Press conference after the European Council at the permanent representation of Spain to the European Union
Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Sánchez held a press conference at the Spanish representation to the EU following the October 2021 European Council meeting in Brussels.
- Main themes
- Energy prices crisis, European Council outcomes, gas and electricity market reform, CO2 emissions market, Spain's European proposals, COVID-19 pandemic management, vaccination success, EU Health Union, strategic gas reserves, interconnections with France, European Commission role
- Duration
- ~45 min
- Words
- 5,365
- Sentences
- 251
- Readability
- 48
- Grade
- 11.8
- Syntax
- 2.94
- Vocabulary
- 2.06
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
251 sentences in 110 paragraphs
I would like to thank the media, as I always do, for their presence here at the Spanish Embassy to the European institutions.
Naturally, I would also like to thank all the services of the Embassy, the new ambassador, the new team and, logically, also the entire team from the Office of the Presidency and from the Ministry of Foreign and European Affairs, who are always working to ensure that these Councils are as effective as possible for our interests.
Well, as usual, I will give a brief overview of the issues and then I will take your questions.
As you know, yesterday we started the European Council by addressing the issue of energy prices. You know that this is an issue that has been put on the agenda at the proposal of the Government of Spain.
We are aware that we have to take measures at national level; they are being taken by the Government of Spain, but also at European level. We have to take action because this is a problem that is already affecting all Member States of the European Union.
We are facing an unprecedented crisis that requires, as we have said on many occasions, extraordinary, innovative measures to control an unprecedented situation in the evolution of energy prices.
As you know, we have been working on this issue for weeks and we have certainly analysed the communication presented by the European Commission on 13 October.
We have endorsed the need for urgent action and, finally, we have agreed on three important advances on the initial Council text that I would like to share with you all.
Firstly, the Council invited the Commission to examine the functioning of the gas market, the electricity market and the CO2 emissions market. In the light of this study, it will assess whether certain commercial practices require action by the regulator at a later stage.
Secondly, the conclusions highlight the specificity of the situation in the Member States. This is also important for Spain because of the issue of interconnections with France.
And finally, we have obtained a commitment that the European Council will return to the issue at its next meeting in December, following the extraordinary meeting of
Energy Ministers on Tuesday 26 October and the presentation of the first studies by the European Commission in mid-November.
Therefore, from the point of view of the objectives that the Government of Spain had set for itself, these are objectives with which we are satisfied, objectives that have been met. We would have liked to go a step further, but we also understand that developments in Europe always move at a different pace.
However, I would like to stress that it was the Government of Spain that circulated various proposals at a European level to the European Commission, the institutions, in the Member States, which were related, firstly, with the review of the functioning of the electricity market.
Secondly, to increase our purchasing power vis-à-vis third countries with gas and, consequently, to build up a strategic gas reserve. And thirdly, to begin to study whether there are speculative phenomena linked to the CO2 emissions market and, in some way, both the European Commission's communication and the conclusions approved by the Council
These lines of work are already being implemented both by the European Commission and agreed by the European Council.
This is in relation to energy, which is undoubtedly one of the main topics of conversation in our country and of concern, as well as in European countries as a whole.
Secondly, a topic that has fortunately not occupied us as much time in the debate has been the situation of the COVID-19 pandemic.
You know what data Spain has. The data is extremely positive. Thanks to the vaccination strategy and its success, we are now almost close to eighty-nine per cent of the population over the age of twelve and, therefore, over the age, or rather, of the age to be vaccinated, fully vaccinated.
And in that sense, I would like to stress that we must never lose our guide.
If we have reached these figures, if we have reached a situation of pandemic control, although we have to monitor it very carefully, it has a lot to do, first of all, with the civic commitment of the citizens who have heeded the call of the health services to be vaccinated. Secondly, the professionalism of our health workers. And thirdly, collaboration, in short, the union between all the institutions.
And it must remain so. at a European level at any rate.
