Speech by Prime Minister Mark Rutte at the Bertelsmann Stiftung, Berlin

Netherlands Mark Rutte · Prime Minister of the Netherlands

1 March 2018 · Bertelsmann Stiftung, Berlin, Germany

Context
Rutte addressed the Bertelsmann Stiftung in Berlin in March 2018, outlining his vision for the future of the EU and rejecting federalism in favor of sovereign cooperation.
Main themes
Future of the European Union, European integration vs. sovereignty, Brexit implications, EU as community of values, internal market and prosperity, federalism debate, rule of law and fundamental rights, member state diversity and strength, geopolitical cooperation, migration and climate change
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,311
92nd percentile
Sentences
363
97th percentile
Readability
55
76th percentile
Grade
9.2
13th percentile
Syntax
2.69
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from Dutch

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 34%33%
  • Geopolitical 29%28%
  • Institutional 21%21%
  • Social 7%6%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

363 sentences in 79 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

In fact, you had a choice today. In Great Britain, to listen to a speech on the question: how to move forward without Europe. Or in Berlin, to hear someone who genuinely wants to talk with you about how we can best move forward with Europe. I am glad you are here. And I thank the

Bertelsmann Stiftung

for the opportunity to share my observations and ideas about the future of the European Union with you. This is in the spirit of the words of

Helmut Schmidt

: '

Wer nicht redet, wird nicht gehört.'

If I am well informed, the new German coalition agreement contains the terms EU or Europe 302 times. It is therefore an understatement to say that the future of the European project is quite a concern here. But this discussion is also being conducted outside Germany with new enthusiasm and energy – a paradoxical consequence of the British decision to leave the EU. After all, Brexit underscores that EU membership is a conscious choice. We realize more than ever the importance of unity among the 27. And it forces us to take a stand, because if a Frexit, Dexit, or Nexit is not imminent – and fortunately it is not – how do we want to move forward with the EU?

Four months ago, we in the Netherlands concluded a new coalition agreement that includes a strong and fundamentally positive EU paragraph. We indeed want to move forward with Europe. And that makes sense, because the European Union is us together with our neighbors, who, like us, are rooted in the principles of the free market and democracy. In the EU, we respect the rule of law, human rights, and other fundamental freedoms. In the EU, the media are free, women and men are equal, and everyone is allowed to have any orientation and adhere to any faith. The EU is a shell that increases prosperity, provides protection, and forms a framework to absorb geopolitical and global developments. And yes, the EU is also our '

bread and butter

', the internal market on which we earn a significant part of our national income. It is the basis from which we compete with China, Silicon Valley, and India. The Netherlands is, in short, inextricably linked to Europe.

How do I view the European Union? In one sentence: as a community of values and a partnership of 27 sovereign countries that strengthen each other on issues that require a joint approach and that adhere to mutual agreements.

What the European Union is not for me is a train that inevitably speeds towards a federal destination. In the debate on European cooperation, the element always creeps in that we are inevitably on the way to a higher level of integration, where only the pace is up for discussion. 'Because the citizens of Europe must be able to follow it,' you hear.

But, in my firm conviction, a federal end goal as an inevitable historical march is not how it is. And not how it should be in the 21st century. Even if we go all the way back to the beginning of the EU, to '

nie wieder Krieg

', to '

plus jamais ça

', we see that that idealistic motivation was translated into very pragmatic cooperation around coal and steel. And that is how Europe must remain: lofty ideals filled with great sobriety. We should therefore not strive for that '

ever closer Union

', but for an ever more perfect EU.

The

bottom line

is that 27 independent European countries cooperate because there are problems that can be better or sometimes even exclusively addressed together. We work together because it increases our prosperity – think of the internal market and the monetary union. Because it improves our security – think of the fight against cross-border crime and terrorism, think of the instability at the external borders. And because only together can we formulate answers to global issues such as climate change, migration, and the future of world trade.

At its core, the primal promise of Europe has remained unchanged for almost 70 years: member states that elevate each other to a higher level of prosperity, security, and stability. There is only one question at the center: what is needed to fulfill and pass on that primal promise of Europe?

