Speech by President of the Government and subsequent Q&A session at the opening of the conference organised by 'The Economist'
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed The Economist conference on June 2, 2014, outlining Spain's economic recovery progress and unveiling a new growth and competitiveness plan.
- Main themes
- Spanish economic recovery, GDP growth and job creation, structural reforms, competitiveness, fiscal consolidation, investment attraction, eurozone outlook, social security trends, government reform agenda
- Duration
- ~64 min
- Words
- 7,674
- Sentences
- 347
- Readability
- 55
- Grade
- 10.9
- Syntax
- 3.02
- Vocabulary
- 1.93
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
347 sentences in 128 paragraphs
Ladies and gentlemen, a very good morning to you.
Thank you Michael Reid for your kind words. I am not going to show any preference about who has to resign the next time that "The Economist" organises an event such as this one; but I will show a preference for someone I don't want to resign, and that is the chairman of Real Madrid, because that would mean that Real Madrid had not done well, and that would be bad for Spain and for me.
So my friends, let's move on from there. As Michael Reid recalled in his speech, more than a year ago I had the chance to take part in the conference organised by this prestigious weekly newspaper and once more you have counted on my presence, and I thank you for that.
At that time, the conference was entitled "Beyond Austerity: Returning to the Path of Growth". In my speech I analysed the problems of the Spanish economy, and presented solutions, what I believed were solutions, to turn the situation around. In other words, I presented the starting point and the economic strategy of my Government to return the Spanish economy to the path of growth and job creation. It is that, and nothing else, that has been our objective from the start; and that is what we have been working on for more than two years.
Today, just over a year later, I can say that the situation has turned. The theme of this summit is "Accelerating the Return to Growth", and I can confirm that the Spanish economy has its foot on the accelerator in our return to growth.
And I'm not the only one to say so. It has been confirmed by international institutions like the International Monetary Fund, which last week made clear that the economic policy employed and the effort made by Spanish society have been decisive in transforming the Spanish economy. And we are beginning to see results.
That is what the rating agencies say as well. They are upgrading Spain's rating and highlighting the improvement in the Spanish economy. The result is a positive impact in terms of attracting new investors.
Ladies and gentlemen,
Recovery in Spain is based on solid foundations. Today we can say that we have a competitive economy with the capacity for balanced growth. I don't want to overwhelm you with a list of figures - there wouldn't be any point to that - but I would like to highlight those that are the most significant for me.
GDP is growing for the third consecutive quarter and labour market figures clearly demonstrate a change in cycle. The Spanish economy is creating jobs; slowly, and the figures are still very modest, but it is doing so. Jobs are already being created in Spain; and what is more, this is happening with rates of growth that are far below those needed in the past.
A few minutes ago we just learned the figures for people registered in the Social Security system in May, which corroborate the recovery of jobs and what I am saying. The figures are as follows:
These are positive figures, as it is the fourth month in a row since the crisis began in which there has been a positive annual rate of change in the average number of people registered; but this is not enough. We have to continue working. There are still many people who cannot find a job, so the Government's duty is to maintain its efforts, maintain the reform policy and continue working in the same direction. But, I repeat, there is a clear change of trend and that should be of use to us in continuing to work extremely hard in the future.
All this that I am referring to - the change in trend in both economic growth and job creation - is possible because we are correcting the imbalances in the Spanish economy:
All the reforms we have implemented over these last two years, from the labour reform to the restructuring of the financial system, from the Budget Stability Act to the reform of the electricity sector, and the sustainability factor for pensions; are all producing their first results.
The change in trend is thus more than evident: we are growing and we are beginning to create jobs. The European Commission has just suggested that Spain will grow this year by more than the average in the Eurozone, and forecasts that in 2015 the Spanish economy could grow at a faster pace than Italy, France or Germany.
However - and this is the most important challenge - we have a large number of people who do not have a job, and that forces us to be increasingly demanding in our goals. We have to grow stronger, quicker and with a greater capacity to generate jobs.
