"The welfare state is an indispensable achievement."

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

8 December 2013

Context
Rajoy gave a joint interview to six major European newspapers in December 2013, discussing Spain's recovery, the welfare state, corruption allegations, and immigration policy.
Main themes
Welfare state preservation, economic recovery, inequality and social justice, unemployment, public services, PP corruption scandal (Bárcenas), immigration policy (Melilla), European economic direction, tax policy, education as opportunity
Duration
~66 min
96th percentile
Words
7,941
96th percentile
Sentences
427
98th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.88
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 35%33%
  • Institutional 32%30%
  • Geopolitical 16%15%
  • Social 13%12%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

427 sentences in 114 paragraphs

Interview conducted by Javier Moreno, Berna González Harbour, Paul Hamilos, Sandrine Morel, Gian Antonio Orighi, and Thomas Urban for the Europa newspaper group (EL PAÍS, Le Monde, The Guardian, Süddeutsche Zeitung, La Stampa, and Gazeta Wyborcza).

"Last year we were debating the bailout [of Spain] and today we are debating what the recovery will look like. I feel more comfortable there." President Mariano Rajoy (Santiago de Compostela, 1955) states in an interview granted to EL PAÍS and the other five newspapers that make up the Europa editorial project that "the worst is over and now it is time for growth." Rajoy asserts that "the welfare state is an irreplaceable achievement" and that the crisis will not leave a more unequal Spain. "What worries me most now is that Europe and Germany are clear about where we are going," he declares. The head of the Executive rejects that his party has a parallel accounting. "In my party, there is none. If someone has a parallel accounting or notes," he points out in relation to Luis Bárcenas, the former treasurer of the PP imprisoned for corruption, "they are theirs, but they are not those of the Popular Party." Rajoy defends the razor wire that his Government has placed on the fence of Melilla as a "deterrent element," although he adds that he will remove it "if there is an alternative."

Although he cannot boast of job creation in his two years in office, the Prime Minister assures that the latest unemployment data "cannot satisfy anyone but indicate that there may be hope." According to Rajoy, Spain does not have so much of a public spending problem as a revenue problem.

The head of the Executive rejects that his party has a parallel accounting. "In my party, there is none. If someone has a parallel accounting or notes," he points out in relation to Luis Bárcenas, the former treasurer of the PP imprisoned for corruption, "they are theirs, but they are not those of the Popular Party."

Rajoy defends the razor wire that his Government has placed on the fence of Melilla as a "deterrent element" to combat irregular immigration. "If there is an alternative, we will change them."

Question. Inequality has skyrocketed during the crisis, with the rich getting richer, the poor getting poorer, and a middle class strangled by taxes and unemployment. Will this be the profile of Spain when we emerge from the crisis, a more unequal Spain? Does it worry you?

Answer. At this moment, there are no precise indicators either in Spain or in Europe regarding inequality data, but one of the objectives of any Government is to ensure equality of opportunity and that people can live in a dignified manner. To fight against inequality, there is something that is crucial, and that is that there is employment. First, because anyone who has a job can carry out a life project and subsist with dignity, and also because a country with many people working is a country that has public income, because those people pay their taxes, and from there public services, healthcare, education, a good pension system can be maintained, and social assistance can be provided to those who are worse off in life. I do not believe that after the crisis, when recovery begins to consolidate clearly, we will move towards a more unequal Spain or Europe. I think we need to make an effort in something that is decisive to avoid that inequality, which is education. Education ultimately becomes equality of opportunity. And then, for those people who are struggling or who have more difficulties in life, there will always be public services that will assist them. Those public services are the pillars of the welfare state, and I believe we must preserve it because only in Europe do we have a welfare state like the one we have here.

Q. You have said that you do not believe that when Spain emerges from the recession it will be more unequal. Does that mean that right now, during the recession, inequality has deepened, or do you think that has not happened?

A. I believe that many people have lost their jobs in recent years. Logically, those people have more difficulties, but it is also true that in Spain there is a very important cushion, which is public services, which is unemployment insurance, that have allowed people to generally maintain a decent standard of living. In tax matters, I, who do not like raising taxes, had to make one of the first decisions to raise income tax, but we did it in seven brackets and tried to be equitable. That is a goal and will always be.

"The way to correct inequality is to have employment and public services for those who do not have them."

