Pedro Sánchez: "I apologize to the victims for the unintended effects of the 'only yes is yes' law."

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

16 April 2023 · Bilbao, Spain

Context
Sánchez gave an interview to El Correo during a visit to Bilbao in April 2023, discussing the Housing Law, the 'only yes is yes' reform, and upcoming elections.
Main themes
Housing Law as constitutional right, 'only yes is yes' law reform and apology to victims, coalition government management, Podemos and Sumar internal conflict, economic optimism, parliamentary alliances with nationalist parties, public housing construction, PP opposition to social reforms, pre-campaign political dynamics
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,783
72nd percentile
Sentences
142
79th percentile
Readability
50
62nd percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.35
84th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 40%40%
  • Economic 28%27%
  • Geopolitical 17%17%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

142 sentences in 59 paragraphs

Pedro Sánchez's strategy is clear: less "noise" and more action, "to the things that matter." "Education, pensions, labor reform... Now it was time for the Housing Law, and we have delivered. It will cease to be a problem and become a constitutional right," he emphasizes. We are in pre-campaign mode, and May 28 is key to predicting what will happen in the general elections in December.

"The economy is smiling at Spain," he emphasizes. But the facts also speak of the open war between Podemos and Sumar, the blow dealt by Ferrovial's move to the Netherlands, or the controversial reform of the 'only yes is yes' law. And here, in the interview he gave yesterday to EL CORREO during his visit to Bilbao, the President of the Government had no qualms about "apologizing to the victims for the unintended effects of the law."

They have just agreed on the Housing Law, one of the major milestones of the legislature, with Esquerra and Bildu. They, in fact, have been the ones to take credit for the agreement. Are they your preferred partners?

First, we should congratulate ourselves on the agreement. Through public commitment, we transform into a constitutional right what is a real problem for a large part of the population, especially young people, which is access to housing. It was a commitment of the legislature. Education, pensions, labor reform... It was time for the Housing Law, and that is what we have achieved. Regarding parliamentary arithmetic, I believe that many times throughout this legislature the debate has been raised as to why it is the nationalist parties that support these advances and not, for example, the PP. And that is the question. The question is not that these social advances are backed or supported by different nationalist formations, but that all these social advances have been achieved with the PP against us, despite the PP and without the PP.

The first criticisms of the law have already begun to emerge, warning of a restriction on the rental supply.

Our goal is to turn public housing into a right and not a problem, committing the administration to the massive construction of public housing. That will be the only way to resolve the serious problem of emancipation, particularly for young people. Spain has intolerable rates compared to Europe. Moreover, one of the fundamental elements is the prohibition of selling public housing to vulture funds, something that is systematically done by conservative governments with their neoliberal recipes.

The reform of the 'only yes is yes' law has already led to the reduction of sentences for a thousand convicted individuals and the release of a hundred sexual offenders. Should someone in your government have resigned?

The 'only yes is yes' law is a good law that places Spain once again at the forefront of protecting victims of sexual assault in an absolutely comprehensive manner. And indeed, there has been an unintended effect. Some of those releases or reviews are not definitive; they can still be appealed, but in any case, an unintended effect has been caused that neither the Executive nor the Legislative contemplated, but that we must resolve. The approach that the Socialist Parliamentary Group has made is to respect the heart of the law, to respect consent as the central element of the law, but we must provide a response from a legal and technical standpoint, not a political one.

But should someone have taken political responsibility?

What I can tell you is that if we need to apologize to the victims, I apologize to the victims for these unintended effects. I believe that no deputy, even those who voted against this law, is in favor of reducing sentences. Therefore, I apologize to the victims, and we are going to find a solution to these unintended effects because it is the best way to defend the law itself.

How will you approve the reform, with the support of the PP?

With the support of the groups that are willing to respect the heart of the law but to resolve these unintended effects from a legal and technical perspective. I told you earlier that the PP systematically votes against social advances, but in cases where we can count on the support of the right if it is for concrete actions. We have achieved a pension reform with social peace, a labor reform with social peace, the Housing Law... In such a difficult context, first with the pandemic and then with the war, the coalition government can be rated highly.

Crisis in the left

Do you lead a coalition government with three partners?

I lead a coalition government. I have been the Secretary General of the PSOE since 2014, and I have always demanded the autonomy of political projects. And if I have defended this, I must respect the autonomy of other formations like Podemos and Sumar to resolve their differences. What is my wish from that respect? That the pieces fit together in the puzzle.

