Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

20 February 2017 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy addressed the Spanish parliament on 20 February 2017 during a parliamentary control session, responding to Socialist Group questions about pension sustainability and purchasing power.
Main themes
Pension sustainability, purchasing power of pensions, Social Security deficit, pension revaluation law, fiscal responsibility, job creation, Toledo Pact, inflation, public spending cuts, budgetary consolidation
Duration
~54 min
95th percentile
Words
6,510
95th percentile
Sentences
229
92nd percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
3.19
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 27%26%
  • Institutional 24%23%
  • Geopolitical 23%21%
  • Social 16%15%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

229 sentences in 93 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Vicente Álvarez Areces, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Álvarez Areces.- Mr. Rajoy, on the 8th of this month of February, the president of the Independent Authority for Fiscal Responsibility stated that if no measures are taken, the Social Security deficit would persist for years and that this would inevitably affect pensions, which would be revalued by approximately 0.25 percent annually until the year 2022, the minimum set by the Law of 2013 that you approved with your absolute majority and which, according to the forecast of the AIREF, will lead to a loss of 7 percent of pensions in the decade between 2013 and 2022.

The FEDEA Foundation today publishes that new retirees will lose 30 percent of their purchasing power over the next twenty years; another foundation, another significant body.

In January, inflation stood at 3 percent, which means that if this situation persists, we would be facing a loss of purchasing power twelve times greater than the increase in pensions this year 2017. All experts predict higher inflation rates for the future than those of recent years.

Future predictions place us, therefore, in a scenario of great concern, not only for the 9.4 million pensioners who have supported their families and, in many cases, their children and grandchildren in situations of unemployment or precariousness, but also for the young people who see that in these expectations future pensions will be bordering, in some cases, on the thresholds of poverty, a situation we cannot tolerate. For all these reasons, I ask you what your Government plans to do to maintain the purchasing power of pensions.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Álvarez Areces. The increase in pensions that we have proposed for the year 2017 is an increase that is made by applying the Law currently in force. Naturally, the Law currently in force can be changed, like all laws; but I believe that, speaking of rules of the game, in this matter it does not seem advisable if we want, as you also want and have said, to guarantee our future.

That said, allow me to make a few brief comments to clarify exactly what we have done, where we are at this moment, and what I, at least, think needs to be done in the future.

I came to the Government at the end of 2011 and the situation of public finances at that time, for the purposes that concern us here today, was as follows: we had lost seventy billion euros in revenue; the public deficit was above 9 percent; the European Commission rightly demanded that we reduce that deficit and, therefore, reduce public spending even further; and, moreover, there was, most importantly, a threat in the markets: it was very difficult to finance ourselves and we ran the serious risk that even the forecast of the public deficit could not be financed.

What decisions did we make? First, reduce spending. It was inevitable for the reasons I have just mentioned, unless we wanted to bankrupt as a country. Second, prioritize spending. What was the priority? First, pensions are not touched, and consequently, pensions increased every year.

What was the second major decision we made at that time? A Pension Law. First, the sustainability factor was established -- which is not relevant to this debate -- that will come into effect in 2019, and then a system of pension revaluation was established. The previous one said: pensions will always be revalued with the CPI, but no one complied with it, starting with you, who did not revalue them as the CPI said. So, we established a modification of the Law where it was stated: they will be revalued based on what the CPI says and also based on the income and expenses of the system, which was reasonable: if there are more revenues, pensions will increase more, and if there are fewer revenues, pensions will increase less. But we said: they will always be revalued, at least by 0.25 percent.

What are we doing this year? Simply applying the Law. If we had not set the limit of 0.25 percent, they would not have been increased.

And now we come to the most important point: what needs to be done in the future, which directly responds to your question? First, we need to continue creating jobs, which is key, because the more people there are contributing to Social Security, since contributions pay pensions, undoubtedly, the better it will be for pensioners and for the country as a whole. And the second major objective is to try to reach an understanding in the debate that is currently taking place in the Toledo Pact.

