Interview with the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez: defense of the ceasefire in Gaza and the Palestinian state.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

4 April 2024

Context
Sánchez gave an interview during a regional tour in Doha, Qatar on April 4, 2024, advocating for a permanent ceasefire in Gaza and recognition of a Palestinian state.
Main themes
Ceasefire in Gaza, Palestinian statehood, humanitarian crisis in Gaza, international isolation of Netanyahu, UN Security Council resolutions, EU-Israel relations, humanitarian aid access, hostage release, Hamas terrorist attacks, International Court of Justice measures, Spain's foreign policy position
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,698
83rd percentile
Sentences
184
87th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
3.00
48th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

184 sentences in 44 paragraphs

President.- First of all, thank you very much for this interview. And I have to say that sometimes I feel very frustrated because, of course, we have been very firm since the beginning of this war. We have condemned these horrible and terrible terrorist attacks perpetrated by Hamas. We condemn those attacks. But, of course, we called for a permanent ceasefire two or three weeks after the terrorist attacks. And the reason is that you cannot respond to this kind of attack only with weapons or with the logic of war. There are other ways to address these terrible situations. That is why I believe it is very important to have the commitment of the entire international community to call for a ceasefire that allows humanitarian aid to enter Gaza and, of course, the immediate and urgent release of the hostages.

Q.- Of course, there is no ceasefire in effect. The guns fell silent a bit at the end of November, only for seven days. When the Security Council finally approved its resolution, all its members welcomed it. Even the United States, which abstained, said positive things. It was well received by the Palestinian Authority. It was even well received by Hamas. The only one that did not welcome that Security Council resolution - in fact, vehemently condemned it - was Israel. Is Israel an obstacle to peace at this moment?

President.- I believe that Netanyahu and his government, with this strategy, are becoming increasingly isolated internationally. At first, I think we all felt that solidarity with the citizens and society that were attacked by a terrorist organization, but then this unbalanced and horrible situation that has shocked the entire international community is putting Prime Minister Netanyahu in a very difficult and isolated position within the international community. This was evident, for example, in Europe, at the beginning of the war, some countries were more aligned with Israel's political position, but now they have drastically changed their position because their own societies are calling for tougher and clearer political stances towards what, unfortunately, we are witnessing in Gaza. In Spain, I can say that the majority of our citizens believe that we need peace, that we need to restore peace, that we need an urgent and permanent ceasefire on the ground, and of course, to respond to the most urgent question today in Gaza, which is: how can we ensure that the necessary amount of aid enters to respond to this humanitarian crisis that the Gazans are suffering?

Q.- You are visiting the region, you have been in Jordan, you have been in Saudi Arabia, and now you are in Qatar, and here in Doha, along with Cairo, is one of the places where they have been trying to reach an agreement on a ceasefire in the talks. What is the latest you know about this? Do you think it is close?

President.- I do not have information on whether it is close or not. What I can share with you is my willingness, and I believe the willingness of the majority of the international community, which is to achieve this permanent ceasefire. And I must also remind you that the Security Council resolutions are binding for all member states, including Israel. Therefore, I believe it is mandatory for Prime Minister Netanyahu's government, of course, to declare this permanent ceasefire. And I believe this will be a very important step to provide a political horizon for the region in order to open a peace process that leads to international recognition, mutual recognition for Israelis and for the Palestinian people.

Q.- You speak of binding Security Council resolutions. There is not only the one on the ceasefire. At the end of last year, there were two resolutions for more aid to enter. The International Court of Justice, which also has binding measures that it has announced twice, says the same, that more aid should enter. And yet, this is not happening. Do you believe that Israel is violating the Security Council resolutions and the measures of the International Court of Justice? And if so, what measures should be taken?

President.- I believe there are indeed some doubts in the sense you mention, and I can tell you that within the European Union, for example, two governments, the Irish and the Spanish, have asked the European Commission to conduct an assessment of the humanitarian law articles that are included in the strategic relationship that the European Union has with Israel.

Q.- That is the agreement that was signed between the EU and Israel. And if it is concluded that Israel is not complying with respect for human rights, for example, as contemplated in that agreement, what measures should be taken?

