Press Conference with the President of the Republic of France and the President of the Government of Spain
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy and Hollande held a joint press conference at the 21st France-Spain Summit on 9 October 2012, discussing bilateral and European affairs.
- Main themes
- European banking union, France-Spain bilateral relations, Eurozone stability, Greece and Troika, European Stability Mechanism, EU financial perspectives, Common Agricultural Policy, structural funds, high-speed rail infrastructure, drug trafficking cooperation, financial transaction tax, economic and monetary union
- Duration
- ~43 min
- Words
- 5,146
- Sentences
- 226
- Readability
- 50
- Grade
- 11.7
- Syntax
- 2.98
- Vocabulary
- 1.96
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
226 sentences in 80 paragraphs
Mr. Hollande. Ladies and gentlemen, the President of the Government of Spain and I, together with leading members of his Government, met for what we call the France-Spain Summit. This was the twenty-first such Summit following a period of three years during which none were held. Therefore, it was about time that our two countries were able to discuss a number of issues related to our bilateral relations in certain depth. We also discussed European affairs and were able to start talking about various common policies related to energy, infrastructure, agriculture and security.
I will begin now by talking about Europe. France and Spain share the same ideas on what needs to be done in the weeks ahead, before a number of important events take place. Three such important events are approaching: the European Council meeting on 18 and 19 October; an extraordinary Council meeting on the Financial Perspectives of Europe; and a final Council meeting, towards the end of the year, on economic and monetary union.
We believe that as much progress as possible needs to be made on banking union at the Council meeting in October, on the supervision of our banks, with the European Central Bank taking responsibility at a Eurozone level and all banks being covered by such supervision. We will then need to go through other stages to finalise this banking union, but at least we will have laid some solid foundations.
We will also need to find solutions for Greece. Once we have the report from the Troika and once Greece has confirmed the strength of its commitments, it will need to receive European support. Let there be no doubt regarding the strength of our will, the will of France and Spain, on Greece maintaining full status as part of the Eurozone.
We also want the mechanisms that were established and introduced during the European Council meeting in June, which as far as I am concerned was a highly important meeting that changed the direction being taken on building Europe… We established a certain number of channels for intervention from the European Stability Mechanism and the President of the European Central Bank, Mr. Draghi, explained how that Mechanism could be completed. It now needs to be implemented so that those countries that may eventually ask for it can do so.
We will also need to tackle the European budget, the Financial Perspectives. France and Spain also share opinions in this regard. Expenditure must be controlled in the European budget. We are in a situation where we cannot ask the Member States to make additional efforts and, at a European level, not be consistent. However, at the same time, we want to preserve the Common Agricultural Policy and the Structural Funds. That will be our common position in those negotiations.
I will end on economic and monetary union. If we can get through these stages - banking union, a response to Greece and application of the new Mechanism - we will then be able to move forward in the process of solidarity and integration. We have taken but a first step with the tax on financial transactions. France and Germany have taken the initiative, other countries are joining us and Spain is going to define its position; I will let Mr. Rajoy do that. But if we can reach an agreement on this tax, which would be implemented and applied in 2013 - the sooner the better - we would be able to make resources available and use them for certain purposes, fundamentally for growth.
I want the Eurozone to be more structured, for there to be simpler and faster decision-making mechanisms, for there to be governance and for the Eurozone Council to be able to meet more often. I don't want to distance the others but we do have our own responsibilities. We, who decided to adopt a single currency, must also have instruments for taking action and for inspiring confidence in our people and the markets that are watching us.
As regards our bilateral relations, a highly important agreement was signed by our two Home Affairs Ministers not only to continue what was already being done - combating terrorism, and ETA in particular - but also about considering drug trafficking as a phenomenon that threatens not only our two countries but Europe as a whole. We, the French and Spanish, are assuming our responsibilities: a triennial plan is going to be applied by our two Governments, by the two Home Affairs Ministers, to tackle the drug trafficking that comes through Spain from North Africa.
We also took important decisions on our infrastructures. Significant progress was made on the High-Speed Railway lines. We will now be able to use the High-Speed Train to travel from Perpignan to Barcelona faster and without changing train. The idea is for it to be possible to travel between Perpignan and Barcelona in two hours. And we are nearly there! We also have the short sea shipping routes that are going to be opened - a great project that will enable us to remove the problems, and sometimes accidents, being caused at the moment by road haulage traffic. So these short sea shipping routes are going to be extensively developed and we have made commitments in that regard.
