Disarmament.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

7 November 1933 · House of Commons debate · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on November 7, 1933, in a debate on disarmament, warning of German rearmament, rebuking Labour and Lloyd George, and urging British freedom and detachment from European commitments.
Main themes
German rearmament, disarmament and the Disarmament Conference, Treaty of Versailles interpretation, Lloyd George's claims on the Treaty, Labour opposition leader's remarks on the armed forces, Treaty of Locarno obligations, British freedom of action in Europe, MacDonald Plan, French security and fear of Germany, sober detachment from Europe
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,164
61st percentile
Sentences
81
53rd percentile
Readability
62
90th percentile
Grade
10.8
29th percentile
Syntax
3.24
77th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 77%65%
  • Institutional 12%10%
  • Social 6%5%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 15%

81 sentences in 24 paragraphs

I am not going to give way, and it is no good the right hon. Gentleman getting so very angry. He made the speech and he has to listen to his own speech. That is all that he has to put up with.

He believed that when the Socialists got into power the mass of the soldiers and sailors would back them up.

Back them up in what? What are the plans which the right hon. Gentleman is nursing against us which he wants to

136

have backed up by the Army and Navy? Then follows the sentence without which I would not have challenged the right hon. Gentleman.

As for their officers, the Socialist Government would know what to do with them if they became treacherous in the day of trial.

It is a mean thing to try to separate the officers from the soldiers and sailors. It is a needless, gratuitous and ungrateful thing. Twice we have had a Socialist Government in power with a minority, and with a country anxious to dismiss them, and never has there been any failure of the Services to obey orders which they have received from properly constituted authority. Here is the right hon. Gentleman, who is always preaching the doctrine of universal loving kindness as long as it concerns countries outside this, a man who holds a responsible position in our hierarchy, who does not hesitate to use language about the armed Forces of the Crown which is utterly uncalled for, and which I have no hesitation in characterising as shameful and disgraceful.

I leave the right hon. Gentleman and come to my right hon. Friend the Member for Carnarvon Boroughs (Mr. Lloyd George). I do not think that he has distinguished himself very much during the Parliamentary Recess. I think he wrote quite a good letter to the British Broadcasting Corporation, but, apart from that, his interventions have riot contributed greatly to our enlightenment or to the consolidation of peace. My right hon. Friend seems to have in his mind a belief, a feeling, that he is entitled to some special claim to interpret the Treaty of Versailles, and other treaties which ended the War. It is quite true that he had a great deal to do with the making of that Treaty, and he wrote into it a great many of its most stringent aspects. I do not know whether "Hanging the Kaiser" actually got into the Treaty. That fell down perhaps at the General Election, but, at any rate, once a treaty is signed it becomes an international instrument which everyone can judge, and I have no hesitation in saying that, personally, I prefer to take the measured opinion of the jurists, upon who the Foreign Office relies, to the highly coloured account as to what is or is not meant in the Treaty which emanated from the right hon. Gentleman.

137

I believe that the Treaty has been maintained in the letter and also in the spirit. It is not true to say that this country—I was glad to hear my right hon. Friend the Member for Carnarvan Boroughs withdraw that aspect of his case—or the great countries with whom we have been associated, have violated the Treaty in the letter or in the spirit. So far as the letter is concerned, that rests entirely upon the statement in the dispatch of the Government of August, 1932, which laid out the whole case in a most masterly manner. So far as the spirit is concerned, it is well known that ever since the Treaty was signed mitigations have been constantly introduced, far more than the Treaty contemplated. The evacuations of German territory have been carried out with greater rapidity, while the great scheme and structure of reparations has been swept away altogether, and the conquerors, the victors, in the struggle, have lent a thousand million sterling to Germany over and above anything they have been paid. It is altogether wrong therefore to suggest that the late Allies in the War have failed in the letter or in the spirit to carry out, broadly speaking, their Treaty obligations.

My right hon. Friend made to-night a deeply interesting speech, to which I listened, like everyone else with admiration, at the persuasive charm and skill with which he pressed his point. There is nothing that my right hon. Friend can do so well as to draw one side of a picture in the most glowing manner and then reduce the other side to small and pitiable proportions. He gave an account of the state of Europe. He represented that Germany might have a few thousand more rifles than was allowed by the Treaty, a few more boy scouts, and then he pictured the enormous armies of Czechoslovakia and Poland and France, with their thousands of cannon, and so forth. If I could believe that picture I should feel much comforted, but I cannot. I find it difficult to believe it in view of the obvious fear which holds all the nations who are neighbours of Germany and the obvious lack of fear which apparently controls the behaviour of the German Government and a large proportion of the German people.

