9. Speech at the Meeting of Mukhtars

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

19 August 2015 · Meeting of Mukhtars · Presidential Complex

Context
Erdoğan addressed the ninth monthly meeting with mukhtars from Eastern and Southeastern Turkish provinces at the Presidential Complex on August 19, 2015.
Main themes
Mukhtars meetings, regional development and infrastructure, airports expansion, Eastern and Southeastern Anatolia, democratic representation, PKK threats and intimidation, Presidential Complex, human rights progress, equality between regions, Turkey's transformation over 12 years
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,260
92nd percentile
Sentences
350
96th percentile
Readability
70
97th percentile
Grade
7.2
2nd percentile
Syntax
2.65
10th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 36%34%
  • Social 22%22%
  • Geopolitical 20%20%
  • Ceremonial 16%15%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

350 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Dear esteemed mukhtars,

Dear brothers and sisters;

I greet you with my heartfelt feelings. Welcome to the Presidential Complex, the home of the nation.

Today, we are holding the ninth meeting we have been conducting with our mukhtars since January. Through these meetings, we have had the opportunity to converse and catch up with mukhtars from every corner of our country. Today, we are together with you, our valuable mukhtars from Bingöl, Bitlis, Diyarbakır, Erzincan,

Erzurum, Hakkâri, Iğdır, Malatya, Muş, Tunceli, Batman, Şanlıurfa, and Ankara. Our goal is to gather and converse with all the mukhtars in our country in this way and to share our table.

At the very beginning of my words, I would like to give you a brief information about the Presidential Complex we are in: The building where we are holding our meeting is, in a sense, the showcase of our Presidential Complex. We manage official ceremonies, official receptions, and other activities from here. In the two blocks next to it, there are the working offices of the Presidential units. Right in front of us is the National Mosque, which we inaugurated during Ramadan, and which we believe is worthy of this area and Ankara.

The construction of the congress center next to our mosque is still ongoing. God willing, we will have it opened for service by the end of the year. Further down, we will build a multi-purpose building where we can hold dining meetings for 2,000 people, which will also include exhibition halls. And right next to it, we will construct the largest library in our country, which will serve our people, students, and researchers 24 hours a day, containing 5 million volumes of books. The project works for these two works are ongoing. As soon as they are completed, we will start construction. Our mosque, our congress center, our multi-purpose building, and our library will be open for everyone’s use. I am pleased to have contributed to our country and Ankara with a complex that is a source of pride for our nation.

Dear brothers and sisters,

Today, we have mukhtars primarily from our Southeastern and Eastern Anatolia regions among us. I would like to make a sincere assessment of Turkey's last 12 years and the process we are currently experiencing with you. Perhaps the young people under 30 may not know because they have not seen it; but some of you must remember the 1970s very well, and all of you must remember the 1990s. We lived through the days of scarcity and poverty in Turkey together with you. We must never forget those years when we had to live without many of the services we now possess and cannot even imagine being without. Thirteen years ago, there were 26 airports in Turkey, but thank God, the number of these airports has now reached 55. And now it is possible to reach Ankara and Istanbul from almost every province by coming to the airports. Were we not human beings? Why did we not have the opportunity to travel by air? George was flying, Helga was flying, but why couldn’t Ahmet and Fatma fly? Did those in the past have such a problem? Unfortunately, they did not. But we were troubled, and because we were troubled, we achieved this. Just think, if it had been said 15 years ago, ‘An airport will be opened in Iğdır, an airport will be opened in Hakkâri, an airport will be opened in Kars, an airport will be opened in Muş, an airport will be opened in Ağrı,’ would you have believed it? ‘Impossible, come on, who would come here? What is the business of these in the Southeast, in the East while the West is there?’ They always looked at it this way, they evaluated it this way. But we did not think that way when we set out. We said one homeland, ‘whatever exists in the West will also exist in the East, whatever exists in the North will also exist in the South.’ We said, ‘All of our citizens in our 780,000 square kilometers of homeland will benefit from this with the understanding of one nation.’ Are these things present now? Yes. Is it still continuing? Yes. Because we love this nation, we love this homeland. But we also see that there are those who do not love it. Let us never forget the nightmare years we experienced in terms of human rights, torture, freedoms, and the security of life and property.