We also made commitments in terms of energy affairs, on the high-voltage lines along the Mediterranean and along the Atlantic.
We will approach this work in such a way that energy and the environment become allies, with one of these high-voltage lines being laid underground and therefore having no consequences for our citizens.
Furthermore, we also share positions and opinions on agricultural affairs, not only in defence of the budget for the CAP but also in defence of certain production activities, on which we have decided to join forces.
Finally, we also spoke about international affairs. France and Spain not only share the same concerns regarding Mali and Syria but also have the same outlook, mainly on the Resolution being prepared by the Security Council. We are aware that this is going to enable intervention by African States, which will decide when that is done.
That is what we have done together here today, together for our countries and together for Europe. I am glad that such a level of agreement exists between our two Governments on what needs to be done and that we can support each other in Europe - we are in situations that could sometimes be viewed as different. If there is no growth in Spain, there can be no strong growth in France. When Spain has liquidity problems, it's true that we aren't paying the same price in terms of interest rates but the consequences for Spanish economic activity are reflected on French economic activity.
We therefore have ties because we are neighbours, because we are two of the large Eurozone economies and, because we have ties, because we are aware of our responsibilities, we have decided to work together.
President of the Government. Ladies and gentlemen, a very good afternoon to you.
I would like to start by thanking the President of the Republic of France, François Hollande, for the warm reception received by the delegation from the Government of Spain, which I am leading, for the excellent organisation behind the meetings and for making us feel so comfortable. The health of bilateral relations between France and Spain are truly at one of their highest peaks in history.
This is the first bilateral meeting since 2009, as the President of the Republic of France said in his speech. I don't think it is a good idea for such a long time to pass between these meetings and I think that having one bilateral meeting a year is important, which will be the case from now on, because there are many things that unite us in terms of European affairs but also because we are neighbours and countries with extensive relations in a multitude of areas. It is very important for us to work together on many issues.
As I said, this is the first bilateral meeting since 2009 but it is the fourth time I have met with the President of the Republic of France since he took office: shortly after he became President of the Republic of France, here, at Elysee Palace; then in Spain, in Madrid; then in Malta, a few days ago, where we discussed many important issues for Spain and our two countries; and now, our fourth meeting here, at Elysee Palace.
I believe that Mr. Hollande has given a perfectly understandable and extensive summary of the issues we discussed today, so I will not repeat what you've already heard. I'm sure you have questions anyway. However, I would like to emphasise three of four things that I think are particularly important. Well, they are all important, but there are three or four things I want to highlight.
Firstly, I want to say something from a European point of view. As the President of the Republic of France said, Europe adopted a series of decisions at one of the most important Council meetings to have been held in a long time - the European Council meeting in June. What we want is simply for those decisions to be implemented. Many things were said at that meeting and, obviously, there were talks on banking union, fiscal union, monetary union, even political union, and we spoke about the direct recapitalisation of banks. We want things to actually happen and, at the next Council meeting in October, which will take place in only a few days time, next week to be precise, Spain will be demanding that be the case. Before the year is out, we have to have taken steps, especially in terms of banking union, banking supervision, in order to send a message saying that we are serious people and that we meet our commitments.
Secondly, I would like to say something about Greece. Spain is in favour of Greece staying in the Euro. Greece must meet its commitments, as we are all doing; but Greece exiting the Euro would demonstrate and epitomise a collective failure of the entire European Union, something we cannot allow. I am absolutely convinced that, between us all, we will find the right solution with Greece meeting its commitments and everyone else taking the decisions they deem necessary and appropriate for Greece to remain as a member of the Euro, so this matter can stop being discussed or even mentioned because, simply put, the fact that Greece is in the Euro is an undeniable fact.
I would also like to highlight, from a bilateral standpoint - the President of the Republic of France also mentioned a few issues - that it is important for us to reaffirm the commitment made regarding the first trains on the Barcelona-Figueres and Perpignan High-Speed Railway Line starting to operate next April, in other words, April 2013. I think that is very important. We also reiterated our desire to develop, in conjunction with the Region of Aquitaine and the Autonomous Region of Aragon, the programme of study regarding the project to re-open the Pau-Canfranc railway line, while respecting the respective national regulations.
We also spoke about electricity inter-connections. We would like to open the Bay of Biscay electricity inter-connection in 2014. Also, as Mr. Hollande said, the work on building the high-voltage direct-current transmission link between Baixàs and Santa Llogaia, which is progressing satisfactorily, and which will begin to operate in 2014.
