Speech by President of the Government at plenary session of Lower House of Parliament to present Draft Constitutional Laws on control of economic-financial activity of political parties and Regulating exercise of senior positions in General State Administration
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed the Spanish Lower House in November 2014 to present draft constitutional laws on controlling political party finances and regulating senior public administration positions amid widespread corruption scandals.
- Main themes
- Political corruption, anti-corruption legislation, democratic accountability, public trust in institutions, financial control of political parties, senior public officials regulation, economic crisis context, transparency in government, rule of law, civic indignation
- Duration
- ~40 min
- Words
- 4,851
- Sentences
- 215
- Readability
- 49
- Grade
- 12.0
- Syntax
- 3.01
- Vocabulary
- 2.12
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other215 sentences in 103 paragraphs
Honourable Members,
Corruption has become front page news in the Spanish press. A good portion of the written press and television news is given over to report on corruption scandals, whether new ones or those that are starting to sound old, to their trends, to the comings and goings of the defendants, to the police records, to the Guardia Civil vans… This is what is being fed to the people of Spain.
An inevitable consequence of this extensive impression is that, wherever you look, what you see is people exploiting opportunities offered by democracy and its institutions for their own personal gain. And with that, the worrying sensation has also become extensive that the essential principles of democratic co-existence are wobbling, such as those that require the visibility of political action, expenditure control, responsibility of public authorities, etc.
A climate is being created which is untenable because it is sowing widespread mistrust in the instruments of democratic co-existence.
I understand the indignation of the Spanish people. I understand it and I share it. The whole world knows that corrupt members of my own party have been unearthed, people who had been worthy of my trust or that of my political party. I have apologised for that.
Having said that, Honourable Members, we should remember that, unfortunately, none of this is new in the short history of our democracy. It is not new, but when so many cases come to light, when the number of scandals piles up in such a way, who can be surprised that this occupies the main focus for attention, concern and irritation of our citizens? Nobody, Honourable Members, and much less so when the corruption affects politicians, and much less so when this comes at a time of economic crisis.
We should not be surprised that people do not judge all cases of corruption equally. Our citizens are more scandalised by those involved in public office, because that lays bare a disloyalty that was not expected of them, they have betrayed the trust placed in us, a trust which should oblige us to demonstrate exemplary conduct.
Neither can we forget the circumstances which we are going through. I refer to the crisis and its consequences on employment and on household economies. Any predator can see how insulting this is to those that have to work numbers to reach the end of the month; this shows indifference to the sacrifice of others and to the efforts of those who meet their obligations to the community and who look speechless at how their sacrifices are turned into reward for others.
It is true that this panorama has many faces and nuances. I am aware that, if so many cases are uncovered today it is because they are being combated and our institutions are working well. I know that everything that comes to light speaks more of the past than of the present.
Nor do I ignore the fact that a good part of the impression created responds to the very duration of the legal proceedings, because the same cases reappear so many times and last for so long, even with the same images broadcast, that it is inevitable that this has a multiplying effect and leaves the impression that we never climb out of the same hole.
While there are undoubtedly many nuances, we are not concerned by any of them here and now, because what is true is that corruption is a fact of life and our citizens are fed up with thinking about it.
For that reason, I will not go into whether there are many cases or few. All corruption, abundant or not, is corrosive for our civic spirit, it harms democracy and undermines Spain. Any corruption is always too much and cannot be tolerated. A respected country must always prosecute it the minute it appears and in as rigorous a manner as necessary.
And that is what we have come here to talk about. Not of the need to prosecute this blight, which is already being done: all corrupt individuals uncovered are now facing trial. We have come here to try to make this more effective, in other words, so that we can guarantee not only uncovering and punishing all those that try to remain hidden, but also ensuring that we are going to be pre-emptive and reduce or eliminate the opportunities that exist for corruption.
But I don't want to get ahead of myself, Honourable Members, without making certain considerations at the risk of confusing our objective. It is very important not to fight ghosts, but rather realities; not against emotional impressions but rather against objective facts.
We have not come here to fight the ghost of "generalised corruption", because such "generalised corruption" does not exist. To accept this would mean confessing that everyone here today, or a good part of us, are corrupt. That would be a grave injustice, and above all, a grave mistake for whoever tries to get the task right that has been entrusted to us by the Spanish people.
