Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

11 September 2018 · Parliamentary control session (responses in the Senate)

Context
Sánchez responded to parliamentary questions in the Spanish Senate on September 11, 2018, during a government control session addressing regional financing and interterritorial fiscal inequality.
Main themes
Regional financing system, fiscal discrimination against Asturias, FLA soft loans and interest forgiveness, Catalan independence commitments, solidarity principle and constitutional equality, Autonomous Communities funding, stability path vote, deficit targets and financial aid, interterritorial grievances
Duration
~52 min
95th percentile
Words
6,284
95th percentile
Sentences
258
93rd percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.33
84th percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
55th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 33%31%
  • Economic 31%30%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

258 sentences in 97 paragraphs

Madam Senator, you have also forgotten another issue, which is that the Government of Spain not only presented in the Congress of Deputies but also in this Chamber a stability path that allowed for 2.4 billion euros more for the Autonomous Communities and, consequently, also to resolve many of the issues related to dependency, healthcare, social services policies, and education. In short, with issues that logically affect each and every one of the Autonomous Communities, also this Chamber, and, of course, the people of Asturias whom you represent.

What is striking, Madam Senator, is that, in the end, your Group here, and also in the Congress of Deputies voted against a stability path that precisely aimed to increase the capacity of the regional governments.

Ms. Domínguez de Posada.- Thank you, Mr. President. Mr. President of the Government, I have not forgotten anything. My question is limited to the new regional financing.

Mr. Sánchez, Foro has been denouncing since 2015 that there is a serious discrimination in regional financing against Asturias, which favors Catalonia, Valencia, and Andalusia. And just yesterday, six Autonomous Communities, the most depopulated, demanded a new financing model based on the principle of equality for all Spaniards. And among those six Autonomous Communities, there were also some from the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party.

Asturias is owed not only the 75 million euros in VAT, as claimed by the Asturian socialist councilor, who should start by claiming the 815 million from the FLA, and the 213 million from the Mining Funds.

Now we know, after the arrival of your Government, that grievances between Spaniards and territories are increasing with commitments, such as the 6.5 billion euros to pay for the Catalan independence vote and the 850 million to silence your comrade Ximo Puig. This is the new regional financing system that the motion of censure has brought us.

Asturians do not want to be more than the rest of the Spaniards, but we cannot accept, either, to be less. Asturias suffers the consequences of a system approved in 2009 by the Zapatero Government, at the behest of the Catalan tripartite, which worsened from 2012 with financial aid measures to the Autonomous Communities, which represent another system of covert financing, which violates the constitutional principle of solidarity among Spaniards and territories, and which favors the wealthiest Autonomous Communities and, at the same time, those that most fail to meet deficit targets.

Mr. President, the FLA distributed 162.25 billion in soft loans among the Autonomous Communities in a discriminatory manner between 2012 and 2016, and subsequently forgave, that is, gave away, 22.061 billion: 7.509 billion euros in interest to Catalonia; 5.321 to Valencia; 3.551 to Andalusia; 271 to Asturias; 268.5 to Castilla y León; 187 to Madrid, and 120.8 to Galicia.

The comparative result of the State's gifts during this period is that Catalonia received 1,009 euros per inhabitant; Valencia, 1,078; Andalusia, 422; Asturias, 262; Castilla y León, 110; Galicia, 45; and Madrid, 29. Only Andalusia, Catalonia, and Valencia, according to official data from the Ministry of Finance, accumulate 75% of the total savings from interest forgiveness of all funds received.

It is not necessary for you to remind me that your Government is not responsible for that fact, because I already know it. And I conveyed this to Minister Montoro in an interpellation in this Chamber.

Foro has repeatedly claimed since 2015, in the General Board of the Principality, the grievance that the FLA represents, and the clear violation of Articles 2 and 138 of our Constitution, which guarantees the principle of solidarity and states that differences between the Statutes of Autonomy of the different Autonomous Communities cannot imply, in any case, economic or social privileges.

With a simple mathematical calculation, we can conclude that for Asturians to receive the same treatment as Catalans, Asturias is owed 1.028 billion.