With this goal in mind, at the Council of Ministers meeting on Friday my Government will this week approve a Plan of Measures to Drive Growth, Competitiveness and Efficiency, which will mobilise resources of more than 6 billion euros. This plan is fully aligned with our budget stability and financial sustainability commitments. In other words, without involving an increase in expenditure, it advances the first set of measures included in the National Reform Plan this year, taking advantage, as far as possible, of the finance from the European Union structural funds. The plan aims first, to boost long-term investment in key sectors, and second, to eliminate the barriers or rigidities that can negatively impact the economic initiative or our companies' capacity for growth and internationalisation.
We are also going to bolster our labour market further with the implementation of a Single Employment Portal, the full implementation of the Youth Guarantee and the reform of the system of training for employment.
In addition, and thanks to the improvement in our tax bases, this month of June we will approve the tax reform, which is based on principles of equity and efficiency. It is a reform that increases family income, stimulates savings and improves the competitiveness of the economy as a whole.
The Government thus aims to continue to boost the Spanish economy's capacity to grow; and the key element in this type of growth is openness to the foreign sector. Spain grows most the more open it is, the more capable it is of increasing its production of goods and services that are competitive in foreign markets, and when it is capable of replacing imports by own production because this is more attractive to consumers.
And how is this done? What is the recipe for this form of growth that gives such good results? Can we copy today what has worked so often for us in our past?
That is precisely what the Government's intention is: to return to the patterns of openness, competitiveness and growth that have made Spain the country it is today: the fifth best economic success story in the world over the last half century. We must not forget that 50 years ago Spanish GDP per capita was equivalent to 17% of the American GDP per capita. Today this percentage has risen, despite the crisis, to 76%.
Well, to achieve this renewed boost to growth a number of basic ingredients have to be in place.
First, we have to ensure that investment and job opportunities are created in the most open sectors that have the greatest capacity to compete abroad, to the detriment of the more closed sectors that are privileged by some kind of internal economic advantage. That sounds great, but it is difficult to achieve; and that is what we call structural reforms to create a more flexible, open and competitive economy. They are reforms that allow the economy to be geared towards activities with an export capacity and/or greater internal market share.
Second, we have to guarantee macro-economic stability. Spain's growth has never been associated with periods of high inflation, high deficits or increasing indebtedness. These elements only lead to the deterioration or even the collapse of the economy.
There are those who advocate policies that stimulate demand as the only instrument to achieve economic growth. However, if the country does not have an attractive and competitive supply of goods and services, these policies only lead to an increase in imports and that is unsustainable.
But in addition to this, in past periods of growth and opening up in Spain, we used a third element to kick-start recovery: the devaluation of the peseta. That had its advantages: the country became cheaper and much more attractive all of a sudden and at the same time all around the world. But it also had its disadvantages: each devaluation has a cost and everyone who trusted in Spain - those who bought a company, who bought a house on the beach or who bought Spanish currency - lost every time there was a devaluation, and so they became less interested in repeating the experience.
Between 1975 and 1995 the Spanish economy devaluated its currency five times. There was an excess of devaluation because it was the only way of recovering competitiveness; but that led us to lose credibility, as reflected by the high risk premiums. In 1995, mortgages were between 12% and 15%, rates unthinkable today, but normal at that time.
This situation came to an end when Spain joined the Euro. The Euro enormously reduced the costs of financing for the Spanish economy, for both companies and consumers; the risk premium disappeared completely when the risk of devaluation disappeared and thus investment in our country increased, as did the productive capacity of companies, and with it the possibility of creating jobs. The welfare and standard of living of Spanish people improved.
However, joining the Euro was also accompanied by strong growth in consumption. Prices and costs increased much more quickly than for our European competitors and this rise in prices was financed with more debt, easily financed in a monetary union.
But despite monetary union, an excessively indebted economy sooner or later collapses. And in the case of the Spanish economy the effects were a major loss in competitiveness, a weakened financial sector and a substantial loss of revenue for the public sector, which together with bad administration during the years of crisis, led to extremely high public deficits.
