Press conference by the President of the French Republic and the President of the Government of Spain
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed a joint press conference with French President Hollande in Paris on 27 May 2013, ahead of the June European Council meeting on employment and growth.
- Main themes
- Youth unemployment, European economic recovery, SME financing, European Investment Bank, growth pact, European Council June 2013, fiscal consolidation, job creation, Franco-Spanish cooperation, European recession
- Duration
- ~29 min
- Words
- 3,487
- Sentences
- 144
- Readability
- 54
- Grade
- 11.5
- Syntax
- 3.09
- Vocabulary
- 1.96
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
144 sentences in 54 paragraphs
This has been a useful day for Europe because, at the gathering this morning and afternoon, during the course of which Mariano Rajoy gave a speech, there was a broad convergence of opinion among the Heads of State and ministers who expressed and highlighted the challenges to be faced as we continue to build Europe. Since a year ago, we have been capable of taking decisions - mainly last June - to bring stability to Europe, implement a growth pact and define tools, and now - this year - for the Council meeting in June, we must show the same strength regarding our proposals for employment. There is broad consensus on this issue.
This morning, here also, I received the German Finance Minister, Walter Schauble; the German Employment Minister; the Italian Employment Minister; and I will receive Chancellor Angela Merkel on Thursday. We will make a proposal that will focus on the issues discussed this afternoon with Mariano Rajoy.
Firstly, to do everything possible to create jobs for young people and even bring forward certain measures in the European budget, i.e. a six-billion euro plan to foster training, insertion and mobility for young people. If we can use part of that amount immediately and then charge it to the budget in coming years, I think it could be a good formula for youth employment.
Secondly, to do everything possible to enable companies - because they are the creators of employment - to finance themselves better and, to that end, mobilise the funds from the European Investment Bank so it can issue guarantees, offer direct loans, support the accounts of those companies as well as certain investment projects to generate activity and employment faster than we can at the moment.
And, finally, ensure that States - which must make efforts to stabilise their public accounts - can have more time because Europe has been in recession for two years and there is every reason to continue controlling public expenditure but we must also avoid supplementary taxes that would continue to affect demand and weaken any chances for stronger growth or even recovery itself.
Those are the issues we have reached an agreement on with the President of the Government of Spain. I will receive the Chancellor on Thursday, we will also meet with the European Commission and the President Van Rompuy, and, during the European Council meeting, we will need to take decisions on employment, on financing, on the EIB and on all those issues that could help growth.
Later on, in early June, all the Labour and Employment Ministers will hold a meeting. The German Chancellor made that proposal, a proposal that I accepted, and we will meet on 3 June in Berlin.
There is no time to lose. We know the schedule, Europe has already emerged from the financial crisis and must now emerge from the crisis.
President of the Government. Thank you very much, Mr. President. Ladies and gentlemen, a very good afternoon to you. I would like to begin these brief words by thanking President Hollande once again for such a warm and friendly welcome, as always. He has already given a good explanation of the content of our meeting today, he has explained there was agreement on what are basically the fundamental issues and also explained the context in which this meeting took place - ahead of a European Council meeting at the end of June, which we all hope will be useful for resolving the real and tangible problems of the people in all our countries.
I would like to start with a quick reminder. Europe has been in recession for six consecutive quarters and Europe is the only region in the world - the only region - with no economic growth. In fact, the situation is quite the opposite; what we have in Europe is negative economic growth.
Now that the financial crisis has been resolved, as President Hollande reminded us in his speech, we believe now is the time to adopt decisions that the people will perceive as decisions with an effect on their lives.
We are all making significant efforts domestically; they are mainly being made by the people. All political leaders have had to take some tough, difficult and complicated decisions, and we believe that Europe itself must also take a step forward in the right direction.
Looking forward to the European Council meeting in June - credit, making life easier for small- and medium-sized enterprises - which are responsible for getting a country moving again and creating jobs through investment, hard work and effort - and resolving the very serious youth unemployment problem to offer opportunities to many young people who cannot work in spite of a desire to do so. These must be the main objectives.
What I told President Hollande and what I will tell the Commission, Mr. Van Rompuy, and other European leaders over the weeks ahead is the following:
We want the European Investment Bank, which has currently earmarked 10 billion euros to finance SMEs, to increase that figure to 30 billion euros. This will produce the immediate and knock-on effects we want, but we want those 10 billion to be increased to 30 billion.
Secondly, we want the European Investment Bank to guarantee the loan portfolios of SMEs - and it can do so - because that will undoubtedly lead to an improved "rating" and an increased volume of credit for small- and medium-sized enterprises.
And finally, we also want the European Investment Bank to guarantee the export and internationalisation activity of our companies.
We believe that the EIB can play a much more active, much more decisive and much clearer role in the support given to small- and medium-sized enterprises; we believe consensus can be reached on this issue between the various European countries and, naturally, this is a position that Spain will defend at the meetings towards the end of June.
