Press conference by the President of the Government and the President of the Council of Ministers of Italy
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed a joint press conference with Italian PM Mario Monti following the 17th Spain-Italy Bilateral Summit held in Madrid on 29 October 2012.
- Main themes
- Spain-Italy bilateral relations, European economic integration, eurozone crisis and recovery, structural economic reforms, banking union and fiscal union, employment and growth, small and medium enterprises, European Council agreements, Greek programme support, political and economic union of Europe
- Duration
- ~48 min
- Words
- 5,710
- Sentences
- 208
- Readability
- 47
- Grade
- 13.5
- Syntax
- 3.26
- Vocabulary
- 2.03
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
208 sentences in 86 paragraphs
President of the Government. Ladies and gentlemen, a very good afternoon and thank you very much for attending this meeting.
It gives me great satisfaction to appear before you all to report on the results of what is already the 17th bilateral Spain-Italy Summit, held today, 29 October, here in Madrid.
The previous summit took place in Sardinia on 10 September 2009 and this time round it was Spain's turn to host one. Three years have passed since then and I believe that the quality and intensity of our bilateral relations and our common vision on the present and the future of Europe oblige us to make an effort to maintain the annual frequency of this important event.
I would like to thank the President of the Council of Ministers of the Italian Republic, Mario Monti, for his presence here today, an unequivocal sign of the will on the part of the Italian Government to continue strengthening cooperation with Spain.
Span and Italy are two countries which are partners and good friends, and evidence of that is the intense Spanish-Italian agenda of visits and bilateral meetings. This is the fourth time that we have held a bilateral meeting this year with the President of the Council of Ministers of Italy, but we have also spoken on numerous occasions when we both attended other meetings and the European Council.
Allow me to highlight for you the perfect understanding we have and offer an analysis of the common diagnosis of the situation that the Eurozone is going through, as well as the measures that should be adopted, both at a national level, at that of the Eurozone and of the European Union as a whole.
I would like to stress, once again, that our main common objective at this time is economic recovery and the creation of quality jobs in the shortest time possible, resorting to all measures necessary to that end.
The governments of Spain and Italy are hell bent on this enormous task, which requires significant political ambition and unavoidable sacrifices with the aim of undertaking structural reforms and the cleaning up of our public accounts that will enable our economies and societies to return to the path of growth, competitiveness, employment and wellbeing. Spain and Italy will be tireless in this task. We are working together, and we will continue to work together, and hence will continue cooperating at all levels necessary to guarantee the levels of prosperity that our respective societies deserve.
This summit is one more chapter in an intense Spanish-Italian chapter of cooperation, which are manifested through the Joint Declaration that the two leaders have adopted, which summarised the results of the summit and the subjects that have been dealt with within its framework, both in the meeting I held with Prime Minister Monti, and in the meeting held by the various ministerial departments.
Although these are set out in more detail in the text of the Joint Declaration, I would like to highlight the main issues that have been tackled at this summit.
As regards the European agenda, Spain and Italy are more united than ever. We have common interests that we will defend with determination and coordination through the European Union. These interests can be summed up in two elements.
The first is the urgent and priority implementation of all of the instruments available to the European Union to stimulate economic activity, generate employment and guarantee sufficient financing for our industrial fabric, and, very particularly, for small-and medium-sized enterprises. The Growth and Employment Pact agreed at the European Council in June, with the express support of Italy and Spain, constitutes the basis for the work to be done to achieve these objectives.
Secondly, we must make a virtue out of necessity and drive forward the reform of the Economic and Monetary Union to ensure that Europe is stronger, more united and more prosperous. I have said this many times and I will say it again today, with my partner and friend, Prime Minister Monti: in order to overcome the crisis we need to push on with the process of the political and economic integration of Europe. Our commitment to the Euro is unequivocal and we will adopt all the measures necessary to guarantee its stability and irreversibility.
We have also underlined Spain and Italy's commitment to Greece remaining in the Euro and we have welcomed the recent progress towards achieving a satisfactory agreement on the Greek programme of budgetary and structural reforms.
At the European Council in June we took a qualitative leap in constructing a new Europe that is emerging from this crisis. We established the outline and the schedule for the creation of a banking union and we approved the basic guidelines for achieving fiscal union, economic union and political union.
