Press conference by President of the Government following meeting of Extraordinary European Council

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

20 September 2018 · Extraordinary European Council informal summit press conference

Context
Sánchez addressed press following the Extraordinary European Council informal summit in September 2018, summarizing discussions on migration, security, and Brexit.
Main themes
Migration and asylum policy, EU internal security, Brexit, FRONTEX border control, fight against terrorism, European Public Prosecutor, data interoperability between member states, human trafficking, national sovereignty, civil protection and natural disasters, Austrian EU Presidency
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,839
84th percentile
Sentences
186
87th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.89
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
39th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

186 sentences in 64 paragraphs

President of the Government .- First of all, good afternoon.

Thank you for attending this press conference to give you, albeit briefly, an explanation of the issues addressed at this informal summit, this informal European Council.

You know that the three issues we have addressed have been, firstly, the internal security of the European Union; secondly, the question of migration, and thirdly, the question of Brexit. And I will give you a brief summary of these three issues at this press conference, followed by any questions you may have.

As regards internal security, the proposal made by the Council and the Austrian Presidency, also as a result of the proposal made by the European Commission, was, to some degree, backed by all the Member States, in particular by the Government of Spain.

Basically, there were two key elements, in our opinion, to improve internal security on the European continent, in the European Union. Firstly, to strengthen the powers of the European Public Prosecutor in everything related to matters in the fight against terrorism, something that the Government of Spain supports, and we also proposed something in relation to this issue that is important in our opinion, which was also to see the powers of the European Public Prosecutor increased in relation to the fight against people trafficking. So, we backed the proposal to strengthen the European Public Prosecutor made by the European Commission, and what we have tried to do is to enhance these powers in relation to something important, as indeed is people trafficking.

The second question, which is closely related to the fight against terrorism, is that we all agreed on the diagnosis that there are cross-border networks for training and funding of terrorism that are not just located in the European Union, but also beyond the European Union and that, hence, it was and is very important to improve the degree of inter-operability of data between Member States. That was another of the proposals that the European Commission brought to the table, and which the Government of Spain supported, and I believe that as regards internal security, the two most important aspects, in my opinion, are these two: to strengthen the powers of the European Public Prosecutor in relation to the fight against terrorism, and the proposal that the Government of Spain also made, to extend powers related to human trafficking. And secondly, to improve the inter-operability of information sharing, of data bases, among Member States to make the fight against terrorism more effective.

Secondly, the issue of migration. In the end, migration has been, I would say 80%-85% of the content of the debates we held yesterday and today.

Yesterday, we made a more global reflection, a more abstract reflection, to put it another way. And today, what we have done is to focus more on the specific proposals made by the President of the European Commission in his speech on the State of the Union just a few days ago in the European Parliament.

The Government of Spain backed each of the proposals made by the European Commission. We support the proposal to strengthen FRONTEX with 10,000 staff, and, furthermore, negotiations on increasing the FRONTEX workforce will take place immediately, so that this can be reflected as soon as possible, I seem to recall by the year 2020.

We as a government simply proposed two questions, which is perhaps where the media have interpreted that there were some discrepancies with the Austrian President, Mr Kurz, which couldn't be further from the truth. I proposed this to him on his visit to Madrid, as I did today, and as, of course the "sherpas" of our governments have also done.

What we proposed is that FRONTEX must clearly be strengthened, but this must include two important elements, in our opinion. The first is flexibility, and the second is complementarity. Why flexibility? Because the needs to control borders are different in different Member States. We are 28 Member States and hence we need a certain degree of flexibility to coordinate and mould the needs that any given country may have with the capabilities offered by FRONTEX.

And secondly, complementarity. In other words, what FRONTEX cannot do is question national sovereignty, which we obviously support.

Hence, flexibility and complementarity, but we clearly agree that it should be improved and strengthened in relation to border control by FRONTEX.

There is a second important question, in our opinion, that was strongly debated by many different Member States, and which I believe will come to fruition during this Austrian Presidency, and hopefully at the Council meeting to be held in October, which is precisely related to civil protection.

Yesterday's debate on this was very interesting, as was today's, on wildfires, natural disasters that, unfortunately, various EU countries have suffered from over recent months. We all remember the tragedy in Greece this summer, but there were also wildfires in Portugal, Spain and Sweden.