We also agreed that the progress on gas pipeline projects being undertaken by French and Spanish operators in Navarre and the Basque Country is very important for both countries as they will enable our gas exchange capacity to be tripled between 2013 and 2015.
It is also important that we expressed our desire to immediately implement the short sea shipping route connecting Vigo and Nantes, which will include a connection to Le Havre and Algeciras, following the success of the Gijón-Nantes short sea shipping route that is already being operated.
It is highly important that both countries are going to defend the maintenance of current agricultural policies in the European Union at the European Council in November where, as was said earlier, discussions will take place on the budget for the coming years. We are going to defend the Common Agricultural Policy so that it may guarantee growth, employment, the environment and innovation in all rural areas of Europe, which we want to preserve.
We also spoke about cohesion policy in support of structural reforms in regions experiencing difficulties - to achieve their growth potential - and in the outermost regions.
I thanked the President of the Republic of France and his Home Affairs Minister for the support provided by the French Republic to our anti-terrorist activity. The results have been excellent for everyone. Furthermore, we signed an agreement, which I am absolutely convinced will produce results, on fighting drugs over the next three years. The specific details and actions will be developed step by step in the future.
Finally, on issues of international policy, there is almost total agreement on the major issues affecting current affairs today: Mali, the Sahel in general, Syria and other issues that we touched on during the course of our meeting this morning.
I will end now. Again, I would like to thank the President of the Republic for the way we have been received. We have been made to feel very comfortable. I think that Europe is something we must all work on and we must all defend sensible positions, common sense, that can, above all, enable growth and create jobs; that is what it's all about. Failing to create an outlook for economic growth and job creation would simply be unacceptable.
Thank you very much.
Q. I have a question for you both. You are committed to complying with the agreements from the last European Council and yet there is reticence from such countries as Germany and even from the President of the Central Bank, who are saying it will be impossible for certain issues, like common banking supervision, to become a reality within the deadline set. Do you think that deadline is realistic?
I wanted to ask the President of the Government about the forecasts made in the Report by the International Monetary Fund. Do you perhaps think they have not taken into consideration the latest reforms implemented by your Government? In any case, do you think it will be possible to meet the deficit target by the end of the year?
President of the Government. Those are two questions and the second was addressed to me alone. I think it can be met. If we agreed to advance towards banking union in June, if the President of the Council, Mr. Van Rompuy, was commissioned in June to make a specific proposal in December, there is no reason why decisions cannot be taken in December. What's more, what I cannot fathom is why decisions aren't already being taken.
Therefore, it's entirely possible and absolutely desirable for the European Council to send a crystal clear message on the determined continuation of the European integration process, on the possibility of launching banking supervision, on giving responsibility to the ECB and issuing instructions so that regulations can be approved in December to come into force in early 2013.
As regards the forecasts from the International Monetary Fund, they are not satisfactory for Spain, as you can clearly appreciate, but neither are they satisfactory for any other country in the European Union, as you can clearly appreciate. My goal is for the forecasts from the International Monetary Fund not to come true and for those made by the Government of Spain to become the reality, as I'm sure will be the objective for any other country in the European Union.
In any event, I should point out that we had forecast economic growth of -1.7% for this year. It is likely that the final result will be better than that forecast.
At the end of the day, what these forecasts from the Monetary Fund actually help me do is reaffirm the need for decisions to be taken on economic policy at a State level and at a Europe-wide level. At a State level: controlling the public deficit and structural reforms. At a Europe-wide level, three things, which we agreed on at the European Council in June: firstly, the structural reforms contained in the growth plan we approved at that meeting; secondly, the resolution of the liquidity problems in the Eurozone in a clear and comprehensible fashion; and, thirdly, progress towards banking union, fiscal union, economic union and political union.
Therefore, if we progress down the path laid out by the European Council in June, we will have made highly significant progress towards a reality that is much better than the forecasts made by any international organisation.
Mr. Hollande. The President of the Government of Spain has made the point: the European Council on 27 and 28 June was a very important step in resolving the Eurozone crisis. What we must do now, all of us, is implement and apply what we ourselves committed to as the process. We need to take decisions.
First of all, the growth pact. There will be an assessment of how that will take shape in reality at the upcoming Council meeting on 18 and 19 October.
Next, banking union, in other words, supervision by the European Central Bank for countries in the Eurozone and with a large number of banks involved. As far as France is concerned, and we've already said this, all banks must be affected by this supervision.
