Control Session of the Government. Senate. Questions to the President of the Government.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

19 October 2021 · Control Session of the Government. Senate. Questions to the President of the Government · Senate, Spain

Context
Sánchez addressed the Spanish Senate during a government control session on October 19, 2021, responding to questions about rising electricity prices across Europe.
Main themes
Electricity prices, energy market regulation, government measures on energy costs, tax reductions on electricity bills, renewable energy promotion, self-consumption incentives, European energy crisis, opposition criticism, sustainable development, Recovery Plan funding, climate change policy
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,363
80th percentile
Sentences
143
79th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
12.3
49th percentile
Syntax
3.31
83rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 42%41%
  • Social 22%21%
  • Institutional 22%21%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

143 sentences in 56 paragraphs

President: Thank you very much, Mr. President. Your Excellency, look, from January to September, the price of electricity has increased by 61.7% in Italy, almost 60% in Germany, 56% in France, and in Spain it was 61%.

For example, on October 7, just to cite one day, the price of electricity in the wholesale market in Italy was 307.72 euros per megawatt/hour. In Germany, it was 302.53 euros, 289.32 euros in France, and in Spain, on that same day, it was indeed 288.53 euros per megawatt/hour.

What do I want to say with this? Well, we are not only talking about an issue concerning Spain, but we are talking about an issue that affects all of Europe, and therefore, we also have to talk about Europe. This is the first clarification, Your Excellency.

The second is that we must always differentiate, always differentiate between the evolution of prices in the wholesale energy markets, where little or nothing can be done, not by this government, but by all governments, and differentiate it from what the electricity bill is. Which is, ultimately, what we Spaniards pay when we have to address this bill monthly or as they have chosen.

In this sense, it should be noted that the electricity bill, Your Excellency, has three components. The first is the cost of energy component, the second is the tax component, and the third are the fixed components, the fixed costs.

And what I have to tell you is that Spaniards, when December arrives, what they will see thanks to the measures taken by the Government, is that taxes will be reduced, or will have been reduced then, by 61% and fixed costs by 50%.

That is what the Government is doing, Your Excellency. Therefore, I cannot accept your premise that the measures being implemented by the Government of Spain are not effective. This is a problem that concerns the Government of Spain because it worries us.

And by the way, in all the measures that I will detail later, you either voted against them or did not vote in favor.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the reply made by Senator Javier Ignacio Maroto Aranzábal of the Popular Party Group.

President: Thank you very much, Mr. President. Look, Your Excellency, regarding October 12, I have never had any problem with people shouting or booing. Insulting is another matter. And it pains me to hear the main opposition party legitimizing with their words in this chamber, in the Cortes Generales, as I told the president of your group, the insults; it seems absolutely counterproductive to me.

It always happens the same way, Your Excellency. It always happens the same way. When you are in opposition, no socialist president is legitimate to govern this country.

I only want to remind you of one thing, Mr. Maroto, just one. This bench has no more, but also no less, the same right as you do, if the Spaniards want it, to govern this country.

But well, let’s get to the question, to what is appropriate, Your Excellency.

We already know your proposals because you governed, Your Excellency. The Government of Spain has had, or will have to pay, around 1 billion euros for the rulings that were pending as a result of the retroactive measures that halted the development of renewable energies.

Well, it is 10 billion euros, the lady, the vice president, Mrs. Ribera, corrects me. By the way, if that is the case, I do not know very well why you wear that pin of the 2030 Agenda if you are so committed to sustainable development.

But look, the commitment of the Government of Spain, you know, the commitment is that Spaniards, thanks to the social buffers that the Government is implementing, will pay on average an electricity bill similar in 2021, discounted precisely for inflation, to what they paid in 2018.

And what have we been doing for the past three years? Furthermore, you will surely applaud, Your Excellency, if you are so committed to sustainable development and the fight against climate change. A plan with different measures.

The first, block 1, structural measures. What we are doing is promoting renewable energies, those that you stopped and that, moreover, with retroactive measures, you tried to halt.

