Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

25 May 2015 · Parliamentary control session (sesión de control)

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions from the Socialist Group during a May 2015 congressional control session amid rising inequality debate in Spain.
Main themes
Inequality in Spain, poverty and social exclusion, economic recovery claims, job creation and unemployment, welfare state dismantlement, austerity and spending cuts, Survey of Living Conditions, education cuts, healthcare privatization, corruption, labor reform, OECD and Eurostat data
Duration
~50 min
94th percentile
Words
6,058
94th percentile
Sentences
216
91st percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
3.37
87th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 55%53%
  • Social 17%17%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Institutional 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

216 sentences in 87 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. María Victoria Chivite, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Ms. Chivite.- Mr. Rajoy, today, precisely today, as the Survey of Living Conditions in Spain is published, I want to ask you about the consequences of the social gap that your policies have had on Spanish society as a whole. Are you aware, Mr. Rajoy, of the brutal inequality that your policies have caused throughout Spanish society, using the crisis as an excuse?

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Chivite. The main cause of inequality—there are others, but the main one—the most important, is the destruction of jobs. The OECD pointed this out in a recent report, we all know this who are concerned about these issues, and not long ago you invited an important expert in these matters who said, indeed, here in Spain, that the main cause of inequality was the destruction of jobs. That is why the moment of greatest increase in inequality in Spain—I refer to the 80/20 indicator, which compares what the richest 20 percent earn with the poorest 20 percent—began to worsen from the year 2007 and rose from 5.5 to 6.5 percent. The data from 2012 is a little better, the data from 2013 is a little worse again, because 2013 was still a bad year from an economic point of view: negative growth of -1.2 percent and there was also an increase in unemployment in our country, which only began to improve at the end of 2013.

We still do not know the data for the year 2014 and, of course, the data for the year 2015; but, given the figures for economic growth and job creation, I am absolutely convinced that these indicators will improve, and therefore, the situation of inequality in our country will also improve.

Ms. Chivite.- Mr. Rajoy, last Sunday the citizens in Spain began to turn the page on a legislature full of blots, political shamelessness, and inequality, and fortunately began to write the beginning of the end of this lost Legislature for the citizens of Spain. The electoral results that you are collecting are the result of the corruption that suffocates your party and the harsh cuts you have made to millions of citizens in Spain.

And honestly, Mr. Rajoy, after the press conference you gave yesterday, I reaffirm that you are completely out of touch, Mr. Rajoy. You even dare to claim during a visit to Navarra that no one talks about unemployment anymore, and it is that you are completely out of touch, as I said. You try to sell us an economic recovery that is not even close to a social recovery, because there are millions of people in Spain who live in a reality that you ignore, but which is real, which is the reality of inequality, the reality of precariousness, the reality of exclusion and poverty. I tell you this, and the citizens tell you this, but the OECD also tells you this.

We are the third most unequal society in Europe, only surpassed by Greece and Portugal. Eighteen percent of our population lives below the poverty line, especially young people and especially women, single women heading a family. And in Spain, 10 percent of households have lost an average of 13 percent of their income each year. Eurostat, another piece of data, has also told us that thirteen of our seventeen Autonomous Communities are among the poorest in Europe. The IMF has told us that the Spanish economy has fallen from being the ninth in the world to the fourteenth.

Furthermore, Mr. Rajoy, we have two million people at risk of poverty, despite being employed, thanks to your magnificent labor reform. A third of those workers are self-employed or false self-employed. 2.3 million people are below the poverty line and two out of three unemployed do not receive any type of public assistance, and you call this recovery.

Listen, Mr. Rajoy: today, today, the INE has published the Survey of Living Conditions in Spain and do you know what it says? It says that one in five Spaniards lives below the poverty line, with less than eight thousand euros a year, and one in three children under sixteen lives below the poverty line.

