Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen's speech at the Municipal Political Summit on March 16, 2023.

Denmark Mette Frederiksen · Prime Minister of Denmark

16 March 2023 · Municipal Political Summit

Context
Frederiksen addressed mayors and municipal officials at Denmark's Municipal Political Summit on March 16, 2023, calling for collaboration on welfare, security, and climate reform.
Main themes
Welfare state renewal, municipal government, Danish security and defense, green transition and climate adaptation, public services (daycare, schools, elderly care), fiscal policy and economic reform, NATO and defense spending, Ukrainian refugee integration, local democracy, societal challenges
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,089
86th percentile
Sentences
461
98th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
6.7
1st percentile
Syntax
2.19
0th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 49%46%
  • Institutional 31%29%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

461 sentences in 305 paragraphs

Thank you for the invitation. I have been looking forward to being here today.

Politics is filled with one-liners.

“Never give in,” said Winston Churchill.

“It’s morning again in America,” was the phrase from Ronald Reagan.

Barack Obama said: “Yes we can.”

And then there is Angela Merkel’s “Wir schaffen das.”

Agree or disagree. When political slogans are at their best, they capture the essence of what it’s all about.

On Friday, I heard a mayor who captured my view of Danish municipalities in three words.

He said: “We fix it.”

That is exactly what you do – all of you who are present today.

Mayors. Municipal council members. Civil servants. And many other local enthusiasts.

You fix the welfare state in everyday life.

You are the ones who are closest to the Danes.

Your employees, who every morning are ready to welcome the next generation in daycare and kindergarten.

Your employees, who prepare schoolchildren to become competent young people with skills and courage for life.

And your employees, who take care of our elderly, who after a long and arduous life need care, compassion. And a chat about what matters.

The welfare state – it is lived life.

And you – and your employees – are at the core of it. Every single day.

Even when a pandemic sweeps across the country and demands extraordinary efforts.

And when tens of thousands of Ukrainian children and adults fleeing the war need a place to live. A job. A school day. A functioning everyday life.

Dear everyone gathered here. On behalf of Denmark.

Thank you for the effort you put in. And thank you to your employees.

* * *

There are periods in a society's history when changes press for attention. When the very foundation is challenged. And when decisive choices and priorities must be made. To secure the future.

This is exactly the kind of period the Danish welfare state is in.

The backdrop is serious.

First of all, there is Denmark and Europe’s security.

The war in Ukraine has been a wake-up call.

It is completely clear that we must take greater responsibility for our own security.

Denmark’s security rests on NATO cooperation. Therefore, we must contribute 2 percent of GDP by 2030.

As far as my eye can see, we will need to spend significantly more money on defense and security. More than we have done in decades.

In terms of security policy, we are in a time that will present difficult decisions and major changes.

The same applies to the green transition.

Here too, there is a need for major decisions.

That involve the whole society.

Not least you.

Rarely have so many Danes eagerly awaited a letter from the municipality. Will district heating be rolled out here on my property?

A surprising consequence of Russia's aggression was that municipal heating planning became a topic of conversation at the dinner table in many Danish homes.

We need to get the Danes onto green heating sources.

The transition is important. And as many of you know, climate adaptation is too.

The green transition and climate adaptation will demand significant resources in the coming years.

Finally, there is our crown jewel. The welfare state. With free and equal access.

Which is indeed the best in the world. But which is also under pressure. And in need of renewal.

In all three areas. Security. Climate. And welfare. Our society faces major decisions. Where we must show courage and the will to take new paths.

We cannot choose one of them and say: This can wait.

There is an urgent need for action in all three areas. And significant investments.

Danish fiscal policy is sustainable in a long-term perspective, yes. That is absolutely crucial.

But if we are satisfied with that fact alone, then we are essentially saying that we do not want more. That the ambitions are not greater.

For surpluses far into the future do not change the challenges we face in the shorter term. And all that we collectively want to achieve by 2030.

If we do not just settle for being satisfied. But actually want a society as strong as it can possibly be.

Then we must invest more. And the economic room for maneuver is not large enough.

Therefore,

there is

a need for reforms.

* * *

Today, my focus will be on the tasks that lie ahead of us as we take the next steps in the development of the welfare state.

We are one of the safest, richest, and most skilled countries in the world.

But honestly. Do we today have the daycare centers. The public school. And the elderly care. That we dreamed of when we entered politics?

I guess that most of you can identify areas that you would like to improve. Invest in. Organize differently.

Citizens whom you would like to help better than today.

Those ambitions – your ambitions – we must not compromise on.

The welfare state has been created in a partnership between Christiansborg and municipal Denmark over 100 years.

Today, I would like to invite, on behalf of the government, to a collaboration on how we take the next big steps.

The prerequisite for that collaboration is that we have a common understanding of the challenges we face.