But from an internal management perspective, are you concerned that Yolanda Díaz will lose authority in the eyes of Ione Belarra and Irene Montero and decide to go it alone?

Beyond the public debate, what is important when evaluating a government is its action. The facts. We have achieved a pension reform with social peace, a labor reform with social peace, the Housing Law... In such a difficult context, first with the pandemic and then with the war, the coalition government can be rated highly.

Are you concerned that these divisions will weaken the left at the polls and roll out the red carpet for the right?

It remains to be seen how these differences will be resolved. But if we want to rebuild everything that was broken during the decade of neoliberal response to the financial crisis and we want to consolidate the advances made for the benefit of the middle and working class of our country, Spain needs a decade of progressive policies.

With the same investiture partners?

Well, I would like to have a broader majority. That is why, when the general elections arrive, I will ask for a majority confidence to have a much stronger government. In my investiture, I said that this would be the legislature of dialogue, and it is being so at all levels.

There are polls indicating a transfer of votes from the PSOE to Sumar. Have you overstepped by 'promoting' Yolanda Díaz over Podemos?

I have been the leader of the PSOE since 2014, and many things have been said since then, but in the end, the PSOE is the great option and the political organization that clearly leads the left and has its own political project that responds not only to the demands for equity of the majority social group in our country but also to efficiency. Look, the economy is smiling at Spain above the European average, and it is not only a success of the government; it is a success of the country. If anything has been proven, it is that social democracy manages the economy much better than the right.

Speaking of the right, you reproach the PP for partnering with Vox, and they reproach you for doing so with Bildu. What wears more? Are these extremes comparable?

As far as I know, the PSOE does not govern with Bildu, and the PP does govern with Vox. The PSOE is separated by an abyss from Bildu. A different matter is that we can occasionally come to an understanding for social advances, such as pension reform or the housing law. In the case of the PP, in this long year of Alberto Núñez Feijóo, we have seen changes. They have formed the first coalition government with the far right in Castilla y León; they have moved from 'no' to abstention in the motion of censure, and we have just seen in Doñana, that despite having an absolute majority, they converge with Vox to perpetrate this aggression. There is a great risk that after May 28, PP governments with Vox will form that will roll back societies.

And will the PSOE govern with Bildu?

We do not have that contemplated under any scenario.

Independentist challenge

President Aragonès has presented a Clarity project for Catalonia that leads to a negotiated referendum. Is there room for negotiation on this proposal?

Aragonès's and ERC's proposal politically demonstrates the enormous distance that separates us and, therefore, the importance of dialogue, of abandoning maximalist positions to reach agreements. Not only the Spanish Constitution, but no constitution in the world recognizes the right to secession. One of the lessons that Catalan independence must learn is that after the pandemic and now with the war, what we are seeing is an acceleration of the process of European integration. The independentist project of separation, as such, is more characteristic of the 19th and 20th centuries than of the 21st century.

And what is the solution?

What is important is that independence is honest with Catalan society and recognizes that we must move towards formulas of understanding and meeting in society, and I do not say this, but the Catalan CEO's own survey in which the majority is in favor of continuing to belong to Spain.

But you will be aware that nationalists, not only in Catalonia, will set as a condition for continuing to support you in a future legislature that you open the debate on the model of the State to recognize plurinational Spain.

Look, landing that question in Euskadi, where both the PNV and Bildu have proposed the review and reform of the Gernika Statute. During this legislature, we have addressed, as had not been done for many years, the process of transfer and compliance with the Gernika Statute, and we have reduced the institutional conflict that we inherited from the PP administration. The PSOE has always advocated for self-government. Opening debates on the instruments that the Basque Government needs, in this case, to address technological revolution, ecological transition, social cohesion, opportunities, or reindustrialization is what matters to people, not so much identity.

But the identity issue is back in the debate...

Today, after the pandemic and with the war, the debates of the citizenry have to do with the things that matter, with the education of our children, with the healthcare of our family and loved ones, with access to housing, with pensions... It is to those debates that we must turn. The league of noise, disqualification, and insult is left entirely to the right and the far right. We focus on management, which is where the main concern of the majority social group lies.

Will you open the controversial issue of regional financing this legislature?