Injustice concerns me greatly. I cannot accept that the suspicion of corruption taints every Spanish politician. Does being elected by our citizens to a public post now change honest people into corrupt people? Do the errors of any professional, whatever it may be, or even of fifty professionals, discredit the whole profession?
I can understand the annoyance of our citizens and the mistrust, because I share them, but neither one nor the other justify the generalisation of guilt. If we must generalise, it is to proudly uphold that the majority of our public representatives are decent people.
Honourable Members, Spain is not corrupt. Spain has certain corrupt individuals which fortunately, we are bringing to light. The rest are untainted and we would do well to remember that. Neither Spain, nor the Spanish people, nor its representatives, nor its companies, nor its workers are tainted.
If I didn't believe what I am saying, I wouldn't be here. Why? Corruption would be invincible.
Nor do I believe that corruption particularly exists in any specific sectors. That is another myth, Honourable Members. Corruption has no colour or allegiance. The only thing that it interests it is opportunity.
If we are asked, and rightly so, to do away with the diseased part, it is because it is only one part, and a small part, of a whole that is well. We are here to prosecute real corruption and not the ghost that portrays the evil, which, if we are successful, will disappear under its own steam.
Honourable Members.
Let's not add lies to the corruption. I don't only say this because it is unfair or because it makes our objective unclear; I say it because it is dangerous, because it breeds generalised mistrust that ends up laying the blame, not on corruption, but on our very democracy.
It starts by generalising corruption, laying the blame at the doors of the politicians, then to politics in general and ends up blaming the system. After that, there is no room left except for the patriotic diehards who want to sweep things away, whose only political programme lies in sweeping everything under the carpet, with the consequences that we are all aware of.
It would be a contradiction if those who have proposed to regenerate democracy, and give it more life, more stability and more trust, use the fight against corruption, not to strengthen our institutions, but as an excuse to destabilise them.
Honourable Members,
The legislative changes we are debating today are not the first measures that this government has taken against corruption. We would do well to remember this to know where we find ourselves and appreciate the contributions made by the new reforms.
We are not starting from scratch. Since the very start of this legislature we have made efforts to improve the quality of our democracy. In other words, from the very first moment. As you may remember, the first Council of Ministers of this government, the very first, approved a legislative initiative to reform the Law on the Financing of Political Parties.
As of that moment we drew up a raft of legal reforms to regenerate our democracy and better combat corruption. I imagine that you can all remember, because some of them were approved by this very House and others, directly by government, through regulatory means.
Thanks to these measures, which are already in force, Honourable Members:
All of this, Honourable Members, which is very important and is already proving very effective for avoiding corruption in the future, has now been in force for the last two years.
Spain no longer operates as it did when we came to power, and we would do well to remember that:
I don't want to go on too long in every aspect of progress we have made so that our citizens can have access, through the Transparency Portal, to all the information that may be of interest to them. This portal will be available on the Internet as from 10 December, and the new Transparency and Good Governance Council will come into operation, with the aim of promoting the visibility of public activity, overseeing compliance with reporting obligations, protecting the exercise of the right of access to public information and guaranteeing the observance of the provisions on good governance.
In short, Honourable Members, we have not stood by and watched corruption, nor did the fight for democratic regeneration begin this morning.
I would not stress this, which is obvious and evident, if it wasn't for the fact that, all too often, I hear people talking about the lack of government initiatives on the matter of corruption which, as well as being false, affects all of us, because it confuses and demoralises our citizens.
It is not a question of boasting, but it is clear - it would seem to be so and you are witnesses and co-participants - that my government, in just a few months, has adopted more measures aimed at cleaning up Spanish public life than others that have also gone through times such as these.
I simply mention that to put things in their place. I know that in the explosive mix of corruption and political diatribe, objectivity is quickly lost. Even so, it is not necessary to make a great effort to acknowledge that these things have not been done for many years in Spain but that now they are being done. In other words, we don't need to start from scratch because it is already more difficult to become corrupt in Spain than before we were entrusted with governing. And it will certainly be far more difficult when the reforms I present today are approved.
As I said before, there are two draft laws: the Draft Law on economic-financial control of political parties and the Draft Law regulating the exercise of senior positions in the General State Administration, to which we have added a third pillar: the reform of the Criminal Code and the amendments to the Criminal Procedure Act, to the Public Administration System and to Public Sector Contracts.
