Press conference by the President of the Government and the Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

5 September 2012 · Press conference following a working lunch with the Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany

Context
Rajoy addressed a joint press conference with Chancellor Angela Merkel in Spain on September 5, 2012, following bilateral talks on the Eurozone crisis and EU integration.
Main themes
Spain-Germany bilateral relations, Eurozone crisis, fiscal consolidation, structural reforms, European integration, banking union, fiscal union, Economic and Monetary Union, trade and investment ties, single currency stability, European Council roadmap
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,918
85th percentile
Sentences
157
82nd percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
3.09
60th percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
6th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

157 sentences in 68 paragraphs

President of the Government . Ladies and gentlemen, a very good afternoon to you all and welcome.

It pleases me to see so many of you here today, thus showing the great interest aroused by the important and close bilateral relations between Spain and Germany, as well as the level of relations between our economies and our companies, and the situation of the European Union and the Eurozone - the most important project that unites our two countries and many millions of European citizens.

It is a pleasure to appear here before you following the working lunch held with the Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, Angela Merkel, to briefly summarise the results of our meeting.

In the first place, allow me to take this opportunity to thank Chancellor Merkel for her visit which, as you are aware, is the third bilateral meeting held this year, but the first time that she has come here to Spain since I took office as President of the Government. It pleases me to announce that we have agreed to hold the next bilateral summit in Germany in early February.

As you are all aware, our bilateral relations are particularly strong in economic and trade affairs, but also - and this is important - our peoples have real and tangible social relations, that are developed in the two countries.

As you know, and today we have had the opportunity to verify this once again, our economies are frequently interrelated and our trade, industrial and investment interests are sound. The ties between Spain and Germany foster growth and job creation in both countries and hence constitute a source of common well-being.

One result of this is the enormous interest with which companies from both countries have welcomed this Spanish-German Business Conference being held concurrently and which has gathered leading Spanish and German companies that invest in the most representative sectors of our economies.

As it should be, during our meeting today we have devoted a significant part of our time to analysing the economic situation of the European Union and of the Eurozone. I have explained to the German Chancellor the situation in Spain and the measures being implemented in accordance with our commitments as responsible European partners, but, above all, because we are convinced that this is the way in which Spain will return to a path of sustained, sustainable growth and as a creator of jobs and prosperity for all.

Spain has shown its determination and European responsibility with a strategy of far-reaching fiscal consolidation and an audacious raft of structural reforms that are unparalleled in the European Union. We have the determination and responsibility to continue down this path. Our reformist agenda, as well as being necessary for Spain and for Europe, is our hallmark. The efforts being made by this government will continue, have no doubt about that, and I welcome Germany's support for our policy of fiscal consolidation and for the extensive programme of structural reforms that my government is implementing.

As regards Europe, we exchanged points of view on the current situation and, in particular, on the Eurozone and the actions that the European Union as a whole should implement. Spain and Germany agree on the diagnosis; we have been seeing strong tension in the differentials in the Eurozone that result in the risk premiums not corresponding to economic fundamentals or to the efforts at fiscal consolidation and structural reforms being implemented.

In this respect, today we want to categorically dispel any doubts the markets may have regarding the continuity of the single currency. Spain and Germany will do everything necessary to definitively resolve the Euro crisis. Only from a comprehensive and extensive focus, with efforts from each country and at a European level, will we manage to dispel these uncertainties. In this respect, the Chancellor and I agree on the necessity to overcome the defects in the design of the Economic and Monetary Union that this crisis has brought to light.

Hence, based on the conclusions adopted at the European Council in June, we will work together to contribute with the European institutions to setting a 'road map' that allows us to make decisive progress towards a banking union and a fiscal union, as well as to extend the economic and political union.

Spain, as a firm supporter of this process, has already presented its proposals towards greater integration, which have been well received by the European institutions and about which we have had the pleasure of exchanging opinions with Chancellor Merkel.

Ladies and gentlemen, Germany is a great country, which for more than seventy years has been a cornerstone of the construction of Europe, which has enabled our continent to enjoy the longest period of peace and prosperity in its history. European integration is our great common project, both for the present and for the future.

