Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

21 February 2017 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to Socialist Group questions during a parliamentary control session in Spain's Congress of Deputies on February 21, 2017, focusing on pension purchasing power.
Main themes
Pension purchasing power, pension revaluation law, CPI and pension indexation, Toledo Pact, social and labor reforms, government majority and legislative vetoes, pensioners' living standards, budget sustainability of pension system
Duration
~23 min
71st percentile
Words
2,705
71st percentile
Sentences
103
64th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.19
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
48th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 53%52%
  • Economic 28%28%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

103 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Antonio Hernando, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Hernando.- Mr. President of the Government, I am going to reiterate a question that we asked you in the Senate, because there are millions of pensioners concerned that this year pensions are going to lose purchasing power. It is your decision, but to make it clear, your Group, along with Ciudadanos, has vetoed in the Chamber's Board a bill from five Groups in Congress, which echoed the union request for a 1.2 percent revaluation of pensions. That is why I ask you, Mr. Rajoy, if you do not think it would be logical for the system to guarantee the purchasing power of pensions.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Hernando.

As you know, the increase in pensions is made by applying the Law currently in force which, as you know, establishes that to set the amount of pensions, the evolution of the CPI will be taken into account, as well as the income and expenses of the system; but in no case will there be an increase of less than 0.25 percent, which is very reasonable. If income increases, pensions will increase more; if income decreases, pensions will increase less; and, in any case, always by 0.25 percent. Therefore, we are applying the Law currently in force, which seems to be reasonable and, of course, the obligation of the Government.

Mr. Hernando.- That is the problem, Mr. Rajoy, the Law, the one you made unilaterally. During the tenth Legislature, the one in which you had an absolute majority, you made a series of reforms in social and labor matters, all restrictive of rights, without dialogue and agreements, neither in Congress nor in society, with unions and employers. They were unilateral reforms that you passed with an absolute majority; now you do not have it and you are trying to veto changes in the Congress of Deputies. One of those reforms referred to the system of updating pensions.

You established a formula, broader than a seat, very complex, which makes Spain the only country in Europe that does not update pensions in relation to prices, Mr. Rajoy. You may like it, you may be delighted with your formula; we find it unfair, but until now nothing has happened, because the CPI was negative. That is no longer the case, the Consumer Price Index in January has risen by 3 percent; pensions, as you have said, will rise by 0.25 percent, so pensioners are going to lose this year, at least, 2 percent of purchasing power.

When things go wrong, it is logical that we all tighten our belts and take exceptional measures; but when the economy starts to go well, and you boast about it, the logical and normal thing should be for pensions to be updated with prices, because it is the only way pensioners can maintain their standard of living and, moreover, your Law allows it.

Therefore, listen to me, this is important: if you want to reach an understanding with the socialists on pensions, prices must return to being the essential measure for their revaluation, because if not, you are betting on a society where the economy may go well, but pensioners will fare poorly. That is unbearable for us and for society, but above all, it is unsolidary, and the issue is that now you no longer have a majority to maintain it, and we are not willing to tolerate it in silence. That is why we are going to try to change it in the Toledo Pact, Mr. Rajoy.

President.- Mr. Hernando, I would like you to explain in this Chamber what you understand by purchasing power because, when I arrived in Government, at the end of 2011, you had made a decision and the decision was: pensions frozen; that is, they increased by zero percent and the CPI rose by 3.2 percent. Is that for you maintaining the purchasing power of pensions?

There was a law that said: pensions will rise with purchasing power; but you never complied with it, because it was very difficult to fulfill. That is why we modified the Law and said: purchasing power, yes, but in addition to purchasing power, we must take into account the income of the system, because frankly, after having lost 70 billion euros in income between 2007 and 2009, it was impossible to maintain public spending as it was in Spain.

What have we done now? Something that is quite reasonable and in the years 2014, 2015, and 2016, when our new Law came into force, pensions gained purchasing power. They rose by 0.25 percent in all three years; but the CPI fell by 0.2 percent the first year, 2014; in 2015 it fell by 0.5 percent and fell again by 0.2 percent in 2016. It is likely that this year -- certainly, the inflation forecast is such -- it will be above 0.25 percent; but it is evident that sometimes they will rise, and at other times, they will not.