Look now, what have they done again? Have they started this? They have started. I know that many of our mukhtars have been threatened even regarding today’s meeting. I know that they have been threatened despite wanting to come. And I also know that there are mukhtars who could not come because of this. Who is a mukhtar? Is he a civil servant? A mukhtar is elected. By whom? By the people. Just as the President is elected by the people, a mukhtar is also elected by the people, so in my view, in the democracy I believe in, the elected is superior to the appointed. Everyone who believes in democracy interprets this matter in this way. But those who do not believe in democracy say, ‘No, I appointed you there, you will do what I say.’ Now, don’t those who point guns say the same thing? They have no such evaluation at this point; because they do not have a religious concern at this point.

We must keep alive in our minds the dark days when the policies of rejection, denial, and assimilation weighed heavily on our nation. Was there a State of Emergency when we came to office 13 years ago? Yes, there was. But didn’t we lift the State of Emergency within a month? We lifted it, and at that time, when we were traveling around the Southeast, the East, all of my citizens there were telling us: ‘Just lift the State of Emergency.’ We lifted it, but was that enough, my brothers? After that, what did we discuss, what did we converse about? They said television, did we start broadcasting 24 hours? We did. Did we start propaganda in our own language? We did. Were institutes established in universities? They were established. Alongside all of this, dear brothers and sisters; did these distinctions of Turkish, Kurdish, Laz, Circassian, Georgian, Abkhaz, etc. disappear in this country? They disappeared. Were infrastructure and superstructure investments made? They were made. Are they being made? They are being made. Despite all these distinctions being removed, what is the reason for the killing and martyring of our saplings in this country? Let me tell you what they want: These dear brothers and sisters are trying to divide our country.

The days in Turkey when economic devastations came one after another, and the environment of trust and stability was shattered, thank God, are no longer. But they cannot digest this. After such a period, we took on the responsibility of managing the country with the favor of our nation, we rolled up our sleeves. We began to implement very profound reform policies in every field. Just think, do we have universities in all 81 provinces of Turkey, dear brothers and sisters? Yes. But was there such a thing before? There was not. Especially if it had been said 13 years ago that there would be a university in the Southeast, it would have been said, ‘Come on, where would a university come here?’ It came. Now, can my Kurdish brother in the most remote corner send his child to the university there? He can. But they are trying to burn and destroy those universities. They are the ones who burn schools, they are the ones who burn hospitals, they are the ones who burn our mosques. We are together to continue a common struggle against these excesses and actions of the terrorists; we will do this together.

On one hand, we have been striving to bring the economy back on track and to raise the welfare of our nation, while on the other hand, we have fought to expand the area of democracy and freedoms. But we did not take orders from the mountain; we took orders from God and the people; that was our difference.

I will not go into detail about the difficulties we faced during this process, the obstacles placed in front of us, and the traps set; you have witnessed all of them, you know them very well. The April 27 Declaration, the Gezi events, the December 17-25 coup attempt, and the recent terrorist incidents all aim at the same purpose; to block Turkey, to prevent its growth, development, and strengthening, and unfortunately, these efforts found support both from outside and from within. We overcame all these ordeals with the support of our nation. The address for solving the issues before us today is again our nation, the will of our nation.