You know that we have taken stock of the work of the Union in the Health Union package, and it includes the creation of this authority within the European Union to prevent and respond to this type of emergency, which is what it is going to be called in its acronym ERA, HRA. In short, it is like a sort of CAES at a European level.
I think this will also be very important in coordinating potential and future pandemics in the future, hopefully many, many years from now.
And we conclude this section with the international and solidarity-based aspect of our action against the pandemic, agreeing on the need to commit ourselves much more to the global vaccination targets set by the World Health Organization.
Because of course Europe already has vaccination figures that are above 60 per cent. We are already at an average of 62, 65 per cent in Europe. In Spain, as I said before, we are above it. We are now approaching 90 per cent of the age group to vaccinate fully vaccinated.
The third topic we discussed yesterday was a sensitive issue with which you are familiar, and I had the opportunity to meet Prime Minister Morawiecki of the Polish Government. It is the issue of the Rule of Law following the ruling by the Polish Constitutional Court.
Well, it was a debate, which I believe was respectful but frank, in which it was made clear by a very large majority of the Member States around the Council table that it is essential to respect the Rule of Law. And respecting the Rule of Law means, among other things, that there is a kind of primacy with regard to what is, shall we say, the reading that is made by all the Member States, and it is the Court of Justice of the European Union that, in the final analysis, sets the standard.
And from Spain we have reaffirmed our confidence in the work of the European Commission to safeguard, and this is how it is recognised by the treaties, these treaties, and as you know, right now the Commission's legal services are assessing how to proceed and we as the Government of Spain are obviously supporting the Commission in defending and safeguarding of the Rule of Law and therefore of the Treaties.
After this first session, Thursday ended with a working dinner where we discussed topics such as international trade. That is where I made it clear, logically, the need to conclude trade agreements with an area of great interest to Spain, such as Latin America, Mexico, Chile, Mercosur - well, as you know. And today we have dealt with the issue of migration, which is always a tricky subject in the European Council, because the positions are very much at odds with each other and it is obviously difficult to find common ground.
In any case, we have been grateful that the European Council dealt with this issue, in the hope that we can once and for all begin negotiations on this, on this new migration and asylum pact that we need in Europe.
You know that the southern European Member States are maintaining, I believe, a fairly constructive attitude in this debate, while at the same time defending our legitimate interests, right?
But it is clear that there are still many, many months to go before an agreement can be reached.
However, the reality of migration means that we are dealing, as we have done today, with the external dimension of the European Union and, therefore, with everything related to the prevention of this migration, of the departure from the countries of origin and also of transit of irregular migration. We have asked for the financial instruments linked to this cooperation in the external dimension, with these third countries, to be strengthened. And also, logically, we have made an explicit reference, which you will see in the conclusions, to what is happening in Belarus and the use that Belarus is making of irregular migration as an element of pressure towards Baltic countries and also towards countries such as Germany, right?
Finally, today we have addressed the digital chapter, where we have also not had the opportunity to discuss it at such length as migration. There was much more consensus.
In any case, we have defended, both in the preparations and today, the need to incorporate two important elements, one of which is the need for 5G to reach all areas of the European continent, including rural areas, or especially rural areas.
And secondly, echoing the digital rights charter approved by the Government of Spain, which has been sent to the General Courts, that a similar exercise be carried out at European level. Digitalisation must also go hand in hand with a humanist perspective of defending values, which I believe the European Union undoubtedly exemplifies.
OK.
These are the issues. I remain available for any questions you may have.
As you know, we have dealt with the price of energy, migration, as two issues, together with the Rule of Law and Poland, which I believe have been the main issues of the debates we have had in the Council, but there are other very important issues, which are related to trade and also with the digital sector, which, I imagine, may go under the radar in the media, but which are undoubtedly very important for Europe and for Spain.
And with this, Carmen, director, I would be available to the media.
