Speech at the Conference on Constitutional Jurisdiction of the Islamic World

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

23 December 2022 · Conference on Constitutional Jurisdiction of the Islamic World · Istanbul, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed supreme court presidents of OIC member states at the second Conference on Constitutional Jurisdiction of the Islamic World, held in Istanbul in December 2022.
Main themes
Constitutional jurisdiction in the Islamic world, rule of law, judicial cooperation among OIC member states, democracy and human rights, separation of powers, balance of powers, justice as foundation of the state, Turkey's democratic experience, Istanbul Declaration, experience sharing among supreme courts
Duration
~19 min
63rd percentile
Words
2,253
63rd percentile
Sentences
102
64th percentile
Readability
37
29th percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
2.97
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
74th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 37%37%
  • Geopolitical 36%36%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

102 sentences in 26 paragraphs

Esteemed Presidents of the Supreme Courts of Member States of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation,

Valued Guests,

Dear Brothers,

I greet you with my heartfelt feelings, with respect and affection, esselamu aleyküm ve rahmetullah ve berekatuhu. Welcome to Turkey and to our beloved Istanbul, which has been honored with the praise of our Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him. We are pleased to host you in our beautiful Istanbul on the occasion of the Conference on Constitutional Jurisdiction of the Islamic World.

The first Constitutional and Supreme Courts Judiciary Conference, which we organized under the auspices of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, was held four years ago in our country. At that conference, the Istanbul Declaration was adopted, aiming to strengthen cooperation and experience sharing among our high judicial authorities. With the second conference held last year in Indonesia, the Conference of Constitutional Jurisdictions of the Member States of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation has now transformed into an official and independent platform. I believe that our current conference, which continues this series, will take the Istanbul and Bandung declarations much further.

I believe that the conference, which starts today and will continue for two days, will facilitate useful and productive discussions on topics such as the rule of law, democracy, and respect for human rights. Likewise, our conference will provide an opportunity for mutual experience and information sharing among our high judicial authorities regarding constitutional cases and precedents. I would like to express my heartfelt gratitude in advance to the representatives of the supreme courts and legal professionals who will contribute to the conference with their valuable ideas, suggestions, and evaluations. I thank our President of the Constitutional Court and his team for their efforts in organizing the conference, and I pray that our meeting will be a source of goodness for the Islamic world and all of humanity.

Valued Guests,

The essence of our state tradition is based on the principle of "live and let live." Accordingly, the primary reason for the existence of the state and all its institutions is to serve humanity, the noblest of creatures. The duty of the state is to provide first-class services in all areas, from security to meeting the basic needs of its citizens, who all have equal rights. The criteria that determine the quality of services provided to citizens by the state are the knowledge, skills, vision, and determination of the governing personnel. The ability of the state mechanism to fulfill its purpose of existence depends on the healthy functioning of all its organs through visionary leaders. Undoubtedly, the state also has a balance of powers within itself; the healthier this balance is established and operated, the better, more efficient, and effective the state mechanism and the institutions that constitute it will work. However, if there is competition, conflict, or destructive rivalry among the powers that form the backbone of the democratic system, society suffers the consequences.

The harmony within each of the legislative, executive, and judicial branches is as important as the balance among them. A lack of harmony in the functioning of the legislative body affects both the executive and the judiciary. A crisis in the executive can paralyze the entire system. Disruptions in the functioning of the judiciary can also lead to problems throughout the system. Turkey is a country that has personally experienced the pain of such crises in its recent history, paying the price in various areas from the economy to democracy. While overcoming difficulties that sometimes appeared as tutelage and sometimes as coups, the time and energy we lost have left us far from our democratic and economic goals. Undoubtedly, the judiciary has a separate importance in this picture. Moreover, Turkey has experienced some very bad examples in this regard that we would rather not remember. However, there should never be a place for ideological prejudice and bureaucratic oligarchy in the provision of justice services. Because justice is not only the foundation of property, but also the keystone that holds the architecture of the state together.

A state can only rise, develop, strengthen, and grow on the foundation of justice. A state that cannot dispense justice and cannot rule its citizens justly is doomed to collapse, just like a building with a rotten foundation. Any neglect or violation of the principle of the rule of law will undermine trust in the legislature and the executive, as well as the judiciary, leading to irreparable damage in the functioning of the state.

In light of the experiences we have had in the past, we have taken many steps in the last 20 years, especially to improve the quality of justice services. We have ensured and established unity in the judiciary by eliminating the distinction between civil and military jurisdiction. By implementing the National Judiciary Network Project (UYAP), we have brought technological and scientific developments to the service of the judiciary. We have implemented alternative solutions that facilitate the parties by establishing mediation and conciliation systems. We have enacted many reforms such as the individual application to the Constitutional Court, the right to be presumed innocent, the Public Ombudsman Institution, the Turkish Human Rights Institution, and the Personal Data Protection Institution. By securing the independence and impartiality of the judiciary constitutionally, we have addressed another significant deficiency in our legal system.

In addition to all this, with the approval and support of our people, we transitioned to a presidential government system, establishing the principle of separation of powers in our country for the first time in our history. In light of the first term implementation of our new governance system next year, we aim to introduce new reforms that will strengthen the legislature and judiciary, in addition to making the executive more effective. Of course, there can be discussions arising from certain events that different segments of the public closely follow during this process. However, we believe that each of these discussions will eventually settle in the pool of the rule of law and reach a conclusion.