At the European Council on 18 and 19 October, we also made progress on the basis of what was agreed in June and we established the path for the agreement that must be adopted in December, based on a road map for the future of the Economic and Monetary Union, in order to make greater banking, fiscal, economic and political integration a reality.
Ladies and gentlemen, despite the difficult circumstances, Europe will not be stopped. It continues making progress and it does so with Spain and Italy united in favour of the objectives I have just outlined.
I don't want this speech to go on too long, but I wanted to point out that we also tackled bilateral issues - later, if you wish, I can expand on this information - on matters of home affairs, industry, energy, economic affairs, tourism, telecommunications and also important matters of foreign policy. We spoke about Mali, Syria, about the recent 5+5 Dialogue Summit, of what is taking place in Syria, in Lebanon, etc. I won't go into more detail unless you expressly ask me to.
I will leave you now, and thank you once again for being here today with us. Everything has panned out as usual, I should say, in a very pleasant atmosphere. And I would like to see you here again soon, Mr Prime Minister.
Mr. Monti. Thank you, thank you very much, Mr President of the Spanish Government and my dear friend, Mariano.
We are pleased to be here, in Madrid, on a special day for our two countries. Apart from the summit between our two governments, we will shortly be inaugurating the 10th edition of the Spain-Italy Dialogue Forum. This is evidence of what some have defined as the extraordinary synergy between our two countries, which was praised during the recent State visit here of President Napolitano.
Today's meeting has been somewhat more than our frequent day-time and night-time bilateral meetings, because good work at a European Council requires, as you would expect, losing many hours of sleep. I should say that the subject matter is not such that allows you much sleep.
As I said, today's meeting is somewhat more than usual, because we have been accompanied at our meeting by a series of ministers who are competent in crucial areas for both our governments. In the case of Italy, the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Giulio Terzi di Sant'Agata; the Minister for Home Affairs, Anna María Cancellieri; the Minister for Economic Development, Infrastructure and Transport, Corrado Passera; and the Minister for European Affairs, Enzo Moavero Milanesi.
The summary of what the ministers have done together with their Spanish counterparts, and which was summarised in the final plenary session, gives an idea of the extent of our bilateral relations and the progress made on these bilateral issues, but also of this common vision between Spain and Italy which greatly characterises the European stage and also the world stage.
Today's summit represents a very important occasion to reassert the strategic nature of bilateral relations between Rome and Madrid. Suffice it to say that, despite the current crisis, in 2011 trade between Spain and Italy amounted to almost 20 billion euros. We are the third biggest customer and fourth biggest supplier to Spain; more than 500 Italian companies have operations in Spain and many business leaders, despite the crisis, feel that this market represents very significant opportunities, particularly taking into consideration the very courageous deregulation programme of your government.
Hence, we also spoke about the economic situation and the budgets in the Eurozone. I said to Prime Minister Rajoy that the European Councils in June and October have resulted in important and positive decisions, and I believe that all of Europe, and the whole world feels that they have given strong signals as regards the determination of the European Union to maintain the stability and integrity of the Euro.
It is easy in other places around the world to criticise the slow pace of European decisions, and we even criticise this ourselves and we would like them to be faster, but all of us together are constructing something that has never been done anywhere else in the world. It is always necessary to want more and to work to achieve more, but we need to be aware of the miracles that are performed each day.
The agreement on the single banking supervisory mechanism is the first step towards financial integration, which is fundamental for the survival and prosperity of the Euro. We have now set certain very specific deadlines that we want to respect. It wasn't obvious that there would be specific deadlines following the previous European Council but these have now been decided on.
We want to work together to strengthen the economic and monetary union. "Towards a Genuine Economic and Monetary Union", as stated by the title of the draft report presented by the President of the Council, Van Rompuy, together with Presidents Barroso, Draghi and Juncker. The European Council needs to periodically comment on the master guidelines of this work in order to present the conclusions in December.
This is important because, when the markets were going through their worst period of turbulence - they haven't fully come out of that, but when turbulence was at a high - the experts said that the first thing to do to calm this turbulence was to respond to the question from the market operators as to whether the Euro would still exist within five years. To answer this question from the operators, we need to define a clear framework in order to proceed to greater integration surrounding the Euro. This work has been swiftly completed.