As I have already said, we will present various amendments to both draft laws which have been extensively debated with various parliamentary groups since March, to improve them. Furthermore, we are incorporating new provisions from experience and from suggestions from experts that gave testimony in this House in April but which had not been envisaged in the original design.
What are our intentions? To put it clearly, if you will allow me, I want "the person who does it to pay for it", and of course I also want the justice system to apply sentences swiftly. What I mean is that we need to facilitate the task of the justice system and increase sentences for corruption. They should be sufficiently severe so as for anyone who is corrupt to think twice before stepping out of line.
But that is not all we are going to do. It is not enough to increase sentences because that does not solve the problem I want to solve. Our objective must be for corruption not to take place because we have found a way to remove the opportunities for it.
In any democracy that is older than ours it is well known that, in politics, everything done behind peoples backs, however good it may be, is suspect. Audacity breeds where there are no obstacles in its way.
It is necessary for no financial decisions to be taken in the shadows. Public life and, in particular, the use of public funds must be effected in a public forum, before everyone. We need to fight decisively against the conditions that favour corruption and the impunity of those guilty thereof.
Let's look at things in detail.
We have presented the Draft Constitutional Law on the control of the economic-financial activity of political parties, with the aim of imposing more control, more supervision and greater transparency through important extraordinary measures. I will mention only three:
We wish to improve the provisions of this draft law through two amendments:
All that is in relation to financing, but things don't stop there. It is very important for democratic regeneration that we set certain minimum standards of operation for political parties.
In this regard, we will propose various far-reaching amendments to this draft law. The government's intention is to require all political parties to have rules of operation that contain certain ethical and democratic guidelines. Whilst respecting the freedom of organisation, we will ensure that the protection of the rights of members is guaranteed by law.
For example,
In addition to these rules which, as you can see, represent a guarantee for members' rights, we will add obligations on conduct for members that will serve as evidence of their exemplary nature before the people of Spain. For this reason,
We are thus creating new obligations for political parties, in their accounts and in their internal regulations. And also new consequences in the event that these are not complied with.
In short, any party which, within a certain term, does not comply with the new legal obligations to adapt their articles of association to the new law, or to present their annual accounts to the Court of Auditors, may be closed down. In other words, the Register of Political Parties can legally request that their registration be cancelled.
To give you an idea, there are approximately 4,200 registered political parties. They will all need to present their annual accounts to the watchdog, regardless of whether they receive subsidies or not, and they will all need to adapt their articles of association. In short, they will all need to be more transparent and more democratic.
The second draft law that concerns us today is the Law Regulating the Exercise of Senior Positions in the General State Administration, which seeks to provide our country with a true Statute on senior positions, clarify the obligation of these officials and determine the controls they should be subject to. It contains a list of requirements and rules that those who exercise duties of responsibility in the public administration must comply with.
- Firstly, requirements of honour, such as the requirement to present a declaration of responsibility upon being appointed and a clean criminal record in relation to certain offences.
- Secondly, stricter regulations and a more rigorous control of remuneration and assets.
- Thirdly, this law will contain increased controls on incompatibilities and on the office entrusted therewith. This office, in addition to collaborating with other bodies to carry out the corresponding checks and balances, will report to the Lower House of Parliament on a half-yearly basis, on due compliance with the system of incompatibilities and, moreover, on the publication of their declaration of assets.
In regard to this law, as with the previous law, we propose amendments that extend these requirements and obligations.
- Firstly, because the honour and trust that is worthy and required of public office also demands that their conduct as a citizen is exemplary, in other words, that they are up-to-date with paying taxes and that this is duly certified. From now on this will be essential in order to obtain a position of responsibility, because it will be obligatory to present a certificate substantiating their tax situation.
- Secondly, because, in order to facilitate the work of the Office of Conflicts of Interest, we are going to increase the resources at its disposal. We want it to be able to take on its new functions effectively so that it can attend to reporting duties and collaborate with public and private bodies that call on it.
Let's move on, Honourable Members, to the so-called "third pillar of democratic regeneration", which is where the criminal and procedural measures to fight corruption are contained.
The control of political parties and senior officials I have referred to is necessary but not enough by itself. We need to provide a clear and resounding response to conduct that is unlawful.
