4. Speech at the International Ombudsman Symposium

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

2 March 2017 · 4th International Ombudsman Symposium

Context
Erdoğan addressed the 4th International Ombudsman Symposium in Turkey on March 2, 2017, celebrating the Turkish Public Ombudsman Institution and discussing governance reforms.
Main themes
Ombudsman institution, citizen-state relations, democratic governance reform, accountability and transparency, Turkey's political transformation, rule of law, presidential government system, public oversight, Constitutional Court challenges, Ottoman historical roots of ombudsman
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,866
74th percentile
Sentences
148
80th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
11.4
38th percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
56th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 36%36%
  • Institutional 28%28%
  • Social 20%20%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

148 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Esteemed participants,

Valued guests,

The esteemed ombudspersons of the Republic of Turkey and friendly countries,

Ladies and gentlemen;

I greet you with my warmest feelings, with longing and affection. I wish for the successful conduct of the 4th International Ombudsman Symposium held this year. I thank the Turkish Public Ombudsman Institution, our very valuable Chief Ombudsman, and their colleagues for organizing this important symposium. I welcome all our esteemed friends participating in the symposium from both domestic and international backgrounds; I express my gratitude on behalf of myself and my nation for their proposals, criticisms, and contributions in advance.

Undoubtedly, such symposiums not only provide an opportunity for a general evaluation and sincere oversight but also contribute to the sharing of experiences from different countries, as well as the identification of shortcomings and mistakes. I believe that the discussions, presentations, and exchanges of ideas that will take place here over the next two days will serve to strengthen our public ombudsman institution in every aspect.

Dear friends;

The Public Ombudsman Institution, which we established in 2012, is one of the most concrete manifestations of our will to embrace the state and the citizen, to remove the barriers in between. In fact, we wanted to introduce the institution of ombudsman to our country much earlier. For this purpose, we passed Law No. 5548 in the Grand National Assembly of Turkey in 2006. However, as you know, this law was annulled by the Constitutional Court of the time, and therefore the establishment of the ombudsman was postponed to later years. Despite the delay, I take great pleasure in the fact that this institution, which draws its inspiration and roots from our own history, from the Ottoman Empire, has been made available to our citizens.

However, I would like to express the following point with care: The establishment process of the public ombudsman is very important in terms of identifying how old Turkey's habits positioned individuals. This event is critical in revealing the reasons for the change in the governance system in Turkey. Because the approach of those who went to the Constitutional Court in 2006 to annul the law is an expression of a problem that we are trying to prevent with the presidential government system. As you know, those who applied to the court for the annulment of Law No. 5548 were the then President and the main opposition party. Considering the perspective of the main opposition party and the structure of the Constitutional Court at that time, the annulment decision taken was not a surprise for anyone.

Yes, Turkey did not reach its current level easily. We fought against an understanding that blocked the way instead of opening it, that took on the guardianship of the status quo. We tried to serve our country by battling a mentality that constantly exerted pressure on the elected, like the Sword of Damocles, and turned the public power into a tool for aligning politics.

Many projects, services, and works that would benefit the country and the citizen were unfortunately sabotaged by vested interests specifically placed within the system. Steps that would increase effectiveness and efficiency in the public sector, strengthen transparency, accountability, and oversight were attempted to be blocked with various excuses. Law, constitution, and regulations were interpreted not with an innovative, conciliatory, and objective understanding, but with a completely status quo-oriented and ideological perspective.

When we look back at the point Turkey has reached today, what we have described may seem like distant events that happened years ago. I am also aware that our foreign guests may have difficulty understanding and making sense of these issues I have mentioned. However, what we have experienced is not the events of an unknown history or a distant past, but rather events from just 3-5 years ago. Rest assured, if we had not stood firm, if we had not put our bodies on the line, we would not have been able to achieve even one-tenth of what has been accomplished in this country.

Thanks to our efforts and the strong support of our nation, Turkey has undergone a transformation in these areas as well. The greatest change has also been in the nature of the relationship between the state and the citizen. In the last 14 years, Turkey has transitioned from an understanding that prioritizes the state's interests over those of its citizens to a system that prioritizes the citizen and protects their rights against the state; this is the essence of the matter.

The perception of the state as infinite has been abandoned, and a structure has been established that limits the state with law, conscience, and international agreements and rules. Instead of an atmosphere where our people feared and were apprehensive of the state, a climate has been created where they embraced their state at the cost of their lives, as seen during the July 15 coup attempt. In Turkey, there is now an understanding that serves the citizen, rather than a despotic, arrogant governance that looks down on its citizens. We cannot bear the thought of even a single citizen leaving the state’s door with their head bowed, their heart broken, feeling wronged. We believe that every citizen of this country, regardless of their origin, religion, sect, worldview, or lifestyle, is equal and has equal rights, and we are fighting for this.

