Appearance of the President of the Government on the progress of the de-escalation.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

14 June 2020 · Press conference on the progress of the de-escalation

Context
Sánchez addressed a press conference on June 14, 2020, to report on Spain's de-escalation from COVID-19 lockdown and outline plans for national recovery.
Main themes
COVID-19 de-escalation progress, pandemic threat and second wave risk, economic and social recovery, parliamentary evaluation commission, gender violence, healthcare system lessons, digital divide, public services resilience
Duration
~93 min
98th percentile
Words
11,169
98th percentile
Sentences
463
98th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
12.8
54th percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 27%26%
  • Institutional 23%23%
  • Economic 22%21%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

463 sentences in 102 paragraphs

Good afternoon, first of all, welcome to the media who are joining us for this appearance and this press conference, and as is customary, I will make an introduction and then I will take questions from my colleagues in the media.

First, I would like to express the solidarity of the entire Government and my own with the families of the three fatalities recorded today in Úbeda, in Jaén, in what seems to be another case, unfortunately, of gender violence. We are talking about María Belén, 46 years old, and her two children, aged 12 and 17. The Government, like the whole of Spanish society, deeply feels the loss of these three lives. I recognize that the best way to pay tribute to the victims is to continue fighting vigorously, as all institutions are doing, so that there are no more victims. We must continue to defend the lives of so many women who deserve to be happy and free. Likewise, we will continue to work to ensure that there are no more destroyed childhoods. Minors also have the right to a life of dignity and free from violence.

In recent days, we have regained a good part of normality in our lives. After these very hard, dramatic, and difficult months we have gone through, we needed to walk through our cities and towns again; we needed to pass through the doors of shops and bars; we needed to look each other in the face again with our friends, with our coworkers, with our family. We needed to return to exercising and also to get excited about sports competitions as we have seen in recent days. But this relief that we so desperately needed cannot make us forget two very important things that I would like to emphasize: The first is the threat, the threat that has not disappeared from a virus that continues to lurk. This is the first of the issues I would like to share with all of you. And the second is that now we must return to fully restarting the country, the reconstruction and economic and social recovery of Spain. The threat of the pandemic, as you know, is still present. The pandemic is not over. Just look at what is happening today in North America and South America to see that.

One single piece of data allows us to understand the magnitude of the challenge that we still have as humanity to address together: on March 13, when I announced the State of Alarm, 10,000 new daily cases of infection and 500 daily deaths were reported worldwide. 10,000 and 500 daily deaths. Yesterday, the number of new cases reported worldwide was 150,000; 10,000 - 145,000. And the number of deaths also rose to 5,000 daily. That is to say, the pandemic is 15 times more ferocious in the world than it was three months ago; the fatalities yesterday were 10 times more than on March 13, when we declared the state of alarm in our country.

It is true that we have managed, together and with a lot of effort, to bend the curve of infections and we have managed to corner the virus in our country and also in the European continent, and the epicenter has shifted to much more distant latitudes. But the risk has not disappeared. A second wave, all experts tell us, is possible; it is a real risk and we must avoid it at all costs because it would lead us to a wall. And it depends on each one of us to avoid it.

Certainly, we must prepare better for that risk in the near future and also in the more distant future. And precisely for that reason, we must learn from this shock, in case the world suffers a new calamity of this nature.

We must draw all the lessons from what has worked best and also, logically, those issues that have worked worst. Evaluate the deficiencies of our healthcare system, the fragilities of our elderly care system, our industrial capacity to provide ourselves with equipment and also with care and protection. We must evaluate the strengths of our telecommunications systems, energy, food supply; the great potential of our law enforcement agencies, of the armed forces, in short, of all public servants who have been at the forefront and on the front lines during these long weeks.

And we must also evaluate the fragilities we carry in teleworking, in non-presential education, the problem of the digital divide that has left behind those who do not have access to the internet, not only from the point of view of income resources but also from the territorial point of view.

All of this will be addressed by a Parliamentary Commission that I proposed this week in the Congress of Deputies, a Parliamentary Evaluation Commission that we will promote immediately when the state of alarm is lifted on June 21. In short, what we have to do is learn from the emergency to prepare better. That must be the guiding principle for all parliamentary forces that will participate in that Parliamentary Evaluation Commission of the COVID crisis.

But in addition to examining what has happened, we have a second fundamental task ahead of us: to fully restart the country and the social and economic reconstruction and recovery of our country.

This is precisely what I want to talk to you about today to focus on three very relevant aspects that I addressed in this already fourteenth Conference of regional presidents that we held this morning:

First, education and the return to classrooms in September.

Second, the relaunch of industry and the need for a specific plan for the automotive sector and also for the tourism sector. And third, the opening of borders and consequently linking it to the support plan for tourism that I previously mentioned.

In the field of education, these months of crisis and halted life have been particularly hard for the youngest, for the children who have seen their lives, their social and emotional environment, and their relationship with the outside world come to a standstill. They have had the refuge of their families, but they have lost connection with their peers and their ordinary bond with their teachers. This forced halt of in-person education has highlighted two shortcomings that I would like to share with all of you:

First, the digital divide: many families lack the devices or the connection or the knowledge to transfer learning from the classroom to the home. And second, family reconciliation, family co-responsibility, how to balance the work of parents with the care of children.

We must address these shortcomings in that Parliamentary Evaluation Commission I mentioned earlier, which must propose far-reaching measures for the future. But we also need to organize and prepare for that necessary and essential return to classrooms, in coordination with the Autonomous Communities, which, as you all know, have the competencies, as is also the case with Health, in the management of Education.

The Ministries of Health and Education and Vocational Training have been working hand in hand over the past few weeks and have developed a framework document that was presented last week, well, this week that we are finishing, and discussed with the education counselors of the various regional governments, and whose sole purpose is to establish what corresponds to the Government of Spain, which are recommendations to the competent educational authorities, which are the Autonomous Communities. Classes will resume in September and thanks to these recommendations, to this joint work being done by the Ministry of Health, the Ministry of Education and Vocational Training, along with the Autonomous Communities, that return in September will be in a safe and healthy environment.