Hence, the approach made by the Member States is that we must improve everything in relation to civil protection at a European level. The general opinion on this was fairly emphatic. I must say that this could be one of the points on which Europe is built.

We often think how this Europe can be built so as to be useful to its citizens. Well, today, precisely in the words of the Swedish Prime Minister, with whom I also had the chance to share a day of campaigning - and some of you present here were also there with me - he recalled the natural disasters, the wildfires that broke out this summer in Sweden, and how the support from different Member States was important in being able to put out these fires in Sweden.

So, what I want to say with this is that this type of measure, in terms of civil protection, is what helps build Europe because it shows how useful the European Union can be and I believe that this could be a good meeting point and a good agreement to reach in these months of the Austrian Presidency.

Hence, the second heading, that of migration, is where we didn't make any progress, but nor have we taken any steps backwards. That is, border control, perfect, in relation to FRONTEX. There are some elements that we have incorporated in the debate and which are related to integration policies, which is something the European Commission asked us to do in the Debate on the State of the Union. And also on the reform of the Common European Asylum System, which you are aware of and which is one of the proposals made by the Government of Spain on repeated occasions.

And another element that seems important to me, which is the reform of the Directive on Returns. This was brought to the table as one of the elements of the debate proposed by President Juncker.

So, internal security, migration, and then we have the issue of Brexit.

In relation to Brexit, I have two things to say: firstly, the dates, because there was talk about whether to hold another Council, as to whether two Councils would be held. Well, basically the proposal we agreed between all 27 Member States is that the moment of truth will come in October. In October, the key points of this major agreement we must reach between the 27 Member States, the European Union with the United Kingdom, must be agreed upon.

Hence, if, in the end, this negotiation process needs to be culminated with a final summit, then we will have to wait and see. But the goal of the 27 Member States and, of course, of the Government of Spain, is that by the month of October we must have reached a broad agreement on the key elements of what Brexit represents.

What are these essential elements for us? Well, Ireland of course - you already know that - is a position to be adopted by the whole of the European Union. Secondly, the internal market must be respected. The internal market must be respected. The four freedoms must be safeguarded. And of course, everything related to governance. In other words, with the cover of European jurisdiction and case law.

At our own particular level, the approach by the Government of Spain on Gibraltar is that, right from entering into government in June this year, we started negotiations along the lines proposed by the previous administration, because we have always considered that Gibraltar, and also Brexit, is a State matter. Hence, the negotiating team is the same as under the previous administration. And of course the approach is the same. The approach adopted by the Government of Spain is as follows: first, what we must do is reach an agreement that allows us, let's say, a transition period together with our relationship with the United Kingdom. There we must forge specific agreements on judicial and police cooperation. We must forge agreements on environmental issues. We must forge agreements on tax matters. We must forge agreements on tobacco. We must forge agreements on something that the Government of Spain feels is fundamental, which are the rights of the citizens living in Gibraltar or that live in Campo de Gibraltar. And finally, something that is also important for us, which is Gibraltar's commitment in the socio-economic development of Campo de Gibraltar.

These are the elements we inherited from the previous administration. The focus on the matter of Gibraltar is absolutely a State issue, and we hope we can forge an agreement with the United Kingdom on the issue of Gibraltar by October.

Hence, one dimension is the relationship between the European Union and the United Kingdom. And another dimension which is particular to Spain, is a bilateral matter which is Spain's situation with Gibraltar in order for this agreement to be reached, which we hope will take place by October.

Our goal, and this is the message we also want to transmit to the United Kingdom, is to reach this agreement by October.

Well, that was the outcome of the Salzburg Summit. I believe that this is the warm-up to important decisions that will materialise over the coming months, we hope that by October and, in particular, in relation to Brexit and Gibraltar, and also, logically that will materialise on the strengthening of border control as a result of the agreement on FRONTEX.

I wanted to end by logically thanking the Austrian Presidency for having given us the gift of this location and also the Mediterranean climate that we are all benefitting from. I will now take any questions.

Q.- Thank you and good afternoon. You mentioned that you had already spoken with the Austrian Chancellor after he said yesterday that Spain was one of the countries that had doubts about the need to strengthen FRONTEX. I don't know whether you believe that Spain's position was made clear to him, if you conveyed the message that way, and what caused him, in any event, to make these statements. And on another note, if you will allow a domestic question, perhaps you could clarify for us whether the controversy over your book with Carlos Ocaña and what the daily newspaper "El País" published today was an involuntary mistake, as announced, or whether you intend to take any measures in this regard. Thank you.

