Press conference by the President of the Government after the European Council meeting

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

21 May 2013 · Press conference after the European Council meeting

Context
Rajoy addressed press following the May 2013 European Council meeting in Brussels, reporting on energy market integration and anti-tax fraud measures.
Main themes
European Council meeting outcomes, energy market integration, tax fraud and tax evasion, automatic exchange of tax information, economic growth and employment, electricity interconnection, Savings Tax Directive, Spanish tax asset declaration, EU economic integration, competitiveness and industrial policy
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,271
88th percentile
Sentences
209
90th percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
10.0
21st percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
1.88
2nd percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

209 sentences in 82 paragraphs

President of the Government . Ladies and gentlemen, a very good afternoon and thank you all for coming.

As you know, I am here to inform you about the results from the European Council meeting held earlier today under a new format that focuses on specific issues to foster growth and employment in Europe. Today's European Council meeting will be followed by others: in October to examine innovation and the digital agenda; in December to examine defence issues; and in February to examine issues related to competitiveness and industrial policy.

This meeting was therefore about promoting the reforms needed by Europe to make progress on the integration of our economies and thereby help economic recovery.

We made progress in terms of both energy issues and the efforts to combat tax fraud. I think, therefore, that the overall result has been positive.

As regards energy, the Member States made a clear commitment to urgently complete a true internal energy market in 2014 based on the Action Plan from the European Commission. This is a fundamental issue for guaranteeing that energy - of essential importance to business - can enable improved competitiveness for our economies and thereby contribute to growth and job creation, completing the efforts that many countries, such as Spain, are already making.

We reaffirmed our commitment to ending the isolation of all Member States with regard to European gas and electricity networks in 2015. More specifically, the conclusions state that the minimum level of electricity interconnection between two Member States will be set at 100% of production capacity. This followed a proposal that I put forward myself.

As regards the efforts to combat tax fraud and tax evasion, I would like to point out that Spain considers them to be of the utmost importance. Spain is fully committed to the fight against tax fraud and tax evasion. Every European government is asking for sizeable efforts from their citizens and so I believe taking firm steps against tax fraud and tax evasion to be an ethical demand in response.

In the last year, as you know, Spain has adopted numerous measures domestically to combat fraud and we have actively participated in all international forums that act against tax havens. More specifically, we have recently introduced - and I will now give you some figures that were released only a short time ago - an obligation to declare all assets and rights held overseas. In other words, all registered taxpayers in Spain have an obligation to declare the assets and rights they own abroad so that the Spanish Tax Office can have a better idea of the tax bases. The information required includes the value of property owned outside of Spain and shares, provided their value exceeds fifty thousand euros.

I am now in a position, as I said before, to give you some figures on the results obtained thanks to this initiative.

The number of taxpayers, in other words, residents of Spain for tax purposes, who have declared income or any other type of asset held overseas stands at 131,411. The majority of these taxpayers are individuals; 129,925 to be precise. The rest - 1,486 - are legal entities. These taxpayers have declared assets worth almost 87.7 billion euros, in other words, 9% of the Spanish Gross Domestic Product. Of that figure, once again, the majority corresponds to individuals - 76.5% to be precise. More than 67.1 billion euros have been declared by fiscal residents in Spain who own assets overseas and the rest, 20.59 billion euros, have been declared by legal entities.

As you can see, these are very significant numbers - 9% of GDP - and given that non-compliance is subject to serious penalties, it is a measure with a very direct effect on putting an end to fraud.

This information has been added to the databases kept by the Spanish Tax Office and provides the government with much more precise information while improving tax collection effectiveness.

This European Council meeting adopted measures along the same line of providing important information with regard to the detection of tax fraud:

Firstly, we focused on promoting and extending the scope of application for the automatic exchange of information. In particular, the Council called for the Savings Tax Directive review to be approved before the end of the year. This review will enable tax revenue to be increased because it broadens the scope of both the types of savings and the taxpayers affected by the regulations and also because it will improve the exchange of information between Member States.

We also adopted an agreement to change the current Directive on Administrative Cooperation in order to extend the automatic exchange of tax-related information to include all kinds of income. The Commission will present a proposal to that end in June. This important decision - and it is important - in the fight against fraud was reached thanks to the initiative taken by Spain, Germany, the United Kingdom, France and Italy to establish standards for the multilateral exchange of tax-related information.

All this means there will be an automatic exchange of information of a universal nature because it will affect taxpayers and, at the same time, all the forms of income of those taxpayers, whether they be savings, dividends, real estate assets, etc.