Q. Do you not think that specific mechanisms are necessary to try to correct that inequality?

A. No, look, for Spain to emerge from the crisis, I do not believe that any specific mechanism is necessary; that is, emerging from the crisis fundamentally means having many people working.

Q. Of course, but that is about emerging from the crisis, not correcting inequality. That is why I speak of specific mechanisms to correct inequality, not just to emerge from the crisis.

A. No, the best way to correct inequality is for everyone to have a job and for those who do not have one, either because they cannot or because they are older and retired, to be attended to by good public services.

Q. The Eurozone is the only economic area in the world that has prolonged the recession. Do you think that austerity is the effective recipe for getting out of the crisis?

A. Having a high public deficit and high public debt is not good, and that is the message I have conveyed to the Spanish people. The countries that have had problems accessing the markets and financing our public deficit had them because we owed a lot. Now, to get out of the crisis, five things are fundamentally necessary, and I said so in the first European Council I participated in: first, fiscal consolidation is needed, gradually reducing the deficit and public debt. We had to reduce the public deficit by more than two points in 2012, during a recession. I believe that things have improved now, and the deficit targets for Spain and other countries have been softened, and I think it was an intelligent decision by the Commission. Second, structural reforms. Spain has made many; they can be shared or not, but we have made them, starting with labor reform, the Budget Stability Law, the reform of the financial system, the electricity sector, the Education Law, the reform of the Administration, the Law of market unity... And that has produced more flexibility, more competitiveness in the economy. The third recipe for getting out of the crisis is also to undertake more reforms at the European level. We must continue to advance in the internal market; there are still many things to do. Fourth, we must also commit to greater European integration, the roadmap proposed by Van Rompuy in 2012: banking union, fiscal union, political union, and more economic union; I supported it, and even as President of the Spanish Government, I presented initiatives. And finally, fifth, we must resolve some credit and liquidity problems in the EU. Those are the five recipes I have been proposing, both in Madrid, in Parliament, and in Europe.

"What worries me most now is that Europe and Germany are clear about where we are going."

Q. Do you think that the grand coalition that will govern in Germany will reduce Berlin's pressure on the southern countries?

A. I do not think things will change much regarding fiscal consolidation. The latest decisions about Spain, France, the Netherlands, and some other countries that the Commission has made allow us a path that is not the same as before. This year we have a deficit target of 6.5%, of course, but before it was 4.5%, and that was impossible to meet. Next year it will be 5.8%, and from there we will continue to decrease. I am comfortable; at this moment, the key is that we have more income; we do not have so much of a spending problem as a revenue problem, and as we move away from the recession, revenues will improve. Therefore, there is no problem there. Regarding structural reforms, Spain will certainly continue to make structural reforms because we are convinced that it is good for our country. What worries me most now is Europe. That is, that all governments, and especially the German government, which is very important due to its GDP and population, are clear about where we are going. In Europe, the worst is over, and now it is time for growth and integration. That is where we must work, and I am convinced that the German government thinks the same and will work in that direction.

Q. Regarding the five points you raised, do you have the feeling that Europe has listened to you sufficiently?

A. Well, yes. And I will explain it to you. In my first European Council, we only talked about the Two Pack, the Six Pack, the Fiscal Pact, the rescue instruments for countries in difficulty, programs for those countries in difficulty; we talked about Greece, we talked about the ESM, we talked about the financial stability fund. We only talked about that, about austerity. Then we started talking about economic growth, youth employment, SMEs, and suddenly we also began to talk about fiscal union, banking union, and more economic union, and even political union, and then we began to take steps in the right direction on banking union issues. It is true that I would like some things to be done more quickly, but what is the overall balance of two years? I am satisfied.

Q. You say that the worst is over, but European elections are coming up in which we may see a backlash against the cuts from Brussels, and that more populist and extremist parties may advance. What do you expect?

