Speech Made at the Dinner Held on the Occasion of the Governors' Meeting

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

27 February 2015 · Dinner held on the occasion of the Governors' Meeting · Presidential Palace, Ankara, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed Turkish provincial governors at a dinner in the Presidential Palace in Ankara during the annual Governors' Meeting on February 27, 2015.
Main themes
Governors' civic engagement, public service and people-centered governance, state-citizen relationship, connecting with ordinary citizens, administrative coordination and harmony, serving the nation with compassion, field presence over bureaucratic reports, family and social integration of governors, state legitimacy and citizen loyalty, local governance philosophy
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,677
90th percentile
Sentences
255
93rd percentile
Readability
57
80th percentile
Grade
9.9
19th percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 43%40%
  • Geopolitical 23%21%
  • Social 21%20%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Economic 3%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

255 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Dear Governors,

My Esteemed Friends,

Distinguished Ladies and Gentlemen,

I greet you with love and respect. Welcome to the Presidential Palace, the home of the nation.

I hope that the Governors' Meeting will lead to beneficial outcomes for our country, our nation, and our cities. I pray that the consultations you hold in Ankara will be fruitful for both you and our citizens, as well as for our cities.

Dear Friends,

The coordination that our governors will establish among all official and civil organizations in their cities, and the harmony they will ensure, is extremely important. Likewise, I find it essential for our governors serving in all 81 provinces to act in coordination and harmony in terms of both state policies and service standards.

The state apparatus is, of course, a mechanism where each element works independently within its own area of responsibility, but must also act in harmony with other elements. This system also has a spirit. What is that spirit? That spirit is the love for serving the nation. If you distance yourself from the people, if you look down on the nation, if you close your ears to the people's troubles, difficulties, and demands, you can never be a successful public servant. This is equally valid for us politicians, even though we may seem somewhat detached from politics now. You cannot win the hearts of the people by merely carrying out routine tasks or fulfilling orders from the center.

Dear Governor Friends,

Serving is necessary for you, but it is not sufficient. So, what is sufficient? What is sufficient is to win the hearts of the people. If you can win the hearts of the people, then you have fulfilled both the necessity and the sufficiency. For this, you must be among the people at every opportunity, day and night, regardless of the weather, with your spouses. Because I see that some of our governors leave their spouses in Ankara or Istanbul, and if they are in the East or Southeast, they govern without their wives. I must say this again: there cannot be such governance; I must repeat this here. Because the people want to see their governor with his wife, and I want to emphasize this.

If you have not sat in the neighborhood café in your city, drinking tea and chatting with the people there, especially if our lady governors have not done this at home, then there is a problem. If you have not gone to sit next to the elderly uncle squatting by the electric pole in the village square and exchanged a few words with him, if you have not gotten dust and mud on your pants while talking to the farmer working in the field, if you have not had oil splattered on your shoes while chatting with the worker in the factory, if you have not kicked a ball with the children playing in the back streets of the city, if you have not sat on the chair next to the patient suffering in four walls and asked about their well-being, if you have not eaten from the offerings prepared with the supplies you brought to the poor household, if you have not befriended the tradesmen, if you have not established a friendship with the village headman, if you have not joked with the students, if you have not sat cross-legged on the floor and sipped tea from the boiling kettle, if you have not sat down at the low table, then there is a mistake here. Those who are not among the people do not know the troubles of the people; we will be among the people. This nation is our family, and we will be part of it. Reports, numbers, statistics, briefings, of course, these are important within ourselves. But none of these can provide you with the authenticity and depth of the conversations, observations, and findings you have with people in the streets and workplaces.

Every governor should be the Omar of their city. You must represent the warm hand, the smiling face, and the compassionate arms of the state, not its cold face or iron fist. There is a saying that "out of sight, out of mind." No matter how much you know about issues on paper, if you do not see them in person, especially on the ground, you cannot fully grasp them. For this reason, you must never sever your connection with the people.

