Speech by Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz on the Budget Law 2024 before the German Bundestag on January 31, 2024, in Berlin:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

31 January 2024 · Budget Law 2024 debate before the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the German Bundestag on January 31, 2024, during the Budget Law 2024 debate, linking fiscal policy to democracy, far-right threats, and European solidarity.
Main themes
Defense of democracy, far-right extremism and AfD, remigration debate, European unity, German budget 2024, Franco-German cooperation, renewable energy and industrial future, COVID recovery fund, right-wing populism, CDU/CSU criticism
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,189
78th percentile
Sentences
167
84th percentile
Readability
62
90th percentile
Grade
9.3
13th percentile
Syntax
2.89
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.91
3rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 34%31%
  • Institutional 22%19%
  • Ceremonial 16%14%
  • Economic 14%13%
  • Social 14%13%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 11%

167 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, colleagues!

Eva Szepesi has just told us: Those who remain silent are complicit. The memorial event has profoundly impressed us all. But it has also given us a mandate: that we must not remain silent now, when conferences are taking place in country houses in this country, where discussions are held about how a part of the population can be removed from this country, "remigration" as a keyword – this reminds us of the darkest times in German history. And this is not just a word, as some try to trivialize what is being discussed and said by them and planned by their staff. We know that it is now being requested in state parliaments by the AfD.

That is why I am very glad that so many citizens, across all party lines, including those who do not identify politically at all, are coming together on the streets of Germany to demonstrate for democracy, for our Basic Law, and against forgetting.

This is very important to me at this point because time and again, far too often, citizens of our country, nationals, women and men who have lived here for decades, whose children have grown up here, tell me that they are afraid and wonder if they are included, if they now have to leave the country. And therefore, I believe we need a very clear commitment from all of us at this point. We stand before these citizens. They do not need to be afraid. Democracy protects us, as Eva Szepesi said today.

I believe it is also important that we are decent in our dealings with one another. It is also about making it clear what this is about: about far-right views that we cannot accept. Therefore, I find it always – always, Mr. Merz – a little disingenuous when, in this situation, the blame is pointed at the other side regarding responsibility. We must stand together as democrats.

And it does not do justice to the great challenge we face when right-wing populism in the USA receives so much support, when, as we have seen, it has plunged the UK into economic misfortune with Brexit, and when, as we can see very clearly, so many governments in Europe, supported by right-wing populists, are sometimes involved. We have a task in Germany before our history. We want to show as democrats that we will stop this trend, and we will do so together.

Everything has been said. I think that is part of the truth. Everything has been said. One should take everyone literally, including the AfD. They mean what is attributed to them, and it is indeed terrible. And I believe that is really the truth we must confront. Suddenly, a word like "Dexit" comes up. That would be the greatest destruction of wealth that could happen to Europe and Germany. Our country has benefited like no other from the European Union and the cooperation there.

Therefore, Mr. Merz, I can assure you: Emmanuel Macron and I have agreed to discuss very, very carefully how we will respond to the possible political developments in the world that are coming our way. It must be clear to everyone: If the world becomes even more difficult, for example, due to an election result that is possible in the USA, then the European Union must become even stronger. France and Germany must take on this task to make it actually possible.

Of course, it is important that we always keep in mind that Europe is the strongest national interest we have. That has many, many consequences. But among them is also that it is sometimes not good to have not followed politics carefully for a while, and when examples of where something was still happening are very, very far back.

But I believe that it was indeed a good collaboration that I had with Ms. Merkel when we, together with the French government, ensured that it became possible to respond to the Corona crisis with a European recovery fund. The last major European initiative is not long ago. Only your involvement in these political events is long ago. I believe one must also be proud of what one's own chancellor has achieved. What we did there was right. Mr. Merz, do not forget it! Do not gloss over it! It was a CDU chancellor with whom we succeeded together.

By the way, we are in the process of addressing everything that has been left behind in this country, and there is a lot that has been left behind. For many years, for very, very many years, the crucial decisions have not been made so that Germany can have an industrial future. Therefore, Mr. Merz, your question was justified: What does this speech of yours have to do with the current budget and the current situation? Nothing! You are right. But the question must be expanded: What does your political program have to do with the future of Germany? Nothing! That is the answer we must give.

After you have really fought underground and intensely to ensure that there is no expansion of networks in Germany, after you, as CDU/CSU, are responsible for the fact that the expansion of renewable energies has not progressed, after you have achieved nothing for the establishment of a hydrogen industry and infrastructure for Germany, after you have not managed to ensure that investments in the steel industry, in the semiconductor industry, in battery factories in Germany take place, all these things are now happening. Two years of the traffic light coalition have made progress where progress was necessary.

