Speech at the 'Presidential System Symposium'

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

11 February 2017 · Presidential System Symposium organized by SETA

Context
Erdoğan addressed the SETA Presidential System Symposium on February 11, 2017, advocating for Turkey's transition to a presidential governance system.
Main themes
Presidential system transition, governance system comparison, Turkish constitutional history, political stability, republican period, parliamentary vs presidential systems, monarchy and democracy, coup and tutelage regimes, multi-party politics, economic and social consequences of instability
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,678
83rd percentile
Sentences
220
91st percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
9.1
12th percentile
Syntax
2.72
15th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 74%71%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

220 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Esteemed members of the Foundation for Political, Economic and Social Research (SETA),

Valued guests,

Ladies and gentlemen;

I greet you with my warmest feelings, with affection and respect. I wish for the Presidential System Symposium organized by SETA to be successful. I would like to express my gratitude in advance to the esteemed academics and intellectuals who will contribute to the symposium with their speeches and evaluations.

I congratulate the SETA administrators for organizing this symposium at a time when Turkey is on the verge of making a historic decision to transition to a presidential system.

Dear friends;

Today, there are nearly 200 countries that are members of the United Nations. Each of these countries has a governance system that varies according to its historical, social, and cultural characteristics. Although there are various classifications regarding governance systems, these only serve to provide a general idea.

For example, when we examine the list of countries governed by a parliamentary system, we see that very different styles of administration are grouped under the same heading in practice. We encounter a similar picture in countries governed by presidential and republic systems as well. In theory, the parliamentary system is the product of the struggle against monarchy and totalitarianism. When we look at European countries, we see that many of them have kings and queens. Similar situations can also be encountered in other parts of the world, such as Japan and Thailand.

Of course, someone will immediately say, "Sir, these monarchs are symbolic; in fact, there is parliamentary democracy there." If there is an actor in the governance system, it never remains merely symbolic. If there is a king in a country, he is the king; if there is a queen, she is the queen. This throne, the crown holder, is in one way or another a rightful owner and has a say in the governance of the country. Monarchy does not only exist in countries governed by a presidential or republic system. There are also regimes that, although they express the name republic or a similar democratic concept, are actually governed by dictatorship, and even resemble monarchy in terms of the transfer of positions from father to son. In summary, each country has a governance model unique to its own conditions.

When we look at our country, we witness that we have experienced very different experiences in the last 200 years. The uninterrupted searches and upheavals throughout the 18th century brought many attempts from the Tanzimat to the Constitutional Era.

My brothers;

In this process, our country has continuously shrunk due to wars and crises, paying very heavy prices. The Victory of Çanakkale represents the point where the knife meets the bone. With the inspiration and strength we drew from Çanakkale, we fought our War of Independence. Of course, every struggle also opens the way for the preferences and orientations of the team that actually carries out that struggle. The declaration of the Republic after the success of our War of Independence is the product of such a preference. While European countries opted to coexist with monarchy and democracy, we expelled the dynasty from the country and declared the Republic. We first came to this point with a single-party system—let's pay attention to this—and then with a multi-party government system, our country has come to this day. Main opposition, I am addressing you; we first transitioned to a single-party system, and then to a multi-party period.

Dear friends;

The Republican period is not homogeneous in itself. For example, there are very serious differences between the 1921 Constitution and the 1924 Constitution. The 1961 and 1982 constitutions also contain sharp differences compared to the past. Similarly, there are significant differences in practice between the presidency of Gazi Mustafa Kemal and the İnönü period. Since we transitioned to multi-party political life in 1950, we have always tried to maintain our democracy under the shadow of coups and tutelage regimes. For the last 14 years, we have felt and experienced all these troubles to the core.

Although we have managed to overcome the problems with the strength we received from our nation, this does not eliminate the underlying structural distortions and flaws. The most important result of these distortions is that the environment of stability and security is constantly under threat. Political instability brings along economic and social problems. While the history of our Republic is 93 years, currently—pay attention here—the 65th government is in power; look at the state of affairs. In other words, the lifespan of governments in our country is not even 16 months.