Therefore, I will today share my – and our – analysis of the most central challenges for our welfare in the coming years.

There are especially five.

* * *

The first major challenge is demographics.

By 2030, there will be over 40,000 more children. And almost 110,000 more elderly.

In fact, it is a sign of something fantastic.

We are facing a time with lots of new little Danes in snowsuits.

And with even more lively grandparents and great-grandparents who have the energy and health to be with their children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren. And with friends. Travel. Pursue hobbies. Live a good life.

Never before have we lived so healthily. So well. And for so long. As we do now.

That was exactly what we wanted with the welfare state.

But the development will also challenge us. As you know.

With the need for more places in daycare and kindergartens.

And although many elderly are healthy, there will also be more who live with chronic illness and dementia.

This means more elderly who need care.

More with a need for home nursing, home help, and cleaning.

And no, we are not talking about an elderly burden here.

We are talking about people who have built our society.

They certainly deserve a safe and dignified old age.

The government will ensure that the money follows the demographics.

The demographic trend.

It pains me that we – in something so human and crucial – have to use such a dull and technocratic term.

I guess many of you – like me – once had a stack of Donald Duck comics in the cupboard.

Perhaps you remember the character called ‘Sorte Slyngel’?

He was characterized by two things: One: He had a black sheet over his head and two: He was a rascal.

It was easy to identify what he was.

It is harder with demographics. It is an invisible opponent and ally.

In 2030, it will cost over 21 billion kroner just to keep up with it.

A large number. But it only covers that we can roughly maintain the status quo.

And yet not.

I know that the specialized social area is significant for you.

Citizens with mental illnesses and disabilities are people with very different living conditions and needs.

Young people struggling in life. Adults needing support in everyday life. People with disabilities.

What they all have in common is that they deserve good lives just like everyone else.

And I also know that your employees work every day to meet those needs.

It is primarily a humanitarian challenge.

But also an economic one. The specialized social area is today the largest single municipal expenditure area.

And expenses are rising.

The development in the population composition – and in the specialized social area – will challenge us all.

And thus the welfare state. In a wide range of areas.

And much more than many might imagine.

Here we must work closely together. Here we will need to find fundamentally new solutions. We must prevent much more. We must find new collaborations. New ways to organize ourselves.

* * *

The next major challenge is a good example of this.

The lack of employees in welfare.

If I asked you in the assembly:

How many of you have experienced that one of your institutions has advertised a position as a social and health worker or educator – without success?

How many have experienced that? Many.

And many have probably also experienced that your institutions have had to give up on making the duty roster work.

That you could not provide the welfare at night that you actually wanted.

The truth is that it is difficult to get enough employees in citizen-facing welfare.

And looking ahead, the recruitment challenge will only grow.

By 2030, we could be short up to 17,000 more social and health workers.

Can we be satisfied with that?

No. Of course not.

Too few are applying for a welfare education. And too many drop out along the way.

We need to turn that development around.

At the same time, we must be able to retain those who go to work every day. And make a huge effort.

We must offer decent pay and working conditions.

Create frameworks that reduce absenteeism.

Encourage more to work full-time.

And get more to want to stay in their profession. In a time of great work pressure.

But it is not easy. It is actually very difficult.

* * *

At the same time, there is also a need to look at how the employees who are working use their time.

Here, the ever-growing bureaucracy is a problem.

In almost ten years, administrative costs in municipalities have increased by 2.5 billion kroner.

Here, some of you might want to interject and say: Well, it’s not just in the municipalities that more people have been hired to administer. It also applies to the state.

And that is completely correct.

Will the government also look into that?

Yes, we will. Of course.

For it is actually paradoxical.

Which of us here in the room has ever wished for the level of bureaucracy we have today?

Probably none.

And which of us has campaigned for more money for administration, documentation, and bureaucracy?

I have yet to meet that politician.

Yet bureaucracy has grown. And it has gotten worse year after year.

The administrations and municipal councils add – just like Christiansborg – extra layers to the bureaucracy.

A strategy that leads to an action plan. Which again leads to a working group. A form. A new guideline.

Communication efforts. Reporting. Supervision and follow-up. And funds. And funds. And so it continues.

And it is not only at the town hall and in the administrations that bureaucracy exists. It has affected our way of working all the way out to the citizens.

Let me give you an example.

In one municipality, it used to be the case that if a citizen needed a bath, and the hearing aid needed cleaning, the employee had to write it both in a journal and in a separate form.

That example is not isolated.

Think about how many working hours that adds up to. Time we could use differently.

Here we must acknowledge and say: You saw the problems before we did in Christiansborg.

It reminds me of the 1980s and 1990s.

Back then, it was also you, mayors, who opened Christiansborg's eyes to the problems with the inadequate integration of refugees and immigrants.