This is, Mr. Rajoy, the legacy you are going to leave, and moreover, you have left no stone unturned. In education, you have obliterated equal opportunities, you have eliminated scholarships, you have torpedoed university education, and you have removed more than twenty thousand teachers from public schools. In healthcare, you have imposed co-payments, privatized hospitals, and reduced benefits. Not to mention the paralysis of the Dependency Law.

In short, you have dismantled the Welfare State, which guarantees equal opportunities for all Spaniards, because your true obsession has been that not all of us are equal, nor that we all have the same opportunities, because you have only given opportunities to 10 percent of the population and have created problems for 90 percent of Spaniards. Because it is not the crisis, Mr. Rajoy; it is what you have done, it is your conception of the world, it is your ideology. Not the crisis nor the legacy, only your ideology and the ideology of the Popular Party. You have worked for 10 percent of Spaniards and have gone against 90 percent of Spaniards.

And do not talk to us about recovery when 25 percent are unemployed. Thousands of young people are in exile, millions of people suffer poverty and are in a situation of exclusion.

The citizens tell you this loud and clear, they tell you this in every survey, they tell you this at the demonstrations, and they also told you this on Sunday in the elections. And your reflection, your only reflection, Mr. Rajoy, has been: the PP must be closer to the citizens. These are the reflections you make, Mr. Rajoy. Is that all you can come up with?

You always resort to the inherited legacy as an excuse to cover your political shamelessness; but, Mr. Rajoy, the legacy that we socialists will receive when we come to power is the legacy of a political ruin and a social ruin. That is the legacy you are going to leave us. Mr. Rajoy, you have only just begun to reap the fruits of what you have sown. The Spaniards are turning their backs on you, so, Mr. Rajoy, start packing your bags.

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Chivite. I do not know when the socialists will come to power, but if the results they are going to have are the ones you had in Navarra, where you are the fifth political force, I think it will take a long time for you to reach the Government.

The Popular Party has had its difficulties in these elections, but it has been the most voted force by the Spaniards, above your party. You need to prepare your interventions a little better because, if not, you end up with what is happening to you at this moment: the fifth political force in Navarra. Candidate? Ms. Chivite.

Let’s go to the response. As I said in my first intervention, the most effective policy to combat inequality is the fight against unemployment. That is why, when you governed and with your political decisions caused 3,400,000 Spaniards to lose their jobs, inequality obviously rose, and a lot, in our country. That is what we are correcting now.

The first year of this Legislature, the year 2012, was bad; we were in the midst of a crisis; we had to fight against the bailout, against the threat of bankruptcy, and against the possible exit from the euro; but in that year and in 2013 we began to lay the foundations, with the economic reforms we made, to be able to grow and generate jobs in the future.

The year 2014 was the first year in which jobs were created in Spain after seven years: 440,000 Spaniards found a job. The EPA for the first quarter of this year 2015 says that 504,000 more Spaniards are employed than last year, and the Social Security data is also good: between April of this year and April of last year, there are 578,000 more affiliates to Social Security. And there are some other data that, without a doubt, can give us hope to all of us here: the number of households with all members unemployed has decreased, according to the latest EPA, by 185,000; the number of people who have been unemployed for more than a year has decreased by 247,000, and the data for young people under twenty-four is also interesting, because 99,300 young people have found a job in the last year.

Undoubtedly, there are many things left to do, but we have already changed the trend: from negative growth and recession we have moved to positive growth and job creation. And it is also important that of the 504,000 jobs created last year, 60 percent are permanent and that temporary employment is now at 23.6 percent.

Therefore, what we need to do is persevere in the policies that create jobs, because it is the most effective way to combat inequality. But there are also some other things on which we have made important decisions. For example, we have extended the PREPARA for those people who finish unemployment insurance, we have signed with Comisiones Obreras and UGT the new benefit for activity for long-term unemployed; the tax reform is also moving in the direction of inequality, to correct inequality, because people earning twelve thousand euros a year will not pay, and for those earning less than twenty-four thousand, which is 72 percent of taxpayers, the reduction will be 23.5 percent; we are maintaining social policies, and the FLA and supplier policies I believe have been very useful for these purposes, the same goes for the municipalities.