President.- Well, in the case of the European Union, the situation will be that there is an open door to have a debate within the European Council to see if we continue with this strategic relationship or not. This is something for which we first need to have the assessment from the European Commission. But, in any case, as I said before, what is important is that today, since the beginning of the war, more and more countries, especially in the Western world, are increasingly reluctant to support and back what Prime Minister Netanyahu and his government are doing in Gaza, and there is an urgency to stop this terrible war and open a new phase of stability, peace, and prosperity in the region. And I believe that, for Europe, for example, it is not only a moral conviction, which it is, but it also serves our geopolitical interest to have a stable, prosperous, and peaceful Middle East. So this is something I have been advocating for, and that is why we have made ourselves heard within the European Union to have this approach, and also to have a strategic vision on what to do from the European Union with our Southern Neighborhood. Which, by the way, I can tell you that I believe there are many opportunities for the European Union and also for these countries in the Middle East and the Mediterranean.

Q.- Humanitarian workers have been repeatedly attacked in Gaza. In the latest tragic incident, seven workers from World Central Kitchen, the NGO created by Spanish chef José Andrés, were killed. They had also been working with a Spanish NGO that had brought their food supplies by boat. They arrived by boat because Israel does not allow enough supplies to enter by land. How can this be acceptable?

President.- It is not acceptable. I think it is important to condemn this terrible situation. And the very dangerous, extremely dangerous, circumstances that humanitarian workers are facing on the ground in Gaza. And that is why I believe it is important, first of all, as I have already done, to condemn this horrible bombing that caused the death of seven workers. This NGO led by Spanish chef José Andrés simply provides food to people. And, of course, what we ask of the Israeli government is to clarify the situation and explain why this has happened in Gaza.

Q.- Of course, this is not an isolated incident.

President.- Certainly.

Q.- In Gaza, more humanitarian workers have died than anywhere else in the world. 150 or more UN staff members, more medical personnel than anywhere else in the world. This leads us to wonder if the Israeli army is very bad at targeting objectives. Or is it about the rules of engagement? Is it some kind of indiscriminate policy of shooting to kill?

President.- I do not know. That is something the Israeli government has to answer. What I can tell you is that the situation on the ground is not acceptable. And this brings me back to the same response I gave you from the beginning of the interview. We need a permanent ceasefire. We need to convene a peace conference, which, by the way, is a proposal that not only the European Union but also the Arab League and the Islamic Conference; we agreed on. So I think it is important that from Europe and also from the Arab countries we work together on this peace conference to move forward and leave behind this terrible war and establish the conditions for peaceful coexistence in the short term.

Q.- You say that Israel has to answer these questions. Is it possible that Israel has to answer these questions before the International Criminal Court? Should there be accountability for this kind of actions?

President.- There always has to be accountability. I believe history is full of examples where this type of accountability is urgent and necessary. But this has to be answered by the International Court of Justice. And what we have to do is ask the Israeli government to comply with what is today binding, which are, of course, the UN resolutions that demand a permanent ceasefire.

Q.- We have also talked about humanitarian workers, medical personnel, and journalists. In Gaza, more journalists have died than anywhere else in the world. Now, Prime Minister Netanyahu's government is banning Al Jazeera from operating in Israel. Is this literally a case where Israel is shooting the messenger?

President.- Well, I want to say that press freedom is the hallmark of any self-respecting democratic government. For my part and on behalf of Spain, what we do is support the work done by journalists around the world, and especially in Gaza in these very difficult circumstances.

Q.- You have spoken about famine in Gaza, which according to the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification report published a couple of weeks ago, will reach its peak by May. This is a man-made famine, is it not? Do you not agree? It is specifically a famine caused by Israel.

President.- What I do believe is, and I was in Rafah at that time, you mentioned it at the beginning of the interview. It is essential that Israel opens the possibility for this humanitarian aid to enter Gaza as soon as possible. And perhaps we are talking, of course, about land crossings and, of course, about a number of 1,000 or 2,000 trucks a day. This is the terrible situation that the population of Gaza is suffering. And this is something that the international community cannot accept. And that is why I believe that not only from the UN Security Council, but also from the European Union Council, we had a council a few weeks ago, we recommended to the Israeli government that it open the border crossings so that Gazans could access humanitarian aid.