Q. [Lluis Tovar, Telecinco]. How are you President? Good afternoon, I'm Lluis Tovar from Telecinco news. I wanted to ask you two questions, a national key question. The first is about the request of the leader of his government's partner Podemos, Ione Belarra, this morning to review the coalition agreements. There seems to be unease among your partners about the possibility of Nadia Calviño leading the negotiation of the labour reform and they understand that this is an exclusive competence of the second vice-president.
So my questions are specific. Have you asked your first vice-president to take the lead in negotiating the labour reform and would you, for example, be happy with a labour reform without the agreement of employers?
And the second question on the issue of electricity. Beyond having managed to get high energy prices onto the European Council's agenda, which you see as a success. What measure, in the end, results? Why?
What measure would you be satisfied with if there is nothing in the short term that will bring down electricity prices beyond studying the functioning of the electricity market? The next time they will meet will be in December, then we will be in the middle of winter and prices may still be high.
What do you see as the success of this summit? Thank you.
President. Thank you very much, Lluis, for your questions.
With regard to the second question, there are a number of things to remember.
First, the European Council is not an executive body. The Executive in EU institutions is the European Commission and the European Commission at the request of the Government of Spain and other countries, and furthermore, at the proposal of many of the measures that we put into circulation, the Government of Spain drew up and published a communication. A communication that has one dimension, first and foremost the Commission should instead point out what tools all Member States have at a national level to be able to respond at a national level to the rise in wholesale electricity market prices. Secondly, it is already starting to point out some issues that need to be studied, and to this end it is asking the regulators for their opinion.
Firstly, it opens up the possibility that we can effectively make a joint purchase of gas from different Member States. This has been a proposal that Spain has defended from the outset and which has already been taken up by the European Commission and, I must tell you, by a large number of Member States.
This, as you will understand, does not happen overnight and is therefore something that the Commission is already working on.
And secondly, it recognises that the electricity market, the formation of prices, we have to examine exactly how it works and whether or not it is being efficient in this context, in which gas prices are rising and the prices of renewable energies are becoming more and more competitive.
Therefore, I would like to say that I believe that in a matter of a month and a half, an issue that was not on the European agenda, that today it is on the European agenda, where in little more than two months there has already been a communication from the European Commission, that the European Commission has been asked to draw up a report after 15 November, when we will know the regulator's opinion, and that we will return in December, which is when we will physically be here, because that is when the Council is held, not that we have decided, but that it is in December when the Council is convened, I believe that these elements obviously give rise to a certain hope that the European Union, also at supranational level, will take action on the matter.
And I think this is very important. And I think it is also fair to recognise the leadership of various governments, including the Government of Spain. This is so.
And secondly, in relation to the request of the partners for the meeting on the issue of labour reform, what you were asking me. Look, three things, the first on deadlines, the second on content, and the third on methods.
With regard to the deadlines, the coalition government agrees, and we have also agreed with the European Commission, that before the end of the year, this proposal and approval of the labour reform should take place.
Secondly, on the content: the coalition government agrees that we have to carry out a comprehensive reform in order to definitively eliminate many of the ills of our labour market, which were aggravated by the Partido Popular's labour reform. I am talking about precariousness and I am also talking about job creation.
And thirdly, on the method. Well, we are talking about a structural reform, a reform that affects very many ministries. Now, thinking, at least five ministries: Labour, Economy, if we talk about Social Security rebates, it is affecting the Ministry of Social Security and Social Inclusion. If we talk, for example, about training, it is also affecting the Ministry of Education and Vocational Training. If we are talking about public money, it is affecting the Ministry of Finance.
In short, at least five ministries are directly affected by the debate on labour reform. Therefore, there is no intrusion. What we have is collaboration.
What we have is coordination, and what we have is a contribution from all the ministries to effectively implement an important reform that our economy needs and that our country's workers and businessmen and women also need.
This is what we have done in other procedures, for example, with the General State Budget, and also with the Housing Law. I know it is a much more laborious way of proceeding, because it involves many ministries, but in the end it is the most effective way of dealing with a reform as important as this one.