In my political life spanning nearly 40 years, and in my public administration career of nearly 20 years, even with some interruptions, I have learned everything from my people. The nation is a good teacher, a good educator. I owe all my success in this process to maintaining a close connection with my people. What do we always say? "Let the person live so that the state can live." Yes, when you neglect the person, you cannot keep the state standing. Can there be a state where there are no people? The respect, loyalty, and attachment of our nation to its state stem from knowing that the state will be by their side when they need it. Do you know why discord enters a nation? It enters because the state neglects its citizens. The void you leave in the lives, hearts, and hopes of your citizens will be filled by someone else. At that time, unfortunately, the state apparatus begins to falter.

The great leaders in history have been those who succeeded in closing the gap between the people and the state. Every governor, as my esteemed Minister just said, is my representative in that province and the leader of that province. Representing the state is not just about using its powers. Representing the state is primarily about winning the hearts of the people. Your success is measured by the good reputation you leave in that city. Ah, once we had a governor who did wonderful things, who came to my house, drank tea with me, and shared a meal with us at our low table; that is what the citizen should say. If the citizen says this, then that is a 10 out of 10, and that score is very important. Governorship is not a task that can be carried out with a standard bureaucratic understanding. The services you provide and the hearts you win should follow you throughout your life. The positions we hold are not for excuses but for actions. Legislation does not hinder skill. Talent surpasses opportunity. I congratulate and commend all the governors who can achieve this, and those who have not should reflect on where they fell short, where they made mistakes, and quickly take steps to rectify this. I believe that every friend here serves with this understanding, and I honestly expect this from them.

Dear Friends,

Our country is going through very vital trials both domestically and internationally; we are experiencing very critical times. There are significant conflicts and crises arising from the regional and global conjuncture in our immediate vicinity. Start from Ukraine above, continue eastward to Georgia and Armenia, then go down to Iran, continue to Iraq and Syria, and extend this circle to Cyprus in the south and Greece in the west. As you can see, our entire surroundings are in instability. Especially what is happening in Syria is a complete humanitarian tragedy. In a place where 350,000 people have lost their lives and 5 million people have sought refuge in other countries, the international community continues to remain a spectator to the events without taking serious action, only with words. And can you imagine that someone who claims to be a politician from these lands can visit a murderer, a tyrant who has killed 350,000 people? This is truly a matter that should lead us to serious introspection. Thank God, yesterday, the statement made by French President Hollande regarding some members of parliament from his country going to Syria or planning to go was a statement that soothed hearts. I mean, how can members of parliament from a country like France visit such a murderer? We are trying to host our Syrian brothers who have sought refuge in our country in the best way possible. A lady from the United Nations spoke, and currently, Turkey is the country with the most refugees in the world. The world, especially developed countries, does not say, "What can we do for Turkey? Let's provide this much support," that is a separate issue. But whether they do it or not, thank God, this treasure is growing, and we continue to provide our support. We will continue to embrace these guests, who have spread to many of our provinces, districts, and even villages, with the understanding of being their supporters. I expect each of you to pay special attention and sensitivity to ensure that no disruptions or unpleasant situations occur in this regard. There may be difficulties, that is true; weren't there difficulties before they came? Similar difficulties were occurring again. But let us not forget that this nation has opened its arms to these people, who are beyond despair and suffering, under the bombs, fulfilling a humanitarian, moral, and Islamic duty.

While the opposition organized within Syria, supported by 120 countries, was approaching a clear result, suddenly an organization called ISIS was invented, and everything turned upside down. The organization, which took advantage of the deep fractures caused by the previous government's mistakes in Iraq, quickly became effective here as well. In fact, there is a structure that does not have a definable base, a definable hierarchy, or a definable goal. Many calculations, both within the region and at the global level, are attempted to be seen under this roof, under this name. You do not need a deep political analysis to understand that this organization is a product of a project; everything is evident. The organization that burns libraries in Mosul, destroys mosques, and similarly burns and destroys tombs is actually no different from the organization that burns schools in our country. They also burn and destroy mosques when the time comes; there is no difference. They burn and destroy schools in the same way.