Therefore, what we need to do now is persevere, trying to generate more economic activity so that jobs can be created, so that people can work and the Administration can collect more money to maintain essential public services and fight more effectively against inequality.

What is evident is that the period of greatest inequality in the history of Spain is the last Legislature in which you governed, and apparently, you still have not realized it.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. José Montilla, of the Entesa pel Progrés de Catalunya Parliamentary Group

Mr. Montilla.- Mr. President, last week I attended the MAX Awards Gala for the Performing Arts, which this year was held in Barcelona. Once again, this event highlighted the quality and drive of those who make possible the vitality of our cultural and artistic offerings, a vitality that constitutes a stimulus for our society and reflects the importance and usefulness of the cultural industries.

It is likely that, given your work schedule, you did not have the opportunity to see the gala, even though it was broadcast by Televisión Española on delay; but I am sure, however, that your collaborators or perhaps the minister in charge have informed you of the advocacy content of the event throughout its development, focused mainly on the sector's complaint about the VAT rate of 21 percent. A bitter complaint, Mr. President, from people who believe that culture and art allow citizens to expand their values, enjoy the beauty of a show, share the emotion of shared feelings, or simply have a good moment of leisure. This, in addition, helps to build a more cohesive, more mature society, and, if you allow me, a more intelligent one.

The decision to tax culture, and more specifically, cinema, music, and the performing arts with a VAT of 21 percent, besides being a measure of dubious revenue effectiveness, has very negative effects for this sector that performs a very relevant social function. Furthermore, this tax increase diminishes the competitiveness of our cultural industries in the European market, as most countries in the Union, as you know, apply reduced rates to these activities.

The fiscal penalty on the cultural industry is further aggravated by the failure to fulfill your electoral commitments regarding a Sponsorship Law that you promised and that, like other electoral commitments, you have not fulfilled.

Throughout these months, there have been numerous conversations between the Ministry of Education and Culture and representatives of the cultural industries, of which I am sure you have been informed. From these conversations, not to call them negotiations, I do not know, there was a certain hope that your Government would modify this decision by setting the rate at 10 percent.

Mr. President, do you acknowledge the existence of these negotiations? Do you plan to modify the VAT rate for culture? Does your Government intend to propose a Sponsorship Law to facilitate the promotion of culture in our country?

President.- Thank you very much for your intervention, Mr. Montilla. I will point out three or four general ideas and then I will address the specific issue you raised.

I believe we must all make an effort to preserve public services in our country. I believe that in Spain we have good public services, especially when we compare ourselves with most countries in the world: we have a good pension system, healthcare, and public education, and good infrastructure. Undoubtedly, we can improve it, and that is the goal as the standard of living in our country improves.

There is a second idea that is also important and we must fight for it, which is that income and expenses must balance because, if income and expenses do not balance, problems will ultimately arise.

When I arrived in government, I found a public deficit of 9.1 percent, and therefore it was necessary to request 90 billion euros a year to cover it. There were many difficulties in financing, given the state of the risk premium at that time, and, logically, this forced us to make decisions that were tough, difficult, and not in our program, such as the increase in the Personal Income Tax or the increase in the Value Added Tax itself, to which you have referred.

The third idea I wanted to convey to you is that, in order for there to be income and, therefore, for us to have public services, there must be growth and employment. If there is growth and employment, there is more revenue, and moreover, the burden can be divided among more people, and therefore, some taxes can be lowered.

This is how we have approached this Legislature, and what we have done is the following: first, we have reduced the public deficit, which I estimate will be half of what it was in 2011 by the end of this year 2015; we have maintained fundamental public services, and at the beginning, as I mentioned, we raised taxes, but we have already made some important decisions regarding taxes: in 2013 we began, in the case of SMEs and self-employed workers, selectively to promote growth and employment; in 2014 we lowered the Personal Income Tax and the Corporate Tax, in a reform that came into effect this year; and in 2016 this same reform will have its second part.