We believe that this reform must take place as part of the Criminal Code, because we need to provide the existing criminal offences to combat corruption with greater effectiveness and, moreover, adapt them to the severity of this conduct.
But the existing offences are not enough. For that reason, we also propose to create two new offences to complement the criminal tools available:
It is also essential to reform procedural legislation, because we need to be swifter and more effective in terms of court action. We are aware that our justice system needs to be quicker, because slow justice loses effectiveness and arouses mistrust in citizens under the rule of law.
While justice is equal for everyone, it is necessary to impose so in due time so that it does not result in early sentencing, as occurs on many occasions, or in a form of impunity.
To this end, our aim is to strengthen the classification of certain offences and also to speed up legal proceedings: all of them in general and those that affect corruption in particular.
This will require amendments to the Criminal Procedure Act. In what regard, Honourable Members? We want to speed up "macro-processes" in such a way that the instruction phase of very complex cases can continue their course without the need for a whole chain of hearings. This will thus avoid cases with great social repercussions from remaining open for years, allowing defendants to appear before one court and establish, as the case may be, the corresponding criminal liability or if not, at least with reasonable timelines.
We also want to set a maximum term for the instruction phase, making the rights of defendants and the requirements of the investigative work compatible with the duration of this period.
And we also want, Honourable Members, for all the assets that the offender is obliged to return to take place swiftly because society deserves, not only to see how those who break the law are punished, but also to see that the economic damage caused by their activities is immediately redressed.
In short, the aim is for the eternity that trials of certain complex economic offences suppose or the impossibility of locating and stripping the offender of their unlawful gains to cease to be newsworthy. It is preferable to hand out justice swiftly, recover everything and redress the damage.
And, Honourable Members, given that all these legislative measures must be accompanied by a greater effort in terms of the means and resources available to fight corruption, we are also considering, for example, announcing a new wave of judicial and prosecutorial appointments, or allocating resources to help drive new technologies, such as those to be approved this very Friday in the Council of Ministers.
Honourable Members of Parliament,
There has been much talk about the time at which the association with a case of corruption should affect the exercise of public representation. In the case of Members of the Upper and Lower Houses of Parliament, the Regulation of the House determines the system for suspending rights and duties, which we are prepared to extend, provided that there is consensus on this complex issue, which there is, in Parliament, because I believe that it makes perfect sense for this moment in time to not respond to individual criteria, but rather to a regulated system.
And I still have another three proposals to mention which I will outline briefly:
This is, Honourable Members, what the government proposes in a much summarised fashion. I understand that, although I have limited myself to a single subject, the raft of reforms may appear overwhelming, because it is, and I hope that it is equally overwhelming for those, in the future, who fall into the trap of betraying the trust placed in them by our citizens.
I have just outlined a very detailed legal structure which is unprecedented in Spain and which affects many aspects of the public administration where we couldn't improvise by pussyfooting and where it wasn't easy to harmonise objectives and priorities.
We have laid out on the table everything that, in my opinion, is necessary in order to regenerate our democracy and effectively prosecute corruption. Overall, all the legally articulated instruments, plus what may be suggested to also be of use here, undoubtedly represents a powerful arsenal to help reduce corruption in our country to the minimum level that could be considered compatible with our civic commitment.
This is an ambitious reform. It doesn't seek to sweep away passing scandals; it doesn't conform with adopting a handful of isolated measures, however appropriate they may be; it is not limited to mobilising just one part of the public administration…Far from it Honourable Members; far from any passing interest, it seeks, and I believe achieves this, to get to the root of the problem, to modify our legislative structure, to alert our public authorities and to add force to our codified texts to seal off all those loopholes that facilitate crime and impunity.
I have already said this: we are facing a very serious problem and the government has taken this very seriously.
Honourable Members,
No-one can guarantee that corruption will disappear from this planet where it has been present since day one, because no-one is in a position to eradicate selfishness, petty-mindedness or greed. This forms part of our very nature. What is within our grasp is to keep them in check, to prevent them from acting, to remove opportunities, to put public life under the spotlight and punish transgression harshly.
Only time will tell if we have built a sufficiently elaborate network to halt the ambitions of anyone aspiring to delinquency. Time will tell if we need to make corrections. If it is necessary, we will make them because, provided that our will does not change, provided that we don't lose sight of our objectives, we will always be able to improve our laws to better achieve them.
