Speech by Chancellor Olaf Scholz at the summer conference "The Future of Our Democracy" of the Political Club of the Protestant Academy Tutzing on June 17, 2022, in Tutzing:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

20 June 2022 · Summer conference "The Future of Our Democracy" of the Political Club of the Protestant Academy Tutzing · Protestant Academy Tutzing, Tutzing, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the Protestant Academy Tutzing's summer conference on the future of democracy on June 17, 2022, reflecting on Russia's invasion of Ukraine as a historic turning point.
Main themes
Russia's invasion of Ukraine, European peace and security order, Germany's role in a changing world, historical turning points, democracy's future, sanctions against Russia, support for Ukraine, global food and energy security, German foreign policy, NATO and EU cooperation, post-Cold War order
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,241
78th percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
50
62nd percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 35%34%
  • Geopolitical 31%31%
  • Social 15%14%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

166 sentences in 70 paragraphs

Dear Director Hahn,

dear Professor Heuss,

dear Mr. Wolfgang Thierse,

dear Gesine Schwan,

ladies and gentlemen,

some of you may remember, I certainly do: On New Year's Eve 1986, the New Year's address of the Federal Chancellor was to be broadcast on the First Program after the "Tagesschau," as usual. However, what was actually aired was Helmut Kohl's address from the previous year. The station had – under circumstances that were never quite clarified – mixed up the tapes. The Chancellor was reported to have been very outraged. I can certainly understand the outrage.

The point is, however, that in reality, no great damage had occurred. Among the viewers in front of the television, very few had even noticed the mistake. This was because the speech lacked specific references to the past year.

I am sure: If the same mishap were to happen on New Year's Eve 2022, then this time it would be noticed by everyone: Something is not right.

But that is how it is: In some years, not much fundamental happens, and then, in other years, events and developments suddenly accelerate. You do not choose this, nor do you strive for it. But when such a situation arises, you must accept the challenge.

Federal Chancellor Kohl himself experienced such a dramatic acceleration of history shortly thereafter – in 1989, when the peaceful revolutionaries of the GDR brought down the wall and the era of the Cold War ended.

This year, 2022, is not even halfway through. Much can, and much will, happen in the coming months. But one thing is already certain: Even in 2022, we will look back on it as one of the particularly distinctive and consequential years.

We will remember the year 2022 as the year in which Russia, under the leadership of President Putin, invaded Ukraine; the year in which a European great power launched an imperial war of aggression for the first time in many decades; the year in which President Putin violently repudiated the European and international peace and security order that had existed since the Cold War; the year in which the war and the preceding coronavirus pandemic dramatically drove up prices for energy, raw materials, and food worldwide – with all the devastating consequences for global food security, for the world economy, and for the stability of entire countries and regions that are already becoming apparent today.

It is therefore obvious: With his barbaric war of aggression against peaceful Ukraine, Vladimir Putin has summoned a turning point in history. I stated this just a few days after the outbreak of war in the German Bundestag. And I added: The world afterwards is no longer the same as the world before.

As you know, I was just in Kyiv. Those who see the destruction that this war has brought with it, who see it with their own eyes, will once again understand in a very personal way what a watershed this war is.

Together with all our partners in the EU, NATO, and the G7, the Federal Government has responded quickly and decisively to the new situation: with tough and effective sanctions against Russia, with comprehensive economic and financial support for Ukraine, with the acceptance of millions of refugees throughout the EU and over 800,000 here in Germany, and also by – in close cooperation with our partners – supplying Ukraine with the weapons it needs to defend itself against Russia's invasion. All these measures contribute to ensuring that Putin does not succeed with his imperialist aggression.

But it is about much more: It is about the question of whether the European and international peace order will ultimately break apart and whether we will succeed in creating a new order.

At this global turning point, we are still at the very beginning. We are, so to speak, in uncharted territory. Precisely for this reason, it is all the more important that we now look ahead, that we understand how the world is changing, what forces are at work, where the fault lines run, which actors matter now and in the future, and what new crises and conflicts are looming. Only then can we preserve what is important to us. Only then can we effectively influence the direction in which things will develop in the future.

When the world changes, particularly much is at stake for Germany. For it is undeniable: Behind us Germans lie, on the whole, good decades; decades of peace in democratic freedom, decades of growing prosperity, decades of internal and external security.

I titled my book from 2017 "Land of Hope" – not without reason. For many people around the world – and for some of us surprisingly – Germany has become a place of longing in recent decades, a place from which they hope for a better life.

And I want to say: Nowhere is it written that new good decades cannot lie ahead of us, even if it is currently difficult for all of us to imagine that. But these good decades do not come by themselves. We must re-establish the conditions for them. This will be strenuous. The effort begins with our understanding of the extent and depth of the upheavals we are facing.

That is why this conference is so important. We must thoroughly discuss the future of our democracy right now at this turning point. This necessarily includes engaging intensively with all the questions that concern the internal functioning and thus also the legitimacy – the radiance – of our free democratic order.

First, we can observe a positive development based on the recent election results: The often-predicted irreversible decline of the major parties and, in parallel, the rise of the radicals has, for the time being, been halted, even if the party landscape today looks different than it did decades ago. But we must not consider this development to be irreversible.

