Speech at the 7th Bosphorus Summit on the Theme of 'Global Future: Human-Centered Smart Economy'

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

29 November 2016 · 7th Bosphorus Summit · Istanbul, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed the 7th Bosphorus Summit in Istanbul on November 29, 2016, organized by the International Cooperation Platform to discuss global future and smart economy themes.
Main themes
Human-centered smart economy, technology and automation, global future and prosperity, poverty reduction, income inequality, employment disruption, international trade, regional cooperation, digital transformation, geopolitical reconstruction, Bosphorus Summit platform
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,193
78th percentile
Sentences
159
83rd percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
2.97
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 45%43%
  • Geopolitical 21%20%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Social 12%12%
  • Technological 8%8%
  • Institutional 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

159 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Dear Presidents,

Dear Ministers,

Valued participants of the Summit,

Esteemed guests;

I greet you with my warmest feelings, with affection and respect. I hope that the 7th Bosphorus Summit, organized regularly by the International Cooperation Platform since 2009, will be filled with successes. On the occasion of the Summit, I welcome our guests who have honored our country and our Istanbul.

Istanbul is at the center of the geographies that are leading the world through the pains of reconstruction. I believe that this summit, where we will discuss the global future and global goals, has gathered in exactly the right place, both in terms of its venue and its spirit.

I would like to thank the International Cooperation Platform, which has been organizing this summit regularly for 7 years, for this event, which I see as aligned with the vision of Turkey, the locomotive country of the political and economic diplomacy of its region. I would like to express my gratitude in advance to everyone who will contribute to the summit with their opinions, experiences, proposals, and criticisms.

I believe that such platforms for exchange of views and cooperation are important in a period when the world and our region are facing new and greater problems every day. I hope that the Bosphorus Summit will continue to increase its effectiveness in the coming years, facilitating close cooperation among the countries and private sectors of the region.

Dear presidents, esteemed guests;

I see that this year's sessions of the summit will primarily address proposals and threats regarding the future. Of course, when we think of the future, what comes to mind first is especially advanced technology. The developments in technology are among the fundamental elements of the transformation our world has undergone in the past 200 years. It is quite normal for the technology that builds the past to also be effective in our future.

The transformative power of technology is indeed impressive. The changes we have witnessed in this field so far have mostly consisted of developments that increase people's comfort and ease their lives. Innovations that cannot be compared to the past have virtually surrounded our lives through technology products in every field, from transportation to health, from communication to education. For example, early diagnosis achieved through advanced imaging techniques in healthcare has enabled painless and bloodless treatments, putting an end to the painful processes caused by diseases. In education, smart boards and classes conducted through remote access have initiated a new era. Thanks to the internet, libraries full of data can be delivered in a very short time from anywhere in the world to the other end. Instead of sailors who had to travel with primitive compasses just a few centuries ago, we now have people who can easily reach their desired destination using navigation on their smartphones, and even driverless cars.

Although not everyone has equal access, it is a fact that the influence of technology is rapidly expanding. This situation makes the competition between humans and technology inevitable. Indeed, many elements that we once heard as fantastic elements in science fiction films and literature are increasingly becoming concrete realities. Farms almost entirely operated by robots are becoming operational in Japan. Factories where robots work instead of humans on production lines are becoming more common. Unmanned aerial vehicles have started to be used in almost every field, including delivering orders to supermarkets, restaurants, and stores. Shopping is increasingly being done online.

All these developments come with striking effects in many areas, from employment to income distribution. While global trade growth is being evaluated above expectations, we see that the use of technology has created a very different ground, becoming widespread. The increase in promises to restrict international trade in elections in many countries is also a sign that trade wars are approaching. Particularly in developed countries, the use of robots instead of unskilled labor in production has a significant impact on widening the gap in quality of life between the rich and the poor.

When we look at the overall picture and trends, we can say that we have now entered an irreversible path in this area. In this respect, I believe that it is a wise choice for this year's Bosphorus Summit, which focused on the theme of less poverty and more prosperity last year, to convene under the title "Global Future, Global Goals."

Esteemed guests;

Increasing prosperity while reducing poverty is not a development that can be achieved spontaneously. Because our world is increasingly facing the pains caused by injustices seen in every area. In a world where millions of dollars are spent to go to space as tourists, and right next to them are large masses who have lost their jobs to robots and the internet, sustainable growth is not possible. The tendency of technology to limit employment and wages will be felt much more intensely in the coming period. It is stated that many young people entering the workforce in developed countries today have to work for much lower wages and accept a much lower level of prosperity compared to their parents. We are all witnessing examples of how these developments lead to negative consequences for democracies.

