Debate On The Address.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

21 November 1933 · House of Commons debate on the Address in reply to the Gracious Speech · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on November 21, 1933, in the debate on the Address, criticising the Prime Minister's foreign policy and the failure of the Disarmament Conference.
Main themes
Criticism of Prime Minister MacDonald's conduct of foreign affairs, collapse of the Disarmament Conference, the MacDonald Plan of Disarmament, Britain's lost capacity to manufacture weapons of defence, private armament firms, use of trained diplomats over summit meetings, London Naval Conference, Lausanne settlement and German debts, World Economic Conference failure, Foreign Secretary's equality formula, France and Germany
Duration
~17 min
59th percentile
Words
2,084
59th percentile
Sentences
83
54th percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
3.20
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 73%61%
  • Institutional 13%11%
  • Economic 9%7%
  • Ceremonial 6%5%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 16%

83 sentences in 22 paragraphs

Allow me to point out to the hon. Member that there will be many hours to-night—the House has no need to adjourn—when a very active discussion could be maintained. With a desire to set an example in that respect, I shall offer a very few observations to the House. It is usual on these occasions for the Prime Minister to give to Parliament and the country a broad survey of public affairs bath at home and abroad and to focus the main issues upon which political controversy is likely to develop in the coming Session between the different parties, but on this occa-

40

sion the Prime Minister, the Leader of the House, has confined himself, except for casual mention of others, to two main topics. He dealt with Foreign Affairs and he dealt with the question of armaments manufactured by private firms. I am bound to say that I thought his argument on the latter subject was very effective and one which might have been reinforced, because I believe it is no exaggeration to say that this country, where we are so busy pillorying the armament firms is, inure than any great country, devoid of the means of making weapons of defence should emergency arise. More than the industry of any country either in Europe or on the northern Continent of America this island has almost lost the capacity to make weapons of defence, if it were required to do so. It is a very odd thing that when the principle, of disarmament has been carried in this island so far as that, even menacing the entire safety of the country, it should receive no recognition from the party opposite, and that those who have disarmed most in the world should still be accused of being jingoes, war-mongers, and protectors of armament firms.

But it is not with that part of the Prime Minister's speech that I wish to deal to-night. I am anxious to follow up for a very short time the discussion which has taken place upon the foreign situation. Europe to-day presents a lamentable scene. There was one phrase in the right hon. Gentleman's speech relating to Foreign Affairs—almost the only phrase in which, I am bound to say, there was any information—in which he dealt with the importance of using diplomatic machinery. He said, and I was very glad to hear him say it, that parallel and supplementary efforts would be made as a result of diplomatic machinery. That is a very desirable thing. There was a time when statesmen never left their own country and there ensued a time when they hardly ever returned. There was a time when the statesmen of different countries hardly ever met each other, but there has come a time when they must be getting frightfully bored with continual propinquity.

I was reading a book the other day by an able young writer, long versed in the affairs of the Foreign Office, Mr. Harold Nicholson, in which he referred to the

41

evils of imprecision in Foreign Affairs. When you get two very distinguished statesmen, representing two different countries, and they meet together, naturally they wish to be extremely polite with one another and naturally they want to make the very best impression. Both desire to have something to take home to their people—this one to show what he has done for his country and what sacrifices he has made of his country's interests for the sake of peace. Each seeks to make an effect with their awn particular public. It is not really a good method of conducting diplomacy. I should have thought that it was much better to use the trained diplomatists more, to use the Ambassadors more, to use the vehicle of carefully considered dispatch, in which the nice terms of meaning and the realities can be stated deftly and clearly, where the situation can be put calmly and patiently in the right way by those men who have made it their life's business to study foreign affairs, and can convey exactly the shadow of meaning which is required. Therefore, I am glad to know, because I made a suggestion on the subject to my right hon. Friend earlier in the year, that we are going to have diplomatic machinery employed again.

The position which we have now reached in Europe is a very lamentable one, and I do not think that this Debate at the opening of the Session, the greatest day in the Session, when the whole field of affairs is open, when the Gracious Speech is made the subject of an Address from the Commons, should pass without some comment on the subject. A most unsatisfactory result has been reached in Europe, and I am going to say, as I have said before, although it will not be at all popular, that the Prime Minister's conduct of foreign affairs, whether as the head of the Socialist Government or as the head of the National, patriotic Government, has been equally attended with misfortune. I do not say for 'me moment that he is responsible for the tremendous turns and twists of events that have occurred in the attitude and demeanour of great countries in Europe, still I must draw the attention of Parliament and the country to the total collapse of all the main matters with which he has been personally concerned in foreign affairs.

