Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

13 March 2012 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in the Spanish Congress on March 13, 2012, addressing naval sector taxation and regional autonomy.
Main themes
Naval sector tax regime, ship financing system, EU regulatory fairness, Spanish shipyards, tax leasing blockade, parliamentary oversight, autonomy and federalism, economic crisis management
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,473
67th percentile
Sentences
98
62nd percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 53%48%
  • Economic 36%33%
  • Social 5%4%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 10%

98 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Francisco Xesús Jorquera, from the Mixed Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Jorquera.- Mr. President of the Government, will your Government report to the European Union the existing tax regimes for the naval sector in different countries of the Union?

President.- Before denouncing anyone, I prefer to solve problems.

We are giving, as you know, absolute priority to the implementation of a ship financing system for the naval sector. I believe this is a very important issue; I know the topic well. I recently responded to Mr. Erkoreka; I have been meeting with trade union organizations there in Galicia, and these meetings aim to define the instruments that should make up a new ship financing system.

I hope that the Commission will soon accept the new regime proposed by Spain, similar to that of other countries, which I hope, if they accept what they have, you will not want to denounce them either. And I hope that the results of the negotiations we are having at this time will ultimately be useful to resolve the problem, which is fundamentally what it is all about.

Mr. Jorquera.- Mr. President, our question has an intention, and I will try to explain it. We are concerned about the fact that the European Union is specializing in applying the law of the funnel to our naval sector: first, it did so with our public shipyards and with the Fene shipyard in particular—I want to take this opportunity to express our solidarity with the workers of the public shipyards in the Ferrol estuary, who are currently marching towards Santiago de Compostela—and now it is also doing so with our private shipyards, with the painful complicity, it must be said, of Mr. Joaquín Almunia.

How can it be explained that, while in some European countries the tax incentives for the hiring of ships are between 20 and 21 percent, a limit of between 1 and 3 percent is proposed for the Spanish State? How can it be explained that the naval sector in the Spanish State is denied what applies in France or the Netherlands? The Netherlands, precisely the country that led the complaint to Brussels about the existing tax leasing regime in the Spanish State. From our point of view, there is only one explanation: trying to expel our shipyards to take over their market share, just what is happening at this moment.

The blockade of the "tax lease" has completely paralyzed the formalization of new contracts, while other countries are benefiting from this situation to secure new orders. And not only that, they are hiring our naval engineering and architecture technicians, with the consequent irreparable loss of know-how and human capital.

To address this situation, we ask you for a position of firmness when negotiating, demanding an urgent and equitable solution that prevents the disappearance of our naval sector. And to negotiate strongly and on equal footing, you have a precious instrument in your hands: as long as the complaint against the tax leasing regime in the Spanish State is not withdrawn, you should also denounce the existing tax regimes for the naval sector in other countries.

President.- I share your concern. You raise a real and very important issue. I agree with almost everything you have said; almost everything, only.

We are working on it. We are negotiating. If you tell me to take a firm stance, that seems fine to me; I will take a firm stance. I know that this needs an urgent solution, and that is why we are working with the utmost intensity possible.

Whenever negotiations take place, one must consider the position of the other party, but what I want to tell you is that I take this issue seriously—let's see later what the results are—that the Government takes it seriously and that it does not seem reasonable to us today to denounce other countries, because precisely what we want is to have a regime similar to that of other countries that we would have to denounce. And that, logically, would make our position somewhat strange.

In any case, I insist, I believe you are addressing an issue that is there, that is true, that you are right about. The Government is aware and, therefore, will fight, as is our obligation.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josu Iñaki Erkoreka, from the EAJ-PNV Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, for some time now, a certain sector of public opinion and published opinion has been urging the Government to take the economic crisis as a pretext to—so it is said—refound the State or to wipe the slate clean of the autonomous model. On some occasions, they not only invite the Government to do so but also announce that this is indeed its purpose. What is true about this?

President.- As you very well know, I am neither public opinion nor published opinion. I am just the President of the Government, and so what I can tell you is that I have no intention of wiping the slate clean of the autonomous regime, as stated in your question and as you habitually remind in your blog. Therefore, I have no interest in it; I told you in the Investiture Debate, and I reaffirm it now. All we intend is to improve the functioning of all public administrations and to do so through a system as civilized as dialogue and agreement. I do not think there is anyone who does not want decisions to be made that serve to improve the position of citizens.

I do not want public administrations to be unaware of each other, and we want them to be more effective, that their public accounts are viable, and that the autonomous system works better for the citizen. There is nothing else.

Mr. Erkoreka.- Thank you very much, Mr. President, for the attention you pay to my blog. I also recommend it to the rest of the deputies; it is really enlightening.

I have nothing against efforts that may be made to eliminate duplications and overlaps; but, look, the political and media sectors I referred to in the first part of my speech always start, when making their considerations, from the assumption that a composite State is, by definition, something incompatible with efficiency; that it is synonymous with chaos, inefficiency, and waste. That is why they allow themselves to ironically comment when they talk about institutions that multiply by seventeen.