Dear friends,

In the past 12 years, we have made very sincere efforts to strengthen our unity, solidarity, and brotherhood. We took very serious risks for this cause. The works we initiated under the name of democratic opening were first transformed into the national unity and brotherhood project, and then into the resolution process. We have implemented very serious investments for the development, growth, and increase of the welfare level of the region. While 6,100 kilometers of divided roads were built in 79 years, dear brothers and sisters; we have managed to fit 17,000 kilometers of divided roads into 12 years. Why? We wanted our brothers in Erzurum, Ağrı, Kars, Iğdır, Hakkâri, in short, to have no city without a road. Is there this now in Muş? Yes. Is there in Bitlis? Yes. Did we break through those mountains? We did. Dear brothers and sisters, who would have thought that these mountains would be pierced? And by piercing these mountains, it will be possible to pass through here comfortably, regardless of summer or winter. These issues have been resolved.

Do you know how much investment has been made in the Eastern and Southeastern Anatolia Region in 12 years? 260 billion, in old terms, we have invested 260 quadrillion in the East and Southeast Anatolia. I am talking about what we have done, not words.

We have changed the face of the region in every area from transportation to mass housing, we have compensated for years of neglect. Just in Van, we invested 17 quadrillion, we rebuilt Van. Just think, in 1.5 years, 2 years, we rebuilt Van after the earthquake; the investment we made just for the earthquake was 5 quadrillion. When you go to Erciş, you will see a new Erciş. Edremit, almost overlooking the sea, -I do not call it a lake, I do not call it Lake Van- we built a city. Well, there are those who appreciate it, and there are those who do not; they will probably understand in the end. We took these steps too. Why? We said, ‘Throw it into the sea, if the fish does not know, the Creator knows,’ we walked this way, our approach was like this. Why? We loved the created for the sake of the Creator. We did not look at it as Turkish, Kurdish, Laz, Arab, or Romani; we looked at it as a human being in front of us. And for this reason, we took steps to completely eliminate the policies of rejection, denial, and assimilation. We made regulations that removed bans in every area, from television broadcasts to names, opening the way for freedoms.

I openly say; in this process, the state and the government have fulfilled their responsibilities to establish an atmosphere of peace and brotherhood. Our nation has also patiently, steadfastly, and hopefully provided the necessary support for this process. However, the organization and the party under its control have poisoned this beautiful climate with lies, cunning, and arrogance, choosing to side with violence and oppression. Those who complained yesterday about the oppression, violence, and pressure of the state are today resorting to the same methods by exploiting the environment of democracy and freedom. Today, there is not the violence of the state in the region, but the violence, oppression, and pressure of the organization. Remember the events of October 6-8. The dead were Kurds, and the killers were also Kurds. Can you say otherwise? In the incidents happening today, the citizens who lost their lives are not all from the region? They are from their own people. Terrorists attack ambulances carrying the sick, the victim is the local people... This is an ambulance carrying the sick, they burn the ambulance. Terrorists burn trucks carrying supplies, the victim is again the local people... That truck, that lorry, these are not mine, they belong to the local people. Terrorists lay mines on the roads, dig up the streets, block transportation, the victim is again the local people, those living there... Schools are burned, health centers, hospitals are stoned, fire trucks are blocked, blood collection vehicles are destroyed, shutters are pulled down, dam constructions are blocked, transformers are blown up, all natural gas lines are exploded, the ones who suffer are always the local people... Here, the citizens living in the region, especially you mukhtars, have a very important duty. Our citizens must stand by their state and security forces against these excesses and actions of the terrorists.

Dear brothers and sisters;

There is a choice, ‘I am on the side of my state’ or ‘I am on the side of the terrorist organization’; we will make this choice. If we are to die, let us die once, but let us die like men; that is the issue. If in a village, a town, or a district, terrorists can move freely by mingling with the people, it means that the local people are not doing their part. I said this before in the previous mukhtar meeting, a well-known newspaper, I can easily name it, Cumhuriyet Newspaper, says ‘he reported the people.’ I say; will the mukhtar not know which house in his neighborhood, in his village, who lives there? He will know. Will he not know if this is a terrorist or not? He will know. Well, he will report this to the nearest security force, to the gendarmerie. Because the step the mukhtar takes at this point will strengthen the state. A strong state is essential for the peace and welfare of our people there; we will do this, we are obliged to do this. Otherwise, terrorism, dear brothers and sisters, takes lives in the city center, we cannot give them the opportunity.