A. It is a topic that worries me, and I am concerned about several things. These are the eighth elections to the European Parliament since 1979. Back then, 62% of Europeans called to the polls voted. In 2009, it was 43%; almost 20 points of participation were lost. Now something very important is going to happen, and this is the one that will have the most powers in the history of the European Parliament. And that is why it is very important that we do not have parties, well, let’s call them "singular" to avoid using other qualifiers. People criticize Europe a lot, but for Spain, European integration has been a success, one of the best things that has happened to us. For us, who lived 40 years under an authoritarian regime, Europe means democracy, freedom, progress. Therefore, we must educate about Europe, in Spain and outside of Spain. People need to be explained outside of Spain what the single market is, what it means to be able to sell to a market of 500 million people without barriers or tariffs; that is very important. In Germany, they must explain what it means, for Germany and for all countries, to be able to export to a market of 500 million. When I was a child, I went to Portugal and had to wait in line for two and a half hours to enter. Explain what free movement is, explain it to the new generations who do not know it. And also, do not blame each other; that does not build anything, do not say that the southern countries do not work or are not effective, or that the northern countries pressure too much. The parties we have now will have our defects, but certainly, looking at some of those who may have a significant result in the European Parliament, it is a serious cause for concern.

"In Europe, the worst is over, and today it is time for growth and integration. That is where we must work."

Q. Has Spain felt stigmatized during this crisis as a southern country?

A. In 2002 and 2003, the sick man of Europe was not Spain. In 2004 and 2005, the country that failed to meet public deficit targets was not Spain; it was other countries in Europe. Therefore, we have all had our problems and difficulties, and that is why, if we want to live together, to be together, and to be an important actor in the world, we must try to build. I am very aware of my obligations; I will try to contribute to European integration, and I believe that the worst in Europe is already over. Europe is a space of many things, and it is also one of solidarity. Spain or Italy have also helped Greece based on each one's GDP.

Q. For decades, Spain and Europe combined the flag of democracy with that of the welfare state. Has that equation been broken by the crisis? Has the welfare state as we knew it ended for Europeans?

A. Europe has a welfare state that no one else in the world has. In the world, there are great economic powers, those that are on everyone's mind, but none has a public pension system like that of most European countries; a public healthcare system; an educational system; or a social care system, each with its variations. For me, that is an irreplaceable achievement that also distinguishes us as Europeans. There will always be corrections according to the economic cycle, but I believe that the fundamental aspects can and, above all, should be maintained. And to maintain it, preserve it, and improve it, public income is needed, and for that, economic growth and employment are necessary, and for that, competitiveness and reforms are necessary. That is why we are doing what we are doing in Spain.

Q. The next European Council on December 19 will address banking union, with certain reluctance on the part of Germany.

It is urgent that all decisions regarding the design of the banking union be finalized by December. Banking supervision has already been approved, the supervisory mechanism is in place, and now we will move on to the stress tests of financial entities. What remains pending is the single resolution mechanism: whether there will be a single authority and who will make it up, and whether there will be a single European fund or several national funds. For Spain, the priority is to close this issue. We do not have a fixed or unmovable position on this matter. We would prefer there to be a single resolution fund and a single authority, which could be the Council or the Commission. There are other countries that do not see it that way and prefer a sum of national funds, with the European one only intervening when the national ones do not. In short, we have a constructive position and we are open to listening to everyone because for us the priority is to finalize the design of the banking union and therefore the single resolution mechanism.

Excuse me, Mr. President, does it matter to Spain whether it is the Council or the Commission?

No, no, it does not matter to me, but I also understand that we cannot go in with an inflexible position, because otherwise we will never reach an agreement. When we talk about agreement, you do not win one hundred percent of your positions, but it is not an issue that puts us in an impossible position, no. It is not a red line, nor do we present it that way. The key is to close the banking union.

"The blades are a deterrent element and have been in place since 2005. If there is an alternative, we will change them."

The other topic for the Council will be illegal immigration following the tragedy in Lampedusa. Italy proposes to strengthen Frontex as we have done with Atalanta in the Horn of Africa.

We need to combine several things, because no country can accept everyone who comes in an unlimited manner. This policy should be an absolutely European policy to help improve development levels and fight poverty in the countries of origin. That is the first thing. Second, it should also work to ensure that human rights are respected in those countries. Third, it should collaborate with the authorities of those countries to fight against human trafficking mafias. That is the policy, the only one that will work in the medium and long term, the only one; and I believe that Spain has made significant progress in this regard. This is a policy that, carried out by the European Union of 28 countries, would be much more effective than if it were done only by national states.

You are talking about human rights, and how can you defend the blades on the fences of Ceuta and Melilla? Sub-Saharan migrants say that no blade will stop them, that they will continue coming. The blades only cause physical harm.

