Speech at the Council for European Policy (EMU Meeting), Tuesday, April 20, 1999.

Denmark Poul Nyrup Rasmussen · Prime Minister of Denmark

20 April 1999 · Council for European Policy (EMU Meeting)

Context
Rasmussen addressed the Council for European Policy in Denmark on April 20, 1999, arguing for Danish membership in the Eurozone on economic and political grounds.
Main themes
Euro membership for Denmark, economic and political integration, social security and competitiveness, common currency and internal market, welfare principles and human rights, European identity and vision, Eastern enlargement, global trade and WTO negotiations, employment strategy, environmental policy, social dumping prevention, referendum timing
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,654
70th percentile
Sentences
150
81st percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
10.0
21st percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 53%49%
  • Geopolitical 19%17%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

150 sentences in 59 paragraphs

'The Euro and Denmark - a perspective and more than just economics'

I hope that today we will have a lively debate - perhaps even a vigorous debate about the Euro.

Thank you to the Council for European Policy for taking up the call to kickstart the European debate. I believe we all feel obligated by that.

Now I hope that the debate will focus more on the content

- rather than on when there should be a referendum. There is certainly much that can be said wisely and strategically about the timing - when - I have no doubt about that. But let us instead have a debate about attitudes and perspectives for Denmark and the Euro.

* * *

Just a few years ago, many believed it was not possible: 11 countries united in an economic community with a common currency and common monetary policy. We are not very keen on mentioning the words 'to make history' these days, because today's agenda may change to a new one tomorrow.

But it is indeed a historic event. We are talking about some of the countries that Denmark is closest to: Germany, France, Benelux, and Finland, which have now entered into a new economic cooperation. We are talking about a region that Danes frequently travel to. We are talking about an economic interdependence that is quite crucial for us. Our trade with the Euro area alone accounts for nearly half of our total foreign trade.

I have not hidden my own viewpoint regarding Denmark's connection to the Euro: I believe we should be a member. I believe it is best for Denmark and the future of our welfare society.

As I mentioned earlier, we will return later to the timing of when the Danes should take a stance on the issue. For it is, after all, solely the Danish population that decides that matter through a referendum!

* * *

My justification for saying yes does not need to be identical to the justifications of other parties or other individuals. I say this because the motivations that lead to a conclusion can be very different and tied to various European visions.

My vision of Europe does not necessarily have to be the same as others' vision of Europe. For my part, the vision of a Europe - a new Europe, a new cooperation in a completely new framework - is an area where high social security goes hand in hand with high competitiveness.

I believe we have shown in Denmark that social security and competitive strength are not opposites, but in fact prerequisites for each other. Lifelong education and opportunities for all. That is part of being able to cope in the future's global competition.

Let me clarify: In the Euro area, we are not only talking about a currency - the Euro, which competes with the dollar. We are talking about more than that. We are talking about a currency that is common for the internal market. But not just a currency for the internal market; it is also a currency for a market for which we politicians have made certain decisions. We have set some minimum requirements that give the market a human face. We demand minimum conditions regarding the environment. We demand minimum conditions in the area of working conditions. And demands for consumer information, etc. We are gradually developing a completely new employment strategy.

But it is more than that. It is also an area where member states commit to certain fundamental welfare principles. And it is finally an area where there is agreement and respect for human rights, and agreement on how to respect minorities in our populations.

As has been made clear, it is a quite special area. In market and political terms. I would like to start by emphasizing this very strongly, for to me, the Euro debate is not only an economic, technical debate, but very much a political debate.

I actually feel that with the Amsterdam Treaty and the Euro cooperation, we have been given some good instruments at our disposal. We must use these instruments to create stability, security within a group of countries, and thus a very large population group - freed from speculative pressure. We must use the instrument to develop our environmental policy and outright reject social dumping or short-term policies that create unemployment.

The European region is a very special region on the blue planet. It obliges us to move forward. One could say that with the agreement on Agenda 2000 - the next 5-6 years of the European budget - we have removed certain skeptics' last justifications for slowing down in relation to the expansion towards Eastern and Central Europe. And one could actually also say that with the Euro area, we have gained a new additional tool to ensure a sensible expansion process.