You referred to the case of VAT. Undoubtedly, it is an important issue and one that is debated, and in fact has caused much controversy. We preferred at that time to maintain the reduced VAT in some cultural aspects; for example, the VAT on books, museum admissions, or library entries. We made an effort to maintain the VAT for the tourism sector, which is very important for the Spanish Gross Domestic Product, providing more than two million jobs, and we kept it at 10 percent.

What happens is that in politics, as in any aspect of life, one must adapt to circumstances. Look, for example, at Greece: after all we have heard over the past few months, the reduced VAT rate, the minimum, for culture and basic products, food, will be set at 9.5 percent.

Therefore, in relation to the question you are asking me, it all depends on how revenue goes in the coming periods; but the philosophy of the Popular Party is to try to lower the Corporate Tax again, to try to lower the Personal Income Tax again, and, if possible, also the VAT. But what is important is how revenue goes at this moment.

Mr. Montilla.- Apart from the general considerations you have made about the preservation of public services and the balance of income and expenses, and the growth of employment, which at a philosophical level we could even share --not so much the measures you have taken, because they certainly do not guarantee the same--; I was specifically talking about the consequences of the increase in cultural VAT, because there is generally a retraction in cultural consumption, which you already know is low compared to other countries in the European Union. Cinema, musical performances, and even theater and dance have today less audience, except for a few exceptions, motivated by the specific success of some theatrical or cinematic production.

What is happening puts the vitality of this sector at risk, and we cannot afford that, because an episode of poor health for culture is also an episode of poor health for our society.

To give an example, according to data from the General Society of Authors, in the first twelve months with VAT at 21 percent, the number of concerts in Spain fell by around 22 percent. And, you know, that decline in live music, for example, particularly affects our youth, who I believe are already sufficiently burdened with other issues. It is true that some sectors of culture have been able to cushion the blow in some way, internalizing the effects of the tax increase without it affecting box office revenues; but that also has consequences. Today in Spain, theatrical, lyrical, or dance productions are carried out with fewer actors and actresses, with less choreography and staging, with fewer lighting resources or effects.

I am not against simplicity or austerity, even in cultural production; but what may be happening is a loss of quality in our artistic production as well, as a consequence of the economic difficulties of the producers; a reduction in quality that also has fiscal repercussions in terms of lower revenue from Corporate Tax or lower income for Social Security.

Mr. President, are you not surprised that the countries in our European environment with which you like to compare yourself have much lower VAT rates? France, 5.5 percent; the Netherlands and Belgium, 6 percent; Germany, 7 percent; Ireland, 9 percent; Italy, 10 percent; Portugal, 13 percent.

Do not continue talking a bit about the refrain of the inheritance because, when we are a few months from the end of the Legislature, it is no longer reasonable to insist on that story. Here the inheritance, the only inheritance, that will exist is the one you will leave, which the Spanish people will have the opportunity to judge in a few months.

Why not place the VAT debate in a more reasonable and common-sense territory? How much have you collected extra with the increase to 21 percent? How much would you collect with a VAT of 10 percent, for example, also taking into account the expected increase in cultural consumption? How much money are we talking about, Mr. President? Because you have allowed yourselves to lower the Income Tax for those earning more than one hundred thousand euros, and yet, not incentivize culture with a more reasonable tax rate. You said you would lower the VAT and you raised it.

I have read in your electoral program for these elections, the ones from last Sunday, new and reiterated commitments. I read point 283 of your program, which says: "we will promote a tax review of culture that brings us closer to the countries in our environment, thereby favoring local talent and our capacity to compete in national and international markets." Does this mean you will lower cultural VAT, Mr. President?

Point 281 of your program says: "we will support foundations and private companies associated with the field of cultural management." Does this mean you will present a Patronage Law?

