Speech by Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz at the 70th anniversary of the Federal Association of Digital Publishers and Newspaper Publishers (BDZV) on September 12, 2024, in Berlin:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

15 September 2024 · 70th anniversary of the Federal Association of Digital Publishers and Newspaper Publishers (BDZV) · Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the 70th anniversary celebration of the Federal Association of Digital Publishers and Newspaper Publishers (BDZV) in Berlin on September 12, 2024.
Main themes
Press freedom and democracy, media credibility and public trust, Ukraine support policy, political-media disconnect, local vs. Berlin media perspectives, populism and far-right rhetoric, digital journalism and business models, diversity of opinion, misinformation and social media
Duration
~14 min
48th percentile
Words
1,637
48th percentile
Sentences
90
58th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
10.5
27th percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
32nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 38%34%
  • Technological 17%16%
  • Institutional 12%11%
  • Economic 11%10%
  • Geopolitical 10%9%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 10%

90 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

congratulations on 70 years of BDZV! You have asked me for an "impulse for free press and democracy." As a passionate newspaper reader – from politics to local news to culture – I am happy to comply with this request. However, I would like to spare you the pious words about the high value that press freedom undoubtedly holds and instead approach the topic through three small incidents that have occurred in recent weeks.

The

first

of these takes place in Thuringia. A journalist colleague of yours, Eva Schulz, reported there with her camera team on the state election campaign. At the edge of an AfD campaign event, initially, no one wanted to speak with a representative of ZDF. When Eva Schulz later found an interview partner, he told her, in essence, that the German media are forced by politics to report in the way that politics dictates.

I could somewhat flippantly say: The daily look at the newspapers somehow proves the exact opposite to me. But seriously: The perception that politics and media are one and the same – as far-fetched as it may seem to you and me – should give us pause, because critical distance is crucial for the credibility of the media. I therefore have great respect for this critical distance; even more so: What I particularly enjoy in my daily newspaper reading are precisely the perspectives that I had not considered, the arguments that contradict my own – that can happen. This does not lead to immediate rethinking, but it certainly stimulates reflection.

The fact that politics and media are perceived in parts of the population as I have just described from Thuringia has, of course, causes. One that I repeatedly notice when I am out in the country. The questions that your colleagues in Berlin ask me are often quite different from those I encounter in conversations with citizens.

For example, Ukraine: In Berlin, I have been asked for months and years why we, as the second-largest supporter of Ukraine, do not pay or deliver much more – weapon system X or cruise missile Y. Mind you: These questions are completely legitimate. They also exist in the population. But at least as often, I have been asked in marketplaces, at citizen dialogues, or election campaign rallies why we even support Ukraine, whether it would not be safer and better for Germany to stop delivering weapons altogether, and whether the billions we invest in supporting Ukraine – rightly so, that is beyond question for me, just to be clear – would not be better spent on German schools or railway tracks.

When such questions occur only marginally in the German media landscape – and are only loudly posed by figures at the extreme edges of the political spectrum, not by the media themselves – then that is a problem, because those in the country who are asking these very questions do not see themselves reflected.

Of course, politics also bears responsibility. And that should not be overlooked here. That is why I have repeatedly advocated for my course of supporting Ukraine in recent weeks and months – a course that is reliable, determined, and measured at the same time. This course is not only right, it is also sustainable – for as long as necessary.

Others, however, who wanted to score points in Berlin just a few months ago with new demands, have quietly retreated into the bushes. They suddenly became completely silent in Saxony and Thuringia on the issue of Ukraine support. And their candidates seemed to have free rein to mimic the sound of the populist competition from the far right or far left. Such a zigzag course, however, creates uncertainty in the country.

So what is to be done – for both media and politics? I would say, listen and address all the questions that concern people in the country. For politics, including government policy, less self-promotion would help, and instead, full concentration on the issues at hand. And the media would do well to focus less on the egos of the actors and more on the actions themselves – more facts instead of nudging, more diversity of opinion instead of the Berlin bubble, more information, less campaigning, perhaps simply: reporting. That would be a gain for trust in the media and politics and thus also for our democracy, for our country.

