Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

16 June 2015 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions from opposition MPs during a June 2015 congressional control session on Spain's economy and IMF recommendations.
Main themes
IMF recommendations for Spain, Spanish economic growth and recovery, labor market reform and single indefinite contract, inequality and income distribution, economic sovereignty, unemployment and job creation, SME competitiveness and tax reform, public debt and accountability, Bankia and financial sector responsibility, social welfare and pension reform
Duration
~23 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,797
73rd percentile
Sentences
87
56th percentile
Readability
40
37th percentile
Grade
14.6
73rd percentile
Syntax
3.43
91st percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 60%60%
  • Institutional 23%23%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

87 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Rosa Díez, from the Parliamentary Group Union, Progress and Democracy

Ms. Díez . .- The latest report from the International Monetary Fund on the Spanish economy ignores wastefulness and ignores the insulting concentration of wealth, the growing differences in income distribution, the destruction of the middle class, and the increase in poverty and inequality. Furthermore, it calls for more taxes, less unemployment benefits, co-payment in healthcare and education, fewer pensions, and greater ease in dismissing people. I ask you, Mr. Rajoy, which recommendations from the International Monetary Fund will you take into account.

President .- Thank you very much, Ms. Díez.

The report we received from the International Monetary Fund regarding our country last week states, fundamentally, three things: first, it sets the growth forecast for Spain in the year we are in, 2015, at 3.1 percent; that is to say, we are going to grow, according to the International Monetary Fund, more than double the average of the eurozone and we will grow more than the government's own forecast, which is 2.9 percent. This is a very important figure since, as you know, we spent several years in negative economic growth. Last year we grew by 1.4 percent and, if this year we grow by 3.1 percent, it would undoubtedly be a good figure.

The second assertion made by the International Monetary Fund is something I do share, which is that reversing the economic policy that has been carried out, and the reforms, could constitute a mistake and would affect economic growth and job creation that is already taking place in our country.

And, thirdly, regarding the recommendations, which are made to us just as they are to the rest of the countries for which they produce reports, that is to say, to all, I must say that they are just that, recommendations, and they are not recommendations because Spain is a country that at a certain moment knew how to avoid a bailout; otherwise, we would be in the same situation as other countries that you know very well.

Therefore, we read those recommendations attentively, because sometimes they say very reasonable things; but we set our own "roadmap," our own economic policy, because we maintain our economic sovereignty for the reasons I mentioned earlier, and that is what will lead us this year to have a very important economic growth figure and to create around six hundred thousand jobs in our country, as we have stated in the General State Budget Project that we have presented here.

Ms. Díez .- Yes, indeed, Mr. President, regarding the statements from the International Monetary Fund, there are two parts: that of the reflection in which it recognizes that the growth of the Spanish economy, the recovery, is fundamentally due to exogenous factors, from the change in our environment, and also, fundamentally, to a very harsh adjustment in jobs and salaries.

But I do not want to refer to that reflection, which we share -- the adjustment of salaries and jobs, and the external factors are fundamental at the time of the recovery that began in 2014 -- and I want to refer precisely to the recommendations, because our Parliamentary Group is afraid that you will choose the worst recommendations, those that are bad for citizens.

What I offer you, what I ask you, is that among the recommendations you choose some that are positive, which there are also; for example, ending the duality of the labor market -- inclusive growth, as the International Monetary Fund calls it -- for which the Fund -- just like Piketty, by the way, recently -- advocates for a single indefinite contract; a good way to combat temporality, since a very protective system, as you know, affects very few workers and particularly condemns young people to wait until an advanced age to benefit. It is a formula, that of the single indefinite contract, which represents a balance that avoids "garbage contracts."

There is another important recommendation, to support competitiveness and SMEs, by eliminating all tax privileges, legal barriers, duplicated public spending, waste..., something that this Parliamentary Group has been requesting from you, always with your opposition.

There is a third recommendation, which is also a positive recommendation, to which you could pay attention: reducing over-indebtedness, demanding accountability for past bad practices; for example, in the case of Bankia. Yes, there must be a bailout, but we must demand accountability from those who behaved poorly, from those who are responsible for the crisis; and, furthermore, a genuine law that defends a second chance.

Just to mention three of the recommendations that the International Monetary Fund makes to you, to the Government of Spain, for the Spanish economy, and that this Parliamentary Group has been requesting here, in this Chamber...

President .- Thank you very much, Ms. Díez.