Secondly, measures to promote self-consumption. Do you remember the Sun tax? You who are so committed to the 2030 Agenda. Well, we repealed it. We simplified the administrative processing precisely to promote self-consumption for families. And in the Recovery Plan, Mr. Maroto should be pleased, we have included 1.2 billion euros in aid for self-consumption. I could tell Mr. Casado to approve the budgets so that this also incentivizes the achievement of the Sustainable Development Goals.

But we also incorporate more competition in the electricity sector, for example, by promoting renewable energies. It is also one of the sustainable development goals, precisely so that through auctions we have greater penetration of renewable energies in the system.

And we also made a commitment to electrification. Look, right now a National Fund for the Sustainability of the Electric System is in parliamentary processing that does the following. It removes part of the regulated costs from the electricity bill, which consumers currently pay 100%, and transfers them to the companies that sell energy, that is, both electricity, gas, and oil.

Well, this is not called Robin Hood, Your Excellency, this is called redistribution and an equitable distribution of burdens between consumers and companies.

Block 2, temporary measures. We have reduced VAT from 21% to 10%, Your Excellency, why do you not vote in favor of this measure? We have reduced the special tax on electricity to 0.5%. Do you remember that tax? That is the tax you created when you were in government. For example, also the 7% tax on the value of electricity production that we suspended, right?

Thirdly, protection for vulnerable households. Your Excellency, I must tell you that this government is protecting, thanks to measures such as the provision of the vital minimum supply to 1.2 million households and, effectively, preventing excessive profits of electricity companies.

Look, you have not voted in favor of any of these measures; you have voted against many of them. Well, Your Excellency, I ask you, truly, as a state party, as a party that aspires to govern and that has governed this country, and that has made many mistakes precisely in promoting renewable energies, for a little sense of state and support for the Government of Spain. There are many people who are having a hard time. Industries, users, small and medium-sized enterprises. And what they would like, what they would want from the Popular Party, is a much more constructive and responsible opposition, not with the Government, but with their country.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Senator Josep Lluís Cleries i Gonzàlez of the Nationalist Parliamentary Group.

President: Well, that is your context, Your Excellency, because, well, it seems to me that it gave the impression that it was more of a rhetorical question than a conversation that we could have here in the Senate.

You ask whether the conditions are in place for the Catalan parliamentary representatives to support the General State Budgets for the year 2022.

And I believe that the context and the conditions are indeed present, Your Excellencies, I regret to have to disagree with you again.

I believe, first of all, that it is a sign of confidence to economic and social actors at a time when the economic recovery, thanks to the success of the vaccination strategy, is precisely consolidating that economic recovery.

Secondly, I believe that the conditions are in place because there is a government that is committed to making that economic recovery as fair as possible, that is, distributing wealth and not leaving it in the hands of a few.

And thirdly, because there are indeed European funds that we also have to transfer to the autonomous communities, to other institutions, such as municipalities. There are also very emblematic projects for Catalonia, for your land, and consequently, I believe that those conditions, in the opinion of the Government of Spain, are present.

I always have the lingering feeling, Your Excellencies, of listening to Catalan nationalism. Well, it seems that all the problems, all the responsibilities, are of other institutional actors. Don’t you have any responsibility? That is to say, what you are saying is that the Government of Spain does not invest in the expansion of El Prat in Catalonia because the Government of Spain does not want to. And you, on the other hand, the Government of the Generalitat of Catalonia, want to, right? You do not even believe that, Your Excellency.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the reply made by Senator Josep Lluís Cleries i Gonzàlez of the Nationalist Parliamentary Group.

President: Thank you very much, Mr. President. Thank you, Your Excellency, for at least opening up to talk, to converse, to dialogue about a possible approval of the budgets by your parliamentary group in the Cortes Generales.

I believe you will be right if you approve those General State Budgets because they are good, they are good in terms of social cohesion, they are good for territorial cohesion, they are also good to make, ultimately, the economic recovery as fair as possible after such a terrible pandemic that many Catalans have suffered and, of course, also the entire Spanish society.