When I took up the reins of government in these circumstances, many people thought that the only solution was the classic devaluation of the currency to recover lost competitiveness. Put another way, many people thought Spain was going to leave the Euro. Others thought that the only way out for the Government was to ask for a complete bailout, as in other countries.
But neither devaluation nor a bailout was acceptable. Another solution had to be found: to achieve the effects of devaluation without having to leave the Euro; to ensure that our prices and costs improved with respect to our EU partners, and that all the economic agents were involved in this - the whole economy; while minimising the social cost, in other words, job losses.
This has been the economic policy of my Government since 2012, with measures such as the reform of the financial system; the labour reform; the energy reform; the boost to market unity; and support for entrepreneurs. And of course, with the necessary fiscal consolidation to gain credibility and lower the cost of finance.
All these measures have responded to the need to improve competitiveness within the single currency. They are measures that have led to an individual adjustment: each company, each region and each sector is adjusting its prices and costs.
Everyone has been involved in this process of adjustment: the public sector, economic sectors, large, small and medium-sized enterprises... all the citizens. There has been a collective effort.
All this meant that in 2012 the bailout was avoided and we established the political and social commitment that Spain would not abandon the Euro. Remaining in the single currency is a priority for the Spanish people. Equally important has been the commitment of the European institutions, including the European Central Bank.
Well, today Spain has been turned right round. After a great deal of effort, we have ensured levels of competitiveness similar to those of the Spanish economy when it joined the Euro. It is the first time that something like this has been done without devaluating the currency.
In 2013, the first positive surprises began to be seen in exports, which improved above the government's forecasts: the number of exporting companies grew by more than 10%, and there was an all-time high in exports of goods and tourism, while the rate of exports as a proportion of the GDP grew in a very short time from 25% to 34%, higher than our main competitors. The effects of the improvement in economic competitiveness were therefore beginning to be seen.
By the second half of 2013 the trend had changed, from recession to growth; it was very modest, but there was a shift. And thanks to the effects derived from the labour reform, the relationship between economic activity and job creation improved. In addition, the normal trend in inflation in Spain was inverted: today Spanish inflation is under the average in the Eurozone and one point below that of Germany. In other words, we recovered competitiveness at the same time as we guaranteed the purchasing power of Spanish people and created jobs in the most open and competitive sectors.
As the financial markets have seen a consolidation in the recovering process of the competitiveness of the Spanish economy within the Euro, confidence in the Spanish economy has increased. This has led to a reduction in the risk premiums and financing costs. In other words, we are entering a virtuous circle.
As of today, the situation is as follows: there has been a turnaround in the trend of the kind that was only thought possible by way of a trauma: as I said before, leaving the Euro or asking for a bailout. But Spain has done so without making use of either of these two routes.
Competitiveness is recovering with two significant differences with respect to what happened in the past:
That has been the policy we have implemented in Spain. I believe that it is only right to point out that this process would not have had the result it is having if the whole of Europe had not in turn overcome its own crisis triggered by the doubts regarding the future of the Euro and the role of the European Central Bank.
Ladies and gentlemen,
The turnaround in our economy is essential in terms of greater capacity to resist external shocks and a greater capacity for recovery; but that is not sufficient. The actions in the national arena are necessary but insufficient. We form part of the Eurozone, and so there are areas in which responsibility falls directly onto the European Union. So the efforts at a national level have to be accompanied by actions of a European scope.
From the start of the project for European construction, the consolidation of the internal market has been a key constituent. Without doubt, there has been much progress achieved in terms of promoting the free movement of goods, services and the factors of production; but we cannot be satisfied with this.
There are still barriers that make growth and convergence between the European economies difficult. We have to intensify our efforts to eliminate these barriers, above all in areas such as energy or services, because there is no doubt that the greater the convergence, the lower the impact of possible asymmetrical disturbances in the different European economies. The aim is to have a European Union that operates in a more efficient and balanced way as an economic zone.
In this sense, the free trade treaties, particularly with the United States, represent a major opening up and liberalisation of the European markets, so they have my full support.