I believe that just this example is sufficient to illustrate the gravity of the situation. Look, 510 kilometers of our 911-kilometer-long border with Syria is under the control of one organization, and 210 kilometers is under the control of another organization. In Iraq, there are serious problems between the Northern Iraq Administration and the Central Government where our borders are located. In such an environment, Turkey is trying to ensure the safety of its citizens on one hand and to find solutions to the troubles of its brothers in these countries on the other. What is even more distressing is that even in such an environment, the political parties within the country cannot act in unity and solidarity. We have all seen and experienced the recent discussions regarding the relocation of the Süleyman Shah Tomb. Yesterday, those who shouted that Turkey should not be dragged into an adventure in Syria are today talking about retreating and losing territory, knowing full well that this is contrary to the truth. Moreover, they do not only criticize the Government and the ruling party. They target me, our Chief of General Staff, our commanders, and all our armed forces. However, a very successful operation has been carried out. Not a single square meter of our land has been lost there; on the contrary, it has been the opposite. Right now, we have entered perhaps the most troubled and problematic region in the world, our soldiers and our spiritual relics have been taken and relocated to a place close to our borders. I once again congratulate our Government and our heroic Armed Forces.

Those who describe moving a tomb that has been relocated twice for various reasons as selling the homeland are, I say openly, those who do not know what the concept of homeland is. Do you know what it means to sell the homeland? Selling the homeland means putting our heroic soldiers in danger despite the obvious truth and concrete information. Selling the homeland means plunging the country into crisis after crisis due to your own incompetence and lack of knowledge. Selling the homeland means turning a blind eye to the material and spiritual losses of the country by failing to ensure the unity, togetherness, and brotherhood of people who have a thousand-year-old common history in these lands. Selling the homeland means squandering the resources of the country and the nation through high interest rates, high inflation, and poor management.

Making a strategic move to prevent those who want to plunge Turkey into the chaos environment right next to us is serving the homeland. Trying to be a balm to the country's bleeding wound and the nation's broken heart with the peace process is serving the homeland. Growing the economy and prosperity threefold in 12 years, bringing the country together with unprecedented investments is serving the homeland. Look, in 1980-1982, the per capita national income was 1,567 dollars; now, thank God, it is 11,000 dollars. Look at how far we have come. Is it enough? No, it needs to be more. Reducing inflation and interest rates and turning the resources that are directed to lobbies into investments for the country and the nation is serving the homeland. We, and our Government, have been striving to serve the homeland until today. You must constantly compare the situation of the cities you govern with their situation 12 years ago and know this well. The achievements are evident. If I were to explain the damage done to this country and this nation by those who accuse us of selling the homeland, they would have no face to show on the street. I know them well. Although this is a familiar situation for them, they have contributed nothing to Turkey and our nation, nor have they benefited the parties they lead. They have lost every election. But they continued on their way, thanking God as if it were raining from the sky. We have proven our love for the homeland and the nation countless times with the services we have provided. Everyone knows what the Süleyman Shah issue is. Turkey has neither given up any of its rights nor abandoned an inch of its land. We changed the location of the tomb with an operation that is entirely our own strategy, our own planning, and our own execution. And this is not the result of a one-day, two-day, one-week, or one-month effort; it is a process we have been working on for months, starting from my time as Prime Minister, and since I became President, we have continuously discussed this in the narrow scope of our work and meetings, and finally made the final decision and took this step. I once again express here, in your presence, that this is what the incident is about.

Dear Brothers and Sisters;

The June 7 elections are important for Turkey in many respects. It is your valuable governors who have important responsibilities to ensure that these elections take place in a peaceful and secure environment worthy of democracy. Some efforts to poison the election environment have already begun. You must be particularly vigilant against the attempts of those who have lost hope in the ballot box to provoke it and create a space for their own initiative.

Dear Brothers,

The ballot box is a matter of honor, the vote is a matter of honor. It is essential for democracy that every citizen casting their vote does so with their own will, and that will is reflected in the ballot box. This honor is primarily entrusted to you. A leader who cannot protect the ballot box, which is considered the honor of the nation, cannot protect their city, nor can they protect their country. There must be no allowance for even the slightest weakness in election and ballot security. I believe that each of you will show the utmost attention, effort, and diligence in this regard.