They have a single objective: to be a deterrent element, and they have been installed since 2005.

But they are not.

I believe they are, and they exist in many countries, in many places, in many institutions, in many locations. If we find an effective alternative, we will change them, but fundamentally they are a deterrent element.

They exist in prisons, but there people have committed crimes. These immigrants will continue coming to Spain with blades or without them.

No, if they are there, they do not do it or they do it less.

I just returned from there and I can tell you that they continue coming.

It is not easy to find an alternative; when there is a border, there has to be a high fence, it is not about inviting anyone to jump from a fence, they are deterrent elements.

"The latest unemployment data cannot satisfy anyone, but they tell us that there may be hope."

6 billion euros have been allocated against youth unemployment over two years, of which about 1.8 billion would correspond to Spain. Do you think that is enough effort on the part of Europe?

Look, no, but it is better than nothing. In the issue of youth employment, it is not so much about making specific and concrete decisions as it is about an economic policy that ends up generating employment. All the structural reforms we are making in Spain have one objective, which is to generate growth, therefore activity and generate employment, and that affects both the young and those over 50. In the coming days, we will present our proposal for spending those 1.8 billion to Brussels. They will be very useful to us because we will use them in the programs we have in the entrepreneurship and youth employment strategy.

What kind of jobs will we emerge from this crisis with? More precarious, cheaper, a precarious workforce?

One of the keys is wage moderation. In 2012, as soon as I took office, Spanish trade unions and business organizations signed an agreement on wage moderation. Public employees in Spain have had their salaries frozen for five years. This, along with some articles of the labor market reform, has led to a situation where there are more alternatives than dismissal: slightly lowering wages, distributing working hours, functional mobility... A more flexible economy allows alternatives to dismissal, and that has stabilized the unemployment situation. The latest unemployment data cannot satisfy anyone, but they tell us that there may be hope. In difficult situations, it is better to bet on earning a little less and maintaining as many jobs as possible. What kind of contracts do I want? I want permanent and indefinite contracts as is natural, I and anyone with minimal feelings, but I believe that we should not deny any possibility.

For example, a part-time contract can change many people's lives. The part-time contract in the Netherlands accounts for 49.2% of contracts, and the European average is 20%. In Spain, it is used in only 14.6% of cases.

Are you considering eliminating the minimum wage?

No, we are not going to eliminate the minimum wage.

In no sector, under no circumstances?

No, eliminating the minimum wage is not among the Government's proposals.

What will the reform of the labor reform be like?

No decision has been made, but we will try to improve the current regulation of part-time contracts. The improvement we made at the time has had effects, and we believe that a greater effort can still be made; many people are asking us for it, and we are studying it.

Was it essential to lower the level of the Spanish welfare state? Will what has been lost be recovered one day?

When I arrived in government, we were spending 90 billion euros more than we were earning. We had a public deficit of 9.1%. We went to the markets and our risk premium was at 500/550 points, and for the 10-year bond, we were paying 7%. There was talk of rescuing Spain; there was talk of the breakup of the euro, that was the situation I found here and what I experienced in the first months. In any press conference, they would ask: When are you going to request the rescue? What is happening with your risk premium? Are you going to get someone to buy a bond in the next bond auction? I found a series of public administrations that went to the markets and no one financed them. It was essential to act decisively because in that situation it was almost impossible to obtain the 90 billion euros we needed. I had to reduce the public deficit, so I had to drastically cut spending and raise taxes. I did it in the first Council of Ministers we held, on December 30, 2011; I had to raise the personal income tax, which was doing exactly the opposite of what I had promised in my electoral program. In other words, nine days later, I was already failing to comply with the electoral program. And this is not easy; we have tried to be equitable in the brackets. The same has been done with capital income. Pensions... we have tried to ensure that this is what we touched the least. In Spain, healthcare remains universal, public, and free. It is true that the payment for medications has increased a bit, but that has resulted in significant savings for the state and also control by the people. Education in Spain is universal, public, and free as it was before. There has been an increase in university fees, and repeaters are charged fees, but of course, we must also think that a person who is studying thanks to what taxpayers contribute is paid by the entire taxpayer, not by the government. Therefore, when it is said "liquidation of the welfare state," look, no, it is neither my will nor have we done it. Yes, it is true that we have made some cuts in healthcare; we hope to recover it. But as I said before, to have the welfare state, we need to have income. The welfare state is there, and for all of Europe, it is something non-negotiable, but for that, we must be competitive and generate public income.