There are no doubts surrounding the commitment and political determination of all of us to see through this project and ensure that the integrity and stability of the euro is central to this project.

In summary, the cooperation between our two great nations is the common currency on which we are building fruitful relations between Germany and Spain.

Ms. Merkel . Thank you very much. I would like to thank you for your hospitality and say that it has been a real pleasure to be here today. Indeed, this is not our first meeting, we are frequently in contact, but this is my first visit here to meet with the President of the Spanish Government, Mariano Rajoy.

Of course we have commented on the current situation, but we have spent a long time preparing this meeting. On the one hand, we exchanged points of view during the working lunch on the current situation of the Eurozone and, on the other hand, today we held the Spanish-German Business Conference, attended by important German and Spanish business leaders. That also shows what is important in our political cooperation. We want to create jobs for the future, where the German economy can help, whether in terms of professional training or joint economic activities, because that is what is truly important and what is urgently needed in Spain - for people to recover their jobs and enjoy lasting and sustained employment. That is why these reforms are not useful as such, but rather serve to restore competiveness and improve competition.

I also wanted to say that we have great respect, both me personally and the German people, for what Spain is doing at this time, for the reforms that are being implemented. The President of the Spanish Government informed me of the different steps being taken and I am impressed by the pace of the reforms and their consistency. We know from our own experience that these reforms take time before having positive effects in terms of employment.

Of course, this part of the road forward is difficult, but I am deeply convinced that the path taken is the right one, and this has been reiterated by many people in Germany and in other parts of the world.

We are committed to the defence of our common currency; that has been the spirit of our conversation. The Euro is the common currency and the Euro is also a political project. It is the realisation of the idea of a united and economically strong Europe, with an internal market, with the peaceful coexistence of its peoples who are increasingly united. And that is why we are also obliged to continue developing the European Union, and above all, cooperate within the Eurozone.

Of course, we also spoke about the next steps to be taken because, at the European Council meeting in December, we are going to have to take decisions in this regard.

Hence we have had a very intense exchange of opinions. Our time has been short and we could have continued talking. I believe that this visit may also help contribute to the continuity of the close and friendly relations between our two countries.

We have accepted the invitation to attend the Spain-Germany Summit with a whole list of ministers who will accompany me. And it gives me pleasure to speak shortly with the economic representatives to look for ways to overcome the barriers that still remain.

I believe that Germany and Spain are heading down the right path towards a Europe of the future, and that we will surely overcome the current difficulties. At least we are fiercely determined to do so.

Q . Madam Chancellor, how do you see the opinion of the Spanish Government regarding how Spain is punished by having to pay interest rates that are two percentage points higher in the markets? Do you believe that the ECB should buy up bonds? The programme has just been announced that carries the delightful name of OMT (Outright Monetary Transactions).

Ms. Merkel . I do not have the power to say how many percentage points too high or too low the interest rates are. I simply want to say that the German interest rates are very low but I know that the interest rates in other countries are much higher. Of course, apart from the competitiveness of the different countries, there are also systemic issues that may affect this.

What does this mean? It means that we must restore confidence in the Euro as a whole, in other words, that the international markets have confidence in the Member States meeting their commitments.

I have already acknowledged what the Spanish Government has done and also what it is doing at the level of the autonomous regions. This is the right thing to do.

Secondly, what we have not achieved in terms of political cooperation when we introduced the Euro will have to be done now. Our two countries are determined to make our proposals and take decisions; for example, common banking supervision, greater economic coordination in Europe and more points in common on fiscal matters. That will all be debated at the next European Council in December.

All the other measures, for example, that help the stability of the value of money, and that is what we have talked about at the ECB, cannot substitute political will. That is why it is important for us, as politicians, to do our homework and to do it in such a credible manner that the markets also recover their confidence in us

Q. I had various question. For the Chancellor, I would like to ask you if you are in favour of this buy-up of debt as announced by the President of the European Central Bank, as a short- and medium-term solution, while greater integration is being negotiated. Do you believe that Spain should request this buy-up of debt without taking on new conditions, as has been defended by the Spanish Government?

And finally, are you concerned by the increasing animosity against Germany in Spain as a result of the position being taken by the German Government in the last few weeks?

