Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

12 May 2015 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in Spain's Congress on May 12, 2015, addressing Basque vocational training competences.
Main themes
Vocational training reform, Basque Country autonomy and competences, employment generation, regional legislative authority, Economic Agreement system, training quality and competition, active employment policies, decentralization
Duration
~23 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,799
73rd percentile
Sentences
96
61st percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
12.2
47th percentile
Syntax
3.34
85th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 51%48%
  • Institutional 22%21%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Social 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

96 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Aitor Esteban, from the Basque Parliamentary Group EAJ-PNV

Mr. Esteban.- Mr. President, Vocational Training in Euskadi is, I would say, leading, selective, within the whole State, with a dual training that is a reference. And seeking a model of excellence, beyond basic vocational training, therefore with many shades of particularity, on one hand legislative, because there is competence, according to the Statute of Autonomy, and because there was a Royal Decree of Transfers, 1441/2010, transferring functions in services related to Vocational Training for employment, which orders that things be managed in a certain way; and, on the other hand, due to the Economic Agreement system when it comes to financing.

Therefore, this requires, first, that in the management forms the Basque Autonomous Community can use all of them, from social security contribution bonuses to subsidies under competitive bidding regimes, etc., etc.; that it can combine its reality, which we have said before is quite specific, in terms of industrial fabric and in terms of, let’s say, specialization of Vocational Training beyond the general structure that the Law may set; that there is competence to accredit and register training entities, and the sanctioning power also regarding the obtaining and possible misuse of bonuses; or even the functions of programming, management, and control in centers in the Basque Country, beyond the fact that that group may have centers in other Autonomous Communities.

That is why I ask you if the Government is willing to negotiate corrections in the Bill for the urgent reform of the Vocational Training system.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Esteban. You know why this Royal Decree Law has been made, which does not aim to take away from anyone any competence that corresponds to them under current legislation. The objective of this Legislature, as you know, and it must be for the next one as well, is economic growth and generating employment in our country, and, above all, establishing solid foundations for the future so that this job creation can be maintained over time.

We have made many reforms, you know them and I will not reiterate them here; but this reform we are referring to today is crucial, fundamentally, because to have a job today it is necessary, of course, that there is economic activity, but it is also necessary to improve training in Spain.

Spain in the future will have to compete with trained people and with innovation, and not with anything else. You know that training was not functioning in Spain as we all wanted it to function; everyone knew it. I believe that this modification, this reform, is important. Training is opened to competition. Everyone will be able to present themselves, the best will win, and there will be no monopolies. There will be quality evaluations, information, control, and sanctions if there is fraud, and we have tried to do it with the utmost respect for all Autonomous Communities.

The objective is not, as I said at the beginning, and you know perfectly well, anything other than being able to increase employment in our country. I insist on not taking away competences from anyone. A good proof of this is that we have accepted that this Royal Decree Law be processed as a Bill and, therefore, what we want, and what we do with that, is to express our willingness to reach understandings in this matter with you or with any other political group.

I insist, the issue that concerns us is to make a reform of Vocational Training that is useful, that improves training and that thus makes it possible to create more employment in our country.

Mr. Esteban.- Mr. President, the competences of the Basque Country are not those of another Autonomous Community; they are special. And I must tell you that my question is not trivial, because this would be the fifth occasion in this Legislature in which competences in active employment policies are not respected, since Royal Decree Law 1/2013, Law 18/2014, Royal Decree Law 16/2014, and Royal Decree Law 1/2005. All of them have already been challenged by the Basque Government and now it would be again this Law, which is in processing.

The competence is not the same because, among other things, the Economic Agreement system of the Autonomous Community must be respected, and this has not been done in these decrees that I have mentioned earlier. And, on the other hand, the State Public Employment Service continues to intervene instead of Lanbide, the Basque service, despite the already agreed Royal Decree…

President.- I just want to reiterate that the deadline for amendments ends, I believe, on the 22nd of this month of May and what I can tell you is that, with respect to what current legislation and the Constitutional Court itself say, we are willing to talk with your Group to try to find a satisfactory solution.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Carlos Martínez Gorriarán, from the Parliamentary Group Union Progress and Democracy

Mr. Martínez Gorriarán.- Mr. President, I wanted to ask you, on behalf of my Group, what your Government plans to do to return to citizens the sixty thousand and something million euros invested in the rescue of the Savings Banks so far, of which, as you know, and according to the Bank of Spain, only about 4.3 percent has been recovered? Considering that the shares that the FROB, that is, the State, still holds in these rescued entities do not cover that amount by any means, we wanted to know what you plan to do to return to taxpayers, from whom that money came, the 58.829 million euros pending that are missing.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Martínez Gorriarán. I will get to the heart of the matter and then I will address the issue that concerns you.