It is true that it needs to be reviewed, but it is also true that we have faced four extraordinary years, and even so, we have managed to increase regional financing since our Welfare State is in the hands of the autonomous communities. When I arrived in government, we found 3,000 fewer healthcare professionals than when Rajoy was elected president; today we have 90,000 more healthcare professionals, and we are opening the largest offer of MIR positions in democracy. I mean by this that the review of regional financing is a pending debate, but the Government of Spain has demonstrated commitment to the autonomous communities and their financing.

"The week we started filing income tax returns, Ferrovial is leaving"

Is Ferrovial's decision to move its headquarters to the Netherlands a severe blow to Spain's image?

This company made the decision the week we Spaniards started filing our income tax returns and the year we are registering a record of foreign direct investment. Let everyone draw their own conclusions. There is a fundamental debate about tax dumping. We have defended that the tax advantages benefiting large corporations through the Corporate Tax be eliminated, setting a minimum of 15%.

The prices of the shopping basket continue to soar. Will you approve a new aid package like another VAT reduction?

In addition to the impact of the economic and social consequences of the war, drought, or the increase in the cost of fertilizers, we are monitoring the evolution of prices daily. In June, the package of measures we launched, over 45 billion euros, will expire. Fortunately, we are having the lowest inflation in Europe, also thanks to the policies that the Government is implementing.

But will you take new measures during the campaign?

We will see how prices evolve, and the Government will react, as we have always done, in defense of the general interest of our country and the majority social group. It must be emphasized that all this policy of protecting incomes and the middle and working class, the Iberian solution, is allowing us to have the cheapest energy prices in Europe, to have inflation relatively lower than the European average, and therefore not to lose competitiveness.

Is the relationship with businesspeople as bad as it seems?

No, on the contrary. In these years, we have received 34 billion euros in foreign direct investment; during the pandemic, we launched ICO loans that saved many companies, ERTE saving many jobs, or the European funds, which are allowing economic and employment growth like never before.

The energy companies or the banking sector do not think the same...

This is a government that is clearly betting on economic and social development. The Government defends the interest of the majority, and those who are benefiting from the war's circumstances will have to help more precisely to improve the Welfare State. For every euro we raise taxes on the wealthy, we save five euros for the middle and working class of our country.

"For me, there is a historical and strategic relationship with the PNV that I do not have with Bildu."

The PNV has been left out of the picture of the Housing Law. Are you not concerned?

As far as the politics of Basque nationalism is concerned, I want to convey this with absolute clarity. The Socialist Party is separated by an abyss from Bildu. A different matter is that we can achieve specific agreements for the benefit of the social majority. But it must be recognized, not only with my administration but also with previous socialist governments, that if there has been a point of convergence between the PNV and the PSOE, it has been precisely that we have always prioritized coexistence over any other political objective. For me, there is a relationship that is not only historical but also strategic with the PNV that I do not have with Bildu.

Urkullu and the regional presidents of the Cantabrian coast are very concerned about the marginalization of the Atlantic Corridor regarding the railway connection through France. Does this worry you?

I believe that when the presidents say this, there is some truth to it. It is true that for a very long time we have been focused on discussing the Mediterranean Corridor, but not the Northern one, and I think it is a structuring element from a territorial point of view, defining present and future competitiveness. What I can guarantee you as the President of the Government of Spain is that you will have us by your side and that we will fulfill our commitments before 2030 for that corridor to become a reality.

Have you discussed this with President Emmanuel Macron?

Not only did I speak with him at the Barcelona summit, but we have also involved the European Commission so that we can incorporate the railway connection between Cantabria and Euskadi into this corridor. Furthermore, you know, I am decisive with France. It seemed that that energy interconnection through Barcelona and Marseille was going to be difficult, if not impossible, and now we will try to make this happen within the deadlines we have set.

The memory of the victims

When it comes to shaping memory policies, do you find it acceptable to mix prisoners with victims of terrorism as has been done in some municipalities in the Basque Country?

I find it absolutely unacceptable. In this Executive, and I have been discussing it with the Government delegate, we have reactivated the Victims Foundation, we have launched the Memorial Center for Terrorism in Vitoria-Gasteiz... What the Government of Spain must do, not only as an institutional and legal duty but also as a commitment to the memory of the victims, is to ensure that the Law on Victims of Terrorism is respected. And this is what is not being done. We are following the procedure that corresponds to us as an administration, first making a request. And in case this situation is not corrected, we will obviously file a complaint.