Speech by Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz on the Budget Act 2025 before the German Bundestag on September 11, 2024, in Berlin:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

11 September 2024 · Budget Act 2025 debate before the German Bundestag · Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the German Bundestag on September 11, 2024, presenting the Budget Act 2025 while addressing migration, the AfD's rise, and Germany's economic challenges.
Main themes
Federal budget 2025, AfD and right-wing populism, immigration and migration policy, skilled workers immigration, economic growth and demographic challenges, asylum and refugee protection, irregular migration controls, CDU/CSU criticism, Germany's future
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,586
82nd percentile
Sentences
181
87th percentile
Readability
59
86th percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
2.92
37th percentile
Vocabulary
1.92
4th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 44%40%
  • Geopolitical 20%18%
  • Economic 16%15%
  • Social 16%14%
  • Ceremonial 4%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

181 sentences in 47 paragraphs

Madam President!

Esteemed ladies and gentlemen!

Dear colleagues!

I want to say a few words about the elections that took place in Saxony and Thuringia – because I believe this is relevant here, and it must be clearly stated –: The election results for the AfD, the election results for right-wing populist parties are disheartening, and we in Germany will never get used to it.

The AfD is bad for our country. The AfD will ensure that our country declines if it can implement its policies. The AfD has a view of humanity from yesterday, a view of women from yesterday. And we will do everything we can to ensure that this political formation loses significance in Germany again.

You are married to the past, a past that you stylize, a past that never existed. You are trying to rob our country of the future. That is why this is the great confrontation here in Germany and in many countries in Europe – by the way, also in the USA –: the confrontation over the question of whether we in our countries believe that we have a better future and make policies to achieve it, or whether we believe that we should only be oriented towards the past, thus leading our country into enmity and resentment towards decline. We will prevent that. Not complaining, but acting and tackling: That is the motto.

Our country faces great challenges, and I believe we must, should, and will talk in this debate about these great challenges – great challenges that we are confronted with and that we must overcome.

One of the great questions for the future of our country is "immigration and migration."

I will start with what is part of the history of our country, with the experiences of the last years and decades, and with what is important for the future. The fact that we have had economic growth in the last 20 years, that we have managed in recent years for our country to be economically successful, is due to the fact that many women and men from other countries in Europe and from other countries in the world have contributed, brought their talents here, and ensured that this economy moves forward.

Since there is a discussion about future conditions, I want to make this very clear: There are many countries around us – calculations of this kind are also available for us – that say there will be a significant economic problem. This results from the fact that the working population is decreasing. For some countries, a halving of the number of those who are employed there is predicted within a few decades. And there is one country in Europe that – just like some English-speaking countries – has the opportunity to ensure that we do not economically decline because we find so many who want to contribute. That is why it is right to make exactly that possible, with the Skilled Workers Immigration Act that we have initiated, and also with the Citizenship Act that we have reformed.

We are turning the matter around – just like the USA, Canada, Australia, and other countries that draw growth potential from this – and say: We want people to contribute here, to learn the German language, to adhere to the laws, to earn their living, but then also to have a say. That is the case there, and it is now also possible in this country with the laws we have put forward. Anything else would lead to economic difficulties. There is no country in the world with a shrinking working population that has economic growth. That is the truth we are confronted with.

At the same time, it is part of our identity – especially due to the experiences we carry with us from our history, the tragedy of fascism and National Socialism – that we offer protection to those who are politically persecuted, who are fleeing for their lives, who must save their lives. That is enshrined in our Basic Law, and we do not put that up for debate.

Openness to the world is therefore necessary. But openness to the world does not mean that anyone can come who wants to. We must be able to choose who comes to Germany; I say that here very explicitly. And that also means that we must manage irregular migration, that we reduce the number of those who come to Germany irregularly, and that we return those who cannot stay.

That is why my government has ended the inaction of conservative interior ministers from the CDU/CSU. It has put an end to the grandstanding. It has ensured that action is finally taken – quite different from many decades of Christian Democratic interior ministers who have failed. They cannot do it. That is the truth we are confronted with.

You are the type of politician who believes that with an interview in "Bild am Sonntag" he has already solved the migration issue. That is not how it is in reality, especially when you belong to the group of politicians who, as soon as they leave the editorial offices, forget what they have just proposed because they never intended to care about it. That is false politics.

That is why we have also achieved the greatest turnaround in this matter, the handling of irregular migration in Germany. This government! We sat down in a laborious process, as the numbers increased again, and did not make it easy for ourselves with any proposals. We made careful agreements, and we made far-reaching agreements, for example, that detention is extended for those who somehow evade their deportation, for example, that one can look around in a refugee facility if someone is not in the place where they should be – a long-standing problem that we have solved – for example, that return cannot be prevented by objections, appeals, lawsuits, and new applications. We have done all that. Even the benefits under the Asylum Seekers Benefits Act are now only granted in a reduced manner. That is also part of the things we have done. Unlike you, we have even expanded the number of safe countries of origin. Grandstanding, achieving nothing: it is you who accomplish nothing!

