- Context
- Churchill, a backbench Member, addressed the House of Commons in London on March 4, 1937, during the Defence Loans Bill debate, criticising the Government's vagueness on rearmament and urging faster arms output and a secret inquiry.
- Main themes
- Defence Loans Bill and £1,500,000,000 rearmament programme, gap between spending and actual weapons production, vagueness of Government defence plans, call for secret Select Committee on defences, anti-aircraft defence of London, German and Italian rearmament, air power and the Air Force programme, Anglo-French defensive association, strength of the Royal Navy, Covenant of the League of Nations, Parliamentary complacency and optimism, foreigners organised under Nazi and Fascist bodies
- Duration
- ~34 min
- Words
- 4,088
- Sentences
- 164
- Readability
- 53
- Grade
- 12.4
- Syntax
- 3.17
- Vocabulary
- 2.10
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other164 sentences in 42 paragraphs
If they were, it is only a proof of the severe Conservatism and Gladstonian orthodoxy which permeates the atmosphere of the Treasury buildings. I think His Majesty's Government have also placed themselves in a very favourable position against critics who, like myself, have for a long time been urging more active and timely measures. The great majority of the House will no doubt feel that the Government are doing everything that the situation demands, or at any rata everything that could be reasonably asked for, and they will feel inclined—I can sense their attitude to some extent, though not always—to silence critics with the remark, "If you are not satisfied with £1,500,000,000 being spent on armaments, nothing in reason will ever content you." The Parliamentary position of the Government is, therefore, as strong as it could possibly be. The Opposition attack halfheartedly a policy which everyone knows is essential to our safety, and critics from the opposite angle are easily disposed of by reference to the grandiose figures which are involved.
But there are other, broader advantages which flow from the Government's declaration. Nothing is more important for British policy than clarity and continuity. The fact that the British Government are coming forward with a five-years' plan of armaments on this scale, the evidences of our great financial strength, the very general acceptance of this policy by all parties in the nation, the welcome which it has received from so many countries, particularly small countries, in all parts of the world—all these give to our Dominions and to foreign countries a chance of walking in step with us. I have felt during the last few years, and especially now, in these years, that Great Britain has only to pursue a set course, uninfluenced by the shifting gusts of incident and opinion, and to pursue that course for a certain
573
period of years, to find herself moving along in a great company. We are the head of an Empire of free Dominions. We are also looked to with friendly, appealing eyes by a large number of peace-seeking nations. We do not give them a chance of adjusting their policy, their future outlook, to ours if we chop and change from year to year, and swing to and fro in accordance with the minor and superficial variations which take place.
We have now got a policy in foreign affairs based upon the Covenant of the League of Nations——and upon special agreements with France which, in any temper but that of partisanship would be recognised, I think, generally as carrying with it what the great mass of the nation as a whole desire. I certainly have not heard any language during this Bill from the Ministers that in the slightest degree diminishes the force of the declarations which have been made upon this subject; and now, in addition to a foreign policy, we have also a policy upon Defence which, if we pursue it resolutely for four or five years, if so long a period is granted to us, and if we do not vary or weaken our course, may well leave us in a far more safe and agreeable position than any which we have occupied since German rearmament began in earnest. Time passes quickly Everything is in constant change. When the first beginnings of evil which may subsequently challenge peace and freedom and even the life of the State make their appearance on the horizon, it is right then to sound the alarm and to try, even by frantic exertions, to arouse somnolent authority to novel dangers, but once we are in the danger zone, once everybody can see that we are marching through that long, dark valley of which I spoke to the House two years ago, then it seems to me that a mood of coolness and calmness is almost enjoined.
There is another aspect. When the dangers are distant, it is right to dwell upon defects and deficiencies so that they should be made good in time, but when the dangers come much nearer, it is perhaps natural and also prudent and healthy to dwell, in public at any rate, upon resources rather than upon defects, and to take a fair stock of our strength no less than of the hazards of our position. We must remember that we are for
574
the time being not any longer entirely masters of our own fate. That no longer depends altogether on what we decide here or on what the Cabinet settle in Downing Street. It depends on what may happen in the world, on what other countries do, for good or for ill. It may be hard for our island people, with their long immunity, to realise this ugly, unpleasant alteration in our position. We are an undefeated people. Nearly 1, 000 years have passed since we were conquered or subjugated by external force. All our outlook for several generations has been influenced by a sense of invincible, inexpugnable security at home. That security is no longer absolute or certain, and we must address our minds courageously, seriously, to the new conditions under which we have now to dwell, and under which Continental nations have always dwelt.