But efforts cannot be focused simply and exclusively on the internal market. We have to go further. We have to follow the roadmap proposed to the European Council in December 2012. We have to continue with the process of EU integration, integration that strengthens the Economic and Monetary Union, and that covers the financial, budgetary, economic and political aspects. Only in this way will we guarantee stable economic and social welfare for everyone.
It is true that in the area of Banking Union progress has been made that few people predicted: starting in October, the European Central Bank will be the single supervisor and we will have a common resolution mechanism. This is major progress that shows that we are moving in the right direction and it has to encourage us all to persevere in the path we have set out for us.
We also have to make progress towards the achievement of Fiscal Union. In Europe we already have the Stability Pact; but this pact establishes some basic lines of action in a generic fashion; it is not a guide for the macro-economic direction that should be adopted by fiscal policy. We need an EU budget and a common macro-economic authority, or at least we have to debate about it. We need to have a common public debt; in other words, to have risk-free assets at a European level.
To make progress in Fiscal Union we need to take a step forward towards Political Union, to guarantee that there is adequate parliamentary control of EU policies at all times.
The final goal is the achievement of an integrated financial framework - Banking Union - an integrated fiscal framework - Fiscal Union - an integrated economic framework and greater political and democratic legitimacy. And it is necessary, as I said before, to promote a profound debate on this architecture within the heart of the European Union; a debate in which the Government I head up will defend the importance of making real progress towards greater union.
Ladies and gentlemen,
The terrible crisis we have lived through has done a great deal of damage to the European project. We only have to look at what happened in the elections on Sunday. We have probably been at the edge of the precipice at some moments, but luckily we have not fallen. Europe has survived and has set out a reform agenda to reinforce its integration.
I believe that the same intensity and the same determination we have shown in overcoming this crisis should be used to advocate the European project and to defend the measures that can allow us to return to solid and sustained growth across the whole continent. That will, without doubt, be the best antidote to the Europhobes and the best way of recovering our citizens' faith in this great project.
And here I will conclude.
In Spain we are doing our bit to avoid future crises. Spanish economic policy as a whole responds to the logic of competitiveness and as of today the Spanish economy is more adapted than ever to this logic. However, there is still much to do. It is a reform that is ongoing over time and needs the collaboration of Europe as a whole to bring it to a successful conclusion.
We have to eliminate all the rigidities in the Spanish economy in order to increase its flexibility. The government is working in this direction with the National Reform Programme and the economic stimulus plan I have announced. All the measures have to take into account the relationship between competitiveness won day-to-day and job creation.
Two and a half years later we have managed to change the trend. Two and a half years later our objectives are beginning to be achieved. Now no-one questions the change in the trend; now the objective - and it is no small task - is to improve the rate.
We are on the right path and, if you will allow me, I believe we can say without fear of being wrong that "Spain is accelerating in the return to growth."
Thank you very much.
Q&A SESSION WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT
Michael Reid: Thank you very much, President of the Government, for this very complete overview of the Spanish economy and its change in trend. You emphasised the need to accelerate growth in order to reduce unemployment and the first instrument you mentioned in this context is the stimuli package we talked about last week, of 6.3 billion euros. At first sight, it appears difficult to see how the Government can, first, commit the private part of this; and second, given that you are still within the straightjacket of fiscal targets, how can you really have more public investment without simply taking money from one pocket and putting it in another? How will it really help?
President of the Government: The first thing I would like to say as clearly as possible, in case anyone is in any doubt, is that the Government is maintaining its targets and commitments to fiscal consolidation. What is more, the target for this year was 5.8% and we have reduced it to 5.5%. This is perfectly compatible with this plan that we will approve, as I have said in my speech, next Friday; a plan worth more than 6 billion euros, with a twofold aim: first, to eliminate rigidities, above all in urban matters and others included in the Plan; second, the aim is to support certain productive sectors, thinking of the medium and long term.