One more thing must of course be added: People must also be reached in practical terms. Here, you, the publishers, are particularly challenged. You need to find ways to make money with good journalism to finance in-depth research as well as reporting on the local handball club. At the same time, you must develop innovative digital offerings and new financing models and are competing against the boundless flood of information on the internet and social media. But perhaps therein lies a business model for the journalism of tomorrow?

That is at least what I told the students and graduates of the German School of Journalism in Munich when I visited there in early summer. Recording a podcast can, in principle, be done by anyone who has a smartphone. But having a real conversation with an interview partner that is more than just self-promotion or chatter is a high art. That is the art of good journalism.

The

second

incident I would like to briefly report on took place a few weeks ago in Papenburg in the Emsland. It was about a support package for the struggling Meyer shipyard. You have all followed that. And we have just received the go-ahead in the Bundestag for our support. But above all, it was about thousands of jobs at the shipyard and many more thousands in a region that, like no other in Germany, depends on shipbuilding and lives from it.

Of course, a company meeting there is not broadcast on national television or live-streamed by the major media houses. It concerns the bus driver in Landshut or the retail clerk in Chemnitz too little. But for the family members of the shipyard workers, for the people in dozens of supplier companies, that morning was about everything or nothing. And the NOZ, which appears there as the Ems newspaper, was there for its subscribers via live stream and with a minute-by-minute live ticker from the event.

This has once again shown me: Local media are the backbone of our media landscape. In many regions, they are even the only independent source for local news. And these local news often move citizens just as much as big politics. That is why I am also firmly convinced: Local news remains a business model. Local media have a future.

The

third

incident I would like to talk about involves a book I recently read that made me reflect. Some of you may know it. It is called "The Coming Wave" and is by the co-founder of DeepMind, Mustafa Suleyman. In it, he intensively deals with the opportunities, but also with the risks and dangers of artificial intelligence (AI), especially with regard to the media. Mustafa Suleyman writes: "AI has the potential to revolutionize many aspects of our lives, including the media, by enhancing creativity, improving personalization, and uncovering new insights. But with this power comes the risk of deepening misinformation, eroding trust, and manipulating public opinion. It’s a double-edged sword (...)."

I think it is good that you are discussing this double-edged sword of artificial intelligence here at your congress: as a risk and as an opportunity. At best, AI can complement the work of journalists and make many things easier – less time spent on simple information gathering, and more time for personal research. That would be to your benefit. And at the same time, AI makes journalistic interpretation more necessary than ever. I would even say: Never have free media and good journalism been so important. We need them so that we do not sink into a sea of information and disinformation and in the waves of daily news, the latest spin, the loudest escalation.

For AI to truly serve quality journalism and press freedom, it must also be clear that the work of journalists remains protected and recognizable as such. Quality journalism does not exist without paid journalists, does not exist without economically strong publishers, does not exist for free. The recently adopted European AI regulation attempts to strike a balance between AI openness and the protection of creative, human creation. This is an important first step.

In Brussels, we are also committed to combating disinformation and have successfully advocated for better protection for journalists against intimidation through abusive lawsuits. In Germany, we are promoting the establishment of a counseling center specifically for media professionals.

And one more thing I recently discussed with Ursula von der Leyen. While it has nothing to do with AI, I want to mention it here anyway because the BDZV and other media associations wrote me a letter about it in August. It concerns the European Union's (EU) deforestation regulation and its impact on print products. To be clear: The regulation must be practical. And that is why I have advocated with Ursula von der Leyen for the regulation to be suspended as long as the open questions raised by the BDZV remain unresolved.

From Thuringian marketplaces to shipyards in the Emsland to the EU deforestation regulation – these may not be the topics and locations one would expect for a speech on the 75th anniversary of the BDZV. But what is really predictable these days in your and my profession?

I am pleased if I could entertain you a little and share my thoughts with you. Take it as a sign of appreciation from a – at least mostly – very happy newspaper reader towards your profession.

Thank you very much!