Q.- Regarding the EU, Joseph Borrell is the High Representative for Foreign Affairs. He was your Foreign Minister, you know him well. He recently said: if you think too many people are being killed, perhaps you should provide fewer weapons to prevent so many people from being killed. Is it necessary for the EU to stop selling arms to Israel? And are you sure that your country no longer sells them?

President.- We no longer sell arms, and I agree with this statement by Josep Borrell. And what I can tell you is that I do not believe that this strategy will provide more security to Israeli society after this war ends, because I believe that the only way to have peaceful coexistence and the security that the Israeli people need is through politics and diplomacy, and not with war and this especially terrible war that we are witnessing in Gaza, not only in Gaza but also in the West Bank and perhaps beyond.

Q.- And on that, I wanted to ask you, because many leaders, including yourself, have warned about the danger of this war spreading. In that context, the recent Israeli attack on an Iranian diplomatic building in the Syrian capital, Damascus, do you believe it killed high-ranking officials of the Quds Force? Do you think it was acceptable or a reckless act of provocation?

President.- It is not acceptable. The Israeli government must clarify this. And of course, this goes in the direction I mentioned earlier, which is that we have to avoid an escalation of the conflict in the region. From Spain, we have deployed for many years one of our largest UN missions on the ground, which is in Lebanon. And, of course, we are trying to ensure peaceful coexistence between the Lebanese people and the Israeli people in that very difficult border between these two countries. And we are very concerned about this situation, and that is why we call on and commend the Israeli government to try to avoid this regional escalation that we are witnessing, for example, with this attack in Syria.

Q.- When the war is over, who will govern Gaza? And who should pay for its reconstruction? Should Israel, for example, be required to pay compensation for some of the damages caused?

President.- In my opinion, the Palestinian Authority is our partner for the international community, and I believe it has the capacity, and if it does not, it must be given the capacity to assume full responsibility for Gaza, East Jerusalem, and the West Bank. And from the Spanish perspective, I believe we are living in a moment where the international community as a whole must recognize the full membership of Palestine in the United Nations system, and of course bilaterally. From Spain's perspective, we are willing to support and recognize the State of Palestine. Because this push must be different from the others we have witnessed in the last seven decades. That is, if we convene this international peace conference, Palestine must come to the table with a recognition assumed by the international community of its own state. And the discussions with the international community, with the Israeli government, in my opinion, must be about what the borders will be, what the government will be, etc., etc.

Q.- You speak of the Palestinian Authority. Prime Minister Netanyahu says that the Palestinian Authority cannot govern Gaza afterwards. How is the international community going to stand firm against the Israelis on issues like this?

President.- If the Prime Minister of Israel, Netanyahu, has tried to weaken the Palestinian Authority in recent years, this is what we are seeing now in Gaza. And what we need is to revitalize the Palestinian Authority.

I think it is important, and we are willing to work together with our friend, President Abbas, and of course, the new Prime Minister of the Palestinian Authority. But I believe they must assume full responsibility for Gaza, the West Bank, and East Jerusalem, and, of course, once again, the international community must take a very important step to recognize the State of Palestine.

And, by the way, I also believe that there is a push for mutual recognition. Some Arab countries also need to recognize Israel for peaceful coexistence to exist.

Q.- The problem is that President Netanyahu... ─you are talking about the two-state solution─ and he does not believe in that either.

President.- Well, actually, it is a one-state solution because the other is already recognized, I mean Israel, by the majority of countries and especially in the Western world. That is why I believe it is a one-state solution. And that one-state solution will lead to the recognition of the Palestinian state. And I can tell you that, within the European Union, of course Spain has been very vigorous from the beginning, but there are more and more countries that are in favor of this idea.

Q.- And in terms of recognition, another thing happens, and that is that if Palestine is going to be a state, it also needs to be a member of the UN. The Palestinian ambassador to the UN has sent a letter to the UN Secretary-General, that is the first step, and then they go to the Security Council. I have been told at the Security Council table that among the 15 members they have the nine votes they need. The issue is the Americans because they have veto power and could veto this. What is your message to the United States for Palestine to become a member of the UN? And regarding recognition, should the United States also recognize Palestine?

