Government statement by Chancellor Olaf Scholz on current domestic political issues before the German Bundestag on January 29, 2025, in Berlin:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

29 January 2025 · Government statement before the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the Bundestag on January 29, 2025, delivering a government statement on domestic security and migration policy following the fatal attack in Aschaffenburg.
Main themes
Right to asylum, Aschaffenburg attack, migration and deportation policy, enforcement deficit, Holocaust remembrance, rule of law, state vs. federal responsibility, border controls, public safety, democratic values
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,831
73rd percentile
Sentences
172
85th percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
2.82
24th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 59%58%
  • Geopolitical 19%19%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

172 sentences in 27 paragraphs

Madam President!

Dear colleagues!

After what we heard today from Roman Schwarzman, it is not easy to move on to the agenda. We bow our heads to him and to all the victims of the Holocaust. Roman Schwarzman's words resonate: "Humanity and justice must not be empty words," he has inscribed in our hearts. I say: Humanity and justice are promises of our democratic constitution. Humanity and justice find their expression in fundamental rights, including the right to asylum, which offers protection from violence, war, and terror.

As we discuss the shocking, cruel act in Aschaffenburg and its consequences today, I want to preface one thing: The right to asylum is an integral part of our legal and value system. We must not waver on this. The right to asylum is the immediate response to the horrors of Nazi rule. Back then, it was German and European Jews who were turned away at foreign borders. This, as the lesson of history teaches us, must never happen again. Germany must never allow this again. So, as we discuss asylum, flight, and migration here in the Bundestag today, 80 years after the liberation of Auschwitz, and also all the difficulties associated with it, the commitment to the right to asylum for those politically persecuted is part of it. Because decency demands that we clearly distinguish between those who can invoke the protection of asylum law and those for whom this does not apply.

What happened in Aschaffenburg is a heinous, monstrous crime. Two people were brutally killed: a two-year-old boy and a man who bravely stood in the way of the attacker. Who stabs a two-year-old child? Such an act exceeds one's imagination. One can hardly fathom the pain of the parents. I often think of the victims and their families and friends. We mourn with them and with the citizens of Aschaffenburg.

In Aschaffenburg and in many places across the country, alongside great sympathy and compassion, one can also sense how deeply unsettled many citizens are. Mannheim, Solingen, Magdeburg, now Aschaffenburg: Again, the perpetrator was someone who abused our protection. Again, it was someone who should no longer be here or at least not be at large. Again, the urgent question arises whether and where authorities have failed. I understand anyone who says: I've had enough! And I say: Enough is enough! I am outraged too. I am outraged when authorities at the federal, state, and local levels do not do everything that is legally possible. That is why I say deliberately: We have an enforcement deficit, because all four crimes—in Mannheim, Solingen, Magdeburg, and Aschaffenburg—could have been prevented with the existing and tightened laws.

That is why it is good and decent that, alongside the federal government, the ministers-president of Baden-Württemberg, North Rhine-Westphalia, and Saxony-Anhalt have promised clarification and have taken care of it. All the more irritating is how the Bavarian state government wants to extricate itself from the affair by pointing fingers at others instead of asking: What has actually gone wrong here with us, here in Bavaria? Because things have gone wrong in the Free State of Bavaria.

Yes, the BAMF, the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees, should have acted more quickly. I clarified that with the president of the BAMF on the day of the crime; that is unacceptable. The enforcement of foreign law, police threat prevention, the execution of deportations, the protection of the public from mentally ill offenders: All of this is the responsibility of the states in our country. That is what the Basic Law states. And I am tired of the smokescreens that are thrown up after such crimes to cover up one's own shortcomings.

The federal government can set the legal framework for better management of migration, for a stricter asylum law, and for more deportations. We have done that. And we will continue to do so. But I expect that laws are applied consistently everywhere. We have streamlined asylum procedures so that our authorities can decide more quickly. We have ensured stricter rules for the care and accommodation of asylum seekers so that the states can utilize them—keyword "payment card," keyword "benefits in kind," and much more. Border controls at all internal borders: We have enforced them, unlike the CDU and CSU interior ministers before us. We turned back well over 40,000 people at the border alone last year.

Longer detention for deportation and deportation custody: We have expanded and tightened the possibilities for this. These possibilities must now also be fully utilized everywhere in Germany in all states. Yes, and we need more places for deportation custody. I have been demanding this for a long time. We also need Dublin centers for the return of asylum seekers for whom another EU country is responsible, in all states and not just in Hamburg. In all of this, it is about effectively enforcing deportations, because we will only maintain acceptance for legal immigration if we enforce our law. And we have significantly increased the number of deportations: by almost a quarter compared to the previous year and even by 70 percent compared to 2021.