Mr. President, the first 100 days of your Government have shown that it rewards independentist Communities by treating them dismissively and bringing independentists closer to subscriptions, when they do not accept the most basic rules of democracy and do not even attend the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council. That extra funding is provided to Communities that fail to meet deficit targets like Valencia, and that Asturians are sidelined with the firm commitments made with the Catalan and Valencian presidents, reducing their meeting with the Asturian president to a publicity photomontage, whose image is of those who embody the sacrifice of Asturias compared to other territories in Spain.

A financing system cannot be limited to ensuring that everyone gets a little more each year. It must be objective, technical, and independent of the economic situation. That said, with corrective mechanisms to be able to meet certain economic and social policy objectives.

Last Thursday, the acts to be held for the 40th anniversary of the Constitution were presented in Congress, and in your speech, Mr. Sánchez, you stated that the Constitution is honored by complying with it and making it comply. As Aristotle said, man is the master of his silences and the slave of his words. As head of the Executive, you must respect the constitutional principles of equality and solidarity among Spaniards and among territories, and enforce them, because the supposed equality of Spaniards is one of the myths that holds up the least when confronted with reality, giving a simple review of the different regional indicators reveals the magnitude of that inequality.

Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you, Mr. President.

Thank you, Madam Senator, for having read the text you brought. I believe that to hold a control session, we should have a conversation and listen to each other, not just come with things brought from home to read them here, I simply say that.

I will say one thing, ladies and gentlemen. Madam Senator, you have not answered me a very simple question, which is why the Foro de Asturias in this Senate, and also in the Congress of Deputies voted against the stability path that expanded the financing margin for the Autonomous Communities by 2.5 billion euros, why? If you care so much, if you care so much about the day-to-day lives of the Asturians, as this Government also cares and occupies itself, what you should have done is to be brave, to detach yourself from the Popular Parliamentary Group and defend the Asturians, instead of defending other types of issues.

Of course, the Madam Senator says that she has been defending since 2015 that the Government of Spain -- then from the Popular Party -- should have renewed the regional financing system. Look, Madam Senator, I sincerely tell you one thing, they were not listened to. Moreover, not only were they not listened to, but when they had the opportunity to vote on each and every one of the resolutions of the Socialist Parliamentary Group presented to the opposition in the Congress of Deputies, and here, in the Senate, you voted against, because you were aligned with the parliamentary majority of the Popular Parliamentary Group.

It is striking when one goes to Asturias --. By the way, I was in Asturias last weekend, congratulations on the Day of Asturias last Saturday -- the depopulation. In your six minutes, Madam Senator, you did not talk about depopulation. This Government is committed to the fight against depopulation, unlike the previous Government that did absolutely nothing.

This Government has always defended a fair financing system for Asturias and for those Autonomous Communities that are suffering from depopulation, that are suffering from an aging population and that are very aware, as this Government is, that the dispersion in many services requires a higher cost. This is what this Government guarantees and, of course, the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party will always guarantee, equality among all Spaniards, wherever they live.

The new Government of Spain has been clear, it has not lied; unlike previous Administrations. The truth is that, Mr. President, it is quite easy and interactive, as the Minister of Finance rightly says, to stir up the Popular bench a bit, which is appreciated. But, in any case, I will tell you one thing, Madam Senator. Look, the Government of Spain has already convened the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council twice. The Government of Spain has created a working group within the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council to continue working on the renewal of the regional financing system. And the Government of Spain, in the meantime, what it will do, ladies and gentlemen, is work to improve each and every one of the regional financings of all and each of the Regions of our country.

Therefore, Madam Senator, fewer words, more actions, support the stability path of the Government of Spain, because that will be better for the Asturians.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Ignacio Cosidó Gutiérrez, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

Mr. Cosidó.- Thank you very much, Mr. President.

Mr. President of the Government, although I am new to these matters, allow me to welcome you to this Chamber, on behalf of my Group. A Chamber that, although some members of your party may doubt it, represents, along with the Congress of Deputies, national sovereignty.

And for the good development of these debates, allow me to say that I will not read my speech, but I will ask the questions, not you. You provide the answers.