While Turkey is governed by such short-lived governments, it has been surpassed one by one by all the countries it has entered into a race for development, growth, and progress under similar conditions. There have been governments in this country that lasted only 25 days. Can a state be governed like this? They tried to manage it. Now we are fundamentally correcting this. If it weren't for the leap movement in the country during this 14-year period, driven by our political movement, we would still be, excuse me, struggling to catch up.

Our searches over the last 200 years, our experiences during the Republican period, and especially what we have experienced in recent years show us a truth. If we want to achieve our goals as a country and a nation, we first need a governance system where the authority and responsibility of a strong and effective leader are clearly defined.

In fact, the topic of the presidential system we are discussing today did not emerge suddenly, in a day, or in a year; it has a deep and thought-provoking background. For example, this issue is definitely not a matter of the Republic; it is certainly not a matter of democracy or freedom. The system we are discussing is the most accurate solution to the existential problem that has persisted for centuries for Turkey and the Turkish nation; that is the issue.

Those who call the period from the declaration of the Republic to our transition to multi-party life in 1950 a democracy are either deceiving themselves or trying to deceive us. The name of this period is single-party rule. O main opposition, first take a look at yourself. It would not be wrong to express that the frequent interruptions of the multi-party life we entered in 1950 by coups and memorandums stem from a certain segment's longing for the single-party period; I am stating this here.

Turkey has suffered greatly from tutelage institutions that hold power and authority but have no responsibility to the nation. Pay attention, whenever national will-based administrations have been in power strongly in our country, there have been very significant leaps during those periods. Nevertheless, you must remember how much I complained about bureaucratic oligarchy during my tenure as Prime Minister. When we bring together all these experiences, the events we have lived through, and historical readings, the need for our country to have a new constitution and a new governance system becomes as clear as day.

My brothers;

As can be seen, the presidential system we are discussing today has nothing to do with regime, autocracy, or personalism. Therefore, I will remind you of something immediately: The provincial heads in this country were certainly not appointed by the AK Party or experienced by the AK Party. Whose are these? These belong entirely to the past of the main opposition party. The provincial heads of the Republican People's Party have also served as governors in this country, both as provincial heads and governors; can there be such a democracy, how will you explain this? But they did it. They do not want to bring this up at all now because it is a stain for them and indeed a serious stain in the history of democracy.

The issue is an effort to establish a governance system that is much more suitable for achieving our much stronger and more resilient goals as a country and a nation, in light of the experiences we have lived through in the past. The greatest assurance of the presidential system is that it is genuinely democratic. In this system, no one who cannot gain the favor of more than half of our nation has the possibility of governing the country. No administrator who is obliged to account to the nation, to the national will, can deviate from the wrongs put forward by those opposing the presidential system. If you abandon the path shown to you by the nation, you will be immediately overthrown by the nation.

For this reason, I say; the insecurity of those opposing the system is particularly against the person who will be elected president, not against the nation; that is the issue. Perhaps because they cannot express this truth, they are trying to confuse people with the lies they produce through individuals. They say, "Your only concern is Tayyip Erdoğan." But Tayyip Erdoğan is not eternal; Tayyip Erdoğan is mortal... Is there a guarantee that I will even be on the ballot on April 16? Therefore, we are fighting a struggle for a system here; the issue is a struggle for a system.

What will happen after Erdoğan? Whatever the nation says will happen, whatever Allah says will happen; we will look at the event this way.

More importantly, Turkey has already taken its first steps towards this system and has successfully concluded them. Yes, I am talking about the constitutional amendment in 2007. Everyone who knows a little about these matters will acknowledge that the system brought by the constitutional amendment, which we will vote on in mid-April, has already started to operate with the direct election of the president by the people. In fact, going even further, it must be seen that Turkey has been governed by a dual system, both of which derive their legitimacy directly from the nation, since August 2014.

If there have been no problems during this process, it is not because the system is functioning correctly, but because we have been in harmony with myself or our presidents, not because of the system. Therefore, we are not personalizing the issue with the constitutional amendment; on the contrary, we are tying the administration that has been running on personal initiatives for more than two years to a system. Unfortunately, due to an understanding that sees opposing everything as doing opposition, we cannot discuss these issues in their actual context.