Q. [Inaudible]. I wanted to follow up on these two issues. The first, because he thinks the result is so good in terms of...
President. I didn't say I thought it was so great. I correct you, I said it is a step forward. Now, if you call it great, I didn't say that.
Q. [Inaudible]. Well, but that's progress. No, I mean, the question is very simple: Do you keep your promise that Spaniards will pay the same this year as last year?
President. 2018 on average, net of inflation. Yes, that is the proposal. That is the proposal, that is the compromise.
Q. [Almudena Guerrero, Onda Cero]. Good afternoon, president. Still on the subject of the relationship with your partners, I understand from your words that you then support the first vice-president, Nadia Calviño, intervening in the negotiations. And how do you assess the reaction of Unidas Podemos? I don't know if you've had the opportunity, if you've been able to find a space and you've spoken in the last few hours, or today with Yolanda Díaz, the vice-president, the Minister for Work.
President. I have just left the Council.
Q. [Almudena Guerrero, Onda Cero]. But what about the former? Thank you. And secondly, if you will allow me, on yesterday's agreement with the Partido Popular on the constitutional bodies, how do you respond to those who criticise and consider these profiles to be very ideological? Thank you.
President. Well, thank you very much, Almudena. In relation to the first, I would qualify the verb. Let's see, different ministries have worked on the Housing Law, not just the Ministry of Housing, in this case the Ministry of Transport, Mobility and Urban Agenda, but also Social Rights because it affects social rights.
Not only has the Minister for Finance been involved in the General State Budget, but also the Secretary of State for Social Rights, who is from Unidas Podemos, because there was interest and because we are aware that the General State Budget affects each and every ministry.
What do I mean by this? What I mean by this is that a structural reform as important as the reform of our labour relations affects at least five ministries, directly Economy, Work, Education and Vocational Training, Finance and Inclusion and Social Security, and therefore here it is not, I insist, to intervene, it is to contribute, it is to coordinate, it is to collaborate.
And in this reform, what we have to be aware of is that it is the Government of Spain's reform and therefore it is all the ministries that are directly affected, those that have to contribute their vision in order to achieve the best labour reform that our country can have.
I believe this is a great opportunity. I believe that we have also set ourselves the milestone of being able to complete this reform before the end of the year.
This is a great opportunity to resolve many of the deficits in our labour market: in the area of job insecurity, in the area of the competitiveness of our companies, but also in the objective of continuing to raise the minimum wage, equality between men and women, and the training and skills of our workers and our young people.
Undoubtedly also the updating of collective bargaining, its modernisation. In short, there is a wide range of issues that do not only affect one ministry, but many ministries. So we are talking about a government law.
And what I want to underline is that what we are talking about here is to contribute, to collaborate and to cooperate, which is a much more, well, laborious process. As I said before, it is obvious, but it is the best, the most effective way to bring to a successful conclusion this great opportunity for the Government to update our labour rules.
Q. [Almudena Guerrero, Onda Cero]. (Inaudible).
President. Ah, yes, excuse me, Almudena. You are right about the agreement, I think it is very important.
I think the most important thing is that after a thousand days it has been shown that when we both want to dance, we can dance on these issues that are important for our country.
It was resolved in a matter of 24 hours after a thousand days of deadlock and so what I want to do is thank the political parties behind this agreement. In the end, each political party, in this case each parliamentary group, chooses its profiles.
And the most important thing for me as President of the Government of Spain is to protect the agreement, because I believe that the blockade leads to a deterioration and weakening of our institutions and this is what we have to avoid.
Therefore, I am grateful to the parliamentary groups that have reached this agreement and allowed these four institutions to be unblocked, but at the same time, after listening to the leader of the opposition, I would like to remind him once again that there is no room for compromise when it comes to compliance with democratic legality and the obligations laid down in the Constitution and that the unblocking of four constitutional institutions, if anything, highlights the senselessness of blocking an institution as important to our democracy as the governing body of the judges.