I would like there to be a future agreement for twenty or twenty-five years that makes the amount of the pension more objective and not subject to the whims of decisions at any given moment. We have the will to reach an understanding and an agreement, and I would like you to have that will as well. Therefore, if we reach an agreement, you will have the answer to the question you just asked today.

Mr. Álvarez Areces.- Mr. Rajoy, first of all, you have not answered what I asked you, which is what concrete measures you would take to maintain the purchasing power of pensions. You have explained to me why we are here, also with arguments that are not acceptable in many of the cases you have mentioned.

In 2011 you received a Pension Reserve Fund much larger than what you will leave it, because you will leave it practically depleted: more than 66 billion euros that have been used, and moreover, in 2011, which was a year of crisis, pensions were increased by 1 percent, four times more than you are increasing them now.

I am talking about what purchasing power is, because everything related to that issue also has its correlation with what is the sustainability of the system. I understand that today we are in the first chapter: how is purchasing power maintained? Because, you see, you have told me that pensions must be revalued and that there must be an increase every year, but there must be economic sufficiency. The Constitution, in Article 50, speaks of economic sufficiency, and the Pact that was made in this Chamber speaks of economic sufficiency. It is not enough to raise pensions by 0.25 percent for years and say that I am complying constitutionally, when the inflation rate is at 3 or 2 percent, etc. That condemns generations of new pensioners to have much lower purchasing power over the years.

Another different chapter is what sustainability of the system means, where, evidently, a series of criteria must be introduced; but it is also true that you spent five years without moving, practically using, and in a comfortable way, that Pension Fund which, when it is depleted, you urge immediate negotiation measures. I believe there should have been a more responsible attitude.

Because I reiterate what was said regarding the AIREF. Not only the AIREF, but also other European bodies, such as, for example, the Federation of Insurers, etc., speak of the fact that in Spain, and within the European Union, there will probably be a devaluation of the pension system at a faster rate than any other country. If today the replacement rate in Spain is around 80 percent of the salaries received in the last working period, and that is because there has been, as it should be, a trace of contributions throughout the working life, not because any Government has immediately influenced it, we are going to end up with replacement rates thirty points lower in the medium-term scenario. And many bodies agree, not just this one. We are talking about a loss of thirty points of purchasing power and that is not tolerable.

No one will expect that social interlocutors, political formations, etc., will sit down starting from the basis that there is a scenario where we must already accept, with the Law of 2013, a scenario of loss. Because that revaluation index of the year 2013, Mr. Rajoy, has de-indexed in relation to the CPI and has set an index that practically forces a minimum of 0.25 percent for many years, because you say that "until the system is revalued as a whole, it will not have something more than 0.25 percent." But with a galloping deficit, which this year breaks all records, which is 18 billion euros this year, and with deficits of that nature in recent years and a prediction to maintain it, there will never be a greater increase than 0.25 percent.

This is unacceptable, it will not be acceptable not only for us but for the political formations themselves and the social formations, which will also have to intervene in the Toledo Pact.

We want this issue to be treated with absolute priority. We cannot tolerate that our Constitution is revised downwards, where acquired rights and those reflected in the constitutional pact will be reinterpreted, deteriorating the purchasing power of pensions. Moreover, there has been a bill in the Congress of Deputies at the end of last year in which a revaluation of 1.2 percent was proposed, with an index also adjusted according to the real CPI at the end of the year. That has been vetoed, Mr. Rajoy; it has been vetoed by you and you must rectify. Because no one will expect that we enter into a thorough debate about what sustainability of the system as a whole means, which we must enter and which we are willing to do, which we have always fought for throughout the socialist governments in democracy, and that even in times of crisis we have increased minimum pensions by more than 50 percent...

We want to strengthen the system in the general interest of our country; but no one will expect that the system is strengthened by accepting in advance a loss of purchasing power for these pensioners and a impoverishment of future generations.

President.- Mr. Álvarez Areces, I share, as could not be otherwise, your good wishes; but what we need to try to do is to be effective in solving problems, because I fear that good wishes alone will not suffice.

I previously told you something that I believe is important and that I would like you to take into account: in the Toledo Pact Commission, we must contribute ideas and collaborate so that things go well, to solve the problem and objectify it for a long time. And I want to tell you that, in my opinion, this is, along with the financing of healthcare, the two major issues we will have to face in Spain in the coming times.