We also spoke with Prime Minister Rajoy about the future multiannual EU budget looking to the European Council of 22 and 23 November. Italy and Spain want to work together to reach an agreement not only in the specific interests of our two countries, but also in the interests of Europe as a whole. We are convinced that national interests exist and I, personally, am convinced that, in the case of countries like ours, of course in a country whose government I have the honour of leading, national interests coincide, to a very great extent, with European interests, of a Europe in which countries make a constructive contribution and which they thus see as their own.
We have both reiterated our satisfaction at the award of the Nobel Peace Prize to the European Union, which also represents, and I would like everyone to appreciate this, in particular the representatives of the media, a great occasion to explain and make European citizens aware, above all young people, of what the European Union means, particularly at a time in which the Union is also being subjected to strong conflicting forces.
We also spoke about international issues: Syria, the region of Mali, the Sahel region, the latest 5+5 Dialogue Summit in Malta; in other words, Spain, France, Portugal, Italy and Malta together with five countries on the southern shore: Libya, Tunisia, Algeria, Morocco and Mauritania. With seeds of horizontal dialogue with these countries and somewhat less fragmented and hostile dialogue than in the past, following their respective political developments, perhaps we will manage to attain the seeds of integration among these countries similar to that which has brought peace and wellbeing to the European Union.
To conclude, I believe, dear Prime Minister, that our two countries have gone through, and are indeed going through - and they are not the only ones - some difficult times at this fledgling stage of European construction towards something more robust and satisfactory. During hard times, if we work well, we can improve our friendship, our collaboration and our desire to constructively contribute towards this common project. The very spontaneous way in which we do this pleases me greatly.
Q. For both Prime Ministers. We have heard that there is a strong common position between Spain and Italy on the main European issues. I would like to know whether you have spoken about the proposal that Mr Draghi once again announced yesterday on the creation of a 'Super-Commissioner' to oversee the various budgets of EU countries.
President of the Government. Yes, this is one of the issues that came out in the talks we held this morning and I will tell you what we believe to be more reasonable to those of us who were there.
I believe that the European Union firstly needs to establish what it wants to be and where it wants to go. Some of us have this clear and I am speaking now for myself. I want the European Union to have greater economic integration, greater political integration, I want to see a banking union and a fiscal union. So, for me, this idea of a commissioner is not an issue for now and only has a bearing on one thing, and that is the public deficit. We are opposed to having a public deficit. We are making a great effort here in Spain to reduce it; other countries as well. What we would like to see is all of this brought together in one package, that something similar is done to what was done when the Euro was brought in.
The Euro was a very difficult project, but all the countries in the Union were told that the single currency was the objective; that this would be beneficial to all, and an obligation was established for all countries to comply with certain requirements regarding their deficits, debt - just look - interest rates, which were still national, and inflation. There was thus an objective and I remember that Spain went through a very difficult situation at that time - in 1996 - but it greatly helped that there was a desire to construct Europe and to create the Euro.
Hence, at these times in which Spain and other countries are going through a difficult period we believe that now is the time to repeat another operation such as the one back then. Let's set objectives (fiscal union, banking union, political union and economic union), let's set deadlines and send out a message of what we really want, because that is what the majority of Europeans want - greater European integration.
What we cannot do is touch firstly on one thing and then on another without saying where we are heading. That is an idea, when considered on its own, that I do not personally like; but it could be considered within a raft of measures for fiscal union. But if it is the only thing we intend to do then I am not in favour. I believe we need to speak about more things, about a true fiscal union for all European Union countries.
Mr. Monti. The matter of the 'Super-Commissioner', which we have indeed discussed with Prime Minister Rajoy, was announced again in an extensive interview with President Draghi in "Der Spiegel". I have not read this interview, and hence am unable to comment on the words of the President. I know that, in general, President Draghi and I have many opinions in common, not only our Christian name. That is what I wanted to say firstly because I still haven't read the interview.
