2. Speech at the Istanbul International Ombudsman Conference

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

18 November 2019 · Istanbul International Ombudsman Conference · Istanbul, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed the 2nd Istanbul International Ombudsman Conference on November 18, 2019, speaking on good governance and state-citizen relations before ombudsmen from around the world.
Main themes
Good governance principles, ombudsman institutions, state-citizen relations, public accountability, national will and democracy, Turkey's governance reforms, human-centered administration, historical Islamic governance wisdom, suppression of dissent, state resilience, technology and civic participation, regional political instability
Duration
~19 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,235
62nd percentile
Sentences
101
63rd percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 43%43%
  • Geopolitical 19%19%
  • Social 18%18%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

101 sentences in 25 paragraphs

Dear guests,

I greet you with my warmest feelings and affection. I welcome the ombudsmen and representatives of equivalent institutions who have honored us by attending the program from all over the world to Turkey and our beautiful Istanbul.

I pray that the second Istanbul International Ombudsman Conference will be a source of goodness for all humanity. I also hope that the General Assembly of Ombudsmen from Asian countries and the General Assembly of Ombudsmen from Islamic countries, which will be held within the framework of this program, will be successful.

I find it very appropriate that the theme of our conference, held in a period where the population is increasing and the functioning of state mechanisms has become complex, has been determined as the principles of good governance. As a nation, we have a very strong accumulation in this regard. Works such as Kutadgu Bilig by Yusuf Has Hacib, Siyasetname by Nizamülmülk, Koçibey Risalesi by Koçibey, and Mukaddime by Ibn Khaldun contain messages that are far ahead of their times regarding state governance.

In today's world, we see that states that cannot establish strong ties with their citizens are much more vulnerable to internal and external interventions. No power or influence can destroy a country that is supported by its people. On the other hand, states that do not listen to the voices of their own people, do not seek solutions to their problems, and instead try to suppress objections harshly can face great suffering and destruction. There are many states and administrations in our region that have fallen into this grave error.

Turkey's difference lies in its strong commitment to the bond between the state and the nation, which has been distilled from its historical experiences. Thanks to this, despite facing many threats, from terrorist organizations' attacks to economic traps, we have managed to stand tall and continuously increase our strength. As the spiritual founder of the Ottoman Empire, which is one of the largest and longest-lasting states in the world, Sheikh Edebali's saying, "Live the human, so the state lives," has become our guiding principle.

Our Lord advises us to live according to a faith that commands goodness and forbids evil. We have never forgotten that any structure or understanding that is not human-centered, that does not aim to do good, avoid evil, and be upright is doomed to collapse sooner or later. Establishing and maintaining the necessary functioning for the well-being of both individuals and society is one of the foremost duties of state administration.

As Turkey, especially with the profound reforms we have implemented recently, we have first rectified the mistakes and shortcomings of the past. We did not stop there; with the change in our governance system, we placed the principle of the supremacy of national will at the center of democracy. We believe that the more we increase, diversify, and make effective the quest for rights of our nation against public institutions, the stronger our state will be. There are many applications we have implemented with this approach, from opening the individual application route to the Constitutional Court to the CIMER under our Presidency and various units operating in municipalities under different names. The Public Ombudsman Institution, which we established within the Turkish Grand National Assembly, is also a product of this understanding.

The developing technology and communication opportunities also enable individuals and organized groups to voice their concerns at every level. It is out of the question for public institution managers to remain indifferent to the voice of our citizens, regardless of the channel through which it comes. As a President who has strong direct contact with the public through city visits and programs where we meet with our citizens, we will not allow such indifference in the first place. It is impossible for the members of a civilization that sees silence in the face of injustice as the silence of a mute devil to act otherwise. As we continue to remove public resources from the monopoly of certain power centers and place them at the service of our nation, we have become a country that can walk with much more confident steps both domestically and internationally. Inshallah, in the upcoming period, we will continue to take steps that will further strengthen the bond between the state and the nation and implement practices. One of the most important elements of our visions for 2053 and 2071, which we entrust to future generations, will be this solid infrastructure. I believe that friendly and brotherly countries will not only overcome their current problems by following the same path but will also leave a proud legacy for the future.

Valued Guests,

In Turkish, there is a saying, "idare-i maslahat," which means to manage the existing situation. While its meaning is broad, we can summarize it in terms of our subject as maintaining the existing situation. Of course, the existing situation here refers to the practices that people generally complain about and want to change. In a place where complaints are increasing, insisting on "idare-i maslahat" is oppression against the people. Our nation says that the fate of those who thrive on oppression or tyranny will be disastrous. Ensuring that every objection based on rights and justice is met with a response in the public sphere is the most important method to prevent oppression.

The so-called unquestionable governance that we refer to as the wisdom of government has now become a thing of the past. Instead, reliable and transparent governance based on law and human rights has become widely accepted. The topic of our conference, good governance, expresses this approach.

The sensitivity to protect the individual against the state, which constitutes the essence of modern governance, is certainly a correct principle, provided that the boundaries are well defined. Who would object to principles such as compliance with laws, prevention of discrimination, proportionality, equality, impartiality, honesty, courtesy, transparency, respect for acquired rights, the right to information, the right to defense, the requirement for reasoned decisions, clear and open alternative remedies, and the protection of personal data? The problem here is that Western countries, which have established this system by considering the state-individual balance, engage in completely individualistic impositions when it comes to other countries. Countries that have not sufficiently established democratic processes either bow to such impositions out of embarrassment for their internal shortcomings or reflexively resort to the opposite practices.