Now allow me to make some considerations. I previously explained what was there when I arrived at the Government, what the situation was, and allow me to repeat it very briefly: we had lost 70 billion euros in revenue, which is no joke, as you perfectly understand; the deficit was above 9 percent; there was a serious threat from the markets of not financing us; the Commission demanded that we fulfill our commitments and, therefore, we had to reduce spending, but we made an important decision which was: we are going to prioritize spending on pensions.

In that year 2011, when we came to power, pensions were increased, by decision -- do not see this as a criticism -- of the previous Government, by 0 percent; they were frozen. And the inflation for that year 2011 was 3.2 percent. I suppose that will not be the system you desire for pensions to maintain their purchasing power.

I, despite the crisis situation we were in, never froze pensions, I prioritized spending and I did it at the worst moment of the crisis. Moreover, I made a law, indeed, and it was approved in the Chamber, in Congress and in the Senate, and that was a very reasonable law because, to have a law that based everything on the CPI and then the Government of the moment did not comply with it, it is better to have a law that is complied with. And that Law said: account must be taken of the CPI, but account must also be taken of the income of the system, which is common sense: if there are no revenues in the system, we have a problem, no matter how good the will we all have, and therefore, it would be difficult to solve it.

This Law came into effect in 2014. In 2014, inflation was -0.2 percent and pensions increased by 0.25 percent, gaining purchasing power; in 2015, inflation was -0.5 percent and pensions increased by 0.25 percent, gaining purchasing power; in 2016, inflation was -0.2 percent and pensions increased by 0.25 percent, gaining purchasing power. This year the inflation forecast, of course, is not that; it is higher. What we are doing is applying the Law but, of course, I would not like to return to the situation of 2011 where, by skipping the Law, which is what was done, pensions were frozen and prices increased by 3.2 percent.

Conclusions and final comments, Mr. Álvarez Areces: it is necessary for us to continue creating jobs in Spain and for contributions to Social Security to increase, it is necessary; second, that is not enough: we need to make a decision, distancing it from the political debate, which in this matter leads nowhere, in the Toledo Pact; third, let us take this matter seriously because this issue, which today already accounts for 38 percent of the expenditure of the Government that I preside over, along with healthcare, which accounts for practically 40 percent of regional expenditure, are the great challenges that this country faces for the future.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Ramón Espinar, of the Parliamentary Group Unidos Podemos-En Comú Podem-En Marea

Mr. Espinar.- Mr. Rajoy, welcome to the Senate. First of all, I would like to make a brief comment. This morning, the Senate Board rejected a request for you to appear to discuss the urgent measures that your Government must take, that we must all take, to stop gender-based violence. It is good that we hold moments of silence here, but until we take measures, we will continue to have to hold moments of silence.

What plans does your Government have, Mr. Rajoy, for foreign relations with the United States of America following the election of Donald Trump as President?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Espinar. I share your concern about the cases of gender-based violence that occur in our country, and in any other, and I eagerly await your proposals to resolve this problem definitively.

You ask me what plans we have, in the Government, to address bilateral relations with the United States after the election of the new President. The plan is to maintain the same good relations that we had with the previous Administration, led by Mr. Obama. I say this because we share with the United States values such as democracy, respect for rights, freedoms, the rule of law… We share this with the United States and with all the countries in our environment. We have excellent cooperation in security and defense, and we want it to continue in the future. We have common interests; probably the most important is the fight against terrorism; it is important that we continue to collaborate. And we have trade and investment relations that are very productive for Spanish citizens and also for American citizens.

From there, we can disagree or have different opinions on various issues; but in international relations, and, in general, if you allow me, in any aspect of life, it is better to focus on what we agree on rather than on what we disagree on. I apply this, as I said, to all aspects of life; I recommend it, because that way one is happier, and I also apply it to international relations with all heads of state and government, regardless of the country they are from.

Mr. Espinar.- You have the Journal of Sessions of this Chamber at your disposal to know that my colleagues in my Parliamentary Group have made proposals on gender-based violence that have been ignored by your Government and your Parliamentary Group.