The state and government have chosen to stand by brotherhood and peace to the end. Indeed, it was not the state that restarted the conflicts, but the separatist organization with its statement on July 11. Those who should have acted with the possibilities and language of politics have unfortunately surrendered to the organization’s stance of violence and blood. Those who claim otherwise are lying. The situation of those who try to justify the actions carried out by the separatist organization with bombs, guns, Molotov cocktails, masks, and pressure is like an ostrich burying its head in the sand. The truths are starkly evident. But they live in another world, drowning in their own lies and slanders, I must say this too.

In the last election, although there were serious irregularities, those who used the votes they received not for democracy but to open the way for terrorism will have to account for this to the nation and to justice. At this point, those who call for the organization to silence its weapons instead of the state are also clearly...

is in a state of negligence and even betrayal. The state's security force is armed; will it let go? The weapon is its instrument. Why is it this instrument? It will do this for the safety of its people, for the peace of its people. The terrorist will lay down arms. Not only will it not lay them down, but it will bury them in concrete, and this will also be detected. Now they come out, they are awake, what do they say? "Let the guns be silent." Do not fall for this game; what does "let the guns be silent" mean? You will lay down the weapon and bury it in concrete. Look at the terrorist organizations in the world; this is how it was done. They buried the weapon in concrete, it was buried, and it was covered with concrete, and this was detected. Either surrender, or... Or leave this country... Because they do not suit this country.

The state is the only structure that has the right to possess all kinds of weapons for the security of the country and the nation and to use them when necessary. Of course, those who use expressions in this direction have different intentions. Those who say they lean on terrorists who use weapons that shed blood and take lives and support them are stabbing the back of this homeland, from which they eat bread and drink water, with their stance. This so-called enlightened group, columnists, are partners in the responsibility of every death and every tear shed; they are in betrayal. Those who do not say a word to the terrorists who brutally kill people who are in pursuit of their bread or at their duty, but attack the security forces that neutralize these terrorists are at the very bottom of the pit of treachery. This rootless, immoral, and heartless group that has no sense of belonging to the homeland and the nation should not think that what they do will go unpunished. Our nation will certainly give the lesson that this "belhum edal" group, which does not even refrain from using the deaths of innocent people for their perverse ideologies, deserves.

The state and the government have no obligation or debt to the separatist organization, nor to the party under its control, nor to the so-called enlightened group. I say this to those columnists, to those who pretend to be enlightened, and I say this to those who have many careers ahead of them; the ink that flows from your pens is blood. What matters to me is the rank my martyr has reached. From the very beginning, the addressee of the solution process was the nation itself. We spoke our words to the nation. We did what we did for our nation, for its bright future. Today, our only responsibility is again to our nation.

But now what do I say? After all these events, the solution process is now in the refrigerator. We are currently continuing on our path with the national unity and brotherhood project. This issue is definitely not a matter of give-and-take, a matter of concession; it is a matter of democracy. It is a matter of rights and freedoms, even a matter of truth and falsehood, a matter of development.

It is the terrorist organization that has turned a process walking on such noble foundations back into a security and order problem; let us know this. Politicians who do not oppose this have also fallen into a situation that undermines their own reason for existence.

The path of politics leads to democracy and development, while the path of terrorism leads to blood, death, and pain. I want to express once again my belief that the issue before Turkey will be resolved through unity, togetherness, brotherhood, and unification around common future and common goals. Those who insist on terrorism are receiving the response they deserve and will continue to do so. It seems that this blessed struggle, which has been ongoing for a thousand years in the geography of Anatolia, will continue indefinitely. I say, between Cain and Abel, who was the murderer? It was Cain; what did he do to his brother Abel? He killed him. The struggle began there. And it has continued to the point where our beloved Prophet received our holy book, the Quran, and there it was stated, "Do not say of those who are killed in the way of Allah, 'They are dead.' They are alive, but you do not perceive." What does this mean? It means that this struggle will continue until the Day of Judgment. But we will never call them dead. They are alive; they are in the rank of martyrdom, which is the highest rank after prophethood. In this struggle, I pray for God's mercy on all the martyrs who have once again registered these lands as our homeland with their blood. Our nation has never forgotten their sacrifices, nor will it forget.