The hate policies developed against immigrants, whom Western societies see as a threat to their current level of prosperity—this is very important, there are over 3 million refugees in Turkey, and we do not see them as a threat—while Western society sees 100, 200, or 300 people as a threat to themselves, have begun to seize the governance of these countries. Turkey is the country most affected by this negativity. For example, since 2001, when the wave of hostility against foreigners and Islam began to rise, there have been 416 attacks against mosques and Muslims in Germany alone. Of these attacks, 46 occurred in the first 9 months of this year. Our citizens living in Germany constitute the group most affected by these attacks and experiencing victimization. These hate attacks will continue to increase, fueled by the growing political support.

On the other hand, it will not surprise anyone that the campaigns currently being conducted against immigrants will soon be directed against robots, which Western societies will again see as a threat to their prosperity. This situation shows that without focusing on human-centered technologies, and without paving the way for developments that increase prosperity while reducing poverty, democracies cannot survive.

Note that today, in the developed countries of the world, the most advanced technological tools are used in the most complex production techniques. But when we look at the same countries, we see that their economies are still dependent on housing sales, and that people invest their wealth in such areas. Practices like negative interest rates, which until recently were unimaginable, have become everyday policy tools for the central banks of developed countries. Despite all this, developed countries are unable to overcome the stagnation they are experiencing in growth. Because their diagnoses are wrong, they are looking for treatment in the wrong places.

The nature of the economy is based on demand. Neither robots nor financial instruments produce demand. Only people create demand. Therefore, the path to sustainable growth lies in expanding the opportunities for people, or rather, for people to live in peace and prosperity.

In conclusion; in the coming period, the one that will determine the winner in trade and war, along with technological superiority, is again human, it is us. Without population growth, without establishing a financial system that supports production and investment, and without adopting an understanding that prioritizes justice in every field, a healthy global future cannot be built. Since technology cannot be banned in this struggle, developing methods to adapt to it is the right path.

Esteemed guests;

Education, as in every period and in every field, is the most important tool that can bring the job opportunities brought by technology to broad segments of society in the new global system. Free trade agreements are certainly important in terms of providing cheap access to many products. However, opening all doors without educating those who lose their jobs because of this will bring new and difficult challenges to overcome. Especially since technology will increasingly take over many jobs done by unskilled workers, ways must be sought to equip people with new skills. Indeed, some new applications that have entered our curriculum aim to increase our competitiveness in smart economies.

In this context, an important value we need to focus on is productivity. Here, of course, I care about two things. As human beings, will we focus on the economy of productivity, or will we also focus on the economy of waste? When we look at life today, unfortunately, the economy of waste is rampant. In a family, instead of one car, you see two cars, three cars. The wife, the children, all have cars; this is called the economy of waste, not the economy of productivity. But when we transition to the economy of productivity, what will come into play? Investments will come into play. Where there are investments, employment will come into play, and where there is employment, production will begin. Where all these exist, competition will begin in that society, and with the increase of competitive power in that society, growth will follow.

According to a prediction made by the United Nations in 2014, by 2050, global food demand will be approximately 60% higher than today. This indicates that we need to obtain more products from the same amount of land. But on the other hand, according to the assessments of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, one-third of the food produced globally turns into waste, which is significant. The approximately 222 million tons of food waste that occurs annually in developed countries is almost equivalent to the annual food production of Sub-Saharan Africa, which is 230 million tons; this is the economy of waste. This situation makes it inevitable that one of the foundations of a human-centered economy is, especially I insist, the economy of productivity, the economy of thrift.

One of the significant developments that will affect human life in the near future will be urbanization. The proportion of the population living in cities, which was 54% worldwide as of 2015, is expected to rise to 66% by 2050. In our country, the proportion of the population living in cities has reached 88%. The increase in urbanization requires us to develop new perspectives in every area, especially in transportation, education, health, retail, and services. Here, the transition from the "economy focused on humans" model to the "human-centered economy" model will be the most meaningful legacy that can be passed on to future generations. For this, I will also mention this beautiful saying that we inherited from our history and ancestors: "Live humanely so that the state may live."

In the new era, phones and the internet will strengthen and sustain their position as the fundamental infrastructure of the economy, just as in every area of life. The fact that education ranks first in our country’s information and communication projects with 45%, followed by public services at 32% and the transportation sector at 11%, shows that we are on the right track. Communication opportunities are a significant opportunity in solving the problems of crowded human communities that have to live together as a result of urbanization. As a result, we must seek ways to develop economic activities without compromising human values. We must do this within the boundaries of the ancient civilization we inherit. Otherwise, we will lose both our path and our direction.

To avoid being more severely affected by the problems currently faced by developed countries, we must preserve our uniqueness and freedom. When I say localism, when I say nationalism, we must not lose this. July 15 is the name and address of this struggle for us. Our nation has given us hope for the future by showing that it will defend its independence, future, democracy, and will at the cost of its life. Rest assured: The path ahead for today's Turkey is much clearer and brighter than it was on the morning of July 15.