I conclude, Mr. President. Modify the VAT on cinema, music, and performing arts to around 10 percent and promote the Patronage Law. You still have time to fulfill, even if exceptionally, with some of your electoral commitments. We already know that your Minister of Finance is probably not very interested in theater or music; but you do not have to emulate him in this, Mr. President.

President.- I believe that in the first part of my presentation it has been very clear what the political approach we have carried out over these three years has been; the reasons for the increase --then decrease-- of the Personal Income Tax; the reasons for supporting SMEs and entrepreneurs, where there are also many cultural industries --and this is good to remember-- and the reasons regarding the Corporate Tax.

If revenue continues to improve, as it is improving this year, we can make decisions in that area. In this sense, we are not here facing any ideological decision. It is a situation of enormous complexity that our country and other countries have experienced. I cited the case of Greece. I am absolutely convinced that Greece does not want to raise the minimum VAT to 9.5 percent and yet, it will raise it.

You have given me many data about VAT in other European countries. I can give you others, but I think it is of no use; but the United Kingdom, 20 percent VAT on culture and Denmark, 25 percent. Here there is a part of cultural VAT that is at 4 percent: books, archives, libraries... And, undoubtedly, we will see how things evolve in the future.

But I had to make important decisions, I reiterate them to you: the hospitality sector was very important and there are countries that have, being tourist countries, this sector with 23 percent VAT; here we have 10 percent VAT. I believe that is also a positive data. If I had raised it to 21 percent, I would be answering a question here.

Therefore, I insist, I believe that at this moment we have the advantage that revenue is increasing in our country, we must continue to meet our deficit objectives and, as economic growth and more employment occur, logically more will be collected and we can touch some tax figures.

But if you ask me "at this specific moment," I am not going to make any further changes in the tax legislation other than the Income Tax and the Corporate Tax for next year 2016, without ruling it out in the future.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. María del Mar del Pino Julios, from the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Ms. Julios.- Mr. President, do you consider it a criterion of cohesion and balance that, while 3.1 billion euros are being tendered this year for High Speed, your Government continues to maintain drastic cuts in the Canary Islands, such as, for example, the Road Agreement, which already amounts to 628 million in these four years, paralyzing works of general interest for the territorial and social cohesion of the Archipelago?

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Julios. As you know, from a budgetary point of view we have lived through a very complicated stage in the national government, but also in the autonomous governments and also in local corporations. Priorities had to be set, and we have done so. The most important priority for us was the public pension system and unemployment insurance; for the Autonomous Communities, it has been the major fundamental public services, such as health and education.

And regarding the Road Agreement of the Canary Islands, I would like to say something, which you already know, but it is good for all of us to know. In the Canary Islands, there is no State Road Network, but even so, the State, due to the special situation of the Canary Islands, makes investments in the roads that are the responsibility of the Autonomous Community of the Canary Islands. There has been an Agreement, in which 2.4 billion have been invested over many years, with different governments in Spain, and in this Legislature, there has indeed been a reduction, as you pointed out: instead of the 207 million euros annually from the Agreement, there have been 68 million in 2012 and 54 million in 2013, in 2014 and in 2015. But even so, since 1994 the State has contributed 2.3 billion euros to the Canary Islands.

Then, there is a piece of information that is also relevant, and I believe that, to make a more balanced judgment, we all need to know: there was a strong reduction in investments in roads across Spain and the national average reduction was six percentage points above the reduction in road investment in the Canary Islands.

Therefore, I am not saying that you are not right regarding the Agreement; but what is evident is that the budgetary situation has forced, as we all know, to make complex and difficult decisions. In fact, the very question that Mr. Montilla just asked me goes exactly in the same direction.

Ms. Julios.- Mr. President, I am going to remind you now here of the words you said during the Investiture Debate regarding the Canary Islands. You said: "we carried out --referring to up to 2008-- an infrastructure plan, a coastal plan, a road plan, an employment plan. These were commitments that were fulfilled. I myself traveled a good part of the roads in the Canary Islands, I had the pleasure of traveling a good part of the roads in the Canary Islands and, among other things, that journey confirmed to me that the claims made there were very reasonable and just." You continued your speech and concluded by saying "that you would remain committed to the Canary Islands."