Dear brothers and sisters;

Turkey is experiencing the process of forming a government in such an environment. Unfortunately, Turkey has not yet reached its new government because no results have been obtained from the discussions held. In this situation, we must seek the solution, as always, in the will of the nation. I am conducting this process within the framework specified in the Constitution, and I will continue to do so. However, I want to emphasize one point here; Turkey has a problem of forming a government. Along with this, there is a serious problem of terrorism. There are very serious incidents occurring at our Syrian border, and there are also steps that need to be taken in the economy. There are decisions to be made and work to be done in other areas. These are the priority issues that we need to discuss, debate, and seek solutions for today. But in our country, a segment is discussing my person day and night, leaving all of this aside. Well, when we look at what their issues are regarding my person, unfortunately, we see nothing but childish observations, childish criticisms, and childish whims. Whatever you say. And we need to ask them one thing: Do you have a tree planted in this country? What work have you done in this country, tell me? None. You were a partner in power for 3.5 years; what did you do? You left without doing anything; you ran away, you could not manage.

Now, we see that the Prime Minister I assigned visited them, toured, and there was no result, and he returned last night. Those who are trying to erase their responsibilities by blaming me and my position for their own incompetence, their own failures, and their own disappointments are engaged in a futile struggle.

From the very beginning, we have advocated an understanding that embraces all 81 provinces, every inch of 780,000 square kilometers of our homeland, that produces projects, services, and solutions for this purpose, and we continue to defend it.

Today, I believe that such an approach is needed for Turkey to overcome the problems ahead. In other words, you will produce projects, you will provide services, you will generate solutions; in other words, you will do politics. Politics is not about abandoning your work and dealing with Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and his family. It is not about saying, "Give my son Bilal, take the power." What a disgusting approach this is; what kind of politician are you? If my son has made a mistake, if he has committed corruption, the one who will hold him accountable is the judiciary; who are you? How can you establish a connection between my child and power? How can you make such an insult, such a disrespect? But those who have no children can do nothing but such disrespect. Because they do not know what family is, they do not know what a child is. Therefore, they do not know what rights and truths are. Unfortunately, they want to achieve something with such empty insults. What is that? Comparisons to Mussolini, Hitler... Look in the mirror; first, see where you stand.

We did not take our inspiration from Mussolini or Hitler; we took it from the truth and the people, and we walked this way; you must know this once. And if the government formation efforts in Turkey are going down a path that my people will find extremely difficult to accept, my people see very well who bears the burden of this, will see it, and I believe they will make them pay the price. Has anyone heard of those who have been dealing with me so far bringing a reasonable proposal for the solution of the terrorism issue? Well, as a politician, are you not responsible for this? Why do you not put your body under this stone? Why do you not take a step to bear this responsibility? They have no such issue, no such concern. And I am not talking about empty words in the economy, foreign policy, social security, health, education, justice, and other areas; pay attention, has anyone heard that they have put forward serious, well-thought-out, grounded projects? Those who cannot go beyond dealing with Beştepe cannot give hope to our nation for a remedy for their troubles. In fact, I must say that we have no time to waste with those who do not even know the address of Beştepe.

In fact, I know very well that their concern is not me but the nation that does not give them credibility. This understanding that harasses the nation through my person and goes so far as to insult the nation is doomed to always lose. Because they want the future of the country and the nation to be handed over to them without working, without putting in effort, without producing projects, without sweating. Our nation says, "You cannot get 5 meatballs for 3 cents." First, you will deserve it, then you will demand it. This nation has seen many who come saying, "I am coming to save you," while adding new burdens to their backs and running away. When the purpose is not service, defeat is inevitable. I advise those who see me as the cause of their defeats to reflect on themselves.