And for President of the Government Rajoy. Mario Draghi has just announced the measures that we have been waiting for expectantly during the last month. Can we now find out whether the government is going to request the purchase of sovereign debt.

And although the government has defended the fact that it doesn't want to meet new conditions, what margin of conditionality do you have? Have there been 'red lines' drawn up?

Finally, have you committed to new structural reforms with the Chancellor?

Ms. Merkel . As regards those questions addressed to me, the press conference given by Mr Draghi is taking place at the same time as our press conference.

The ECB acts within the limits of its own independence and according to its own mandate, and it is responsible for the stability of the currency, and it is the body that takes the appropriate measures. My task and our task consists of performing our political duties, among others, that the reforms that Spain has made are implemented with credibility. I cannot say more on this matter at this time.

Secondly, of course I wish for there to be a realistic image of Germany in Spain. Perhaps I can also say that this visit is precisely so that we can speak with each rather than about each other, because that is the grave danger in this difficult situation of an economic crisis and the debt crisis; that more is said about each rather than talking with each other.

I would like to say again that we really are very respectful of what is being done in Spain. For decades, Germany and Spain have maintained friendly relations, and that will long continue, not only between our governments and politicians, but also between our peoples. There are many Germans who come to spend their holidays here, to spend whole months here, and there are also many Spanish citizens who come to Germany on holiday, or to spend some time, or even to live permanently. These ties are solid and will not change.

Thirdly, I believe that we all need to understand that no country wishes to impose difficult conditions on another country for the sake of it. Why do we have to implement this kind of reform?

Because Germany also went through a time when we had five million unemployed while today we only have three million out of work. So why do we have to do this? Because, if we don't do it, we will be unable to sell our products in today's world, because each year we need to spend more than we collect, because we depend on the financial markets and thus we cannot live our lives in liberty and democracy.

When we visit China, India or Brazil, we can see there that people also want to live well, that they are also making an effort and that they now know how to do many things that they didn't know how to do 20 or 30 years ago. That is why we also need to know how to do things that others don't know how to do; we need to be innovative, produce good-quality products and sell them, because that is the only way to safeguard our prosperity. It is not a question of complicating the lives of others, it is a question of knowing whether in 20 years time Europe will continue to be a continent that the rest of the world takes seriously, that can speak about democracy, about freedom of opinion and environmental protection, or whether we will be a continent that depends on other continents.

That is what guides me in my policy-making and where I want Europe to continue being a Europe of which one can feel proud because we are doing things right and well. That is why we are working so hard, and working together, because in a world of seven billion people, 80 million Germans cannot doing anything by themselves, even though we are the largest country in Europe. It is only together, as 500 million Europeans that we can achieve anything.

President of the Government . I have been asked two questions; the first is what am I going to do. Firstly, I have not even had time to read the speech made by Mr Draghi.

At any event, the Spanish Government's priorities at this time are growth and job creation. And the priority instruments are: firstly, continue down the path of reducing the public deficit - that is our main priority; secondly, continue to make structural reforms; thirdly, restructuring the financial sector - I believe that in the coming weeks we will have news about the modifications to be proposed in the banking sector - then we need to create a 'bad bank' and at the end of October there will be aid from Europe. This is an important matter, because a good, healthy and solvent system, that does not generate doubts and which gives credit is essential for growth and job creation.

Finally, I am working hard to collaborate with the rest of our European partners in the integration of the European Union, which is undoubtedly the most resounding message that can be given about the Euro and the future of the Union.

As regards whether I am committed to making new structural reforms, the answer is no. The truth is that I haven't even thought about it, as you'd expect. Nobody proposes the structural reforms that they need to implement to their partners and allies. The only commitment that I have is to make structural reforms that I believe are good in order for Spain to provide its companies with greater flexibility and competitiveness, and to foster growth and job creation. If anything, I will take into consideration the recommendations which, in the same way as for other countries, were made by the European Council in June for the second half of the year.

Having said that, I will say something else, and that is what needs to be done. It is true that they are very difficult decisions and measures which are difficult to explain, and which many people, as you would expect, don't like. I understand that, it is logical, but, in the situation in which we find ourselves, it is what needs to be done.