When we came to Government, as you know, a substantial part of the Spanish financial system was bankrupt and there were two options: the first, to let the financial entities go bankrupt, which would have meant the loss of all jobs, the loss of people's deposits, the loss of investment funds and pension plans, and the loss of confidence in our country; and, of course, there would have been no recovery of credit.

This was one option, very respectable, and there was another, which is what the United Kingdom, Belgium, Holland, Germany, France, and countries already in another situation like, recently, Cyprus, Greece, or Portugal did, which is to try to save the financial system to prevent those perverse effects from occurring. We opted for this second option, like everyone else, which seemed the most reasonable to us. We requested a loan from the European Union, we were given 100 billion, we used 39 billion, a ten-year grace period, and an interest rate below 1 percent.

When will this be recovered or how will it be recovered? For now, the State, as you know, is the majority owner of an important bank, such as Bankia. From there, we will privatize it, but we will wait for the best conditions in the market with the aim of achieving the greatest recovery of the entire amount that has been borrowed and that, as you know, has a ten-year grace period and an interest rate below 1 percent.

Mr. Martínez Gorriarán.- Thank you for your accounting data, Mr. President, but I fear that is not the heart of the matter. I will tell you because many members of your Government, and you yourself, have said many times that this rescue, for several years now, since 2012 in particular, would not cost citizens a euro. And you yourself said a phrase that summarized the situation, from your point of view. You said in 2012: "It is a loan to the banks that the banks themselves will pay."

The facts are quite different and this is concerning. Let us remember, for example, that Banco de Sabadell acquired the Caja de Ahorros del Mediterráneo for one euro. That is not really a loan under normal conditions, nor a loan that the banks will pay; it is a gift. The rescue of the Galician savings banks, which were later acquired by the Venezuelan group Banesco, cost us eight billion euros, and that is already lost money, evidently.

You have talked about Bankia in which, indeed, the State is the main shareholder. Bankia recently held a shareholders' meeting where the distribution of profits was already discussed. Come on! Don’t you think that Bankia's first priority should be to return to the State, and therefore to taxpayers, the largest possible portion of the twenty-four billion euros we need to balance the economy, to create jobs, and to invest in R&D, education, health, etc., etc., etc.?

The question remains the same, you have not answered me: What are you going to do? Are you going to make a tax reduction to compensate citizens? Are we going to see measures to rehire those dismissed by many of these entities also through ERE in their own banking expansions that in the end, this is what has happened? Are you going to compensate for the cuts that have occurred in these years, precisely to sanitize the financial system? Because it is very well to say that there were two alternatives, but there was never a real debate about those alternatives or their consequences.

What has happened has been, in fact, a rescue of the Banking from which, ultimately, the private banking has benefited and which has meant the disappearance of that kind of public banking that were the Savings Banks made with the savings of small savers, SMEs, the deposits of public institutions, etc. And this is the question: What are you going to do…?

President.- I insist, Mr. Martínez Gorriarán: there were two options: If we had let the financial entities go bankrupt, who would have paid the deposits of taxpayers? What would have happened to jobs? What would have happened to investment funds or pension plans? What would have happened to the loss of confidence in our country? That was one option, but in that option no one bet on it in Europe, no one. There is no country that simply let its financial entities go bankrupt.