So what can and must happen to permanently strengthen the reputation of our political institutions? What can we do to increase voter turnout again, especially in state and local elections? And how can we succeed in transforming the fortunately existing political passion of young citizens, which is expressed in protest movements like "Fridays for Future," into sustainably effective political engagement?

How do we manage to vitalize the democratic parties so that they once again become a stronger transmission belt between societal interests and state policy?

How do we ensure that regardless of income, social, regional, or ethnic background, all citizens in our country can confidently say: "In politics, there are people who deal with the issues that are important to me"?

What must happen for authoritarian and anti-democratic tendencies in our society to find less resonance in the long term? How do we protect our free democracy from the influence of conspiracy myths and systematically spread disinformation? We will discuss exactly this intensively among the G7 countries at the end of the month.

All these are questions to which we, politics and society, must provide answers – especially in light of the immense transformation tasks that lie ahead of us in the coming years and decades.

Behind us lie 250 years in which our prosperity was based on burning coal, oil, and gas. Now we have about 23 years ahead of us in which we must exit fossil fuels – and we will exit. For we have committed to this: By 2045, Germany must be climate-neutral.

Human-caused global warming must be stopped; otherwise, this planet will sink into disasters. This will be the greatest transformation of our industry and economy in at least 100 years.

In addition, there are the challenges of digitalization and demographic change. Russia's invasion of Ukraine does not make any of these challenges less urgent – on the contrary.

Great changes always also mean great conflicts of goals and interests. This cannot be otherwise in an open, pluralistic, and democratic society. Wolfgang Thierse has just described this.

We will only resolve these conflicts with a great deal of pragmatism, with a willingness to cooperate and compromise at all levels of society and the state. That is precisely why I initiated a new "Concerted Action" at the beginning of this month to discuss together with trade unions and employers: How do we deal with rising prices? How can we relieve employees without fueling inflation?

For the same reason, I invited the new "Alliance for Transformation" to the Chancellery for the first time last Tuesday. This alliance will closely accompany the transformation of our country and our industry on the path to climate neutrality and help to balance conflicting interests.

In the program of this conference, I saw: Your debates this weekend will revolve around exactly such conflicting interests.

"Democracy or climate protection?" – with a question mark: That is the title of one of your discussion rounds. "More citizen participation!?" – followed by an exclamation mark and a question mark: This is the title of another session. This is cleverly sharpened. Here, the difficult contradictions and conflicts of goals we are dealing with and must resolve are already highlighted in the title.

That is why I believe that your guiding questions for this conference touch on the core of the tasks that lie ahead of us and for which we must find wise solutions. I am therefore very much looking forward to the answers you will develop together in the next two days here in the Political Club. Wolfgang Thierse and Gesine Schwan, I would be very glad if you could report back to me on your results.

But I want to broaden the focus a bit – not in contradiction to what has been said so far, nor in contradiction to the central themes of this conference, but perhaps as a necessary complement. I believe that we need to expand the framework of our considerations.

My thesis is: The future of our democracy does not depend solely on us. Rather, "our" democracy – understood as "our" democracy here in Germany and Europe – will only succeed and thrive to the extent that democracy also succeeds and thrives worldwide.

In the conditions of the 21st century, this is more true than ever before, as the world faces truly global and common challenges more than ever before. "Our" democracy – in this sense, the democracies worldwide.

Whether it is about tackling the climate crisis, whether it is about shaping globalization wisely, solidarity, and sustainably, whether it is about defeating Covid-19 and preventing new pandemics: In none of these global challenges is it sufficient for us in Germany, Europe, or the classical West to commit to these goals.

If we are truly serious about these goals, then we need like-minded partners. We need new partners. We also need more partners. For with our traditional partners in the so-called West alone, we already do not bring enough weight to the scale demographically and economically.

This also applies to the group of traditional democratic industrialized nations of the G7, namely Germany, France, Great Britain, Italy, Japan, Canada, and the USA. Today, the G7 still represents 45 percent of global economic power, but only ten percent of the world's population.

The share of these states in the world population is shrinking, but the relative economic weight of the West is also declining. By 2050, it is expected that five of the seven largest economies in the world will be countries that we still refer to today as "emerging countries": China, of course, but probably also India or Indonesia, Brazil, or Mexico. Many other countries in Asia, Africa, and Latin America are gaining more and more economic and demographic weight.

Societies around the world have set out on a path. Everywhere in the world, many millions, indeed billions of people are seizing the new opportunities and possibilities that globalization brings them. And of course, the emerging states are therefore also demanding greater political influence.

What is emerging is a truly multipolar world. This development also signifies a global turning point – not a shockingly triggered turning point like Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine, but a long-term upheaval of global relations that therefore has an even more profound effect.

Many citizens in the classic Western democracies are afraid of this process. They feel threatened, they feel a loss of power and control. My impression is that the attractiveness of right-wing populist and racist theories, up to the conspiracy narrative of the so-called "Great Replacement," can also be explained against the backdrop of these fundamental global shifts. Many sense that many things are fundamentally changing. This causes discomfort, indeed also fear, sometimes even anger.