Mr. President, Spaniards know very well what the project of Mr. Torra and Mr. Puigdemont is. A xenophobic and exclusionary project, a project that has divided Catalan society and has broken coexistence in Catalonia. A project that violates the rights of those who do not share the independentist ideas. A project that has had a very high economic cost for Catalonia and for Spain with the exit, moreover, of 2,000 companies from that Autonomous Community.

But the question that many Spaniards, and many Catalans are asking is what will be the response of the Government of Spain to this project and this challenge?

This afternoon you have a good opportunity, here in the Senate, to tell us, to answer three very basic questions. The first is, on what terms are you going to engage in dialogue with Mr. Torra? What are the limits, Mr. President, of that dialogue? The second thing I would like you to answer in this Chamber is what referendum do you propose for Catalonia? The independentists propose a self-determination referendum. You propose a self-government referendum. But, does Catalonia not have self-government? What more self-government, which fits in the Constitution, do you want to give to Catalonia? Does the current Statute of Autonomy not have legitimacy? What is it, Mr. President, that you want to submit to a referendum by entering into the game of the independentists?

And finally, Mr. President of the Government, the key question: What price have you paid to reach La Moncloa, and how far are you willing to go to remain President of the Government?

President.- Thank you, Mr. President.

Thank you, Mr. Cosidó, and I also welcome you, congratulations on being elected President of the Parliamentary Group in the Senate, sorry, spokesperson, it is good that even in this, we interact with the Popular bench and the Government of Spain. I fear, Mr. Cosidó, that, in any case, the last of your questions has been a bit tricky. Or rhetorical.

As I fear that, unfortunately, because when the Popular Party is in opposition, the same thing always happens, when they are in Government, please, sense of State. The Socialist Party must support the Government of Spain even in the application of Article 155, as we did, but when they come to the opposition, that sense of State is conspicuously absent.

In any case, as we are going to talk a lot about Catalonia, I fear, because, indeed, we will always be permeating Spanish politics with doubts, shadows, and tricky questions. I will tell you one thing, Mr. Cosidó, look, just so we can move forward in the debate. What are the axes of the Government of Spain's policy regarding Catalonia? One, law and dialogue. Law and dialogue. I repeat, law and dialogue. The times you ask me, I will respond with these two phrases or these two words: law and dialogue. And I will tell you one thing, Mr. Cosidó, for the simple reason that we have always believed that there is only one legality, and that, consequently, in a democracy, what must be done is to comply with the legality, the sentences, that is not an option, it is an obligation, and, above all, the political leaders. That is what the Socialist Party has always defended when we were in opposition, and, of course, when we are in Government, we will ensure that the law and legality are upheld. But also, dialogue, Mr. Cosidó. We must bet on dialogue, also, with the Catalan citizenry.

Look, we are asking you, and I believe you can surely agree with us, that one of the main problems that Catalonia has is coexistence, not independence. Therefore, what we need to urge the president of the Generalitat of Catalonia and the entire Generalitat of Catalonia to do is to open a dialogue among Catalans, not Catalonia against Catalonia, but Catalonia with Catalonia. That is what the Government of the Generalitat of Catalonia must do. And the Government of Spain must help facilitate that dialogue.

What is the problem? What is your problem, Mr. Cosidó? Your problem is that you confuse opposing the Government with opposing dialogue. And the disconnect has been so great over these last few years that, look, in a hundred days, in a hundred days this Government has done what you were unable to do in seven years, convene the bilateral Commission that is included in the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia.

Of course, therefore, law and dialogue, and, secondly, Mr. Cosidó, coexistence, and not independence.

Look, Mr. Cosidó, you previously referred to the issue of self-government, and it is evident that I believe that after many years, I, look, I was elected Secretary General of the Socialist Party in 2014, you, at that time, were the Director General of the National Police, if I remember correctly, right? And, since 2014, how many electoral processes have there been in Catalonia? How many calls for referendums have there been in Catalonia, by the way, under your Government? That Government that now, when it reaches the opposition, demands a lot of firmness from the Government of Spain. Two referendums under the Government of the Popular Party in Catalonia, Mr. Cosidó, just so you keep that in mind when you criticize the current Government.