The initial promoters of the initiative that I just listed have since been joined by many other Member States and, with that, the European Union is going to make life harder for tax evaders, which in turn will also enable them to adopt a leading position globally that I hope will produce results at the next multilateral summits, especially the G-8 and the G-20.

Finally, this European Council meeting took important steps on achieving progress in the fight against VAT fraud, with a view to approving relevant directives before the end of June 2013.

Ladies and gentlemen, I will now take your questions.

Q. Mr. President of the Government, I would like to ask you about the interview yesterday with former President of the Government, José María Aznar. I would like to know whether you saw the interview and what you thought of the statements by the former President of the Government in which he does not discard the idea of returning to front-line politics.

I also wanted to ask whether you think that statements such as those he made yesterday damage or destabilise the Partido Popul ar at this time.

President of the Government. As a general rule, as you know, I never comment on the opinions of former Presidents of the Government; and I do not intend to start now.

Q. Mr. President of the Government, but Mr. Aznar is Honorary President of your party. I would like to know where you think that interview came from, an interview in which many people consider he demonstrated considerable disloyalty towards you, someone he chose to be his successor. Do you think he might be upset because he thinks you failed to defend him with regard to the "Gürtel affair" and the "Bárcenas affair"?

President of the Government. As I told your colleague, you are not going to steer me towards any comment or any controversy with anyone who has held the post of President of the Government, and much less so with former President of the Government Aznar.

Q. Mr. President of the Government, I would like to repeat the question from my colleague about whether or not your saw the interview, which you were asked directly.

I would also like to ask you about your course in economic terms, in terms of economic policy. Are you going to maintain, Mr. President of the Government, the same pace and scope in your economic policy?

President of the Government. Yes, I am. We inherited a very complicated and very difficult situation, and we set major objectives; those major objectives are job creation, for which we need economic growth, and improved well-being for the people. It's all the same: job creation, economic growth and improved well-being for the people.

If we are capable of growing, it will be because there is activity; which means there will be jobs; if there are jobs then people will be able to pay taxes, which the government will collect more in revenue and services will improve. That is our main objective.

Now, to achieve that, we have had to put an end to the serious imbalances in the Spanish economy, i.e. the public deficit, inflation, the foreign trade deficit, foreign debt and the situation in the financial system. Those were the five imbalances.

We have worked very hard. I am fully aware that we have taken decisions that certain people liked and others disliked; some people like certain decisions and other people like other decisions. It is perfectly understandable for people to have an opinion about these decisions and, moreover, people are doing the right thing by expressing their opinion and saying what they like.

We have had to take decisions on taxes and on spending cuts; but we have already started to correct those imbalances: we have begun to correct the public deficit, inflation is already at 1.4% and will be at 1% this year, i.e. prices will go up by 1%; this is very positive for the future of the Spanish economy. The foreign sector is performing very well, growing. According to the latest figures, we are the only country in Europe that has improved its exports in the last month; meaning that another important imbalance is going to disappear. Our foreign debt - because our country as a whole owes a lot of money overseas - is being reduced. And the restructuring of the banking sector has started.

Now, the positive effects can already be seen: the risk premium... Last year, we were discussing whether or not we would be asking for a bailout. You used to always be asking me that, do you remember? This time last year, we were paying 7% whenever we issued 10-year bonds and now we are paying 4%. That has also enabled large corporations to access finance. We are also financing ourselves at a much cheaper rate in terms of shorter term bonds. So that is a very important step.

Inflation, as I said, is very positive. And we have overcome the financial crisis, which was another of our serious problems last year.

So there are good things to be said. Having said that, we have not yet reached the final goal, which is economic growth and job creation; but we are on a clear path and that course must be maintained. I am absolutely convinced that course will lead us out of the crisis and into economic recovery in our country.

We are on the path to economic recovery and so I am not about to change the policy because, if I changed the policy, I would be tricking the people of Spain, because I am doing with my government exactly what we believe needs to be done.

Q. If you will allow me to insist, I would like to ask you whether...

President of the Government. You can insist all you like.

Q. ...you believe that Mr. Aznar was disloyal towards you and your party.

President of the Government. On that issue, as you are fully aware after what I just said, everything I had to say and everything I should say has already been said. My duty at this time, and for this I was chosen by the people of Spain, is to govern, to take decisions and to help this country out of the very difficult situation it was in and is still in today.

We have lived through five years of economic crisis, a long time; but I believe we are now taking steps in the right direction and some people like certain things while other people like others. If you come to a debate in the national Parliament, you will quickly see that there are many people who do not share my opinions. Many of you here do not share many of my opinions either; others of you do but I don't know whether you say so or not. In any case, the government is absolutely convinced that it is doing what needs to be done and that we are going to overcome this situation. That is what a President of the Government is supposed to do.

