- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on November 7, 1933, in a debate on disarmament, urging support for the League of Nations, collective dealings with Germany and adequate British defence provision.
- Main themes
- Adherence to the League of Nations, limits of the League in the Far East, recreating the Concert of Europe, collective address to Germany over its grievances, German rearmament, British disarmament to the verge of risk, responsibility of Defence Ministers, pressure from press, Treasury and economists to cut defence, British neutrality
- Duration
- ~8 min
- Words
- 935
- Sentences
- 37
- Readability
- 61
- Grade
- 11.1
- Syntax
- 2.95
- Vocabulary
- 2.01
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other37 sentences in 7 paragraphs
I think that is so. At any rate, it is not the Gold Standard we are discussing. I do feel that there should be recognition of the fact that we ought not to place ourselves continually in the most prominent position and endeavour to produce spectacular effects of disarmament in Europe, because as surely as we do a good deal of our discretionary power will be gradually whittled away and reduced. I would not like to speak in this Debate without giving a definite counsel, because I think one ought to do that. The hon. Gentleman who preceded me said that the situation was hopeless. I am not so sure that it is hopeless. It seems to me that there is a fairly general measure of agreement as to the course which we should now pursue. I think we should adhere to the League of Nations. I did not agree with my right hon. Friend the Member for Carnarvon Boroughs when he mocked and scolded the League, not to-day but in a speech in the country. Nor do I agree with those poor friends of the League who say that just because the League was incapable of dealing with the situation in the Far East, on the other side of the world, it will have no efficacy in dealing with the European situation. What could you expect of the League in far off Asia? China and Japan—what do they care for the League of Nations. Russia and the United States—neither of them Members of the League. Those four countries comprise half the population of the globe. They form another world, a world in itself, and you should not judge of the success or power of a great international instrument like this by the fact that it has not been able to make its will effective at the other end of the world. Very different is the case in Euope. In Europe you have at least erected it upon the basis of the Treaties of Peace. That is the foundation on which you can build and not only is it erected on that foundation but powerful nations stand fully armed to defend those Treaties and if necessary to make themselves the agents and authorities of the League of Nations.
142
I believe that we shall find our greatest safety in co-operating with the other Powers of Europe, not in taking a leading part but in coming in our proper place, with all the neutral States and the smaller States of Europe which will gather together anxiously in the near future at Geneva. We shall make a great mistake to separate ourselves entirely from them at this juncture. Whatever way we turn there is risk. There is peril on every side. But I believe that the least risk and the greatest help will be found in recreating the Concert of Europe through the League of Nations, not for the purpose of fiercely quarrelling and haggling about the details of disarmament but in an attempt to address Germany collectively, so that there may be some redress of the grievances of the German nation and that that may be effected before this peril of re-armament reaches a point which may endanger the peace of the world.
I have only one thing more to say, and it was suggested to me by what the right hon. Gentleman the Member for Carnarvon Boroughs said at the close of his speech and by those figures which he gave of our disarmament and other people's rearmament. I see in the House some of the Ministers responsible for Defence Departments. I have been in that position myself in the years of baffling uncertainty through which we passed before the Great War, and I should like to tell those Ministers this, which I give from my own experience. In such circumstances every kind of pressure will be put upon them to reduce what they consider and what they are advised to, be the necessary provision for our security. The papers will write leading articles. The Chancellor of the Exchequer in his bounden duty and the Treasury are bound to put their case. The economists will give their views, and in Parliament there will be pressure for cutting down this and cutting down that. But if trouble should come, none of these gentlemen, none of the able editors, none of the stern economists will be at hand to defend the Ministers. When the Service Departments are found to be hopelessly lacking in the essentials of our safety it will be no use to turn round and say to this or that newspaper, "You wrote an article saying that there must
143
be a great cut," or in saying to this or that Member of Parliament, "You voted against any increase." These people will be among the very first to say, "Oh, you took all this money and yet you have not even provided what was necessary."
In these circumstances, proved as it is that we have disarmed to the verge of risk, nay, well into the thick of risk, a very great responsibility rests upon the Ministers for the Defence Departments to assure us that adequate provision is made for our safety and for having the power and the time if necessary to realise the whole latent strength of our country and also, let me add, for us to be able in any case to maintain our neutrality effectually—a neutrality from which, as I have said before, we should never be drawn except upon the conscience and the will of the overwhelming mass of our people.