Q. [Carlos Cue, El País]. Yes, thank you very much. With regard to energy, if there are several countries like Spain that are clear about it, why is it so difficult to agree on the change in Brussels? Who opposes? And what arguments are they giving for not doing so?
On the labour reform, it is a particular reform, because there is a negotiation with trade unions, there is a negotiation here in Brussels, which yesterday was with the President of the Commission.
I do not know if they discussed this issue, but in any case, who has to negotiate, the first vice-president or the second vice-president? Who is the negotiator of the labour reform, because so far it has been the Ministry of Work.
And finally, do you agree that the Member of Parliament, Alberto Rodríguez, should lose his seat?
President. Thank you, Carlos.
There are three questions and I would like to answer them. With regard to..., it is not that there are countries that are opposed, there are not, in fact. No one can deny that we are actually experiencing a rise in electricity prices in the wholesale gas market and that this is having an impact on the competitiveness of our industries and also, logically, on economic recovery and, ultimately, on citizens. No one is against it. The only thing that has happened is that the Commission has been asked to carry out studies to assess exactly how effectively and efficiently the electricity markets work and, on that basis, to operate. This is what has been requested by those countries that are currently a little more... or less clear, to put it in a much more diplomatic way, than the Government of Spain, which is very clear, that we have to act on the electricity market, on price formation. But, anyway, that is why I said yesterday that the times in Brussels, as there are 27 of us and not just one country, are different. But in any case, progress has been made on the conclusions and also on the recommendations put forward by the Commission in its communication.
And I insist, the debate will not stop until December, because on the 26th we have a meeting of energy ministers. Subsequently, in mid-November, the European Commission will hear the regulator's views on the functioning of the markets. You will then make your proposals and then, in December, we will have a further debate on this issue in the European Council. So what I want to say to you is that this will not, not at all, be overshadowed, it will be off the agenda, but it will be on the European agenda. I think it is important to underline this, because it is true.
Secondly, in relation to who negotiates: the government negotiates, the government negotiates, the government negotiates. And I insist, here we are talking about one of the most important laws, one of the most important reforms, one of the most transcendental, that any government has in a legislature and which affects a large number of ministries. And, therefore, these ministries must also contribute and must be involved in this dialogue, as we have been in the drafting of budgets, as we have been in the Housing Law and as we have been in many other laws. If we have been there, how can we not be there for the labour reform? And I insist: Is it a more laborious procedure? Yes, it is, but it is the most effective.
And with regard to the third question, Carlos, I would like to say the following: look, as President of the Government of Spain, I feel obliged to remind you of some basic issues. The first is that we live in a democracy where there is independence of powers. We have the legislative power, we have the executive power and we have the judiciary. There is an issue here that has to be settled between two government powers, the legislative and the judiciary. And, therefore, what the executive power does, and what I personally do, is to respect the independence of those powers. And so, logically, both will have to pronounce themselves. It seems that the Supreme Court has already ruled, as the legislative power will have to rule on this case soon.
Q. [Sandra Gallardo, Radio Nacional]. Hello, good afternoon president, on the subject of energy, given that for the moment there are no measures at European level, I wanted to ask you about the decree that has already been validated in Congress. Iberdrola has said that they are prepared to maintain prices for industry, not raise electricity prices for industry, if you withdraw the decree. I don't know if they would be willing to do that. And on the issue of coordination in the negotiation of labour reform, the government negotiates, but someone has to coordinate the ministries. Would it be Nadia Calviño? Would that be you? Would it be the Minister of the Presidency? Thank you.
President. I insist... Well, I don't know if you remember, if you won't allow me, that in everything to do with the Recovery, Transformation and Resilience Plan there is a round table where the Government of Spain is represented and the social agents are represented. I chaired that round table.