But I would like to say something about the Super-Commissioner, because talk started on this subject, I believe, about one or one-thirty in the morning on 18 October, a day on which we finished the European Council at three in the morning. On the matter of the Super-Commissioner, I can see two questions that I would like to differentiate and that is what indeed took place during those night-time talks. On the one hand, the idea of seeking another instrument to ensure that budgetary rules are followed so that those countries that are uncomfortable because other countries don't meet their budgetary rules have a type of ulterior safety belt. We need to be careful with this because, if we have the Treaty of Maastricht, the Stability and Growth Pact, the Six-Pack, the Fiscal Compact and the Two-Pack in place, and we are saying that we need an instrument to better apply fiscal rules, it doesn't sound very good in terms of the seriousness of the countries that need to comply with the rules, in other words, all countries, or the confidence of each country vis-à-vis the others.
Furthermore, the signal to the markets whereby we are always proposing new examples of budgetary integrity and fiscal virtue is a sign that might make the markets feel, and they are always alert, that the instruments that exist aren't working.
This does not mean, and I am always speaking from my personal viewpoint, that we don't need greater efficiency in the European Union so that certain rules are complied with. But I believe that there are sectors within an economic and monetary union that are seeking a perfect and good economic and monetary union, and which have left the performance and the application somewhat behind, and which are all those areas except the rule on budgetary equilibrium.
Specifically, the idea that was discussed at the table at the European Council of possible contractual agreements between the different Member States and the European Union, with these contracts having some kind of legal validity, and also of the possibility that the European Union can provide limited financial support to those countries that need it, eventually with this necessary equilibrium for the Euro that we are talking about… If the European Union provides a little pressure regarding structural reforms; reforms that certain ministerial departments present here today are dealing with, so that the economy, the labour market, the energy market or the market of products can be in freer markets, more efficient markets, and to make our economies more competitive; in other words, more capable of generating imbalances in the long term, this may also cause problems to the public deficit.
It doesn't bother me that action is taken on structural reforms. Since the Lisbon Strategy there have been a series of reforms, while other aspects have been left to the good will of Member States, but there hasn't been any kind of monitoring with powerful persuasion on the part of the European Union, through contracts and agreements of this type. But that is something different from a super-commissioner.
This is the last comment that I wish to make and please excuse me for the length of my response. I am not talking about Professor Draghi now, because I am yet to read his speech, but I would like to refer to the whole debate on this matter. It is somewhat a myth to seek out a super-commissioner. As President Barroso explained well in a discussion that night; aside from the special powers given a year and a half ago to the Vice-President of the Commission, Olli Rehn, responsible for Economic Affairs and Monetary Affairs, that was said about the Commissioner for Economic and Monetary Affairs having as extensive powers as the Commissioner for Competition- a true super-commissioner - as something that is not possible, because under this reform introduced by President Barroso, the Commissioner for Economic Affairs already has more extensive powers than the Commissioner for Competition, and certain cases may even go before the College of Commissioners.
Hence, it is important that we, as Heads of Government, reflect on the possible defects. It is useful to always think that the Commission is a political body where those who make austerity proposals, such as on matters of the public deficit, may then be in a political minority as a result of the other commissioners. That is not how things are and experience shows us that, starting with the case in 2003 when France and Spain breached the Stability Pact - excuse the slip of the tongue, I was wrong; I always carry Spain close to my heart - France and Germany, in alphabetical order, breached the Stability Pact in 2003. The Commission had already issued its decision on the penalties to be imposed, but the Council did not follow this decision. Hence let's reduce the powers of our national governments but let's not carry out a witch-hunt on the performance of the Commission.
I'm sorry I've gone on for so long but the issue is important.
Q. I had a question for each of you. Mr Draghi, whom you mentioned just now, outlined something else this weekend: the content of his programme for purchasing debt, and he apparently said that this will involve a periodic revision of the adjustment plans and the adjustment measures for each country that requests this.
I wanted to know, Prime Minister Rajoy, what you still need to know about this programme and what conditions still need to be firmed up so that Spain can decide to request it or not.
And for Mr Monti. I understand that Italy, before the end of the year, has certain significant debt maturities and that its risk premium is not excessively low. I was wondering if you feel it is appropriate for Spain and Italy to decide to activate this purchase of debt together?