The EU can only fulfill its basic promise if the member states are individually strong and maintain their uniqueness. Nowhere in the world do we see such a rich socio-cultural diversity in recognizable nation-states on such a relatively limited surface. We must cherish that uniqueness as our breeding ground for new ideas, innovation, and creativity. After all, we did not become the most prosperous, most social, and most democratic continent in the world after 1945 by compensating for each other's weaknesses, but precisely by pooling our strengths and making each other stronger. It is up to the countries themselves to safeguard and develop that strength within the community frameworks: financially, socio-economically, and in terms of the rule of law. Because if we fail nationally and elevate that failure to the collective level, we create a giant on clay feet, with the danger of toppling. Or to put it in a painful metaphor: the absence of the Dutch national team at the upcoming World Cup cannot be a reason to advocate for a European team at the next World Cup. We will simply ensure that we are there again in 2022.

For this reason, the principle in the European Union must be: a deal is a deal. Our cooperation has long rested on the Treaty as our common basis and on the willingness to make compromises based on the trust that agreements made will also be honored. And that has brought us much. But increasingly, it seems that member states believe that agreements can be set aside when things are tough nationally. As if Europe is a menu from which one can pick and choose – the benefits without the burdens. But Europe is not a menu. We must be able to rely on each other that a 'yes' is indeed a 'yes'. For this, the community institutions, the Commission and the Court of Justice in particular, are indispensable. They safeguard the level playing field and have the sometimes thankless task of monitoring and enforcing the implementation of agreements.

This immediately touches on the support for the EU. We must not underestimate how vulnerable the sentiment in many countries is. In our country, in Germany, and also elsewhere. People see that the EU often promises more than it delivers. I see that too. Promises of more prosperity, security, and stability are repeatedly made, reaffirmed, and renewed, while the implementation is sometimes mediocre. And that undermines credibility and trust. But is it not the EU's duty to excel? To consistently deliver more than promised instead of the other way around? What else can people expect from the European Union than concrete results? As far as I am concerned, these are rhetorical questions.

Ladies and gentlemen, these are the Dutch principles for the future of the EU:

1: fulfill the basic promises: prosperity, security, and stability. No words but deeds.

2: it starts and ends with the member states. Brussels serves the member states, not the other way around.

And 3: a deal is a deal. The necessary compromises apply to all of us completely, not just the parts that sell easiest at home. Solidarity requires responsibility.

For the Netherlands, these are the principles in addressing the major cross-border issues we face in all member states. And the question is: what does this mean concretely for the approach to migration and security in times of great international instability? For the approach to sustainability in times of climate change? For working on economic growth in times of global competition? And for a fair labor market in times of open borders?

Ladies and gentlemen, I preach results, so you can also expect me to deliver them. I give you 9 concrete examples of the possibilities I see through that lens. 9 positive proposals with which we can start tomorrow and that will quickly yield results for the citizens of our countries, from north to south and from east to west, in the cities and in the countryside. For more prosperity. For more security. For stability. And for a strong rule of law.

Proposal 1: make the European services market truly open. There are currently 5,000 protected professions in the EU. That is 50 million people, 22 percent of all workers. Eliminate those protected professions. Only where safety, health, and consumer protection are at stake should we still impose specific and binding requirements. Notaries and architects, to name just two, do not need national protection. But a notary who is going to work in another EU country may indeed be required to meet a language requirement. And every small entrepreneur in Europe should be able to sell their goods and services online elsewhere in the Union without administrative barriers making this impossible. After the European elections of 2019, it is time to finally tackle the barriers that prevent us from making the digital market and the services market as great a success as the goods market.

Of course, we have already achieved a lot in the internal market: free movement of goods, people who can relatively easily work and study abroad, and recently roaming at domestic rates. But we are still far from there in the services market and the digital market. And we must take this to heart. Services account for 70 percent of economic activity in the EU. And if we implement the Commission's proposals, we can add 410 billion euros to GDP in the digital market.