What is the element that currently unites Catalan society as a whole? Self-government. That is what we need to reinforce, Mr. Cosidó. Therefore, this Government is trying to normalize institutional life in Catalonia, as a preliminary step to normalizing social life in Catalonia, which is necessary.

That is what the Government is focused on, and we would like to have the support of the Popular Party bench, but, as in this and many other things, the Socialist Government, or the Socialist Party, to be more precise, when it is in Government and when it is in opposition, hears different nuances, different approaches from the Popular Party. State responsibility, when you are in Government you demand it from the rest of the parties, and state irresponsibility when you are in opposition.

Mr. Cosidó. Mr. Sánchez, you have not answered two questions that I believe are very important and that the Spanish people want to know.

The first is what referendum do you propose for Catalonia? And the second is whether you have, in some non-rhetorical way, any kind of agreement with the separatists who govern the Generalitat.

I do not know if you do not answer me because you do not know how to respond, because you do not know where you are going, or if you do not answer me because you want to hide the answers to those two questions from the Spanish people. But, in any case, allow me to say something very clearly, dialogue with the coup plotters is a tremendous mistake. Dialogue with the coup plotters only serves to strengthen them, to legitimize them, and to embolden us, which is exactly the scenario we find ourselves in currently.

Those who want to break Spain, those who want a totalitarian project for Catalonia, do not deserve that dialogue.

What I demand from you, Mr. President of the Government, is that you dialogue with the parties that defend the Constitution, with the parties that believe in democracy, and with the parties that defend the unity of Spain; those are the ones you must dialogue with to see how we confront that separatist challenge that comes from the coup plotters in Catalonia.

I tell you more, the pact you need to reach is not with the coup plotters; the pact you need to reach is with the millions of Catalans, with the majority of Catalans who feel Spanish, who at the same time feel abandoned by your Government and attacked by the separatists. It is with that majority that you must make a pact, Mr. President of the Government.

Look, I offer you all our capacity for dialogue, all the negotiation capacity of this Group, the Popular Group, to defend our rule of law together. To make the necessary reforms in our legislation that allow us to give a precise, a forceful response to anyone who calls for an illegal referendum, to anyone who commits crimes of secession or subversion, or for those who cannot have the right to be pardoned by the Council of Ministers because they have committed some of these crimes.

I offer you the maximum dialogue and collaboration, Mr. President of the Government, on behalf of my Parliamentary Group so that the money we all Spaniards pay with our taxes goes to improve healthcare, goes to improve education, goes to improve public services in Catalonia. It should not go to finance pseudo-embassies, or directly finance an independence process, ultimately, a new coup d'état in Catalonia.

I offer you, Mr. President of the Government, all our capacity for dialogue and negotiation to defend our Constitution, to maintain the resources before the Constitutional Court that the previous Government had filed, and for you to appeal to the Constitutional Court against any norm that is illegal.

And, ultimately, Mr. President of the Government, I conclude by saying that in a hundred days of Government you have practically rectified everything: you have rectified your economic policy, you have rectified your immigration policy, you have rectified in matters of justice, you have rectified in everything. You yourself acknowledged it.

What I ask you, Mr. President, is to rectify this policy of appeasement and dialogue with the separatists, because it is a policy that necessarily leads to failure. And the sooner you rectify this policy, the better it will be for everyone.

I ask you to rectify that policy, to do it as soon as possible, and I tell you that my Group will be waiting for you, that my Group will applaud that rectification and will support any forceful proposal that the President of the Government and the Government make to this coup challenge to our rule of law, to our Constitution, and to our democracy.

Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Cosidó, Mr. President.

Ladies and gentlemen, was that the change? The change was to see the Popular Party returning to the past, returning to territorial grievances, once again using Catalonia as a battering ram, as Mr. Arenas and so many others said in past times. The change was to once again offer the Spanish people and the entire Catalan society a project of disintegration, division, fracture, and not of union and aggregation, which is what the Government of Spain is defending, ladies and gentlemen.

The problem, Mr. Cosidó, is that you refer to the hundred days. These are indeed the hundred days of the Government, but before that, we had seven years of Government of the Popular Party. And so, what is the problem, Mr. Cosidó? Instead of opposing the Government, what you are doing is opposing yourselves. Opposing yourselves, of course. Because if you say that trying to dialogue with the Generalitat is a symptom of weakness, then you are telling me that Mr. Rajoy, when he attempted the Dialogue Operation, to do the same thing we are doing, was a symptom of weakness and betrayal to Spain, Mr. Cosidó.