I would also like to remind you that, not long ago, the President of the European Central Bank, Mr. Draghi, spoke about the financing problems of our small- and medium-sized enterprises, and that he supported the start of inter-institutional dialogue to tackle the SME credit crunch problems. Personally, I was pleased to hear that. I thought it was a statement well worth bearing in mind and I think it is important now for the European Central Bank to go ahead with the intention expressed at the time by Mr. Draghi.
As regards youth employment, there are two fundamental issues that are very specific and that I would like to comment on at this point.
The first has already been mentioned by President Hollande in his speech. A figure of six billion has been agreed upon in the budget - yet to be approved by the European Parliament - for the period 2014-2020; six billion in seven years. We would like it to be possible for that money to be used even before 1 January 2014 because of the urgent situation at the present time. Again, we would like to be about to use that money to tackle one of the most important problems in many European countries, Spain in particular: youth unemployment.
Secondly, Spain will also suggest that the discounts that can be applied to social security contributions for the hiring of young people not be counted or penalised in the excessive deficit procedures. This would be a temporary measure but would have an essential objective: to say that, for however long is decided, all those discounts that countries may apply to social security contributions for the hiring of young people will not be counted for penalty purposes in the excessive deficit procedure.
These are the most important issues we discussed and I would also like to say that we all hope the next European Council meeting in June will make clear and understandable progress on banking union, that the commitments made at the European Council last June are met and that the goal of fiscal union, greater economic union and political union is never lost from the minds of European leaders or institutions.
I hope that progress can be made on this issue at the next European Council meeting but, I repeat, the most pressing issue at this time is to offer support to small- and medium-sized enterprises, the recovery of credit and the response to youth unemployment.
Q. For both of you. There has been talk today of a 60 billion plan to combat youth unemployment. When might that plan be launched? How well defined is it at the moment? When might it reach the people? What can France do for Spain in this regard? Where would the money for that plan be taken from? Would countries, Spain specifically, be asked to implement more labour reforms, a change to unemployment benefits? Will anything else need to be sacrificed?
And now for President of the Government Rajoy specifically. The deficit figures in Spain are quite bad at the moment, worse than last year. This makes us think that more cutbacks will be needed, more tax rises, more reforms... How do you intend to meet the target?
Mr. Hollande. Six billion have been earmarked by the Heads of State and Government for the next European Budget. That's six billion euros, six billion for the period 2014-2020, as Mr. Rajoy said just now, and for the regions with an unemployment rate of more than 25% of those under 25. If we wait much longer and if that figure needs to be spread over five years, it will have little impact.
What we are suggesting is to bring that forward, perhaps even before the European Parliament has adopted the Financial Framework - it will do so in a totally sovereign manner in a few days or a few weeks -; once that is done, the Member States could bring forward the application of said plan, meaning that measures could start to be taken to boost youth employment from the autumn and the corresponding finance could be sought next year. The Member States would bring forward the spending, to put it one way. There would be no conditions applied except that it would only be available to those regions with an unemployment rate in excess of 25% among young people. Unfortunately, Spain meets that condition and several parts of France also do.
That is basically the idea, as well as what Mariano Rajoy has added; the ability to deduct the amounts that would be committed by Member States and the European plan from the public deficit calculations for the European Union recommendations. And we will lay this all out at the next meeting of the Council.
President of the Government. I think President Hollande has pretty much answered the first of those questions. I would just add that what the European Investment Bank can do and what the European Central Bank can do is very important. The other proposals are those that I mentioned in my introduction.
As regards the public deficit for this year, those are only partial figures; in other words, those figures cannot yet be used to make a definitive assessment of how the situation will progress. That said, what I do want to say - and I said this the other day to the presidents in my party and I will say it to all the institutions - is that our commitment to the public deficit is a commitment we have to meet above all else.
From what we have heard, I think that the European Commission is pointing to the adoption of a smarter, more flexible measure to seek a more gentle deficit path through this difficult situation; but I think we should all be very clear that if we want to grow and create jobs, we need to have healthy public accounts as well as adopt the measures we are talking about today.
Therefore, the government will, as it did last year and, I'm sure, as did the regional governments and local authorities last year, make the utmost effort to meet the deficit targets. I repeat, this is not a whim; this is being done because it is good for the economy, this is good for sustained and stable growth and this is good for creating jobs, regardless of there undoubtedly being other measures that are also necessary, such as those we have just explained.
Q. Mr. Rajoy, François Hollande presented a Franco-German plan of action on youth employment this morning. Spain and Greece are the two countries most affected by this problem. Do you regret not being directly associated with this initiative?
Mr. Hollande, some people are saying that the six billion euros contained in the draft European Budget are simply a drop in the ocean. Should we be thinking about raising that figure?
President of the Government. Would I have liked to have been in the Youth Employment Plan you are referring to? I can say that Spain is presenting its proposals, that I am here speaking with the President of the Republic of France and that I will speak with other people who will also sit around the table at the European Council meeting in June. To be precise, next week we will be at the Commission, I will also speak with Mr. Van Rompuy and with other presidents tomorrow; however, what did please me from what I heard today is that President Hollande and I agree on the fundamental positions we will all adopt at the next European Council meeting.