My valued friends;

Of course, I do not claim that we have fully achieved our goals or that we are in a perfect place in every aspect. We are aware that this is a long and arduous process, but despite all the difficulties, we know that the reforms we have implemented have brought us one step closer to our ideals.

Indeed, the events of the night of July 15 have reaffirmed the validity of our observations. Setting aside all their differences, all 80 million people stood by their state that night. A gang that had infiltrated the state for 40 years, stealing the nation’s wealth, livelihood, and children under the guise of service and education, was defeated thanks to the resistance of 80 million. That night, our nation wrote a democracy epic in history with its blood and life.

Now we are taking determined steps towards the expulsion of this organization from state institutions. Despite all its difficulties, we hope to carry this process out within the framework of the law. Likewise, we are trying to clean up the traces of the damage the organization has inflicted on our state and social structure.

In addition, we are dealing with the games of the remnants of old Turkey, who enjoy hunting in murky waters and have pinned all their hopes on crisis and chaos. We hope that with the complete expulsion of the remnants of FETÖ and the guardianship centers, Turkey's path and destiny will open even further.

In this process, our Public Ombudsman Institution undoubtedly has important responsibilities. Despite all the difficulties experienced during its establishment phase, thank God today the Public Ombudsman Institution provides great services to our nation. The applications made to our institution in the last five years are an important indicator of the gap filled by the ombudsman mechanism. As was stated a moment ago, the number of applications made to the institution has approached 25,000. More than 23,000 of these have been examined and concluded. The compliance rate with the decisions made regarding the applications is 42%. Considering that this figure was 27% in 2013, we see that the effectiveness and enforcement capacity of the institution is increasing day by day. However, we do not find these levels sufficient. We must continue to work together to further increase this rate. I believe that with the support of myself, my government, and our Parliament, we will raise this rate to levels worthy of our country.

Valued guests;

I would like to express that I find it extremely appropriate for this year's symposium theme to be determined as 'migration and refugees.' Not only our country but almost every region of the world, from Asia to Europe, from Africa to America, is facing the issue of migration and refugees.

We just watched the situation and condition of refugees on the screen. We saw children and how they are living in misery. I believe it is essential for all of us to uphold the requirements of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights for them.

However, I must express that the strong countries are not sensitive to this issue. Today, discussions about migrants constitute the main topic of current politics, especially in European countries. The discussion is nice; but when it comes to solving the problem, unfortunately, it is merely observed.

Here, we need to make a good determination of the following point: Although the issue of migration and refugees ranks high on the agenda of states and international organizations, we see that the matter is discussed more in terms of security. Unfortunately, the humanitarian, social, legal, and moral dimensions of the problem are not sufficiently addressed. Undoubtedly, the serious impact of the terrorist attacks is present. Certain circles in the West, especially racist groups, are trying to establish a parallel between refugees and terrorist incidents. Evaluating the issue of refugees and migration solely within the security framework will inflict great wounds on the conscience of humanity.

First and foremost, we must identify the motives that cause people to leave their homes, their countries, and their loved ones. No one throws themselves, their families, and their beloved children into raging waves with makeshift boats without a compelling reason. Our Coast Guard Command has rescued 130,000 migrants from drowning in the seas and brought them to our country in the last two years. Despite all the tragedies experienced, if millions of people are willing to take this risk, it indicates that there is a serious problem that needs to be addressed and contemplated.

Currently, we are hosting 3 million refugees from Syria and Iraq in our country. And so far, our expenditures have reached 26 billion dollars. Unfortunately, neither the European Union has kept its promises, nor has the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. Whether they give or do not give, we will continue to host these people who are fleeing from weapons and barrel bombs in our home. We consider this a humanitarian duty. While they flee from bombs, we cannot do the same as the West, which closes its doors with barbed wire. Neither conscience, nor Islamic, nor humanitarian understanding allows us to do so.

Without identifying the causes that lead to the deaths of babies like Aylan, we cannot accurately determine what needs to be done to solve this issue. In this regard, I find it very valuable to involve humanitarian aid organizations alongside public institutions in determining the topics of presentations and discussions at the symposium. Because these organizations see firsthand the reasons that force people to migrate.

Representatives of these organizations are the first to witness the planes that shatter children's hopes, the civilians struggling to survive under barrel bombs, and the prisons where all kinds of torture are experienced. They know best that the issue cannot be addressed solely in the context of security and humanitarian crisis. At this point, I believe that their contributions to the discussions and sharing of experiences will be very valuable for both our guests and our Public Ombudsman Institution.