Had we listened to you back then, Denmark would probably have pursued a different immigration and refugee policy.

And now, when it comes to the problems with the growing bureaucracy in welfare, it is again you who are opening our eyes.

I am ready – on behalf of myself and Christiansborg – to take on my – our – share of the responsibility.

We have centrally created far too many rules and far, far too much detailed management.

And unfortunately, we continue to do so.

Because for many years we have believed that we could regulate and micromanage our way to the best welfare.

Simplistically put, we have believed that the road to a good welfare society was paved with regulation.

That was a misunderstanding. And it is a misunderstanding

That has been reinforced by an impatient political logic that has not always been conducive to good solutions.

Another bill. Another new right. Another fund.

Another new coalition that has agreed on a new political agreement filled with new detailed requirements.

None mentioned. None forgotten. I have stood there myself. In front of the minister's office and been genuinely pleased with such agreements.

I promise you that they have been made with the best intentions.

But when layer upon layer of legislation and rules, made with the best intentions, are piled on top of each other. It becomes heavy.

It hits all the way out to the employee. And the citizen.

A vicious circle. And a huge paradox.

But it happens again and again.

When it comes to the growing bureaucracy, the finger points to us at Christiansborg.

But it must also point back at you.

For many of the rules and documentation requirements that institutions and employees are subject to have been devised by local administrations. Also, of course, with the best intentions.

You have indeed been subject to the same political logic. The demand for quick solutions to difficult problems.

Yes, even at the individual institutions, they have, on top of the regulation they have received, imposed a lot of regulation on themselves. Again, with the best intentions.

Here in Aalborg Municipality, they have reviewed the rules that have been initiated locally in the elderly sector.

It turns out that 17 out of 20 municipal rules have been introduced by local care units. Only three out of 20 have been introduced by the administration.

That underscores, in my view, that the fight against bureaucracy is a fight against a misguided idea of how we create the best welfare society.

Because it is about an overly systemic and overly cold approach to people.

In that way, it is a real battle of values. That we must fight together.

Against an idea that exists at all levels. With us at Christiansborg. With you locally. And all the way out in the institutions.

* * *

The next major challenge for welfare concerns our cohesion as a country.

A few weeks ago, I visited Tingbjerg School. A school full of happy children and young people. Most of them with a different ethnic background.

Here, the young school leader has come a long way in creating a completely ordinary Danish public school.

Integration is progressing in many places across the country.

All of you who have created these successes deserve huge praise for that. You can stand tall. Well done.

But at the same time as we celebrate the successes, the problems are still far too many.

Even after 30 years of integration efforts, the picture is clear: Immigrants and descendants from countries in the Middle East and North Africa are doing, on average, worse than immigrants from many other countries.

Fewer of the women are entering the workforce.

More of the young men are being convicted of crimes.

And around our country, there are areas where groups of people live isolated from the rest of us.

People who cannot manage in our language, even though they have lived here for years. Who do not go to work. Who do not share ordinary Danish and Western values. Or participate in the communities we have with each other.

This affects a society.

The welfare state is fundamentally a community. Built on mutual trust that we all contribute.

That we know each other. Talk to each other. And are part of the same public conversation.

All of this is seriously challenged by parallel societies.

And if we do not do even more to lift the integration task. And make it very clear that those who have come to Denmark must always take responsibility for our country. Then we undermine the welfare state.

* * *

The last challenge is our expectations of welfare.

Nine out of ten of you mayors experience that the expectations of Danes regarding welfare have become significantly greater.

This is not surprising.

As we become richer and richer and can buy more and more, we expect more from public welfare. Schools. Daycare institutions. Elderly care.

When a child has a fast computer at home, it is expected that the school's computer is not slow and old.

This is the case all around.

Back in the 1950s, the Swedish politician Olof Palme was aware of the connection.

He called it "the dissatisfaction of growing expectations."

Improved conditions quickly become everyday life. And are followed by new expectations.

But the welfare state is not primarily a service institution.

It is much more. Much larger. And much more important.

Our welfare state is about warmth. Presence. Care.

And not least about citizenship.

That we engage in the community. In life in kindergartens. Schools. Local communities. Helping those who are struggling.

The roots go far back.

Farmers who organized themselves in the cooperative movement and folk high schools.

Workers who founded trade unions, housing associations, sports clubs, and much more.

All of this led to the welfare state we know today.

Let us not lose that historical heritage.

If we reduce welfare to merely being a 'service'. Then we will not only become spiritually poorer. Dissatisfaction with welfare will also increase.

This will result in declining support for the universal welfare state.

So we must ask ourselves: Are we talking too much about a welfare state that should deliver a service?

Instead of a welfare community that is built on engaged citizens?

Welfare cannot be a transaction.