Valued Friends,

No matter how significant the actions taken under the headings of justice services and human rights are, they are never sufficient. In a climate where life is constantly changing and change brings new problems, it is inconceivable for the legal system to remain outside of this. It is extremely important for the state to continuously renew itself in these matters, to address any deficiencies it may have, in order to fulfill its purpose of existence. As politicians who bear the responsibility of governing the country, we view the issue this way and continuously develop our legislation.

In every matter concerning rights and freedoms that relate to the balance of freedom and security, we prioritize a human-centered approach. In this process, we listen to every criticism, every idea that opens our way, gives us perspective, and raises the standard of service. We have never been complexed about any issue that we believe is for the benefit of our nation, nor will we be. The most significant hallmark of our years in power, which have now surpassed 20, is that we have never lost our will for reform focused on rights and freedoms. We are determined to keep the reformist spirit that has guided us for all these years alive and continuously strengthen it.

I know that our brothers in the member states of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation are also sincerely striving in the fields of law, justice, democracy, and freedoms. We witness the reforms implemented in many countries we visit. In fact, we see that in many areas, our friendly and brotherly countries in the Islamic world are in a much better position than Western states. However, the Orientalist approaches towards the Islamic world and Muslims often overshadow these sincere efforts and critical steps taken. The Islamic world is particularly subjected to many unjust, baseless, and excessively critical accusations regarding law and justice.

Orientalism, a disease from the colonial era, continues to exist not only in academia but also in international politics and the legal community. Those who cannot show the virtue of confronting their own colonial past speak to us about human rights and the rule of law every time they open their mouths. Those who see no problem in supporting bloodthirsty terrorist organizations in many countries of the world lecture us on the sanctity of human life. When it comes to their own security, they leave no stone unturned and spare no effort, yet they criticize our legal and justice system. However, it is both wrong and dangerous to make the issue of law and human rights a tool of inter-state competition.

Applying double standards in matters that directly affect human beings, human dignity, and the future of nations harms the struggle for human rights. The victims of the gap between the rhetoric and actions of international organizations and some Western states are the oppressed, those whose fundamental rights and freedoms have been ruthlessly seized. The Syrian crisis, which is nearing its 12th year, stands as the most painful example of this. Unfortunately, humanity has not passed this test well in the face of a crisis that has claimed the lives of more than a million Syrians. The cries of the Syrian victims have gone unheard by anyone except for a handful of countries and organizations, including Turkey. Neither the tragedy of little Aylan, whose innocent body washed ashore, nor the suffering of children who lost their lives under bombs has been enough to stir consciences. Western countries and institutions have only reacted to the humanitarian tragedy in Syria when refugees knocked on their doors. This reaction manifested itself in closing migrants behind barbed wire fences rather than finding a solution to the crisis that is the source of the problem. We are witnessing with dismay how those who ignore the oppressed beyond their borders exhibit the most primitive reflexes of fascism when it comes to their own security and welfare.

Valued Friends,

The negative impact of the waves of hatred and animosity stemming from a sporadic perspective towards Muslims continues to this day right next to us. The attitude of our western neighbor Greece towards migrants has now reached the level of barbarism. Every day, new atrocities are added, from sinking refugee boats in the middle of the sea to torturing and stripping migrants before pushing them back. Moreover, Western countries show little significant reaction to Greece's arrogance and cruelty. Aside from a few statements made as a formality, we have not seen any efforts to prevent this cruelty or to protect the rights of the oppressed, including children and women. The ongoing indifference in the face of the shameful images reflected from the border line and refugee shelters reminiscent of Nazi camps deeply saddens us all. We are witnessing a similar attitude in the fight against terrorism.

Institutions that are a wall to Syrian, Iraqi, and African migrants behave as leniently as possible when it comes to PKK and FETÖ terrorists. The coup plotters who martyred 250 of our citizens on the night of July 15 are now freely roaming in many European countries. The separatist terrorist organization finances its attacks on Syria, Iraq, and Turkey with millions of euros collected in these countries every year. We even know that there are countries that directly allocate funds to terrorist organizations in their budgets.

Terrorists are being protected and sheltered behind the vague concept of political asylum, which has no clear definition, boundaries, or framework, while those involved in coup crimes are escaping justice. Despite all our requests regarding many fugitive coup plotters whose names, criminal records, and offenses are well known, Western countries have taken no legal action. The folders we provided, filled with documents, are evident, yet no one from the security forces of the host country has knocked on the door of the mansion of the FETÖ leader. Those who criticize the legal steps taken by Turkey after the coup attempt, in which 252 of our children were martyred, are now witnessing the strict measures taken in the face of coup rumors. Just yesterday, those who accused us of pushing the limits of the law in the fight against coups have nearly reached the stage of setting the law aside when it comes to their own democracies. Of course, we are aware of the mindset behind this contradictory attitude towards the terrorist and coup crimes targeting our country. We are determined to continue our struggle within the framework of law and legitimacy, regardless of what anyone says. We will continue our efforts until Turkey rises to the top ranks in the world in terms of security, freedoms, and justice.

However, those who prioritize their own welfare and interests over human dignity have no chance of sustaining this distorted system indefinitely. Sooner or later, this unjust system will crack, and hopefully, it will give way to an inclusive order that serves the happiness of all humanity.

Our duty is to continue working shoulder to shoulder as one heart, one wrist, for our brothers, for the peace and well-being of our people. I believe that the future of the Islamic world will be much brighter than our present. I hope that our conference will become a platform where all these issues are discussed, debated, and solutions are proposed.

With these thoughts, I conclude my remarks, once again congratulating those who contributed to the organization of the conference. I welcome you, our guests from abroad, once again, and I greet all participants with my heartfelt feelings.

Stay safe.