We are the only country in Europe that has managed to deport offenders to Afghanistan in recent years. That is incredibly difficult with a Taliban government, but we have succeeded. The next flight is being prepared. We are also closely monitoring developments in Syria. As soon as the situation on the ground allows, we will also carry out deportations of offenders there—according to law and legislation, as is proper in a constitutional state. We are discussing this with the heads of government of the states, just as we have repeatedly made extensive resolutions in this circle in recent years.

I am ready to implement any, even any new proposal that further facilitates the work of our authorities. But once again: The acts in Mannheim, Solingen, Magdeburg, and Aschaffenburg could have been prevented through the consistent application of existing laws—all of them. That is what must improve. On Monday, the interior ministers discussed exactly this. I expressly support that the interior ministers have agreed to prevent violent acts by the mentally ill more effectively so that such offenders, who are not terrorists, can be identified earlier and monitored better. And I welcome their decision to intensify data matching and information exchange between all security authorities and to utilize biometric data for threat prevention even more.

With some of our measures, we have pushed the limits of what our constitution and European treaties allow. This is especially true for the temporary border controls, which must be justified and extended every six months. We are doing this and will continue to do so. But it is also clear: One cannot go beyond existing law, one must not go beyond existing law. To avert harm from the German people: That means doing everything that is legally possible—as a constitutional state, as the largest member state of the European Union. What harms the German people, however, are sham solutions that undermine our constitutional state and our constitution, that destroy Germany's reputation in Europe and the world, that undermine the foundation of the European Union, which we need especially in these times and for which we as Germans bear special responsibility.

But that is exactly what you are doing, Mr. Merz, when you say: We simply will no longer apply European law at our borders. That is the answer of the populists! The Catholic and Protestant churches warned yesterday in a letter of concern against your proposals, Mr. Merz. Our courts would be forced to immediately annul such unlawful actions. They would annul it immediately. That would happen in an expedited procedure within just a few days. You want to use an emergency article in the EU treaties. Yet you know full well: The European Court of Justice has never accepted that and would not accept it. The largest country in the EU would openly break EU law, just as Viktor Orbán in Hungary dares to do—sending a fatal signal to other states.

No German Chancellor has ever done such a thing, not Konrad Adenauer, not Willy Brandt and Helmut Schmidt, not Helmut Kohl, and not Angela Merkel either. That must be noted here. They all understood Germany's responsibility. And they knew: Our economy benefits like no other from the European internal market. But that too thrives on respect for European law. An erosion of the rule of law destroys trust and stability—and this at a time when our democracy and its institutions are already being attacked and undermined by right-wing extremists. In such a time, stability is needed, not more uncertainty.

What would our companies, hospitals, or the many cross-border commuters say if truck and passenger traffic at the border collapsed? They are already complaining about the difficulties associated with the border controls introduced by my government. What would the Polish Prime Minister and the French President say if Germany openly broke European law? The Austrian Chancellor has already made it clear that his country will only take back individuals according to the applicable European rules. This means that your grandly announced measures would not work in practice at all.

Germany's role in Europe must be different. It follows from our history. It is enshrined in our constitution. Especially in this time, when Russia threatens our peace order, when President Trump is taking a new political course, European unity is more important than ever. This applies especially in migration policy, which has long been a divisive issue. After eight years of standstill, we have succeeded in getting the European Union to finally agree on a common asylum system. Next year, it will be implemented everywhere. This will better protect the external borders and many returns will take place directly from there. Countries that have previously simply let refugees through will have to electronically register all arrivals in the future. Countries that have long evaded responsibility have agreed to a solidarity distribution of refugees.

And what is particularly important for Germany: We will be able to return asylum seekers much more easily to the European country responsible for these individuals, as these countries cannot simply deny their responsibility. This will remedy one of the biggest birth defects in the Dublin system for the future. All of this represents concessions for which we have fought for years, concessions that we had to wrestle from others. All of this would be jeopardized, because if we withdraw from the European rules, others will withdraw as well. Therefore, we have a great interest in ensuring that the new rules are applied everywhere. We can pass the law necessary for the implementation of this major reform here in Germany in the Bundestag before the election.