President of the Government. I will tell you what I think. I believe that this is an instrument that is out there and the fact that it is out there is something very important, because it shows that there is a will to maintain the Euro.
When this instrument was created, it sent out a message on the irreversible nature of the Euro; if problems or difficulties arose, the European Central Bank is there to address them. Aside from that, any country can ask for it and any country that asks for it does so when it is appropriate and opportune to do so. I, of course, will do that. When I feel that it is in the general interest of Spain to do so, I will ask for it; until such time I will not ask for it. But, for the time being I am simply grateful that this instrument exists and Spain, I repeat, may ask for it if this is in the general interests of the Spanish people. What I feel is more important is simply that it exists.
Aside from that, you will understand that I am not going to enter into any kind of debate or discussion on the matter. If we feel that it is appropriate, we will speak about it of course, and we will announce this to the public with the reasons behind our decision. But at this point in time, the Spanish Government has not asked for it and it has not asked for it because it considers that it is not essential at this time to defend the general interests of the Spanish people.
Mr. Monti. I believe that Italy has fought more of an intellectual and political battle than any other country to convince the European Union, exactly as Prime Minister Rajoy has said, and also to show our determination at having the Euro as a major point of reference. Italy has been a country that has fought particularly hard for that the "anti spread" shield to be created within the arsenal of the European Union and the Eurozone.
We are very pleased that this has been possible. I would like to say that the cooperation with Spain both before and during the Council in June was very useful from this point of view, as well as from France, and also from Germany, because on many occasions, through dialogue with Mrs Merkel, we have tried to show her and the French Minister of Finance, Schäuble, our full conviction that Italy was not going to deviate by even an inch from its line on budgetary discipline.
Hence, with the conviction that by Italy having this instrument this favours all of us, I asked for it but not as an excuse to resolve our problems. For us it has been an intellectual and political satisfaction to have contributed, together with the others, because the decision was taken at five in the morning, to create this instrument. And it is very important that, having created this line of principle, that this instrument is activated, that it becomes operative, and doesn't only exist as a theoretical construction.
As regards Italy's position today, both the Minister for Economic Affairs, Vittorio Grilli, and I have been saying for months that we don't think Italy, without prejudicing the decisions that may be taken by other countries, is in a condition to have to activate this instrument.
I should say that we are convinced that the current risk premium in Italy compared with the German ten-year bond is higher than what the market basis justifies. It stood at 330 the other day while today, I don't know why, it has increased and stands at 350, obviously a lot lower still than it was a year ago, when the premium stood at 575. But I believe that this premium should be much lower than this.
Of course these are delicate matters which must be dealt with with great caution.
Q. A question for Prime Minister Monti. Both you and Prime Minister Rajoy have spoken about the commitment to financial stability, but much depends on the stability of the government. I wanted to ask you, Prime Minister Monti, if you are concerned by the threat from Silvio Berlusconi to take confidence away from your government and what would be the financial consequences for Italy if your government lost power before the end of its term of office. Is that perhaps why the risk premium has gone from 330 to 350?
Mr. Monti. I know that you are a competent analyst and hence I will take note of this hypothesis that I hadn't thought about.
Of course, the matter of the risk premium, as we all know, is a very complex matter.
You asked me about the possibility of Berlusconi taking confidence away. You mentioned the word "threat", that "he has threatened to take confidence away from this government". But that cannot be done, not only because confidence cannot be taken away, but also because we don't look at it as a threat.
We have made a contribution to the country at a difficult time. If anyone wants to take our confidence away, and they manage to do this on a well-founded basis, who are we do judge them? We are doing all we can to achieve good results, but these are assessments that fall on others to make. Hence, I cannot call something a "threat" which, and I believe I speak on behalf of my ministerial colleagues, cannot take anything away from us, but rather governmental action that we haven't taken anyway.
Q. What consequences could there be if your government does not complete its term of office?
Mr. Monti. I don't want to speculate on this either. I believe that the best thing is to continue doing our job with a time horizon of Spring 2013, as has always been our intention. That is what the President of the Republic and Parliament have asked us to do.
This is a question you could ask of the political parties, of the markets, of the whole world, but not of me.