But we can and should go even further. I actually believe that we must now begin to shape a pioneering region that can leave its mark on the rest of the blue planet - both in relation to the third world, in relation to Latin America, Africa, Asia, the USA, Canada, and Japan.

I believe that in the upcoming WTO negotiations, we should make our mark more clearly and strongly. And I believe that the dream some of us had as young people is no longer so distant. It is in sight and within reach. We can begin from the European region's side to set demands on world trade in a different way than before. Demands for compliance with certain fundamental labor rights, demands for certain ILO standards, demands for a ban on child labor. Of course, taking into account how quickly developing countries can meet these demands - demands that things should be done properly for all people in all countries on this planet.

I noticed that the President of the United States in his recent address to the nation touched on some of the same elements. Therefore, it is not just theory, but actually within reach. For the first time in many years - perhaps for the first time ever.

With these strong positive perspectives, I would like to elaborate on the reasoning behind why we cooperate on a stable currency, the Euro. The answer is simple: Because the Euro is important for our economic welfare.

Since World War II, Denmark, as a smaller country, has always been tied to a larger currency: After World War II, Denmark participated in the Bretton Woods system. It lasted until August 1971, when the Americans suspended the dollar. In September 1971, the so-called Smithsonian Agreement was reached. The agreement meant that other currencies could fluctuate +/- 2 1⁄4 % in relation to the dollar. This meant that the European currencies could fluctuate by up to +/- 4 1⁄2 %.

Then came the Basel Agreement of April 10, 1972, where it was decided to limit the fluctuations of the EEC currencies against each other to +/- 2 1⁄4 %. We joined the agreement along with the other applicant countries; Norway, the United Kingdom, and Ireland, and the system for the European currencies became known as 'the snake in the tunnel'.

In March 1973, the Bretton Woods system in the form it had taken with the Smithsonian Agreement was finally abandoned. 'The snake cooperation' continued in Europe for several more years.

The EMS system replaced 'the snake cooperation' from March 13, 1974, until the introduction of the Euro on January 1 of this year. The EMS system has been the framework for European currency cooperation. But we remember the real collapse of the EMS system a couple of years ago and the motivations and background for that.

* * *

On one hand, one could say that the European currency cooperation has clearly proven its durability and its value. In my opinion, that is beyond discussion. On the other hand, the very collapse of the EMS cooperation has also shown that it was still vulnerable when pressure was applied. Therefore, I believe it was well-founded to start considering what else could be done to strengthen its defense capability against speculative pressure and in relation to the region's demands and needs for currency stability.

The challenge is primarily to do something about unemployment and low growth - without jeopardizing what has already been achieved.

The answer is largely changes and structural policy, which each individual country naturally makes decisions about: The labor market and an offensive macroeconomic policy. For the latter, of course, also coordinated in the way that is well-known in European cooperation.

The European Central Bank lowered interest rates by half a percentage point on April 8 with the aim of contributing to stimulating growth and employment.

* * *

For me, this historical process is proof that the way forward is to pull together by coordinating our economic policy. I have no doubt that cooperation of this nature is far better than a situation where we work against each other and thereby risk exporting unemployment to one another.

We have indeed worked against each other before. History has several examples of that. If we are to find the innermost, real reason for why we have high unemployment in the European region, actually 18 million unemployed, we find the explanation. It is not that we have European cooperation, but that we have lacked a European cooperation that is sufficiently strong in this area.

I am especially thinking of the oil crises in 1974 and 1979, where it was quite obvious that we did not have an offensive response in Europe to the price increases by the oil sheikhs, which hit our societies so massively. There was no doctrine developed in European cooperation. I remember it so clearly. We lacked a common response that could protect employment.

The problem was that when an external shock occurred, as the two oil crises represented, we found ourselves in a situation where all the Western European countries had deficits in their balance of payments. Each individual country reacted and felt pressured to implement significant internal cuts, with the result that each individual country actually pressured its neighbor to also make significant cuts.