Allow me to give you some data to refute that assumption from which those arguments start. Look, the first economic power in Europe, Germany, is a composite State, not a unitary one; the first world power, the United States, is a composite State, not a unitary one and with competences for the member states that some Autonomous Communities would envy; most emerging states—Brazil, India, or Mexico—are also composite states. If anything is evident from comparative experience, it is that strength, development, and prosperity go hand in hand with composite states, because there are also unitary states in Europe, but unitary states in Europe are Greece, Portugal, or Ireland, which are not precisely models of efficiency.

That said, Mr. President, I must also tell you that we have nothing to object to the fact that some autonomous presidents renounce their self-government and decide to return autonomous competences to the State. We have nothing to object to that. What we will always oppose is that the fact that some Autonomous Communities want to return competences to the State becomes a rule that is inexorably imposed on all others: on those that want to and on those that not only do not want to but want to expand their competences to infinity and beyond.

President.- You speak to me of political and media sectors. I will not tell you to ask them. You are here asking the President of the Government, and the President of the Government has not said a word regarding that matter.

I have recalled throughout my speech in this plenary session that we have made some decisions that I believe are good for the Autonomous Communities and are good for everyone. I have referred, among others, to the suppliers' plan. I believe that things can be done together, and I believe that steps can be taken in the right direction.

Recently, the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy made decisions, in my opinion, important regarding the deficit of the Autonomous Communities, and a large majority have agreed on all of this.

What it is about is that we are not unaware of each other, that we can talk, that we can see how we are more effective, and that we can, if it seems very reasonable to me, have some rules… Just as in Europe we want common rules in economic matters, why can’t we also have rules in economic matters in Spain?

Let’s talk about that. It seems reasonable to me, it seems operational to me, it seems good for everyone, and I am convinced that you will end up being an enthusiast of the proposal that the Government of Spain will make.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. President of the Government, are you willing to make modifications to your labor reform?

President.- This Chamber validated the labor reform with the favorable vote of nearly two hundred deputies last week, and we also decided to process the reform as a Bill. If we had not wanted to, we would not have done it, and therefore, I believe that this makes our willingness to accept modifications to the reform sufficiently clear, and I do not know why you are asking me this question. However, of course, we will accept those that seem reasonable to us and that serve to improve the objective, which is economic growth and job creation.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- The reform has been in place for a month; it is therefore already in full operation, and there are workers who have been dismissed with less compensation and more easily; there are already workers who have seen their working conditions changed unilaterally or their salaries lowered unilaterally, and there are already workers who were permanent in the public administration and have been dismissed with twenty days of compensation. All of this is already happening, Mr. Rajoy.

We also know that you had the reform well thought out, although not announced—parenthesis: you could announce the tax measures so that we do not have the same situation with taxes on the 29th as with the labor reform; close parenthesis—we know it. We also know that there are alternatives, and the unions have presented several. For example, they have presented alternatives to your contract, the one that creates free dismissal for a year; they have presented alternative formulas when there are mismatches or disagreements to reform working conditions between employers and workers, also for ultra-activity; alternatives that seek to restore a balance that you have broken with your labor reform.

What I tell you is that this reform has affected the lives of millions of people, the lives of millions of workers, and for the future, it affects the lives of millions of workers who will see their rights diminished and their salaries lowered. Overall, a reform that breaks fundamental social balances.

And what I also tell you is that there is time for this not to be the case, and I ask you once again to sit down with the unions and with employers, for the Government to do it, not technical meetings. For the Government to do it, to sit down with the unions and to sit down with employers. To listen, to dialogue, to not give up on convincing the unions and employers; to listen to them, to dialogue.

In summary, there is time, Mr. Rajoy, for this reform to become a fairer, more efficient reform, and above all, one that socially respects the balances that for many years have allowed our labor market to function with agreements, with agreements, and with agreements, because that social peace, Mr. Rajoy, is competitiveness in the veins.

President.- I do not share your opinion, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba. We have made a labor reform because there were five million more people in Spain who could not work, because more than half of young Spaniards could not work, because more than a million and a half people or families had all their members unemployed, because unemployment was increasing more and more, and because we were the country with the highest unemployment in all of Europe.

That is why we have made a labor reform, because we are the country with the highest unemployment in all of Europe, and we are doing it to promote employability, to flexibilize labor relations, to give opportunities to young people, to have more people who can mediate when it comes to placing individuals in the labor market, and to ensure that no organization has a monopoly on training or on the fact that people can enter the workforce.

I believe it is a reform in line with the rest of the European countries and I believe it will produce beneficial effects.

You are now telling us to negotiate with the unions; but, of course, back in 2008, the President of the Government appeared in this Chamber and encouraged employers and unions to negotiate, and they did not negotiate anything, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba. I am willing to negotiate and, in fact, we are talking. Why can't there be technical meetings? Those are the meetings that need to take place to address the issues that are part of the Royal Decree Law.

You yourselves announce an alternative text. Hey! Present the alternative text. However, you do not expect, as stated in the text of your question, that we accept your alternative text, because we are convinced of ours. We are talking and we are willing to discuss with the unions and with you things that may serve to enrich the text. Now, the impression I have, I tell you with absolute certainty, is that what is wanted is to maintain a system that has been functioning this way for thirty years and that is not adapted to the times we live in.

And I will tell you more, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba: if you present good amendments, I will consider them. I am not going to do what you did with your labor reform, because we presented 71 amendments and none were accepted; zero percent. Not a single one of the proposals we made, and we made 71, was accepted. I am not going to do it that way.