If we have listened carefully to what you have said, then we know now: You have learned nothing at all. All the growth brakes you have applied to Germany, you want to apply again. You announced that here. How can one want to gamble away the future of Germany as you do? Zero economic expertise! That is the truth. No perspective for Germany, no industrial perspective, no perspective for jobs!

I would like to add. You are talking past all that is necessary for this to work and also past what is actually to be reported about Germany. This reality indeed includes that we are struggling with global growth weakness, that we are struggling with the growth brakes of the past that we have resolved, but we can also note: Germany has the highest employment level in our history that we have ever recorded. Never have so many employees been employed.

If companies in this country fear anything, it is not, as it was 20 years ago, unemployment, but rather a shortage of skilled workers. That is the challenge of the future, and this government has set the course so that we can do something about it: with the Skilled Workers Immigration Act and with the new citizenship law. All of this is a perspective for the future of Germany.

That is why we have ensured that work in Germany is finally worthwhile again: with a minimum wage that you continually fight against. Because: When you talk about work needing to be worthwhile, you never include the 10, 20, 30, 40 percent of our working population who earn far too little. We need better wages. The minimum wage was exactly the way to put that on a good course.

The same applies to the question of the income situation of those who earn little. We have done this with measures that provide relief for those who earn a little less than 2,000 euros: with social security contributions, with housing benefits for workers and for pensioners, with the increase in child benefits and the child supplement – all measures that improve the income of workers who unfortunately have too low wages. We are proud of this joint achievement.

We have – this is also part of it – repeatedly lowered taxes for employees, for self-employed individuals who do not have large incomes. We have lowered taxes and relieved the working middle class of this country. I tell you here: We will continue to pursue this course.

However, it is against the future perspective of employees, of all those who strive every day, when they are then told: The most important thing we want to do in Germany – despite the stable pension finances that we can currently record – is to raise the retirement age, supplemented by nice, loud speeches about the "leisure park Germany" that we supposedly have today with the large number of employed people. I find this insecurity of the life perspective of employees that you spread is not right. And I find it an insult to hardworking citizens when one says they live in a leisure park. That is not right.

What is the paternalistic insult to employees who have to organize their everyday lives with the words: "Everyone must work more"? They work quite a lot. I believe such admonitions are not deserved by the diligent people of this country, not even from the opposition leader.

Of course, it is important that we face the challenges we have. One of them is – as has been mentioned – irregular migration. We have made many, very far-reaching decisions, by the way, in the greatest agreement with the 16 states. We met with them three times last year and worked through all the questions and made three joint resolutions on issues such as a final financing mechanism for rising and falling numbers. We have agreed on very concrete measures that the federal government must implement, and it has delivered all of them with the laws we passed in January and put them on the way.

We are working to ensure that the states can also advance the things they have taken on: shorter asylum procedures, faster digitization of foreign authorities, and so on. But if it is the case that, entirely without your involvement, the states agree with the federal government that we will introduce a payment card for asylum seekers, if the tender is now running and the opposition leader apparently does not even read the newspaper and can report that this is the case and is already on the way, then something is not right in the land of the opposition. Clearly, you not only read little newspaper, but also do not talk to the CDU prime ministers. They could have told you that over a beer. That would have been a good thing.

By the way: With the intensified protection of our external borders, with the measures we have initiated, the numbers regarding irregular migration are now also decreasing. The measures I just talked about have only just been decided and are currently being implemented; they will come in addition to what will have an effect in reality in the near future.

This also includes, in my view, the job turbo, with which we ensure that Ukrainian refugees, after they have completed all the language courses, are now also actively placed in the labor market – with growing success. I believe it is also not a contribution to solidarity with Ukraine when the opposition leader tells the Ukrainians seeking protection here: That we have accommodated them was probably a mistake. – You did that, Mr. Merz. You did that.

But I would like to add a sentence. I have tried to establish a Germany pact on the one major issue – I will come back to that shortly – "Speed, speed in Germany" and to get you to participate, which you somehow did not manage to do properly. But it is true that you then briefly focused on a subtopic: migration. We also had good discussions about that; at least I do not remember a bad one. We had one that was very careful. And in that conversation, I explained to you that there is already a kind of understanding with the heads of the Senate and State Chancellery on many questions that are very important, and that we will probably agree on that with the prime ministers the following Monday – we met on Friday. You had no objections because we said: Beyond that, we can still do something.

