, that is our goal.
Above all, there is one thing I have to tell you: The European Commission has said that it does not have to ask Spain for more in the years 2102 and 2013 when it comes to reducing the public deficit. That means that the European Commission understands that the Spanish people and their government have made a major effort. They ask for clarification and more specific data with respect to 2014, and we will do that when the time comes; but this is positive news. We will see what the deficit is when we calculate the budget execution of all the levels of government.
Q. Mr President of the Government, when you say that "Spain does not need an intervention at the moment", could you clarify for us what the threshold would be when this could be necessary, or are you simply referring to losing access to the markets?
President of the Government. Spain is not going to lose access to the markets. It has never lost it, and in fact the last bond auctions… Yesterday there was one, and what is more, they were 3-year, 5-year and 28-year bonds, I seem to remember, and they went very well. So Spain is not going to have any problem in accessing the markets.
With respect to what I can be specific on, I can't be more specific. When and if it is in the general interests of the Spanish people. And if not, then no. It is a possibility that is out there and that the Spanish Government can use or not. The decision will be based on the general interest. So far, it has not seemed a good idea for us to do so, but it is possible that it may appear a good idea to do so in the future - or not. We'll see.
Q. Mr President of the Government, with respect to the Minister of Education, after the presentation by the Minister of the draft Education Bill, given the opposition this has generated, what is your opinion of the opposition it has generated and, at the same time, are you planning to replace the Minister at the Ministry?
President of the Government. With respect to the second question, I can tell you with the utmost clarity, no. And I am not going to give you any other opinion on that.
With respect to the first question, I will tell you one thing. One of the common topics doing the rounds at the moment is that each new government creates a new educational model. That is what people say, we have all heard it and very often we have heard people talk about it. I tell you now that in Spain, there has only been one educational model since Franco's: that of the Socialist Party. The Partido Popular approved an Education Law and as soon as the Socialist Party came to power it repealed it with its majority.
So in a situation such as this, with the school dropout rate we have in Spain, with the cases of school failure we have in Spain and with the results of the PISA report, the very least a responsible government can do is to try to improve the quality of education: and that is what we have done. It is true that there are people who are not in favour, just as there were many people who were not in favour when the previous model was created. That is open to opinion. What is not open to opinion are the results of the previous model; they are not open to opinion, because they are objective facts. So we are going to make an effort to improve the quality of education.
With respect to the issue of language, we have offered... On this question the Minister for Education has talked with absolutely everyone. The fact is that of course there are people who it is easier to talk with, there are people who are more willing to reach an agreement and then there are people for whom discussion means you have to accept what they say or nothing changes. It is very difficult to do things in that situation.
There has been a lot of discussion, there will continue to be so, and on the subject of education we are prepared to look for a formula that allows people to exercise their individual rights. But all these things about acting against a language are absolutely false; absolutely. We are very proud of all the languages there are in our country and we want everyone to know them, understand them and be able to communicate with them; but we also want this to happen with the language that is common to all, and above all for there to be a respect for people's individual rights.
So based on that, we are fully prepared for dialogue; but dialogue also implies trying to find solutions and not saying that everything has to remain as it is, because that is not being serious.
Before I conclude, I would like to return to a previous question that I did not answer. I was asked about the unemployment fund or something like that. I forgot to answer, as there were a number of questions. Well yes, yesterday I saw that it was said that I had had a discussion... And I did not have any discussion; nor did anyone say a word about this issue. But what I can tell you is that yesterday three presidents had a meeting and we presented an amendment that was not in the planned conclusions; and it was accepted. The amendment established the possibility of introducing agreements for competitiveness and growth; in other words, it provides support for structural reforms, which is strengthened with mechanisms of solidarity.
So what we are talking about is the start of what is called a fiscal capacity; in other words, a European fund that provides incentives for structural reforms of any kind: unemployment, R&D+i or anything else. So a way is being opened up here that I consider is very important for growth, for competitiveness and for solidarity between all the Europeans.
That was not in the draft conclusions, but now it is and so we are going to continue working, as we have until now, on the basis that the decisions in Europe… Many of you here are people who already have a wide experience and know that decisions are not taken in twenty-four hours. Let me recall the exemplary case of the Euro: the requirements for entry had to be complied with in 1999 and we began to pay using Euros on 1 January three years later, in 2002.
Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much for being here, for your questions and for your attention. Thank you.