Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

26 May 2015 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to opposition challenges in a Spanish parliamentary control session on 26 May 2015, defending his government's legitimacy and infrastructure spending.
Main themes
Government legitimacy, democratic mandate, parliamentary debate, Cercanías rail service investment, public transport infrastructure, Catalonia rail network, high-speed rail vs commuter rail funding, regional government responsibility
Duration
~17 min
59th percentile
Words
2,074
59th percentile
Sentences
78
51st percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
12.8
54th percentile
Syntax
3.41
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.31
75th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 47%35%
  • Social 21%15%
  • Ceremonial 21%15%
  • Economic 11%8%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 27%

78 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Mr. Rajoy, do you know what this is called? This is called "pucherazo." A pucherazo of a bad loser, a pucherazo of a cheating player.

Mr. Rajoy, as all the polls indicate, and you know it, and it has been confirmed by the Andalusian, regional, and municipal elections, you are usurping a power that does not belong to you. It is that clear. You are making use of a parliamentary majority that has long expired, and you know what happens with expired products: they are harmful to health; the democratic health, in this case.

Mr. Rajoy, no more pucherazos, no more pucherazos, no more pucherazos.

President.- Your intervention is, evidently, undemocratic, which does not surprise me at all given your political and other trajectories over many years.

This Government that I lead is a legitimate Government; it has the support of more than 180 deputies in this Chamber; it has been voted for by more than eleven million Spaniards; it has a four-year mandate, as stated by the Constitution and laws, and we will continue to approve laws until the end of the Legislature, because we intend to fulfill an electoral program and because, as I have said on numerous occasions, ours is a reformist policy and there are many reforms that need to be made for the future.

Therefore, I insist, this Government is a legitimate, democratic Government, and it seems unbelievable that in the year 2015 we can still hear such crude, undemocratic, and illegitimate interventions in this Chamber. Those are indeed illegitimate.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pere Macias, from the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

Mr. Macías.- Mr. President, today you came by car, others have come on foot, but there are hundreds of thousands of citizens who need a good public transport service to get to their work in Madrid, Barcelona, and other cities.

Have you ever wondered what happens when this service is not reliable, when delays are common; breakdowns, frequent; information, scarce and, often, as happened last week in Barcelona, chaos affects eighty thousand citizens?

The Government, Mr. President, cannot be proud of how citizens are treated in such an essential service. For this reason, I ask you what the Government has done and what it plans to do to improve the Cercanías service.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Macías. The Government of Spain invests significant amounts in infrastructure in Catalonia; specifically, throughout this Legislature, in railways, 2.9 billion. In the budgets of this Legislature, we have allocated more than 570 million euros to Cercanías in Catalonia, to which we must add almost 90 million annually for maintenance. Therefore, I want to say that we have taken care of the Rodalies of Catalonia because it has the most extensive network, with 670 kilometers and 145 stations, and each year it has more than 105 million passengers.

Mr. Macías.- The figures, Mr. Rajoy, your figures, are very eloquent. In this Legislature --these are data from your Government-- in investment, not maintenance, the Government has allocated 14 billion to High Speed throughout Spain and only 169 million in investment in Cercanías; a miserable 1.1 percent.

With such insufficient investment, Mr. President, everything suffers: the catenaries fail, the power supply fails, the control systems fail, and even the central software fails. This does not take into account that the chronic lack of investment in the network does not allow for adequate frequencies.

The Government has not done, Mr. President, its homework. I will give you a fact: through the ADIF tunnels in Barcelona, a maximum of nineteen trains circulate per hour. A few meters away, through the tunnels of the Generalitat railways, 32 circulate. What is the reason? That some have been investing for years with continuous and noticeable improvements, while your Government neglected the problem.

It is not useful, Mr. Rajoy, to blame the Generalitat. Without trains, without stations, without tracks, which are your responsibility, you have the nerve to blame the Generalitat for the disaster of Cercanías! It is also not useful to present a virtual plan at the end of the mandate --which, by the way, is not even on the Ministry's website-- for Cercanías.

Mr. Rajoy, talking about Cercanías is talking about social railways, which truly affect citizens in their daily lives. You cannot, Mr. President, leave them stranded every morning.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Macías. I remind you that on the day the event that motivated this question occurred, lines 9 and 10 of the Barcelona Metro, managed by the Generalitat, suffered a similar incident for four hours. They were paralyzed between three and seven in the afternoon, forcing the evacuation of numerous passengers.

I remind you that investments in transport by the Generalitat of Catalonia have decreased by almost 65 percent in the period 2011-2013.

And regarding the incident on Thursday, May 21, it originated from a software failure at the Control Center during a scheduled maintenance process. It is true that the breakdown, lasting just under an hour and a half, affected users of a good number of early morning trains, to whom I extend my apologies from here; and, in any case, by eight o'clock, the proper functioning of the systems and normality in railway services were restored.

I want to say that measures were taken from the very first moment. The company responsible for the software used the secondary or emergency control system. As soon as the incident was resolved, we proceeded to review the action protocol and requested, finally, responsibilities from the contracting company, and we have opened a file, whose penalty can reach up to the termination of the contract.