In any case, I invite you to something that I believe is fundamental for the future of pensions, which is that you are able to build in the Toledo Pact Commission.

In 2007, 442 billion euros were collected in Spain; ten years later, we still collect twenty billion euros less and, however, during that time pensions rose by forty billion euros. Therefore, the key is that we are able to create a system that lasts many years and that we are able to agree on it among all. That, and that we are also able to continue creating jobs in our country, because January 2017 was the best collection of Social Security contributions in the entire history of Januarys.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pablo Iglesias, of the Confederal Parliamentary Group of Unidos Podemos-En Comú Podem-En Marea

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. Mariano Rajoy, how many isolated cases does corruption stop being isolated?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Iglesias. Frankly, it depends on how you want to see it. I believe that in the face of any political problem, a fair assessment of its dimensions must be made. The problem should neither be minimized nor magnified. I certainly do not minimize it. I know that there have been many cases in recent years in Spain, but it is also not advisable to magnify it. And it is also worth noting that in Spain, and in politics, there are thousands of people who do their work very well, who are here by vocation and who, certainly, I do not think deserve to live under suspicion.

Therefore, let us neither minimize, which should not be done, nor magnify the problem. What it is fundamentally about is addressing it and making decisions so that this does not happen again in the future, and we have done so. We have approved many legal reforms, we are willing to approve all that you want and that are reasonable; a short time ago we approved one on pardons, here, in Congress. Judges are functioning; the courts of justice, the Prosecutor's Office, the State Tax Agency, the State Security Forces and Corps, and I am absolutely convinced that if we persevere in this way of acting that we have carried out in recent times, this will soon cease to be an anecdote and you will have to ask me about different things than this one you are interested in today.

Mr. Iglesias.- I would not want to magnify, Mr. President, and I would love to ask you about something else. Bárcenas, Gürtel, Aquamed, Imelsa, Púnica, Cooperación, Fabra, Brugal, Palma Arena, Emarsa, Taula… we could not magnify, but I would exhaust my two minutes simply naming cases of corruption. So I have to choose one, but I am not going to choose one, Mr. Mariano Rajoy, neither from the last years nor from the last months; I have to choose from those of the last week, among all those that occurred after your national congress.

I could ask you about the indictment of the president of Murcia for alleged crimes of prevarication, embezzlement, fraud, and falsification of public documents. I could ask you about the former mayor of Cartagena and current senator of the Popular Party, Pilar Barreiro, who is attributed with fraud, embezzlement of public funds, bribery, continued prevarication, and disclosure of confidential information. I could ask you about the imprisonment of the thirteen convicted in the FITUR case in the Valencian Community. I could ask you about the little house of your former president of La Rioja, and now vice president of the Senate, Mr. Pedro Sanz. But, as I have little time left because among so many isolated cases we should not magnify, I am going to ask you about your friend José Manuel Soria. Yes, the one with the accounts and companies in tax havens, the one who had to resign so that he would not be further investigated. Your Vice President is not here, but you should ask her about your friend José Manuel Soria's business abroad, the same one who used a corrupt judge and a prosecutor to attack our deputy Victoria Rosell.

Now we know that your friend José Manuel Soria lied in this Chamber and to the Spanish people saying that he paid for his little hotel in Punta Cana with his money. Well today, by the ruling of a judge, we know that he only paid for the massages and only paid for the massages because they were billed by another company. And he called the journalists who investigated him criminals. Who is the criminal today?

You say, Mr. Mariano Rajoy, that your Government fights corruption. That is not done with words. I propose something: you should propose to your Minister of Justice to give orders to the prosecutor to investigate Mr. José Manuel Soria's stays in luxury hotels because, perhaps, we are facing a case of bribery.

I insist, Mr. Mariano Rajoy, corruption is not fought with words or with the face washes of your partners. It is fought with actions.

President.- I am a naturally optimistic person, but I think that today I have gone too far, because trying to talk to you about measures that need to be taken to solve the problems seems complicated.

As everyone has been able to see, your intervention today has not contributed absolutely any idea to try to make this problem cease to be one.