I regret to inform you, Mr. President, that we believe that this has not been the case. The majority of the items I just mentioned and that you mentioned in your investiture speech have disappeared. Even a large part of the items from the Agreements that were signed with works already awarded.

I want to comment on what two institutions say, one, the Foundation for Applied Economic Studies (FEDEA) and the other, the Court of Auditors itself regarding the AVE. Both say that it presents a negative social and financial return, and that it should not have been built. The Court of Auditors says: "it is unsustainable. The current financing model generates --in relation to the AVE-- a serious problem of economic sustainability, given the high indebtedness to which the public sector has resorted to build it." 9.142 billion euros are what will have to start being repaid due to the indebtedness in relation to this starting in 2017.

You will understand, Mr. President, that with these figures and these reports, many of us in the Canary Islands question the austerity criteria of your Government and the equity with which territorial funds, the funds of all Spaniards, are distributed. Meanwhile, Your Honor, in the Canary Islands, that cut in the signed agreements, those for roads, and other agreements as well, continues to be maintained, but also the PIEC, the Comprehensive Employment Plan for the Canary Islands, has disappeared to zero; the contribution that the State made for tourist infrastructures and for educational infrastructures. Allow me to say that there has been no progress in favoring territorial cohesion and connectivity of the archipelago; on the contrary, we have gone backwards.

It is hard, Your Honor, to believe you when you say that it is only due to the crisis, when, however, the budgets for this year 2015 for the AVE are increasing by 11.5 percent: 3.5 billion. Why is there money for this multimillion-dollar investment? Why is there 1.2 billion to modernize the commuter trains, which you just announced, which I do not question the need for? What Coalition Canaria is asking is, why is there no money for the Canary Islands?

We are not against, absolutely not, Mr. President, the territorial integration of the Peninsula, even if some sections of the AVE are necessary for social reasons; but we ask: and the integration of the Canary Islands? Why are the cuts not the same for everyone, for all territories? Forty-five percent of the budget for Development goes to the AVE, while other territories, like the Canary Islands, continue to have serious structural deficiencies: towns completely cut off in every way, only by a road that is not finished being built, like La Aldea; or islands cut off, with prohibitive ticket prices on key dates.

In various motions defended by Senator Narváez, it has been demanded that maximum prices be set in the islands for tickets between the Islands and the Peninsula to end abusive prices; that the subsidy for tickets be increased by at least 75 percent for citizens of the non-capital islands; that point-to-point rates be established as mandatory, as there are in many other means of transport in the Peninsula, or a flat rate for inter-island flights.

Mr. President, all experts say that in Spain, infrastructures have been built without a global planning that takes into account the different modes of transport in Spain, and certainly, the Canary Islands are still further away from that planning.

I ask you, Mr. President, and I do not know how you are going to respond, and I would ask you to leave behind the arrogance and pride that at times some members of your Government express. The Popular Party has also defended significantly in these last elections in the Canary Islands. Look at it however you want, that has been the case. I tell you, Mr. President, that the citizens in the Canary Islands do not understand why the Canary Islands continue to be punished. And do not deceive yourself, Mr. President, it is not a problem of difficulties in the way the Government communicates, nor of you, nor of the Popular Party; it is a problem that your political strategies and priorities are wrong, they are antisocial, and, moreover, they are fostering inequality between territories.

I urge you to rectify. You speak of improving macroeconomic figures; avoid past mistakes, Your Honor; provide a response to the proper planning of all the transport problems that Spain has, and especially the Canary Islands; please move forward, recovering dialogue and consensus with the Government of the Canary Islands, to jointly resolve the serious structural problems of mobility and transport that we have in the Canary Islands due to our remoteness, due to our insularity.