Look, I think some examples can persuade you to open up to that negotiation and dialogue with you for the approval of the budgets. It is the largest social and public services investment in democratic history. More than 240 billion euros. I believe that the reasons and motives are in the minds and hearts of all after the suffering of this pandemic.

Look at the revaluation of pensions; you talk about infrastructure, but we must also talk about people. There are pensioners in Catalonia, 1.5 million pensioners in Catalonia who will see their pensions revalued and, above all, even more the non-contributory pensions or the increase in investment in dependency policies; there are 240,000 users in Catalonia, and thanks to that transfer that is budgeted at 382 million euros, they will benefit. Or, for example, the National Health System focusing on primary care, on oral health, or on something that I believe is very important, which is mental health, where Catalonia will receive or has, rather, 7.5 million users, and the National Health System as a whole, that of the entire country, will increase by 11%, and in particular these three items: primary care, oral health, and mental health will be multiplied by three. Or the investment in social protection with that social achievement that the Government of Spain has achieved, which is the minimum vital income that increases by 3% and will benefit more than 60,000 people who today, fortunately, thanks to the commitment of the Government of Spain, receive it in Catalonia, thus fighting against child poverty, which I believe is the most painful poverty, or the thermal social bonus. Earlier we were talking precisely about the need to defend and protect the most vulnerable groups. Well, this is an item that will increase by 43%, with 110,000 Catalan households benefiting. The boost to key sectors such as R&D+i, such as, for example, cultural investment, as well as SMEs and self-employed workers in Catalonia, the youth, I do not want to forget about them, with access to housing thanks to the 250 euros for rent for those young people under 35 in Catalonia, as in other parts of Spain, there is tension and difficulty in being able to emancipate. In short, the investments in the Mediterranean corridor, in commuter trains, the Mediterranean corridor with 120 million euros and commuter trains with almost 680 million euros. In short, Your Excellency, look, I will conclude with some words from the current president of the Generalitat of Catalonia, Mr. Aragonés, who stated on September 28 in the general policy debate in the Parliament of Catalonia the following: In October, I quote verbatim what Mr. Aragonés said, "We will present the budgets of the Generalitat that will be increased by three billion five hundred million euros compared to those of 2021, thanks to European funds and REACT-EU funds." Well, where do those funds come from? They come from Brussels. They are transferred through the central government. Therefore, Your Excellencies, I celebrate that you at least open up to negotiate those budgets and, obviously, from the fundamental disagreements that we have among the different parliamentary groups. I believe there is one thing that unites us especially in this situation, and that is prioritizing policies for the benefit of people and, of course, also for the benefit of the territories. The Government of Spain will be there, and I would like to extend that request for negotiation not only to your group but to the entire Chamber because I believe that the effort will be worth it.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Senator María Pilar González Modino, from the Parliamentary Group of the Confederal Left.

President: Ladies and gentlemen, first of all, I want to thank you for the tone and I also want to thank you for bringing the debate on inequality to this discussion, which is probably the debate of our time, and I believe it is very important that we do not sugarcoat things. Spain is an unequal country. It was before the pandemic and, unfortunately, after the pandemic, those gaps have widened as a result of it.

It is true that after the financial crisis, what we have seen has been austerity policies that we would very likely have to qualify as unsolidarity, and what they did was weaken the public response, the common response, and it weakened primary care, which is so important across the State. I mean, it is true that there were governments that precisely strengthened that type of primary care, such as the socialist governments in Andalusia until the change of government more than two years ago. But in any case, that inequality exists, it was exacerbated as a result of the financial crisis and the neoliberal response based on austerity, on unsolidarity, and it is also true, ladies and gentlemen, that what we are seeing after this pandemic is a paradigm shift, in the sense that citizens have realized not only in Spain but across Europe, that those who tried to turn what is a basic right, such as health, education, or pensions, into a commodity, as neoliberal doctrine has always defended, are not only a real danger to health but also to the economy of our countries.