When there have been high institutions of the State, for example, this Chamber, that even in writing has invited the former president of the Generalitat, Mr. Puigdemont, to come to the General Council of Autonomous Communities to explain his project for Catalonia, is that a symptom of weakness, Mr. Cosidó? Is it a symptom of weakness for you? I did not see you protest then when that formal invitation was made to the president of the Generalitat, then Mr. Puigdemont. Was it a symptom of weakness, or a symptom of democratic courage?, which is what this Government interprets. A symptom of democratic courage and a claim of a democracy that opens its doors to anyone to defend their ideas, always within the law.

The problem is that you, as I told you before, Mr. Cosidó, by opposing the Government are opposing dialogue. And look, what I expect from the Popular Party bench both in the Senate and in Congress is the following: that you think, think, Mr. Cosidó, that the exercise, or rather, the responsibility in the exercise of Government, is just as important as the responsibility in the exercise of opposition. And that many times, opposing the Government, I tell you from experience, because I learned from it, is helping the Government in strengthening the State. That will be good for the Spaniards, and I can guarantee you one thing, Mr. Cosidó, I would even dare to say that it would be beneficial for you in electoral terms.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Ramón Espinar Merino, from the Parliamentary Group Unidos Podemos-En Comú Podem-En Marea

Mr. Espinar.- Thank you, President.

Allow me a moment, Mr. President of the Government. Ladies and gentlemen of the Popular Party, respecting a parliamentary chamber does not consist of putting many papers in the chamber's registry saying that it must be respected; it consists, for example, of not turning it into a cacophony every time someone speaks that you do not like.

First of all, I do not welcome you because you are already here. But it is the first opportunity for my Group to address you, and I wanted to convey that we are very happy to have you in front of us and to have left Mr. Rajoy behind. And I wanted to ask you what measures the Government contemplates to improve the economic situation of the citizens, after the lost decade between 2008 and 2018?

President.- Thank you, Mr. Espinar. Thank you to the Parliamentary Group of Unidos Podemos. The truth is that if I had to summarize in one sentence the purpose of this Government, it is to build a country more committed to social justice. And, in that sense, I believe there are five axes that I think we can share between both Groups: first, education; the second is work; the third is public health; the fourth is the environment. And the fifth is the public pension system. The dignity of pensions and, of course, the sustainability of them, which has been called into question by seven years of the previous Government.

These are the objectives, and I hope that in that purpose we can find common ground both in Congress and in the Senate with your Group.

Mr. Espinar.- Yes, Mr. President, I appreciate the response and the tone, but I propose that we go a little further in the reflection.

First of all, I propose that we share a diagnosis and an analysis of what has happened in recent years in our country. We entered the crisis in a situation of income transfer that began in the 1980s, and that has intensified and continues to intensify today. Labor income weighs less and less in the total national income, and what weighs more and more are capital incomes. We must agree to reverse those income transfers because they are generating a process, which is the financialization of the economy, that brought us to the 2008 crisis, and that we have done absolutely nothing to resolve in Spain from the institutions.

The issue remains intact, and we see some indicators that make us think that the 2008 crisis and the causes that provoked it are still present. We are beginning to see an incipient real estate bubble. We are beginning to see how employment is becoming precarious. We are beginning to see how this country is losing population, and there are risks that we will experience another crisis.

And that has to do with the third element I wanted to share with you, which is that we are an economy that generates low added value. We should generate much more added value. We should be a more productive economy. An economy with the capacity, in terms of the almost forgotten Mr. Rajoy, an economy with the capacity to do things, and not just to be competitive. And this is the fourth element I want to share with you, based on tax cuts and fiscal competition with other territories, and depreciating wages, which, as you know, is how we have come out of the crisis.

