Conduct Of The War.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · First Lord of the Admiralty

8 May 1940 · House of Commons debate on the Conduct of the War · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on May 8, 1940, in the debate on the conduct of the war, defending the Norway campaign and arguing that Hitler's invasion of Norway favoured the Allies.
Main themes
Trondheim operation and the Norway campaign, Hitler's invasion of Norway as a strategic error, German wireless claims of British ships sunk, naval losses and damage actually sustained, calculations of profit and loss in the war at sea, blockade and control of sea commerce, Danish and Norwegian shipping brought into Allied service, Denmark's role as supplier of bacon and butter, British and French merchant shipping losses and replacement, exchanges with Lloyd George and other members
Duration
~5 min
17th percentile
Words
639
17th percentile
Sentences
32
19th percentile
Readability
65
95th percentile
Grade
8.9
10th percentile
Syntax
3.03
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.41
91st percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 42%34%
  • Economic 27%22%
  • Ceremonial 23%19%
  • Social 4%3%
  • Institutional 4%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 19%

32 sentences in 6 paragraphs

Not for a moment. Do dismiss these delusions. When my hon. and gallant Friend tells us, as he did, that he himself volunteered to lead this attack, I can only say that, had the attack been delivered, that privilege had been reserved to himself by the Commander-in-Chief, Sir Charles Forbes.

I have dealt, as far as I can in the time open to me, with the details of this Trondheim story, but I must say that I cannot recede at all from the statement I made, which has been much criticised, that this invasion of Norway by Hitler has been a cardinal political and strategic error. In the brown hours, when baffling news comes, and disappointing news, I always turn for refreshment to the reports of the German wireless. I love to read the lies they tell of all the British ships they have sunk so many times over, and to survey the fools' paradise in which they find it necessary to keep their deluded serfs and robots. The Germans have claimed to have sunk or damaged 11 battleships; actually, two have been slightly damaged—neither of them withdrawn for a day from the service. They have claimed three aircraft carriers heavily damaged; the facts are that one was slightly injured by a near miss, and that it is still going on in the service. They have declared that they have sunk or damaged 28 cruisers; actually, one anti-aircraft cruiser has sustained damage. As to destroyers, and so forth—I could go on, but I will not. The only point on

1360

which they have not exaggerated is the sinking of trawlers. We have, unhappily, lost 11 trawlers in the Government service at one time or another; and that explains all these "battleships" in the German accounts.

My right hon. Friend—I always call him that—the Member for Carnarvon (Mr. Lloyd George) said we must not mention calculations of profit and loss, but I do not agree. Calculations of profit and loss are our life. We win by these calculations of the ships we sink. It seems to me that, although Hitler's sudden overrunning of the vast regions of Norway has had astonishing and unwelcome effects, nevertheless, the advantages rest substantially with us. I will give some of the facts which are worth mentioning. Hitler has certainly lost ten lives for every one—not that he cares for that, I agree. He has condemned a large part of the Scandinavian peninsula and Denmark to enter the Nazi empire of Hungryland. He has committed an act of self-blockade. We see no reason why our control over commerce of the seas should not become even more effective now that the Norwegian corridor exists no longer, and now that unhappy Denmark, when her reserves have been devoured, will no longer be the purveyor of bacon and butter and the channel of trade and communications with the outer world.

Although Hitler has treacherously received a large part of Norway it is perhaps forgotten that, like our own people, the Norwegians live largely by the sea. The French and the British mercantile marine can now rely upon the invaluable support and co-operation of the Norwegian merchant fleet, the fourth largest in the world, and on the services of seamen whose skill and daring are well known. Also we have taken into our service a very large amount of Danish shipping which will be of the greatest assistance. These are notable facts when we remember that the British and French losses through enemy action since the war are barely 800,000 tons, and the captures and the building have already made good three-quarters of that loss. [An Hon. Member: "Oh."] I dare say the hon. Member does not like that. He skulks in the corner——What are we quarrelling about? [Hon. Members: "You should withdraw that."] I will not withdraw it.