The celebration of 25 years of internal market this year should, in my view, be modest. Because we are still leaving over 1,000 billion euros a year on the table, if I may quote the European Parliament's estimate. That is the primal promise of the EU. The internal market must improve. So when people ask me what I think of the internal market, I freely quote Gandhi: 'What a good idea. Let's do that.'

We must finalize the 4 internal market strategies for the digital market, capital, energy, and goods and services in 2018. Because a deal is a deal. Too often, legislative proposals from internal market strategies get stuck at the level of the trade unions. Decisions cannot wait. Our economy is becoming more digital every nanosecond. In the here and now. I therefore embrace Donald Tusk's Leaders Agenda. During the upcoming European Council on March 22 and 23, we must make decisions about the digital market.

I should add that I agree with the warning of many of my colleagues in the European Council: a level playing field must not lead to abuse and unfair competition. Not within the EU and not from outside the EU. '

Deeper and fairer

', we say. Or to be clearer: equal pay for equal work at the same place. I also welcome the provisional agreement reached yesterday between the Council and the European Parliament on the posting of workers directive. We need that to counter further distortions. It is not for Dutch and German plumbers and bricklayers to explain that their jobs are being taken over for a wage below the minimum through sham constructions by colleagues from other countries. Just as it is not socially just that Polish or Slovak plumbers and bricklayers must settle for worse working conditions than their German or Dutch colleagues. In the future European labor market, there can be no unfair competition on working conditions within member states. That is proposal 2: Existing agreements must be honored and enforced, starting with better cooperation between inspection services to combat cross-border fraud and abuse. Not new, I know. But important enough to mention separately. And moreover: a ‘

done deal

’ is only ‘done’ when the deal has also been executed. A deal is a deal.

The EU is a world power in international trade. This must remain so. I expect that we can soon say a definitive yes to a trade agreement with Japan. The trade agreements with Mexico and the Latin American Mercosur countries are also nearing completion. In the slightly longer term, crucial agreements must follow with Australia and New Zealand. And of course, it remains important to keep the door open to the US. The tide is not favorable now, but let us not forget in the long term that a trade agreement between the EU and the United States can make a huge contribution to growth and jobs on both sides of the Atlantic. Moreover, it would strengthen the transatlantic relationship, and that is important too.

The foundations of our trade policy system are under pressure. The EU must, together with other major trading countries, including the US, find solutions for frictions around dispute resolution and market access for state-owned enterprises. The EU is a trendsetter for free trade in a fair, sustainable, and socially responsible manner. Trade must be free and fair. We are working hard on that. We must protect ourselves, but we must not fall into the trap of protectionism, because a short-term benefit for one is often a long-term disadvantage for many others. The Netherlands stands firmly for free trade on a level playing field.

Ladies and gentlemen, then the euro. What does it mean if we return to the primal promise of the euro? What does it mean for our currency if I say: it starts and ends with the member states? And what does 'a deal is a deal' mean in the eurozone?

Without a strong euro and a stable monetary union, any discussion about the future of Europe is almost a theoretical exercise. What I advocate is that we return to the basic promise of the euro. To the promise that a common currency should bring us all more prosperity and not a redistribution of existing wealth. Because that is what ultimately happens if we continue to allow some countries to have prolonged high deficits, accumulate high debt, and fail to modernize their economies. Then the monetary union ends up as a transfer union, and that is not the way to make the euro stronger. Let alone to strengthen the support for it. I invite everyone to explain that in the Netherlands or Germany. I do see the necessity to achieve significant risk reduction through the Banking Union before we can talk about a European Deposit Guarantee Scheme. And I also believe that the European budget could do much more to stimulate reforms in the Eurozone. I will return to that last point when I later speak about the Multiannual Financial Framework.

In recent years, we have crawled through the eye of the needle. I was there myself during that exciting Greek summer of 2011, and during all those sleepless nights, it was a close call a few times. Especially when other countries also ran into trouble. The fact is that the countries that took difficult measures during the crisis, countries that implemented reforms to meet the commitments of the Stability and Growth Pact, are now showing the best figures. Fortunately, this also applies to countries like Spain, Portugal, and Ireland, which fell under the Troika regime. I take my hat off to that. From experience, I know that creating growth potential through reforms is a painful process, but it does bear fruit. And I would like to express my support for President Macron, who does not shy away from tough measures in the labor market and pensions. That is not only in the interest of France but of all of us.