In data, that management of the crisis has cost us two million workers in Spain. It has cost us a 30% loss of income in Spain. When today it is said that Spain is growing, it has to do with how, if you allow me the metaphor, the fridge is. When one has the fridge empty and puts in two tomatoes, it gives the impression that the fridge is much fuller than before, but it was empty. We have a 30% loss of income. We have a problem of galloping inequality. We are growing again above 3% year-on-year, and yet, 25% of our compatriots are at risk of poverty.

This means that in the macroeconomic data, the crisis is over because we are growing, but that we continue in the social data, for the majority of citizens, in the worst of the crisis. And against that, we must work, above all, you must work from the Government, but we all have to work, and we must compose parliamentary majorities in service of reversing that situation.

Furthermore, we have lost 20% of investment in R&D+i in our country. And this is fundamental for a reason that I will now explain. We have a labor regulation that has made it so that since the 1980s, talking about labor reform in Spain means talking about the systematic loss of workers' rights, which has brought us a situation of precariousness and temporality never seen before in our employment. We have set a record for overtime hours, most of which are unpaid in our country. There are 6.8 million overtime hours worked each week in Spain, and the majority of them are not compensated, while we coexist with a situation of unemployment.

What we propose to you, Mr. Sánchez, is a National Plan for the modernization of our economy. It must be based, first, on one condition, and on a political agreement. And that is that the Government, any Government, is not a social balance; it is not a balance of equilibriums that listens to some and listens to others and takes measures seeking a kind of middle ground that does not anger anyone. A Government must lead transformations in the country. And a Government must dare to lead transformations.

It is not enough to act as a social balance, especially when one side is pulling the balance, as the right-wing parties are doing in our country. Therefore, you have the responsibility to exercise leadership in the transformation of our country. And we have the responsibility to set tasks for you, and to set agendas and to propose some measures, which is what I am going to do.

The change between the Popular Party and the Socialist Party must be noticeable, the change between Mr. Rajoy and you must be noticeable, and it must not only be noticeable in talent and in forms, it must be noticeable in economic measures. It must also be noticeable in other things related to studies, with master's degrees and with the explanations given, but that was not the question today.

We need to promote national agreements for employment and for the productive model. We need to finance it, abandoning a model, and in this I believe that you and we agree, in which the State has systematically subsidized the rich in our country. The State in Spain subsidizes capital income, large companies, and the wealthy. Meanwhile, it is indeed taxing workers and the popular classes in our country heavily.

And with what we obtain from tax justice, we need to promote an entrepreneurial State. We need to activate a cycle of consumption that allows self-employed individuals to develop their activities, that workers have better salaries and better jobs, so that pensioners can also have better pensions. It is not just a declarative issue to improve pensions; it is also about filling the Social Security fund, with better jobs and a better productive model.

Let us invest the 2.7 billion euros from Castor, the 4 billion from the highways, or the 2 billion euros from the submarines that do not float from Ms. Cospedal into improving the fiscal situation of the self-employed, reducing VAT, equating pensions to the CPI, guaranteeing free school materials, regulating the rental market, or making the Dependency Law not just declarative, but effective. It is important that laws and the constitutional order are made effective, not just declarative, because otherwise it will take us back to a situation of loss of citizen trust in institutions, and that situation I believe sounds familiar to both you and us.

The General State Budgets of 2019 have the opportunity to be the start of a takeoff in Spain towards a decade won, after the lost decade between 2008 and 2018, in which we have done absolutely nothing to improve the situation after the economic crisis and to move towards a model that restores dignity to Spain, that guarantees a fair economic model, that guarantees growth, and that guarantees the Welfare State in our country.

Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you, Mr. President.

Thank you, Mr. Espinar, for your approach to this debate. There is a figure that has always caught my attention. And when I read it, I share it with many of my colleagues in the Council of Ministers, and that is that the level of public income, the percentage of public income in our country represents around 38% of Gross Domestic Product. And the European average is at 46% of Gross Domestic Product, which means that there is a 'gap', to put it in technical terms, of around 80 billion euros, of capacity that the public sector in our country could have to implement redistribution policies and policies for the modernization of the economy, as you mentioned earlier.

Therefore, I am not saying that we want to reach that 46% in two or three years. But it is evident that we must set a horizon, and that horizon must be not to be at the tail end of importance in the public sector, in relation to GDP, nor in relation to public income, but rather to be at or around the average of our European countries, especially those we want to resemble.