The defined measures aim to reduce the risks of contagion: reinforcing, for example, health education; limiting contacts; promoting personal hygiene and ventilating spaces. At the same time, measures are recommended to manage any cases of contagion that may occur in schools.

Each educational center, starting in September, will have to open with a Start of Course Plan and a Contingency Plan that will detail the actions and necessary mechanisms for any type of incident. It is expected that there will be a reference person in each center for aspects related to COVID-19 and a team made up of different representatives of the educational community to ensure information and compliance with the principles.

In Early Childhood Education and up to 4th grade of Primary Education included, it has been determined that stable groups of students should be established, preferably of 15 students, although they could reach up to 20 students. These are recommendations that we have proposed to all Autonomous Communities.

For the rest of the courses, spaces will be reorganized so that there is a distance of one and a half meters between students. The mask will be mandatory starting from 5th grade of Primary Education and also in the four previous grades when students are not with their stable coexistence group. In Early Childhood Education, wearing a mask will not be mandatory. Additionally, the use of outdoor spaces for educational and leisure activities will be prioritized.

You should also know that there is a set protocol for managing possible cases that present symptoms compatible with COVID. Public Health will be responsible for identifying and following up on contacts according to the current surveillance and control protocol of the corresponding Autonomous Community. And from the Government, from the Government of Spain, we consider it absolutely a priority to guarantee the return to classrooms for all students. The abrupt interruption of the school year was already a severe blow for our students, also for families. And this damage is not expressed in economic figures or business figures, but it is a wound that affects generations of boys and girls that we cannot allow to deepen.

We are, in any case, aware of the difficulty of adapting centers to this new situation, as is also the case in workplaces, recreational areas, or commerce. But, as I have requested from the regional presidents, it is essential to work on this for the benefit of all citizens, and above all, of the children, the minors, who deserve to return, with all guarantees, to the school year starting in September.

The Government of Spain is doing its part. Not only by developing these recommendations for all Autonomous Communities. Also, and I do not want to forget, the educational community, the teachers, the parents, and also, logically, the students.

And in another area, the Government, as you know, announced, well, we are going to approve it in the coming days, a non-repayable fund of 16 billion euros for the Autonomous Communities. And from this injection of resources, as you know, 9 billion euros must be allocated to health, but 2 billion euros, this is what I wanted to highlight, will be directed precisely to education. Because in September, when children return to school, both public health and education must be strengthened, revitalized, and reorganized. These protections and guarantees of health and freedom are absolutely essential. Without them, a true reconstruction and recovery in our country will not be possible.

Secondly, regarding the automotive sector, there have been various regional presidents who, throughout these weeks, also in the direct dialogue we have had with the automotive sector, workers, and companies, through the Ministry of Industry, Trade, and Tourism, we have been developing this plan to defend the automotive sector at this critical moment they have gone through as a result of the halt and the drop in demand.

It is unnecessary to explain the importance of the automotive industry for Spain. It represents up to one-tenth of our Gross Domestic Product and almost one-fifth of our exports. It employs 650,000 people directly and almost two million jobs in total are linked to the sector either directly or indirectly. And it is also unnecessary to explain at this point the importance of the ecological transition of our economy at a time when the climate emergency is one of the main problems and challenges facing humanity as a whole.

The Government has worked hand in hand with the sector to anticipate a comprehensive plan that responds to its needs and also serves to carry out an urgent ecological transition that must also take place in the field of mobility. A plan aimed at supporting the sector in the transition to sustainable and connected mobility, directed at the entire industrial value chain, to help it adapt and maintain competitiveness. And coherent, logically, with our international commitments to combat, adapt to, and mitigate climate change. We want to promote stability and momentum in the automotive sector. And the vehicles of the future will resemble very little those of the past in terms of their impact on the environment. I can inform you that this plan includes measures to prepare the industry in:

First, investments and legal reforms;

Second, with a stimulus for research and innovation;

Third, with taxation that provides greater competitiveness;

And finally, with training and professional qualification to provide human resources to the industry.

We will announce it, I inform you, we will announce this Automotive Plan tomorrow, Monday, in a meeting I will have at the Palacio de la Moncloa with all the representatives of the sector. And I announce that this plan will be backed by a budget of 3.75 billion euros.

There will be funding for the renewal of the vehicle fleet, especially incentivizing electric vehicles and providing special aid to low-income families so that no one is left behind in this process. Entrepreneurs, self-employed workers will also benefit through the savings in fuel that the renewal of their fleet will entail. And this boost to the industry is not intended to take us back to past times. On the contrary, it will facilitate the renewal of the vehicle fleet to make it more efficient and more in line with the energy transition objectives we have set, and the objectives are very ambitious: to reach zero emissions by 2050, in line with the tenets of our Energy and Climate Plan, with the law we have sent to the Congress of Deputies, and logically also with the Green Deal at the European level that many countries, including ours, are promoting. In summary, we are working so that in the future we have better vehicles, more sustainable cities, cleaner environments, and higher quality jobs with a much more competitive sector. These objectives are at the horizon of all our actions, and logically in that public-private collaboration, I believe we can promote their achievement.

Thirdly, I would like to talk to you about the Tourism Plan, which is a sector that has logically been damaged as a result of border closures, lockdowns, and mobility restrictions, and to comment on the announcements I have made to the regional presidents regarding the opening of our borders.

If the automotive sector is a strategic sector for our country, as I said before, tourism is no less so, having been one of the most affected by the health emergency due to the inevitable mobility restrictions that have saved so many lives. Tourism, to give you some figures, accounts for more than 12% of Spain's GDP and employment. It is a fact that any crisis in tourism has serious consequences for the Spanish economy and for the families in our country who are dedicated to this sector. But tourism is also a key sector for the recovery of our economy. It was during the 2008 crisis. And it will be again now. And as in the automotive sector, overcoming this crisis cannot take us back to the previous point. We must take advantage of it to transform our great strengths in our tourism offer to promote urban renewal and make it more sustainable from an environmental point of view. With that objective, the Government will present next Thursday a Tourism Boost Plan, designed together with the representatives of the sector and with the coordination of the Autonomous Communities.