The third decision we took at the last European Council meeting was about equipping ourselves with a mechanism that could come into force for those countries that request it, that clean up or are cleaning up their public finances and that wish to obtain liquidity. Right now, today, these countries are suffering certain interest rates that we all know are too high. This mechanism has taken its time to arrive because we needed to wait on a decision from the court in Karlsruhe and that has only now become possible. The Central Bank has organised a form of intervention that enables the instrument to be completed and, from there, there are no more conditions that need to be imposed or other mechanisms that need to be thought up. We now have what we need.
Finally, the European Council left a door open for any country wishing to join the process regarding a tax on financial transactions. Following the European Council in October, or no later than November, there will be enough countries - nine - capable of reaching a significant consensus.
I am going to answer the question that you didn't ask me, about the forecasts from the IMF, because they were made for many countries, although not necessarily with the same figures. If we want to see growth in May 2013, we must first re-establish confidence, in other words, do everything we decided on through actions and decisions at the European Council meeting in June:
- Sort out the situation in the Eurozone, first condition.
- The second condition for there to be growth: re-establish balance in the public accounts. This needs to be done in every country to different degrees according to the initial situation in each one.
- And, thirdly, support productive investment, competitiveness and infrastructure at a European level - this is the Growth Pact, at domestic levels and even at bilateral levels, as we are doing.
If we sort out the situation in the Eurozone, if we apply our decisions, if we implement policies to control our accounts and, at the same time, support productive activity that includes action on competitiveness, then we will have growth figures that are very different to the forecasts being made today in today's context. The IMF is making a forecast based on today's situation, but the role of our politicians is to make sure tomorrow doesn't look like today because, otherwise, today would be like yesterday.
Q. You both signed a statement in Malta calling for the implementation of banking supervision between now and the end of the year, while the German authorities have been saying this week that it might be better to wait until 2014. It would seem there is a real problem regarding the scope to which this supervision would be applied to the banks. Do you think you will actually find a solution between now and the next Council meeting?
On the subject of Germany, the companies EADS and BAE have announced that their merger has collapsed. It would seem that France and Germany were unable to find an acceptable compromise. What was missing for this European merger to have been a success?
Mr. Hollande. Was the first question addressed to Mr. Rajoy and the second to me?
President of the Government. Probably, I can't see how the second could have been aimed at me, Mr. President; I already have quite enough!
I am unaware… I have no knowledge about Germany having said that this needs to be delayed or allowed to be delayed. I think that we all agreed on one thing in June. When something serious is agreed, one maintains one's position. I am absolutely convinced that everyone has agreed on this because, what's more, there is even a proposal from the European Commission and the President of the European Council, Mr. Van Rompuy, also agrees, because they all believe it to be necessary right now for a clear message to be sent on the continuation of this process.
Therefore, I am convinced and what we asked for is for there to be banking supervision, that said banking supervision be the responsibility of the ECB and for the European Council and Commission to present regulations for approval in December.
As regards what type of banks would be affected by this supervision, if you're asking my opinion, in my opinion, all of them. But I would have no problem, it's not an essential condition, of course; things are decided amongst us all, with their being deadlines for the inclusion of certain groups of banks. But if you ask me, I would say all of them. We have no problem in Spain in that regard.
Mr. Hollande. I absolutely share the point of view expressed by the President of the Government of Spain. We should implement what we agreed upon and what we wanted to do with the banking union: establish this supervision. For it to be credible, there has to be a supervisor and for that supervisor to have its own authority. The Central European Bank unquestionably has such legitimacy. Also, the scope of the banking system must be sufficiently broad to remove all doubt in whatever country with regard to the banks, even the slightest doubt.
On the other question you asked me, two very large companies, EADS and BAE, were seeking a way to build an even stronger group at a global level and had every right to do so. France is a shareholder in EADS and, therefore, imposed certain conditions so that the leaders of both countries knew what we could accept and what we couldn't. Those conditions, and this is no secret, included a presence within the capital, less than there is today; the location of the company headquarters - and hence jobs; and the protection of our defence interests. And we have given all that information to EADS.
Other countries have done so from a different position to ours. Germany is not a shareholder, the German State is not a shareholder, while a company, Daimler Benz, is. In the United Kingdom, the State is not a shareholder in BAE but has a preferential stake. All this information has been given to the companies and then they made their choice and took their decision.
As far as France is concerned, we have applied what seemed appropriate to us in the interest of employment, our industry and our defence. We have also maintained relations with Germany, because there was an agreement between shareholders. And there's always a shareholder agreement that binds the French and the Germans. And we've also maintained good relations with the United Kingdom, because this was not about us wanting to control a company that is now British.