Regarding education and science, what can I say? Every day the Minister of Science reminds me: that there has been a very substantial cut in recent years, that science has not been perceived by the previous Administration as one of the central core elements of all social progress and all economic progress, and not only does he tell me, he also tells the Minister of Finance, and what I want to guarantee is, of course, a Government will have a commitment that will be established not only in black and white but also in figures of a decisive bet for science in our country.

I hope that, in addition, this sets an example, that the rest of the Public Administrations that we govern, the Socialist Party, the Popular Party, Unidos Podemos, that we all work to implement transversal policies that improve the state of science in our country, and of innovation.

I previously mentioned that I had divided, separated into five, those transformation objectives that our country needs. What I tell you is that the objective is indeed social justice. The horizon must be 10 years, it must be 12 years. We have set 2030 as a moment that must indeed produce the entire set of transformations that our country needs to win that future.

And, in relation to that issue, Mr. Espinar, I will tell you that we want to make a decisive commitment to education, to education. What makes no sense is that we currently have some of the lowest levels of education, in terms of public investment, in the EU, that we are moving away and not approaching the EU average. And, therefore, I want to announce to you here today, in the Senate, that in this next Council of Ministers, the Government will present the Draft Law that will allow the reversal of all the educational cuts proposed by the Government of Spain in the previous mandate. That is the commitment of the Government of Spain. We will do it. Among other things, so that those of us who have daughters, for example, in public schools, and who have seen over the past few years the increase in the student-to-teacher ratio, can see our children, our daughters, our grandchildren, and our granddaughters, in classrooms with fewer students, with greater pedagogical capacity from the teachers, which is precisely what was lost during these years of cuts.

In education, of course, we have talked about this Draft Law that we are going to present in the Council of Ministers, about science, which I mentioned earlier, and, of course, about child poverty.

I believe you referred earlier to poverty in our country. This Government is committed to eradicating child poverty, which also has a lot to do with the poor state, to a large extent, of the Welfare State, especially in the inability to combat intergenerational inequality. In the end, it is the young people who have really suffered from this policy of cuts, and, in that sense, we want to make a decisive commitment from the public sector, but also from the private sector, in the fight against child poverty.

Regarding work, Mr. Espinar, I cannot agree with you more. There are issues you mentioned that are currently being addressed in the Social Dialogue Table, and the Minister of Labor can refer to that later, for example, when she talks about the unpaid overtime that workers are not being compensated for.

But I remind you of one thing, in less than a hundred days this Government has launched a Director Plan for decent work, which is the same as saying a Director Plan against labor exploitation or labor precariousness. What has that meant? According to the data we are currently receiving, the emergence of 8,000 false self-employed workers. I believe this is one of the elements, by the way, you, who are much younger than I am, will know perfectly well that there are many young people who are being exploited in many cases by this misnamed collaborative economy, where we also need to start regulating, precisely, to gain that quality in the realm of dignity in employment.

And, of course, also, something that is being processed in the Congress of Deputies, which your Parliamentary Group has initiated, which we also initiated, and it is the fight against labor inequality between men and women. I believe that the wage gap, that dignity and equality in many areas for women in the labor market must be a central objective of our Parliamentary Groups, and, of course, it is for the Socialist Parliamentary Group.

In health, I believe that in 100 days, the recovery and reconstruction of the universality of Public Health is a great success, not only of this Government but of the left in this country, because it has also been validated by the support of the Unidos Podemos Parliamentary Group, and I want to publicly acknowledge that, so thank you, Mr. Espinar, for that support.

We are very concerned, and, in addition, the Minister of Ecological Transition has already made some statements regarding this. We are very concerned about the rise in electricity tariffs. I believe that if anything reflects the enormous failure of the previous Administration, it is the entire reform of the electricity sector that was carried out. I’m sorry, but that’s how it is. What can we do, members of the Popular Party!

And, of course, regarding the public pension system, we have two commitments. One, in the short term, but also in the medium term. And another one in the medium term, and not so much in the short term. In the medium and short term, it must be to guarantee the increase in pensions and, of course, also the CPI of pensions.

Nothing more and thank you very much.