You have come here… You have come for what you have come for. You are part, judge, and prosecutor and you came with the sentence already dictated. For that, I do not know why you ask me. In any case, thank goodness you are not Robespierre, nor is this the Convention, because otherwise we would undoubtedly have a problem.

You neither have a measured opinion, nor do you intend to have one; nor do you have a solution to resolve this problem, nor do you intend to achieve this solution. I see Spain differently than you do. It is a country that has our problems and difficulties; but Spain is a great nation. It is a country where many things are going well, the majority, and the vast majority of us who engage in political activity are people who carry out our work with dignity. What you need to ask yourself is whether you do too.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Ana María Oramas, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Ms. Oramas.- Mr. President, when does the Government plan to approve the new Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands in the Council of Ministers?

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Oramas. The commitment of the Government of Spain to the Canary Islands is undeniable; it has been in recent years and continues to be. As you know, we have modified the Economic and Fiscal Regime in its fiscal aspects, with the aim of introducing specific tax incentives that are contributing to job creation and the economic development of the Archipelago.

From there, we are indeed negotiating the Economic Regime to which you have referred. In that Regime, there are many issues related to financing, transport, services, tourism, commercial promotion, telecommunications, energy, cooperation between Public Administrations, employment, education, training… There are many topics we are addressing and many negotiations in which different Ministries are involved, and I would like to do it quickly; but I am not in a position to say at this moment when the negotiations will conclude. What I can tell you is that it is our will to reach an understanding and it is our will, just as we have approved the fiscal aspects, to also approve the economic aspects of the Special Regime of the Canary Islands.

Ms. Oramas.- Thank you, Mr. President. As you know, after twenty-three years, the modification of our historical statute is fundamental. It is fundamental because it will mean the creation of more and better jobs, the social and territorial cohesion of our land, and for this, the condition of the Canary Islands as an outermost region will be recognized for the first time, and that remoteness and insularity are structural and permanent elements over time. Also a lower tax pressure and that the revenues from the REF are additional and complementary to the system of regional financing and of councils and municipalities.

Canary Islands will be determined as an internationalization platform in the Atlantic, and policies such as compensation for the transport of goods and travelers will be consolidated; specific employment policies for the Canary Islands. In terms of tourism, a special training plan and a tourism infrastructure plan. In terms of the economy, a differentiated treatment regarding regional incentives, with a special opportunity for the non-capital islands. For the first time in environmental matters, waste recycling is introduced as a boost to circular economies and the reduction of water production costs. And a very important issue, the fundamental one: the energy system in the Canary Islands, in renewables, with different remuneration and self-consumption policies compared to the national territory.

In agriculture, the commitment to finance the additional item of the POSEI and in telecommunications, that Canarians have the same access to broadband in prices and conditions as the rest of the territory.

In short, these policies will structure our territory, will reduce the difference with the national territory, will allow for job creation, and will provide a very important opportunity for the non-capital islands.

You committed to us, to Coalición Canaria and to all Canarians, in the Investiture Debate. We hope that this agreement of the Government of the Canary Islands, of the Canary Islands, with the State will be approved soon in the Council of Ministers and enter this Congress of Deputies, because it is our historical charter and it is the right of the Canarians.

President.- Thank you very much, Mrs. Oramas. You have explained it very well. These are very important decisions we are talking about; they are complex decisions in many cases, and they are decisions that, when implemented, will undoubtedly have and produce very beneficial positive effects for all citizens of the Canary Islands. But that, as I told you before, takes time; many Ministries are involved in these negotiations.

What I can tell you at this moment is that, just as we approved the fiscal aspects of the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands in its day and made decisions that I believe benefited the Canary Islands, such as the Autonomous Liquidity Fund -- which was also applied to other Autonomous Communities -- and also with the Supplier Payment Fund -- today the Canary Islands are paying interest at zero percent, as you know; just as we did all that in its day, we will also bring to this Chamber, as quickly as possible, all the economic aspects of the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands that you referred to in your speech, believing that this will be positive for the citizens of the Canary Islands and will also benefit all Spaniards.

Thank you very much.