Another debate is whether the practices of good governance will change according to each country's own historical, social, and cultural accumulation and security needs. A country that has solved its security problems, raised its level of prosperity, and established its democratic institutions and practices can certainly set very high standards in this regard. Evaluating a country that is still struggling with serious problems by the same criteria prevents the discussion from continuing on a constructive basis. Moreover, we clearly see how some countries, which supposedly appear to be at the forefront of democracy and especially human rights, can rapidly become despotic in the face of even the slightest crisis.

Therefore, discussions on good governance need to be conducted within the framework of ideals and possibilities. Turkey is one of the countries that experiences the least problems in this regard, in light of the experiences already present in its state tradition. Despite all its shortcomings, we have nearly 70 years of multi-party democracy experience. We have many imperative regulations in this regard, especially Article 40 of our Constitution. Our legal corpus also has a substantial body of case law that prioritizes the individual in state-citizen relations. We have also achieved significant gains in this framework with the obligations we have undertaken in our relations with the European Union and other international organizations. More importantly, we currently have a government that sincerely demonstrates every will to solve the problems in practice and has made progress.

I pause to emphasize that countries that sincerely strive for democracy, the rule of law, human rights, and the principles of good governance should not be treated unfairly. For example, the European Good Governance Law was enacted in 2001, nearly half a century after the establishment of the Union. We believe that it would be much more appropriate for countries that sincerely strive for good governance to be supported with formulas that facilitate their work rather than facing impositions that exceed their capacities.

Valued Guests,

If we pay attention, the essence of the issue we call good governance is actually respect for the individual and their inherent rights. Only states that can ensure the security, peace, and happiness of all individuals under their governance, regardless of their size or wealth, deserve the title of great state. Each of the headings we refer to as principles of good governance is aimed at this purpose. If threats to the security, peace, and happiness of individuals come directly from the state, then there is a significant problem. This distortion lies behind many of the civil wars, turmoil, chaos, and humanitarian crises experienced in various parts of the world.

Turkey is a country that pays the price for the humanitarian crises in its region, both through terrorist attacks and large waves of refugees. Can you imagine that as of now, Turkey is a country hosting 4 million refugees? The European Union has provided us with 3 billion euros in support through NGOs such as the Red Crescent and AFAD so far. So, what have we spent? We have provided over 40 billion dollars in support to refugees and continue to do so.

What do the strongest in the world say? They say, "We are number one." No, you are not number one. The country that provides the most significant support to the least developed countries or refugees in the world is Turkey; I state this clearly. And this is not just my figure; it is also the figure of the OECD; Turkey is such a country. Developed countries, whose economies and governance systems are far ahead of ours, have closed their doors to refugees for the security and welfare of their citizens, while we have not; we have kept them open and continue to do so. And as we see those women, men, and children trying to cross those sharp barbed wire fences, our hearts break, but they do not feel such a thing. We have shared our resources with over 4 million victims and vulnerable refugees in every area, from shelter to education and health, for years. The Main Opposition in our country says, "We will send them back to their homeland." We will never and ever hand over these people, who are fleeing from barrel bombs, back to those barrel bombs. -Translate it correctly- Because we love the created for the sake of the Creator, and for this reason, we cannot hand them back to bombs. But the Main Opposition in Turkey may say so; let them say it. We love humanity, and that is why we do not make such distinctions.

We do not just content ourselves with keeping terrorist organizations at bay with the understanding of "let the snake that does not touch me live for a thousand years"; we go into their lairs and destroy them. We are fighting against all terrorist organizations that threaten our country and the world, from ISIS to Al-Qaeda, from PKK-YPG to FETÖ. With all these efforts, Turkey not only ensures its own security and peace but also pays the moral debt of the entire international community. While the recent refugee issue is filled with shameful images that will lower the heads of many countries, we have, thank God, always held our heads high and our foreheads open in this regard.

Similarly, while some are involved in oil sharing, wondering how much more oil we can extract, they brought this issue to us, and we said, "Our concern is not oil; our concern is humanity, saving these people." While many states do not hesitate to collaborate with terrorist organizations for oil or political gain, we maintain our honorable stance in this regard. Nevertheless, we cannot escape being subjected to slanders such as the so-called Armenian genocide. What is even more tragicomic is that we face threats of sanctions due to the legitimate steps we take to ensure our security. History records all these events. Future generations will evaluate these times and, God willing, will place Turkey and others in their rightful places. That is why we say let us seek good governance not only for our citizens but for all humanity. Until we demand and implement rights, law, justice, equality, respect, and all other principles for everyone, none of us can be at peace. Those who play a carefree theater of freedom and prosperity behind the walls they build today will understand very well what other people feel when their glass palaces come crashing down tomorrow. But unfortunately, by the time that day comes, it will be too late.

I hope that the principles of good governance, which is the theme of this year's Istanbul International Ombudsman Conference, will be discussed and talked about from this perspective.

With these feelings, I once again wish for the conference to be successful. I express my gratitude on behalf of myself and my nation to the ombudsmen and all speakers for their participation and contributions. I congratulate everyone who contributed to the organization of the conference.

I send you my love and respect; stay healthy.