But, in any case, let us get to the issue at hand. On February 7, we learned through the media that you had a telephone conversation with Mr. Trump. Some things have emerged from that telephone conversation, which I would like to ask you about.

The first concerns military spending. Mr. Trump has repeatedly announced that he will ask European Union countries for an increase in military spending, on average, of 2 percent. It turns out that, after that conversation, some American media reported that this request was the subject of the telephone conversation you had with Mr. Trump, but you did not explain it to the Spanish people. I ask you to explain it now, in this parliamentary setting; to explain whether you are going to increase military spending because Mr. Trump has asked you to.

The second question I ask you -- I will ask it bluntly and without ambiguity, if you allow me -- concerns the wall that Mr. Trump has announced he will build in Mexico. Do you agree with that wall? Did you discuss that wall with Mr. Trump and will you support the construction of a wall between the United States of America and Mexico? We fear, in light of the precedents and the migration policy that Spain is following, that you will not put up any resistance to the construction of a wall between the United States and Mexico. It is true that you have no power to legislate or regulate what the President of the United States does; but it is also true that citizens in Spain would appreciate a position of respect for human rights and the defense of human rights also in the area of migration and asylum rights.

You made another announcement in that telephone conversation, which has also been reported by the media, that you offered yourself as an interlocutor for Latin America and the European Union with Mr. Trump and the Government of the United States of America. And there is another question that comes to my mind, Mr. Rajoy, and that is: have you spoken to anyone in Latin America before offering yourself as an interlocutor?

Look, there is an obstacle to good relations between Spain and Latin America, and you will not be unaware of it, because you have been the President of the Government for quite some time and you know the leaders of our brother countries, and that is that precisely that relationship of brotherhood must be a relationship of equality and not a paternalistic relationship, in which the President of Spain offers himself as an interlocutor for something that is not very clear, without entrusting himself to God or the devil. If you want to be an interlocutor for Latin Americans, speak to them first.

In the meantime, some recommendations regarding foreign relations with Latin America: practice brotherhood and not paternalism; practice respect, mutual understanding, and more balanced foreign relations with Latin American countries. Against the walls that Mr. Trump wants to build, let us build bridges with Latin America, with a view of equals and a commitment to mutual learning.

Spain has lost a lot of presence in Latin America in the years you have been President of the Government, and it has lost it due to an economic policy of the Government, because you have been more focused on the big Spanish companies' business in Latin America than on playing a role, for example, in the ongoing peace process in Colombia, in the new scenario opened in Cuba, or in the urgent need, which we have also discussed in this Chamber, for a dialogue process in Venezuela.

Mr. Rajoy, practice an assertive, balanced, and constructive presence in relations with Latin America.

And regarding relations with the European Union and the possibility of being interlocutors between the European Union and Latin America, let us base that possibility of dialogue on mutual recognition, on the fact that the brother countries of Latin America and the countries of the European Union recognize us as having a privileged position to be actors in that dialogue process; but not because you arrogate it to yourself in a telephone conversation or in a press conference, but because we work on those foreign relations.

I must acknowledge that, in terms of relations with the European Union, it is probably -- and believe me, I like very little how you govern -- the area in which I like the least how you have governed, because you have followed a foreign policy with the European Union that I believe has been detrimental to our country and that has consisted of being docile with the strong and relentless with the weak. You were relentless with the Greeks, despite the fact that Spain's interest was that they not be subjected to a memorandum or the conditions that were imposed on them, while you have practiced an alliance with Angela Merkel that has not benefited our country in the framework of the European Union at all.

Mr. Rajoy, international relations, as we humbly understand them from my Group, must consist of some elements: the first, respect for other countries; the second, the defense of human rights; the third, the defense of democracy; and the fourth, the defense of well-being.

Mr. Trump is a ticking time bomb for all these elements; society is already ahead, there are mobilizations all over the world resisting Mr. Trump; and they resist him not because they have a grudge against him or because he is very conservative, they resist him because he is a ticking time bomb against human rights.