Mr. President, we in the Canary Islands also want to get out of the crisis and the unequal distribution of wealth in Spain, the unequal distribution of public funds, and in Spain, from the Government of Spain, what is being fostered is territorial inequality. And that is not good for economic growth, neither in the Canary Islands nor anywhere else.

President.- Indeed, I know the plans that were signed, in my previous term in the Government of Spain as minister, with the Community of the Canary Islands, because, in addition, I was the one responsible in the Government, as Minister of Public Administrations, for monitoring them. And I believe that, without a doubt, very good work was done.

I cannot share your assertion of punishing the Canary Islands. We neither punish the Canary Islands nor punish any other Autonomous Community in Spain. Simply, what has happened is that between the years 2008 and 2009, seventy billion euros of revenue were lost in our country, eleven trillion of the old pesetas, as a consequence of the fall in economic growth and employment, and we have not yet recovered from that. And, as you know, that forced us to tighten our belts, to control spending. We also had deficit commitments with the European Union and had to set priorities.

My priority, honestly, was not roads or trains; my priority was to maintain pensions; secondly, unemployment insurance, and then the major fundamental public services. And from there, we would make the decisions that were best for all citizens.

Now, having said that, I would like to make two or three comments regarding your intervention.

The policies promoted by the Government of Spain have a fundamental objective, which is to generate economic growth and employment, and this benefits all Spaniards, and therefore also benefits all Canarians. When employment is currently rising in the Canary Islands, the economic policies being implemented by the Government of Spain also have something to do with that.

I want to say, secondly, that you have cited the things you do not like that have not been done; but you have not made any reference to any of the important decisions that this Government has made. I remind you again that all the roads in the Canary Islands are the responsibility of the Government of the Canary Islands. In pure technical terms, it should be the Government of the Canary Islands that pays for all that, and that does not happen, and I am in favor of it not happening.

Thirdly, there is something that is very important: the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands has recently been approved with very favorable conditions; there is a complete renewal of the specific tax incentives for the Canary Islands; the Reserve for Investments in the Canary Islands is renewed --very important-- and for the first time it will be able to materialize in the creation of jobs not linked to a new investment project --this is very important--; a new deduction for investments by entities with tax residence in the Canary Islands made in certain countries; and it is increased, which is also very important, to 45 percent the deduction for technological innovation to promote high value-added investments in the Canary Islands.

You have not talked about this, but this is very important and greatly affects the economic growth of the Canary Islands and its own future.

On the other hand, I want to remind you that the State has made significant investments in the Canary Islands: nearly 1.5 billion euros in investments. Specifically, the General Budgets for this year have territorialized 267 million. Investment in roads has continued, the railway agreements are also ongoing, and then, the transport subsidies are very important, which have amounted to 665 million euros, and for 2015, 239 million are planned in the Budgets, which is a 12 percent increase from 2014, and in the case of goods, the subsidy increases by 42 percent.

These are also positive figures, and you could have logically referred to them in your intervention.

Also, the tax reform that has been carried out affects the citizens of the Canary Islands. And then there is something that is crucial, which are the extraordinary measures to support liquidity: 3.847 billion euros have been allocated to the Canary Islands. This is very important because it has allowed services in the Canary Islands to be attended to for an amount of 1.5 billion distributed between health and education.

The Payment Plan to Suppliers was widely used in the Canary Islands: 315 million, the Government and 512 million, the Local Corporations. Thanks to that, many suppliers, who were not being paid by the Administrations, began to do so.

Moreover, this year --and this is also important--, thanks to the measures adopted during the year 2014 taking advantage of the improvement in the economic situation, the Canary Islands, from the new Financial Facility Fund, will benefit from 958 million euros and the financing rate will be zero for its outstanding debt, for FLA, for the Payment Plan to Suppliers and for the new loans. This will mean a saving of 716 million euros.

So, you may be right that we dedicate somewhat less to roads; but where you are wrong is in saying that the Government has not taken care of the most important issues that exist in the Canary Islands at this moment, as I believe I have demonstrated in the intervention I have just made.

Thank you very much.