The details of the constitutional amendment will undoubtedly be discussed thoroughly throughout this symposium. Our professors and intellectuals, each of whom has expertise in their fields, will address the issue from all angles. For this reason, I am not going into the individual articles of the constitutional amendment; I am only focusing on the spirit of the system.

My brothers;

Of course, without a spirit, a body is a corpse. If we do not explain the spirit, essence, and fundamentals of the work to our nation, the provisions of the constitutional amendment alone will remain mere legal expressions. With this understanding, we must travel our country from corner to corner, using all communication means, as those who say yes to the presidential government system until the date of the referendum, April 16.

Yesterday in Aksaray, we said, "Of course, yes." Why? Yes for a single nation, yes for a single flag, yes for a single homeland, yes for a single state... Can there be anything more than this? 80 million as a single nation, yes for this. And our flag, which has taken its color from the blood of our martyrs, crowned its independence with the crescent, and each star represents a martyr, yes for it. And "The blood that makes the flag is the blood of those who died for the land." 780 thousand square kilometers as a single homeland, yes for that. And a single state, the Republic of Turkey, yes for that.

My brothers;

A person is an enemy of what they do not know. I believe that those who currently express their opposition to the presidential system will change their opinions when they learn the spirit of the matter. But we also know one thing; today, do those who say "no" know what they are saying "no" to? Look, who is saying "no"? The PKK says "no." Who is saying "no"? Qandil says "no." Who is saying "no"? Those who want to divide and fragment this country say "no." Who is saying "no"? Those who oppose our flag say "no." Who is saying "no"? Unfortunately, those who oppose what is national and local in this country say "no." Well, my brothers, is the main opposition moving along with these? It is. I hope that by April 16, they will also pull themselves together.

Valued friends;

This change, this transformation will not be an ordinary event. The essence of the presidential system is that governance is directly given to the nation; that is the essence of the matter. The president, who will perform the executive function, must have the public's eyes on him with every step he takes because he will be responsible to the nation from whom he derives his power. Do you know what they say without shame? "The parliament will be abolished, there will be no parliament, there will be no legislative body"; can there be such nonsense? Who, where, and in what record has such a thing been stated, is there such a thing? No. But of course, lying and walking with lies; that is the understanding. Everything is clear and evident. Today, in countries where presidential systems are applied, for example, in America, is there no legislative body? There is. They have a bicameral system; ours will not be bicameral, it will be unicameral; that is the issue. What did we say? Ours will be a Turkish-style presidential system; we do not have to be the same.

Secondly, the executive; it exists. The president, that is, the head, will represent the executive. He will form his cabinet, will dismiss when necessary, and will make appointments. But to whom will he be accountable? To the nation. Some say they are disturbed by this, "the motion of censure is being removed." Good luck, because this motion of censure has caused governments in this country a lot of trouble, and we have suffered a lot too. The motion of censure mechanism is a mechanism that prevents the Parliament from functioning, a mechanism that prevents governments from functioning. By eliminating this obstacle, you will see a rapidly functioning executive. God willing, we will succeed; this is very important. Where will the real motion of censure work? It will work in front of the nation every five years; can there be a more beautiful motion of censure than this? Did you do wrong, did you not work well? What will the nation do? It will hold you accountable, "Come on, friend, you could not manage this, we are putting you aside, and we are bringing a new team, a new person to lead the executive."

Now, unfortunately, there are those who say "those with a guilty conscience." The members inside the Parliament must have given 339 votes by hearing the voice of their conscience. Do they have no conscience, but you do? Excuse me. Are they not fair, but are you fair? Excuse me.

All parliamentarians are representatives of the nation and they have made their decisions, and they have not been satisfied with this decision, stating that on April 16, sovereignty belongs unconditionally to the nation and the nation will make its decision in the human plan. In this system, it is not possible for anyone to act with self-proclaimed authority, to make decisions, or to carry out implementations. The two heads of the executive, namely the president and the prime minister, are now united under a single name. Thus, our nation knows from the very beginning to whom it has given authority, who has taken on responsibility, and therefore from whom it will demand accountability when necessary.