Regarding the progress made in the Legislature in terms of Cercanías, improvement works have been carried out in 74 stations, 12 infrastructure improvement actions have been put into service, and accessibility improvement actions have been carried out.

I also want to say that this same month of May we have put out to tender the ERTMS in the Cercanías of Barcelona; specifically, in the section between Hospitalet and Mataró. On the 14th, we began actions to double the R-3 Line, tendering the contract to draft the first project; on the 15th, we authorized the start of works for the railway access to T-1 of El Prat Airport, known as the "shuttle," whose works will begin in June; and on the 21st, we tendered the renovation works of the platforms at the Paseo de Gracia station.

Therefore, we are investing in these Cercanías trains…

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pedro Sánchez, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Sánchez.- Mr. Rajoy, I would like to know your opinion on your Government's policy regarding the Town Halls.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Sánchez. We value it positively. When we came to power, many Town Halls were in a dramatic situation; some, bankrupt; some with very few revenues and high debt; with suppliers who were not being paid their debts; with public services that they were supposed to provide and that were at risk; and, moreover, in many cases, they were not collecting the debts owed to them by the Autonomous Communities, a situation similar to that experienced by other public institutions.

What did we do? Put order in the accounts, with the Stability Law; put order in the competencies, with the Local Administration Law, and pay the debts: the Payment to Suppliers, almost twelve billion euros, through the Fund for Financing Local Entities, and recently we have launched the Social Fund to pay Local Corporations the debts that the Autonomous Communities had with them, especially in social services.

Mr. Sánchez.- Mr. Rajoy, on May 24, the Spanish people decided with their vote to open a new era in municipal politics, an era marked by change and dialogue. And dialogue is precisely what has not existed in this Chamber when we have talked about the counter-reform of the Local Administration Law approved by your Government; a counter-reform that you have made against the Parliamentary Groups of this Chamber; a counter-reform that you have made, even, against the opinion of the Council of State, of many Autonomous Communities, and even of thousands of Town Halls that, considering their local autonomy violated, have filed a lawsuit in the Constitutional Court.

Mr. Rajoy, at a time when one in three Spaniards is suffering from poverty, especially many children and young people in our country, as a result of your policies, what you have done is privatize many social services in the hands of the Town Halls. We are talking about things as essential, as basic, as public employment policies; for example, anti-eviction offices; for example, support for abused women; for example, tele-assistance services and also home care; for example, school meal grants, school canteens; or, for example, public health. And the list is endless, Mr. Rajoy, Members.

Under the euphemism of improper competencies, what you are doing is privatizing citizenship rights, which are, in the end, the identity of municipal politics. I know that you, Mr. Rajoy, will tell me that we need to balance public accounts, and I will tell you: Mr. Rajoy, if you look at the good practices in many town halls, for example in Dos Hermanas, in Vigo, or even in Fuenlabrada, in a town hall in the Community of Madrid, you will see that there is a strong investment in social policy and that is not at all incompatible with budgetary rigor. That, for example, has happened here, in the City Council of Madrid, which is the most indebted City Council in Spain.

I tell you the following, Mr. Rajoy: on June 13, all Local Corporations in this country will be constituted, and therefore, we have the enormous opportunity to correct many mistakes made by your Government and by you. And I bring you here a proposal, Mr. Rajoy: withdraw your counter-reform of the Local Administration Law, which privatizes essential rights, and safeguard those social services currently in the hands of the Town Halls. Because just at the moment when greater inequality is suffered, as the National Statistics Institute told us yesterday, what is needed is a Government committed to social policies and also to safeguarding those social policies. If you do not do it, we will do it as soon as we win the elections.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Sánchez. I am in deep disagreement with the statements you have just made here, in this Chamber, because precisely what we have done, the decisions we have adopted, have served for Town Halls to be able to implement social policies because, when we paid from the Payment to Suppliers Plan 11.595 billion euros, what we did was pay invoices, which were fundamentally invoices for social care. When we launched the social FLA, what we did was pay the debts that the Autonomous Communities had with the Town Halls precisely for social care.

Now we manage to ensure that people are paid in nineteen days, which is a very important advance for people, because among those who are paid are also all the dependency sector and all the social services sector, which is very important in the Town Halls.

Therefore, the decisions taken by the Government have served exactly for the opposite of what you say: for social services to be maintained and continue to be paid.

On the other hand, there is something that is also very important, which is that Local Administration went from a deficit of 0.4 percent in 2011 to a surplus of 0.5 percent in 2014. They have met their deficit objectives and have met their debt objectives. This has been capital for Spain to also meet them and, therefore, it has been capital for the recovery of the Spanish economy and the creation of jobs.

Today, Spanish Town Halls are solvent, they pay their debts on time, and they are functioning like no one else. And the decision you refer to regarding improper competencies is a no-brainer: each Administration has its own competencies. If one does not have competencies, it can only exercise the improper ones if the one who delegates them gives it the money, which was not happening with the Autonomous Communities, or if they are solvent, because if not, they would all end up going bankrupt, as we found a few of us in 2011.

Thank you very much.