"This is a country that went from giving more credit than reasonable to giving much less than necessary."

The bank rescue is coming to an end, but credit is not reaching SMEs nor is employment reaching people.

The Spanish banking system has been subjected to surveillance, inspection, and analysis exercises like no one else in Europe, no one. It was concluded that the Spanish banking system needed 40 billion euros, although the maximum authorized was 100 billion euros. That program is ending now, and that it is ending now is good news for Spain, certainly, but it is excellent news for Europe because it demonstrates that EU instruments work.

And of those 41 billion that we have used, how much do you estimate can be recovered?

Well, that will have to be seen in the future, when the nationalized banks and real estate assets are sold. It is 40 billion at 0.5% with a 10-year grace period, so logically, public debt will have to be issued because the payment is, I believe, between 10 and 15 years. Undoubtedly, we still have the problem of credit. I am fully aware of that. Now I will also give you a piece of data: credit to SMEs is starting to improve, and for consumption. Not yet for mortgage credit for home acquisition. This was a country that went from giving much more credit than reasonable to giving much less credit than necessary. I hope that the banking restructuring, that the operation that the ECB is now doing, with these stress tests and the beginning of banking supervision will also mean that credit in Spain begins to flow more intensely than before. From there, the debate arises: macro figures improve, but people do not see it. That is the great challenge, without a doubt. And if the macro is not fixed, it is impossible to fix what is important, which is the well-being of the people. And in Spain now, there are positive data, for example, exports.

But the export sector hardly creates jobs.

Yes, it creates jobs. That is to say, we export capital goods, which is what we export the most, we export chemical products, the agri-food industry exports, the automotive sector exports, that does create jobs. Then consumption creates jobs, and tourism also creates jobs, and we export services much more than tourism. I am not at all satisfied with the employment situation in Spain, as is evident. But I can say one thing: a year ago, I could not talk about hope; now I can. A year ago, I could not, and in fact, I did not talk about it. Now I can talk about hope for the future. These are the registered unemployment data [shows some graphs]. Suddenly, for the first time in October of this year, the trend has changed; there is less unemployment than a year ago. And in November, that trend has been maintained; today there is less registered unemployment in Spain than in November of last year. Is that something to be satisfied with? No. I am not satisfied; I am fully aware that this is the challenge to talk about the improvement of a country's well-being. But this is very important because it shows that there is hope and that this country can and will move forward, and that all the efforts that have been made make sense. Last year, there was debate about when Spain would be rescued, and this year, there is debate about how recovery will be in Spain. Well, I feel more comfortable there.

"If something is unreasonable in the security law, there are sufficient procedures to modify it."

The Government has just approved legislation that increases the amount of fines for certain protests, which also grants that power to the police to the detriment of the judicial system. It is a type of law that exists in countries that we do not consider particularly democratic. I am perhaps thinking of Russia. Is there really a problem with protests in this country? How can you defend a law that will sanction offenses against Spain in a democracy with freedom of expression?

The right to freedom of expression, to demonstration, and to assembly is a constitutional right, and evidently, no one can call it into question, nor will they, nor does this Government have the slightest intention of doing so. This legislation is fundamentally made for one reason: because a series of behaviors that were previously classified as offenses have been removed from the Penal Code, and they have been eliminated. They cannot remain without at least an administrative sanction. And there is a second reason, which is that there is already sufficient jurisprudence in the Constitutional Court and in the Supreme Court itself for us to adapt the current law. There are also some requests from merchants, from neighbors, and even municipalities, to tackle certain behaviors that cause them problems. If there is anything that is unreasonable, there are sufficient procedures to modify it.

"I cannot authorize a referendum nor do I want to. If they want to reform the Constitution, there are procedures for that."

Q. There are serious problems facing this country: Catalonia, the crisis of the Monarchy, the crisis of the Spanish institutions as a whole, in the political system. All three crises would require decisive actions on your part as head of Government, and in all three we do not see any clear initiative on the table. What is your plan of action regarding the problem of Catalonia?