How will this be financed? Basically by reorganising the European funds; and second, by some commitments derived from European Directives that the private sector itself has to undertake, above all in energy, which is one of the biggest challenges. In some cases, there are also loans from the European Investment Bank; in others, there is the reorganisation of expenses already included in the budget. In fact, the only increase in expenditure is these 6.3 billion euros in the PIVE Plan, which is certainly a minor amount and has been extended because it has had a very significant success in Spain. That should amount to thirty or forty million euros.
In other words, the approval of this plan is perfectly compatible with maintaining our commitments to fiscal consolidation.
M. Reid: On the tax side you have also indicated that there will be changes over the coming weeks. There was a report by a committee of experts that recommended, broadly speaking, lowering direct taxes and eliminating allowances, and eliminating allowances on indirect taxes as well. Do you share these recommendations and have the intention to implement them?
President of the Government: Yes, the tax reform will be approved this June, probably at the Spanish Council of Ministers on the 13th and not later than the Council of Ministers meeting on the 20th. The report of the experts, without doubt, is a report or a study that the Council of Ministers will take into account. In fact, we are working on the same basis and we agree with some of the things that are said there, while on others we have our doubts. But I believe that it is a very well-argued document, very well drafted, and a great deal of time has been put into it by many people with proven qualifications and prestige won after many years of work, so we will take it very much into account.
What are we going to do? We are going to cut personal income tax, we are going to cut corporate income tax from 30% to 25%; we are going to simplify the bands of personal income tax and we are not going to raise value added tax, although there are some people who believe that this should be done.
Those will be the most important lines of action. What we have to ensure is that this is compatible with the maintenance of our fiscal consolidation targets, and I believe that it will be possible to do so. In other words, the reform will not have an immediate effect in a year. It will be a reform, as we have already announced, that will be effective over various years; but already next year, in 2015, there will be a substantial reduction both in personal income tax and in corporate income tax.
M. Reid: But is the way of making this compatible with the fiscal balance to eliminate the allowances so that the real rate increases?
President of the Government: No. I believe that... I'm not making this statement categorically. The most important point is to increase economic activity and extend the taxable bases. This year, for example, revenues are increasing considerably compared with the past. Between 2008 and 2009 we lost seventy billion euros in revenues in Spain, which is no small figure.
Revenues have suffered due to the negative economic growth we have experienced in 2012 and 2013, above all in 2012; but this year there has been a recovery in the first four months in tax receipts; and above all, there has been one very positive piece of data: there has been a recovery in the taxes paid by small and medium-sized enterprises, which were those that suffered most directly from the crisis.
So we believe that the increased economic activity in Spain, which is reflected in the unemployment figures, as I have given them now, with almost 200,000 more people registered with the Social Security system in May, will be enough to ensure sufficient revenues and maintain our commitment with respect to the public deficit.
M. Reid: You mentioned the structural reforms implemented by the government, and it is true that compared with many other European countries Spain has done a fair amount. That is true, but what is also notable is what has not been done. For example, the airports here are still managed by a State-owned company and there have been privatisations that could have been carried out but were not. Some people say that if you really want to accelerate the drop in unemployment another labour reform is needed. How do you respond to that?
President of the Government: People have opinions about everything, as is all walks of life; but there are countries, and not insignificant ones, in the European Union, where even the national airline or electricity sector is practically State-owned.
M. Reid: But they are not a good example, are they?
President of the Government: You can be sure they're not, and that is why this is not the case here. But there is very little left for Spain to privatise.
What we are going to implement is the privatisation of the passenger rail transport sector; it is already privatised in the case of freight. And we are studying the case of AENA; it is something that is being studied; but, of course, the Government wants to be clear about things and know precisely where we are headed.
In any event, the reform process carried out by Spain is, to be frank, not comparable with what has taken place in any other country that I know, at least in recent years. And there are still some important reforms under way: the first is fiscal reform, which we have talked about earlier; the second is the reform of the public administration services. That is a major reform that has been talked about in Spain for at least the last 30 years; in fact, I believe that it has been talked about since the public administration services first existed in Spain. Now it is an issue that we are talking about seriously, that has the goal of simplifying life for the people who are at the receiving end of the administration, above all, the life of companies, and it is producing truly notable cost savings.
