Speech by President of the Government at Plenary Session of Lower House of Parliament to report on Stability Programme and National Reform Plan
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed the Spanish Lower House plenary in May 2013 to report on Spain's Stability Programme and National Reform Plan submitted to Brussels.
- Main themes
- Fiscal deficit reduction, Spain's Stability Programme, National Reform Plan, unemployment crisis, EU economic governance, public expenditure cuts, structural reforms, economic competitiveness, GDP targets, Stability and Growth Pact
- Duration
- ~41 min
- Words
- 4,891
- Sentences
- 231
- Readability
- 57
- Grade
- 10.3
- Syntax
- 2.96
- Vocabulary
- 2.07
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other231 sentences in 87 paragraphs
Ladies and gentlemen,
The difference between the first situation and the other is enormous. Just think, for a moment, what we would have had to do at the Council of Ministers on 26 [April] if we had not been able to propose this new deficit limit: a raft of actions, both in regard to revenue and expenditure, which would have very drastically affected a wide spectrum of Spanish society.
As a reference, remember that last year the deficit reduction of the public sector reached the figure of 22 billion euros and the enormous effort this meant for everyone. The reduction forecast for 2013 was 26 billion euros, which will now drop to a little over 7.2 billion euros. This gap marks the difference between a path of reasonable and viable deficit reduction and a social and economic stranglehold on this year for the Spanish people.
That is the most substantial aspect of the plans we have submitted to Brussels. Everything else, whilst containing important aspects, is a question of either minor adjustments, which amount to around 3 billion euros, or reforms that we are going to implement.
I have requested an appearance to report on all this. There are no changes in the course of this government, Honourable Members, but we are in a new situation that will allow us greater room to manoeuvre.
I will also take advantage of this debate to report to you on the new data contained in the Active Population Survey in relation to the first quarter of this year which, as you are all aware, shows a total figure of unemployed that exceeds 6.2 million people. I know that this is not new. In fact, two months ago, in the Debate on the State of the Nation, I started my speech by indicating that we then had 5,965,000 citizens out of work. This is not new, nor unexpected in a situation of economic recession, but I cannot get used to these figures nor much less resign myself to them.
We are faced with the harshest aspect of our economic reality, both because of its seriousness and because of its extent. We are faced with the most dramatic image of Spanish society which forces us to continue viewing it as the core of our entire economic policy, as I will endeavour to explain to you this morning.
Honourable Members,
As you are aware, in April, all of the Member States of the European Union must present their economic programmes to Brussels: the National Reform Plan and the Stability Programme. This is not something that has just been invented. This dates back to the entry into effect of the Euro. As a result of the 1998 Stability and Growth Pact, the Member States of the Monetary Union must draw up a Stability Programme and the rest of the countries a Convergence Programme. Honourable Members, we are talking about more than 15 years responding to these obligations of common commitments. In turn, the National Reform Plan dates back to 2005, following the so-called Kok report, which summarised in a single document the different procedures for coordinating economic policies then already existed.
Honourable Members, Brussels does not impose these matters, but rather we demand them as Europeans, because that it how we want Europe to be.
Since then Spain has presented its updated plan year after year, in exactly the same way as the other Member States.
I am clarifying these things because, to judge by what has been said in the last few days, some people seem to think that we are faced by a measure that is imposed on Spain in an exceptional manner, as if it were a case of a singular evaluation of our capabilities. That is not the case. It is not new, it is not exceptional, nor is it specific to us. All countries have to do it. All twenty-seven. In essence, each country, in its Stability Programme, seeks to outline the way in which it intends to fulfil its obligations on the matter of the public deficit. That is the main issue. The rest of the content only seeks to give credibility to this.
Honourable Members,
What Spain presented a few days ago is simply an adaptation adjusted to the changes that have been taking place in recent times, both here in Spain and in Europe as a whole.
On the one hand, the National Reform Plan takes stock of the recently approved reforms, quantifies their impact and outlines the actions being taken or that are soon to be taken. The Honourable Members are well aware of the latter actions, since they were recently announced in the Debate on the State of the Nation. It is thus a question of employing Eurospeak to set out the strategy of economic policy, the measures and the effects of the same that we have been applying in this legislature to make our economy more competitive and flexible.