Of course, the question turns entirely upon whether the air is regarded as a decisive weapon. In France it is not so regarded, and in Germany, I believe, it is not so regarded. I hope I shall not hurt the feelings of the hon. Member for West Fife (Mr. Gallacher) if I quote a once beloved leader, from whom, I gather, he has separated himself—Mr. Trotsky. We all have our delusions. At the Brest-Litovsk Conference he uttered the following sentence when the full strength of the German power was made known. He said that the destiny of great nations is not to be determined by the temporary condition of their "technical apparatus," and I must say that I have always believed that that was a very profound truth. If that failed to be true in respect of any country in the world, that country would be this island, so artificial in the character of its strength and wealth, and which is in a different position, from every point of view, from that of the great self-contained or self-supporting masses of the populations which inhabit the Continent of Europe.
It is this new element of uncertainty which darkens our outlook, and I must point out that mere declarations of readiness to spend money over a five-year period do not affect the realities through which we shall have to live in 1937, 1938, and 1939. It has been obvious for some time past that the Government desire to spend as much money as they possibly can upon rearmament, getting value for their money, but neither the readiness of
575
Ministers to place orders nor the readiness of the House of Commons to vote enormous sums is the limiting factor which governs our position to-day. The sole question of interest from the point of view of security is not the amount of money which Ministers will ask or which Parliament will vote, but what the contractors can earn in the next two years, and the only proof of our increasing security, the only measure of the steps which are taken to regain our security, is the weapons which we actually put in the hands of trained units from month to month. I tried to bring this idea to the notice of the House a year ago. I know of no factors which are now apparent which were not apparent a year ago, and of no vital factors which were not apparent two years ago and even earlier.
There is, as I say, nothing new in this situation, nothing that the House has not long ago been apprised of. The Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence, as soon as he found out what to do, has been placing orders, endeavouring to stimulate the expansion of skilled labour, the manufacture of machine tools, the erection and adaptation of very large plants. All that process, so tardily begun, is now going forward, is now gradually acquiring momentum. No foreigner will underrate the possibility, the power and flexibility of British industry, and I certainly think that we ourselves should not do so, but the only figure of real interest in this enormous proposal of £1,500,000,000 is, from the point of view of security, the amount which can be spent in 1937 and 1938. That figure we do not yet know. Indeed, we are in a position to-day where it is difficult even to surmise about it. We do not know the outturn of 1936, although it is perhaps a fair deduction from the figures already published that our expenditure on armaments during that year will realise about £190,000,000. We now know the Navy and the Army Estimates for this year, but we do not know the one which is most important of all, the Air Estimates. We shall not know, I suppose, until this time next year how large is the borrowing in aid of revenue to which we must have recourse, because even when the Estimates are all before us, even when the Budget speech has been made, there is always the possibility of Supplementary Estimates and the hope that large supplementaries,
576
increasing the expenditure demanded in the first instance, will show that practical and concrete steps are being swiftly taken to regain for this country its position of security.
I should be very much surprised, and agreeably surprised and reassured, if, proceeding on present lines, more than £60,000,000 or £70,000,000 was required by loan in the next 12 months. Surely the City of London has shown itself somewhat adrift from Parliamentary and political realities when there has been a fall in gilt-edged stocks in respect of borrowing which, during the next year, cannot possibly amount to any serious burden upon the great movements of the money market.
One of the many difficulties which baffles effective discussion of Defence programmes is that the Government are studiously vague on every point. The Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence —I am not going into these matters except to show how discussion is baffled—told us of a large number of important subjects upon which plans have been made or even actual preparations begun. He spoke of food supply, of the accumulation of raw materials, the gathering of projectiles and the production of cannon, and above all of preparation for Air defence. But nowhere was there any quantitative statement, nowhere was there any date given by which particular progress points were to be reached. Nowhere was there any distinction drawn between paper plans of committees and the elaborate organisation of personnel required to make them work. Nowhere was there any assurance that the programmes would be carried out punctually, or in good time. How could he do so when, except for the Air programme, no dates for the completion have been assigned to any of the numerous programmes nor even in most cases the dimensions of the programmes?
For instance, take shells for the Army. Without knowing what is to be the scale of the Army it is impossible for the House to judge whether the arrangements made are or are not adequate. An Army with three or four divisions is one thing, but an Army of five or 10 or 15 divisions, as we had in the first six months of the War, is an entirely different problem. We know nothing on the point.