Having said all that, those that decide, as I said, are the companies.
I have no reason to be glad or disappointed. All I can do is say that talks took place between those two companies; that the shareholder, the French State, presented its arguments, its conditions; that our German friends also expressed certain criteria that they considered fundamental and that the British did the same. Afterwards, the companies then drew their own conclusions.
I don't know what exact decision will be adopted, but I have a great deal of confidence in EADS. It is a very large company that is currently enjoying great success internationally. Creating jobs is also a good example of what can be done at a European level. In any case, EADS is going to continue moving forwards, maintain its pace, and the French State, from its position, will do everything it can for that company to receive all the necessary support, without that involving the provision of public financing, for it to obtain new perspectives in the market. It already has those perspectives, but it could develop its activity even further.
Q. For Mr. Hollande. Even though it's a sovereign decision for Spain, does the President of France think that the conditions remain the same for Spain to ask for a bailout, that help from the European Central Bank, or do you think that the situation has changed? I would like your thoughts on that.
For the President of the Government of Spain, Mr. Rajoy. Obviously, if you've already reached a decision on this, we'd love to hear it. But my question is about another domestic issue: does the President of the Government think there's a need to change the current education model in Catalonia? Do you think the current one isn't working? Minister Wert spoke this morning about "specialising", his choice of vocabulary, the content of the education system in Catalonia.
President of the Government. As regards the first question, although, in reality, I can see there is a lack of conviction on your part, probably because you already know what the answer will be and, in fact, the content of the answer is as you imagine.
As regards the second part of your question, I am unaware of any statements that may have been made. There is something I will be frank about: Spain is going through a difficult economic situation and the main objective we all need to focus on is that of implementing policies that enable us to generate economic growth and create jobs. We need both national policies and policies applied at an EU level.
The French President told me this morning that he dedicates a lot of time to European policy, and he is right to do so because European policy, as everybody knows, is more important today than it has ever been for national policy. That is the objective and I would like to work together, all of us, to collaborate and cooperate, and not create more problems than are strictly necessary. I think we need to focus all our energies at this time on resolving the situation of the Spanish economy.
As regards education, what I want is what I've always said: I want good coexistence and for everyone to feel proud to be both Catalan and Spanish. As far as education is concerned, what I want, and hence the education reform and the Draft Bill we've submitted to Parliament, or that we are going to present and that is now being debated with various stakeholders, is to have an education system with greater quality, something that is perfectly understandable. That would be good for the people, first of all, and also good for jobs and the economy.
The better the training given to our young people, the more skills they have and the more things they've seen, the more chances they will have to find a job and the more chances the Spanish economy will have to create qualified people, to grow. That is the only thing that concerns me at the moment.
Mr. Hollande. On the national education system in France, I gave a speech yesterday and I'm not going to repeat myself today. The truth is that schools have a dual purpose: to enable each child to have the best possible future; and to improve the level of training and skills in a country, and thus enable growth in the future.
This is an issue for every European country. If we want to be more competitive, we must make a considerable effort in terms of knowledge, know-how, and therefore in terms of mobilising our young people.
Europe must deal with the youth issue. We spoke yesterday with the Austrian Chancellor about how we could use the product of the tax on financial transactions and we said it could be used to train those young people who leave the school system with no qualifications.
On the other question, I get asked this a lot: When will Spain ask for assistance? That's up to Spain to say and it's up to Europe to create the mechanisms that enable every country - I'm not talking about Spain - to use them if they need to. That's why we've created the ESM and why the Central Bank has decided to have supplementary intervention: to enable any country that can turn to this mechanism without adding more conditions than those that have already been defined with regard to reducing deficits.
Q. The arrests following the dismantling of a terrorist cell in our country at the weekend have been extended. It is an exceptional measure in the event of an imminent threat. Mr. President, is there an imminent threat in France today?
Mr. Hollande. There are provisional arrests, there are investigations and it is the public prosecutor who is in charge of them and the police who are doing their job. What can be said is that all this began with the attack that took place in Sarcelles. We found material that led us to believe that other action was being planned. That is why I congratulate the work of the Justice System and the Police, and I did so at the Council of Ministers this morning, because not only were people arrested who may have already committed attacks but, above all, who could have committed other, more serious attacks.
Let's allow the investigations to be completed. Not everything has come to light yet.
Thank you.