Response to inquiry F 24 from Frank Aaen (The Red-Green Alliance): "What can the Prime Minister inform about the fulfillment of the election promises from March 1998?"

Denmark Poul Nyrup Rasmussen · Prime Minister of Denmark

11 February 1999 · Question time in the Folketing (inquiry F 24 on election promises) · Folketing, Denmark

Context
Rasmussen responded in the Folketing on February 11, 1999, to a parliamentary inquiry from Frank Aaen challenging the government's fulfillment of its March 1998 election promises.
Main themes
Fulfillment of election promises, early retirement scheme reform, economic responsibility, welfare state preservation, minority government coalition politics, employment and unemployment reduction, government platform implementation, fiscal policy, social democratic governance
Duration
~19 min
64th percentile
Words
2,314
64th percentile
Sentences
147
80th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
8.5
7th percentile
Syntax
2.71
13th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 41%37%
  • Economic 34%31%
  • Social 22%20%
  • Ceremonial 4%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 10%

147 sentences in 43 paragraphs

One could almost be tempted to say: We might as well vote on it right away. I simply do not understand the purpose of this matter today. I do not know what the goal is.

I can understand that what one has not been involved in oneself does not seem as good. But that is not a new standpoint. I believe there will be a broad majority for this in the Folketing.

Furthermore, I cannot recognize the argumentation at all. It is not the most objective contribution I have heard in the Folketing. I have also read what has been said from the other side of the chamber, including the remarks of the leader of Venstre about the so-called broken promise, which Frank Aaen is also so concerned about. It is a bit tilted to one side and a bit to the other side.

Of course, Venstre feels cheated out of power. It was theirs, as Mr. Anders Fogh Rasmussen's predecessor so vividly expressed on the front page of Ekstrabladet the day before the election. But contrary to what the Enhedslisten expresses and contrary to what Venstre expressed in March last year, we, the government, have actually secured the early retirement scheme. We have secured it in a way that the economy can meet expectations and the needs of worn-out wage earners. After all, it is the task of the government and the head of government.

I am always ready to discuss the things we can see in hindsight, including who said what and when about early retirement, or about any other theme.

But I will also always stand by the fact that the task of securing Denmark's future and our welfare society is a task that cannot be solved by merely looking in the rearview mirror. It is solved by looking ahead, by steering clear of the obstacles that lie before us.

And that is what the finance agreement for 1999 was really about. It is a sensible agreement. It is a responsible agreement. It is a logical consequence of the municipal agreement and the Pentecost package. Therefore, I do not think it serves any purpose to engage in that kind of personal demagoguery and the personal attacks that I hear various people contributing to.

* * *

With the intervention in the early retirement scheme, the government has done what we found to be the right thing. We have secured the early retirement scheme, and we have not least ensured that taxpayers can afford to pay for it in the next century, and that the welfare society will have better opportunities in the future by having people who can stay a little longer in the labor market.

The programs that the governing parties each campaigned on have subsequently been worked together into a government platform. That is how the government has worked since it came to power in 1993. Like the previous government platform, the government is in the process of fulfilling the goals described in our government platform - 'Well on the Way'.

Many of the goals have actually already been met here less than a year after the election. We have come a long way. But two crucial questions obviously determine the pace at which the government can achieve its goals.

One is the parliamentary. It is known to everyone that we do not have 90 mandates ourselves. Like any other minority government, a majority must be sought from time to time among the parties we have in the Folketing. The working conditions in the Folketing are as the voters have decided. That is how it is.

The second factor that determines the implementation of the government platform is the economy. Having order in the economy is not a goal in itself. It is a means. Why do the government and I often talk about the economy? Well, we do not do it because it should be our very existence. We do it because we know very well who will be hit hardest if the economy is not in order. It is the weakest; it is those at the back; it is those who entered the labor market last who will be the first to go out again. And then the many hundreds of thousands of ordinary wage earners will feel it shortly thereafter.

That is why we said from the start in 1993: Never again an economic development under social democratic-radical leadership that brings society to the brink of the abyss. Never again an economic development under our leadership that risks forcing society back into a potato diet, where everything comes to a standstill.

It is clear that there have been concessions made along the way. That is just how it is. There is nothing new in that either. But for six years, we have placed decisive emphasis on strengthening employment and combating unemployment. And again: When we fight so hard for unemployment to continue to go down, and when we fight so hard to create jobs and employment in Denmark, it is not for the sake of the economy, but for the sake of people. It is because employment and jobs are best for self-esteem and for welfare.

* * *

And in fact, the fundamental goal has exceeded all expectations. Since we began in 1993, things have progressed faster than we had anticipated, faster than we had dared to hope, faster than we had built as a basis for our decisions. Today, we have a lower unemployment rate than we have had in 20 years. Unemployment - also for the young - is the lowest since 1979. Youth unemployment has been reduced from over 60,000 to just under 20,000. Long-term unemployment has decreased as well.

All of this did not come by itself. All of this came because we wanted it, because we could negotiate. All of this came because we implemented labor market reforms I and II, a tax reform, an educational initiative, and a responsible economic policy.

* * *

From the start, we have said: The money must be there before we can use it. We have said from the start that we will use the money to reduce debt and improve the quality of our society.