A. Catalonia is one of the most important issues we have at hand right now, and the position I defend as a political leader, as a member of the PP, and as a Spaniard is well known. Spain is the oldest nation in Europe, the one that achieved its unity centuries ago. Catalonia and the rest of Spain have never lived separately. The ties that bind us are of all kinds: emotional, historical, commercial, personal... and my position in that regard is clear. As President of the Government, I have certain obligations, certainly to comply with and enforce the law. That is to say, I cannot authorize a referendum in Catalonia. I do not want to, but moreover, I cannot; I could not authorize a referendum, for example, like the one in Scotland for the simple reason that national sovereignty belongs to the Spanish people, as stated in the Constitution. Therefore, if there were no reform of the Constitution, no Government, not even Parliament, could authorize a referendum like the one being proposed in Scotland. It is surprising that there are still those who have not realized something so simple as that. All I want to say is that I have never refused to talk. In fact, I have done so on numerous occasions, but it is evident that I have to fulfill my obligations as President of the Government, and I will do so. If they want to reform the Constitution, there are procedures for that.

Q. Speaking of Scotland, will you use your veto to prevent Scotland from being a member of the European Union if it votes for independence?

A. The cases of Scotland and Catalonia are very different. The United Kingdom does not have a written Constitution. Moreover, the right to self-determination was only recognized, as far as I remember, in three constitutions: that of the USSR, that of Yugoslavia, and that of Ethiopia. On the other hand, it is quite reasonable that no country imposes such a clause on itself. All I want to say is that this is a fact, it is not a value judgment or an opinion: Any part of a country integrated into the EU that leaves that country logically remains outside the EU, not because I say so, but because the treaties say so.

Q. Would you use your veto in the EU?

A. I cannot use my veto for anything. I could only use the veto to prevent it from leaving. Because it is not a veto problem. It automatically leaves, and therefore I cannot veto; it is leaving.

Q. I mean to veto its subsequent access.

A. It would have to go to the back of the line. We would be in another story. We are not going to jump ahead of events.

Q. Regarding Catalonia, apart from acting within the law, do you have plans to win back hearts, those emotional ties that seem to be strained?

A. I believe in those emotional ties, I believe in history, and in what unites us. I know that these moments of economic crisis do not help at all and that this is not the first time such events have occurred. The Government is trying to help the Generalitat, which cannot finance itself. It is the Government that is addressing the debt of the Generalitat; the Government is making a great effort to pay suppliers of the Catalan Administration and other autonomous communities. Between debt refinancing, deficits, and paying suppliers, we are already talking about 29 billion euros during the time we have been in Government in Catalonia. We are working to ensure that Catalonia, which is capital - there are almost seven million Spaniards - remains a leading region in Spain, a region with initiative, with a very high level of exports. We are helping in terms of infrastructure; we have already completed the AVE, the Prat airport, and now we are undertaking a major project, which is the Mediterranean corridor. We are in a difficult and crisis-ridden moment, but I am convinced that this situation will be reversed. Not only as a legal issue, which there certainly is, but also as a matter of feelings. The world today is not going in that direction. We are talking about banking union or fiscal union in Europe, we are talking about the European single market, we are talking about reaching agreements like the other day with Georgia or Moldova from the EU. The world is moving towards something akin to a country, to a united states of the world. Look at all the regional integration movements and all the free trade agreements that are being negotiated. I think these are important facts. That is to say, I believe we must walk in the direction that the times are going. And they are moving towards integration, not in the opposite direction.

Q. Are you going to take any initiative to reform the Constitution or the monarchy?

A. To reform the Constitution, three things are necessary. First, and most importantly, to know what we want to do. That is very important because one should not start a journey without knowing where one wants to end up. The Constitution in Spain has been reformed twice, the last time not long ago. And I remember that the then Prime Minister called me in August 2011 and raised it with me. And I said, "Go ahead." It was precisely the fiscal pact of the European Union. Second, we need to see what consensus exists. Because, of course, the Constitution of 1978, with all its problems and difficulties, had the consensus of the major national parties, of the nationalist parties - with the exception of the PNV - and of Izquierda Unida, that is to say, it had an overwhelmingly majority consensus that was later ratified at the polls. I, like Miguel Roca in his newspaper, do not see today that a similar consensus could exist; and third, we need to see the right moment. When something like the Constitution is opened, one must be very clear about what is being pursued and how it is achieved. I do not see it as a priority at this moment. Moreover, it was not in our electoral program. I did not run for election with the reform of the Constitution. But I insist, it is not that I am a maniac about not reforming it because it has been reformed twice and I believe for the better, it is that I do not see the issue at this moment.