Finally, they have twisted my statement about the change in the management system in Turkey. You know, according to the constitutional amendment accepted in the Parliament and published in the Official Gazette on June 16, 2007, which received 69% support in the referendum on October 21, 2007, the President of our country is now elected by the people. The first implementation of this change took place on August 10, 2014. This is a fundamental change initiated not by a coup but by a parliamentary decision and the will of the people; this has been expressed. For the first time in Turkey's history, is a new management model being created by the Parliament and the will of the people? It is being created. The constitutional literature is clear. Everyone knows this openly. This is a system change. Look, I am talking about the Constitution. I must express that I have very serious doubts about the ability of those who struggle to comprehend this obvious truth to find solutions to the other issues of the country. Those who conduct politics at the level of an elementary school play cannot grasp any issue of this country, nor can they provide solutions to them. I want to express that I am extremely saddened on behalf of my country and my nation about this situation. If Aleppo is there, the measuring stick is here; we are rapidly heading towards another election. Those who know nothing but repeating the nonsense that I have refrained from answering to avoid unnecessary polemics will express their troubles to the nation in the election.

Indeed, they have always been in an effort to escape from the ballot box. However, when they are forced, they have come out to the election squares. The June 7 elections are over. When the picture was like this, they went to the podium and what did they say? "Bring it on, early election." Now they do not want it. One of them came out and said, "I will not do it with this one," now he says, "I will do it." Another one came out and said, "I will not go to Beştepe," now we see that they have started to say, "I can go to Beştepe." What kind of business is this?

Dear brothers and sisters;

You know how they say; a child said, "Dad, I caught a thief." The father said, "Son, bring him." The child said, "He is not coming, Dad." The father said, "Let him go." The child said, "He is not going, Dad." Their situation is exactly like this... Form a government, they do not form it. Go to the election, they do not go. Well, then what do you want? Believe me, they do not know that either. Then they come out and say the President is preventing the formation of the government. The conditions for the formation of the government are clear; did you come and meet these conditions, and did the President kick you out the door? Did you agree to form a government, shake hands, and did the President hit your hand?

So far, I have not intervened in this matter other than implementing the processes specified in the Constitution. Of course, when someone asks for my opinion, I express my opinion, and I will continue to do so. I am not in a position to ask for permission from anyone for this; the nation has given me permission, and I will use the permission given by the nation. This is my most natural right as a citizen, as an individual. The claims beyond this have no rational basis. The ballot box is also a place for accountability to the nation. It should not be forgotten that not only the work done but also the work avoided will be accounted for at the ballot box. As always and in every matter, dear brothers and sisters, I trust the common sense, wisdom, discernment, and judgment of my nation in this matter.

Dear brothers and sisters;

At the beginning of our meeting, the officials from our Ministry of Interior introduced the Muhtar Information System established within our Ministry. In the dining hall we will go to shortly, there will be a muhtar information form in front of each of you. The same form is also available in the system that you can access online, which has been introduced to you. You can report your requests, needs, expectations, and complaints regarding other institutions to our Ministry by filling out either the form on your table or the form on the internet.

Last week, I asked our Minister how many applications there have been so far. They said, "There have been about 10,000 applications." I asked, "How many have you resolved?" They said, "We have resolved about 5,000 issues so far." Now, I hope our Ministry will resolve these types of issues by following up. Our Ministry will follow all these requests on your behalf with the relevant institutions. It may not only be related to itself; there may be an issue in Transportation, in the DSI, in Forestry, whatever ministry it is, it will follow all of them.

Once again, I thank each of you for honoring the Presidential Complex, the house of the nation. I especially ask you to convey my greetings, respect, and affection to each of your brothers and sisters in your neighborhoods and villages. We will be together at dinner shortly.

For now, I greet you with love and respect, and I say may Allah be our helper and supporter.