But what is most important, as I already mentioned, is that the new chart contained in the Stability Programme estimates that the public deficit will stand at 6.3% of GDP, this year which will fall to 5.5% in 2014, 4.1% in 2015 and be below 3% in 2016. However, the effort in structural terms in 2013 is very similar to that of 2012, at two percentage points of GDP, to ensure compliance with our obligations to Europe.
The commitment to the nominal deficit has, however, been reduced and I believe that we can all congratulate ourselves on that because, Honourable Members, the reduced effort this year is a welcome respite for the Spanish people because otherwise, the situation would have been unbearable.
Last year we managed to reduce the deficit by 22 billion euros through making enormous sacrifices. This year, with Europe in recession, it was unthinkable that we could reduce our deficit by 26 billion euros, which is 4 billion more than in 2012. It is enough for you to just imagine what it would have meant to reduce the deficit by this amount. And I'm not speaking about what it would have meant for the autonomous regions or local authorities. Just think about some of the competencies of central government, such as pensions or unemployment benefits.
This is the main value of the Stability Programme: setting the deficit objective for the public administration services. That is what we commit to as a country as we are obliged to do.
So, to make this proposal it is necessary to base it on certain forecasts. Forecasts are a very important instrument, but they are only an instrument that can guide us towards taking the true decision, which is the path of the deficit.
These forecasts should be realistic and in line with the financial year under way. Nobody has missed the fact that both the forecasts on activity and the forecasts on employment correspond to a reality that was not foreseen. Nobody imagined, not here nor elsewhere, that the recession in the European Union would be as it is, nobody at all. That clearly limits our ability to grow.
When we talk about forecasts, Honourable Members, we are talking about this, about forecasts, and not about anything else, as it seems to me that someone else wanted to understand. We have made them conservatively, something which should alarm no-one, because that is reasonable. They are deliberately prudent estimates, which makes them more serious and more reliable.
I would not want to give a false impression whatsoever. I want to be, and I want us all to be, realists. Would it be better to do things like before, when the figures were employed wishfully, in an attempt to shine, but which, in the end, only served to enhance the level of mistrust in Spain?
The forecasts, Honourable Members, are not even a publicity campaign on the part of the government, nor should be manipulated to plant false hopes or, on the contrary, to cause unjustified alarm. They don't even have to be met. I am the first one to desire that some of them do not come to fruition and I will do everything possible for this to happen. Everyone can appreciate that, if a doctor predicts that a patient will come out of intensive care in two weeks' time, but at the end of the first week the patient is ready to leave, no-one will stop him, as you would expect. His forecast will be forgotten. Well, the same applies to us.
Nor do these forecasts reflect any change in our objectives, in the guidelines or in the course of our economic policy. Anyone who thinks that these forecasts change this government's economic policy is mistaken.
We are not the only ones to correct them. The International Monetary Fund, the OECD, the European Commission and all the European countries have changed their forecasts for this year yet no-one thinks that they are changing their economic policy.
I very much regret disappointing those who enjoy spreading alarm, but they are clutching at straws. They are confusing the forecasts with government policy and they are wrong.
The government's policy, by way of example, aims to reduce the deficit and that has not changed. The forecast is limited to offering an approximation of the rate at which something happens and the possibilities within. It contributes to setting a path for the reduction and then adding credibility to this.
I would like to insist on this point: these forecasts do not represent any change in economic policy, and much less a change for the worse. They represent, firstly, meeting an obligation and, secondly, adapting better to circumstances in which we will continue applying the same policy; a policy whose final objective is to reactivate the economy and create jobs, and which is now creating the necessary bases to achieve that.
Remember, Honourable Members, that to lay these foundations it was necessary to remove the barriers that blocked our path: inflation, the deficit of the public sector, the foreign trade deficit, the weight of our debt and the problems of the financial sector. These things have all been implemented in 2012 and some of these barriers no longer exist. We will speak about this in greater detail later, but first allow me to insist on the need to maintain the coherence of the actions in line with the course we have set.
Honourable Members,
There are two very sound reasons for not changing the government's guidelines, not in terms of the deficit or in terms of the structural reforms: the first reason is that we have 6.2 million unemployed; the second is that we are meeting our objectives. I repeat this because I want it to be perfectly clear: all our economic policies, and a good part of our social policy, have been established as a result of these unemployed, numbering more than 6 million.