What I want is for these measures to be approved and for them to start working straight away. I have contributed some ideas and others have contributed others. Naturally, I am going to support all the measures that are useful. What I want are useful, effective and understandable measures that can be implemented right now, not measures for the centuries to come.
I think now is the time to get things done very well, to take decisions and send a clear message, because these issues of banking union and fiscal union are enormously important; but they takes time, they don't reach the people. Right now, however, we need some urgent action. We have already overcome a very important financial crisis but, I insist, Europe is still the only region of the world that is not growing and so people are asking themselves, and rightly so, why is the whole world growing except Europe? Something is not being done right.
Well, the European Council meeting in June is about answering that question. And the SME issue, the credit issue and the Youth Employment Plan issue are vitally important in my opinion, and I hope that we will all be up to the task at the Council meeting in June.
Mr. Hollande. When Germany and France do not agree, you ask questions... When France and Germany do agree, you are concerned... I despair. What matters is that France and Germany can move forward together on these issues, and others, because it is the best way to mobilise the people of Europe.
The French and German economic and financial affairs ministers and labour and employment ministers have agreed to come up with proposals to boost youth employment that, furthermore, share aspects in common with those that the President of the Government of Spain and I have just presented. That means we trust in the European Council meeting in June, provided that we create this dynamic.
I think things are moving in the right direction. Why are they moving in the right direction? Because we have overcome the financial crisis but above all because we are aware that we know today what the young people of Europe are going through: exceptionally high unemployment rates, despair, generational fracture... That is why, to combat that risk, that challenge, France and Germany have taken action, Spain and Italy too, large countries that can be affected, as others can be, by their economic situation.
But, more than hope, I am sure that the European Council meeting will produce strong proposals that will be committed to.
As regards the six billion, the issue has not even been voted on yet. What I am asking for is that it be possible to bring them forward once the European Parliament has decided and then, if the situation does not improve and the budgeted amounts have been spent, we can increase them because we have obtained flexibility within the framework of the talks surrounding the European Budget; in other words, the option to transfer amounts from one heading to another, and I think that the priority target for spending at the moment is employment.
Q. My questions are for President of the Government Rajoy, on a more domestic issue. Yesterday we saw that disagreement still exists between the various heads of regional government in the Partido Popular. Were that disagreement to continue until the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council meeting, and this is the question, would you be willing, Mr. President of the Government, to impose central government criteria even though not all parties would be pleased?
And, also on a domestic issue, what role do you think, Mr. Rajoy, should be played by former Presidents of the Government in Spain?
President of the Government. Whenever a debate arises on issues that affect the financing of the regional governments or issues such as this that are closely related to financing, there is a range of different opinions; furthermore, different opinions that have nothing to do with the ideology of the person leading the government in question, and you know that to be the case. Whenever there is a debate, for example, on a regional financing model, everyone starts looking out for number one, with one person saying "the criteria should be to distribute the money based on the number of inhabitants" and others say "not the number of inhabitants but rather on the size of the elderly population, on population dispersion...". It is always the same.
Exactly the same is happening with this now. Yesterday's meeting was a party meeting. It was not a meeting I went to as President of the Government. We had an interesting contrast of views, which was really good to see and comforting. There were arguments of all sorts and, as I expected, given that the deficit target for Spain has not yet been decided on and won't be until June, there will be a meeting of the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council after the European Council meeting, and the decision will be taken then. Meanwhile, the Ministry of the Treasury will endeavour to speak at an institutional level with all the heads of regional government, regardless of the political party to which they belong, naturally, in order to reach a solution that pleases everybody.
I can tell you now, it is impossible that everyone will like the decision that is taken, but you can't please all of the people all of the time. In other words, not once has absolutely everyone been happy with the result. However, an agreement is always reached eventually through common sense and consensus.
You ask whether we will impose a result. I have no interest whatsoever in imposing anything. What I want is for there to be the broadest consensus possible but, in the same way, I have to tell you that a distribution of the deficit between the regional governments clearly has to take place. I think we will reach an agreement in the end because people are working constructively; but please remember that the deficit target for all the regional governments was 0.7% not long ago but now we are only talking about 1.2%. Just imagine if it were still 0.7%. We would not be having this discussion but would rather have, as you can perfectly understand, an infinitely greater problem that would be 0.7%.
As regards the role of the former Presidents of the Government; frankly whichever they want to adopt. That is the role they should have, the one they want to play. The only thing I am sure of is that they want the best for their country and, naturally, if they were asked for help, I am convinced they would offer it.
Q. For President Hollande. An agreement has been reached in the case of Bernard Tapie and Crédit Lyonnais, an agreement that is being questioned today and that fell in favour of Bernard Tapie. Could the State be a civil party as suggested by certain articles in the press, articles that have not yet been rejected by the government?
Mr. Hollande. I do not have all the facts of this case, but what I can say is that I have a principle that works for any situation: the State will always defend its interests at the right time and to also access the information. That is the answer I can give you.
Thank you very much.