Q. I had two questions for Prime Minister Rajoy, about national affairs in this instance.
Firstly, I wanted to ask about Catalonia, because both the CiU and the PSC, the two main political parties, defend in their electoral programmes the idea of a referendum for the Catalan people to see if they are in favour of independence or not. I wanted to know what the government's response will be and what the government will do to prevent the promotion of this referendum.
Secondly, I wanted to ask about the statement made by Barack Obama, who recently said that "we cannot allow Spain to fall". This is the second or third time that Spain has burst onto the scene of the US electoral campaign.
Spain is heading towards six million unemployed and I wanted to know if you have doubts about the austerity policy that you are applying and whether you believe that a policy of greater stimuli should be applied to create jobs.
President of the Government. As regards the question you have just asked about Catalonia, a matter about which I can assure you nothing was said in today's meeting because, as you correctly said, it is a national issue, the first thing I am going to do is not announce anything whatsoever about this matter.
I am the President of the Government and it is my obligation, and even if it wasn't, to still act with the greatest degree of common sense possible. I have already stated my position this weekend in an appearance I made in the city of Barcelona; hence I shouldn't need to add much more except for one thing: we have lived side-by-side, we are the oldest nation in Europe; we have done many things together and we will do many things together in the future. We live in a world going through processes of union; just look, we are talking here about banking union and economic union in the European Union, and Mr Monti himself spoke about the union of countries in North Africa whom we met with just a short time ago. Hence, I believe that we will overcome this situation.
I have always been open to dialogue. But I should say one thing in this respect: dialogue requires that two parties have a desire to sit down and talk. You can't simply say to someone "here you go, take it or leave it", which was the sensation I had when the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia came here. But that is in the past. My position is well known; I believe that problems can be resolved through dialogue, I believe that things will go much better for everyone if we work together - I repeat, much better for everyone - and I believe that it is not worth arguing about what may happen in other circumstances.
We will overcome this situation through dialogue and, of course, through the law, which is where democrats and sensible people who operate through common sense resort to.
As regards the second question, I am absolutely convinced that nothing of what may happen will actually materialise. Spain is suffering from a complicated economic situation, as everyone is aware, as are other EU countries; but we are implementing the policies that need to be implemented.
Firstly, we are actively reducing the public deficit. This needs to be done because that is what the European Union has decided, and it is pure common sense to do so, because last year - I always say this, but I believe we needs reminding of it - the public administration services in Spain spent 90 billion euros more than they collected in revenue; in other words 15 trillion old pesetas, or 9% of our Gross Domestic Product. One cannot live like this. In the same way as a family with income of 1,000 euros cannot live forever spending 1,500 euros, neither can the State. Hence, this needs to be done and we are doing it, and during hard times.
Secondly, structural reform needs to be undertaken. We have made very significant structural reforms: in the energy sector, the labour market reform, the whole banking restructuring process, we have announced a new package in the month of July… I believe that the right things are being done.
Thirdly, it is necessary that Europe sends out a very clear message about the irreversibility of the Euro; saying that this is a real project and it's here to stay. I believe that it has done this, but these things always need to be said time and again.
I repeat, in 1996, during hard times, Europe sent out a great message: we are going to bring in the Euro. I want this message to be sent out with conviction, in an overwhelming fashion, and I am willing to do battle to that end, together with other European countries, to continue taking strides forward in this project in which I strongly believe.
Finally, I believe that it is very important that those countries that are working seriously, who are doing things well, who have had to take tough decisions in tough times, and which certain people don't understand and which it is hard for them to understand, because they are very tough and misunderstood, we have to ask for help and support. Those governments deserve the solidarity of all of us. That is why I have always said that the main problem faced by Spain today is one of financing; if we don't receive financing, we cannot grow and, hence, create jobs, and hence correct the deficit.
That is the most important problem being faced by Spain. It has many, but one of those if financing. We need to have sensible, reasonable prices, and we cannot live in a monetary union where some receive free financing, in other words are paid for issuing bonds, while other have to pay through the roof to do so. That is not fair.
I don't know whether Mr Obama referred to that or something else, but that is my opinion, the one I gave to him.
Thank you very much and a good afternoon to one and all.