We are not playing a game on two boards, to put it another way: that of the economy and that of unemployment. No, Honourable Members. We are playing on one board only, because the creation of jobs is inseparable from correcting the serious economic imbalances that we inherited. That is what we are doing; straightening out what was previously twisted.
The previous government made the mistake of thinking that it was possible to stimulate growth in economic activity and create jobs without correcting the imbalances. The result was that it couldn't stimulate growth; as we are all aware, it stimulated unemployment and the enormous hole in the public coffers that we are now trying to fill.
Don't ask me to repeat this folly, particularly in a climate of stagnation that is not only affecting Spain but the whole of the European Union.
What these 6.2 million unemployed want is not that we throw all these sacrifices, all this effort and all the progress achieved in the last 16 months out of the window, but rather, what they need is that we climb out of this hole as soon as possible.
And as you can see, Honourable Members, we have made a great deal of progress in a very short period of time and, according to general international opinion, we have left the worst behind, so now we are under a moral obligation to not be frivolous with the interests of the people, to not perform experiments with the economy and to persevere in the same direction, because that is the course that will lead to correcting our imbalances, to overcoming stagnation and, consequently, to the creation of new jobs.
The figure of 6,202,700 unemployed as reflected in the Active Population Survey for the first quarter is the best incentive for not taking even the tiniest step backwards and for firmly and resolutely maintaining the course set. Neither continuous change, nor appearing to do so, nor indeed playing to the gallery have any value whatsoever and prove to be very costly. We have seen that in the past and we have still not finished paying the price. It would be folly to repeat the same mistakes. Six million unemployed don't deserve flippancy of this nature, nor indeed erratic policies, but rather hard work, sacrifice and perseverance.
We are here to give these unemployed and their families an opportunity, to turn the situation around and to create jobs. I was not elected for any other reason and that it what I am going to do.
Honourable Members,
We are undertaking the best employment policy possible, removing the pitfalls and cleaning up our economy from everything that contributed to jobs being shed and to blocking the creation of new job positions. There is no better employment policy than removing imbalances. Everything else is simply a caricature.
We do not need to look for shortcuts that are mere illusions or improvise through erratic measures, but rather we need to persevere with our reforms and allow time for those under way to take effect, because we not only intend to correct this situation, but also to avoid it returning. We want to prevent Spain - every time that a crisis appears on the horizon - from falling back into its old habit of generating mass unemployment.
Honourable Members,
I am not saying this empty-handed. Things are changing in Spain, fortunately, and they are changing considerably. Perhaps the best sign of the recovery is the ease with which we forget everything we have left behind.
Just a year ago we were on the verge of bankruptcy, Honourable Members; a year ago we were under the constant threat of a bailout. Since then, something has changed in Spain. Nobody now asks me whether we are going to ask for a bailout. Until just a few months ago I was asked this question every day. Why am I not being asked that now? I will tell you why: I am not being asked this because the people of Spain, during the course of last year, showed a fierce desire to improve, a capacity for sacrifice and a commitment to meeting their commitments and these have blown away any doubts.
Today nobody doubts Spain and that is the best sign of the change we are undergoing.
Just a year ago we were going through two extraordinarily critical periods. Around this time then we were on the verge of being bailed out because of the problems with one part of our financial system. What for some was "the best financial system in the world" was on the verge of wiping us out. We overcame this, as we overcame the very serious sovereign debt crisis in the month of July.
What is a better sign of the changes than the evolution of the risk premium? Nine months ago it stood at 638 points whereas now it is less than half that. What does this mean? It means that we are paying a lot less for the money we need to service our debt. Or better put, it means we are being asked for less because we are trusted more.
Just a year ago, a good part of the savings in public expenditure disappeared into servicing our debt. The fall in the risk premium means that by the end of this year we could make savings under this heading in excess of 1 billion euros. We are not talking about a heading of the Budget, but rather the most important one after pensions, and ahead of unemployment benefits. That is not just one more item.
Do care those who can't find a job about the fact that the interest rate on our debt has fallen to 4%? Undoubtedly, Honourable Members, they care a lot. They probably have not perceived it yet but it means there will soon be a lot more possibilities of finding work. That goal is now closer; there is one barrier less to overcome.