Of course, the results of the June 7 elections are also critically important for the future of the governance system in our country. Depending on the election results, the new constitution and presidential system will come to our agenda. The presidential system is, in one aspect, a system in which local governments are further strengthened and made more effective. In this system, the power of the presidency at the center is balanced by the Parliament on one hand and the power of local governments in the field on the other. Therefore, when this system is transitioned to, our governors will find themselves in a different position, with broader authorities, which will also be possible. In fact, the direct election of the President by the people is the first step taken in this regard. Now it is time to take this step further and transition to a system that is suitable for the state tradition of our country and the needs of our nation, consisting of a strong president, a strong Parliament, and strong local governments.

The outcries of those who owe their legitimacy, especially not to the people but to mechanisms hidden within the existing system, are in vain. The tutelage regime established by the coups of 1960 and 1980 cannot bring Turkey to its 2023 goals. We have fought against this oligarchic structure for 12 years. At this point, we see that it is impossible to reform this structure without fundamentally changing the system. Turkey's democratic maturity has reached a level that will enable the transition to a presidential system. The new Turkey will rise on the strong ground provided by the new constitution and presidential system. This is not just a change of system; it is also a matter of the survival of the Republic of Turkey.

Now, it is sometimes said: there cannot be a Turkish-style presidential system, etc. Dear friends, I say very clearly and unequivocally; it absolutely can, why not? Are all the presidential systems in the world the same? In America, there is a different presidential system, just south of it in Mexico there is a different presidential system, you come to Cuba, it’s different, Argentina is different, Brazil is different, they are all different, you go to Russia, it’s different, you come to France, it’s a semi-presidential system, there are different systems. What do we say? Let’s take our share from the flowers with the skill of a bee, and then let’s make our honey, let’s say that this is our presidential system framed within our own traditions and customs, and with this, we will walk into the future. Right now, the systems in America, Latin America, Russia, Europe, etc., are not indispensable. They have all gone through many tests. We must negotiate this by discussing it in the public sphere, in our civil society organizations, with our academics, and with everyone. Because we are now just spinning our wheels. We need to break free from this stagnation and leap forward. We need to reach much further, much faster. You can already see this in the work you are doing in your provinces; there is a blockage stemming from this.

In the face of the changes happening in the world and our region, we cannot protect our power, our claims, and our goals with a status quo understanding. A change that is suitable for our history, culture, needs, and the developments in today’s world is for the benefit of Turkey, for its good. Let there be no doubt about this. Those who want to impose the sick structure of the single-party era on 2015 Turkey will once again be disappointed. Together with our governors, district governors, mayors, village heads, tradespeople, artists, workers, youth, women, in short, with our nation, we will hopefully build and revive the new Turkey together.