Dear friends;

Although Turkey has recently faced the issue of migration and refugees intensely due to the instabilities in Syria and Iraq, it is by no means a stranger to this issue due to its history and geography. Anatolia, this land, is a land of migrants.

For centuries, this land has been a safe haven for the oppressed who have faced persecution, oppression, and violence in their countries. From the Jews fleeing massacres 500 years ago to Christians in Western Europe, and to Circassians, all the oppressed have found a protective shelter in this country.

As I have stated before; Turkey is a 'safe haven,' a land of trust for the oppressed. In the words of our late brother Fethi Gemuhluoğlu, this is a country of friends who wipe away tears without letting the eye see. Our nation has embraced everyone who comes to its door, regardless of their religion, language, or ethnic background, and has set a place at the table for them. We believe that the way to live and survive is through giving, sharing, and the blessings of sharing.

With this understanding, we have supported our neighbors coming from Syria and Iraq for six years, and we have not left them to the mercy of dictators, bloodthirsty killers, and terrorist organizations. We have mobilized all our resources for our brothers and sisters trying to survive both within the country and along the border. Additionally, we have prevented loss of life in the Aegean, controlling irregular migration and breaking the chain of human smuggling. The expenditures we have made for our brothers and sisters in Syria and Iraq have reached 26 billion dollars, as I mentioned earlier. The contributions made by international organizations, along with the latest arrivals, amount to about 1.2 billion dollars from the European Union and the United Nations.

Today, Turkey has the title of the most generous country in the world with its humanitarian and development aid carried out in more than 140 countries.

On this occasion, I regret to state the following: Unfortunately, the efforts of Turkey have not been matched by even one-tenth of what developed countries have shown. Countries that constantly lecture us on democracy and rule of law have remained silent on the violation of the most basic human rights in regions like Syria and Iraq. The international community and organizations have unfortunately failed to pass a successful test in resolving humanitarian crises.

The proposal for a 'terror-free safe zone' that our country has persistently voiced for years has been ignored. In our bilateral discussions, they always told me, 'It's a very good proposal.' When I said, 'Then let's take a step,' unfortunately, a policy of forgetting has always been pursued. It has been the same in Syria, and it has been the same in Iraq. And unfortunately, those who provide arms support to the PYD and YPG are these powers. We have documents for all of them. Those who provided arms support to ISIS are also these powers. Now we are the ones fighting against ISIS, but what does the West say? 'Turkey supports ISIS.' We are the ones fighting against ISIS.

Right now, we have lost martyrs in Syria; the Free Syrian Army has lost martyrs; but thank God we have killed more than 3,000 ISIS members in Syria, and we will continue to do so. Because they pose a threat to us. Let me also say this, here our guests

The organization known as ISIS has nothing to do with Islam, and I want you to know this. It is a completely un-Islamic organization. Some friends say "Islamic radicalism," they say "Islamic terrorism." Please, no one should associate terrorism with Islam. Because Islam is peace; in terms of its literal meaning, it comes from the word "silm," which also expresses peace. And a religion that is, by definition, peace, a religion of greeting cannot be associated with terrorism. This is a very serious operation for us; we cannot accept such an operation, and we are telling this to all our friends.

Dear friends;

In a world that is globalizing and increasingly turning into a large village, no one can remain indifferent to the problems of others; pain has no color. Our fate and our sorrow are common. Problems cannot be solved by ignoring them. If we want peace, if we want tranquility, we must turn our direction not inward, but towards the places where crises and conflicts exist. We must not forget that our security passes through the safety of our neighbors. The painful events we have experienced in recent years have shown that while Aleppo, Baghdad, and Mosul are burning, Gaziantep, Brussels, and Berlin cannot be at peace. Therefore, the necessary actions are clear. Solutions that will prevent the Mediterranean from turning into a large graveyard swallowing the bodies of tens of thousands of refugees are evident.

We say that the refugee and migration issue cannot be overcome without sacrifices, without sharing burdens, and without changing the bloody exploitation system that has been established. We express that policies that fuel conflicts in the name of economic interests and escalate ethnic, religious, and sectarian tensions are not the solution to the problems we face. I believe that the experiences Turkey has distilled from history and re-harvested over the last six years, while hosting 3 million refugees on its soil, are extremely valuable.

I also value the experiences our guests have seen and lived in their own countries from every aspect. I find the experiences in African countries particularly meaningful. I believe that throughout the symposium, all these experiences will be discussed in depth, and proposals that will guide the whole world will be put forward.

With these thoughts, I once again congratulate those who contributed to the organization of the symposium. I extend my love and respect to you all. Stay healthy.