And what has happened with our foreign debt? Something surprising, Honourable Members, Spain does not need financing from overseas. I am not talking about a change in respect of last year; this is a case of a new chapter in our history. Does anyone know the last time this happened? It's hard to remember that far back. We are at a true crossroads in the Spanish economy. We reached a point where we had to get into as much debt as 10% of our GDP, in other words, more than 100 billion euros in one year under this heading. That was an awful lot of money, Honourable members, so much so that the net foreign debt reached as high as 900 billion euros in 2011.
Fortunately, we have turned the situation around and we are starting to return what we needed to ask for before. And it is not small change either! I am talking about a surplus, of what economists call "financing capacities vis-à-vis the rest of the world", of around 2%, which amounts to some 20 billion euros.
But, aside from the amount, which is considerable in itself, what is particularly important is that we are reducing our foreign debt. Returning, rather than asking for, credit. And this qualitative change translates into confidence and tranquillity as regards our country.
Honourable Members,
Together with the public sector deficit, the foreign debt imbalance has historically been the blight of the Spanish economy which has most often strangled our possibilities of growth. And there you have it, one barrier less.
Something is changing, Honourable Members, and not by chance. These changes, the fall in the risk premium or the volte-face of the balance of payments, among other things, are not the result of a miracle. This is a hard-won victory for the Spanish people. This has been earned by being more competitive; the social stakeholders have reached an historic agreement on wage moderation; through the efforts made by our companies to export, particularly SMEs; through adjusting margins; making our level of inflation one of the lowest in the Eurozone and beating records in terms of our trade and services balance. Our economy is more open, it sells more overseas than it buys, and this is diversified in terms of markets and sectors.
Neither is it a miracle that we were offered up to 100 billion euros to overcome the financial crisis under extraordinary conditions: a term of 15 years at an interest rate of 0.5%, with a grace period of 10 years. This was the result of negotiations that were possible because Spain had one more become credible.
We could say the same thing about the new rhythm in the deficit adjustment. It was not a miracle that we have been able to reduce the effort by 18.9 billion euros this year, nor is it a question of finding the European Commissioner for Economic and Monetary Affairs in a good mood. This was the result of negotiations with a country that is changing, that keeps its own accounts well, that meets its commitment, and that has stuck its head above water and become credible once again.
I repeat, Honourable Members, it is not a miracle that the risk premium has dropped and that it is now cheaper to service our debt. This has been a hard-won victory for the Spanish people based on sacrifice, commitment and perseverance. No other country made the same level of commitment as did the Spanish people in 2012. This was unparalleled, both in Spain and abroad. That is why we are now credible.
I repeat, none of this is down to good luck, in the same way as nothing that took place before was the result of bad luck.
It wasn't bad luck that sunk us before. We sought it out through obstinacy and made it worse for years through our own stubbornness. And, in the same way that it was not a result of bad luck, it is clear that the effort being made now by the Spanish people serves a purpose. We are making progress in the midst of serious difficulties and, despite that, the foundations that will sustain our recovery are being made stronger with every day that passes; some of these spectacularly, considerably more than the forecasts indicated.
But I say all of this, Honourable Members, without any shred of triumphalism, because this task will not be complete until we resolve our main objective which is to return those unemployed to work. No shred of triumphalism, but neither do I want anyone to be unjust, not in respect to Spain, nor to the Spanish people and the sacrifices they have made or the example they have given, because that is something we can all be proud of.
We have made a great deal of progress in terms of this economic imbalance of the public sector deficit. Progress has made been made but we are not finished yet. I would remind you that we acquired this at 9% of the Gross Domestic Product, even though we were told that 2011 would close at 6%.
We made a huge effort last year. We reduced it by two percentage points. Two points, Honourable Members, which amounts to 22 billion euros, as I said earlier. This was very important, very costly, very painful and all the more so because it was done in the middle of a recession, in other words, in particularly unfavourable circumstances.
If we had been enjoying growth, the revenue derived from this very growth in the economy would have been greater, but this was not the case. That is why, in addition to reducing expenditure, we had to raise taxes which made us subject to criticism and unpopular.
I will be told that this measure - raising taxes - had negative effects for growth. I am aware of that, but we had to prioritise reducing the deficit. At that time - remember, last July - with the sovereign debt crisis at boiling point and with the risk premium in excess of 600 points, had there been any sign of weakness at all, the pressure from the financial markets would have inevitably led us to a bailout.