Look, for me, this is perhaps the most important reform that is being carried out by the Government of Spain. The fact is that it is not arousing much attention, nor is it something that generates enthusiasm and makes the front pages; but it is important.
Then there is also the reform of market unity. We are at the present time revising 2,700 government regulations and also those of the different regional governments so that there is a truly single market to make the lives of people easier. There is no point in Europe having a single market and there being in some cases 17 different regulations on the same matter. This is also one of the difficult, complex reforms that cannot be undertaken overnight; but the Government is also carrying it out and working on it.
So we have a major raft of reforms. On the labour question what we are going to do, before the summer, as I said before, is to implement the Youth Guarantee Plan, the Single Employment Portal, improve collaboration between the private employment services and the public employment services, and reform the policy of worker training, which is also undoubtedly a very important challenge, one that is very difficult but a basic requirement. The other day I explained some figures that were truly revealing: during this crisis the proportion of people with no qualifications who have lost their jobs has been 40%; but university graduates have actually increased their employment in this sector by 2%, at the height of the crisis.
So we are aware that the Dual Vocational Training we have implemented, the issue of training, is key and another of the reforms that we will have to tackle before the summer.
M. Reid: You talked about the reform of the public administration services. For those of us who look at Spain from outside, the subject of Catalonia cannot be avoided, it's out there. First of all, you give the impression that you and the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia do not talk, and one can't help thinking that this is a problem. Is that the case?
President of the Government: No. I have always talked with him whenever he has called. There has been no time ever that the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia has called me and I have not talked to him and have not received him. That has never happened. The situation is that I have not heard from him for some time. I have learned through the media that he was going to call a referendum. I found out more or less in the same way as you, with the difference that I am the President of the Government of Spain and they could have told me; but, no, I found out... And he has not called me again since then, or rather since before that happened.
But I am prepared to talk, of course.
M. Reid: There are many people in Spain, across the whole of Spain, who say that there could be a third way through a constitutional reform that could satisfy some of the discontented Catalan people and other Spanish people as well.
I read some statements you made a couple of days ago in which you said: "But what kind of constitutional reform, "symmetrical" or "asymmetrical" federalism? They should tell me." What do you think about that? Is that a solution?
President of the Government: I think that there is one thing in life that is very important: first, you have to think about things, then act; and not the other way around, act first and then think about things; because that ends up generating bizarre situations, as must be clear to everyone.
So now there is talk of a third way or talk of reforming the Constitution; but those are procedures. We have to talk about the content. What is it that you want to reform? Some people say they want a federal State. I am not set against the idea, but what is different about it? I am not against the idea if you explain clearly what it is, because how does a federal State differ from what we have in Spain? There are those who want an asymmetric federal State and if you explain what it is that an asymmetric federal State is and how it is different from what we have, we would be prepared to consider it. There are those who want the State to recover its powers; there are those who want the regional governments to have more powers and there are those who want national sovereignty to be broken up, who are those that say that in each autonomous region they should decide about their own national sovereignty.
In other words, there are many and very different opinions. Look, Spain is a country that in 1977 and 1978 made a great effort and was capable of reaching agreement, among other things, between people who had been ministers in the Franco regime and people who had come back from exile; between people who wanted a strongly centralised State and people who believed in a very de-centralised State. There was a wide-ranging national agreement, which was a very difficult procedure. We all gave ground and from it a democratic regime emerged; a regime that defended freedoms; from it emerged the system that provides most self-government in the world. There is no country in the world.... Look at Scotland. If Scotland had the level of self-government that exists in some places in Spain, I am absolutely convinced that the problem would not exist.
The Government that I lead spends 20% of total Spanish public expenditure, 20%. Think about it, 20%. That obviously does not include pensions. So it is the system of greatest self-government in the world.
That was a great agreement. Now, I am not against reforming the Constitution. In fact, it has been reformed twice in Spain. But what is very important... Of course, this is the Constitution, and it is not like the personal income tax rate tax, which you can raise, lower, discuss; some vote in favour, others against. The Constitution is the rules of the game; they are the rules for living together. So what should happen is that the vast majority of the political forces should reach an agreement, as happened in 1978.