Q. About the crisis of the Monarchy?

A. This "crisis" of the Monarchy already implies a value judgment about the situation of the Monarchy. I believe that the Head of State has had a tremendous sense, it still has, I believe it has majority support, it has provided and continues to provide great services to Spain and guarantees great stability to the country. Therefore, what we all need to do is support it and preserve it. That is my position at this moment.

"The legitimacy to reform the abortion law is that of the electoral program of the Popular Party."

Q. And about abortion: Do you believe you have the legitimacy to propose the reform of the abortion law that you are proposing?

A. The legitimacy is that it is a reform that was in the electoral program of the PP.

Q. Correct, but the general consensus is that Spaniards voted for the PP to take Spain out of the crisis, and opinion polls show that there are very large percentages against reforming the abortion law as it is being proposed.

A. Again, we are faced with opinions, all very respectable, but the fact is that it was in the program of the Popular Party.

Q. Gibraltar rarely made the news before, but now it seems that there is something about Gibraltar every day. Why is that, and what could England expect from Spain on the issue of Gibraltar?

A. The relations between Spain and the United Kingdom and mine with Mr. Cameron are excellent. I want to make that very clear. From there, Spain refers to international legality. This is an issue that is at the United Nations, which states that negotiations should be held between the United Kingdom and Spain for decolonization, as stated according to the criteria established by the United Nations. That is one issue, but the debate that is currently taking place does not refer to this, but to some decisions that have been made by the authorities of Gibraltar that affect other issues, such as environmental or fiscal regulations. We are not talking about sovereignty but about complying with what are the EU regulations, and we must comply with them both as Spain and as the United Kingdom, and in fact, there is an open file in the European Commission itself. There is another issue, which is also very important, which is the smuggling of tobacco: the data on the number of packets that enter there to then exit are truly remarkable. And then it is impossible to know who the owners of thousands of companies that are in Gibraltar and operate in numerous countries of the European Union, including, for example, England or Scotland or any other part of the United Kingdom, are. Therefore, these issues need to be resolved, and I hope they will be resolved and that they will be resolved intelligently and to the satisfaction of all parties.

Q. Finally: How to lower taxes without lowering revenue?

A. By increasing economic activity. Before we were not in a position to lower taxes; now we believe we are in a position to do so. And the fundamental objective of the tax cuts that we will approve next year will be to relieve the burden on families, that is to say, primarily the personal income tax, and to help entrepreneurs. Those will be the two principles that will inspire our actions throughout the next tax reform.

"Spain is a moderate, balanced country, and the vast majority opts for classic options."

Q. An important element of the debate on the crisis is corruption. Transparency International has published the latest data according to which Spain is losing points to the level of Libya, Mali, or Guinea-Bissau. Is this not a big problem for Spain's image? What will be the instruments to fight against corruption?

A. It is undoubtedly a problem. We have all seen what the media have reported in recent times. I would reflect on this and then explain what we are doing and what we have done. There is a problem, there is corruption, we have seen it here and in many other countries. Now, I have been in politics for 32 years. I started in politics in 1981. I was 26 years old then. And I have known a lot of people doing politics. I started as a town councilor, in my land, there in Galicia. And I have seen people working in small towns for many hours, earning zero. Because people say: there are a hundred thousand politicians, but the town councilors, who are the majority of those hundred thousand, do not get paid, nor have they ever been paid, because the Town Hall does not provide for that. There may be cases, which are also in everyone's mind, but the vast majority of people are honest and decent. And we should not contribute to the idea of generalized corruption that is not true. That is the reflection I leave. Second, we have presented to the Cortes and already approved two laws. The Organic Law on the Financing of Political Parties, to try to regulate everything more, and a Transparency Law that I think is very advanced. And this year 2013 we will present the organic law for controlling the economic and financial activity of parties, the regulatory law for the exercise of public office of the general administration of the State, and criminal and procedural measures in the fight against corruption. All of this makes things more difficult, makes them more regulated; I also believe that many people will have learned from many things we have seen in recent times. Undoubtedly, I cannot be satisfied with this issue, and we are trying to do everything possible.