Indeed, there are some things on which we can agree with the International Monetary Fund and with you, and others, we cannot. I already tell you that I am not going to raise taxes; on the contrary, I am going to lower taxes. The Income Tax and the Corporate Tax have already been lowered this year, 2015. It affects twelve million taxpayers and the average reduction of the IRPF is 8.07 percent. In 2016 there will be another new reduction of the IRPF and the Corporate Tax, and we will study, if the level of collection allows it, new tax reductions.

I agree with what you and the International Monetary Fund say about SMEs and competitiveness. It has been very important and has been an inspiring principle of our government action, and that is why jobs are being created in our country at a very good pace. I agree with controlling public spending. I also agree with controlling debt and, in general, what I agree with is maintaining a reformist policy that has managed to overcome the crisis, although we still have many things to do, because the great objective is that at the end of the next legislature there will be in Spain...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Cayo Lara, from the Parliamentary Group Left Plural

Mr. Lara .- Mr. Rajoy, today, as you are going to remodel the Government, we have made the questions easy for you; it is the same as the previous one: Do you plan to follow the latest recommendations from the International Monetary Fund for our country? Let it be clear that we have not agreed on this.

President .- Thank you for informing me that I am going to remodel the Government. It is good to learn about new developments every day, even if it is from Mr. Lara. I appreciate it very much.

And I also thank you for asking the question about the International Monetary Fund, because it is a question about a matter that is certainly important for our country, isn't it?

I would tell you, to complete what I said to your colleague, Ms. Díez, that we must differentiate between good economic policies, which are those that produce economic growth and job creation, and others that do not.

We have implemented an economic policy based on important structural reforms: labor reform; the reform of the Budgetary Stability Law; the reform of the financial system; the energy reform; that of the Administration; the market unity, the Entrepreneurs Law, the Second Chance Law... There are many reforms and you know them well. And, secondly, a fiscal consolidation plan, because it makes no sense, nor is it possible, as history is currently demonstrating, to spend more than what is collected in a country.

Those reforms we have implemented have produced results, the imbalances have been corrected, competitiveness in Spain has improved, and the most important thing is that we are growing and creating jobs at a very good pace. As I told Ms. Díez, we must continue working, we must continue to commit to maintaining that policy and what the International Monetary Fund asks us is to maintain the reformist spirit, and then, there are some specific measures that, as I told Ms. Díez, I can share some and others, I may not share. The important thing is that Spain, unlike other countries that made very wrong policies, maintains its economic sovereignty and, therefore, can make its own decisions.

Mr. Lara .- Mr. Rajoy, we have two different visions regarding the reforms. The International Monetary Fund seems to have come to lend you a hand in the electoral campaign, endorsing precisely your reforms, which, in our view, have only benefited capital at the cost of destroying quality jobs, lowering salaries, and increasing poverty.

The International Monetary Fund recommends establishing a single contract, adjusting salaries and working hours, facilitating the withdrawal from agreements, raising special taxes and VAT, among others. To these measures, the Bank of Spain has once again joined, in a servile and shameful manner, which also calls for tightening the labor reform, liberalizations in trade, transport, and professional services. That is to say, they abound in the recipes that sink our economy, deteriorate the lives of workers, and increase inequality. The single contract with increasing compensation is an invitation to increase dismissals and does not solve the high turnover of employment. It asks us for wage adjustments when half of the salaries are below nine hundred euros, and a third of them are below 648 euros, the Minimum Wage that you have frozen. I asked you one day and I repeat it today: could you live on a salary of 648 euros?

The withdrawal from agreements leaves workers unprotected and breaks collective bargaining. Raising special taxes and VAT will only accentuate the fiscal injustice, which is already one of the highest in Europe.

Mr. Rajoy, the democratic and social exit to this crisis does not go through the recommendations of the International Monetary Fund, nor through those of a Bank of Spain at the service of the CEOE. Those are failed policies that have led us to the greatest economic and social disaster we have known in the history of our democracy. It is evident that the International Monetary Fund only aims to raise the profits of capital and guarantee the payment of debt to international creditors, whom it represents.

There is another social exit to the crisis: a model with fair taxes, that avoids layoffs, generates stable employment and decent wages. That is the way and not the one outlined by the International Monetary Fund.

Mr. Rajoy, now that we are talking about radicalism, get down from the mountain of the radicalism of the International Monetary Fund and govern the time you have left for the social majority of our country.