And what does the astonished public experience? Hardly has this agreement with the state premiers been decided, the opposition leader declares: "Well, that seems to be it for cooperation on migration." Such cowardice, with which you run away from your own responsibility, I have never experienced, Mr. Merz. I have never seen such cowardice in the face of one's own courage. I am still puzzling over why you ran away. I believe it was because you did not want to let go of the nice topic. We could have delivered everything, everything could have been done properly, so that we could get a grip on irregular migration and its management together with the states and municipalities in Germany, but then you could no longer say: "Everything is going wrong." That is why you ran away. That is the reason why you are no longer available for a compromise.

You are quite special in this regard: You attack the federal government every day – that is your right – often below the belt – that is also your right – but when you are criticized, you become a sensitive flower. I think: Those who box should not have a glass jaw. But you have quite a glass jaw, Mr. Merz.

We have a great challenge in light of the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine. This will also play a major role this evening in Brussels, after the memorial services for Jacques Delors, and tomorrow. We must support Ukraine in its fight for freedom, which is indeed what it is about. And it is necessary that we do not let up in our support for Ukraine. This is our obligation for peace in Europe and for security in Europe.

By the way, it is astonishing what the Ukrainians have achieved. Let us not forget how much of their territory has already been conquered by Russia and how much they have also recaptured. Let us not forget with what perseverance they have resisted the incredible onslaught of Russian troops, in which the Russian president does not shy away from the loss of his own soldiers – in numbers that are hardly expressible – and in which he does not hesitate to use material and let everything be destroyed in order to actually achieve his goal, namely to conquer part or all of Ukraine. He has called into question what Willy Brandt and Helmut Schmidt initiated with the CSCE, the current OSCE, with the peace and security order in Europe, whose principle states: Borders in Europe must not be changed by force. That must be our principle.

It has spread all over the world – soon also in Germany –: We are the second largest supporter of Ukraine after the USA, also in terms of military support with weapons. And we are it with the budget that we are discussing here, and the plans for this year. According to everything we can know, Germany is providing more than half of what will be contributed in Europe this year for Ukraine's resistance. And that is why I want to emphasize here: It is very important to me that we achieve broader European support. It cannot depend solely on Germany. To quote Helmut Schmidt again: "We are only a middle power." If we were the ones who had to do the majority of the work, it would not be enough for Ukraine. We want more countries to actively participate in supporting Ukraine, also with arms deliveries, also with what they finance there. I say this deliberately not to put others on the spot.

That is why we have not done that; we have not publicly addressed individuals. Because we want the opposite. We want everyone to say: Okay, we will make another effort. I hope that will also be the result of the discussions we are starting today and tomorrow, but certainly will not conclude on this issue. I just want to assure you here: We will make our significant contribution for this year, and we will do everything to ensure that Europe's collective contribution is so large that Ukraine can rely on it, and that Putin cannot expect that our support will wane at some point. He must not think that.

Yes, it is true: He hopes for the American presidential elections, he hopes for fatigue in Europe. We know how difficult that is when we look at the USA: The American president has still not succeeded in obtaining approval in Congress for the budgetary funds he needs for support for Ukraine this year. I am quite confident that he will succeed. And we will all do our part to help convince that it is a common cause for us, the friends of freedom, democracy, and the rule of law, to not leave Ukraine alone. But just imagine for a moment, if that does not succeed. Then Germany – as of now – would be the largest supporter of Ukraine in terms of arms deliveries worldwide. Dear friends, that is something for which we must do everything internationally to ensure that this situation does not occur. Because it would be hubris if we believed that we could manage it alone. That is not the case. We need unity and solidarity.

By the way, this also applies to the other decisions that are now necessary in Europe. We want to finally decide on the European budget now. It includes a budgetary aid for Ukraine of twelve billion euros per year for the coming years. So it is about a lot of support that is necessary. It is about Europe standing together in these times.

Finally, I want to say regarding our common Europe: Yes, we need a joint effort for Europe to move forward. Perhaps surprisingly for some, I said at an SPD party conference: We absolutely need the banking and capital market union for that to progress. Therefore, we must develop another initiative from what we have already achieved. The minimum taxation that we have established in Europe could also serve as the benchmark for a uniform, common corporate tax base, so that banks can compete under fair conditions across Europe. That would be a real step forward for Europe.

We urgently need it; because indeed, part of the better economic growth in the USA is attributable to their banks and capital markets, which are more capable of supporting economic growth without public subsidies and investing heavily in start-ups and growing companies, sometimes in those that do not make profits for years despite billion-dollar valuations. That is something that does not occur in the same way in Europe. Therefore, it is our common task to eliminate this obstacle to growth and prosperity in Europe. The fact that this year must be so much about Europe is perhaps an opportunity to work on this and on all other necessary reforms for a strong, sovereign Europe in a globalized world.

Thank you very much.