The recovery of tourism activity will be a priority for the Government of Spain. We will ensure that the development of tourism contributes to strengthening territories at risk of depopulation. We will improve employment conditions, reducing precariousness and the gender gap. And we will promote with these plans the coexistence between the tourist population and the local population with the utmost health safety. Spain is not just any country when it comes to tourism. Neither in quantity nor in quality. We are the second country in the world by number of visitors and by tourist spending. And we have led the Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Index prepared by the World Economic Forum for the past five years. I have no doubt that with the joint effort of companies, public institutions, and at the forefront the Government of Spain, we will consolidate this leadership. And for that, we need to count on the reopening of our borders, which is imminent. And thanks to the joint initiative of the Governments of Italy and Spain, as you know, the European Commission has established a staggered reopening order. First, internal borders will be opened, and then entries from third countries will be allowed. Several countries have already partially lifted their internal border controls. And the Commission has recommended that other countries do so starting tomorrow, from June 15. It has also recommended extending the restriction on non-essential travel from third countries until the end of the month. That is, until June 30. During that time, a list of safe countries will be prepared with which restrictions can be lifted starting, as I said before, from July 1. I would like to point out that on a day like today, June 14, 35 years ago, the Schengen Agreement was signed, which paved the way for the elimination of border controls and marked the future of European integration. I can think of no better way to commemorate this anniversary, precisely today, another June 14: with the announcement of the restoration of one of the fundamental freedoms that define the European ideal.

Therefore, in line with the criteria of the Union, with the requests from the tourism sector of the Autonomous Communities, and with the fortunately good evolution of the health emergency, I can announce the following: that Spain will lift border controls with the Member States next Sunday, June 21, coinciding precisely with the end of the State of Alarm. From then on, the obligation of quarantine for travelers entering our country will disappear. Consultations have been held with neighboring Member States, taking into account the necessary bilateralism of the measures to be adopted, which we are adopting.

As a result of these consultations, controls at the land internal borders with Portugal will remain in place until June 30, as they have requested us. However, given the close relationship we have with our dear Portuguese friend and neighbor, we have agreed to hold a very special, very emotional reopening event between the two countries on July 1, which will be attended by the Head of State, His Majesty the King, my presence as well, and logically the Portuguese Prime Minister and the President of the Portuguese Republic. That will be on July 1 in an event we will hold in a Spanish city and in a Portuguese city.

For this weekend, or rather for the upcoming week, we have already launched a pilot project that will involve the arrival of 10,900 German tourists to the Balearic Islands. An initiative with which we will verify all the safety measures that we will apply this tourist season.

And I insist, this is a pilot project that will serve us well to learn in the coming months. We want our country, which is already recognized as a quality tourist destination, there are the figures, to also be recognized as a safe tourist destination. Safe in the streets and safe in health. Subsequently, starting from July 1, borders with third countries outside Schengen will be gradually opened. Not all, of course, but those included in a list when they meet three requirements.

First, their epidemiological situation must be similar to or better than that of the European Union.

Second, they must assume certain health conditions at origin, during transit, and at the destination.

And finally, they must act reciprocally. That is, they must also accept the entry of travelers from the European Union. In summary, on June 21, borders will open except with Portugal, which will be on July 1. Borders with Schengen countries will open, starting from July 1 with Portugal and with those third countries with which we reach a border reopening agreement. They will be opened safely and gradually, as I said, on June 21, July 1. We want tourism and health safety to go hand in hand. Tourism, yes; exchange, yes; opening, yes. Safety and health, too.

On more than one occasion, I have insisted that we should not choose between health and business, between health and the economy, because if health is sacrificed, business and the economy also suffer, as we have seen during these very difficult weeks we have gone through.

Beyond these specific sectors, to which I have previously referred, which are tourism, automotive, and logically the return to school of our sons and daughters starting in September, the task of reconstruction must encompass all fields and must be sustained in the maximum degree of possible unity.

Unity with unions and employers at the Employment Table; unity between the Government and the conferences of regional presidents, and it is the proposal I have made to the regional presidents, to hold a monographic and in-person Conference at the end of July, after the elections in the Basque Country and Galicia; and also unity among the political parties that make up the Parliamentary Commission for Reconstruction that is advancing in its work and in its recommendations to the Government of Spain.

What sense does it make today to talk about Reconstruction, about Social and Economic Recovery? It has a social dimension, of course, because it means recovering the confidence of consumers, businesses, and workers. But it also has a resounding economic significance. It means recovering economic activity; it means recovering employment. In short, Reconstruction equates to the recovery of the security that our economy and our society are getting back on their feet and resuming their march with strength.

Reconstruction, recovery, will be faster with unity; this is what I have always defended: it will be more effective with unity. Just as it will happen in the European space. As you know, the European Commission has presented a proposal to establish a European Recovery and Reconstruction Fund that has been named Next Generation EU.

The final amount of the Commission's proposal amounts to 750 billion euros: 500 billion in direct transfers and 250 billion, as you know, in loans. They are intended to reactivate the most affected economies and to provide support to workers, the self-employed, SMEs, health systems, and the most hard-hit sectors such as tourism and culture. This proposal has very broad support, but it is not yet approved. And it faces reluctance, as you know, in some countries that resist accepting this advance, which in my opinion is essential, is decisive for the recovery of the most affected countries but which actually benefits all of Europe.

Therefore, I would like to publicly ask all Spanish parties to actively support the European Commission's Proposal within their respective political families, so that it can be approved at the European Council and can be implemented as soon as possible. Besides being fair, it is crucial for our recovery.