You are jeopardizing this great European agreement in the interest of Germany with your thoughtless announcements and unlawful proposals. There are limits that one must not cross as a statesman. The oath of office of a Chancellor—and not just that oath—demands that the constitution and the law be upheld and defended. That is the standard set by our Basic Law. You say you would go "all in" with your proposals, as one might say in poker. But politics in our country is not a poker game! The cohesion of Europe is not a stake in a game. And a German Chancellor must not be a gambler, for he decides, in the worst case, about war or peace.

You said it would not matter to you who supports your unlawful proposals. But it does matter whether one collaborates with the extreme right—not in Germany! Since the founding of the Federal Republic over 75 years ago, there has always been a clear consensus among all democrats: In our parliaments, we do not collaborate with the extreme right. You have unilaterally abrogated this fundamental consensus of our republic in a fit of rage. And you have made it clear first and foremost: You will no longer negotiate your proposals with the democratic parties. This leaves you with only those as partners who have always disregarded law and order: the extreme right. You know that. Even more: You are aiming for it. You openly accept the support of the AfD for your unlawful proposals, the support of those who fight our democracy, who despise our united Europe, who have been poisoning the climate in our country for years. That is a grave mistake. That is an unforgivable mistake.

Until now, we have only known your flip-flops and zigzag courses from other areas: in foreign policy – I only mention the Taurus ultimatum – or regarding the retirement age, where you tell people something different than what is in your party program. But in a question that is so central to our country, namely the question of whether one can collaborate with the extreme right as a democrat, I really believed your assurances. On November 12, you said: I do not want to form majorities in Parliament with the AfD. On November 13, you reiterated this here at this podium in elaborate terms. You made a firm agreement with the chairman of the SPD parliamentary group to refrain from anything that relies on votes from the AfD. Just three weeks ago, you gave your word on television that the CDU would not sell its soul through cooperation with the AfD. You tied your political fate to that. Many citizens trusted that and your word. But what are those words worth now? What are those words worth now?

We are currently experiencing this in Austria. There, too, all democratic parties clearly stated before the election: We will not govern with the FPÖ, the local equivalent of the AfD, under any circumstances. The conservatives especially made this promise solemnly. And now, after the election? Now the Austrian conservatives are suddenly willing to elect an extreme right chancellor from the FPÖ and govern with him.

For the citizens in Germany, it is now completely clear: There must be no majority for CDU/CSU and AfD after the federal elections. There must be no majority for CDU/CSU and AfD after the federal elections; otherwise, we risk a black-blue government in Germany. Because whoever says, I do not care who votes for my proposals, ultimately also says: I do not care who votes for me. And there are not only programmatic overlaps between you and those from the AfD regarding the illegal, anti-European proposals to limit irregular migration. The tax plans of the CDU and AfD would disproportionately relieve the very richest. And you also agree that supposedly too little work is being done in Germany and that therefore more pressure must be put on employees. But the citizens can ensure on February 23 that there is no majority for such false policies in Germany. The citizens can ensure that there is no majority for black-blue in our country.

We will ensure more order, regulation, and humanity in migration policy from the democratic center, just as we have done together with the states in recent years. Important proposals to strengthen internal security are ready for decision here in the Bundestag or in the Bundesrat. I have already mentioned the law for the implementation of the European asylum reform. The sooner that comes, the better the states can prepare for it. We want to modernize the Federal Police Act; that is also here in the Bundestag. It is about enabling the Federal Police to conduct better investigative work, using the current state of technology. We can set this in motion together this week.

And the tightening of laws that we decided after the attack in Solingen is still on the table. This includes, for example, new powers that our security authorities are urgently waiting for, such as biometric data matching on the internet. I have no understanding for the fact that these changes are still being blocked by the union-led states in the Bundesrat. What are we waiting for?

One last word: The day after the attack in Aschaffenburg, I was in Erfurt. At the edge of this citizens' event, a young man approached me and said: Mr. Scholz, I come from Afghanistan, just like the perpetrator from Aschaffenburg. And I want to say to you and all Germans: We are not all like that. What happened there shocks me just as much as everyone else here in the country. – Almost a third of us in Germany have a migration background. Many of them are very afraid of being placed under general suspicion. They suffer from hate and violence just like all the others among us.

Among the victims of Aschaffenburg were a small boy from Morocco and a little girl from Syria. And that is why we must not allow ourselves to be divided. Maximum consequences for those who exploit our country and our protection without abandoning the rule of law, and at the same time, no tolerance for those who sow hate and incitement. That is the right course for our country.