Of course, I have also been saying recently, and I will say it here today: Let us all together activate the gold standard internationally. We need to free the markets from the pressure of foreign currency. Let us seek ways to borrow in that way, let us seek ways to borrow in local currencies. Recently, all the owners of shopping malls, etc., have chosen to rent in foreign currency. We say that now, by taking some new steps here, if a temporary regulation is necessary, it should be made, and this process should be carried out in local currency so that our country can successfully navigate this process. I believe in this, I have announced it, I am announcing it, and I will continue to announce it. Because in the other case, there is almost an imperial logic; on the other hand, there are shopkeepers who are struggling and are on the verge of bankruptcy. We must navigate this process together, we must navigate it in solidarity. This homeland is ours, this land is ours. We are all brothers, and we will navigate this process together in solidarity. Remember, this nation, which has successfully overcome the most despicable coup attempt, the most insidious invasion attempt, and the bloodiest terrorist attack in recent history, will certainly defend itself against economic pressures as well.

Esteemed guests;

Turkey, by virtue of its geographical location and historical heritage, is a natural part of every formation centered on Europe, Asia, and Africa. Unfortunately, the European Union has not been able to see this obvious truth, and even if it does, it cannot accept it, which is why our full membership negotiations have been stalled.

He has insisted on continuing. I call out to all friends, there is a European Union that has kept this country waiting for 53 years. I say, you are not an irreplaceable gem; we have already endured these 53 years, whether in this way or that. You have exerted such pressures on many countries in the world, what happened, did you finish them off? God willing, you can never finish off Turkey. We believe in ourselves, we believe in our friends, we believe in our resources. Today, we can work twice as hard, three times as hard, God willing, we will travel more while circling the world and we will never bow down. Those who try to make us bow down with such ideological impositions should not take it amiss, Turkey is not one of those countries. While you cannot take care of 100, 200, or 300 refugees, this country is currently hosting and taking care of 3 million refugees from its own capital, from its own pocket, everything is clear.

The latest decision of the European Parliament is a recognition of this reality that we have been living for years by themselves. Of course, we have been saddened by Turkey being insulted in this way by the European Union. Nevertheless, at this moment, we have not yet closed the book on the European Union. However, the current picture does not allow us to have positive expectations in this regard for now. But let no one forget this: Turkey always has many alternatives ahead and we will continue on our path by evaluating any of these alternatives. And I do not find it appropriate to express this right now, but of course, we are continuing our discussions with these alternatives as well.

Just now, our President of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus expressed something here; there have been ongoing discussions there for months, years, it has always been a matter of stalling, stalling, stalling… This is the tactic. Do you know what? They say, ‘You give us Cyprus completely, do not interfere with anything’; that is the goal. Just wait, there is so much blood of martyrs there, what are you giving? And I go even further; without shame, they come to European Union meetings with a flag that includes the entire island of Cyprus. First of all, you cannot have such a flag… There is a Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus here. You are the Greek Cypriot Administration of Southern Cyprus, and there is a Turkish Republic in the north, you will see this, this is also a disrespect. One way or another, they will understand this, they will learn. Recently, the Prime Minister of Greece also called, I spoke with them, they say, ‘let’s have a bilateral meeting’, we say multilateral meeting, and so on, all these are being discussed. But this matter should not be prolonged too much, it needs to be resolved by the end of this year. But if there are such things as ‘these lands will be ours, the management will be completely ours’; if such things happen, this will not work. A hungry chicken thinks it is in a grain store, this is what they are doing.

And I hope that the Bosphorus Summit will be a series of sessions where many issues are discussed and addressed. I think we can consider establishing a new commercial platform where member states' public and private sector organizations and individuals can participate under the leadership of our country. To bring this platform, which will operate entirely in an electronic environment using the conveniences provided by technology, to life, the only thing we truly need is the common will of approximately 60 states in the Islamic and Turkish geography, which I find very, very important. I believe that countries coming together on this trade platform, where goods and services will be entered into the system through standard codes, should be able to access all kinds of goods and services from each other with the least cost and the fastest way.

It is possible to build an independent structure from the existing global trade order through standardizations such as the integration of member countries' logistics systems, a common payment system, common financial instruments to be used in this system, and a common trade language. We believe that such a large geography, on which everyone relies, can create its own economic and commercial infrastructure if it wishes. The commercial platform I have outlined can also constitute the nucleus of a larger economic union. In fact, such new initiatives should be seen not as alternatives to existing structures but as formations that will also bring dynamism to them, serving as a lifeline.

I believe that such issues will be discussed thoroughly at the Bosphorus Summit. Indeed, I am pleased to see that one of the summit's goals is to take the first step towards a global consensus document focused on peace, referred to as the ‘World Council’.

I wish the summit, where all dimensions of global and regional cooperation opportunities will be discussed, to be fruitful once again. I would also like to remind you not to forget that the import-export process with local currency can also be activated.

I once again welcome all our guests, friends, and brothers, and I extend my love and respect to you all.