It is true that within this round table there are other coordination sections, where the labour market, digitalisation, ecological transition, etc., etc., etc., are to be found. What I am saying is this: this is a whole-of-government reform and the whole of government is contributing. And what we are talking about, therefore, is neither meddling nor intervening, but contributing, coordinating and collaborating.
And with regard to the first question, the Government of Spain will always be there, it will always be there. We have done it before. We were one of the first governments in Europe to act, and to act decisively.
I always repeat, we have been working for three years on structural measures, promoting renewable energies, on economic measures, for example, with the drastic reductions we have made in taxes - VAT, special taxes, the tax on energy production. In short - and the fixed costs - in short, everything we have in our power to be able to cushion the rise in prices on the wholesale markets. And we will continue to do so. We will continue to take action where necessary to protect consumers, to build transparency into the market, to protect and defend the interests of industry, which are also vulnerable to price rises. And also, logically, to specify in much greater detail which companies are or are not susceptible to this review of excess profits, in the event that they have been produced and are being applied.
These are the four areas on which the Government of Spain is working: consumers, industry, transparency and also specifying much more specifically which companies should be affected by this review of excess profits because they are being applied to third parties.
And if you want, one last question, Carmen, and now...
Q. [Andrés Gil, Eldiario.es] Thank you very much, Andrés Gil, Eldiario.es.
I wanted to ask you, insisting on the issue of labour reform: today you speak of structural reform, in the PSOE Congress you expressly spoke of repealing the Partido Popular's reform, the first vice-president has spoken of a "balanced package of changes that modernise our labour market"; I wanted to know if there is agreement on this assessment and, on the other hand, if you also share what the first vice-president says about negotiations starting now, when the social dialogue has already been going on for five months.
And, on the other hand, I wanted to ask you about the pact for the Constitutional Court:
What does the Government expect in return, in exchange for having allowed the PP, or agreeing to allow the PP, to bring before the Constitutional Court the judge who had to be removed from the Gürtel case by his colleagues because of his closeness to the PP, and a professor who manoeuvred with Ignacio González to move judges and prosecutors to bring PP leaders implicated in corruption cases?
Thank you.
President. Thank you very much, Andrés, for your questions. Regarding the last question: look, for me the most important thing is to safeguard the agreement. The pact. It is necessary to comply with the mandate of the Constitution. Each political party, each parliamentary group is responsible, in this case, for who it is proposing.
For me, as President of the Government of Spain, after more than 1,000 days of blocking five such important institutions, many of which are, shall we say, embedded in our Constitution and we need parliamentary majorities like the ones we need and, therefore, the agreement with the Partido Popular is essential, because otherwise it could not be reached, it seems to me that my duty, my obligation, is to protect this agreement and promote renewal and, therefore, I do not have much more to say. Others will have something to say about it.
In any case, I would like to reiterate that there is still an important institution to be renewed, which is the General Council of the Judiciary and that, therefore, for the same reasons that have led to the renewal of these four institutions, the fifth must also be renewed. It makes no sense, it is not in the Constitution, it is outside the Constitution, that the General Council of the Judiciary is still blocked.
And with regard to the first question: look, you can say things the way you want to say them. In any case, the Government of Spain has an investiture agreement, it has a coalition government agreement and therein lies the commitment of the Government of Spain to update the labour regulations in our country. We want to do this hand in hand with employers and trade unions. We have agreed with the European Commission that this reform will be implemented before the end of the year.
Therefore, we are talking about an important reform that any government has throughout the legislature, which is a law of the Government of Spain and therefore affects, I insist, once again, Work, the Economy, the Treasury, Social Security, Education; because we are talking about training, vocational training, active employment policies, public resources, Social Security bonuses, aspects related to work, but also with the economy. In short, we are talking about an important law that affects many ministries, and all the ministries have to contribute, they have to coordinate, they have to collaborate. And that is the, shall we say, the request and the order that I have given to all the ministers of my government.
Well, thank you all. I hope you have a safe return to Spain, to those of you who are not correspondents here.
Non official translation