Q. You say that many people will have learned many things from what we have seen in recent times. Are you referring to what happened in your party with the Gürtel case, specifically?

A. As you can understand, I do not like it at all, and what I would have liked is for this to have never happened. To me, to the leaders of the PP, to the militants, and to people who are not from the PP but are Spaniards who dedicate themselves to their things or who think differently from us. I hope this never happens again.

Q. The level of dissatisfaction of citizens with politicians here is 17 points above the average in Europe. The reputation that Spain had ten years ago was that of a modern and progressive country, but now it is that of a country with a fairly large corruption problem. Why does no politician here ever resign when there is evidence everywhere? And what do you think of Spain's international reputation today?

R. All the people affected by the cases that have been in the media have resigned. I do not know of anyone who holds a public office and is currently under indictment. But when I say no one, I mean no one. If you know of one who is under indictment and has not resigned, then let me know. But, well, I certainly do not remember any. Here in Madrid, everyone has resigned, the former treasurer of the party as well, as far as I know, all the people involved in the Gürtel case have resigned. I do not rule out that there may be someone left, but the vast majority have not held their positions for a long time. Second, of course, you mention the parties and the credibility of the parties. I am not going to talk about what has happened in other countries of the European Union because I think it makes no sense. But I will tell you one thing: Spain, despite what is said about the parties, has a very stable party system. That is to say, in Spain, the center-right or center-left has governed, namely the Popular Party, the UCD, or the socialists. In Spain, there are no europhobic parties, nor are there euro-skeptical parties, nor are there far-right parties, nor are there parties of comedians, there are none. In other places, there may be such things without a doubt, but that does not exist in Spain. That is to say, Spain is a moderate, balanced country, and the vast majority of people bet on classic options.

P. But that does not explain the dissatisfaction of the people with the politicians.

R. Well, in other places they must be more dissatisfied when they give their support to extremist or anti-system parties. This dissatisfaction is very difficult to measure. But certainly, when it comes to voting, generally Spaniards vote with a lot of common sense. And certainly, extremist, anti-European, or xenophobic parties have not emerged here. Not here, in other places it is possible, but they have not emerged here. Here, people are quite moderate, quite balanced, and quite sensible. One can be right or wrong like everyone else.

"If someone has a 'b' accounting or has some notes, they are theirs, but they are not from the Popular Party."

P. You have defended that Fabra is exemplary or that there is no 'b' accounting of the PP. Do you not fear the loss of credibility of your word?

R. Well, listen, I say that there is no 'b' accounting in my party. And if someone had 'b' accounting, it would be theirs, but in my party, there has never been 'b' accounting, there is none, there is simply none. If someone has 'b' accounting or has some notes, they are theirs, but they are not from the Popular Party. Someone may have made some notes. And therefore, I maintain that. We did not have 'b' accounting; we only have 'a' accounting.

P. But the question is: do you not fear losing the credibility of your word?

R. Well, I hope not.

P. But the distance between what you say and what the people say is quite large, and it is a credibility problem because everyone I talk to talks about political corruption in Spain. What responsibility do you have in that?

R. Look, the people usually speak in elections. That is to say, we will see this later. I have raised this in the Congress of Deputies, I have had a debate in the Congress of Deputies. I have presented a series of anti-corruption measures that have been approved, and others that I have told you will be presented in a few days. Undoubtedly, you can have an opinion, but you have to think that others may have a different opinion than yours. To summarize: we already know what has happened to us, the people involved in these cases are no longer here, we will try to ensure that this does not happen in the future.

P. But if there is evidence that the hard drives of two computers used by the former treasurer Luis Bárcenas were deleted, for example, would you consider resigning?

R. Excuse me, I do not know about that issue. Believe me, I do not know about that issue.

P. But under your leadership, everyone is talking about that issue; it needs to be addressed.

R. Yes, yes, the only thing I know is that this has been sent to a court and that the court has archived the case. What do you want me to do? Do you have evidence different from what the judge evaluated? I do not know; you are asking me about something I am unaware of.

P. It is a reaction that is very difficult for the people to accept. That is why there is such a distance between the citizenry and the political class, because it is an evasive response.

R. That people do not like that is evident; that I do not like it is also evident. That we have made decisions to ensure that this does not happen again in the future is also true. From there, you can have your opinion, which may coincide with some people's and not with others.

NOTE: Interview published with the authorization of "El País."