The great dominant fact is that Germany is re-arming, has already begun to re-arm. I have no sources of informa-

138

tion but those of the public Press, but we read of large importations of scrap iron and nickel and war metals, quite out of the ordinary. We read all the news which accumulates of the military spirit which is rife throughout the country; we see that a philosophy of blood lust is being inculcated into their youth to which no parallel can be found since the days of barbarism. We see all these forces on the move, and we must remember that it is the same mighty Germany which fought all the world and almost beat the world; it is the same mighty Germany which took two and a half lives for every German life that was taken. No wonder when you get these preparations, these doctrines, and these assertions openly made that there is alarm throughout the whole circle of nations which surround Germany, an alarm which concerns not only the countries involved in the late War and still affected by the antagonisms of the War, but countries which observed strict neutrality during the War, like Denmark, Holland and Switzerland. Switzerland, indeed, has been forced to make a large credit, this peaceful country, quite impartial, Germans as well as Frenchmen living there, in order to defend herself. There is no doubt where the fear lies. I do not know, no one knows exactly, what is the position of German armaments; all we know is that the greatest anxiety has been caused to all her neighbours by her armaments and by her doctrines.

The Leader of the Opposition said just now that he and the Socialist party would never consent to the re-arming of Germany. I was very pleased when I read that. I agree with him. I should feel very much safer if I felt that that would not happen in my lifetime or in that of my children. But is the right hon. Gentleman quite sure that the Germans will come and ask him for his consent before they re-arm? Does he not think that they might omit that formality, and go ahead without even taking a card vote of the Trades Union Congress? Then the right hon. Gentleman said, "But in order to prevent them re-arming I should like to see all the other countries, their neighbours, disarm, "and that has been the burden of his speech and of many other speeches. But I doubt very much whether the other Powers are going to take any notice. I do not see why they should. In the next breath

139

the right hon. Gentleman said that if they take his advice, and if it should turn out wrong and they find themselves exposed to attacks and getting into trouble, the first thing he will do will be to call a general strike in order to prevent any aid being lent them. If the right hon. Gentleman is not going to take the slightest responsibility for these people, even if they do take his advice, I am inclined to think that they will be quite entitled to say to him, "Mind your own business."

But it is our own position that weighs upon us most of all here in this House, and it is about that that I will say a few words before I make room for the right hon. Gentleman who is to wind up the Debate for the Labour party. I was very glad to hear the definition given by the Foreign Secretary of our obligations under the Treaty of Locarno, and also that given in the very admirable speech in the country some days ago by the Under-Secretary. It is perfectly clear, as I have several times contended in this House, that whether in regard to the general Clauses of the Treaty or in regard to the special obligations under the emergency Clause, we still remain the judges of the event; we are the honourable judges of the event, but we still remain the judges, and we are free to choose. That is a very great re-assurance to the country, for in many parts it has been suggested that the decision would rest with someone outside the control of this country altogether. We are free to choose; and such declarations as that made by the Under-Secretary some days ago and not controverted by the French Government will henceforth rule in the interpretation of this Treaty. I am bound to say that I welcome those interpretations very much indeed. Now we have our freedom, our freedom to decide, let us be very careful that we do not corn-promise it or do not whittle it away.

That is why I am so glad that this period of what is called probation, this interval, has been introduced into this dangerous process of disarmament in Europe, which has played a noticeable part in raising the temperature to its present level. if we wish to keep our freedom, we must recognise the fact—I mean our freedom within our obligations, for far would it be for me to suggest

140

that we should abandon our obligations, whatever they are—it is of the utmost importance that we should forthwith recognise that our role in Europe is more limited than it has hitherto been considered to be. Isolation is, I believe, utterly impossible, but we should nevertheless practise a certain degree of sober detachment from the European scene. We should not try to weaken these great Powers which are in great danger, or feel themselves in great danger, and thereby expose ourselves to a demand that we should come to their aia—a demand interpreted in the very strictest sense.

I have deprecated these schemes which we have laid before the Disarmament Conference prescribing the size of all the armies and navies and air forces of Europe. I am not going to take up the limited time I have in analysing these schemes, the MacDonald Plan as it has been called. It never had the slightest chance of being accepted—never. I told the House in March that it never had the slightest chance of being accepted. How could you expect those countries that feel themselves in so great danger to make the very large reductions which were asked for in their armaments, their air forces and armies, while at the same time substantial increases were offered to the Germany with which we are now confronted? I know that it is natural for Ministers, for the Prime Minister, to wish to play a great part on the European stage, and to bestride Europe in the cause of peace, to be as it were the saviours of Europe. You cannot be the saviours of Europe on a limited liability. I agree with the statement of the late Mr. Bonar Law, who said that we cannot be the policemen of the whole world. We have to discharge our obligations, but we cannot take upon ourselves, our people do not desire us to take upon ourselves, undue obligations into which we shall certainly come if we are the leaders in compelling and pressing for a great diminution in the strength of France and other Powers which are neighbours of Germany. How lucky it is that the French did not take the advice that we have been tendering them in the last few years, or the advice which the United States has given them —I am glad the right hon. Member for Carnarvon Boroughs quoted the figures—

141

advice tendered from the safe position 3,000 miles across the ocean If they had accepted it war would be much nearer, and our obligation to come to their aid would be much more strictly interpreted.