577
There is no means by which the House can check these provisions except by a secret Select Committee with power to send for persons and papers. Take the defence of London. Everything that has emerged from the Spanish business shows the importance of anti-aircraft guns. We know that Germany has 30 regiments of mobile anti-aircraft artillery, or about 250 to 300 batteries with 1,50o modern aircraft guns in addition to the whole of their static artillery for anti-aircraft defence. It is perfectly true that we do not need to have a large Army like Continental nations, but we do need to have as effective and adequate antiaircraft defence. There is no alteration in the scale for us on that point. How long will it be before we have 1,500 good modern anti-aircraft guns with trained crews and all the necessary equipment? I do not expect an answer. I am not criticising or blaming the Minister for not giving the facts. I am only pointing out how impossible it is for us to form any judgment without being given these details.
It is the same with the Air Force, although there we had a point, the 31st March, by which a certain measure of Defence was to be reached. We know that this programme is grievously in arrear. The Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence spoke in these debates of our anti-aircraft Defence being the "best that could be devised." I should like the House to note the use of the word "devised." I wonder how long the interval will be before what is being devised will be actually translated into what we actually have. Take the re-equipment of the Territorials of which we spoke a year ago. Is that going to be completed in 1938 or 1939, or in 1940? I am not bringing these matters forward except to point out how utterly impossible it is for the House to form its own opinion on these matters. We shall know in time, because people all over the country will see exactly the state of these forces when they turn out to drill; they must become known when they pass from schemes into realities. But we shall not be the only people to know.
There is a serious issue, which I am bringing forward on another occasion, raised by the fact of the large number of foreigners in this country who now since the war are all held together by bonds
578
of Nazi and Fascist organisation. That is a new feature, and it is a matter which certainly will have to be considered. In my view there are any number of facts about which we have no good information in this House, on which probably foreign general staffs are perfectly well informed. When the Fleet went to the Mediterranean a year and a half ago the movements of every ship were printed in every paper on the Continent. The only country which was unable to form any opinion about it was the one which was vitally interested. I must say that I am astounded at the wave of optimism, of confidence, and even of complacency, which has swept over Parliament and over public opinion. There is a veritable tide of feeling that all is well, that everything is being done in the right way, in the right measure and in the right time. So much are hon. Members reassured that it is a matter of public comment that it is difficult to keep a House even when the gravest matters are being discussed.
I cannot resist the conviction that we are moving through times as dangerous as any through which we have ever passed. I wish that even now the House would rouse itself, face the responsibilities and exercise its full commanding powers. I am sure that in no other generation would the House of Commons have been content to dwell in this complete ignorance about the vital security of the State and nation. In any other but this war-stricken and war-ravaged generation the House of Commons would have insisted on making a discreet but resolute inquiry into some of the leading facts about our defences, especially after the miscalculations which the Government have candidly admitted. In any other country in the world which boasts free Parliamentary institutions, in France in particular, there would have been a searching inquiry. Members who could be trusted would be chosen to converse with the Government on these matters and make a brief report to the House as to whether all was well in this or that sphere, or, if not well, whether extra measures should be taken to repair the deficiencies.
But the official Opposition do not desire to be drawn in any way into sharing the responsibility of the Executive. The Government refuse a secret Session, I am sure on the wrong view of what its character
579
and course would be. It, therefore, would seem that the choice open to a private Member is really limited to saying in public things which, as matters get more critical, ought not to be said, or else acquiesce in an endless series of blind and purblind Votes of Confidence in whatever we are told by the Administration. This difficulty will recur with sharpened edge as debates on defensive forces take place this Session, and in the end the House of Commons will have a far less clear view of what our position is in a great many important matters than will be possessed by foreign countries, friendly or otherwise.
The Chancellor of the Exchequer told us that there is no imminent danger of war. I hope it is true; I believe it is true so far at any rate as the Spring and Summer of this year are concerned. But what has the future in store for us? Can Ministers assure us that this time next year the British Air Force will be more nearly a match for the German Air Force than it is to-day? Can Ministers assure us from their special knowledge that this time next year the German Army will not be a good deal stronger compared to the French Army than it is now? The immediate future offers us no surcease from the anxieties under which we must lie. Wars do not wait till everyone is ready. Usually they come when one Power thinks itself less unready than another, and sometimes they come when one Power, under great strain, feels that it has nothing to gain by delay and that the future holds for them no relative improvement.