If Spain wins, we all win: workers, self-employed, large and small businesses, social economy. If Spain loses, not only does the Government of Spain lose, we all lose. No one can dream of making a profit by harming the interests of Spain and the whole of its citizens. So I ask for responsibility, I ask for a broad perspective, and I ask above all, patriotism. I began this speech by saying that we cannot forget the hardest days. But even less can we forget - we will never forget - those who are no longer with us, those who died in these terrible months we have gone through. We are not all here. More than 27,000 compatriots are missing who died as victims of COVID-19. Too many people are missing. Too many who are no longer here and who contributed to making our country a better place. And, as I announced a month ago, this country, your country, Spain, will always remember them and will pay tribute to them in a State Ceremony that will also be held in the days following July 12, which is the day of the elections in Galicia and the Basque Country. I conclude, and I do so by referencing an Eastern proverb, to convey some reflection. There is an often-cited Eastern proverb that states, "when strong winds blow, some people build walls, while others build windmills." You will have heard this proverb on many occasions. Obviously, no one expected this storm. But it has arrived and shaken us, as it has hit the whole world. And there are only two possible responses: to be a wall or to be a windmill. Division or transformation.

Even before the pandemic, we knew what walls were for: to divide, to segregate, to confront, to separate.

With the pandemic, we have seen other walls rise: those of fear, deception, and hatred. Walls are not the solution. There is another option: that of the windmills, as the proverb says. We can use the storm we have lived through and turn it into a positive force. A force of transformation. A positive force to reconnect by forging alliances between the youngest and our elders, the most exposed to the virus; entrepreneurs and workers who want to preserve and relaunch their businesses and jobs; alliances among all the peoples of Spain; the union of all political forces with the aim of rebuilding and recovering employment and economic growth. In all territories of Spain, we are beginning to enjoy those things, often small, that give meaning to life. Things that we once thought were secure and forever, and now we know can be lost and how costly it is to regain them.

We have paid as a society, as a country, a very high price to recover a part of the normality of our lives. It is in our hands to transform all this harshness and pain into something that makes us better and strengthens us as a country, as a community. It is in our hands to act, with perseverance and humility, to set aside what confronts us and what separates us. We can do better, much better, for our country, taking advantage of the effort that this misfortune has forced upon us. It is this hope for a better future that kept us all standing during the hardest days of this pandemic, and it is this hope that we must make a reality now.

So thank you very much for your attention, and thank you also, above all, for your responsibility and generosity.

Q.- Hello, good afternoon. Inma Carretero, from Cadena SER. It is a pleasure to see you again, Mr. President. I wanted to ask you about the budgets. I would like to know to what extent you believe the programmatic agreement between PSOE and Unidas Podemos is compatible with the economic and, above all, fiscal policy of Ciudadanos and to what extent you see those contents of the agreement as revisable in pursuit of a possible budget agreement and to seek a majority in a potential negotiation with Ciudadanos.

On the other hand, the other day in Congress you were asked about possible cuts and you spoke of reforms. What reforms is the Government considering and what scenario do you foresee regarding the possible conditionality that the European Commission may impose to transfer the funds from that restructuring plan you just referred to? What conditions do you think we will have to meet as member states? And finally, I would like to know if you support your Vice President Iglesias' plan to limit the private management of nursing homes. He has said that the current situation is highly precarious, highly privatized, and dangerous for health. I would like to know if you agree with this reform. Thank you.

President.- Thank you very much. I am also very pleased to see you again and the rest of the colleagues in this press room. We hope that as we recover this new normality, we will even be many more present here. We are also joined by those following us through telematic means, and in this regard, I want to thank, of course, the work that the State Secretariat for Communication has been doing during these complicated circumstances.

Well, there are many questions, and we will answer them all. Let’s see if I can be very brief.

Regarding whether some proposals are compatible with others, the fiscal proposals, the proposals... I believe we all need to be very aware that the halt in economic activity in our country as a result of the lockdown is unprecedented, unprecedented. Not only in Spain but in Europe and across the world. That the COVID crisis will also bring a social and economic crisis that some Spaniards are unfortunately already suffering from, but above all, what we need to do is not only absorb this shock but also get our country moving in recovery, in economic growth, in job creation, which is what we were recording before this pandemic emerged and exploded, and in that sense, we all need to do our part.

Certainly, the Government of Spain has always appealed for unity. Unity, we have said many times, saves lives, and unity saves businesses and saves jobs, and I believe that if it is justified at a given moment for us to all do our part to achieve a budget, it is in these very complex, very difficult, extraordinarily dramatic circumstances that our country has gone through. And I think it would be very good news for the productive sector, for healthcare professionals, for workers, for those who will suffer the consequences of this crisis to have a budget tailored to the extraordinary economic and social reality we are going through, so we, as a government, extend our hand to all parliamentary forces willing to lend a hand, to shoulder the burden so that Spain can emerge from this crisis as soon as possible and recover the economic growth and job creation we had until the emergence of this pandemic last March.

Regarding the reforms and the conditionality you mentioned earlier. I have made a reflection that I would like to share with all political parties, whether they are right-wing or left-wing in our country. In Europe, please, let us go hand in hand, do not ask for things that are counterproductive, I am not even saying for Spain, they are counterproductive even for the preservation of a great milestone in our continent and our European project, which is the Single Market. The response that the European Commission is giving with that proposal is an unprecedented proposal, it is a turning point in what is the response to an economic crisis completely different from that of 2008, but it is also a response that favors greater integration, a greater shared response to a common problem such as this pandemic, which, although it has affected some countries more than others, from an economic and social point of view, the halt is similar in all countries that belong to the Single Market and the eurozone.

Therefore, from the standpoint of the position of all political parties --regardless of whether they are in the government or not, in the Government of Spain, or in regional governments-- I believe it should be the same. I believe it should be the one that Spain is maintaining, humbly, along with other countries within the Union. Reforms? Conditionality? Look, this government is a government that in just over 100 days, we have been in office for just over six months in this legislature that began in January, we have made and proposed to the Cortes Generales broad reforms, for example, modernizing our education system, vocational training. We have also proposed a draft law on Climate Change that will transform our energy model, for example. We have transposed directives as important as, for example, those on CO2 emission markets. We have approved a new circular economy strategy.

Evidently, we are proposing positive responses to a crisis that has accelerated many changes that we already saw coming, for example, in the field of digitalization, not only in education but also in businesses. Therefore, we are always willing to undertake reforms but in a positive response to a crisis that must allow us to transform this economic system we have positively.