That is why I want to say very clearly here: The rise of the countries of the Global South does not mean a threat. It certainly does not mean a threat if we manage to ensure that the multipolar world will also be a multilateral world; a world in which rules apply that are evident to all and to which everyone adheres; a world in which very different centers of power cooperate reliably and rule-based in their well-understood self-interest to tackle common challenges.

That sounds like a distant vision, but it is by no means as far-fetched as it may sound. The reason for this has a name: democracy. For that is the great commonality that connects us with quite a few emerging countries of the Global South: We are democracies.

To be clear: Most democracies in the world function differently than ours, and in many other democratic societies, one might only smile wearily at our debates on electoral rights and citizen participation – which does not make them wrong. But there, they often have very different, and indeed greater, concerns.

The truth is: Every democracy is unique. Or to put it in the words of Kofi Annan: "There are as many different forms of democracy as there are democratic nations in the world." Not every one of these democracies functions perfectly smoothly, and ours certainly does not either.

The truth is, however: In some states with democratic traditions, there have been troubling shifts towards authoritarianism in recent times, even here in Europe. This is referred to as "democratic backsliding." Such developments are concerning; however, they are not irreversible.

Even the autocrats or dictators of this world like to claim to be the true executors of the will of the people, and this is almost everywhere. It is a surprising number, but only seven states in the world do not claim to be democracies. These are Saudi Arabia, Oman, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Brunei, Afghanistan – and the Vatican.

All other rulers of this world, who do not govern democratically, even in so-called people's republics, invoke their people to legitimize their own rule – and thus involuntarily remind us every time of the principle of democratic popular sovereignty. This is not trivial. For this means that democracy, however perverted the practice may be in the countries, remains the basis of every legitimacy. Exactly this opens up spaces for democratic dissent and opposition, which points to the glaring gap between claim and reality.

"We are the people": This was shouted by millions of democratic revolutionaries in the GDR in the autumn of 1989, and it was precisely this that ultimately shattered the merely claimed democratic rule of the SED. It was this that ultimately brought down the rule of that state party, which had only been able to suppress the uprising of the East Germans on June 17, 1953, 69 years ago today, with brutal violence. Wolfgang Thierse just reported on this again.

So this is good news: Wherever rulers invoke the will of the people, there remains more democracy, better democracy, real democracy, fought for against them, a possibility on the horizon. That is encouraging.

It is also encouraging that all truly democratic states in the world share a very central characteristic. Democracies are those states in which the rulers cannot afford to regularly and systematically ignore the wishes and interests of broad majorities of their citizens.

Abraham Lincoln's famous democracy axiom remains unchanged: "You can fool all the people some of the time and some people all the time. But you can never fool all people all the time."

When rulers in democracies try to do this anyway, the voters will eventually show them the red card.

This is precisely where the decisive advantage of democratically structured societies lies in comparison to authoritarian regimes. The renowned economist Branko Milanovic has convincingly pointed this out, and that is why I would like to quote him:

"Since (democracy) requires an incessant consultation of the population, it also serves as a very effective corrective for economic and social developments that adversely affect the well-being of the people. (...)

Anyone who believes that democracy has no benefit as a mechanism for averting harmful developments must be convinced that the majority of the population will persistently make wrong (or irrational) decisions over a long period of time. That seems unlikely."

In contrast, as Milanovic also notes, authoritarian regimes "tend to produce bad political measures and achieve poor social outcomes that cannot be corrected because the rulers have no incentive for a course correction."

The quote ends here, but one must say: The best example of how correct this thesis is is currently provided by President Putin with his ruinous war against Ukraine, which is also disastrous for Russia itself.

The great global challenges of our century are obvious and existential. They directly affect the lives, well-being, and future of citizens in all countries of this world. And they demand answers – answers that dictators and autocrats will not provide and cannot provide. Only democracies, only the democrats of this world will be able to do so.

That is why I am deeply convinced: The future belongs to democracy. The future belongs to the democracies of this world. The future belongs to the democrats of this world.

But: A democratic future does not come by itself. We must advocate for it. We must work for it practically and with new partners. Yes, we must fight for it to become a reality. That is exactly what I do with great passion.

Already next Sunday, I will be here in this area again for this purpose. Just 50 kilometers south of here, in Elmau, the G7 summit will take place under German presidency. It will address all the major global questions I have already mentioned, from Russia's war to climate protection to the fight against hunger.

It will not only be the heads of government of the G7 countries themselves who will negotiate there. Rather, it was particularly important to me as the host that this time colleagues from some of the most significant emerging democracies of the Global South will also be present.

Therefore, the heads of government of India and Indonesia, as the current and future presidency of the G20, will come to Elmau, along with South Africa and Senegal as the chair of the African Union and Argentina as the presidency of the Latin American and Caribbean states. They represent countries and regions whose cooperation the world needs to solve the global problems of our century. With them, with the representatives and with the societies of many other countries of the Global South, we must work much more intensively together in the future than we have so far. The future of democracy depends on it, the future of "our" democracy.

Thank you very much.