When a whole Continent is arming feverishly, when mighty nations are laying aside every form of ease and comfort, when scores of millions of men and weapons are being prepared for war, when whole populations are being led forward or driven forward under conditions of exceptional overstrain, when the finances of the proudest dictators are in the most desperate condition, can you be sure that all your programmes so tardily adopted will, in fact, be executed in time? At any rate, His Majesty's Government would surely be prudent to shorten this dangerous passage through the valley by every means in their power and bring to an end the period of insecurity to which we should never have been exposed. I have dealt with the
580
good effects of this Defence Loans Bill throughout the. Empire and Europe, but probably all the reactions abroad have not been equally beneficial.
I do not set too much store by the declarations of the Italian Dictator, which are no doubt addressed to our account. Italy has for a long time, under the inspiration of that extraordinary man, been held at a very high pitch of tension. I seem to have read a year ago that even quite young children were being taught to fire with the rifle. I expect they have been doing all that they can for a long time back. In Germany too the strain is very great. One wonders whether the people of these countries have a spirit so much uplifted above all other races as to enable them to support hardships and perform prodigies which are beyond the normal vigour of mankind. In short, I do not believe that either of these great dictators can do much more than they have been doing for a long time past. But do not ignore what they are doing. They are welding entire nations into war-making machines at the cost of the sternest repression of all the amenities and indulgencies of human existence.
But that only disposes of half the argument. We must recognise that one of these great countries is putting a direct question to us, and we must recognise that another country is closely associated with that. I cannot understand, in the face of all these facts and so many others that are known to all of us, that His Majesty's Government can imagine they can meet and ward off the armed menace of nations already at full strain and overstrain, merely by going along in the present comfortable manner without any decisive impingement upon private trade or profit making or without demanding temporary sacrifices of comfort and changes in our way of living in order that we may preserve ourselves in freedom. Financial sacrifices alone will not suffice; the whole nation must pull together.
As I have said, when dangers are far off one may dwell upon deficiencies, but when they are near one must dwell on resources. Having felt bound to strike a sombre note this afternoon I am most anxious not to omit the other side of the case before I sit down. First of all there is the Navy which, even to-day, is far stronger, relatively to any Navy in Europe, than it was in 1914. When we see the enormous programme included in
581
this Bill, which Parliament will so gladly vote this year, we may well feel assured that, so far as Europe is concerned, not only will the supremacy of the Navy be maintained, but it will become increasingly preponderant. I am glad to think that the menace of the submarine is no longer comparable to what it was in the Great War. Everything we have heard from the Spanish war seems to enforce the Admiralty view that it is not so easy to annihilate warships by aeroplanes as some people have been making out. We must not undervalue the enormous power and security which we would derive from the British Navy in any quarrel in which the right feeling of the United States was not withdrawn from the British Empire.
In the second place, I rest my comfort and my reassurance upon our association with our closest neighbour, the other great Western democracy—the French Parliamentary democracy. What has come to pass is, undoubtedly, a virtual defensive alliance between these two countries against any unprovoked act of aggression towards either of them. I feel that the companionship of these two countries, who have no other aim than the peace and freedom of all States and races in Europe, is one of the greatest guarantees for our common safety, for a continuance of peace, for, at the very worst, our joint survival.
Finally, I think we ought to place our trust in those moral forces which are enshrined in the Covenant of the League of Nations. Do not let us mock at them, for they are surely on our side. Do not mock at them, for this may well be a time when the highest idealism is not divorced from strategic prudence. Do not mock at them, for these. may be years, strange as it may seem, when Right will walk hand in hand with Might. Let us, therefore, lay aside every impediment and do everything in our power to add to our own strength and use that strength for the purpose of helping the gathering together of the nations upon the basis of the Covenant of the League. Upon the rock of the Covenant many nations great and small are drawing constantly and swiftly together. In spite of the disappointments of the past, in spite of many misgivings, difficulties and ridiculings, that process is continuing, and these nations are welding themselves into what will some day be a formidable yet
582
benignant alliance, pledged to resist wrong-doing or violence from an aggressor.
That is what we are working towards. It is not the situation as it exists to-day. The situation, as it exists to-day, is that we are moving forward towards our goal but are still widely short of it. Every step that we take to advance along this path, to make what are now, perhaps, only, in some cases visionary assurances, into solid effective pacts—every stage that we move forward on that road, we shall be taking not only the best measures for our own safety but the surest means for safeguarding the civilisation of the world.