I believe that beneficial effects have occurred: we have regained confidence in the financial sector, both inside and outside Spain; the stress tests conducted by the ECB place us at the forefront of Europe; credit has returned to our country; the risk premium has fallen; we are financing ourselves at incredibly low prices and, certainly, as has never happened in our history; people have their deposits and their jobs…

What are we going to do? We will privatize Bankia, which will have significant value, when that value is the best in the market. At this moment Bankia, as you know, is a public entity and, therefore, the owner is the State, and, therefore, the Spanish taxpayers; but the idea is to put it on the market so that…

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pedro Sánchez, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Sánchez.- Mr. Rajoy, I would like to know your opinion on the situation of young people in our country.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Sánchez.

The main problem that young people have in our country, as a whole of Spanish society, is unemployment, which prevents them from carrying out an independent life project. It has been the main objective of this Legislature, and it must be for the next one as well, as I have said on numerous occasions, the creation of employment, and I can say that at this moment there are already positive data. We started from an impossible situation, but a change of trend has already occurred, although we still have many things to do.

Mr. Sánchez.- Mr. Rajoy, if you did not read the papers that are written for you and spoke from the heart, you would see that it is impossible to say, Mr. Rajoy, that young people are living better since you became President of the Government.

Look, the bad things that have happened during these three and a half years are not the erratic nature of your Government's policies, but that, on top of that, you boast about it. You boast about it, Mr. Rajoy, and I am going to give you a piece of data that certifies the failure of your economic policies and your triumphalist discourse on the economy: two million young people under 34 years old are unemployed in our country. Two million young people.

I do not know what you are boasting about, Mr. Rajoy, because, as a result of your Government's negligence, for example, the Youth Guarantee Plan has not been developed during this last year and, as a result, only 4 percent of unemployed young people have taken advantage of that Plan. So, what are you boasting about, Mr. Rajoy? Because what is happening in this country, as a result of your economic policies, is that right now young people are either unemployed or tied to the wheel of labor precariousness. Seven out of ten young hires are part-time, Mr. Rajoy; temporary.

I am going to tell you one thing: you are greatly complicating the job situation for young people, and you are also doing another thing: you are greatly complicating the training of young people, because what you have done is raise university fees by 40 percent and cut the amounts of scholarships by six hundred euros, that is, by an average of 20 percent compared to what you inherited in 2011. And a country, ladies and gentlemen, that in 2011 was a leader in Erasmus scholarships, with an investment of over 60 million euros, you have left with just over 35 million euros during these last three and a half years.

So, Mr. Rajoy, you are only offering young people two options: one, the passport; and, two, the INEM. Those are the solutions you are offering to young people and, as a consequence, there are five hundred thousand young people who have left Spain in recent years because there are no opportunities in Spain. That is what Mrs. Báñez calls "external mobility."

But I tell you one thing, Mr. Rajoy, those two million young people who are unemployed, who are abandoned to their fate as a consequence of the neglect of the Government of Spain; those two million young people, do not be surprised if both they and their families, very soon, will leave you and your entire Government without a job.

President.- I write my papers, Mr. Sánchez. I am not like you, who we saw in the State of the Nation Debate reading a reply.

But, in any case, I would recommend that you also write your papers, among other things, to speak properly because, of course, to say here that five hundred thousand young people have left Spain is a lie. It is exactly 24,638 -- I have it written here -- according to the National Institute of Statistics. That is why it is advisable for you to write your papers, for which it is also good for you to read something beforehand.

Come on!, to boast about job creation seems to me that you are not the most suitable person, because in the last Legislature, 1,771,517 jobs for young people were lost in Spain. Therefore, I am very sorry, but I cannot accept any lesson from you.

What I can tell you, for your satisfaction, is that if you had read and written something as well, the latest EPA, you could verify that today there are already fewer young people unemployed than when we came to power in 2011, that the EPA says that youth employment is growing by 4.7 percent and that the Social Security data from last month says that employment is growing by 9.2 percent.

Therefore, you must write and, above all, you must read, and you must know what an economic policy that creates jobs is, which is what is happening now in Spain, and not an economic policy like the one you practiced, which only destroyed jobs.

Your economic policy is a step backward; it is a return to a time that fortunately we have already overcome because, luckily, today in Spain there is economic growth -- the first country in the European Union in growth -- and job creation is taking place: 440,000 people found a job last year and 600,000 are going to find one now, which means we are starting to recover the jobs that were lost in Spain when you were in power.

Thank you very much.