President .- I believe that those statements could be directed to the International Monetary Fund, but not to the Government of Spain. The Government has an economic policy whose main objective was to overcome the crisis and now is to grow and create jobs. Today I can say, and I believe that the whole Chamber can be very satisfied, that there are already more people employed, fewer people unemployed, and more people affiliated with Social Security than when we came to power, and that despite living through a very difficult situation in 2012 and 2013. But in 2014 and 2015, as a result of the policies we have implemented, we are already growing this year -- as we recalled earlier, we are going to be the country in the European Union that grows the most -- we are already creating jobs -- one million Spaniards are going to find a job between 2014 and 2015 -- and, if we continue to persevere, in the coming years we could see as many as twenty million Spanish citizens working.

That is the policy we have carried out. On some occasions we agree with the International Monetary Fund, as we do with you, and, at other times, we do not.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Pedro Sánchez, from the Parliamentary Group Socialist

Mr. Sánchez .- Mr. Rajoy, I would like to know if you consider the statements made by the president of Radiotelevisión Española in this parliamentary chamber, stating that he is a voter of the Popular Party and that he will always be a voter of the Popular Party, to be appropriate.

President .- In Spain, as you know, there is ideological freedom, there is freedom of vote, and there is freedom of expression. I suppose you do not intend to take that away from anyone, whoever that person may be. And, of course, referring to what the text of the question says, the opinions expressed by the general director do not affect at all his informational independence or that of the officials of Televisión Española.

Mr. Sánchez .- Mr. Rajoy, do not insult the intelligence of the deputies of this Chamber. You have governed alone and against everyone, Mr. Rajoy. Your Government, yes your Government, has governed against the workers of Radiotelevisión Española and has governed against the Informative Councils of Radiotelevisión Española, liquidating the independence of that public entity, Mr. Rajoy.

They have done the same thing they did with the educational community, legislating against it and imposing the LOMCE; as they have done against women, cutting back freedoms in the last stretch of the Legislature, modifying the Law on voluntary interruption of pregnancy; as they have done with workers by imposing a labor reform that has devalued their labor rights and as they have also done, Ladies and Gentlemen, with all Spaniards, at least with the majority of them, who, while they saw you raise their taxes, approved shameful amnesties so that members of the Popular Party, like Mr. Rato or Mr. Bárcenas, could benefit, Mr. Rajoy.

Look, Mr. Rajoy: you have earned the transition from an absolute majority to absolute solitude, because you confuse institutional stability with putting the interests of each and every institution at the service of your party: the Tax Agency, the day before yesterday; the day before yesterday of Spanish Radio and Television. But, Ladies and Gentlemen, it should not surprise us, Mr. Rajoy, because you are the President who refuses to be held accountable in this Parliament for the political corruption of your party, which directly affects you.

And in the height of electoral revenge, what you have done, Mr. Rajoy, is threaten with the unilateral modification of the Electoral Law to tailor it to your electoral interests. Mr. Rajoy, that is to say, you are once again testing the exhaustion of your political project.

Ladies and Gentlemen, Mr. Rajoy, members of the Government, I do not know if you, Mr. Rajoy, today, this afternoon, are going to modify the Government or not, if you are going to change it, if you are going to call early elections or do both: call early elections and change the Government. I will tell you one thing, Mr. Rajoy: the Spaniards neither care about it nor are interested in it, because at this point in the Legislature the only change they expect is yours at the head of the Presidency of the Government after the general elections.

President.- I do not know what change the Spaniards expect, but I believe that the only change they do not expect is for those who generated 3,400,000 unemployed in Spain to return to Government. The only change they do not expect is for those who left this country on the brink of bankruptcy to return to Government. The only change they do not expect is for those who left this country on the brink of rescue to return once again to Government. The only change they do not expect is for those who implemented an economic policy that generated six years of negative growth and a continuous increase in unemployment in our country, and that created the greatest economic crisis we have experienced in Spain since the return of democracy in 1977. And, of course, the only change they do not expect, by any means, is the one that can be provoked by a person who, after having said in all the forums he attended in recent months, that he would never ally with extremist, radical parties, or those under the orders of Venezuela, has allied throughout Spain and has given, bypassing the democratic will of the Spaniards, who in the large cities voted for the Popular Party, power to extremist groups that are already putting on the shows we are seeing in the Madrid City Council.

The responsible party is not those councilors; the responsible party is you, who have turned the Socialist Party into a radical left party, extremist and far removed from all centrality. You.