At this present time, I frankly don't see it... I see the possibility that the PP and PSOE reach agreement, of course I see that; but what for me does not appear good for Spain is a Constitution that should emerge only with the votes of the PP and PSOE.
So, I'm not digging my heels in; but it is worth making these things very clear and, above all when someone makes a proposal, it is important that we - the others - should know about it, because all that talk about the federal system, the third way.... I have asked one of the people who is sponsoring it and he has really not been able to answer me, to be frank.
M. Reid: You referred to the great national agreement of the Transition which really did lay the very successful foundations for Spain of political harmony for a generation, but that generation has now passed. I feel that the Spain emerging from these years of economic crisis is another Spain and that the difficulty facing the country, one of the core difficulties, is that the political institutions date from another time.
For example, when we talked last time and I asked you about the risk of populism in Europe, you said to me: "Here we don't have the kind of outlandish parties that there are elsewhere." I would now ask you if after last Sunday, this statement is still true.
President of the Government: Here the elections were won by the People's Party (Partido Popular) and the Socialist Party (PSOE) came second.
M. Reid: With, for the first time, less than 50% of the vote between the two of them.
President of the Government: Yes, but in other countries the government parties have been relegated to third place.
As we stand, in a very complex situation, very difficult, with such a major economic crisis such as the one we have lived through in Spain, in elections that are traditionally used by many people to penalise the Government or the opposition party - and they have the perfect right to do so and they do so because they want to...a limited but significant majority of the Spanish people have shown their commitment to moderation and common sense; and that, in all honesty is what in the end has happened in Europe.
Who won the elections in Europe? The People's Party, at the level of Europe as a whole. Who came second? The Socialist Party, at the level of Europe as a whole. Who came third? The Liberal Party, at the level of Europe as a whole. So Ms Le Pen has won some votes and Mr Farange has won some more, and so on. But you should always put things into their correct perspective.
I believe without any doubt that countries are governed on the basis of moderation, of balance and in accordance with the fundamental issues, and that is the commitment that my party will continue to make in the future.
The other day there was something that really caught my attention: the rating agency Fitch said:"It is really incredible that the People's Party has won the European elections in Spain." That was what it said. Then it explained and said: "After all those measures and decisions it is really incredible..."
I have a great deal of confidence in the common sense of the Spanish people. I have always had it.
M. Reid: But are you confident that Spain will return to the two-party system, or rather continue with the two-party system, or do you believe that it is entering new political territory?
President of the Government: I believe that in Spain the People's Party and the Socialist Party are going to continue with a great deal of support, and I believe that is very good for Spain. The major countries, the most stable democracies, where things function best, are the countries that have two major parties, and then one or two smaller parties; that is what happens in the United Kingdom, where despite what we have seen in these European elections, you will see how next year those who won the European elections will not win. The same is the case in France where either the right or left is in government. And the same happens in Germany: Christians Democrats and Social Democrats. Those are the countries that have most stability and where there is most progress.
And then, not on our continent, but outside our continent, the decline in major parties, as has occurred in some parties in the Americas, has brought different forms of government to these countries; but let's leave that there.
M. Reid: The most pressing job this week is that of the government and Parliament: approval of the Constitutional Law on the succession to the throne. One wonders whether this new Spain that is emerging from the crisis is less monarchic than the Spain that entered the crisis; and one wonders whether there is an interpretation from the left, let's say, that this is an operation designed to ensure a transition for the Crown, while the votes are there. Is that the case, or will the Prince have absolute legitimacy in the eyes of society?
President of the Government: First, H.M. the King talked to me about this some time ago. Why? He said that he had been king for many years, that perhaps this was the time to abdicate, as has happened in other countries in the European Union. So this is not at all improvised. It is something that has been thought through, in great depth, and that he has been considering for some time, as yesterday he himself explained from Zarzuela Palace.