President.- I believe that the Biden administration is trying to do everything possible to find a political solution to this terrible war. And I also recognize that political will. Secondly, what we first saw in the war in Ukraine, and then in Gaza, is that increasingly the political debate and influence are not in the Security Council but in the General Assembly. And I believe that in the General Assembly there is a large majority of countries that agree with the Palestinian Authority's request to become a full member of the UN.

Q.- Regarding the General Assembly, the countries I have in this program, the President of Brazil, for example, states that there is a double standard regarding what is happening in Ukraine and in Gaza. If it is wrong to attack hospitals and bomb civilians in Ukraine, why is it not wrong to do the same in Gaza? Do you think that the statements about Gaza, the policies regarding Gaza of some of your Western allies, will hinder the obtaining of international support for the other war, the one in Ukraine, which is still ongoing and perhaps we are not focusing on as much?

President.- From my point of view, I consider that Spain has a coherent position. And we are with Ukraine because we defend a rules-based world order. One of those fundamental pillars, as you know very well, is respect for national sovereignty and territorial integrity of that country, which is currently not being respected by a member, by the way, of the UN Security Council, which is the Putin regime in Russia. And because we are coherent, we are also, and firmly, in relation to the war in Gaza, because what we are witnessing there raises many questions. One of them is whether Israel is respecting or not, complying or not, with the UN security resolutions and the resolutions of the Security Council or international humanitarian law. So, again, I believe that by being coherent regarding both Ukraine and Gaza, we are defending international law.

Q.- Are you concerned about the situation in Ukraine? Because a year ago there was a lot of talk about a counteroffensive by the Ukrainians. Since then, and in recent months, very slowly, it seems that the Russian side is the one gaining ground. Gaza is taking all the attention. This means that, potentially, funding and weapons are being diverted from Ukraine. And then there is another ghost on the horizon, in November: President Trump could return to the White House and withdraw support from President Zelensky. Are you concerned that Ukraine is going to lose this war?

President.- I do not believe that Ukraine is going to lose this war because today everyone knows that there is a nation called Ukraine that wants to be respected and defend its own freedom to be closer to the European Union and our values and to be a member of the European Union in the near future. So I do not believe that it is going to lose the war. And I do not believe that Putin is going to win the war. Not at all. Because at the beginning of the war, what he intended was to invade the entire territory of Ukraine and that is no longer the case. So I believe that the great risk is that we are witnessing a kind of frozen conflict.

Q.- You have skillfully dodged the last part of my question. President Putin, you say, is not going to win the war in Ukraine, but President Trump could well win the elections in November and says he can resolve this in a day. He could weaken President Zelensky, as you know, there are fears that he will question Article 5, the basic rule of the NATO charter, the rule of all for one, if one is attacked, all support them. Are you concerned about the possible return of President Trump?

President.- I am a progressive president, my government is progressive, so what I would like is, first of all, to have good relations with President Biden and his administration. And I would like him to be reelected as President of the United States. But this is something that the American citizenry has to decide. What we want is to have the best relationship with the American administration. Trump, Biden, or whoever is in charge and leads the country.

And I believe that one of the main ties between the United States and Europe is NATO, it is our transatlantic bond, our transatlantic relationship. And I believe that this is above who the Prime Minister or President of one country or another is. It is something strategic for security, not only for Europe but also for the United States.

So I do not believe that we are going to witness a weakened position of NATO in the coming years in the event that Trump wins the elections.

What we are going to witness is what we have seen in the last two years, which is a stronger NATO. And this is due to Putin's war. This is the paradox, the paradox is that what Putin wants is not only to invade Ukraine but to weaken NATO and what he has achieved is the opposite. Now we have Sweden, we have Finland, we have a stronger NATO, and moreover, within the European Union, we have a stronger awareness that we need to do more regarding our defense and deterrence capabilities. And this is something we are already doing within the European Union. I always say that we do not have a problem with Russian society, but with a regime that is questioning borders and, therefore, the security not only of Ukraine but also of Europe and the whole world. And this is something that, I insist, we must resolve through diplomacy, but unfortunately, today it is not possible. Let us hope that in the future we can find that path.