Remember the last time your Government, a Government of the Popular Party, embraced an Atlanticist approach with a very conservative Government of the United States of America. It did not turn out well for you, it did not turn out well for the world, and it did not turn out well for Spain and the Spanish people. Reflect, Mr. Rajoy, and apply some of the advice I have given you.

President.- Mr. Espinar, I greatly appreciate your advice. I always try to listen to what others say; one always learns, and that is very positive. When one renounces the capacity to learn, one automatically dies. You will understand that I intend to stay alive, without intending to offend anyone.

That said, I will respond to the questions you have asked me, as is my duty. I believe I have been able to take note.

Regarding military spending for defense, I did not speak with Mr. Trump in my telephone conversation. Believe me, I did not say a word to him about this matter. It is true that his Secretary of Defense came here, to Europe; yesterday the Vice President also came, to say that NATO member countries should increase spending. But I did not discuss that matter, and my position is already known: in Cardiff, at the NATO meeting, we made commitments, and I am certainly willing to fulfill them in due course. But I did not say a word, nor did the President of the United States ask me anything about this matter.

I also did not speak about my mediation with Ibero-American countries. Believe me, I did not say a word about this matter. What I do say is that Spain has good historical and all kinds of relations with Ibero-American countries, is part of the European Union, has a good position in North Africa, and therefore is a country that can play a role -- pardon the expression -- in the international concert.

I did not discuss the famous wall in Mexico either. I have an immigration policy that is not Mr. Trump's; but that has nothing to do with the relations that Spain and the United States have, because these things happen with many other countries in the world that are not the United States. I did speak with the Mexican President, who later communicated to the media his gratitude for the call I made and the message of support and solidarity. But I did not discuss this matter with Mr. Trump either.

You then spoke about Spain's international position and its relations with Ibero-America, and you used a series of expressions that sound good to me: respect sounds good to me, non-paternalism sounds good to me, and the defense of human rights sounds good to me. But, well, let us get to specific and determined issues.

We have made a significant effort to help other countries -- others have helped us -- for example, on the issue of visas. Ask, for example, the Colombian Government or the Peruvian Government, or now the Ecuadorian Government.

We have fought on trade issues. We are now trying to advance the EU-MERCOSUR free trade agreement. I think it is important. Also, in the case of Mexico and Chile, which have agreements with the European Union from the years 2000 to 2002, we are working to renew them and to make them better and more effective for them.

You spoke to me about dialogue in Venezuela. I have never refused dialogue; but, come on, aside from dialogue, it would be advisable for political prisoners to stop being political prisoners and to be released. Do not talk to me about freedom and human rights, as I agree with freedom and human rights, and then do not use Venezuela as an example of absolutely anything, please. I believe that in Venezuela the priority is for political prisoners, of which there are many, to be released, as happens in any democracy, and that we all defend the freedom of all.

I must say that I have never done anything against the Greek Government; on the contrary, I have supported their positions, and we have done so in the Eurogroup, in ECOFIN, and in the European Council. Because I want things to go well for Greece, because that means that things will go well for the whole of the European Union. Greece has gone through a very difficult period; some people who came to power had to rectify some positions, and what we want now, at least the Government I preside over, is to help them, among other things, because Greek citizens should not have to pay for the faults or mistakes of absolutely anyone.

Mr. Espinar, my position is very clear, and I believe it is the position that any responsible leader would adopt in a position like mine. I want to have good relations with everyone, especially with those with whom our peoples share the same values and principles. I believe that, at the same time, I have the obligation to defend the interests of Spain and, as I mentioned before, there are many areas of mutual interest between the United States and Spain, and between the United States and the European Union. There are things that I do not like, but probably others will not like things that the Government of Spain does or decisions that the Senate of our country adopts.

From there, I believe it is very important for Spain to have a good relationship with the United States from any point of view. Look, in economic matters, which I believe is important to all of us, the United States is the largest investor in the world in Spain, with an investment stock of 47 billion euros at the end of 2014, which has now increased. I am interested in maintaining that, and that more than two million American citizens come to Spain, with significant purchasing power, is something I want to see continue.