Second, the Prince has great popular support. He is someone who has been there for many years, who knows the world very well and who knows the reality of Spain in great depth. So we are all absolutely convinced that he will perform his role with at least the same skill as H.M. the King has done.
Third, the Spanish Constitution, approved in 1978 with an overwhelming majority, established the Monarchy as the form of State; with an overwhelming majority.
And fourth, Spain is a democracy. So in a democracy the law is very important. But now we see that there are those who ask for a referendum, who want a change and who want... Everyone who wants to change the rules of the game can do so, but they have to use the instruments established under law. So you can present before Parliament a reform of the Constitution if you believe that you don't like the Constitution. You have the perfect right to do so. The only thing that you can't do in a democracy is to sidestep the law, because we live under the rule of law and democracy. And it is very important that we should be fully aware of that.
I believe that the monarchy has overwhelming majority support in Spain and if there is someone who doesn't like it, he or she can present a reform to the Constitution.
M. Reid: I was struck by your call at the end of your speech for much closer European fiscal union and economic union. I'm not saying this because I'm British, but I believe that many people would say that you are moving against the tide in Europe; isn't the trend increasingly to retrench with a Europe of nation states? I don't know if Spain is becoming a little isolated in this.
President of the Government: I don't see it like that. Europe is a process that has not been created overnight, and its future is a long-term process. The Treaty of Rome dates back to 1957, and just look what has happened since then. At that time the European Union consisted of six countries: the three Benelux countries, France, Germany and Italy. Since then there have been some major changes, among them, the disappearance of national currencies, monetary policy, foreign-exchange policy and many other things.
I will only mention two things to you: I firmly believe in the European process and I believe that the vast majority of Europeans believe in it as well. Proof of this is that countries are queuing up to join Europe. In other words, everyone wants to join Europe; I don't know if anyone wants to leave.
M. Reid: But what kind of process?
President of the Government: I'll explain to you now the type of process: two years ago if someone talked about banking union in Europe people thought he was crazy; well, today banking union is an objective fact. It has been achieved in two years. Two years ago I recall a debate at the European Council, in June 2012; it was the time when all the talk was about fiscal consolidation in Europe and people began to talk about growth; but many things were generalities. And some of us put forward the question: why don't we set a time horizon? And then, in December that year, a project was presented that talked about banking union, where there was talk of making more progress in economic union, where there was talk of fiscal union and political union. That was in an act of the European Council of 2012.
And banking union has become a reality; as to fiscal union, the common debt and the Eurobonds, we'll see; and political union, we'll see as well. Progress with economic union will continue. Now one of the Commission's recommendations is that electricity and gas interconnections should be made, which is a substantial and very significant advance in the single market.
So what you are saying is what some people think, that's true; but we'll see how Europe develops. And I tell you: it isn't done overnight, because there are very difficult decisions involved. I believe that on the matter of immigration it is crazy that there is no common European policy, really crazy. In a place where there is free movement of people it is absurd that we don't all look after all the borders. It is absurd that we don't have a common regulation. It is absurd that immigrants have different rights in France, Italy and Spain; or that the rules on repatriation are different, because there is free movement of people.
So I have the full and absolute conviction that progress will continue in this area. I believe that we are part of a process that, luckily, is unstoppable. In Europe there are very few of us compared with other areas of the world. We account for 25% of GDP and have things that others do not, such as a first-class system of welfare, because things like healthcare, education and so on, don't exist everywhere. That is our European heritage, and I believe we have to maintain it and to do so we have to be competitive. I have talked about the Free Trade Treaty with the United States, which is also very important for us.
So that is the situation in Europe; and in any event, what you and I can agree on is that it will still take time, but there has already been progress. I tell you, banking union was nothing two years ago and now there will be a single European supervisor and a common European mechanism. Perhaps within a few years we will have European debt and Eurobonds.
M. Reid: Mr President of the Government, thank you very much for being here and opening this event; and also, above all, for your democratic attitude of accepting open questions without any type of conditions. We hope that next time we organise this event, even if there are no more abdications, at least there will be accelerated growth.
President of the Government: Yes, that's the key. Thank you very much.