It is clear that what we attempted to resolve back then was an issue prior to tackling economic growth. The very credibility of Spain was at stake; whether Spain could meet its commitments or not; whether it was capable or not of controlling its accounts.
And, if Spain had not met its commitments, Honourable Members, the risk premium would not now stand at 280 basis points, nor would the return on the 10-year bond stand at 4%, nor would our companies have been able to issue bonds to finance themselves in the international markets. None of the elements of progress that I have pointed out would have taken place. This would have been an infernal vicious circle because we would have irreparably been condemned to the loss of economic sovereignty and been immersed in a crisis that would have been more serious, harsher and longer-lasting.
For example, on Sunday 28 April - just a few days ago - the Council of Ministers met on an extraordinary basis in Athens, and a little later, the Greek Parliament. The purpose was to urgently approve a series of measures to unblock a part of the second bailout to Greece: 2.8 billion euros pending payment since March and another 6 billion euros more corresponding to the second quarter. The Greeks urgently needed this money to pay public sector wages, pensions, and bonds that had fallen due. There is no need to say how unpopular the raft of measures approved was for the Greeks.
Spain has been saved from situations like this, because at those times, back then, we were not administering our own future but rather taking a grip on attaining the possibility of having a future. Fortunately, thanks to what some have criticised, Spain today has little in common with where we were back just a year ago. We are no longer empty-handed; we no longer raise doubts beyond our borders. We have managed to overcome barriers that seemed insurmountable within an incredibly short period of time and we have achieved this because the Spanish people understood this, accepted it and suffered.
It has been very tough but it has not been in vain.
Consequently, Honourable Members, we need to persevere and allow these measures to act which will enable the results to come. Economic policy cannot be improvised, it cannot change with every step, nor are there magic potions or short-cuts to be taken.
There is no measure that can work miracles overnight. They all require time and we must allow them this time. That is called perseverance: carrying on with the task at hand, not leaving things half-done and not abusing the sacrifices made.
This government has not changed its course since the very first day in office, nor does it intend to do so. Don't expect us to veer off course or submit to folly. Adapting to circumstance is one thing, idle folly is another. We will continue with the same policy, which will result in palpable results, which will help clean up our accounts, which has enabled us to recover the trust of the international community and, above all, which has laid sounder foundations for stable growth.
So we will continue with the same objectives and with the same instruments because there is still important work ahead of us and we must finish it.
In summary, Honourable Members,
Spain is now fortunately in a new situation; it is sounder and has a better future ahead than a year ago. We are implementing structural reforms that will place Spanish society in a position to compete in the globalised economy of the 21st Century. We have drawn up a programme of reforms and proposed a realistic path for reducing the public deficit, to which end we have just updated the macroeconomic chart containing forecasts more in line with the national and international situation.
As I have made clear, this does not represent any change in the main guidelines of our economic policy. As I mentioned, the best service we can offer to those who are unemployed is to persevere with our policy until such time as all the obstacles blocking the growth of economic activity and job creation are removed.
We can say that today we are considerably closer to remedying this situation than a year ago.
In short, Honourable Members, this is now starting to work. This is still much work to be done, but the rewards will be reaped. Next year we will start to see very clear changes because, among other things, we will come out of recession and start to grow.
Honourable Members,
That is the work to which I would invite anyone to sign up to who truly seeks to help the unemployed with something more than mere good wishes and pipedreams. I am open to any useful suggestions that would help us to become stronger and more effective to the benefit of the Spanish people. Any form of help to reach the objectives we have proposed will be welcome, not because the government lacks sufficient parliamentary support, but rather because we are faced with a responsibility that touches us all and to which everyone can undoubtedly contribute.
This is a battle that is necessary to win every day, tirelessly and without giving in to resignation. I am not used to, nor will I become used to, the unemployment panorama in Spain. I have a mandate to meet - to turn the situation around - and I have set myself the target of fulfilling that. We were elected to do that and we will indeed do that.
We do not lack confidence in the plan we are applying, nor faith in the capabilities of the Spanish economy, nor security that the Spanish people - although they recognise the bitterness of the effort that we have had to make - do not wish a return of the calamities we have now put behind us.
Honourable Members,
We are not on the wrong path, nor have we wasted time, nor are our hands empty. The worst is behind us, we have stopped the rot and we will now start to improve and the results will come, because we will all know how to steadfastly follow the path that lies ahead of us.
Thank you all very much.