From there, we try to have the best possible relations, and if we disagree on some issues, that’s okay. Let’s move in parallel.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Mirella Cortés, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana

Ms. Cortés.- Mr. Rajoy, are you informed about the "Catalonia Operation," which consists of using the state apparatus and its reserved funds to illegitimately discredit Catalan politicians who do not share your political project and who defend the right of Catalonia to decide its future?

President.- Ms. Cortés, the operation I am informed about, among other things, because it has occupied some of my time over the years, has been the operation to overcome the greatest economic crisis that Spain has faced in decades, which, as is natural, has also affected Catalonia: five years of negative economic growth, 3.7 million Spaniards who lost their jobs, and a loss of no less than 10 percent of national wealth. That is what I have dedicated myself to, and, as is evident, that is what I am informed about. Believe me, it was not easy. As you very well know, things have improved, although we still have much more to do.

I believe that all of this was very positive, sincerely, for Catalonia, because it also brought Catalonia back to growth and job creation, and increased revenue; but there is still much to be done in Catalonia. I also believe that the 63 billion euros from the FLA and the suppliers were positive for Catalonia. This was a great operation, this was indeed a great operation, because it allowed public services to be maintained, it also allowed suppliers to be paid, preventing companies from closing, and addressing debt maturities that would have inevitably led to bankruptcy.

Therefore, that is what I have dedicated myself to, and believe me, for a long time, as, on the other hand, it was my obligation.

Then, there is another matter that I have also dedicated myself to, which is the situation in Catalonia, and I can tell you the following:

I agree with many citizens of Catalonia who want to stay together; I agree with those citizens who want to continue being Spanish, Catalan, and European, and who do not want anyone to force them to renounce any of those conditions; I agree with all those citizens who live in Catalonia, who want to remain in Europe and not outside; I agree with all those citizens of Catalonia who want to share a future with the rest of the Spaniards, as they have shared a past for many centuries; with all those who believe that together we will do better and with all those who think that we are in a world that is moving towards processes of union and not separation or division.

I agree with all those citizens of Catalonia who want something as reasonable and democratic as the Law to be upheld and that the rulers should not disregard it. I agree with all those citizens who think that in a Rule of Law, all of us, including senators, deputies, and members of the Government, but also the rest of the politicians, are subject to the Law. I also agree with many citizens that institutions should not be institutions of a particular ideology, in this case, the independence ideology, but should defend all citizens, even if they think differently from those who are in the institutions. I agree on the need not to unnecessarily divide society. And I agree on the need for governments to have a minimum of personality and that there should not be extra-system political forces that appoint presidents of the Generalitat or impose certain conditions that will ultimately lead to a change in the economic and social model of Catalonia, an issue that should concern you and everyone else.

I am willing to discuss all of this, but there is one thing I cannot be asked to discuss: I cannot discuss, and you understand this, with anyone about how we can jointly violate the Law. Do you know why? Because my first obligation as President of the Government of Spain is to guarantee compliance with the Law.

Ms. Cortés.- Yes, Mr. Rajoy, I see that you continue with the same line as always: someone asks you something and you answer what you want. In Catalan, we say: "demanem naps i vostè contesta cols"; that is, "we ask for turnips and you answer with cabbages"; in other words, we ask one thing and you answer whatever you want. In this line, you have just done the same as always: you ask a question and you answer another.

To refresh your memory, I will remind you of the following: First, the actions of the former Minister of the Interior, Jorge Fernández Díaz, conspiring in his office with the director of the Anti-Fraud Office, Daniel de Alfonso, who left some gems like, for example, "he --you-- is the President of the Government and I can assure you that he is a man of discretion personified." "We are investigating things about Esquerra, but they are very weak." That is the truth, Minister.

Second, the actions of your Chief of Staff, your right-hand man, Jorge Moragas, with the famous messages to Victoria Álvarez: "if you gave an interview and told everything, you would save Spain and I would make you a monument. Big kiss."

Third, the actions of the director of the Anti-Fraud Office of Catalonia, Daniel de Alfonso, with the hiring of a security company with former police officers to --as he said-- conduct sweeps; that is, espionage. Or what did he mean by saying "sweeps"?