The reality is: we are coming out of a period in which non-compliance with the commitments of the Stability and Growth Pact had become the norm, and we need to get back in line. Let’s not kid ourselves. If national buffers do not work, a European buffer will not work either. So back to the agreement that countries in the eurozone must get their own budgets and national debts in order and maintain them, thus ensuring their own shock-absorbing fund at the national level to cope with a sudden crisis. My conviction is that we, figuratively speaking, need 19 national shock-absorbing funds in the eurozone. I do not need to propose that, as we have long made this agreement. Let’s all adhere to it. The pie does not get bigger through centrally managed emergency funds and the printing press, but through structural reforms and a healthy budget.

If I may use the example of my own country: we too had to have a higher budget deficit than the allowed 3 percent in 2008 and thereafter. But by implementing strict reforms and austerity measures, we have recorded a surplus for the second consecutive year. The budget deficit is now a surplus, and the national debt is now well below the 60 percent ceiling. This means that the Netherlands, if a similar shock were to occur as in 2008, can borrow large amounts if necessary to take emergency measures.

Everyone keeps their own house in order. And if it really cannot be helped, good neighbors help each other. But that is the order. European funds are a last resort, not first aid. My proposal, number 3, is to transform the European Stability Mechanism into an intergovernmental European Monetary Fund, the EMF, where the current roles of the Commission, European Central Bank, and European Stability Mechanism in support programs are brought under one roof. Not as a form of further risk-sharing, not as a form of solidarity that goes one way, but as a last resort. Just like the ESM now, thus maintaining the requirement of unanimous decision-making.

For the Netherlands, it is a hard condition that support programs for countries with unsustainable debt can only come if holders of government bonds first contribute to the rescue through a restructuring. The future EMF must determine, based on a debt sustainability analysis, whether a debt is sustainable. If not, then a restructuring of outstanding debt, including bonds, is a prerequisite for a loan from the EMF. That is proposal 4: the Netherlands advocates a

Sovereign Debt Restructuring Mechanism.

Those who invest in countries with an unsustainable budget and unwise economic policy, under favorable conditions, are taking a conscious risk. It would be unfair for taxpayers from other countries to bear the costs if things go wrong with private parties.

Ladies and gentlemen,

What I also want is for the EU to do more in the areas of security, stability, migration, and climate policy.

Because it must. Because the necessity is pressing. There is no doubt that an effective common European foreign and security policy and a common asylum policy are urgently needed. This necessity has become self-evident in recent years. It is restless at the external borders of Europe, in Crimea and Eastern Ukraine, in Turkey, the Middle East, and North Africa. There is political unrest and armed conflict with the threat of terrorism and uncontrolled migration as a result. The relationship with Russia has deteriorated sharply, the one with the United States is no longer a given, and the one with China is subject to rapid changes. It is abundantly clear that no member state can cope with these developments alone. Insecurity and instability are multi-headed monsters. Our unity is the best weapon against this.

I am positive about the agreements we have made regarding internal and external security. Cooperation between police, justice, immigration services, and border control is becoming increasingly intensive. This is now really improving a lot.

In military terms, NATO remains our best guarantee of peace and security. But that does not mean that the EU can afford to do nothing. We are making good strides, for example, with the establishment of a European Defense Fund and Permanent Structured Cooperation – PESCO. The Netherlands wants to contribute significantly to this. PESCO is a good example of the added value of concrete cooperation between member states. Not a European army, but joint procurement, aligning military needs, and facilitating troop movements. It starts and ends with member states, as I said earlier.

Let me also make a concrete proposal in the area of military mobility, number 5. To begin with, the Netherlands wants all countries to grant permission for military transport to cross national borders as soon as possible. Less 'red tape', therefore, less unnecessary bureaucratic hassle. We must also agree to make a number of highways, bridges, and overpasses suitable for military transport. This speeds up responsiveness and strengthens the military capability of the EU. The Netherlands aims for a ‘mobility pledge’ to be made in NATO and EU contexts. The EU, NATO, and the individual member states and allies must commit to this permanently.