Let us look back. There was the London Naval Conference. I do not

42

think there is any doubt whatever to-day among those who study the position of our Navy that that has been a very great hindrance not merely to our naval strength but to our spending such little money as we can afford to spend in a manner calculated to give us the greatest measure of security. Then we come to Lausanne. I have always thought that it was a very great mistake to release our German debtors until we had some security in regard to our credit. What has been the result? We have released them and what have they done with the money that otherwise they would have had to pay across the exchange? They have been buying the nickel referred to by the Prime Minister with the money that ought to have been put across the exchange, whereas we have received no sort of effective release from our creditors elsewhere. I cannot feel that the triumph of Lausanne, the more it is examined, will bring any sense of satisfaction to those who have studied the situation.

Then there is the World Economic Conference. I have heard people say about the Prime Minister that, although he may have his faults and short comings, see how good he is at conferences; that is his speciality. Before the meeting of the World Economic Conference Parliament sent him to the United States on purpose to arrange beforehand and make sure that there were no misunderstandings. All that happened was that we allowed that conference to assemble without any effective common policy with the United States of America, with the result that the nations brought together from all ends of the globe to London were made participators in one of the most painful and melancholy fiascos of international intercourse. Future international relations have to that extent been impaired and the prospect of general co-operation impoverished.

Lastly, there is the Disarmament Conference, which is the main topic upon which I desire to speak. I have often wondered what is the secret of the Prime Minister's success. I have watched him with the greatest interest all these years and I have often been very puzzled how it is that he seems able, in the words of the poet:

to ride in the whirlwind and direct the storm.

43

I have not the slightest doubt that it is far from his intentions, but I am bound to say that one of the qualities which have led him to the giddy pinnacle which he now holds is an extraordinary aptitude for laying the blame for failure on other people. He was for a long time, two years, the leader of the Socialist Administration, of whom I have expressed the worst possible opinion. It now appears that all the blame rests with hon. Members now sitting on the benches opposite. The right hon. Gentleman the other day spoke about the importance of having a good memory. He has the best kind of memory one can have, a memory which conveniently forgets. His anno domini, his hegira, begins with the end of the year 1931.

Now in regard to our foreign policy, the long series of breakdowns—they cannot be described as anything else—which have reduced diplomacy almost to bankruptcy in Europe, I understand that the blameworthy person is the Foreign Secretary. I have no means of information except the many channels of the public Press, but as far as I can see and from what I hear he is the guilty person. I hold no brief for my right hon. Friend the Foreign Secretary; indeed, no one has any need to hold a brief for him. He is very good at holding briefs, that is his forte. But where the Foreign Secretary makes a mistake is not in the manner in which he conducts the brief he has taken up, but in his readiness to accept any brief which is tendered to him in the proper manner and with the appropriate fee marked in the corner. He takes up anything which is presented to him, with the consequence that he finds himself, and has found himself on this occasion, placed in a very difficult position.

In regard to the Disarmament Conference, I think that the Foreign Secretary was set an impossible task. The task he was set was to persuade Europe to agree to what is called the MacDonald Plan of Disarmament. The Prime Minister placed this great plan before Europe, making enormous demands upon ourselves and prescribing to the angry and nervous Powers of Europe exactly the size of their armaments and air forces. But the Prime Minister had never worked out the figures. He presented this scheme to Europe, and, as I said at the time, France and other countries, although naturally

44

polite, said they would read it a second time and send it to a committee. I understand that it was only read a first time and then sent up to a committee, and I gather that the Foreign Secretary was entrusted with the difficult business of handling the matter in committee. The French would never agree to let such a plan be read a first time unless they had a perfectly clear plan and method, very proper on their part considering the danger they are in to see that the plan worked no mischief. There was bound to be a breakdown when the matter came into committee.

Look at the formula put forward with so much triumph by the Foreign Secretary. He dealt with it quite tenderly, as one which would reconcile France and Germany. It was, "a system of equality within a system of general security," or was it "equality within a general system of security"? Or was it "qualitative equality within a general system of security"?

What does it all mean? What is the result of all that? When you are trying to get agreement to bridge the gap there is this absurd formula presented, which is really a contradiction in terms. You might just as well say that you are in favour of deep water bathing provided it is certain none of us get wet. Ladened with this tremendous plan, this plan which would make Germany and Italy numerically stronger than France, a plan which would derange entirely existing balances of Europe, and which, I believe, if it were the rule to-day would place us in a position when we should not be far removed from war, the Foreign Secretary goes to the committee and at a certain stage, having tried to cozen the French, has to agree to something which they put in, with the result that the Germans leave the Conference. And he has to bear the blame for that. The responsibility rests on those who, without adequate study, put forward a plan which makes us interfere in the vital life of Europe, a plan which had no chance of being accepted, and then throw the burden of carrying it through upon the right hon. Gentleman the Foreign Secretary.