Certainly, the Government of Spain has made it clear, what we want is an inclusive and sustainable response, sustainable from a social, environmental, and, logically, labor perspective. Look, one of the significant responses that will probably be one of the great transformations we leave for future generations is the massive use we are making of temporary employment regulation files. In previous crises, what was done? To directly expel workers. We are no longer doing that. 31% of the employed population in our country is currently being maintained with state resources.

I want to say with this that we are innovating, that we are proposing reforms that were already being made in other countries, for example, in Denmark, in Germany, the temporary employment regulation files, and that we are incorporating into our way of addressing work in the labor field, and in that sense, I believe that one of the good paths we have started is that these ERTEs, these temporary employment regulation files, we have done hand in hand with the unions and employers.

And, regarding the last of your questions. Look, there have even been some regional presidents who have said, I don’t know very well, about nursing homes. Well, there are several things I would like to say, like health and education, dependency, and nursing homes are in the hands - their management - of the autonomous communities. But the Government of Spain has not looked the other way in this crisis, and not only because we have approved orders but because we have sent the Army.

To give you an idea, during this crisis from March 18 to May 17, the Government sent the Army to carry out 5,200 actions in nursing homes throughout Spain as part of Operation Balmis. Greater commitment to our elders, to the safety of our elders that this Government has shown seems impossible to me in the sense that we have even sent the Army to disinfect and assess the state of the nursing homes in our country. I insist, from March 18 to May 17, 5,200 actions in nursing homes by the Army and then, logically, all the orders we have been drafting over the intense weeks we have lived from March 5 to March 19, to March 23, to April 4, and then an extraordinary social fund of 300 million euros that the Government of Spain approved on March 19 to mitigate the effects of COVID-19 by reinforcing the staff of nursing homes and social services centers.

Therefore, that commitment from the Government of Spain is absolute, absolute with nursing homes. I insist, the army, 5,200 actions.

In any case, I believe that - and it has also been shared by all regional presidents, who are responsible for this management - it is evident that we will have to draw some lessons from what has happened, and that is why I believe that one of the debates on the Evaluation Commission that we are going to propose in Congress will be to see how we can resolve this situation in nursing homes that has concerned us all over these weeks.

Q.- Mercedes Arroyo, from Expansión. What tax measures does the Automotive Industrial Plan include? Does it mean that you are renouncing the diesel tax increase that was in your Budgets along with the rest of the tax increases? Are you going to propose Nadia Calviño to preside over the Eurogroup and have you already secured support for that? Are you concerned that this means you will have to make an adjustment of the kind you do not want to talk about that is in this position?

There are outbreaks in the Basque Country and parts of Catalonia. Have we gone too fast in these cases to seek your political support? And finally, the 8M case has been shelved, but it is a provisional shelving. In Italy, Giuseppe Conte has been interrogated by the Prosecutor's Office. Do you think the case could be reopened and do you contemplate having to respond yourself or some member of the Government? Thank you.

President.- Thank you very much, Mercedes, for your questions. I believe I have understood the five questions you have asked me. Regarding the automotive sector, tomorrow you will learn about the commitments that the Government is undertaking, which have also been agreed upon with the sector, but I believe that more than 3 billion euros allocated to recover such an important sector that has suffered such an evident shock as a result of the drop in demand seemed necessary to me, and that is a commitment from the Government of Spain.

Regarding March 8, well, obviously, all the files are provisional, all the files are provisional, therefore, there is no news on this issue that you raise, and, obviously, we are a Government that collaborates with Justice, as it cannot be otherwise. And, regarding the candidacy of the economic vice president of the Government for the presidency of the Eurogroup. First of all, I think it is an honor for Spain that personalities like Nadia Calviño, in this case, the economic vice president, not only from the Government of Spain but from many European colleagues, is strongly considered as a candidate for the presidency of the Eurogroup. Of course, as you can understand, the Government of Spain would be very interested, logically, in that type of responsibility, and during these days we have until June 25, we will logically talk with all colleagues to see if that candidacy matures, but, obviously, I see it with, not good eyes, I see it with very good eyes that candidacy.

And, regarding the other issue of cuts and, ultimately, the things you have said linking them to the candidacy of the Eurogroup, well, honestly, first news. I have not received that type of input at all from European colleagues, I mean.

Q.- Hello, good afternoon, Mr. President. I am Federico Molina from Informativos Tele5. I wanted to ask you a couple of questions related to tourism. With the quarantine eliminated for travelers from the European Union, are there any measures planned, such as temperature checks at airports or rapid tests to ensure that they are not coming infected? If so, is there room, since we are a week away, to prepare for that contingency? Thank you. President.- Thank you very much, Federico, I think it is one of the questions that we are all working on at the European level. What I can tell you is that from the point of view of the Government of Spain, what we have been doing in recent days is reinforcing external health with the autonomous communities. We have been reinforcing external health, we will continue to reinforce it with the autonomous communities, and, ultimately, this is one of the most critical moments because we have the pandemic under control, obviously, in Spain, the data is there, the de-escalation has been a success, the data is frankly positive, much better than I initially expected over these weeks, and, obviously, the opening of borders is a critical moment for which we have been preparing.

Earlier, Mercedes mentioned, to which I did not respond regarding the outbreaks. Obviously, there will be outbreaks because the virus -as I said before- is among us, continues to lurk, we do not have a therapeutic remedy, we do not have a vaccine, and consequently, what we have to do is appeal to individual responsibility. None of us can let our guard down, and from an institutional point of view, it seems to me that one of the good news is that these outbreaks, when they have occurred, the Health Systems of the autonomous communities have detected them quickly, whether in the Basque Country, in Catalonia, in Murcia when it happened in Totana, for example, or in other places in our country. That is to say, the early detection mechanisms of those outbreaks are fortunately working well, and we hope to keep Covid at bay among all of us, but, in any case, I would like to return, I insist a lot on this because I think it is fundamental. Institutions can reach as far as they can, health professionals can reach as far as they can. The most important thing is that we all assume that individual responsibility, that responsibility in the first person to keep the virus at bay.