President of the Government.- Yes, as regards the first question, I can say to you that this is not the first time that I have met with the Austrian Chancellor. I spoke with him just a few weeks ago in Madrid to prepare this Informal Summit between Member States. And I can assure you that the approach I made to the Austrian Chancellor is the same as I made here. We want to strengthen FRONTEX.

I remember that even under a Socialist administration in 2004, we were already talking about strengthening FRONTEX, with the crisis of the boats arriving on our shores; I don't know if you remember. What do I mean by this? That the government has always advocated strengthening FRONTEX.

Which nuance did we incorporate? Firstly, flexibility. Because the reality of border control in Spain is not the same as in other countries. And secondly, complementarity. Sovereignty should not be brought into question in the border control of a Member States. Simply that. So, we agree on an increase in FRONTEX resources. We agree on increasing everything related to material capabilities, human resources, etc. But logically, with flexibility and complementarity.

That is what I said to the Austrian Chancellor when we met in Madrid, and that is what I conveyed to him last night. I am unaware of what Chancellor Kurz may have said on this matter. But I believe he is clear about it. It is a different matter if we have not been in tune in communicating this. I am not saying just us, but both of us. But I can state that the position of the Government of Spain has been the same and, in this regard, I want to be clear, because our position has been constant, including when we met with all the European leaders who have visited Madrid when talking about FRONTEX. And obviously at the Summit and at the European Council we held before the summer, when we spoke about FRONTEX, when I also clearly stated the need to strengthen the resources of this vital coast guard.

And, in relation to the second matter, I would say, look, a mistake was made in a review, which will be replaced in a new edition of the book. Aside from that, if the People's Party wants me to appear in the Upper House of Parliament, then I will heed that call.

But I would also warn the opposition: being in the opposition doesn't mean making a "noise". If they are dead set on making a "noise", then so be it. What the Government of Spain is going to do is govern. And I believe that we have implemented the right measures on electricity. What the Minister for the Treasury has proposed today is to study a reduction from 25% to 23% in the rate for Small- and Medium-Sized Enterprises which invoice less than 1 million euros.

The constitutional reform on special privileges will be brought before the Council of Ministers tomorrow. And, for example, something very important that the Minister for Work said today, which is that precisely thanks to the Master Plan for Dignified Employment, some 47,000 workers who were previously falsely self-employed have been uncovered and their situation has now been regularised as workers with permanent employment contracts.

I think this shows that the government is making progress, that this government governs, as has been shown today, specifically in the Lower House of Parliament, where all of the Royal Decree-Laws and parliamentary initiatives proposed by the Government of Spain have been pushed through.

If the opposition wants to make a "noise", then so be it. We want to govern.

Q.- The Foreign Affairs Councillor of the Regional Government of Catalonia, Ernest Maragall, has said on Onda Cero this morning that the Minister for Territorial Policy, Meritxell Batet, told him that she would give instruction to the Public Prosecutor on the proceedings on the pro-independence leaders. Does that sound real to you? Do you think that is plausible? Was that the case? Is that possible?

President of the Government.- I think that the Minister for Territorial Policy has already been quite clear in respect of this issue. So, I refer you to her statements.

Q.- The proposal from the European Commission on FRONTEX states that in the event of an emergency, the European Commission or Council may send forces to a country where a problem has arisen. Would you accept that proposal or do you consider that this invades the sovereignty of such countries as Spain? Secondly, in relation to the problem of the review of your book, do you believe that this irregularity may fuel doubts as to your thesis and strengthen the argument of those who say that it was plagiarised? Thank you.

President of the Government.- No to the second question. As regards the first question, the truth is that I am unaware of these aspects, of these details. I would first prefer to study this to be able to answer this question on what capabilities FRONTEX may have in potential crises.

Q.- Thank you, President of the Government. I wanted to ask you about Brexit. This morning we heard the Maltese Prime Minister stress that many European partners were in agreement that a second referendum should be held in the United Kingdom. I wanted to know whether you addressed this issue. Does Spain agree with this? What is Spain's position? And how did Theresa May react?