It is a personal responsibility.

Let us talk more about that. And about caring for each other. About engaging in the community.

That citizenship. I believe there is a need to strengthen it.

* * *

The five challenges that I have outlined here.

Demography.

Recruitment problems.

The growing bureaucracy.

The cohesion that is threatened.

And growing expectations of welfare.

This is my analysis of the reality we face. The government's analysis.

We would like to discuss it with you.

And I look forward to hearing yours.

In my view, we are faced with the choice: Will we just limp along? Patch things up here and there. Hope that it will last us through our time?

Or will we take a more fundamental approach?

With new ways to organize welfare? And reforms that can create changes that extend beyond our lifetime?

I probably won't send shockwaves through this room by saying that we in the government prefer the latter.

And we do not want to. In fact, we do not want to do it alone.

On the contrary. We want to collaborate with you. With the parties. And not least with the Danes.

* * *

Before I conclude, let us address some of the elements in the government platform that I know have sparked debate and criticism in the municipalities.

Let me start with administrative expenses.

For yes, we will stand firm that the expenses for administration in municipalities and regions must be reduced by 3 billion kroner by 2030.

Because we believe it is better to spend the money on wages and working conditions for employees in welfare.

I know very well that it is a hundred times easier said than done to curb the growth of administrative expenses. And even harder to reduce them.

Nevertheless, that is the task.

And the government will work to ensure that citizen-centered welfare is protected. It is administration that should take up less space.

We will propose a multi-year cooperation program between the government, municipalities, and regions. With the aim of reducing administrative expenses and protecting citizen-centered welfare.

Because we would like to discuss with you what we can do to contribute.

Through fewer objectives. Simpler management and oversight. Fewer documentation requirements.

You should have the opportunity to challenge us on all the regulations we can remove for the task to succeed. Follow or explain.

* * *

And then there are the job centers.

That we will abolish them. We know that this is a very tough measure. And an unusually clear statement.

Let me emphasize: This is not because the employees in the job centers are not doing their jobs well enough.

They have done exactly what they have been instructed to do from Christiansborg.

No. This is a reckoning with a system that is entangled in rules, process requirements, and bureaucracy.

For example, employees at Jobcenter Aarhus experience that they spend three hours on rules and bureaucracy for every hour they spend on an unemployed citizen.

That is too skewed.

This is not about Aarhus.

It is about us finding a new way to do it together.

* * *

The government and the politicians at Christiansborg have been criticized for raising expectations for the welfare you are to deliver higher than is good.

But we know that there is not money for everything.

That you experience that budgeting has become increasingly difficult.

You face tough priorities every single day.

Therefore, we want to give you more freedom to do things the way you find best.

This also means that there should be more room for diversity in welfare across municipalities. More than there is today.

Already today, there are local differences in welfare in Denmark.

But the government's ambition is that you should be able to organize welfare even more according to what you think is best locally.

Because it is you who know your local areas and citizens best.

And because increased local freedom can pave the way for higher quality in welfare.

I think it has been a misunderstood notion that uniformity is a marker of quality.

That if welfare is the same from Ballerup to Hobro. From Hedensted to Odense. Then it is an expression of high quality.

That is nonsense.

Quality in welfare is about professionalism, presence, and care.

And we can only strengthen that if we create space for much greater local differences, preferences, and priorities.

I am convinced that if we unleash local creativity, it will lead to new paths.

If in Hedensted they want to run the nursing home and daycare differently than they do somewhere in Funen, then they should be able to do that.

Diversity can indeed be an expression of quality. Of the local. Of citizenship.

There are, of course, exceptions – health is probably the most obvious example – where there should be national quality requirements and standards. The same quality across the country.

But I hope you have taken my signal down.

* * *

All the challenges we face are deeply complex. And they intersect with each other.

To solve them, it is not enough to turn a screw in one place. Or implement a quick legislative package.

We need to take a more fundamental approach. Develop solutions together. And involve all relevant actors.

This also includes civil society. Private companies, volunteers, organizations, and others.

The new broad government is built on the ambition to change the political culture.

To break with block politics. To insist on dialogue and inclusion across the board.

That way of thinking is not foreign to you.

If anyone knows about cooperation across the aisle. About making tough decisions. About everything from new school districts to merging nursing homes.

It is you.

I began my speech today by saying that there are times in a society's history when the very foundation is challenged. When decisive choices and priorities must be made. To secure the future.

Dear summit!

This is exactly where Denmark stands right now.

It is us. The first broad government across the aisle in many years.

And you.

Who are currently faced with the task.

With the responsibility.

With a historic opportunity.

If we use it correctly, we can not only fix it together.

We can also make the choices and decisions that will be crucial for the future of the welfare state.

We hope to do that together with you.

Thank you for your attention.