Q: Good afternoon, Mr. President, I am Ana Martín from the newspaper esDiario. You mentioned first the importance of preparing better because the threat of the virus is still there. And if I am not mistaken, the president of Madrid has announced that in that telematic meeting, which is also announced as the last one, she has asked for a national plan for outbreaks. Next week the state of alarm ends. No one knows very well what will happen after the summer, heading into autumn, winter even. I wanted to ask you if you, in view of the fact that there have been no legislative reforms, rule out for the future the use of the state of alarm again as a tool.

And secondly, if you allow me, I wanted to insist again on the filing of the case that was being instructed by a court in Madrid regarding the March 8 demonstration. I wanted to ask you if with this filing you consider that both you and your government are exempt from what refers to the political responsibility of having maintained that demonstration. I say this because in the ruling the judge states that the gatherings in March increased the risk of contagion and therefore were a certain and safe risk to public health. Thank you.

President.- Thank you very much, Ana. Regarding the videoconference, indeed, I also want to thank all the regional presidents and presidents with whom we have had 14 videoconferences. I must remind you that I believe there have been six held in the last forty-some years of democracy, and only in this semester have we held fourteen videoconferences of presidents, and we have scheduled a face-to-face conference of presidents for the end of July.

That is to say, the effort that the Government of Spain has made and the effort that the autonomous communities have made to work shoulder to shoulder in such difficult circumstances, as we have all lived through as a society, deserves my recognition and gratitude. And I do so, I have done it before in private to each and every one of the regional presidents, but I also do it publicly. Regarding the National Plan for outbreaks, well, let's see, the Government of Spain has approved a royal decree law that is now pending validation in the Cortes Generales, which is the Royal Decree-Law where we establish what we call the parameters of that new normality. In which we establish the health criteria that we have been told we must assume in the first person by all citizens to be able to face and keep the virus at bay. Social distancing, the use of masks, ultimately, everything you know from the royal decree law. Secondly, during these months what we have done is also greatly enhance the dialogue between the Minister of Health and the health counselors in the Interterritorial Council, which will be the main forum to evaluate from a multilateral point of view the evolution of the epidemic. Without prejudice to the fact that, obviously, the Minister of Health will maintain a bilateral dialogue with each and every one of the Autonomous Communities and autonomous cities to follow the evolution of the epidemic second by second, not minute by minute, second by second, and that new outbreaks may arise. Well, we have proposed a state of alarm until June 21 and I remind you that the Popular Party has voted against its states of alarm. Therefore, what I want to say with this is that I do not rule out that in the future we may need to return to the State of Alarm, but it is not my intention. I hope and wish, moreover, that we do not find ourselves again subjected to such a critical situation that justifies the approval of the state of alarm, and therefore what I want to highlight is the collaboration, cooperation, and coordination that we are developing with the autonomous communities and with the Ministry of Health over these critical weeks and those to come. And therefore, I believe that we have all equipped ourselves with sufficient material resources, capacities, intelligence as well, because before we did not know, we were unaware of the nature of this virus, now we are beginning to know it in a much more accurate way, so we have sufficient instruments to be able to address this new normality with more guarantees. But, obviously, that constitutional instrument is there, it exists, and obviously the response that the Government will give will be proportional to the challenge itself. And regarding the last of the issues, the ruling, I can simply say that the Government respects, logically, judicial rulings, in this case the filing of a case regarding March 8. And I do not have much more to add, to be honest. Q: Good afternoon, Mr. President, I am Albert Calatrava from Televisión de Catalunya. First, during today's videoconference, President Torra has already announced that they will request that Catalonia move to phase 3 next week and not wait until the following Monday. I would like to know if you think it is possible to meet this request or if you think it is hasty.

Then, Mr. President, you also mentioned that once the state of alarm was overcome, it would be the time to address issues that had been put on hold, such as the dialogue table. Can you commit to convening that dialogue table with Catalonia in July?

And finally, do you maintain that you want to base the legislature on those parties at the parliamentary level, those parties that facilitated your investiture, such as ERC or PNV? Or after what we saw on Friday, from the last votes, from the gestures with Ciudadanos, can we clearly say that there is a change of strategy, with what that means in terms of risk? Some parties like PNV or ERC especially, have already warned that they are completely incompatible with Ciudadanos. Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you very much, Albert, for your questions. Regarding the first of them, it is true that today President Torra said that he wanted to move to phase 3 for all of Catalonia. It is not for me to decide, it corresponds in this case to the experts of the CCAES, the health authorities, to share this, let’s say, this issue with the Generalitat of Catalonia, with the Department of Health. Well, whatever they decide will be well decided, and therefore what I have done over these months is base myself on expert, epidemiological criteria, and therefore I have little to add to this issue. Except to reaffirm that it has been science that has explained, justified, the measures we have been taking from the Government of Spain. Secondly, regarding the Dialogue Table, yes. I have said it many times, I certainly will have no problem in holding it in July, among other things because it will mean that this health emergency is definitively overcome, which will be extraordinary news for everyone.

And regarding the legislature, if Ciudadanos, ERC, PNV. Well, we have such a fragmented Parliament, the citizens are asking us to reach agreements. The circumstances, I believe, that the citizens have gone through lead us to the fact that, obviously, we all have to pull together.

You see, it is the first time in many years that conferences of presidents are held in which all regional presidents are present. I mean, there is a demand. Vote whatever each one does in their electoral contests, whether they vote for independentist parties, recentralizing parties, left-wing parties, right-wing parties, nationalist parties, well, of all colors, right now there is a citizenry that demands, longs for, unity from all political forces. And in that sense, I believe that this legislature will also need to articulate transversal agreements. I certainly believe, and I have also told ERC that our commitments for the investiture, for the abstention that allowed that investiture, fortunately, because imagine what crisis we would have if we had not had a government in that month of January, well, they remain in force and we will work on them over the next few years, right? And there is, for example, the resumption of the convening of the dialogue table.

But I insist, I think it is very important the unity of all, of institutions, of companies, of workers, of political parties, because what we have ahead is to recover the productive fabric, employment, and above all that those who have suffered the consequences of this crisis the most do not get left behind.