And I say this: We have ensured that this is now happening. The number of those who come to us has decreased because we have, for example, introduced border controls and have now, at the beginning of this week, also decided that we will do this at all borders in Germany for as long as possible. We have been successful with this, and we will continue this successful approach.

By the way, we are doing this even though it is becoming difficult with our neighbors. Some of you are now quite surprised that the neighboring countries are still there, that they say: Oh, we do not like this at all. I believe we must endure this. It is now necessary that we also withstand this dispute; that is part of it.

By the way – also because so many women and men with great hubris are sitting over there – I want to make it clear: The power of the Federal Republic of Germany ends at the border of the Federal Republic of Germany. – In case you have not heard that yet!

By the way – I also want to say this – we have said – I here in this German Bundestag –: We will also carry out deportations of criminals to Afghanistan and Syria again. And we have done it. That was difficult. We were constantly asked: How is that possible, and does it still work? You only said that! We did what one does when acting responsibly, namely, worked carefully. And indeed: We have now organized such a deportation flight to Afghanistan. And I tell you: We will have more and continue this.

Tomorrow we will discuss a security package in the German Bundestag that we have initiated and that is also necessary: with stronger laws regarding the handling of weapons, with tightening of gun laws, with better possibilities to combat Islamist extremism, and explicitly also with more possibilities to act precisely when it comes to irregular migration.

I want to make it clear at this point: Whoever comes to Germany from Italy, from Portugal, from Greece, from Finland and says: "I want to stay here now," cannot submit an application and say: I would like my living expenses to be financed here. That is not connected with the freedom of movement. Good! Because there are 400 million inhabitants in the European Union. If everyone could say: "I will drop by and would like benefits here," that would not work.

And indeed, we are now doing the same with the existing laws by ensuring that they are implemented, and with the new laws that we are now initiating, and saying: If your procedure has been conducted or is being conducted in another country in Europe, then you must receive benefits there and not from us. – A self-evidence that applies to 400 million residents of the European Union and that also applies to those who must conduct their procedures elsewhere! We have decided that.

And now comes the Common European Asylum System. That sounds so abstract. Honestly, I believe many people here in Germany thought: This is something that happens somewhere at the external borders of the European Union. – Greatly mistaken! This also means very far-reaching legal changes for us, for example, with the options for action of the airport procedure, that is, faster and more efficient procedures for those whose procedures have no chance of success. We will implement this very quickly now, and we will not wait until the last moment. These laws are almost finished being written. They will soon reach the German Bundestag, and they will be passed this year. We will use all possibilities to tackle this task.

Well, Mr. Merz, then you offered that we work together. You even offered that I should break up my coalition, that would also be a great thing. I did not do that. But I tell you explicitly: It was good that you made this offer; because the citizens of this country do not want to experience any theater performances here. They want us to make serious and responsible politics. Seriously – I am happy to spell out how the word is written –: That is really the way politics must be made.

The citizens do not want what is happening now, which a newspaper has called a "mud fight," where everyone presents why they are good and the others are bad. That is not the right approach to this issue from my perspective.

That is why I say: It would have been good if we had come to common solutions. And I tell you – even if you may not want to hear it –: We never close a door. You can always come back, despite the bad experiences we have had.

When this offer was already on the table a year ago, when we had united with the countries, when we explained to you what we want to do with the countries, when we told you: "We are also happy to do something beyond that," and I had already told everyone here in this governing majority: "Prepare yourselves! I am determined to reach an agreement and also to do things that may be difficult for some," – and I still remember some of the "enthusiastic" facial expressions – you could not get away fast enough. That is a problem. You have retreated into the bushes – and now again. That is not good for Germany.

You have retreated into the bushes. Two or three weeks ago, you wrote a script in which you laid out that you are making an offer for cooperation. And then, when it is possible, you reject it and say: It is not enough. We cannot handle such a serious matter in this country like that. We want cooperation across party lines.

And I say again, because everyone always likes to make historical comparisons: There are great political leaders in opposition parties, and there have been them repeatedly. For example, the asylum compromise of 1992/1993: The greatest achievement of the opposition leaders of the SPD was that they convinced their party to make a compromise and take steps. It was not the achievement that they made life difficult for the government, but they worked together with the government on a nationally important issue, went to their party conventions, and said: We will do this now; we will implement this now.

Leadership is not about climbing onto a barricade and making demands with a wild gesture. Leadership is about turning around and being able to move your own people towards a compromise. That is leadership, Mr. Merz! And because this matter is so important, I want to say gladly and explicitly: We are still ready. The door is not closed. We would do this with you.

We have now had rejections at the borders due to the border controls we are implementing: 30,000 since we started this, so that no false tales are told here. We will use all possibilities to carry out rejections within the framework of applicable law. And we have put a concept for effective rejections on the table, where we are ready to implement it with the opposition. I say this: We will do it, even if you do not participate. The government will implement and initiate this concept. And we hope that you will still be involved and that you will not leave the door we are keeping open unused. That is the situation. Therefore, one more sentence on the entire topic: A quarter of our German population has an immigration background; that means either they themselves or a parent came from another country. And these people need to know and be able to rely on the fact that even in difficult times, when we have to combat issues like irregular migration with a clear stance and tough policies, there are principles. You can rely on us. We are grateful for their contribution to our society.