Since we began, many, many results have been achieved. More children can be cared for today than could before. 140,000 childcare places have been realized. The limits for free places have been raised to take into account the lowest incomes. Hospitals have been allocated more resources. Everyone knows that. The educational initiative has been strengthened. We have ensured slightly better elderly care, which is, by the way, better than the reputation we sometimes hear. I have noted that the Danish Municipalities' Association has just published an analysis showing that it has not - to put it mildly - become so terribly worse compared to the years before. In several areas, it has actually been possible to achieve some small progress. In others, there have been a few municipalities that have implemented some cutbacks.

The conditions for families with children, home care, elderly care, hospitals, and public schools are areas where all parties want improvements. The art consists in long-term insuring the improvements we can achieve in the various areas. It is our shared responsibility. Not only a responsibility we have here in the Parliament, but a responsibility we must share with the municipalities; a responsibility we must share with every single institution in Denmark, with the labor market parties, and with each one of us. So far, so good.

* * *

There is still much to be done, but it is a better Denmark now than it was six years ago. The government refuses to jeopardize the results that have been achieved by allowing itself to be drawn into a bidding war that Denmark does not need. The government instead says: Now it is about the next big move. This requires that we can manage the welfare society safely around the obstacles and dangers that lurk on the horizon.

When economic growth in countries in Europe slows down, when there is a crisis in Asia and Latin America, we must of course take this into account. That is what a responsible government must do, and that is precisely what we are taking into account. When there is too much speed in the Danish economy, when the increase in private and public consumption is too high, we must of course take this into account. That is what a responsible government does. We have always done that. We will always do that. The prerequisite for us to achieve all that we want is that the economy can stay on track. That has been our guiding principle until now. It continues to be.

In 1998, we entered into an agreement on the Pentecost package with the parties on the left side of the chamber. Then we implemented the municipal agreements. Then we implemented a finance bill with the parties in the middle and to the right in the chamber. The parties to the right in the chamber do not like the Pentecost package - they were not part of it - and the parties to the left in the chamber do not like the finance agreement - they were not part of that either. The government has pursued the same consistent policy all the way through, also in 1998: to secure the welfare society; to ensure that the broadest shoulders bear the most; to ensure solidarity in welfare; that is the foundation of our policy.

The finance agreement for 1999 is a clear continuation of the solidarity policy we have pursued. We have improved the conditions for vocational schools. We have implemented a labor market reform that is not a technical wish in itself, but is determined by our overarching goal of getting people into work faster than before: For their own sake and for the future of society.

We have taken the future into account when it comes to housing support. For if we did not take changes in housing support into account, a long, long line of pensioners would face difficulties in five or ten years. We have done this in a solidarity manner by taking into account that future pensioners, for some, have slightly better financial conditions than before.

We have implemented changes in medicine subsidies, but we have maintained that it should be solidarity-based, humane, and decent. We have done this by not giving as many direct subsidies for medicine as before, but by giving it to people's consumption. The greater the medicine consumption one has, the greater the subsidy from society. Changes that have been implemented in a solidarity and decent manner. Changes that take into account the individual person.

And we have implemented changes in the early retirement scheme, but again here in a solidarity and decent manner. If one has a lot on the side, and we must have the economy and people's welfare to align, then one receives a little less 'on top' from society.

* * *

I sense that the biggest criticism of the government today is actually that the government refuses to spend the same money twice.

That is how I perceive it. Politics is about wanting, politics is not about passively watching. A society is not a steamer on autopilot. A society must be led by a government that takes on responsibility together with a majority of parties, and that dares.

We set clear goals. Goals that we will achieve. We do not run away from anything. A responsible government does not do that. We do not either. We can achieve the goals we have set if we manage societal development in a responsible manner, if we maintain the good employment growth, if we maintain our responsibility for ensuring balance in the economy, then we can achieve lasting improvements in all the areas we want: hospitals, elderly care, home helpers, schools, children's conditions, etc.

But we refuse to contribute to a bidding war that may feel good to start with, but quickly becomes very, very cold, perhaps especially for the weakest groups in our country. If, on the other hand, we responsibly take into account the changes that come to us from the outside and from within, then we can safely lead society forward for the benefit of most.

* * *

I have read in the newspaper that there are several proposals for resolutions here today. I do not think those I have heard about signal anything other than a bidding war that has no economic coverage. Economic growth should be used to improve the lives of the weakest in our country, not to hand out generously to the most affluent.

The government places decisive emphasis on continued sound economic development. We know that when the economy goes wrong, it is the weakest who are hit.

We acknowledge that responsible reforms do not mean that everyone gets more in their pockets every time. We all have a shared responsibility for precisely that line. What has been proposed does not seem to add up.

That bridge would collapse if anyone tried to walk on it. The money must be there before we can use it. The population can, however, safely count on the government continuing to know how to implement targeted service improvements at the pace that can secure financing for them and in the reality that we emphasize working in.

Air castles are expensive to maintain.

My appeal to the Folketing here today should therefore be: Put the teasing aside. Drop the campaign. Roll up your sleeves - as the government has been doing since 1993. Then we would very much like to extend a hand for cooperation, as we have always done.

But it must be sustainable. It must be responsible, and it must benefit the Danes and the general reputation of this esteemed assembly.