We had a great example this week with the approval by everyone, except for the abstention of the far-right, of a great social achievement, such as the minimum vital income. I believe that is very good news for the whole of Spanish society. And now it is not only about talking about those people who do not have opportunities and that we have to create them, now we have to talk about how to revive the economy, how to make self-employed workers return to work, how to make workers and companies recover the path of growth and job creation that we had before the outbreak of this pandemic.

And of course, the Government will be involved in that, in rebuilding and recovering, and we will call on all political forces, of course, all of them. Because I said it in the Congress of Deputies this past Wednesday, no one is surplus. What is surplus in politics is hatred, insult, and provocation. But in the task we have ahead of us, no one is surplus. Q: El Confidencial Digital. What is the Government's assessment of the fact that the Prosecutor's Office is investigating the former king Juan Carlos? Secondly, you speak of education as one of the fundamentals for working towards this return to normality and you specifically explain the return to school classrooms. Is there any plan for the return to universities? Do you also expect it to be in-person starting in September? And finally, today at the Conference of Regional Presidents, you said, Mr. President, that there could be a positive surprise in the search for the vaccine. Can you clarify exactly what you mean? Thank you very much. President.- Well, regarding the last question about the positive surprise, I am referring to all the news coming from science. I believe that in this crisis, on many occasions we forget a disruptive element, which is the contribution of science. The tireless work that scientists and researchers are doing across the planet, but also in our country. I want to pay tribute and, logically, recognition to the Spanish scientists and researchers who are doing everything they can to achieve that vaccine as soon as possible. I think this is very important, not to forget this dimension of science, of research because hopefully soon it can give us positive surprises.

In relation to the first question, I don't have much more assessment to make, that is to say, this is a government that respects the work of judges and prosecutors, what we can do is logically collaborate with justice and obviously nothing more to add.

And secondly, regarding the university plan, indeed the Minister of Universities is already working with the educational community, with the autonomous communities, and we hope to reach a series of recommendations throughout this month so that, evidently, university students can also return to classrooms with total safety guarantees. Q: El Diario.es. Hello, Mr. President, good afternoon. I would like to ask you again about the issue of the budgets. After all, for there to be years of legislature, it is essential to have a budget this year. Will those budgets inevitably go through the legislative agreement that PSOE and Podemos have, or are you willing to make any concessions to bring in other groups? And then I wanted to ask you more clearly, in the event that Esquerra and PNV tell you that they are incompatible with Ciudadanos, will you prioritize that dialogue that has started with Ciudadanos or will you focus on the minority partners, which is what the spokesperson and Minister of Finance said?

I would also like to ask if you rule out a government crisis in the event that Nadia Calviño finally goes to the Eurogroup. And finally, in the agreement you signed with Bildu, it stated that the repeal of the most harmful aspects of the labor reform would be carried out before the extraordinary measures adopted in economic and labor matters due to Covid-19 ended. When will those legislative changes to the labor reform be promoted?

President.- Thank you very much for your questions. Regarding the budgets, it should be remembered that this is a government that has 155 seats to start with. 120 and 35, 120 from the Socialist Party and 35 from Unidas Podemos and the convergences, which adds up to 176, which is the absolute majority because the Congress of Deputies has 350, we have a leap to make of 21 seats, so we will obviously look at those parties that actively supported the investiture or simply did not block, and obviously, as I said before, I think it will be very important for all parliamentary groups to be sufficiently aware of the magnitude of the challenge we have ahead. And I believe that if there is any justification for us to have a budget this year with transversal agreements, then I think this is the moment. An unprecedented moment. Let us remember that we are suffering the greatest pandemic in the world in the last 100 years and suddenly, and therefore I think we will have to prioritize the general interests over the particular interests of one or another political project. In any case, we have our government agreement that we want to carry forward. We will talk to all political forces and I insist we have 155 seats, so it is not that we have to renounce anything, it is that we will have to complement our government agreements with the contributions of other parliamentary groups that will legitimately consider that the General Budgets must include their contributions and their different perspectives. There should not be a government crisis because Nadia Calviño, the vice president, will be president of the Eurogroup; these are complementary positions and therefore it would not imply the departure of the vice president from the Government, it would be the opposite, not only a recognition of her work and of Spain but also, I believe, very good news for our country. And regarding the last question, the Government will prioritize social dialogue. It will prioritize social dialogue. We have many things to discuss with them, for example, the extension of the ERTEs, and therefore we will prioritize social dialogue among unions, employers, and the Government of Spain. Q: The Argentine newspaper Clarín. Good afternoon. Three months have passed since the declaration of the state of alarm. On one hand, what has been the most difficult decision you had to make? On the other hand, looking back, what would you have done differently?

Then, regarding Latin America, you have a close relationship. I know that in five months you received the president of Argentina, in September 2010 when he was a pre-candidate, and in February of this year he was already the elected president. You are in contact with the leaders of America in these very difficult times, now that this region is so hard hit by the pandemic. And regarding the last thing you mentioned in your appearance about the possible list of countries for the opening of borders starting July 1, is that list already prepared, or will it be a joint list, and what is your assessment? Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you very much, Marina, for your questions. The most difficult decision, well, it is to approve the state of alarm, indeed, suspending such fundamental rights as, for example, the right to freedom of movement, the right to assembly. It seems to me that, obviously, for any ruler, these are very drastic, very difficult measures due to the impact of telling citizens that they have to stay home and that we have to make a confinement to stop the virus.

What would I have done differently? Well, right now I could tell you that, of course, having procured much earlier the PPEs, for example, for healthcare professionals, would have been one of the issues, or for example, the ventilators for ICUs, obviously, or even having reoriented our manufacturing for self-sufficiency earlier. In short, things that now seem very obvious, that in February everyone was unaware of, including our country, and obviously, I believe that one of the lessons we have to draw in that evaluation commission, to which I appeal to all parliamentary groups to constitute as soon as we lift the state of alarm, is that this pandemic must leave a mark of preparation, of prevention that we did not have before. And I believe that would be what I would do differently.