International stability, internal security, and migration are interconnected. Our part of the world has an enormous attraction. In 2015, the situation was extremely precarious. We saw people in rickety boats who, with the help of human smugglers, attempted to cross from Turkey to the Greek islands in large numbers. We saw images of drownings. Of crowds making their way through Europe. Of temporary, sometimes improvised facilities to provide people with basic shelter. In 2016, we managed to reach an agreement with Turkey under high tension. There we saw Europe at its most effective. We need more of these kinds of agreements with third countries. We must also increase the possibilities for reception in the region. The EU can provide financial and political support for this.

We must ensure a comprehensive approach to combating irregular migration on all fronts, along all parts of the migration route, to prevent similar emergencies in the future. What does that mean in practice? First of all: prevention is better than cure. The Netherlands stands for a broad approach. We must do more to eliminate the root causes of migration – poverty, violence, climate change – so that people can see a future in their own country again. Therefore, development cooperation must be more focused than it is now on creating better prospects for people. European countries can also do more to promote security, stability, and better border management. France sets a good example with the G5 Sahel initiative, which helps African countries improve their border management. The Netherlands contributes to this. We must also do more to improve reception in the region.

The management of the European external borders remains crucial. Therefore, it is important that member states fully utilize the toolbox of the renewed European Border and Coast Guard Regulation together with Frontex. We must show solidarity with member states like Italy and Greece in the initial reception of refugees. And we must especially ensure that we, as the EU, are prepared for a new crisis. The experiences of 2015 and 2016 teach us what happens when governments are no longer 'in control'.

Specifically: proposal 6. We urgently need to agree on a new Common European Asylum System. This must focus on a better distribution of responsibility among member states when the influx increases significantly again, including a rapid return of migrants who do not qualify for asylum and a redistribution mechanism. And I tell you honestly: I am concerned about that last point. The redistribution of refugees across Europe remains a difficult issue because not all countries are willing to bear their share. To those countries, I say: I understand your concerns, but solidarity is not a one-way street. Moreover, as the 'front door', the external border, becomes increasingly controlled, an important argument for countries that do not want to cooperate in the redistribution of refugees also falls away. Controlled external borders prevent uncontrolled influx and unmanageable numbers.

In the area of climate, the Netherlands is coming up with far-reaching proposals. Simply because it is also unavoidable. The current European target of a 40 percent reduction in CO2 emissions by 2030 compared to 1990 dates back to before the Paris Climate Agreement. It was agreed that the earth may warm a maximum of 2 degrees and that we strive for one and a half degrees. That agreement calls for an update, for a higher European ambition. 40 percent is too little to achieve that 2 degrees, let alone one and a half degrees. The bar must be raised. Therefore, Proposal 7: we agree on a CO2 reduction of 55 percent by 2030, which will allow us to fulfill our commitment to Paris. With 55 percent as a joint EU contribution to the global ambition, we do our part to keep that one and a half degrees in sight. And let’s not wait. The current Commission can still prepare this. As far as I am concerned, the European Council should give this mandate in June.

And let’s not perceive that goal as a pure burden. Such an enhanced ambition also helps us innovate and brings the energy-efficient, sustainable, and circular economy closer. My assertion is that every investment in the climate is also an investment in the strength of the European economy. That may be a long-term story, but we will say goodbye to our fossil addiction one way or another. And do not be mistaken: most of us will still experience that. In this, the future Europe also has a task and a mission.

Then, ladies and gentlemen, the money.

Last week, we had a first round of discussions in the European Council about the new Multiannual Financial Framework. I explained the Dutch position there. How are we going to use the EU budget for the new priorities in security, stability, prosperity, and climate policy? And I will summarize that immediately in proposal 8: accept that the British are leaving and the budget will be smaller, and modernize by freeing up money within the existing funds for the challenges of tomorrow.

The Netherlands is a wealthy country, and in that respect, it is logical that we are a net contributor. It is not always easy, but even in the Dutch public debate, I stand for our financial contribution to the European Union. Because, once again, 17 million Dutch people receive prosperity and security in return, the primal promise.