In the new system, the legislative body and the members of parliament serving there will focus solely on their primary duties. We all know that in our country, members of parliament do not have time to carry out their legislative duties due to following up on work. There are members of parliament who have served one term, two terms, or three terms without making a single legislative proposal or a single legislative effort. With the new system that clearly separates the executive from the legislative, all members of parliament will concentrate on the work of the Assembly. In the new system, the president, who is the head of the executive, has no authority to propose laws outside of the budget. Legislative activities, which have largely been conducted with draft laws prepared by the government until today, will now completely fall under the responsibility of the members of parliament. Is there legislation? Here it is. The excessive intertwining with the executive was tarnishing the prestige of the Assembly and the members of parliament; now the lines are becoming clear. It is also elevating the reputation of the parliament to the level it deserves.

The judiciary, which is the most critical institution in the life of the state and the nation, has been the most worn-out power in our country in recent years. There are unpleasant images in our memories regarding the judiciary, which could not display a strong stance alongside democracy during the coup and tutelage periods. We have seen judges and prosecutors in this country who went to briefings in their robes during the February 28 period, handing over the authority they were supposed to use on behalf of the nation to a terrorist organization and its charlatan leader. We will have the opportunity to implement the efforts we are carrying out to solve these problems more strongly in the new system. What have we added to its independence? We have added neutrality. I believe that the judiciary, under constitutional guarantee, along with the new structure of the High Council of Judges and Prosecutors, will quickly reach the position it deserves in the hearts of our nation.

Thus, the powers of the executive, legislative, and judiciary will focus entirely on their own areas and contribute to the construction of a strong and great Turkey by doing their own work. Whoever convinces our nation that they can provide the best service in this construction process will be the president. The era of those who claim to be populists by insulting the people is now completely closing. The oppressive mentality of those who do not see the nation as a discerning entity is now becoming history. Young people, you may not know, but let me tell you; there have been politicians in this country who have claimed that if I put a four-legged - excuse me - donkey in Taksim Square, I could get it elected as a member of parliament. Now these are history.

Now, where did we lower the age of candidacy? To 25. I am talking about the age of candidacy. Now, where are we lowering 25 to? To 18. The difficult part is not being elected; the difficult part is voting. Now, by lowering the voting and candidacy age to 18, we are rephrasing history; what does this mean? This nation is the descendant of conquerors who closed one era and opened another at the age of 21. We will open the way for youth, we will give youth a horizon, and what will the youth do in this race? They will participate. They ask, "Well, what will happen to military service?" Look at where they are stuck. If they can enter Parliament, they will be exempt from military service; it is that simple. Look, for example, our police have always served in the military, as you know. During my premiership, we abolished this, saying they are already serving in the military. If a young person is serving in such an important place as Parliament, you can exempt them from military service, and that’s it; we will bring this.

What are all these? These are steps that express the importance of these duties; these are important steps. And there is no point in blocking things with something. If we really want to overcome obstacles, these can be easily overcome. If you remember, I have a saying; I used to say, "I am managing the country like a joint-stock company." There would be those who got stuck, yes, that was my logic in management. Look at companies; they appoint a CEO to a huge corporation at the age of 30. If you were to ask someone now, "Can a 30-year-old be entrusted with such a huge corporation?" they would say no. Once you are aware of the job, once you understand it, it can definitely be entrusted. The issue is one of accumulation, the issue is one of trust, and with that, you can make progress.

Now, of course, they have wanted to continue on this path for a long time by saying "let it be small, as long as it is ours," shackling this country. But this era is now coming to an end. It is time to elevate the understanding of "let it be big, let it be ours." The constitutional amendment opens the way for a strong Turkey, a great Turkey, a prosperous Turkey with this approach.

This system is needed not for my person but for our country, for our nation. In other words; we are transitioning to the presidential system for our country, for the future of this brave nation, with the support and contribution of my person. What else can be said to such a system? We say, "Of course, yes."

With these feelings, I wish once again that the Presidential System Symposium will be beneficial and successful. I thank everyone who will contribute. I congratulate the SETA Management for organizing this important and meaningful meeting once again. I extend my love and respect to you all, stay healthy.