President of the Government.- Well, Theresa May was quite clear in her speech yesterday. She said that there would be no second referendum, and hence, what all the Member States and the negotiation team have to do is precisely be aware that time is running out, that the moment of truth has arrived, and that we all need to be united and determined. In two phases: the first is to close off the agreement on the transitional period. And then we also need to firm up the political declaration on the future relationship that the European Union will have with the United Kingdom.

Hence, what we are doing at the moment is dealing with the urgent part, which is firming up all the details in relation to Gibraltar. And of course, we then also need to firm up all the details on issues affecting this transition period with the United Kingdom.

I have to say that the negotiation team, with [Michel] Barnier at the head, is being extremely effective. It is doing a job that I believe deserves to be acknowledged under some extremely complex circumstances. Unity has been built, and I believe that this is very important for the times we are in, and we are now so very close to the finish line.

Of course, for Spain this issue is very important. For Spain, Brexit affects issues related to the rights of almost half a million Spaniards who live in the United Kingdom, but we are also talking here about designations of origin as well, which is very important in Spain. Or, for example, air transport. And also all those British citizens living in our country.

Hence, it is not only Gibraltar, but many other things that are also on the table in relation to Brexit. I believe we are close to reaching an agreement, and, as always happens in this type of negotiation, close to the end those issues and matters that are most controversial always end up being dropped.

Of course, if we were to say something it would be that, first we support Ireland in its demand, which, by the way, is being championed by [Michel] Barnier's team. Second, we do not want to see the Single Market watered down. Three, the four freedoms must obviously remain, which are the free movement of capital, services, goods and people. And four, logically, we have case law, and a European Higher Court of Justice that must also guarantee governance over this transitory period.

We have spoken about all of this. We have spoken, and I have explained this to our European colleagues, about the state of negotiations on Gibraltar. I found all the Member States supportive on the issue of Gibraltar, and I just hope that in October, I repeat, that this is the message I would like to give the public, and also, of course, to the British people since we need to reach an agreement on Gibraltar by October.

Q.- As regards the matter of the book (…), it was Pablo Iglesias who today used the word sleazy. Are you sleazy? Has your conduct been sleazy? Do you believe that this episode may weaken your relationship with a supposed partner at this time?

President of the Government.- I hope not.

Q.- This morning, Regional President Torra said that he tried to call you to comment on the leaking of some e-mails but that you were unable to answer but he explained that you would call him back later that afternoon. I wanted to know whether you finally spoke. At any event, what is your evaluation of this leak, of these e-mails between judges disparaging the pro-independence movement?

President of the Government.- Well, I have to admit that I haven't had time to see these images. At any event, as President of the Government, allow me to say the following: we do not give our opinions on private chats. What we can guarantee both Regional President Torra and those that feel affected by this type of information is that the Government of Spain trusts in the independence and impartiality of the judiciary in our country as regards the judicial proceedings opened against the leaders of the secessionist process in Catalonia. That is what I can tell you on this matter. And logically, when I have time, I will speak with Regional President Torra.

Q.- (Inaudible)

President of the Government.- I can tell you that I am optimistic with regard to the possibility of reaching an agreement with the British authorities on Gibraltar. It is true that there are still some catches but I think that the intention of the British and Spanish Governments is to reach an agreement by mid-October. That is something very important for us and what I would like to say to the British Government is that we need to reach an agreement on Gibraltar by mid-October.

Q.- (Inaudible)

President of the Government.- Rather than problems we have our differences regarding environmental, judicial and police cooperation and the freedom of movement, to which I would add on tobacco and taxation. You may think that there are differences on everything, but that is not true. We are very close to reaching an agreement, but as you are well aware, in a negotiation it is always complicated to reach an agreement ahead of the deadline. But I am optimistic and I believe that the focus and the conduct of the British Government are very constructive and I believe we can reach an agreement in October.

Q.- Mr President of the Government. You have told us your position on FRONTEX and the nuances introduced. But there was a second criticism made by Chancellor Kurz, which was on the issue of Spain not performing true checks on entries, which then allowed these migrants, who had recently arrived, to move on to Central Europe. That accusation is quite serious. I wanted to know your response to this, and what guarantees we have that these controls are carried out with, let's say, precision.

President of the Government.- I was unaware that Chancellor Kurz had made these statements, but what I can say to you on this question is that I wholeheartedly deny it.

Thank you very much.

Non official translation