Dear Brothers,

As I mentioned earlier, the resolution process is very important for the future of our country. Thanks to the support of our nation and the people of the region, we have brought the process to an important point. To speak frankly, the chaotic environment in our region and the inadequacies of our interlocutors in demonstrating strong political will are causing the process to be more painful. Nevertheless, we desire the resolution process to succeed for the bright future of our country and nation. For this, we have shown every effort and made every sacrifice so far. However, we cannot tolerate the exploitation of our sensitivity and meticulousness in this matter. While we carry out the resolution process to ensure that weapons are silenced forever and mothers’ tears are dried, we cannot allow the weapons to be brought into the cities and the hearts of our people to bleed every day. No matter how much some desire this, we cannot say yes to it. There is no solution by terrorizing the streets. There is no solution by terrorizing the Parliament; the Parliament is not a place to be terrorized. The Parliament is not a demonstration area for terrorists; we must be sensitive about this. I believe that even doing this in any form is disrespectful to this nation and disrespectful to that Parliament. There is no solution through threats, terror, pressure, or intimidation. Where there is violence, fire, destruction, and attack, there is no solution. We say the resolution process is to prevent all of this. Can there be a solution where democracy, law, and security do not operate? The political will, together with the relevant state institutions, continues and will continue the resolution process. At the same time, we cannot allow any action or attempt that would disrupt public order. The internal security package currently being discussed in the Parliament brings important opportunities in this regard. Of course, we are facing a striking situation in this matter. The 2+1 coalition established during the presidential election is now, with the participation of another political party, practically waging a battle to prevent the security package from being enacted. Just look at the masked faces, the bombs brought to the podium, the broken microphones, the attacks and insults directed at speakers and the Chairperson, and so much more. I would hesitate to express the words used against a female Deputy Speaker of the Parliament here. How can these be called female deputies, how can they be called male deputies? How can such expressions be displayed against a female Deputy Speaker of the Parliament? Those who see it would think that the enemy is at the door of the Parliament, and they are fighting against it. Just yesterday, those you thought could never come together are now like bosom buddies. A member of the main opposition party is doing these things in the General Assembly, and in the meantime, they are tweeting, excuse me, likening the Parliament to a barn, I apologize for that. Another opposition party member is supposedly criticizing the regulation on television, but the things they say are not in the text being discussed. They have no respect for the nation, nor do they have respect for the Parliament they are part of. We already knew that their democracy and nationalism are fake, an illusion. On this occasion, our nation has once again seen this. Meanwhile, there is a package aimed at strengthening public order. I believe that with the determination of the Government and our deputies, this package will be enacted as soon as possible. Even if they try to obstruct it, it will come out sooner or later. I speak openly; we no longer want to see masked faces and groups with sticks in the streets, we do not want to see masked individuals. If you are a man, walk like a man, why are you walking in a woman’s skirt? On the other hand, if you are not a terrorist, why are you covering your face with a mask, walk openly. Those Molotov cocktails, those fireworks, those shops of our tradespeople that are burning and being destroyed, public vehicles, citizens’ vehicles, are these acts of patriotism, are these acts of nationalism? We do not want to see burning vehicles on screens, streets blocked with barricades, children fleeing in terror with school bags in their hands, forcibly closed shutters. Using the right to protest, which is a democratic opportunity, is one thing; turning a city, a street into a battlefield under the pretext of it is another. Therefore, I especially ask our governor brothers; concessions lead to more concessions, know this. If there are such initiatives, it is imperative to stand against them with all your strength, with the security forces, with the gendarmerie, with everything. There will be tension; it is not about tension; what is our duty? It is to intervene immediately in such actions and demonstrations and to narrow and eliminate their area of intervention. As long as they find this intervention, what will they do? They will continue to burn and destroy. They will say that we are stronger than the state. What they have done so far is already this. Therefore, we need to demonstrate the power of the state. Then the citizen will say; ah, I have a state, I believe in my state, my state will protect me. But the moment they cannot trust their state, the moment they fall into weakness, know that June 7 will develop differently. We have full respect for the use of democratic rights. If they want to hold a rally, let them come and do it. Is it possible to hold a press release with a thousand people, with 1500 people? If you are going to read a press release, read it in your association or rent a hall and read it there. All of these are about how we can do this differently, how we can turn it around.

For 40 years, throughout my life in associations and politics, thank God, we have not participated in any such actions. We have done everything within the law, we have come this far within the law. There should be no tolerance for the terrorization of the streets or the disturbance of our citizens’ peace; I especially want this to be known. We must prevent the scenes that break the hearts of our nation. Because we initiated the resolution process with the approval and support of our nation, and we have brought it to this day in the same way. A fracture here would jeopardize the future of the process. The other side aims exactly this, they want this. With their verbal and physical provocations, their incitements, they want to make both the Government and the nation give up on this process, to tire them out. Our duty is to both disrupt this game and to prevent the emergence of scenes that will darken the hearts of our nation. I believe we can do both of these together.

You valuable governors have very important responsibilities in this regard. Our governors serving in the region must primarily keep the hopes, expectations, and excitement of our people regarding the resolution process alive. They must have very close relationships with all of them, especially with NGOs. By bringing opinion leaders to their side, they must hopefully mature this entire process in the direction we expect. This is the greatest antidote to the threats against the process. Our governors serving in other regions must also explain to citizens the importance of this issue and convince them with patience, determination, and decisiveness that results can be achieved. I trust you. Hopefully, together we will resolve this important issue of our country and ensure that our nation looks to the future with confidence.

Here, I thank each of you for being with us in the house of the nation, the Presidential Palace, for sharing our table, and I wish you success in your work. When you return to your duty stations, I ask you to convey my greetings and affection to all citizens there.

Thank you, be well, and may God protect you.