Speech by Chancellor Scholz on the occasion of the Media Policy Hour of the 46th Congress of German Local Newspapers on June 1, 2022, in Berlin.

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

1 June 2022 · Media Policy Hour of the 46th Congress of German Local Newspapers · Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the 46th Congress of German Local Newspapers in Berlin on June 1, 2022, speaking at the Media Policy Hour about press freedom and local journalism.
Main themes
Freedom of the press, local journalism, Russian disinformation and propaganda, democracy and free media, Ukraine war context, media diversity, challenges facing local newspapers, public funding for press, digital competition and social media, press freedom under threat
Duration
~11 min
37th percentile
Words
1,262
37th percentile
Sentences
71
47th percentile
Readability
36
27th percentile
Grade
12.7
53rd percentile
Syntax
2.88
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 47%46%
  • Economic 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 17%17%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

71 sentences in 22 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

Under the title "Putin Show," the British news magazine "The Economist" recently published a particularly exciting interactive piece, but also a very distressing one. It vividly illustrates what a typical media day looks like for an ordinary Russian citizen today, from reading the morning newspaper to social media channels and radio programs throughout the day, culminating in the evening talk shows on television. From morning to night, a complete parallel world is presented across all media channels, self-contained and airtight against reality. In this parallel world, everything revolves exclusively around alleged Ukrainian Nazis, supposed misdeeds of the West, and the purportedly heroic resistance of Russia against the forces of evil.

This interpretation is overwhelmingly effective. Yes, it is total. Because the vast majority of citizens in Russia inform themselves exclusively through state-affiliated channels. This majority in Russia has no possibility, due to censorship, to experience a version of reality that deviates even slightly from the official line of the Kremlin under Putin. Of course, this constant loop across all channels is pure disinformation. We know that. Some Russians see through it. But for the broad majority of citizens in Russia, there is only this one version of current events. They know no other, and because habit easily becomes certainty, they often do not want to hear or see any other reality.

As bitter as it is: disinformation works. Where disinformation is total, where no alternative information is perceived or can be perceived, the unspeakable becomes sayable, and eventually, horrific crimes become possible. This is evidenced by Russia's brutal war of aggression and annihilation against Ukraine.

Ladies and gentlemen, as the voice of local newspapers and media houses in Germany, your association has been advocating for the concerns of your industry for 55 years now. These concerns are more important than ever for our free democracy. I wanted to make this clear with my introductory look at Russia, and I am all the more grateful for the opportunity to speak with you today.

I want to emphasize explicitly: a free and independent press is fundamentally system-relevant for a functioning democracy. It is therefore under the special protection of our constitution.

At the same time, a free press and free journalism counteract precisely those anti-democratic and anti-freedom developments that have occurred in such a shocking manner in Russia. That is why journalists are repeatedly targeted by the enemies of freedom and democracy, including here with us. Think of the attacks on journalists at anti-lockdown protests or the defamation of independent reporting as "lying press." This is unacceptable, and our state will not tolerate it.

In fact, the free press is a crucial reason for the strength and attractiveness of our societal model, now more than ever. That is why it is good that you exist. Thank you very much for your work!

Ladies and gentlemen, a particularly important component of media diversity is local journalism. Germans usually consume local news via radio or read it in daily newspapers. Local media, in particular, manage to reach citizens and motivate them to engage in their communities, who otherwise might have stayed out. This is also a lifeblood for our democracy.

However, I also know that your lived reality, the everyday reality of local press, does not always correspond to this ideal image of democracy. Business areas are migrating to the internet. Moreover, there is healthy competition between public broadcasters and your newspapers. With the rise of social media, the boundaries between reporting, advertising, influencers, and fake news often blur.

Regarding the refinancing of your press products, the newspaper industry faces growing challenges. Energy, personnel, and raw material prices are rising. Paper, in particular, has become rapidly more expensive. The high costs force editorial offices to focus more on national content that they can offer to many other newspapers. This narrows the scope for purely local reporting on the ground.

Ladies and gentlemen, we are closely monitoring these developments. We recognize the value of your work for our community. That is why we will advocate for the protection of local journalism, especially local newspapers, and improve the framework conditions for your work. We want to ensure that comprehensive access to regularly published press remains guaranteed; this has been agreed upon by the federal government. The Federal Ministry of Economics is currently examining which funding opportunities are suitable for this purpose.

Local journalism will also be the central theme of the next media and communications report of the federal government next year. As early as the beginning of 2022, State Minister Roth, as the Federal Government's Commissioner for Culture and Media, commissioned a study on the situation of the German local press. This study is intended to provide comprehensive insights into the situation, which you are, of course, already familiar with. An important aspect will be the question of how much the described developments endanger press and opinion diversity and whether a need for state funding can be justified.

In addition, the federal government intends to propose a legal basis for the press's right to information from federal authorities, thereby strengthening the press. We have also agreed on this. I look forward to the inquiries.

The already established ancillary copyright for press publishers is intended to help maintain journalistic quality and the diversity of free, independent media.

We will improve the protection of journalists by supporting European-wide measures against the restriction of freedoms through abusive SLAPP lawsuits.

And last but not least, the federal government has set up a new funding program aimed at strengthening the conditions for journalistic work and contributing to the protection of independent journalism. This will support projects with a radiating effect and exemplary character that convey the value of quality journalism for democracy.

So you see: the federal government has set itself several goals to strengthen free, independent journalism in our country.

But we certainly agree on the insight that the federal government – or "politics" in general – is not capable of compensating for the major structural changes affecting your entrepreneurial sector. The significant upheavals of digitalization, demographic change, or altered reading habits of your customers – all of these are circumstances that publishing companies must primarily adapt to with appropriate business decisions.

I am convinced that, amidst all the developments of globalization and digitalization, and perhaps especially in light of these developments: there is a longing among citizens for home, a longing for orientation, for meaning and cohesion in their local communities. This means that the raw material for the business model of local and regional newspapers still exists in the 21st century. The challenge lies in organizing the digital transformation of local daily newspapers in such a way that it ultimately results in black numbers, meaning that journalistic content continues to generate revenue in the future.

I am confident: the digital transformation itself offers opportunities. You all know today, for example, much more precisely than in the analog era who your readers are, which texts they read, and which content interests them. That is why I am optimistic that local newspapers can also be successful in the digital future if they manage to select the right interesting information for their readers.

Ladies and gentlemen, we agree on the goal of preserving press freedom and press diversity under changing conditions. From the very practical side of the digital transformation of local media, you understand much more than I do. That is why it is important for me to stay in conversation with you, and that is why I look forward to our discussion today. Thank you very much!