We also have other major challenges. One of them is the Russian attack on Ukraine. I say it is very important to emphasize once again at this time: It is Russia that has started this war. It is Russia that is conducting it with brutal intensity unchanged. And it is Russia that simply wants to conquer its neighboring country entirely or partially and is paying a high price for it. Some reports say: 300,000 to 400,000 dead or severely injured Russian soldiers. And that is terrible: Something that will only lead to someone who has political responsibility there, at some point after their death, if they could still read, realizing that they have expanded the country by a few kilometers. Terrible! I say this explicitly.

Therefore, it must be said at this point – even if we know that part of the people who have now voted for right-wing populist and populist parties did so because they do not agree with our support for Ukraine; that should not be downplayed – that it is right for us to support Ukraine as long as it is necessary. And we will do that. Because it is a breach of our peace and security order that Russia is trying to shift borders.

We will do this with our own means. We will do this with what we have agreed upon together with the G7 countries, the economically strong democracies: a 50 billion euro loan for Ukraine, so that it can do what is necessary for the defense of its country.

At the same time, we will do everything to ensure that the possibilities for peace – a fair peace that is not a dictated peace, not a capitulation, that respects the integrity and sovereignty of Ukraine as the attacked country – are always explored. And we have done many, many things to make this possible, with peace conferences that have taken place all over the world: in Denmark, in Saudi Arabia, in Malta, a large peace conference at the Bürgenstock in Switzerland.

I say again: Now is the moment, now is the time when we must explore what possibilities arise. And it is right when the Ukrainian president says – I repeat this again –: We need another peace conference, and it must be such that Russia is at the table. That is the task we must now tackle: to explore what can be done.

It is about the future of our country. There are many uncertainties, especially in the wealthy countries of the world. And debates like the ones we are having here – it is sometimes important to make this clear – are also being held elsewhere. There are surveys on this in the USA, in Canada, in Australia, in Europe, in many countries: Especially in these wealthy countries, future confidence is much lower than, for example, in Asia, in Africa. This must concern us, because of course the question of whether we are fighting for the future or want to return to the past is the decisive political question, as I already said at the beginning. Therefore, we must do everything to modernize our society, to create the possibilities that are necessary for this to actually succeed.

With the decisions of this government, we have done a lot, a lot, a lot to bring about change, for example with more investments in our infrastructure, for instance in our railways, not like the proposal from Mr. Merz that we should reduce train services, but with massive investments in infrastructure so that it actually works better for trains. We will invest billions for ten years, have to renovate entire routes because everything has been neglected for decades. This applies to the roads. This applies to the radio masts, of which we have too few. This applies to the question of the speed of approvals for industrial facilities.

At the same time, we must improve the growth potentials of our country. We are doing this with the growth initiative, which is explicitly aimed at getting everything out that is possible and good for young people, for families in our country, by saying: We want to create better opportunities for young families. We are providing billions to ensure that the expansion of all-day services in schools and daycare centers progresses now. This is a crucial improvement.

We are ensuring that there are more opportunities in vocational training and that young people have perspectives there. We are taking care that those who need to learn a new profession also have the opportunity to do so. And we are explicitly fighting for older people to have a perspective to work as long as they wish. And there are two points that are important.

The first is, when you are in your mid-50s, early 60s: Ask around – it has actually been the case for many decades – whether someone at 55 or 61 years old, when they lose their job, believes they will find a new one again. That is not the case. Ask around how many are hired. Therefore, it is important that we improve these opportunities and perspectives so that everything that we can achieve in our country is realized.

But it is also important that we support those who want to work more. We are doing this with the growth initiative by supporting and saying: If you increase your working hours, companies can pay additional bonuses for that. If someone voluntarily wants to work beyond the retirement age, then they receive support by having their contributions collected from themselves instead of being paid by the employer to the pension insurance, or they receive something from the pension insurance because they retire later.

We are doing all this to mobilize our country, to make growth possible, and to develop a forward-looking realistic perspective. Modernization is necessary: for our society, for its cohesion, and for a good future.

And it should also be said here: The most important asset that many have in our country is their entitlement to retirement benefits: the pension insurance. Therefore, the 17-year-olds who are now leaving school and have to pay contributions for five decades need a clear statement on what they can rely on. That we want to guarantee a stable pension level in Germany is one of the major projects of this government. And it has something to do with confidence that, in such a long life project for each individual, security is created. We guarantee this security for the citizens.

So there are many topics that we need to address – this is necessary – so that we can develop new dynamics, so that we can advance our economy. We must not shy away from the great challenges we are currently facing. Therefore, I find it right that this Bundestag discusses the issue of immigration and migration, including irregular migration and how to limit it. I find it right that we discuss how to guarantee peace and security in Europe and support Ukraine. And I find it necessary that we discuss modernization, growth, and future perspectives, that we do not allow the country to be talked down by those who only want to pull it back into the past and threaten our economic future.

Thank you very much.