And regarding Latin America, I convey all my support, all my solidarity and brotherhood, mine and that of the Government and the entire Spanish society to Latin America. I have been in contact with various Latin American presidents in recent weeks, with whom we are also exercising a relationship of solidarity, the same solidarity that we asked of other countries when we were suffering the pandemic, we are also developing with our Latin American countries and of course, since you are a journalist from Clarín, I want to convey to Argentina, logically also to my dear friend the Argentine president, Alberto, all my encouragement, all my solidarity, and all my empathy and the desire that we meet again soon in person because that will mean that the health emergency has been overcome. And finally, I would like to say that the work we are doing in Spain is to ensure that this list of countries is joint, from the entire European Union, because it makes no sense for us to open the Schengen borders and for each of the countries to have agreements with third countries outside Schengen, because then we would not be doing our job well, it would be absolutely ineffective, so we hope that the European Union can achieve that agreement for relations and reopening of borders with third countries based on the criteria I mentioned earlier. Q: ONDA MADRID: Thank you, good afternoon. I would like to know if you share the words of the second vice president, Pablo Iglesias, saying that what happened in the residences in Madrid has been a scandal and even a crime. The president Isabel Díaz Ayuso, the president of the Community, offers an interview today in ABC in which she claims that the vice president never called for help and that Iglesias has poured gasoline whenever he could. I would like to know what you think of those words. The president of the Community of Madrid has also requested today at the Conference of Presidents a Barajas Plan because it could be a focal point for the entry of the virus. Are you going to work together with the Community of Madrid to prevent it from being, precisely, an entry point for the virus? She has also requested a reduction in the VAT of the fighting bull to 4%. I don't know if you are going to address that request. And I return to a question that Inma asked about the cuts that you did not clarify to the EH Bildu deputy Mertxe Aizpurua last Wednesday. Will they be limited to a withdrawal of spending that has been necessary to tackle the crisis caused by the confinement, or are you thinking of a cut in public salaries and pensions to reduce the public deficit? Thank you. President.- Thank you very much. Let's see. Regarding the first question, I insist, the management of the residences for the elderly is in the hands of the autonomous communities. And we have all witnessed the orders and counter-orders that have come to light from the regional government regarding the elderly in residences and their admission to hospitals. I leave it there. What the Government of Spain has done, I insist, was to approve, on March 19, an order adopting measures regarding the residences for the elderly and socio-sanitary centers in light of the health crisis caused by COVID-19. We converted a protocol from the Ministry of Health from March 5, that is, nine days before approving the state of alarm, into an order that, among other things, urged all residences to take the following measures: classify all residents according to their relationship with COVID-19, isolate all residents with acute respiratory infection, and, in general, whenever there was availability, carry out the diagnostic confirmation test for cases presenting symptoms of acute respiratory infection to confirm possible cases of COVID-19 infection. And these are issues that were approved by the second vice presidency of Social Services, under its leadership and the leadership of the Ministry of Health. On March 23, a new order was issued that empowers the competent authority of each autonomous community to intervene in residential centers according to the epidemic and care situation. 300 million on March 19 with an extraordinary social fund to mitigate the effects of COVID-19 by reinforcing the staff of the residences for the elderly and social service centers. Assistance to the homes of dependent elderly people or people with disabilities, as well as assistance to homeless people. 300 million euros on March 19. Also led by the second vice presidency of Social Services, of Social Welfare. And I insist: 5,200 actions in residences for the elderly throughout Spain led under the framework of Operation Balmes by the Spanish army at my request and that of the competent delegated authorities in the state of alarm; the Minister of Defense, the Minister of the Interior, the Minister of Health, and the Minister of Transport, Mobility, and Urban Agenda. The greater commitment we have had with our elderly, sending the army to disinfect and protect them in those residences for the elderly where there might be some type of difficulty or vulnerability, I believe is absolute.

Regarding the Barajas Plan, indeed, we have agreed that the Minister of Health will speak with the Minister of Health to work on this issue. I insist that the Government of Spain is reinforcing external health, which has been very weakened in recent years, and therefore we are also reinforcing it with the support of the autonomous communities. Regarding the fighting bull, I would tell you that the Minister of Agriculture has met with the collective, with the associations. It seems that this week the Minister of Culture will also meet with these associations.

And in relation to the last of the questions, let's see, I mean, the response that Europe and Spain are giving is very different from what was seen in the crises of 2008. What we are focused on now is recovering economic activity, recovering employment, and, evidently, providing a positive response. I insist, I believe, and I say this humbly, that this crisis has accelerated changes that we saw coming. Certainly, the health emergency is one of them, or the emergency, rather, climate-related, the digitalization of our educational system, of our productive system is also one. And, evidently, we are going to have to make many transformations in our energy sector, in our productive sector. We are going to have to do it in our public sector as well, of course, are we not going to strengthen our National Health System, for example? Or do we not need to review, not to go any further, the functioning of the elderly care homes that are, I insist, in the hands of the Autonomous Communities? Therefore, I think we need to contextualize things. I understand that you ask about this, I understand that, but I insist, it is talking partially about a response to the crisis that is much more positive than the one given in 2008. And, evidently, there are automatic stabilizers, of course we are spending more right now on unemployment benefits because there are more unemployed. When we recover economic growth, there will be fewer unemployed and, therefore, we will be spending less on unemployment benefits. Ultimately, the debate is much more complex than just confining it to this issue. And this is a Government that defends the welfare state, that defends the strength of the public sector. I believe we will have to draw some lessons from that. And, evidently, there is a roadmap set by this Government. Among them is, for example, tax reform. These are issues that we will have to address, but step by step. Right now, what we need to focus on is recovering economic activity, recovering employment, recovering economic dynamism, helping and rescuing very competitive sectors that have suffered a lot as a result of the lockdown: the tourism sector, the automotive sector. In short, that is what the Government is focused on.

Secretary of State for Communication. Thank you very much, Mr. President. The question-and-answer session is now over. Allow me to remind you that today is International Sign Language Day. The press conferences of the President, of the members of the Government, of the technical officials that have taken place over the months, are conducted with sign language, and we thank the team responsible for this translation, for their tireless work, truly, thank you very much. Mr. President.

President. Thank you very much to everyone.