But I want to be very clear. My goal for the multiannual budget is: no higher contributions, but better results within a smaller budget. The Netherlands wants the EU to seize this opportunity to fulfill the primal promise of added value through cooperation. The 27 member states that continue together cannot simply fill the Brexit gap. And we also cannot tackle the challenges of the 21st century with a budget that reflects an old reality from decades ago. We talk a lot about new priorities for the EU: sustainability, climate, security, migration, innovation. It is inevitable that funding for new priorities cannot leave ongoing programs and subsidies untouched. But let us also remain realistic: 70 percent of the Union's expenditures go to agriculture and structural funds. A little less in these areas creates room for our new priorities. We must make sharp choices and deliver on our commitments.

A reasonable contribution to the Union can also include a rebate. I have been hearing lately that, now that the British are leaving the Union, the system of rebates must come to an end. After all, the British had 'the mother of all rebates,' so the reasoning goes. I want to counter that: the system of contributions and revenues must be perceived as fair by all member states. This means that countries with a comparable level of prosperity pay a similar net contribution. No one should end up in an extreme contribution position because of the agreements we make. Whether the British are in or out of the Union, this principle remains valid.

Also in the case of the budget, the EU must not be a menu of choices. Upward convergence, one of the main objectives of the EU budget, must be stimulated by more strongly linking EU funds to the implementation of structural reforms. In my view, there should also be conditions that guarantee that solidarity within the EU works both ways. My proposal 9 is about this: link the EU budget to encouraging member states to reform and modernize their economies as agreed. I am not at all opposed to the idea that richer member states provide support to the poorer ones. But that must then yield structural economic growth. This can be achieved by incorporating a mechanism in the EU budget that links support from the structural and cohesion funds to the extent to which countries make progress on those reforms. We can measure that against the annual reporting by the European Commission on the so-called country-specific recommendations. There is no need for a separate eurozone budget, as we already have an EU budget. Jean-Claude Juncker is absolutely right about that.

The concept of conditionality is, by the way, not new. We discussed it last week in Brussels. You understand, I am also a strong advocate of it in general. Because: fulfilling the primal promise starts and ends with the member states, and an agreement is an agreement. My proposal focuses on economic reform. But I also hear suggestions for linking it to addressing the migration issue and compliance with the principles of the rule of law.

And that is not without reason. Those who say that the rule of law is an internal matter of the member states and that the EU should only deal with the internal market are mistaken. The internal market can only exist and be successful if the rule of law is strong in all countries. If companies and investors know that their money is safe. And if they know that a potential conflict can be brought before an independent judge, without interference from the sitting government. Those who undermine the rule of law undermine the internal market. And those who undermine the internal market undermine the European Union. Here, the principle of an agreement being an agreement applies very strongly.

Ladies and gentlemen,

I am an optimist. And from experience, I know that we always find a way together in the EU. That gives confidence. But I am also concerned. I already mentioned that the sentiment around the EU is fragile. Brexit shows that the EU is not an irreversible certainty. In many member states, the parties in the political center, the parties with a long European tradition, are under pressure.

But as I also argued: we did not simply become the most stable, most prosperous, most social, and most free continent in the world after 1945. Those achievements rest on a foundation of shared values, mutual trust, and the willingness to make compromises. Time and again, to become stronger as individual member states and as a collective. If we allow that foundation to erode, we are cutting at the root of everything that has been built.

And that danger is not imaginary, as we see parties rising on the flanks of the political spectrum across Europe that simply deny the great importance of European cooperation. Complaining about that is pointless. The only thing we can counter with is results. Therefore, the center parties in all member states bear a great responsibility to prove that cooperation pays off and delivers added value. If we do not fulfill that primal promise of the EU, people will sooner believe the false promises and fantasies of politicians on the flanks.

Grand visions do not create jobs and security. Shouting from the flanks does not either. Only hard work, step by step, Schritt für Schritt, yields results that people can benefit from in their daily lives. If we do that, and continue to encourage and challenge each other, then I am sure we will fulfill that promise of Europe.

Thank you.