Honourable Members, we are faced with a commitment that calls for responsibility from everyone. I have expressed on many occasions that I would like to reach agreement on this issue. I have already sought it and I don't renounce achieving it.
I brought to you a commitment on transparency and regeneration in the Debate on the State of the Nation last year. I offered my intentions to reach an understanding so that the measures we were to adopt would receive broad-based support. This agreement took shape in a Resolution Proposal that reflected the feeling of the Honourable Members. The measures agreed therein are now before this House. In fact, we are also complying with the commitment that these laws could be approved by this House before the end of the year. For our part, this will be the case.
Honourable Members,
We are facing major changes in the legal structure of our country, called to substantially modify political life in all its shapes and forms, from the public administration services to political parties, from the law to individual responsibility. It is important that we find a way to support this through a broad-based agreement.
These are my two aims: to approve them as soon as possible and that they receive the greatest degree of consensus possible from among the groups in this House. Each aspect is as important as the other. Let me express this in other words: I would prefer to reach an agreement. We will try to reach a broad-based agreement but, should that not be possible, I will have no other option, I'm afraid, but to uphold my duty, in other words, to push through these draft laws with the votes assigned to me by the Spanish people.
The reason is obvious, Honourable Members: no-one, including our own citizens, would find room to accept that the Spanish Parliament could not take effective measures to fight corruption due to a lack of agreement between the different political groups in this House. No-one would be able to understand that. No-one would understand that the Government of the Nation could renounce applying its own ideas in the fight against corruption, just because others refuse to support them. No-one would understand this.
The people of Spain want to see an agreement. They are offended by the differences on this issue; they are upset that it has become a weapon for political dispute and it seems ridiculous to them that we are arguing over whether they are rabbits or hares, when all that matters is that they are living creatures. They expect us to take decisions, approve measures and do so together; measures that reflect the feelings of the majority and which show our empathy with the concerns of our citizens.
I am prepared to listen, to talk and to share. I am prepared to consider any kind of contribution that can improve these draft laws, but I cannot accept any form of stagnation.
The Spanish people expect these reforms, they need these reforms and it is my duty to assure them that they will be pushed through and come into force. If just hope we can do so with the support of a great agreement. You can count on my disposition for that.
It is time to put this desire to correct our errors that we proclaim each time a new scandal shakes up public opinion to the test. This is the time to offer reasons to the Spanish people to renew their trust in their institutions and their representatives. It is time for those who enjoy the honour of representing them to respond to the trust placed in them.
But it is also necessary to convey a social and political lesson in order not to contribute, I repeat, to increasing the impression that everything, absolutely everything, is tainted in our country in terms of our political class and our public servants.
Honourable Members,
These seats are occupied by men and women from all parties, who have decided to dedicate their lives to politics out of conviction, to uphold their ideals and to devote their lives, or part of them, to serving others. The same is true in the public administration services, in the regional parliaments and in our local authorities.
No-one more than them, or us, suffers to a greater degree from the discredit and disaffection deriving from the conduct of those who didn't rise to the level of their responsibilities. For that reason, no-one is keener than us in implementing all those measures, from the first to the last, so that such harmful conduct will be harder to commit, uncovered sooner and punished more severely.
I will draw to a close, Honourable Members,
These reforms I propose weren't drawn up today nor are they in relation to today's actions. Corruption was already waiting for us when we came to power. The same happened with the previous government and all those that preceded them. What we seek, Honourable Members, is that corruption can be removed from the list of priorities of any future government.
I know that this is an ambitious goal, as ambitious as are the demands of our citizens; as ambitious as the cry to clean up our democracy, but I can assure you that our efforts have risen to the challenge of this ambition.
We can now say to the Spanish people that we are taking sufficient and effective measures to ensure that the abuses we have seen have not the slightest possibility of being repeated.
And I am not forgetting something that is as important as everything else, Honourable Members, as serious as flouting the law or stealing from the State, which is giving a bad example. It is all well and good to have laws and reforms but, above all that, we have a duty to set an example. That is what our citizens expect and that, since it is a personal commitment, is something that each one of us must attend to individually. As far as I am concerned, the Spanish people know that they have my permanent commitment on the table.
That is all, thank you very much, Mr Speaker.