I believe that precisely after this pandemic we are emerging from this crisis with an intensity in economic recovery, in the levels of employment that we have already recovered, the levels of employment we had before the pandemic, in contrast to what happened in the financial crisis, which took twelve years, ladies and gentlemen, twelve years to recover the levels prior to the financial crisis of 2008. I believe it also demonstrates that social democracy, which this government and the Socialist Party I lead humbly represent, is showing not only that it is possible to promote fair economic recoveries but also economic recoveries from a much greater efficiency perspective than those proposed by neoliberal doctrine.

That said, ladies and gentlemen, we do not hide the seriousness of the situation of inequality. I have said it before, in response to another parliamentary group, the poverty, the exclusion that hurts me the most is child poverty. More than two million children are suffering from poverty in our country. As a result of that commitment against child poverty, the Government of Spain approved the minimum vital income. It was a policy that was in the hands of the autonomous communities, which thanks to a structural reform the Social Security took charge of, and today, fortunately, more than 800,000 compatriots are receiving a minimum vital income.

And I also want to add that of those 800,000 people, 400,000 are children who benefit as a result of that minimum vital income. I cannot think of a greater example to demonstrate the social commitment that we on the left have, precisely to end social exclusion.

You see, what we do in the General State Budgets is increase the allocation linked or destined for the minimum vital income. As I told you before, we are revaluing pensions and, therefore, putting an end to that counter-reform that the Popular Party approved with its absolute majority in 2013, breaking all the agreements with social agents. We have recovered that consensus with social agents. We are increasing pensions in accordance with the CPI. 98,000 elderly people in Andalusia will benefit, with an allocation of more than 566 million euros. In the chapter on scholarships, because this is also important, I want to tell you that at the national level we will exceed 2,199 million euros and it will benefit 210,000 students from Andalusia. And this is essential if we want to activate social mobility among the youth of Andalusia and the whole country.

I would not like to end this first round in response to your question by saying that fortunately and thanks to the policies implemented by the Government of Spain in the toughest moments, such as the ERTE, as well as all the measures linked to the social shield, the minimum vital income, direct aid, or also benefits for the self-employed.

Fortunately, this crisis, which has been very serious, the worst, the worst health, economic, and social emergency in the last 100 years, has fortunately been mitigated to a large extent by those public policies we have implemented.

It is not enough, it is not. We will have to continue doing many things, among them, for example, managing European funds. You see, many times when I am asked, well, what do European funds mean? I always say two things: European funds mean, for example, vocational training for our youth, which has been one of the pending subjects of our education system. We are going to incorporate more than 5 billion euros into vocational training. Our commitment is to increase vocational training places by 200,000 by 2024 for students. And in addition to those 5 billion euros, more than 1 billion euros will come from European funds. Therefore, European funds mean education and European funds also mean a huge opportunity for a territory like Andalusia. They mean a huge opportunity because European funds must be linked to reindustrialization.

And the energy transition, the energy transition will redefine the location of much of that industry in the 21st century, and I believe that Andalusia has the best conditions to take advantage of that reindustrialization.

If you ask me, the only doubt I have is whether the current government of the Junta de Andalucía has the vision to make that a reality.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the reply made by Senator María Pilar González Modino, from the Parliamentary Group of the Confederal Left.

President: I believe that the competitiveness that, for example, an investment as important as that of Algeciras-Bobadilla can represent, which can position Jaén as a logistics platform in our country, is a huge opportunity for Andalusia and for the whole country.

I do not measure development solely in territorial terms, although we obviously give that prominence to territorial development. But I believe that we precisely need projects that unite the country, and that must be conveyed beyond Andalusia.

Ladies and gentlemen, we will always, always, always comply with Andalusia.

In this budget, we comply with the Statute of Autonomy in the percentage of public investment for Andalusia, and we are also complying with direct aid to companies to save them from the tragedy of the pandemic, as well as in everything related to training, ERTEs, the protection of the self-employed, and ultimately, also the minimum vital income.

And that is where we will meet.