The result was not long in coming. We drove each other down into a downward spiral of unemployment creation instead of developing an intelligent response to the shock we faced from the oil-producing countries. History repeated itself in 1979. If we look at the unemployment curve for Europe, we can see the clear trace.

For Denmark, it is actually only now, after 6 years of massive effort, that we have succeeded in bringing unemployment down to the lowest in Europe - and the lowest unemployment in 20 years.

That is the lesson from the last 20 years: I have no doubt that the path we are trying to pursue now - outwardly - is about building resilience in the area against external shocks. Inwardly, it is the prerequisite for stabilizing our cooperation on our employment goals. Therefore, we must hold on to the close cooperation in the EU, which applies to the Euro countries, and it applies to Denmark.

* * *

And now to my views on a fixed krone exchange rate and fixing currencies - is it an advantage, or is it not an advantage? How significant is it for us to have the freedom that comes from being able to devalue or revalue?

I would like to say that the fixed krone exchange rate is an unyielding cornerstone of the government's economic policy. The goal is to ensure low interest rates, low inflation, and stable currency conditions. It helps consumers, it helps savings, it helps employment. One should not be mistaken: High inflation is not beneficial for low-income earners; on the contrary. A fixed krone exchange rate with the resulting effects helps investments and sales and thereby also growth and employment.

A so-called active exchange rate policy may sometimes seem tempting to some, but all experience shows that the result is negative for small countries if things get going. Especially for small countries with a large foreign trade. I will not mention country names from recent times, but just say that one of our closest neighbors has had some quite painful experiences! But now we are building bridges - in more than one sense. And my Dutch colleague will likely confirm that after the devaluation of the Dutch guilder in the early 80s, it took almost 10 years before the Dutch interest rate was as low as before.

* * *

The figures for Denmark's economic development undoubtedly show that the fixed exchange rate policy has served us well. And that we have always sought the binding international currency cooperation. Hence our agreement on ERM 2.

With ERM 2, we respect the formulation from the national compromise of 1993. The national compromise 'Denmark in Europe' states: 'Denmark must, even when other EU countries possibly move to phase 3, participate in a close currency cooperation in the EU'.

The government has maintained the fundamental principles of Danish exchange rate policy with ERM 2: The fixed exchange rate policy and the binding international cooperation. In fact, I have not met many who seriously wished that we would break with our exchange rate policy principles, which now have more than 40 years of history. I consider the stability that is part of this cooperation to be something completely fundamental for Denmark.

* * *

But are there not some downsides to the Euro?

It is, of course, a very big decision to give up one's national currency. It is a very consequential decision, which is not easy to revert once the decision has been made. One can also think a lot about the pace of the integration process that is associated with the Amsterdam Treaty, about our de facto position in relation to the cooperation. I will not go into that right now.

One can certainly also think about what price formation situation, what fiscal effect will arise from our neighboring country - Germany - possibly having the same currency as Denmark: prices will be measured in the same currency unit, so that any citizen, German, Danish, or third-country citizen within the EU area, can compare directly.

There is also no doubt that some of the cooperation related to the Amsterdam Treaty will gain momentum with Euro membership. There will likely, as I hinted earlier, also be some effects on the scope and nature of the fiscal policy instruments we can use, either to counteract an economic downturn or to achieve an economic upturn.

* * *

The question of interest rates in relation to Euro countries, when we are not members of the Euro, has been discussed extensively. All else being equal, there is no doubt that not being a member of the Euro area for a period will mean that we will have to pay a premium interest rate. Its size and scope will also be determined by a number of other developments.

I would also like to mention that Denmark, as an attractive investment country for foreign investors, cannot overlook the fact that it matters whether we are a member of the Euro or not. How significant that impact is, no one can say, but it does matter. We feel it, that’s just how it is. There is no reason to hide that.

* * *

There are many angles one can take in the discussion. It is good that we are now engaged in this debate. Let us, for heaven's sake, get started discussing the substance. It is important that we make every effort to ensure that the population - every single person who will eventually have to take a stance - at least has had real access to familiarize themselves with what membership of the Euro means. And what it means to be outside of it.

I would like to contribute to that today.