Q. If you don't want to argue with former President of the Government Aznar, I would ask you to send a message to your voters and party members, who may have felt confused yesterday when an important member of their party was saying that the party lacks clear direction. A message to your voters and party members to say that you have a clear direction to defend that line.

Also, were you able to take this opportunity to meet with Chancellor Merkel and discuss any issues of importance? It seems that the Germans are asking you, Spain, to ask for more than those 100 billion euros made available to the banks. Is that any chance that might happen? Are you in talks with Germany? Are you considering such action?

President of the Government. They would never ask me to do that. They might, perhaps, ask me the opposite. They have never asked me to ask for more than the 40 billion, I can assure you of that. Not that they have asked me the opposite either, but if they were to ask me anything, I know what they would ask.

Having said that, there are things it could be used for, naturally, for what certain political leaders in Spain are saying, don't you think? Because, obviously, I too would like what certain political leaders in Spain are saying; but in reality, that is like asking for something similar to a bailout, with a new macroeconomic plan.

That money, which is a loan, is for the restructuring of the financial system. True, it is a loan subject to certain excellent conditions - 10 years interest free, at a rate of 0.5% for 15 years. That is what is enabling us to do what we are doing with the process to restructure the banking sector. We have had to nationalise three financial entities in Spain, including one of the largest - Bankia - but also Caixa Catalunya and the merger of the two Galician savings banks. At this moment in time, we have no plans to ask for any more, which in any case could not be used for anything other than restructuring the financial system.

I think those 40 billion will be sufficient for the financial system. I want to remind you that Spain carried out an audit on its financial system; something that no other country in the world has done. That exercise in transparency by the Spanish financial sector, which provides security at the end of the day, was not undertaken by any other country in the world, with international assessors and with involvement from the European Central Bank, the European Commission and the International Monetary Fund.

That is why this operation - the restructuring - is difficult, complicated; but we are convinced we will get it done and the main objective is for credit to flow soon, for the small- and medium-sized enterprises above all, which are experiencing great difficulty and which are essential for economic recovery.

As regards the other issue, really, you understand me perfectly, Mr. Cue. I have already said everything I have to say. I need to concern myself with what I need to concern myself with.

Q. For the third time, I would like to ask you...

President of the Government. If it's for the third time... At least start differently - not by saying 'for the third time'.

Q. I would like to ask you about the macroeconomic imbalances that you mentioned. You said that the situation has improved a lot, but the report on which the European Commission is going to base its decision in a week on possible disciplinary action, is based on a snapshot taken at the end of 2012, when Spain was failing on six of the 11 indicators...

President of the Government . You mean 2011.

Q. Exactly, 2011. I would like to know whether Spain is confident, whether the government is confident, it can avoid such disciplinary action and whether we are going to see any more measures in the next few days, whether any of the promises in the National Reform Plan will be further defined or whether a timeline will be defined, which is what Brussels is asking for.

I also wanted to repeat a question that was left hanging; have you had a chance to see yesterday's interview?

President of the Government. As regards the question, you have explained it very well yourself. To see the details of any possible proceedings of that nature, which have not begun until now, as you are aware, the data from previous years are used, hence we are looking at the data from December 2011. However, since then, many of those imbalances have improved.

For example, the public deficit has clearly improved: it was 9% but is now 7%, and we must continue making efforts to improve it further.

Inflation has improved greatly and this is very positive because it helps our competitiveness enormously. I can tell you that I believe inflation this year will stand at 1%, unless oil behaves in a way we are not expecting it to behave.

The foreign sector is performing very well; I repeat, very well indeed. The other day - you are from "La Vanguardia" - I was in Barcelona for the Motor Show and they are very happy. Exports are up. I believe our current account balance will post a surplus this year. We already have a surplus, and this has been the case for several months now, with the European Union and you would have to go back to 1970, more or less, to find the last positive figure from our trade balance. Therefore, that is another imbalance that is on the path to correction.

What is not going well? Unemployment, obviously; but that, as I said in my speech before, is the end of the entire process. To return to growth and job creation is no easy task; decisions need to be taken first, we need to be patient. These things take time. And that is an imbalance of which we are clearly aware.