Fourth, the actions of Mr. Eugenio Pino, former Deputy Operational Director of the National Police, with the use of the UDEF to launder information.

Fifth, the actions of José Ángel Fuentes Gago, chief inspector, with the use of reserved funds to pay for information about the former mayor of Barcelona, which has been proven to be completely false.

Sixth, the revelations of José Manuel Villarejo Pérez, former commissioner and businessman, when he said: "we are going to screw you over by direct instruction from the Minister of the Interior."

And I could continue and go on, but I will not do so to avoid tiring you, because the list, Mr. Rajoy, is endless.

For all this, for you to answer me what I am asking, so that you do not answer cabbages when I ask for turnips, I will ask you again; I will ask you three direct and easy questions: first, do you deny, Mr. Rajoy, that there is now an operation led by the main leaders of the Catalan Popular Party, by your own Chief of Staff and by various active and retired officials of the State Security Forces to destroy a political movement, ideological pluralism, and the main democratic institutions of Catalonia against the basic principles that uphold the Rule of Law?

Second, do you deny, Mr. Rajoy, that what has been organized is actually a new GAL, without physical violence, but that has maintained the bad practices, the sewers of the State, the false dossiers, the bought journalists, and the rewards with reserved funds to buy statements?

And finally, although those from your bench may not like it, we understand perfectly, do you deny, Mr. Rajoy, being the Mr. X who directs the operation?

President.- Ms. Cortés, allow me to begin my second intervention by congratulating you on the constructive tone you have used today in this Chamber.

I would like to say one thing: I usually, when I come here or to Congress, answer what seems reasonable to me; but I am willing to rectify: from now on, you ask me the question and give me the answer, and that way we avoid the problems.

Now, Ms. Cortés, allow me to give you my opinion on what I believe we should do in Catalonia. We must try to address the real problems of people, of the citizens. Recently, a Conference of Presidents of Autonomous Communities was held, and among other issues, we talked about autonomous financing, which is something that is supposed to matter to the citizens of Catalonia; about employment, dependency, demographic problems… The Generalitat did not attend, and the Generalitat does not want anyone in the working group to discuss autonomous financing. I invite you to go and let’s address this issue. We can talk about budgets, investments, infrastructures…

There is a second important issue to discuss: what can we do to ensure that institutions are not at the service of people of a particular ideology? Because, of course, in Catalonia, there are many people who are not independentists and who do not see themselves reflected in the actions of the Generalitat.

What can we do to end the tension and division? Perhaps, interventions like the one you made today? Well, I don’t think so!

And what can we do to ensure that the Generalitat is not in the hands of extremist, radical, and anti-system groups?

On all of this, without a doubt, we can talk. Of course, there are others who only want to talk about stopping the Law from being in force or for Justice to stop acting; but that is not possible, because this is a democracy and you cannot oppose Law to democracy.

Ms. Cortés, I ask you for a little moderation. I am not going to do as you have done: I am not going to read you the statements of anyone, not even that of the former spokesperson of your party in the Senate, who recently asked me a question… Frankly, I only wish that you have different destinies, and I am convinced that this will be the case.

Finally, let’s get to the argument of operations. The argument of conspiracy is very convenient. Do you know why? Because it saves the trouble of thinking: "the blame lies with a conspiracy, so there is no need to think." It absolves the one who uses the argument of all responsibility; it shifts it to man’s best friend, who is the scapegoat --that is what you have done here today--, and corners the convenient sensibility to move in public affairs.

I would ask you one thing: stop inventing operations. Now I have seen that you have invented another one, which is the "Operation Carrot." Today I heard the president of your Group in Congress, yesterday in the Catalan Parliament… I don’t know what the "Operation Carrot" is, but I have the feeling that the "Operation Carrot" is about if I want to propose something to the president of the Generalitat, you are not going to support it because you say that is a carrot and that we all have to do what you say, which does not seem excessively democratic to me.

And one piece of advice. Since I received one from Mr. Espinar, I will send you one: apply your imagination and your time to more noble and beneficial ends, which the common people will appreciate.