Spain will start to grow in a sustainable and stable manner, and to create jobs, when we start to adjust our expenditure to our revenue, when we don't spend more than we have, and when we make reforms that generate confidence. That is the objective, that is what we have always defended in the Partido Popular and that is what we have done at other times in our past, when we took power, and I, of course, defended this at the European Councils that I have attended since I became President of the Government.

Hence, I repeat, I believe that today Spain needs to control its public accounts and it needs greater flexibility and competition in the economy. If that happens, we will start to create jobs and enjoy growth, public revenue will increase and public services will improve.

Q . Madam Chancellor, have you spoken with your Spanish counterpart about possible conditions in the event that Spain requests further aid? If you have, what might these German conditions be?

Ms. Merkel . I can only agree with what the President of the Spanish Government has just said. We have spoken about what is taking place in Spain at the moment, but we haven't spoken at all about any possible conditions. We have spoken about the clean-up of the banks, about the date on which the audit results will be published and about the funds provided for the recapitalisation of the banks.

I cannot give any other answer to this question except what Mariano Rajoy has just said a moment ago.

Q . I also had a question for each of you.

Ms Merkel has praised the reforms being implemented in Spain but they will probably not be sufficient to meet the deficit objectives. Do you believe that Spain will need to explore other avenues such as a new reform of the pension system? And do you believe that the current autonomous model that exists in Spain distorts things and that it will need to be reformed to contain costs?

For the President of the Government. At the end of July, you said that, with the data you had available, you didn't foresee any cuts in pensions. I would now ask you if you believe it will be necessary to freeze them in order to save between three and four billion euros and if you feel it would be necessary to resort to the Social Security Reserve Fund to maintain them.

Ms. Merkel . I have not come here to say what reforms Spain has to take. I have full confidence that the President of the Spanish Government has taken the necessary measures.

Of course, we have also spoken about the autonomous regions, because they form a part of Spain, in the same way as the 'lander' forms part of our country. Reforms need not only be taken at a national level; they always need to be taken at all the levels where something needs to be changed.

The President of the Government has informed me about the cooperation taking place with the autonomous regions, and it would seem to me a very close cooperation. For me it is important to have this information because sometimes, when one travels, or even in Germany, we are asked about this and actually making a trip like this fosters mutual comprehension in order to be able to discuss such things with our opposite numbers.

Coming back to the question on the image that we have of the country, it is very important that in Europe, this common continent of ours, we always highlight what others are doing. I feel that it would be very negative, especially at a time of crisis - this, of course, is human nature, because we also knew it… If times are tough, it is very easy to blame someone else, but that will not help us in Europe.

We all need to join together in Europe and discuss what is being done, and a lot more is being done now than in the last 15 or 20 years, and it is also being done much quicker. This is also a great opportunity for Europe and I firmly believe that Europe will come out of this crisis stronger.

President of the Government .- In relation to the question about pensions, the most important thing to maintain the public pension system is for there to be people in gainful employment. That is the most important thing, because pensions are paid with the contributions of those who are working at any given time and our pensions will be paid in the future by those who are contributing when we are pensioners.

So, a good part of the measures that we are implementing have a primary objective of job creation because, by creating jobs, as well as satisfying many people who obviously want to work, there are also more people paying their Social Security contributions, and hence, pensions are better guaranteed and these will be better pensions.

Hence, the main objective is to create jobs for people, for the pensioners themselves and because this means greater revenue for the State to maintain public services.

I, of course, as I have said on many occasions, said the same in the month of July, exactly the same. We have taken many decisions that have been unpopular with our people, but it seems to me that the people in the greatest difficulties, those who are unable, purely for reasons of their age, to fight in the same way as a youth of 20 years of age, are the pensioners. Hence, of course, I have no intention of changing the status quo at this time, in the same way as I didn't in the month of July.

As far as resorting to the Social Security Reserve Fund is concerned, I cannot say anything on this matter at this time, but, in the event that the Social Security Reserve Fund is used, it will be used for those provisions contained in its own internal regulations and in the legislation that created the Social Security Reserve Fund, and not for any other end.

Thank you very much.