And then the public debt. However, we are still at a level of public debt that cannot be compared with that of other countries in the Union. Our case is that we have a very sizeable public deficit and that later translates into public debt. In Spain, we have implemented a Supplier Plan and that translates into public debt; but in reality it was a debt - that was a trade debt. So, we are trying to tidy up all the accounts of all the public administration services because by keeping invoices in a drawer, they don't officially exist, but in practice they do exist and, at the end of the day, they need to be paid. Therefore, that led to a small increase in public debt.

In reality, those are the only imbalances we have; improvements are being made in all the others and that is the prologue to recovery.

And as regards the other question, I am convinced you will ask me for a fourth time now; so, let's just leave it there.

Q. Seeing how you said that you didn't want me to start with "for the third time", I will start with "for the fourth time".

President of the Government. See?

Q. Did you see the interview? What did you think?

Also, Mr. Aznar quoted a figure: that he spent 10% of his salary on paying rent at Moncloa. Do you do the same?

President of the Government. I think I have already said everything I have to say on this issue. In other words, I will now ask you to not ask me the same thing again, even if you do so in a different way.

Q. You have said we are not going to need more than those 40 billion to recapitalise the banks; I suppose you are referring to the money from the ESM. Does that means that the banks are not going to need more money or that, if more money is needed, it would not come from the ESM?

President of the Government. The latter: that, in the event that it were needed, I do not think it would need to come from the ESM. If there was a need to make any provisions, I think it could easily be done by turning to the markets.

In any event, we are talking about very minor amounts. That is a decision to be taken, as you know, by the Bank of Spain, not the government; but we are talking about very minor amounts. I am in no way concerned by this issue.

What I am concerned about, and I think this is the challenge we will have to tackle in the future, is the issue of credit to small- and medium-sized enterprises, the issue of youth employment and the issue of improving consumption in Spain. Precisely now, in June, I think there is an important meeting of the Council; a meeting of the Council, in June, at which decisions should be taken. We are going to be very active and we have already spoken with a number of other countries on coming up with a real Youth Employment Plan; in other words, one that will do things right and get things done. We also want substantial progress to be made in June on the issue of banking union.

Europe, I am reminded of this more and more, is moving in the right direction but is not travelling as fast as some of us would like.

Q. Mr. President of the Government, if you will allow me, I am going to insist, not on the question about yesterday's interview with Mr. Aznar but about the question from my colleague about the macroeconomic imbalances. The European Commission will make an announcement next Wednesday; there was backing from the Eurogroup but it was not entirely resounding. I wonder whether you are expecting Brussels to ask for more measures than those already presented in the latest Reform Plan at the end of April.

Also, I would like to know about that appointment you have on Tuesday in Paris -what are the objectives and what is it we can expect?

President of the Government . I think that the European Commission has taken a decision that shows the facts have been considered carefully. I think that a smart move was made when it was said: "listen, rather than go for a public deficit of 4.5% in 2013, go for a public deficit of 6.3%". That was a very good move.

While in recession, we lowered it from 9% to 7% in 2012, and that was very tough - you all know that as well as I do. There were cutbacks in spending and we also needed to raise taxes, and that was very tough and painful on the people.

I think that the Commission has taken a fair and balanced decision this time, with a country that is making a great effort. That is what will enable us this year not to have to raise the most important taxes and make smaller cutbacks in spending, and focus on what I told you before: the issue of credit, consumption and youth employment; growth, at the end of the day, which is what matters most.

Furthermore, we have presented our National Reform Plan. We have implemented a large number of reforms, as you know; but the most important is the Budgetary Stability Act, which is a highly significant structural reform. I always insist: it is probably the most important structural reform to have been made, because it affects the way the State model works at its core. But then there was the labour reform, the restructuring of the financial system and other decisions, which will be followed by more decisions, in the energy sector. You know there was a very serious problem: a tariff deficit of twenty-something billion euros.

And now we are going to continue with the Reform Plan, because I said so during the Investiture Debate: this legislature will consist of a constant process of reform.

This Friday, we will approve the Entrepreneur Act; last Friday, we approved the Education Act. There is another very important issue - that of the public administration services. I hope that the report we have commissioned, on which they have been working for various months, can be delivered in June. And then we have the Market Unity Act. I am unaware whether it has been submitted to Parliament yet or whether it is still being examined by the consultation bodies.

In other words, there are many reforms. Can they ask us for any more? I'm not sure about that. I think that everything reasonable, everything sensible, has already been done or is under way. Many things can be said about the government and, as you know, are said about the government; but nobody can deny that this government is taking decisions, is implementing structural reforms and is adopting many measures that we know are not popular with many people.

Ladies and gentlemen, if you don't mind, I have to leave now because I am travelling again. Thank you.